A syndemic born of war: Combining intersectionality and structural violence to explore the biosocial interactions of neglected tropical diseases, disability and mental distress in Liberia

'The Lost Peace': Evidencing the Syndemic Relationship between Neglected Tropical Diseases and Mental Distress in Liberia

Neglected Tropical Diseases (NTDs) are a group of chronic infectious diseases of poverty affecting over one billion people globally. Intersections of NTDs, disability, and mental ill-health are increasingly evidenced but are rarely studied from a mixed-methods perspective. Here, we advance syndemic understandings by further assessing and contextualising the syndemic relationship between NTDs (particularly their associated disability) and mental distress in Liberia. Participatory qualitative methods, including body mapping (56 participants), social mapping (28 participants), and in-depth interviews (12) provided space for persons affected by NTDs to narrate their experiences. Simultaneously, 201 surveys explored experiences of common mental health conditions among persons affected by skin NTDs. An intersectionality approach was applied within the analysis for both qualitative and quantitative methods informed by Meyer's minority stress model, adapted for NTDs. Qualitative data was analysed thematically and gender-disaggregated, univariable and multivariable analyses were applied to survey data for the outcome measures depression (PHQ-9) and anxiety (GAD-7). Disability was associated with higher levels of depression and anxiety (p < 0.001). An interaction between disability and being a women increased incidence risk ratio of depression (p < 0.001). In alignment with qualitative findings, persons affected experienced additional generalised (financial concerns), external (experience of stigma) and internal (experience of pain and physical symptoms) minority stressors, to varying degrees, which contributed towards their mental distress, and mental health conditions. These findings were used to co-develop a syndemic-informed person-centred health system response to address the suffering associated with NTDs and mental distress, including a focus on strengthening relationships between formal and informal community health actors and the broader health system.

Addressing the Syndemic Relationship between Lymphatic Filariasis and Mental Distress in Malawi: The Potential of Enhanced Self-Care

Lymphatic filariasis (LF) causes disfiguring and disabling lymphoedema, which can lead to mental distress and requires life-long self-care treatment. This study applies syndemic theory to understand the biosocial relationship between LF and mental distress in Malawi. Using in-depth qualitative methods, we critically evaluate experiences of mental distress and LF through 21 life-history interviews, to narrate experiences from the perspective of persons affected by LF, and to understand how enhanced self-care (ESC) for lymphoedema management disrupts the syndemic relationship. Complementary key informant interviews with Ministry of Health LF programme staff were conducted to further understand intervention and health system delivery. All interviews were recorded, transcribed, and translated, and then subject to thematic analysis. Our findings suggest that for persons affected by LF in Malawi, before being trained in ESC, absent referral pathways, inequalities in healthcare provision or available treatment, and limited knowledge of the condition (LF) drove the syndemic of LF and mental distress. Distress was often exacerbated by stigma and social exclusion, and shaped by intersections of gender, generation, poverty, and extreme climate conditions. We argue that addressing the syndemic suffering associated with LF and mental distress through interventions which center the needs of persons affected is critical in effective and equitable LF care delivery.

Participatory development of a community mental wellbeing support package for people affected by skin neglected tropical diseases in the Kasai province, Democratic Republic of Congo

BACKGROUND

Skin neglected tropical diseases (NTDs) produce signs and symptoms that are often physically challenging, stigmatizing and have a negative impact on the mental wellbeing of people affected. In the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), little is known about the mental wellbeing experiences of people affected by skin NTDs and support is lacking. We collaborated with ongoing NTD programs, the Ministry of Health and people affected to evidence experiences and opportunities for change and co-developed a mental wellbeing support package for people affected and local health system actors.

METHODS

This implementation research study used the photovoice method alongside key-informant interviews to evidence mental wellbeing challenges in people affected by skin NTDs and explore opportunities for change. These were used to co-develop a skin NTD mental wellbeing support package with people affected, community members and local health system actors through a participatory workshop.

RESULTS

Stigma, discrimination, decreased livelihoods and mental wellbeing challenges were evidenced by people affected by skin NTDs, their communities and health system actors. Participants identified and co-established community-led peer support groups, strengthened with basic knowledge on psychosocial support, and income-generating or recreational initiatives to support mental wellbeing of people affected by skin NTDs.

CONCLUSIONS

Co-developing a support package with persons affected, community members and health system actors is a step towards holistic care for people affected by skin NTDs and promotes uptake and ownership of intervention components.

CONTEXTE

Les maladies tropicales négligées (MTN) cutanées produisent des signes et des symptômes qui sont souvent difficiles à supporter physiquement, ils sont également stigmatisants et ont un impact négatif sur le bien-être mental des personnes touchées. En République Démocratique du Congo (RDC), on sait peu de choses sur le bien-être mental des personnes atteintes de MTN cutanées, et le soutien fait défaut. Nous avons collaboré avec les programmes de lutte contre les MTN en cours, le ministère de la santé et les personnes touchées pour mettre en évidence les expériences et les possibilités de changement, et nous avons élaboré un programme de soutien au bien-être mental pour les personnes touchées et les acteurs du système de santé local.

