Impact of pH on succession of sourdough lactic acid bacteria communities and their fermentation properties

Cyclic pairwise interaction representing a rock-paper-scissors game maintains the population of the vulnerable yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae within a multispecies sourdough microbiome

IMPORTANCE

Traditionally, multispecies consisting of lactic acid bacteria and yeasts collaboratively engage sourdough fermentation, which determines the quality of the resulting baked goods. Nonetheless, the successive transfer of these microbial communities can result in undesirable community dynamics that prevent the formation of high-quality sourdough bread. Thus, a mechanistic understanding of the community dynamics is fundamental to engineer sourdough complex fermentation. This study describes the population dynamics of five species of lactic acid bacteria-yeast communities in vitro using a generalized Lotka-Volterra model that examines interspecies interactions. A vulnerable yeast species was maintained within up to five species community dynamics by obtaining support with a cyclic interspecies interaction. Metaphorically, it involves a rock-paper-scissors game between two lactic acid bacteria species. Application of the generalized Lotka-Volterra model to real food microbiomes including sourdoughs will increase the reliability of the model prediction and help identify key microbial interactions that drive microbiome dynamics.

Changes in the Physicochemical Properties of Chia (Salvia hispanica L.) Seeds during Solid-State and Submerged Fermentation and Their Influence on Wheat Bread Quality and Sensory Profile

This study aimed at investigating the impacts of 24 h of either solid-state fermentation (SSF) or submerged fermentation (SMF) with Lactiplantibacillus plantarum strain No. 122 on the physico-chemical attributes of chia seeds (CS). Furthermore, this study examined how adding fermented chia seeds (10, 20, and 30% concentrations) affected the properties and sensory profile of wheat bread. Acidity, lactic acid bacteria (LAB) viable counts, biogenic amine (BA), and fatty acid (FA) profiles of fermented chia seeds were analysed. The main quality parameters, acrylamide concentration, FA and volatile compound (VC) profiles, sensory characteristics, and overall acceptability of the obtained breads, were analysed. A decline in the concentration of certain BA and saturated FA and an increase in polyunsaturated FA and omega-3 (ω-3) were found in fermented CS (FCS). The same tendency in the FA profile was observed in both breads, i.e., breads with non-fermented CS (NFCS) or FCS. The quality parameters, VC profile, and sensory attributes of wheat bread were significantly affected by the addition of NFCS or FCS to the main bread formula. All supplemented breads had reduced specific volume and porosity, but SSF chia seeds increased moisture and decreased mass loss after baking. The lowest acrylamide content was found in bread with a 30% concentration of SSF chia seeds (11.5 µg/kg). The overall acceptance of supplemented breads was lower than the control bread, but breads with 10 and 20% SMF chia seed concentrations were still well accepted (on average, 7.4 score). Obtained results highlight that fermentation with Lp. plantarum positively contributes to chia seed nutritional value, while incorporation of NFCS and FCS at certain levels results in an improved FA profile, certain sensory attributes, and reduced acrylamide content in wheat bread.

Diurnal Variation of Epiphytic Microbiota: an Unignorable Factor Affecting the Anaerobic Fermentation Characteristics of Sorghum-Sudangrass Hybrid Silage

