Hertwig's Epithelial Root Sheath Fate during Initial Cellular Cementogenesis in Rat Molars

Current Trends, Advances, and Challenges of Tissue Engineering-Based Approaches of Tooth Regeneration: A Review of the Literature

INTRODUCTION

Tooth loss is a significant health issue. Currently, this situation is often treated with the use of synthetic materials such as implants and prostheses. However, these treatment modalities do not fully meet patients' biological and mechanical needs and have limited longevity. Regenerative medicine focuses on the restoration of patients' natural tissues via tissue engineering techniques instead of rehabilitating with artificial appliances. Therefore, a tissue-engineered tooth regeneration strategy seems like a promising option to treat tooth loss.

OBJECTIVE

This review aims to demonstrate recent advances in tooth regeneration strategies and discoveries about underlying mechanisms and pathways of tooth formation.

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION

Whole tooth regeneration, tooth root formation, and dentin-pulp organoid generation have been achieved by using different seed cells and various materials for scaffold production. Bioactive agents are critical elements for the induction of cells into odontoblast or ameloblast lineage. Some substantial pathways enrolled in tooth development have been figured out, helping researchers design their experiments more effectively and aligned with the natural process of tooth formation.

CONCLUSION

According to current knowledge, tooth regeneration is possible in case of proper selection of stem cells, appropriate design and manufacturing of a biocompatible scaffold, and meticulous application of bioactive agents for odontogenic induction. Understanding innate odontogenesis pathways play a crucial role in accurately planning regenerative therapeutic interventions in order to reproduce teeth.

Spatiotemporal cellular dynamics and molecular regulation of tooth root ontogeny

Tooth root development involves intricate spatiotemporal cellular dynamics and molecular regulation. The initiation of Hertwig's epithelial root sheath (HERS) induces odontoblast differentiation and the subsequent radicular dentin deposition. Precisely controlled signaling pathways modulate the behaviors of HERS and the fates of dental mesenchymal stem cells (DMSCs). Disruptions in these pathways lead to defects in root development, such as shortened roots and furcation abnormalities. Advances in dental stem cells, biomaterials, and bioprinting show immense promise for bioengineered tooth root regeneration. However, replicating the developmental intricacies of odontogenesis has not been resolved in clinical treatment and remains a major challenge in this field. Ongoing research focusing on the mechanisms of root development, advanced biomaterials, and manufacturing techniques will enable next-generation biological root regeneration that restores the physiological structure and function of the tooth root. This review summarizes recent discoveries in the underlying mechanisms governing root ontogeny and discusses some recent key findings in developing of new biologically based dental therapies.

Hertwig's epithelial root sheath cells show potential for periodontal complex regeneration

BACKGROUND

Although researchers have been exploring therapeutic strategies of treating serious periodontal tissue loss, including the application of stem cells, tissue regeneration of the periodontal complex involving cementum, periodontium, and alveolar bone has hardly been achieved. Aiming at tackling the problem of severely damaged periodontal complex, it is worth trying to make advantages of Hertwig's epithelial root sheath (HERS) cells to tissue regeneration mimicking the physiological developmental process with their ability of cementum, bone, and periodontium formation.

METHODS

HERS cells and dental follicle cells (DFCs) were acquired from Sprague Dawley rats' molar germs and identified by immunofluorescence. Alizarin red assay, ALP staining, AKP test, real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction (RT-qPCR) and Western blot were conducted to confirm the osteogenic potential, epithelial-mesenchymal transition (EMT) character of harvested HERS cells and epithelial-mesenchymal interaction (EMI) with DFCs. An animal model of periodontal defect was constructed to testify the tissue regeneration ability in vivo. Micro-CT and histological examinations were interpreted to unveil the tissue repair outcomes.

RESULTS

HERS cells expressed strong epithelial cell markers CK14 and E-cadherin. The in vitro experiments overall showed the concretely enhanced osteogenic differentiation ability in either HERS group or HERS+DFC group. Meanwhile, the in vivo conduction of rat mandibular periodontal repair experiment showed regenerative effectiveness of periodontal complex structure in both HERS and HERS+DFC group in situ, testified by Micro-CT and histological analysis.

