Regional strain variations in the human patellar tendon

Are subject-specific models necessary to predict patellar tendon fatigue life? A finite element modelling study

Patellar tendinopathy is an overuse injury that occurs from repetitive loading of the patellar tendon in a scenario resembling that of mechanical fatigue. As such, fatigue-life estimates provide a quantifiable approach to assess tendinopathy risk and may be tabulated using nominal strain (NS) or finite element (FE) models with varied subject-specificity. We compared patellar tendon fatigue-life estimates from NS and FE models of twenty-nine athletes performing countermovement jumps with subject-specific versus generic geometry and material properties. Subject-specific patellar tendon material properties and geometry were obtained using a data collection protocol of dynamometry, ultrasound, and magnetic resonance imaging. Three FE models were created for each subject, with: subject-specific (hyperelastic) material properties and geometry, subject-specific material properties and generic geometry, and generic material properties and subject-specific geometry. Four NS models were created for each subject, with: subject-specific (linear elastic) material properties and moment arm, generic material properties and subject-specific moment arm, subject-specific material properties and generic moment arm, and generic material properties and moment arm. NS- and FE-modelled fatigue-life estimates with generic material properties were poorly correlated with their subject-specific counterparts (r²≤0.073), while all NS models overestimated fatigue life compared to the subject-specific FE model (r²≤0.223). Furthermore, FE models with generic tendon geometry were unable to accurately represent the heterogeneous strain distributions found in the subject-specific FE models or those with generic material properties. These findings illustrate the importance of incorporating subject-specific material properties and FE-modelled strain distributions into fatigue-life estimations.

Ultrasound-based speckle-tracking in tendons: a critical analysis for the technician and the clinician

Ultrasound has risen to the forefront as one of the primary tools in tendon research, with benefits including its relatively low cost, ease of use, and high safety. Moreover, it has been shown that cine ultrasound can be used to evaluate tendon deformation by tracking the motion of anatomical landmarks during physical movement. Estimates from landmark tracking, however, are typically limited to global tissue properties, such that clinically relevant regional nonuniformities may be missed. Fortunately, advancements in ultrasound scanning have led to the development of speckle-tracking algorithms, which enable the noninvasive measurement of in vivo local deformation patterns. Despite the successes in other fields, the adaptation of speckle-tracking to tendon research has presented some unique challenges as a result of tissue anisotropy and microstructural changes under load. With no generally accepted standards for its use, current methodological approaches vary substantially between studies and research groups. Therefore, the goal of this paper is to provide a summative review of the technical complexities and variations of speckle-tracking approaches being used and the impact these decisions may have on measured results and their interpretation. Variations in these approaches currently being used with relevant technical aspects are discussed first (for the technician), followed by a discussion of the more clinical considerations (for the clinician). Finally, a summary table of common challenges encountered when implementing speckle-tracking is provided, with suggested recommendations for minimizing the impact of such potential sources of error.

Patellar tendon buckling in post-operative total knee arthroplasty patients is more prominent than in healthy controls

Recent evidence suggests the patellar tendon undergoes buckling during normal knee flexion, which likely contributes to the functioning of the extensor mechanism. Thus, evaluating buckling in patients following total knee arthroplasty (TKA), where extensor mechanism dysfunction remains a common complication, may be relevant. The study goals were to identify whether post-TKA patients exhibit differences in patellar tendon buckling from healthy, similarly-aged adults and whether such buckling correlates with knee and patellar tendon health. Patellar tendon buckling was assessed during passive knee flexion using ultrasound in post-TKA patients (n = 20; 12M, 68 ± 8 years) and compared with previously reported data from healthy adults (n = 12; 12M; 70 ± 8 years). Patients exhibited significantly larger (p < 0.01) buckling magnitude and angles than healthy adults, and reduced distal buckling was linked with better Knee Society Scores (p = 0.04, R² = 0.24). The greater patellar tendon buckling observed in post-TKA patients could arise due to factors related to the surgery itself (e.g. infrapatellar fat pad resection) or it may be that post-TKA patients had greater patellar tendon buckling before their procedure. Alterations in patellar tendon buckling may predispose individuals to post-surgical complications including instability, anterior knee pain, and extensor mechanism dysfunction, with further work necessary to elucidate potential links.