Forage epiphytic microbiota exhibits pronounced changes in composition and function throughout the day. However, the effects of these changes on silage fermentation are rarely explored. Here, we transplanted the epiphytic microbiota of sorghum-sudangrass hybrid (SSG) harvested at 7:00 h (AM), 12:00 h (M), and 17:00 h (PM) to sterilized SSG to evaluate the effects of diurnal variation of epiphytic microbiota on fermentation characteristics. During fermentation, remarkable differences in bacterial community successions were observed between silages inoculated with AM and M microbiota. Compared to AM microbiota, M microbiota inoculation increased the proportions of Pantoea dispersa, Leuconostoc lactis, Enterobacter, and Klebsiella variicola, whereas it decreased the proportions of Weissella cibaria and Lactobacillus plantarum during fermentation. This led to the most rapid pH declines and organic acid production in AM silage and the slowest in M silage. Both M and PM microbiota affected the bacterial cooccurrence patterns, indicated by decreased complexity and stability in the community structures of M and PM silages compared to that of AM silage. The predicted functions indicated that some key carbohydrate metabolism pathways related to lactic acid synthesis were downregulated, while some competing pathways (ascorbate and aldarate metabolism and C5-branched dibasic acid metabolism) were upregulated in M silage compared to AM silage after 3 days of fermentation. Correlation analysis revealed positive correlations between competing pathways and enterobacterial species. The current study highlights the importance of diurnal variation of epiphytic microbiota in affecting the silage bacterial community, potentially providing an effective strategy to improve silage quality by optimizing harvest time. IMPORTANCE Ensiling is a way to preserve wet biomass for animal and bioenergy production worldwide. The fermentation quality of silage is largely dependent on the epiphytic microbiota of the material. Plant epiphytic microbiota exhibit diurnal changes in composition and function. However, the effects of these changes on silage fermentation are rarely explored. The results presented here demonstrated that diurnal variation of epiphytic microbiota could affect the fermentation characteristics and bacterial community during SSG fermentation. Marked bacterial community differences were observed between AM and M silages during the initial 3 days of fermentation. The dominance rate of Lactobacillus plantarum was highest in AM silage, whereas enterobacterial species were more abundant in M silage. The predicted function revealed downregulated lactic acid synthesis pathways and upregulated competing pathways in M silage compared to those in AM silage. This study provides clues for technological-parameter optimization of the fermentation process by the selection of harvest time.

Preparation of Sourdoughs Fermented with Isolated Lactic Acid Bacteria and Characterization of Their Antifungal Properties

Traditional sourdough is obtained using a mixture of flour and water stored at room temperature until acidification. Therefore, adding lactic acid bacteria (LAB) can improve the quality and safety of sourdough bread. Faced with this problem, four drying techniques-freeze-drying, spray-drying, low-temperature drying, and drying at low humidity-have been applied. Our goals were to isolate LAB strains with antifungal potential against Aspergillus and Penicillium fungi. The antifungal capacity was evaluated with agar diffusion, co-culture in overlay agar, and a microdilution susceptibility assay. In addition, the antifungal compounds generated in sourdough were analyzed. As a result, dried sourdoughs were prepared with Lactiplantibacillus plantarum TN10, Lactiplantibacillus plantarum TF2, Pediococcus pentosaceus TF8, Pediococcus acidilactici TE4, and Pediococcus pentosaceus TI6. The minimum fungicidal concentrations ranged from 25 g/L versus P. verrucosum and 100 g/L against A. flavus. A total of 27 volatile organic compounds were produced. Moreover, the lactic acid content reached 26 g/kg of dry product, and the phenyllactic concentration was significantly higher than the control. The P. pentosaceus TI6 exhibited a higher antifungal capacity in vitro and demonstrated a higher production of antifungal compounds compared to the other strains; therefore, further studies will evaluate the impact of this sourdough in bread manufacture.

Evolution of the spontaneous sourdoughs microbiota prepared with organic or conventional whole wheat flours from South Brazil