CONCLUSIONS

HERS cells show potential for periodontal tissue regeneration which suggests the future possibilities of being considered as one of the cell choices for severely damaged periodontal tissue repair.

Effects of short-term orthodontic force application on the root at different developmental stages in rat maxillary molars

INTRODUCTION

The suitable timing and duration of orthodontic force to be applied to teeth with developing roots are unclear. We investigated the effects of short-term orthodontic force application on the roots at different root developmental stages in rats to predict the optimal timing for orthodontic treatment of teeth with developing roots.

METHODS

Light orthodontic force was applied on the maxillary first molars of rats from postnatal day (PN) 21 or PN28 for 3 days. After that, the force was released, and the roots were evaluated on PN35 to determine the root length, apical morphology, and cell proliferation of the maxillary first mesial roots using microcomputed tomography and histologic evaluation.

RESULTS

When a light orthodontic force was applied from PN21, the root length did not differ from that in age-matched controls. In addition, after the force was released, the roots attained the normal root-completing length and had a well-formed root apical morphology at PN35. Conversely, when the force was applied from PN28, the roots showed apical abnormalities characterized by deformed dentin and disorganized arrangement of odontoblasts, reduced apical cell proliferation, and significantly shorter length than those in the age-matched controls at PN31. The shortened root and disturbed apical integrity could not be rescued by releasing the orthodontic force at PN35.

CONCLUSIONS

Short-term orthodontic force at the late and slow root developmental stage results in a shortened root and a defect in the root apex with reduced cell proliferation. Our findings support that orthodontic force for a limited duration during the active and rapid root developmental stage is more favorable than during the late and slow stage.

Expressions of cytokeratin 14 and proliferating cell nuclear antigen in the Hertwig's epithelial root sheath of a Vps4b knockout mouse

OBJECTIVES

The effect of Vps4b gene mutation on the expressions of cytokeratin 14 (CK14) and proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) in the Hertwig's epithelial root sheath (HERS) is investigated.

METHODS

The bilateral mandibular tissues of mouse on postnatal days 5, 9, 11, 15, and 19 were removed. The mandibular first molar tissue sections were obtained after paraffin embedding. The CK14 and PCNA expressions in the epithelial root sheath of the normal mouse and Vps4b knockout mouse were compared through immunohistochemistry.

RESULTS

On postnatal day 5, the normal mouse began to form HERS and had a strong positive PCNA expression in the HERS cells; on postnatal day 9, the HERS structure was continuous, and PCNA was positive in the HERS cells; on postnatal day 11, a small portion of HERS began to break, and PCNA was weakly positive in the HERS cells; on postnatal day 15, HERS continued to fracture; PCNA was weakly and positively expressed in the HERS cells on the root surface; on postnatal day 19, the tooth root reached normal physiological length, and PCNA was positively expressed in the HERS cells of the terminal part. Similar to the normal mouse, the gene knockout mouse also formed a HERS structure on postnatal day 5. However, HERS began to break on postnatal day 9. On postnatal day 19, only a few fragments of HERS were found on the root surface, and the root development was immature. Moreover, the expression intensity of PCNA in the gene knockout mouse was decreased.

CONCLUSIONS

The Vps4b gene mutation may change the CK14 and PCNA expressions, leading to abnormal root development.