Non-uniformity in the healthy patellar tendon is greater in males and similar in different age groups

There is increasing evidence that tendons are heterogeneous and take advantage of structural mechanisms to enhance performance and reduce injury. Fascicle-sliding, for example, is used by energy-storing tendons to enable them to undergo large extensions while protecting the fascicles from damage. Reductions in fascicle-sliding capacity may thus predispose certain populations to tendinopathy. Evidence from the Achilles tendon of significant superficial-to-deep non-uniformity that is reduced with age supports this theory. Similar patellar tendon non-uniformity has been observed, but the effects of age and sex have yet to be assessed. Healthy adults (n = 50, 25M/25F) from a broad range of ages (23-80) were recruited and non-uniformity was quantified using ultrasound speckle-tracking during passive knee extension. Significant superficial-to-deep non-uniformity and proximal/distal variations were observed. No effect of age was found, but males exhibited significantly greater non-uniformity than females (p < 0.05). The results contrast with previous findings in the Achilles tendon; in this study, tendons and tendon regions at high risk for tendinopathy (i.e. males and proximal regions, respectively) exhibited greater non-uniformity, whereas high-risk Achilles tendons (i.e. older adults) previously showed reduced non-uniformity. This suggests that non-uniformity may be dominated by factors other than fascicle-sliding. Anatomically, the varied proximal attachment of the patellar tendon may influence non-uniformity, with quadriceps passive resistance limiting superficial tendon movement, thus linking flexibility, non-uniformity and injury risk. This study also provides evidence of a differential effect of aging on the patellar tendon compared with evidence from prior studies on other tendons necessitating further study to elucidate links between non-uniformity and injury.

Nonuniform Deformation of the Patellar Tendon During Passive Knee Flexion

The purpose of this study was to evaluate localized patterns of patellar tendon deformation during passive knee flexion. Ultrasound radiofrequency data were collected from the patellar tendons of 20 healthy young adults during knee flexion over a range of motion of 50°-90° of flexion. A speckle tracking approach was used to compute proximal and distal tendon displacements and elongations. Nonuniform tissue displacements were visible in the proximal tendon (P < .001), with the deep tendon undergoing more distal displacement than the superficial tendon. In the distal tendon, more uniform tendon motion was observed. Spatial variations in percent elongation were also observed, but these varied along the length of the tendon (P < .002), with the proximal tendon remaining fairly isometric while the distal tendon underwent slight elongation. These results suggest that even during passive flexion the tendon undergoes complex patterns of deformation. Proximal tendon nonuniformity may arise from its complex anatomy where the deep tendon inserts onto the patella and the superficial tendon extends to the quadriceps tendon. Such heterogeneity is not captured in whole tendon average assessments, emphasizing the relevance of considering localized tendon mechanics, which may be key to understanding tendon behavior and precursors to injury and disease.

Mechanical Coupling Between Muscle-Tendon Units Reduces Peak Stresses

The presence of mechanical linkages between synergistic muscles and their common tendons may distribute forces among the involved structures. We review studies, using humans and other animals, examining muscle and tendon interactions and discuss the hypothesis that connections between muscle bellies and within tendons may serve as a mechanism to distribute forces and mitigate peak stresses.

The Achilles tendon is mechanosensitive in older adults: adaptations following 14 weeks versus 1.5 years of cyclic strain exercise

The aging musculoskeletal system experiences a general decline in structure and function, characterized by a reduced adaptability to environmental stress. We investigated whether the older human Achilles tendon (AT) demonstrates mechanosensitivity (via biomechanical and morphological adaptations) in response to long-term mechanical loading. Thirty-four female adults (60-75 years) were allocated to either a medium-term (14 weeks; N=21) high AT strain cyclic loading exercise intervention or a control group (N=13), with 12 participants continuing with the intervention for 1.5 years. AT biomechanical properties were assessed using ultrasonography and dynamometry. Tendon cross-sectional area (CSA) was investigated by means of magnetic resonance imaging. A 22% exercise-related increment in ankle plantarflexion joint moment, along with increased AT stiffness (598.2±141.2 versus 488.4±136.9 N mm^-1 at baseline), Young's modulus (1.63±0.46 versus 1.37±0.39 GPa at baseline) and about 6% hypertrophy along the entire free AT were identified after 14 weeks of strength training, with no further improvement after 1.5 years of intervention. The aging AT appears to be capable of increasing its stiffness in response to 14 weeks of mechanical loading exercise by changing both its material and dimensional properties. Continuing exercise seems to maintain, but not cause further adaptive changes in tendons, suggesting that the adaptive time-response relationship of aging tendons subjected to mechanical loading is nonlinear.