The purpose of this study was to compare the composition and stability of bacteria and fungi communities during the propagation of sourdoughs prepared with organic or conventional whole wheat (Triticum aestivum) flours from South Brazil. Sourdoughs were prepared and samples were collected during different fermentation times (0 to 216 h). Total DNA of sourdough samples were extracted and the 16S rRNA gene and Internal Transcribed Spacer region were sequenced by MiSeq-Illumina. A total of 43 and 56 OTUs were identified and defined as core taxa in the bacterial and fungal communities, respectively. The analysis revealed increases in the relative abundances of the lactic acid (Pediococcus pentosaceus, Weissella hellenica and Limosilactobacillus pontis) and acetic acid bacteria (Gluconobacter frateurii and Acetobacter tropicalis) during the sourdough propagation. The filaments fungi, Alternaria tenuissima, Fusarium culmorum, Fusarium petersiae and Microdochium seminicola remained more stable in organic than conventional during propagation cycles. After 216 h of fermentation, both sourdoughs were dominated by acid- and salt-tolerant yeast Issatchenkia orientalis (syn Pichia kudriavzevii, and Candida glycerinogenes). In conclusion, there were no significant differences in microbial communities among the sourdough samples. This study revealed that both flours contain autochthonous LAB, AAB, and yeasts with biotechnological applications in sourdough bread-making.

Time of Day for Harvest Affects the Fermentation Parameters, Bacterial Community, and Metabolic Characteristics of Sorghum-Sudangrass Hybrid Silage

To characterize the effects of time of day for harvest on the fermentation parameters, bacterial community, and metabolic characteristics of sorghum-sudangrass hybrid (SSG) silage, SSG (vegetative stage) harvested at 7:00 (AM), 12:00 (M), and 17:00 (PM) on three sunny days were ensiled for 1, 3, 7, 14, 30, and 60 days. Compared to AM silage, M and PM silages were characterized by delayed fermentation, unnormal lower final pH, and lower acetic acid production. In addition, PM silage contained higher residual water-soluble carbohydrates than other silages. After 60 days of ensiling, AM silage was dominated by Lactobacillus, whereas the bacterial communities of M and PM silages were complex and mainly composed of bacteria such as Delftia, Methylobacterium-Methylorubrum, Enhydrobacter, Acinetobacter, and Bacillus. The harvest time affected a wide range of metabolic pathways including "Metabolism" and "Cellular Processes" and "Organismal Systems" in SSG silage. Particularly, at the late stage of ensiling M silage exhibited highest relative abundances of amino acid metabolisms including "glycine, serine, and threonine metabolism," "phenylalanine metabolism," and lowest relative abundances of "lysine biosynthesis." These results suggest that the time of day for harvest could affect the fermentation parameters, bacterial community, and metabolic characteristics of SSG silage. Better SSG silage characteristics could be achieved through morning harvest. IMPORTANCE Ensiling is a common way for preserving green forages worldwide. Silage fermentation quality can vary greatly depending on the chemical and microbial characteristics of forage crop being ensiled. It is well documented that forages exhibit considerable variations in chemical composition and epiphytic microbiota during daylight. However, the effects of the time of day for harvest on silage fermentation is less investigated. Our results demonstrate that the time of day for harvest could affect the fermentation parameters, bacterial community, and metabolic characteristics of SSG hybrid silage. Harvesting SSG late in the day delayed fermentation process, lowered acetic acid production and final pH, and increased the residual water-soluble carbohydrates content in silage. Moreover, the delayed harvest time increased the relative abundances of bacteria such as Delftia, Methylobacterium-Methylorubrum, Acinetobacter, Enhydrobacter, and Bacillus, and amino acid metabolisms at the late stage of SSG ensiling. This study highlights the importance of diurnal changes in forage to fermentation characteristics, providing a strategy to improve silage quality through optimizing the harvest time.

Taxonomic structure of bacterial communities in sourdoughs of spontaneous fermentation