MÉTHODES UTILISÉES

Cette étude de recherche sur la mise en œuvre a utilisé la méthode photovoice, ainsi que des entretiens avec des informateurs clés, afin de mettre en évidence les problèmes de bien-être mental des personnes touchées par les MNT cutanées. Ces éléments ont été utilisés pour élaborer un programme de soutien au bien-être mental des MNT cutanées avec les personnes concernées, les membres de la communauté et les acteurs du système de santé local dans le cadre d'un atelier participatif.

RÉSULTATS

La stigmatisation, la discrimination, la diminution des moyens de subsistance et les problèmes de bien-être mental ont été mis en évidence par les personnes atteintes de MTN cutanées, leurs communautés et les acteurs du système de santé. Les participants ont identifié et mis en place des groupes communautaires de soutien par les pairs, renforcés par des connaissances de base en matière de soutien psychosocial, et des initiatives génératrices de revenus/récréatives pour soutenir le bien-être mental des personnes touchées par les MTN cutanées.

CONCLUSIONS

L'élaboration d'un ensemble de mesures de soutien en collaboration avec les personnes concernées, les membres de la communauté et les acteurs du système de santé, constitue une étape vers une prise en charge holistique des personnes atteintes de MNT cutanées et favorise l'adoption et l'appropriation des composantes de l'intervention.

ANTECEDENTES

Las enfermedades tropicales desatendidas (ETDs) cutáneas producen signos y síntomas que a menudo suponen un reto físico, estigmatizan y tienen un impacto negativo en el bienestar mental de las personas afectadas. En la República Democrática del Congo (RDC), se sabe poco sobre las experiencias de bienestar mental de las personas afectadas por ETDs cutáneas, y falta apoyo. Colaboramos con los programas en curso sobre las ETDs, el Ministerio de Sanidad y las personas afectadas para poner de manifiesto las experiencias y las oportunidades de cambio, y desarrollamos de manera conjunta un paquete de apoyo al bienestar mental para las personas afectadas y los agentes del sistema sanitario local.

MÉTODOS

Este estudio de investigación utilizó el método fotovoz, junto con entrevistas a informantes clave, para poner de manifiesto los desafíos de bienestar mental de las personas afectadas por ETDs cutáneas y explorar las oportunidades de cambio. Estos datos se utilizaron para desarrollar un paquete de apoyo al bienestar mental de manera conjunta con las personas afectadas por las ETDs cutáneas, los miembros de la comunidad y los actores del sistema sanitario local a través de un taller participativo.

RESULTADOS

El estigma, la discriminación, la disminución de los medios de subsistencia y los problemas de bienestar mental fueron evidenciados por las personas afectadas por ETD cutáneas, sus comunidades y los agentes del sistema sanitario. Los participantes identificaron y establecieron conjuntamente grupos de apoyo entre pares dirigidos por la comunidad, fortalecidos con conocimientos básicos sobre apoyo psicosocial e iniciativasrecreativas y generadoras de ingresos para apoyar el bienestar mental de las personas afectadas por las ETD cutáneas.

CONCLUSIÓNS

El desarrollo conjunto de un paquete de medidas de apoyo con las personas afectadas, los miembros de la comunidad y los actores del sistema sanitario es un paso hacia la atención holística de las personas afectadas por las NTDs a y promueve la adopción y apropiación de los componentes de la intervención.

Mass drug administration for neglected tropical disease control and elimination: a systematic review of ethical reasons

BACKGROUND

Neglected tropical diseases (NTDs) are a diverse group of debilitating diseases and conditions afflicting more than one billion people in impoverished communities. Control of these diseases is crucial to achieve Sustainable Development Goal 3 and the pledge to 'leave no one behind'. Relying on large-scale delivery of wide-spectrum drugs to individuals in at-risk communities irrespective of their health status, mass drug administration is a core strategy for tackling half of the NTDs targeted by the latest WHO roadmap (2021-2030). However, ethical challenges surround its implementation and long-term impact. This systematic review aims to give a comprehensive picture of the variety of ethical reasons for and against mass drug administration for NTD control and elimination, facilitating further debate in ethics and policy.

METHODS

PubMed and Web of Science Core Collection were searched for all relevant publications. Of the 486 retrieved records, 60 met the inclusion criteria for qualitative analysis. Ethical reasons discussing the topic at hand were extracted from full texts and synthesised through the Kuckartz method of qualitative content analysis.

RESULTS

Data extraction revealed 61 ethical reasons, of which 20 (32.7%) had positive, 13 (21.3%) had ambivalent and 28 (45.9%) had negative implications regarding mass drug administration for NTDs. The health benefits and cost-effectiveness of the measure were extensively highlighted. However, equity, autonomy and sustainability emerged as the domains with the most pressing ethical concerns. Many issues related to implementation are yet to be adequately addressed in policy documents.