The challenges of measuring in vivo knee collateral ligament strains using ultrasound

Ultrasound-based methods have shown promise in their ability to characterize non-uniform deformations in large energy-storing tendons such as the Achilles and patellar tendons, yet applications to other areas of the body have been largely unexplored. The noninvasive quantification of collateral ligament strain could provide an important clinical metric of knee frontal plane stability, which is relevant in ligament injury and for measuring outcomes following total knee arthroplasty. In this pilot cadaveric experiment, we investigated the possibility of measuring collateral ligament strain with our previously validated speckle-tracking approach, but encountered a number of challenges during both data acquisition and processing. Given the clinical interest in this type of tool, and the fact that this is a developing area of research, the goal of this article is to transparently describe this pilot study, both in terms of methods and results, while also identifying specific challenges to this work and areas for future study. Some challenges faced relate generally to speckle-tracking of soft tissues (e.g. the limitations of using a 2D imaging modality to characterize 3D motion), while others are specific to this application (e.g. the small size and complex anatomy of the collateral ligaments). This work illustrates a clear need for additional studies, particularly relating to the collection of ground-truth data and more thorough validation work. These steps will be critical prior to the translation of ultrasound-based measures of collateral ligament strains into the clinic.

Evidence of patellar tendon buckling during passive knee extension

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to investigate and describe buckling of the patellar tendon.

METHODS

Healthy young adults (28±4years, 10F/10M) underwent passive knee flexion/extension during the simultaneous measurement of knee angle and collection of cine ultrasound from the patellar tendon. Patellar tendon buckling was observed visually in ultrasound images, and the corresponding knee angle at which evidence of buckling disappeared was identified.

RESULTS

All subjects showed evidence of distal buckling which occurred on average at 23±8° flexion. Proximal buckling was only observed in fourteen subjects (10F/4M) at an average of 15±8°. Buckling patterns varied between subjects, but with high within-subject consistency. Buckling magnitude increased with age (p=0.03) and decreased with more weekly exercise (p=0.02).

DISCUSSION

The patellar tendon exhibited significant buckling in knee extension suggesting that buckling is a component of healthy knee function. Like tendon crimp, buckling may serve as a protective mechanism, allowing the tissue to unwrinkle prior to undergoing pure strain. The links between increased buckling magnitude and both age and reduced activity suggest that excessive buckling may be maladaptive, though future work is necessary to elucidate this relationship. Buckling is relevant to consider when estimating tendon length, as buckling can lead to significant underestimation of resting length and thus overestimation of strain.

CONCLUSION

This study demonstrates the complexity of tendon behavior even in healthy adults undergoing passive motion, suggesting that buckling may be relevant to an improved understanding of tendon health and pathology.

Athletic training affects the uniformity of muscle and tendon adaptation during adolescence

With the double stimulus of mechanical loading and maturation acting on the muscle-tendon unit, adolescent athletes might be at increased risk of developing imbalances of muscle strength and tendon mechanical properties. This longitudinal study aims to provide detailed information on how athletic training affects the time course of muscle-tendon adaptation during adolescence. In 12 adolescent elite athletes (A) and 8 similar-aged controls (C), knee extensor muscle strength and patellar tendon mechanical properties were measured over 1 yr in 3-mo intervals. A linear mixed-effects model was used to analyze time-dependent changes and the residuals of the model to quantify fluctuations over time. The cosine similarity (CS) served as a measure of uniformity of the relative changes of tendon force and stiffness. Muscle strength and tendon stiffness increased significantly in both groups ( P < 0.01). However, the fluctuations of muscle strength were greater [A, 17 ± 7 (SD) N·m; C, 6 ± 2 N·m; P < 0.05] and the uniformity of changes of tendon force and stiffness was lower in athletes (CS A, −0.02 ± 0.5; C, 0.5 ± 0.4; P < 0.05). Further, athletes demonstrated greater maximum tendon strain (A, 7.6 ± 1.7%; C, 5.5 ± 0.9%; P < 0.05) and strain fluctuations (A, 0.9 ± 0.4; C, 0.3 ± 0.1; P < 0.05). We conclude that athletic training in adolescence affects the uniformity of muscle and tendon adaptation, which increases the demand on the tendon with potential implications for tendon injury.

In vivo strain in the deep and superficial regions of the human patellar tendon

This study investigated strain differences within the patellar tendon (PT) mid-region using an ultrasound-based digital image correlation (DIC) method. Six healthy young participants performed six knee extensions to 60% of maximal voluntary isometric contraction on 2 days. Sagittal ultrasound videos recorded during each contraction were analyzed using the DIC method to determine the strain-torque relationships of the superficial, deep, and whole PT mid-regions. Significantly greater strain was observed in the deep vs superficial layer of the PT mid-region for all contraction intensities, with peak strains of 5.8% (SD 1.7) and 4.5% (SD 1.5), respectively. DIC-based measures of peak tendon strain were repeatable within [intraclass coefficients (ICC) >0.97] and between sessions (ICCs >0.83) and agreed well with the conventional point-to-point method. This study confirmed that significant differences exist between deep and superficial layers of PT mid-region during ramped isometric extensions. These findings support the use of DIC to examine regional strain patterns within the PT mid-region that may be important in the context of tendon injury and adaptation.