The article is devoted to the study of the microbiome of spontaneously fermented sourdoughs. The aim of the work was to study the inf luence of the technological parameters of sourdough propagations on the taxonomic structure of the microbiome of spontaneously fermented sourdoughs. Two spontaneously fermented sourdoughs were studied: dense rye sourdough and liquid rye sourdough, both prepared using the same batch of peeled rye f lour. To study the taxonomic structure of the sourdough microbiome in dynamics, the method of high-throughput sequencing of 16S rRNA gene fragments of microorganisms was used. It was shown that the technological parameters of sourdough (humidity, temperature) do not affect the taxonomic composition of the microbiome of dense rye or liquid rye sourdough at the phylum/class/genus level. It was found that during the f irst three days of propagations, bacteria from the phyla Proteobacteria and Firmicutes dominated in the microbial community. In the phylum Proteobacteria, microorganisms from the order Enterobacterales took a large share, which persisted for three days of backslopping. The phylum Firmicutes was represented by lactic acid bacteria of the genera Weissella, Lactobacillus, Leuconostoc, Pediococcus, Lactococcus. It was established by classical microbiological methods that after a day of fermentation, the number of lactic acid bacteria cells was signif icantly higher in liquid rye sourdough compared to dense one. However, with further propagation of sourdoughs, the number of cells was comparable, while signif icant changes occurred at the level of genera and species. It was shown that as the relative number of lactic acid bacteria of the genus Lactobacillus increased, a gradual displacement of the coccal forms of Lactococcus, Leuconostoc, Weissella, Pediococcus happened. With further propagation of sourdough after 10 days, the position of the dominant groups of bacteria was occupied by representatives of the phylum Firmicutes, lactic acid bacteria of the genus Lactobacillus. The inf luence of the mode and parameters of the sourdough on the species composition of lactobacilli, which demonstrated a low bacterial diversity, is shown. In the f irst three days of propagations, lactobacilli L. curvatus, L. brevis, and Lactiplantibacil- lus sp. dominated in both sourdoughs. After a month of backslopping, Fructilactobacillus sanfranciscensis and Companilactobacillus sp. dominated in dense rye sourdough, and L. pontis dominated in liquid rye sourdough

Mechanistic Insight into Yeast Bloom in a Lactic Acid Bacteria Relaying-Community in the Start of Sourdough Microbiota Evolution

The spontaneous microbiota of wheat sourdough, often comprising one yeast species and several lactic acid bacteria (LAB) species, evolves over repeated fermentation cycles, which bakers call backslopping. The final product quality largely depends on the microbiota functions, but these fluctuate sometimes during the initial months of fermentation cycles due to microbiota evolution in which three phases of LAB relay occur. In this study, the understanding of yeast-LAB interactions in the start of the evolution of the microbiota was deepened by exploring the timing and trigger interactions when sourdough yeast entered a preestablished LAB-relaying community. Monitoring of 32 cycles of evolution of 6 batches of spontaneous microbiota in wheat sourdoughs revealed that sourdough yeasts affected the LAB community when the 2nd- or 3rd-relaying types of LAB genera emerged. In in vitro pairwise cocultures, all 12 LAB strains containing the 3 LAB-relaying types arrested the growth of a Saccharomyces cerevisiae strain, a frequently found species in sourdoughs, to various extents by sugar-related interactions. These findings suggest competition due to different affinities of each LAB and a S. cerevisiae strain for each sugar. In particular, maltose was the driver of S. cerevisiae growth in all pairwise cocultures. The functional prediction of sugar metabolism in sourdough LAB communities showed a positive correlation between maltose degradation and the yeast population. Our results suggest that maltose-related interactions are key factors that enable yeasts to enter and then settle in the LAB-relaying community during the initial part of evolution of spontaneous sourdough microbiota.

IMPORTANCE Unpredictable evolution of spontaneous sourdough microbiota sometimes prevents bakers from making special-quality products because the unstable microbiota causes the product quality to fluctuate. Elucidation of the evolutionary mechanisms of the sourdough community, comprising yeast and lactic acid bacteria (LAB), is fundamental to control fermentation performance. This study investigated the mechanisms by which sourdough yeasts entered and settled in a bacterial community in which a three-phase relay of LAB occurred. Our results showed that all three layers of LAB restricted the cohabiting yeast population by competing for the sugar sources, particularly maltose. During the initial evolution of spontaneous sourdough microbiota, yeasts tended to grow synchronously with the progression of the lactic acid bacterial relay, which was predictably associated with changes in the maltose degradation functions in the bacterial community. Further study of ≥3 species’ interactions while considering yeast diversity can uncover additional interaction mechanisms driving the initial evolution of sourdough microbiota.

