Upfront special staining for Helicobacter pylori in gastric biopsy specimens is not indicated

Improving the detection of Helicobacter pylori in biopsies of chronic gastritis: a comparative analysis of H&E, methylene blue, Warthin-Starry, immunohistochemistry, and quantum dots immunohistochemistry

Objectives

The objective of the study was to compare the consistency of various staining methods, including H&E, Methylene Blue, Warthin-Starry (W-S), Immunohistochemistry (IHC) and Quantum dots immunohistochemistry (QDs-IHC), in detecting Helicobacter pylori (HP) in cases of mild, moderate and severe chronic gastritis.

Methods

Biopsy samples were obtained from 225 patients with chronic gastritis at the Department of Pathology, Yichang Central People's Hospital between January 2019 and October 2019. The presence of HP was detected using H&E, Methylene Blue, W-S, IHC, and QDs-IHC.

Results

The positive rates for HP detection using H&E, Methylene Blue, W-S, IHC, and QDs-IHC were 42.22%, 51.11%, 53.78%, 59.11%, and 58.67%, respectively. In cases of mild chronic gastritis, the consistency of test results between H&E, Methylene Blue, W-S, and QDs-IHC with IHC were Kappa=0.196, P=0.033, Kappa=0.706, P<0.001, Kappa=0.717, P<0.001, and Kappa=0.968, P<0.001, respectively. Similarly, in cases of moderate chronic gastritis, Kappa values between H&E, Methylene Blue, W-S, and QDs-IHC with IHC were 0.356, P<0.001, 0.655, P<0.001, 0.741, P<0.001, and 0.946, P<0.001, respectively. For cases of severe chronic gastritis, the Kappa values between the staining methods and IHC were 0.271, P=0.037, 0.421, P=0.002, 0.621, P<0.001, and 1, P< 0.001, respectively.

Conclusion

The study showed that the positivity rate of IHC was significantly higher than that of H&E, Methylene Blue, and W-S in detecting HP infection in chronic gastritis cases. In terms of consistency with IHC, QDs-IHC was the most reliable staining method across all severity grades, while the agreement between H&E and IHC was poor, and that between Methylene Blue and W-S with IHC was average. Pathology departments may choose the most appropriate staining method based on their specific needs, considering the staining time, contrast, and cost of each method.

Objective Visual Analog Scale for Biopsy Diagnosis of Helicobacter pylori Infection in Clinical Practice

Historic and current pathology society guidelines recommend using visual gestalt to identify substantial inflammatory cell infiltrate in Helicobacter pylori gastritis, but these scales were subjectively designed. This study aims to objectively investigate the density of inflammation that justifies additional workup for H. pylori infection. We retrospectively identified 2 patient cohorts who had undergone endoscopy with gastric biopsies; 1 with H. pylori infection (n=66), confirmed with a positive stool antigen test and/or Campylobacter-like organism test, and 1 without infection (n=81). Antral and body biopsies were selected from each case, if available, and stained with MUM-1 to highlight mucosal plasma cells. Digital analysis was performed to calculate the number of plasma cells/mm2, termed the "inflammatory score" (IS). Patients with H. pylori infection had an average of 1289 plasma cells/mm2 in the antrum and 835 plasma cells/mm2 in the body, compared with 346 plasma cells/mm2 in the antrum and 178 plasma cells/mm2 in the body in patients without infection. IS cut-off values for a positive infection were 714 plasma cells/mm2 in the antrum and 316 plasma cells/mm2 in the body, with high sensitivities and specificities in both the antrum (92%, 92%) and body (85%, 84%), respectively. A visual analog scale was created to provide a histologic correlate of the observed IS ranges and cut-offs. This practical and objective scale is associated with a high sensitivity and specificity for diagnosing H. pylori infection and justifies moving away from upfront universal H. pylori testing in routine clinical practice.

An Update on the Role of Immunohistochemistry in the Evaluation of Gastrointestinal Tract Disorders

As in other organ systems, immunohistochemistry (IHC) serves as an ancillary diagnostic tool for a wide variety of neoplastic and non-neoplastic disorders, including infections, work-up of inflammatory conditions, and subtyping neoplasms of the gastrointestinal (GI) tract. In addition, IHC is also used to detect a variety of prognostic and predictive molecular biomarkers for carcinomas of the GI tract. The purpose of this review is to highlight the use of IHC in common diagnostic scenarios throughout the tubular GI tract. The clinical indication and guidelines for performing IHC for detecting Helicobacter pylori is discussed along with role of gastrin and neuroendocrine markers in the diagnosis of autoimmune metaplastic atrophic gastritis. The major portion of this review discusses the use of IHC in the diagnostic workup of malignant neoplasms of the GI tract, such as adenocarcinoma versus squamous cell carcinoma, workup of poorly differentiated malignant neoplasms, and evaluation of uncommon gastric neoplasms (alpha-feto protein-producing carcinomas) and switch/sucrose-nonfermenting complex-deficient carcinomas. Lastly, localization of neuroendocrine tumors of unknown origin to aid clinical management, as well as HPV-driven anal neoplasia and IHC in the workup of basaloid anal neoplasms are also reviewed.