Quantitative ultrasound mapping of regional variations in shear wave speeds of the aging Achilles tendon

OBJECTIVES

Evaluate the effects of aging on healthy Achilles tendon and aponeurosis shear wave speed (SWS), a quantitative metric which reflects tissue elasticity.

METHODS

Shear wave elastography was used to measure spatial variations in Achilles tendon SWS in healthy young (n = 15, 25 ± 4 years), middle-aged (n = 10, 49 ± 4 years) and older (n = 10, 68 ± 5 years) adults. SWS was separately measured in the free Achilles tendon, soleus aponeurosis and gastrocnemius aponeurosis in resting (R), stretched (dorsiflexed 15° from R) and slack (plantarflexed 15° from R) postures.

RESULTS

SWS significantly increased with stretch and varied with age in all tendon regions. Slack free tendon SWS was significantly higher in older adults than young adults (p = 0.025). However, stretched soleus aponeurosis SWS was significantly lower in older adults than young adults (p = 0.01). Stretched gastrocnemius aponeurosis SWS was significantly lower in both middle-aged (p = 0.003) and older (p = 0.001) adults, relative to younger adults.

CONCLUSION

These results suggest that aging alters spatial variations in Achilles tendon elasticity, which could alter deformations within the triceps surae muscle-tendon units, thus affecting injury potential. The observed location- and posture-dependent variations highlight the importance of controlling ankle posture and imaging location when using shear wave approaches clinically to evaluate tendon disorders.

KEY POINTS

• Shear wave elastography shows promise as a clinical quantitative ultrasound-based technique. • Aging induces location-dependent changes in Achilles tendon shear wave speed. • Spatial and postural dependence necessitates careful integration of this approach clinically.

Sex Variation in Patellar Tendon Kinetics During Running

Purpose. The aim of the current investigation was to determine whether female recreational runners exhibit distinct patellar tendon loading patterns in relation to their male counterparts. Methods. Twelve male (age 26.55 ± 4.11 years, height 1.78 ± 0.11 m, mass 77.11 ± 5.06 kg) and twelve female (age 26.67 ± 5.34 years, height 1.67 ± 0.12 m, mass 63.28 ± 9.75 kg) runners ran over a force platform at 4.0 m · s-1. Lower limb kinematics were collected using an eight-camera optoelectric motion capture system which operated at 250 Hz. Patellar tendon loads were examined using a predictive algorithm. Sex differences in limb, knee and ankle joint stiffness were examined statistically using independent samples t tests. Results. The results indicate that patellar tendon force (male = 6.49 ± 2.28, female = 7.03 ± 1.35) and patelllar tendon loading rate (male = 92.41 ± 32.51, female = 111.05 ± 48.58) were significantly higher in female runners. Conclusions. Excessive tendon loading in female runners indicates that female runners may be at increased risk of patellar tendon pathologies.

Variants within the MMP3 gene and patellar tendon properties in vivo in an asymptomatic population

BACKGROUND/AIM

Gene variants encoding for proteins involved in homeostatic processes within tendons may influence its material and mechanical properties in humans. The purpose of this study was to examine the association between three polymorphisms of the MMP3 gene, (rs679620, rs591058 and rs650108) and patellar tendon dimensional and mechanical properties in vivo.

METHODS

One hundred and sixty, healthy, recreationally-active, Caucasian men and women, aged 18-39 were recruited. MMP3 genotype determined using real-time PCR was used to select 84 participants showing greatest genetic differences to complete phenotype measurements. Patellar tendon dimensions (volume) and functional (elastic modulus) properties were assessed in vivo using geometric modelling, isokinetic dynamometry, electromyography and ultrasonography.

RESULTS

No significant associations were evident between the completely linked MMP3 rs591058 and rs679620 gene variants, and closely linked rs650108 gene variant, and either patellar tendon volume (rs679620, P = 0.845; rs650108, P = 0.984) or elastic modulus (rs679620, P = 0.226; rs650108, P = 0.088). Similarly, there were no associations with the Z-score that combined those dimension and functional properties into a composite value (rs679620, P = 0.654; rs650108, P = 0.390). Similarly, no association was evident when comparing individuals with/without the rarer alleles (P > 0.01 in all cases).

CONCLUSIONS

Patellar tendon properties do not seem to be influenced by the MMP3 gene variants measured. Although these MMP3 gene variants have previously been associated with the risk of tendon pathology, that association is unlikely to be mediated via underlying tendon dimensional and functional properties.