Sourdough production: fermentation strategies, microbial ecology, and use of non-flour ingredients

Sourdough production is an ancient method to ferment flour from cereals for the manufacturing of baked goods. This review deals with the state-of-the-art of current fermentation strategies for sourdough production and the microbial ecology of mature sourdoughs, with a particular focus on the use of non-flour ingredients. Flour fermentation processes for sourdough production are typically carried out by heterogeneous communities of lactic acid bacteria and yeasts. Acetic acid bacteria may also occur, although their presence and role in sourdough production can be criticized. Based on the inoculum used, sourdough productions can be distinguished in fermentation processes using backslopping procedures, originating from a spontaneously fermented flour-water mixture (Type 1), starter culture-initiated fermentation processes (Type 2), and starter culture-initiated fermentation processes that are followed by backslopping (Type 3). In traditional recipes for the initiation and/or propagation of Type 1 sourdough productions, non-flour ingredients are often added to the flour-water mixture. These ingredients may be the source of an additional microbial inoculum and/or serve as (co-)substrates for fermentation. An example of the former is the addition of yoghurt; an example of the latter is the use of fruit juices. The survival of microorganisms transferred from the ingredients to the fermenting flour-water mixture depends on the competitiveness toward particular strains of the microbial species present under the harsh conditions of the sourdough ecosystem. Their survival and growth is also determined by the presence of the appropriate substrates, whether or not carried over by the ingredients added.

Sourdough Microbiome Comparison and Benefits

Sourdough is the oldest form of leavened bread used as early as 2000 BC by the ancient Egyptians. It may have been discovered by accident when wild yeast drifted into dough that had been left out resulting in fermentation of good microorganisms, which made bread with better flavour and texture. The discovery was continued where sourdough was produced as a means of reducing wastage with little known (at that point of time) beneficial effects to health. With the progress and advent of science and technology in nutrition, sourdough fermentation is now known to possess many desirable attributes in terms of health benefits. It has become the focus of attention and practice in modern healthy eating lifestyles when linked to the secret of good health. The sourdough starter is an excellent habitat where natural and wild yeast plus beneficial bacteria grow by ingesting only water and flour. As each sourdough starter is unique, with different activities, populations and interactions of yeast and bacteria due to different ingredients, environment, fermentation time and its carbohydrate fermentation pattern, there is no exact elucidation on the complete make-up of the sourdough microbiome. Some lactic acid bacteria (LAB) strains that are part of the sourdough starter are considered as probiotics which have great potential for improving gastrointestinal health. Hence, from a wide literature surveyed, this paper gives an overview of microbial communities found in different sourdough starters. This review also provides a systematic analysis that identifies, categorises and compares these microbes in the effort of linking them to specific functions, particularly to unlock their health benefits.

Diversity and dynamics of sourdough lactic acid bacteriota created by a slow food fermentation system

Sourdough is a naturally fermented dough that is used worldwide to produce a variety of baked foods. Various lactic acid bacteria (LAB), which can determine the quality of sourdough baked foods by producing metabolites, have been found in the sourdough ecosystem. However, spontaneous fermentation of sourdough leads to unpredictable growth of various micro-organisms, which result in unstable product quality. From an ecological perspective, many researchers have recently studied sourdough LAB diversity, particularly the elucidation of LAB community interactions and the dynamic mechanisms during the fermentation process, in response to requests for the control and design of a desired sourdough microbial community. This article reviews recent advances in the study of sourdough LAB diversity and its dynamics in association with unique characteristics of the fermentation system; it also discusses future perspectives for better understanding of the complex sourdough microbial ecosystem, which can be attained efficiently by both in vitro and in situ experimental approaches.