Utilization Rate of Helicobacter pylori Immunohistochemistry Is Not Associated With the Diagnostic Rate of Helicobacter pylori Infection

BACKGROUND

Utilization rates of immunohistochemistry (IHC) for the diagnosis of Helicobacter pylori infection may vary by laboratory and/or pathologists. IHC for H. pylori is not performed routinely in our practice. Instead, it is used in selected cases at the pathologists' discretion (and according to their specific criteria). The purpose of this study was to determine if IHC utilization rates correlated with rates of detecting H. pylori infection.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We searched our records and investigated all gastric biopsies for 1 calendar year. H. pylori diagnostic rate and IHC utilization rate was calculated for each pathologist.

RESULTS

Overall, the rate of diagnosis was 12.1% and the IHC utilization rate was 45.2%. Individual pathologists had H. pylori diagnostic rates ranging from 3.6% to 34.1% (median: 11.1%) and IHC utilization ranging from 17.1% to 95.2% (median: 42.2%). The rate of detection of H. pylori infection among pathologists showed no significant correlation with rates of IHC utilization (Pearson coefficient=0.121).

CONCLUSIONS

Increasing use of IHC is not independently associated with the diagnostic rate of infection. Ultimately, if we assume that the case mix was similar for each pathologist, it suggests that more liberal criteria to order IHC does not result in more infections diagnosed.

Pathologic Features of Infectious Gastritis

This manuscript presents a review of infectious causes of gastritis aimed at the practicing anatomic pathologist. We shall highlight unique histologic findings and clinical attributes that will assist those analyzing endoscopically obtained mucosal biopsies of the stomach or resection specimens.

Routine Anti-Helicobacter Immunohistochemical Staining is Significantly Superior to Reflex Staining Protocols for the Detection of Helicobacter in Gastric Biopsy Specimens

BACKGROUND

The role of special stains in the detection of H. pylori is controversial; some pathologists claim that hematoxylin and eosin staining alone is adequate to detect bacteria, while others maintain that immunohistochemical staining must be used on all gastric biopsies. This study was designed to test the hypothesis that hematoxylin and eosin and histochemical special stains have similar sensitivity and that immunohistochemical staining only marginally enhances the detection rate of the organisms.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Records of all gastric biopsies examined in a large pathology laboratory between January 1, 2010 and December 31, 2014 were extracted and stratified according to the stain used for the detection of Helicobacter (1. hematoxylin and eosin only; 2. Upfront HP Blue; 3. Upfront HP Blue including reflex immunohistochemistry; 4. Upfront anti-Helicobacter immunohistochemical staining.

RESULTS

Gastric biopsies from 794,859 endoscopies obtained from 622,945 unique patients were analyzed. The basic demographics of the patients in different staining groups were identical. A total of 56,955 gastric biopsy sets were stained with histochemical stains only, and 731,193 with anti-Helicobacter immunohistochemical stain; in 4409 of these, an immunohistochemical stain was also performed. In 2302 cases, only hematoxylin and eosin were performed. In this latter group, 7.0% of patients were Helicobacter-positive; in the upfront HP Blue, the prevalence was 7.8%, whereas patients with upfront immunohistochemistry had a prevalence of 10.2% (p < .0001, compared to hematoxylin and eosin only).

CONCLUSIONS

There was a dramatic improvement in detection of H. pylori infection through the use of upfront immunohistochemical stains. Therefore, we contend that the routine use of IHC for all gastric biopsies is an appropriate protocol to ensure that every patient gets the right answer.

A Strategy for Helicobacter Immunohistochemistry Utilization in Pediatric Practice: Insights From Morphologic and Cost-Benefit Analyses

OBJECTIVES

Recent studies in adults have examined the utility of immunohistochemistry (IHC) in detecting Helicobacter in gastric biopsy specimens and reached differing conclusions. Dedicated cost-benefit analysis of Helicobacter IHC in pediatric gastric biopsy specimens has not been performed.

METHODS

From 1,955 pediatric gastric biopsies in a 1-year period, we identified 63 Helicobacter -positive and 120 Helicobacter -negative biopsy specimens. All cases were scored according to the Updated Sydney System for the severity of inflammation.

RESULTS

We observed that pediatric Helicobacter infection was significantly associated with germinal center formation, active inflammation, oxyntic mucosa with moderate to severe chronic inflammation, and antral mucosa with any chronic inflammation, exclusive of mild and superficial chronic inflammation. At least one associated pattern was seen in each Helicobacter -positive biopsy specimen. In comparison with adults, pediatric Helicobacter -positive biopsy specimens are more likely to lack acute inflammation and more likely to show moderate to marked chronic inflammation.