Therapeutic potential of HERS spheroids in tooth regeneration

Hertwig's epithelial root sheath (HERS) plays indispensable roles in tooth root development, including controlling the shape and number of roots, dentin formation, and helping generate the cementum. Based on these characteristics, HERS cell is a potential seed cell type for tooth-related tissue regeneration. However, the application is severely limited by a lack of appropriate culture methods and small cell numbers. Methods: Here, we constructed a 3D culture method to expand functional HERS cells into spheroids, and investigated characteristics and application of dental tissue regeneration of these spheroids. HERS spheroids and HERS cells (2D monolayer culture) were compared in terms of biological characteristics (such as proliferation, self-renewal capacity, and stemness) in vitro and functions (including differentiation potential and inductive ability of dentin formation) both in vitro and in vivo. Further, transcriptome analysis was utilized to reveal the molecular mechanisms of their obvious differences. Results: HERS spheroids showed obvious superiority in biological characteristics and functions compared to 2D monolayers of HERS cells in vitro. In vivo, HERS spheroids generated more mineralized tissue; when combined with dental papilla cells (DPCs), HERS spheroids contributed to dentin-like tissue formation. Moreover, the generation and expansion of HERS spheroids rely to some degree on the HIF-1 pathway. Conclusion: HERS spheroid generation is beneficial for functional HERS cell expansion and can provide a useful cell source for further tooth regeneration and mechanistic research. Notably, HIF-1 pathway plays a critical role in HERS spheroid formation and function.

Are Hertwig's epithelial root sheath cells necessary for periodontal formation by dental follicle cells?

OBJECTIVE

The role of Hertwig's epithelial root sheath (HERS) cells in periodontal formation has been controversial. This study aimed to further clarify whether HERS cells participate in formation of the periodontium, and the necessity of HERS cells in differentiation of dental follicle cells (DFCs) for periodontal regeneration.

DESIGN

HERS cells and DFCs were isolated and identified from post-natal 7-day Sprauge-Dawley rats. In vitro, direct co-culture of HERS cells and DFCs as well as the individual culture of HERS and DFCs were performed and followed by alizarin red staining and the quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction analysis. For in vivo evaluation, the inactivated dentin matrix (iTDM) was fabricated. HERS cells and DFCs were seeded in combination or alone on iTDM and then transplanted into the rat omentum. Scanning electron microscope and further histological analysis were carried out.

RESULTS

In vitro, mineral-like nodules were found in the culture of HERS cells alone or HERS + DFCs either by alizarin red staining or scanning electronic microscope. The mineralization and fiber-forming relevant mRNA expressions, such as bone sialoprotein, osteopontin, collagen I and collagen III in HERS + DFCs were significantly higher than that of the HERS or DFCs alone group. After transplantation in vivo, cementum and periodontal ligament-like tissues were formed in groups of HERS + DFCs and HERS alone, while no evident hard tissues and attached fibers were found in DFCs alone.

CONCLUSIONS

Hertwig's epithelial root sheath cells directly participate in the formation of the periodontium, and they are essential for the differentiation of dental follicle cells to form periodontal structures. The combination use of Hertwig's epithelial root sheath cells and dental follicle cells is a promising approach for periodontal regeneration.

Osteoprotegerin deficiency causes morphological and quantitative damage in epithelial rests of Malassez

Epithelial rests of Malassez (ERM), the only odontogenic epithelial structures in periodontal tissue, are proposed to correlate with root resorption, but the detailed mechanism remains unclear. Osteoprotegerin (OPG), the main inhibitor of osteoclastogenesis, plays a pivotal role in inhibiting root resorption, and ERM cells express OPG mRNA in vitro. Thus, in this study, we aimed to clarify OPG expression in ERM in vivo and to explore the role of OPG in ERM to determine whether ERM are associated with root resorption via OPG. We established Opg-knockout (Opg-KO) mice and detected the OPG expression in ERM by immunohistochemical staining in 4-, 6-, 10-, 26- and 52-week-old mice. The ERM of wild-type (WT) mice and Opg-KO mice were evaluated histologically at 4, 10 and 26 weeks of age. Orthodontic root resorption models were established, maxillae were collected after 4 weeks, and ERM were analysed by histomorphometric analysis. In our study, OPG displayed sustained expression in ERM, and OPG deficiency caused the destruction of ERM, characterized by irregular morphology and reduced numbers. Moreover, after orthodontic treatment, the loss of OPG severely damaged ERM, aggravating root resorption. Together, our results demonstrated that ERM expressed the OPG protein in vivo and that OPG deficiency resulted in morphological and quantitative damage to ERM. Furthermore, ERM may be associated with root resorption via OPG, thus helping to explain the mechanism underlying root resorption.