CONCLUSIONS

This is the first systematic review of ethical reasons pertaining to mass drug administration for NTD control and elimination. Due to the diversity of included studies, no general recommendations can be made. Instead, context-specific strategies seem necessary. Alternative approaches tackling socioecological determinants of ill health are needed for long-term sustainability. Future research could benefit from contributions of non-Western philosophies and perspectives by local researchers.

Mental health, stigma and the quality of life of people affected by neglected tropical diseases of the skin in Kasai Province, Democratic Republic of the Congo: a sex-disaggregated analysis

BACKGROUND

Worldwide, persons affected by skin Neglected Tropical Diseases (NTDs) may experience stigma and discrimination, which could lead to impaired societal functioning and poor mental wellbeing. Evidence of comorbidity of NTDs and mental health conditions is dominated by Leprosy, largely lacking in post-conflict areas, and rarely disaggregated by sex.

METHODS

This cross-sectional survey is the first to explore depression, anxiety, stigma, and quality of life amongst people affected by Lymphatic Filariasis, Buruli Ulcer, Onchocerciasis or Leprosy in the Democratic Republic of the Congo. After a census through active case identification, the survey was completed by 118 persons (response rate 94.4%).

RESULTS

In total, 58.3% of men and 80.0% of women screened positive for major depressive disorder (PHQ-9). Symptoms indicative of generalised anxiety disorder (GAD-7) were displayed by 54.8% of men and 62.2% of women. Being female, having a disability, experiencing stigma and lower physical quality of life were predictors of depression. Anxiety was predicted by age, physical quality of life, disability (for men only) and environmental quality of life (for women only).

CONCLUSIONS

Integrated, intersectoral and gender-sensitive initiatives are needed to respond to the many biopsychosocial challenges that persons affected face.

CONTEXTE

Dans le monde entier, les personnes atteintes de maladies tropicales négligées (MTN) peuvent faire l'objet d'une stigmatisation et d'une discrimination, ce qui peut entraîner une altération du fonctionnement de la société et un mauvais bien-être mental. Les preuves de la comorbidité des MTN et des troubles de la santé mentale sont dominées par la lèpre, manquent largement dans les zones post-conflit et sont rarement ventilées par sexe.

MÉTHODES UTILISÉES

Cette enquête transversale est la première à explorer la dépression, l'anxiété, la stigmatisation et la qualité de vie chez les personnes atteintes de filariose lymphatique, d'ulcère de Buruli, d'onchocercose ou de lèpre en République démocratique du Congo. Après un recensement par identification active des cas, 118 personnes ont répondu à l'enquête (taux de réponse 94,4%).

RÉSULTATS

Au total, 58,3% des hommes et 80,0% des femmes ont été dépistés positifs pour un trouble dépressif majeur (PHQ-9). Des symptômes indiquant un trouble anxieux généralisé (GAD-7) ont été observés chez 54,8 % des hommes et 62,2 % des femmes. Le fait d'être une femme, d'avoir un handicap, d'être stigmatisé et d'avoir une qualité de vie physique inférieure était un facteur prédictif de la dépression. L'anxiété était prédite par l'âge, la qualité de vie physique, le handicap (pour les hommes uniquement) et la qualité de vie environnementale (pour les femmes uniquement).

CONCLUSIONS

Des initiatives intégrées, intersectorielles et sensibles au genre sont nécessaires pour répondre aux nombreux défis biopsychosociaux auxquels sont confrontées les personnes touchées.

ANTECEDENTES

En todo el mundo, las personas afectadas por Enfermedades Tropicales Desatendidas (ETD) cutáneas pueden sufrir estigmatización y discriminación, lo que podría conducir a un deterioro del funcionamiento social y a un bienestar mental deficiente. La evidencia científica sobre la comorbilidad de las ETD y las afecciones mentales está dominada por la lepra, en general insuficiente en zonas post-conflicto y rara vez se desglosan por sexo.

MÉTODOS

Esta encuesta transversal es la primera que explora la depresión, la ansiedad, el estigma y la calidad de vida entre las personas afectadas por la filariasis linfática, la úlcera de Buruli, la oncocercosis o la lepra en la República Democrática del Congo. Tras un censo mediante identificación activa de casos, la encuesta fue completada por 118 personas (tasa de respuesta del 94,4%).

RESULTADOS

En total, el 58,3% de los hombres y el 80,0% de las mujeres arrojaron resultados positivos para el trastorno depresivo mayor (PHQ-9). El 54,8% de los hombres y el 62,2% de las mujeres presentaban síntomas indicativos de trastorno de ansiedad generalizada (TAG-7). Ser mujer, tener una discapacidad, sufrir estigmatización y una menor calidad de vida física fueron factores predictivos de la depresión. La edad, la calidad de vida física, la discapacidad (sólo en el caso de los hombres) y la calidad de vida ambiental (sólo en el caso de las mujeres) fueron factores predictivos de la ansiedad.

CONCLUSIONES

Se necesitan iniciativas integradas, intersectoriales y con perspectiva de género para responder a los numerosos retos biopsicosociales a los que se enfrentan las personas afectadas.