CONCLUSIONS

We recommend performing Helicobacter IHC on pediatric gastric biopsy specimens with any of the above inflammatory patterns. This approach can sensitively identify pediatric patients with Helicobacter gastritis, limit IHC staining to approximately 30% of all gastric biopsy specimens, and reduce costs by up to $55,306.90 per 1,000 biopsy specimens.

Factors Associated With Detection of Helicobacter pylori in Gastric Biopsies: A Case-Control Study of 396 Biopsies

AIM OF THE STUDY

Helicobacter pylori (HP) infection is associated with significant gastric mucosal inflammation. We aimed to determine the clinicopathologic features associated with HP in gastric biopsy.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Three hundred ninety-six gastric biopsies were evaluated including 165 HP-positive cases and 231 randomly selected HP-negative controls. HP was detected using hematoxylin and eosin (H&E), Giemsa, and immunohistochemistry staining. The univariate and multivariate analyses were conducted to study the relationship of clinicopathologic characteristics and HP infection. Among the HP-positive cases, 131 cases were confirmed by H&E staining and 34 cases were confirmed by Giemsa or immunohistochemistry staining. Compared with chronic inactive gastritis, chronic active gastritis was more likely associated with having HP detected by H&E. Males were more likely to have HP gastritis than females (odds ratio: 1.72, P=0.01). The patients who had chronic active gastritis or chronic gastritis (moderate or severe) were more likely to have HP infection than patients with mild chronic gastritis (P<0.001). Conversely, patients who had intestinal metaplasia were less likely to have HP infection than patients without intestinal metaplasia (odds ratio: 0.22, P<0.001). However, concurrent atrophic gastritis was not related to HP infection (P=0.37). HP infection history was not associated with HP infection (P=0.74).

CONCLUSIONS

HP detection in gastric biopsies is associated with active inflammation, male sex, and the lack of intestinal metaplasia, but not atrophic gastritis or HP infection history. Routine ancillary staining may not be required for HP detection in all biopsy specimens. We do not recommend ancillary staining for mild chronic inactive gastritis.

Epidemiology and Diagnosis of Helicobacter pylori infection

During the period reviewed, prevalence studies were essentially performed in less economically advanced countries and a high prevalence was found. The traditional risk factors for Helicobacter pylori positivity were mostly found. Transmission studied by molecular typing showed a familial transmission. The eventual role of water transmission was explored in several studies with controversial results. Concerning diagnosis, most of the invasive and noninvasive methods used for the diagnosis of H. pylori infection are long standing with efficient performance. The most interesting recent improvements in H. pylori diagnosis include advances in endoscopy, developments in molecular methods, and the introduction of omics-based techniques. Interpretation of old or newer method should take into account the pretest probability and the prevalence of H. pylori in the population under investigation.

Diagnosis of Helicobacter pylori Infection in the Proton Pump Inhibitor Era

Proton pump inhibitors (PPI) are a major cause of false-negative Helicobacter pylori test results. Detecting PPI use and stopping it 2 weeks before testing is the preferred approach to improve the reliability of H pylori diagnostic tests. Immunoblot and molecular methods may be useful for the detection of H pylori infection in difficult cases. When conventional tests are negative and eradication is strongly indicated, empirical H pylori treatment should be considered. In this article, an updated critical review of the usefulness of the various invasive and noninvasive tests in the context of extensive PPI use is provided.

Helicobacter infections with rare bacteria or minimal gastritis: Expecting the unexpected

BACKGROUND

The routine use of special stains for detection of Helicobacter remains controversial.

AIMS

To determine the frequency of histologically atypical Helicobacter infection.

METHODS

All gastric biopsies received at a large pathology reference laboratory over a 6-month period were stained for Helicobacter, and the histologic and clinicopathologic parameters evaluated.

RESULTS

Amongst 7663 Helicobacter-positive biopsies, 823 (10.7%) did not show typical chronic active gastritis with numerous Helicobacter organisms, and were therefore considered histologically atypical. Rare Helicobacter pylori organisms accounted for 58.0% of all atypical infections; the next most common atypical Helicobacter infection was that with minimal or no gastric inflammation (23.3% of atypical infections). Patients in these groups did not differ demographically from those with other forms of atypical or typical Helicobacter infection, although a small subgroup (6%) was more likely to have had a previously treated infection.

CONCLUSIONS

In many of these atypical infections, Helicobacter would not have been suspected based on the histologic findings alone, and would have been missed without routine special stains. Performing a sensitive stain could prevent additional testing and allow prompt treatment of the affected patients, thus substantially reducing the risk for peptic ulcer and gastric cancer and preventing the transmission of the infection to family members.