Repeat length and RNA expression level are not primary determinants in CUG expansion toxicity in Drosophila models

In vivo strategies for drug discovery in myotonic dystrophy disorders

Myotonic dystrophy (DM) is a complex neuromuscular genetic disease for which there is currently no valid therapy. The recent development of non-mammal animal models opened up the possibility of performing drug discovery in vivo, using as screening readout phenotypes with underlying molecular parallels to the disease. In this review we discuss the state of the art technologies already used in large scale drug screening and provide guidance for further development of novel technologies.

Distinct roles for Toll and autophagy pathways in double-stranded RNA toxicity in a Drosophila model of expanded repeat neurodegenerative diseases

Dominantly inherited expanded repeat neurodegenerative diseases are caused by the expansion of variable copy number tandem repeat sequences in otherwise unrelated genes. Some repeats encode polyglutamine that is thought to be toxic; however, other repeats do not encode polyglutamine indicating either multiple pathogenic pathways or an alternative common toxic agent. As these diseases share numerous clinical features and expanded repeat RNA is a common intermediary, RNA-based pathogenesis has been proposed, based on its toxicity in animal models. In Drosophila, double-stranded (rCAG.rCUG∼100) RNA toxicity is Dicer dependent and generates single-stranded (rCAG)7, an entity also detected in affected Huntington's Disease (HD) brains. We demonstrate that Drosophila rCAG.rCUG∼100 RNA toxicity perturbs several pathways including innate immunity, consistent with the observation in HD that immune activation precedes neuronal toxicity. Our results show that Drosophila rCAG.rCUG∼100 RNA toxicity is dependent upon Toll signaling and sensitive to autophagy, further implicating innate immune activation. In exhibiting molecular and cellular hallmarks of HD, double-stranded RNA-mediated activation of innate immunity is, therefore, a candidate pathway for this group of human genetic diseases.

RNA toxicity in human disease and animal models: from the uncovering of a new mechanism to the development of promising therapies

Mutant ribonucleic acid (RNA) molecules can be toxic to the cell, causing human disease through trans-acting dominant mechanisms. RNA toxicity was first described in myotonic dystrophy type 1, a multisystemic disorder caused by the abnormal expansion of a non-coding trinucleotide repeat sequence. The development of multiple and complementary animal models of disease has greatly contributed to clarifying the complex disease pathways mediated by toxic RNA molecules. RNA toxicity is not limited to myotonic dystrophy and spreads to an increasing number of human conditions, which share some unifying pathogenic events mediated by toxic RNA accumulation and disruption of RNA-binding proteins. The remarkable progress in the dissection of disease pathobiology resulted in the rational design of molecular therapies, which have been successfully tested in animal models. Toxic RNA diseases, and in particular myotonic dystrophy, clearly illustrate the critical contribution of animal models of disease in translational research: from gene mutation to disease mechanisms, and ultimately to therapy development. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Animal Models of Disease.

RNA Foci, CUGBP1, and ZNF9 are the primary targets of the mutant CUG and CCUG repeats expanded in myotonic dystrophies type 1 and type 2

Expansions of noncoding CUG and CCUG repeats in myotonic dystrophies type 1 (DM1) and DM2 cause complex molecular pathology, the features of which include accumulation of RNA aggregates and misregulation of the RNA-binding proteins muscleblind-like 1 (MBNL1) and CUG-binding protein 1 (CUGBP1). CCUG repeats also decrease amounts of the nucleic acid binding protein ZNF9. Using tetracycline (Tet)-regulated monoclonal cell models that express CUG and CCUG repeats, we found that low levels of long CUG and CCUG repeats result in nuclear and cytoplasmic RNA aggregation with a simultaneous increase of CUGBP1 and a reduction of ZNF9. Elevation of CUGBP1 and reduction of ZNF9 were also observed before strong aggregation of the mutant CUG/CCUG repeats. Degradation of CUG and CCUG repeats normalizes ZNF9 and CUGBP1 levels. Comparison of short and long CUG and CCUG RNAs showed that great expression of short repeats form foci and alter CUGBP1 and ZNF9; however, long CUG/CCUG repeats misregulate CUGBP1 and ZNF9 much faster than high levels of the short repeats. These data suggest that correction of DM1 and DM2 might be achieved by complete and efficient degradation of CUG and CCUG repeats or by a simultaneous disruption of CUG/CCUG foci and correction of CUGBP1 and ZNF9.