Histology of human cementum: Its structure, function, and development

Cementum was first demonstrated by microscopy, about 180 years ago. Since then the biology of cementum has been investigated by the most advanced techniques and equipment at that time in various fields of dental sciences. A great deal of data on cementum histology have been accumulated. These data have been obtained from not only human, but also non-human animals, in particular, rodents such as the mouse and rat. Although many dental histologists have reviewed histology of human cementum, some descriptions are questionable, probably due to incorrect comparison of human and rodent cementum. This review was designed to introduce current histology of human cementum, i.e. its structure, function, and development and to re-examine the most questionable and controversial conclusions made in previous reports.

Differentiation of Apical Bud Cells in a Newly Developed Apical Bud Transplantation Model Using GFP Transgenic Mice as Donor

Rodent mandibular incisors have a unique anatomical structure that allows teeth to grow throughout the lifetime of the rodent. This report presents a novel transplantation technique for studying the apical bud differentiation of rodent mandibular incisors. Incisal apical end tissue with green fluorescent protein from transgenic mouse was transplanted to wild type mice, and the development of the transplanted cells were immunohistologically observed for 12 weeks after the transplantation. Results indicate that the green fluorescent apical end tissue replaced the original tissue, and cells from the apical bud differentiated and extended toward the incisal edge direction. The immunostaining with podoplanin also showed that the characteristics of the green fluorescent tissue were identical to those of the original. The green fluorescent cells were only found in the labial side of the incisor up to 4 weeks. After 12 weeks, however, they were also found in the lingual side. Here the green fluorescent cementocyte-like cells were only present in the cementum close to the dentin surface. This study suggests that some of the cells that form the cellular cementum come from the apical tissue including the apical bud in rodent incisors.

Multiple essential MT1-MMP functions in tooth root formation, dentinogenesis, and tooth eruption

Membrane-type matrix metalloproteinase 1 (MT1-MMP) is a transmembrane zinc-endopeptidase that breaks down extracellular matrix components, including several collagens, during tissue development and physiological remodeling. MT1-MMP-deficient mice (MT1-MMP(-/-)) feature severe defects in connective tissues, such as impaired growth, osteopenia, fibrosis, and conspicuous loss of molar tooth eruption and root formation. In order to define the functions of MT1-MMP during root formation and tooth eruption, we analyzed the development of teeth and surrounding tissues in the absence of MT1-MMP. In situ hybridization showed that MT1-MMP was widely expressed in cells associated with teeth and surrounding connective tissues during development. Multiple defects in dentoalveolar tissues were associated with loss of MT1-MMP. Root formation was inhibited by defective structure and function of Hertwig's epithelial root sheath (HERS). However, no defect was found in creation of the eruption pathway, suggesting that tooth eruption was hampered by lack of alveolar bone modeling/remodeling coincident with reduced periodontal ligament (PDL) formation and integration with the alveolar bone. Additionally, we identified a significant defect in dentin formation and mineralization associated with the loss of MT1-MMP. To segregate these multiple defects and trace their cellular origin, conditional ablation of MT1-MMP was performed in epithelia and mesenchyme. Mice featuring selective loss of MT1-MMP activity in the epithelium were indistinguishable from wild type mice, and importantly, featured a normal HERS structure and molar eruption. In contrast, selective knock-out of MT1-MMP in Osterix-expressing mesenchymal cells, including osteoblasts and odontoblasts, recapitulated major defects from the global knock-out including altered HERS structure, short roots, defective dentin formation and mineralization, and reduced alveolar bone formation, although molars were able to erupt. These data indicate that MT1-MMP activity in the dental mesenchyme, and not in epithelial-derived HERS, is essential for proper tooth root formation and eruption. In summary, our studies point to an indispensable role for MT1-MMP-mediated matrix remodeling in tooth eruption through effects on bone formation, soft tissue remodeling and organization of the follicle/PDL region.