Cellular toxicity of expanded RNA repeats: focus on RNA foci

Discrete and punctate nuclear RNA foci are characteristic molecular hallmarks of pathogenesis in myotonic dystrophy type 1 and type 2. Intranuclear RNA inclusions of distinct morphology have also been found in fragile X-associated tremor ataxia syndrome, Huntington's disease-like 2, spinocerebellar ataxias type 8, type 10 and type 31. These neurological diseases are associated with the presence of abnormally long simple repeat expansions in their respective genes whose expression leads to the formation of flawed transcripts with altered metabolisms. Expanded CUG, CCUG, CGG, CAG, AUUCU and UGGAA repeats are associated with the diseases and accumulate in nuclear foci, as demonstrated in variety of cells and tissues of human and model organisms. These repeat RNA foci differ in size, shape, cellular abundance and protein composition and their formation has a negative impact on cellular functions. This review summarizes the efforts of many laboratories over the past 15 years to characterize nuclear RNA foci that are recognized as important triggers in the mutant repeat RNA toxic gain-of-function mechanisms of pathogenesis in neurological disorders.

Double-stranded RNA is pathogenic in Drosophila models of expanded repeat neurodegenerative diseases

The pathogenic agent responsible for the expanded repeat diseases, a group of neurodegenerative diseases that includes Huntington's disease is not yet fully understood. Expanded polyglutamine (polyQ) is thought to be the toxic agent in certain cases, however, not all expanded repeat disease genes can encode a polyQ sequence. Since a repeat-containing RNA intermediary is common to all of these diseases, hairpin-forming single-stranded RNA has been investigated as a potential common pathogenic agent. More recently, it has become apparent that most of the expanded repeat disease loci have transcription occurring from both strands, raising the possibility that the complementary repeat RNAs could form a double-stranded structure. In our investigation using Drosophila models of these diseases, we identified a fortuitous integration event that models bidirectional repeat RNA transcription with the resultant flies exhibiting inducible pathology. We therefore established further lines of Drosophila expressing independent complementary repeat RNAs and found that these are toxic. The Dicer pathway is essential for this toxicity and in neuronal cells accounts for metabolism of the high copy number (CAG.CUG)(100) double-stranded RNAs down to (CAG)(7) single-stranded small RNAs. We also observe significant changes to the microRNA profile in neurons. These data identify a novel pathway through which double-stranded repeat RNA is toxic and capable of eliciting symptoms common to neurodegenerative human diseases resulting from dominantly inherited expanded repeats.

Muscleblind participates in RNA toxicity of expanded CAG and CUG repeats in Caenorhabditis elegans

We have utilized Caenorhabditis elegans as a model to investigate the toxicity and underlying mechanism of untranslated CAG repeats in comparison to CUG repeats. Our results indicate that CAG repeats can be toxic at the RNA level in a length-dependent manner, similar to that of CUG repeats. Both CAG and CUG repeats of toxic length form nuclear foci and co-localize with C. elegans muscleblind (CeMBL), implying that CeMBL may play a role in repeat RNA toxicity. Consistently, the phenotypes of worms expressing toxic CAG and CUG repeats, including shortened life span and reduced motility rate, were partially reversed by CeMbl over-expression. These results provide the first experimental evidence to show that the RNA toxicity induced by expanded CAG and CUG repeats can be mediated, at least in part, through the functional alteration of muscleblind in worms.

Neurodegenerative models in Drosophila: polyglutamine disorders, Parkinson disease, and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis

Neurodegenerative diseases encompass a large group of neurological disorders. Clinical symptoms can include memory loss, cognitive impairment, loss of movement or loss of control of movement, and loss of sensation. Symptoms are typically adult onset (although severe cases can occur in adolescents) and are reflective of neuronal and glial cell loss in the central nervous system. Neurodegenerative diseases also are considered progressive, with increased severity of symptoms over time, also reflective of increased neuronal cell death. However, various neurodegenerative diseases differentially affect certain brain regions or neuronal or glial cell types. As an example, Alzheimer disease (AD) primarily affects the temporal lobe, whereas neuronal loss in Parkinson disease (PD) is largely (although not exclusively) confined to the nigrostriatal system. Neuronal loss is almost invariably accompanied by abnormal insoluble aggregates, either intra- or extracellular. Thus, neurodegenerative diseases are categorized by (a) the composite of clinical symptoms, (b) the brain regions or types of brain cells primarily affected, and (c) the types of protein aggregates found in the brain. Here we review the methods by which Drosophila melanogaster has been used to model aspects of polyglutamine diseases, Parkinson disease, and amyotrophic lateral sclerosis and key insights into that have been gained from these models; Alzheimer disease and the tauopathies are covered elsewhere in this special issue.

Myotonic dystrophies 1 and 2: complex diseases with complex mechanisms

Two multi-system disorders, Myotonic Dystrophies type 1 and type 2 (DM1 and DM2), are complex neuromuscular diseases caused by an accumulation of expanded, non-coding RNAs, containing repetitive CUG and CCUG elements. Similarities of these mutations suggest similar mechanisms for both diseases. The expanded CUGn and CCUGn RNAs mainly target two RNA binding proteins, MBNL1 and CUGBP1, elevating levels of CUGBP1 and reducing levels of MBNL1. These alterations change processing of RNAs that are regulated by these proteins. Whereas overall toxicity of CUGn/CCUGn RNAs on RNA homeostasis in DM cells has been proven, the mechanisms which make these RNAs toxic remain illusive. A current view is that the toxicity of RNA CUGn and CCUGn is associated exclusively with global mis-splicing in DM patients. However, a growing number of new findings show that the expansion of CUGn and CCUGn RNAs mis-regulates several additional pathways in nuclei and cytoplasm of cells from patients with DM1 and DM2. The purpose of this review is to discuss the similarities and differences in the clinical presentation and molecular genetics of both diseases. We will also discuss the complexity of the molecular abnormalities in DM1 and DM2 caused by CUG and CCUG repeats and will summarize the outcomes of the toxicity of CUG and CCUG repeats.

Cytoplasmic CUG RNA foci are insufficient to elicit key DM1 features

The genetic basis of myotonic dystrophy type I (DM1) is the expansion of a CTG tract located in the 3′ untranslated region of DMPK. Expression of mutant RNAs encoding expanded CUG repeats plays a central role in the development of cardiac disease in DM1. Expanded CUG tracts form both nuclear and cytoplasmic aggregates, yet the relative significance of such aggregates in eliciting DM1 pathology is unclear. To test the pathophysiology of CUG repeat encoding RNAs, we developed and analyzed mice with cardiac-specific expression of a beta-galactosidase cassette in which a (CTG)₄₀₀ repeat tract was positioned 3′ of the termination codon and 5′ of the bovine growth hormone polyadenylation signal. In these animals CUG aggregates form exclusively in the cytoplasm of cardiac cells. A key pathological consequence of expanded CUG repeat RNA expression in DM1 is aberrant RNA splicing. Abnormal splicing results from the functional inactivation of MBNL1, which is hypothesized to occur due to MBNL1 sequestration in CUG foci or from elevated levels of CUG-BP1. We therefore tested the ability of cytoplasmic CUG foci to elicit these changes. Aggregation of CUG RNAs within the cytoplasm results both in Mbnl1 sequestration and in approximately a two fold increase in both nuclear and cytoplasmic Cug-bp1 levels. Significantly, despite these changes RNA splice defects were not observed and functional analysis revealed only subtle cardiac dysfunction, characterized by conduction defects that primarily manifest under anesthesia. Using a human myoblast culture system we show that this transgene, when expressed at similar levels to a second transgene, which encodes expanded CTG tracts and facilitates both nuclear focus formation and aberrant splicing, does not elicit aberrant splicing. Thus the lack of toxicity of cytoplasmic CUG foci does not appear to be a consequence of low expression levels. Our results therefore demonstrate that the cellular location of CUG RNA aggregates is an important variable that influences toxicity and support the hypothesis that small molecules that increase the rate of transport of the mutant DMPK RNA from the nucleus into the cytoplasm may significantly improve DM1 pathology.

Neurodegeneration: RNA turns number one suspect in polyglutamine diseases

Polyglutamine expansion diseases are triggered by the accumulation of toxic proteins. A new study reports that RNA molecules containing long CAG repeats can also be toxic to neurons and may play a significant role in pathogenesis.

The RNA-binding protein CUGBP1 regulates stability of tumor necrosis factor mRNA in muscle cells: implications for myotonic dystrophy

Type I myotonic dystrophy (DM1) is caused by a triplet repeat expansion in the 3'-untranslated region (UTR) of the dystrophia myotonia protein kinase (DMPK) gene. Pathogenesis is closely linked with production of a toxic RNA from the mutant allele, which interferes with function of several RNA-binding proteins, including CUGBP1. Here we show that expression of a mutant DMPK 3'-UTR containing 960 CUG repeats is sufficient to increase expression and stability of an mRNA encoding the potent proinflammatory cytokine, tumor necrosis factor (TNF). CUGBP1 specifically recognizes sequences within the TNF 3'-UTR that are dissimilar from its canonical UG-rich binding site. Depletion of CUGBP1 from mouse myoblasts results in increased abundance of TNF mRNA through stabilization of the transcript. Moreover, activation of the protein kinase C pathway by treatment with phorbol ester, which has been shown previously to result in CUGBP1 phosphorylation, also causes TNF mRNA stabilization. Our results suggest that the elevated serum TNF seen in DM1 patients may be derived from muscle where it is induced by expression of toxic DMPK RNA. Importantly, overexpression of this potent cytokine could contribute to the muscle wasting and insulin resistance that are characteristic of this debilitating disease.