Embryos in the fast lane: high-temperature heart rates of turtles decline after hatching

Morphological and transcriptomic analyses of embryonic development of red-eared slider Trachemys scripta elegans

Embryology provides an understanding of individual's origin and developmental patterns. Turtles are among the oldest living reptiles and have unique body structure. However, the morphogenesis and mechanisms of turtles are not fully understood. In this study, we focused on the embryonic development of red-eared slider (Trachemys scripta elegans) which widely distributes in the world. At an incubation temperature of 28 °C, the turtle eggs had a 61-day incubation cycle, and the entire embryonic development process was divided into 27 stages and 3 phases according to variations in age, body size, and morphological characteristics. The early phase of embryonic development (the first 12 stages) were characterized by embryo growth, and the appearance of internal organ precursors. The middle phase (stages 13-20) involved prominent heart division at stage 13 and the appearance of carapace and plastron at stages 14 and 17, respectively. In the later phase (stages 21-27), the hatchlings formed, and the carapace and plastron thickened. Transcriptome analysis of embryos showed enrichment of the differential genes in pathways related to development, metabolism, disease, and cellular processes. The Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes enrichment (KEGG) analysis implied the crucial regulatory role of the axon guidance pathway. Real-time fluorescence quantitative PCR indicated upregulated expression of wnt5a and bmp7 in stages 7 and 16 compared to that in stage 12. This study revealed the development process of red-eared slider embryo and the dynamics of the signaling pathway affecting its development, which supplemented the theory of embryo development, and provided new ideas for the molecular mechanism of turtle embryo development.

Beneficial Effects of Warming Temperatures on Embryonic and Hatchling Development in a Low-Latitude Margin Population of the High-Latitude Lizard Lacerta agilis

The effects of warming temperatures on embryonic and hatchling development are critical for determining the vulnerability of species to climate warming. However, these effects have rarely been investigated in high-latitude oviparous species, particularly in their low-latitude margin populations. This study investigated the embryonic and hatchling development and fitness-related traits of a low-latitude margin population of a high-latitude lizard (Lacerta agilis). These traits were examined under present (24°C), moderate warming (27 and 30°C), and severe warming scenarios (33°C). Based on embryonic and hatchling responses to thermal variation, this study aimed to predict the vulnerability of the early life stages of low-latitude margin population of Lacerta agilis to climate warming. The incubation period of the low-latitude margin population of Lacerta agilis decreased as the temperature increased from 24 to 33°C. Hatching success was similar at 24, 27, and 30°C but decreased significantly at 33°C. No differences with temperature were observed for hatchling snout-vent length and hatchling body mass. The sprint speed was higher for hatchlings from temperatures of 24 and 33°C. The growth rate of hatchlings was highest at 30°C; however, the survival rate of hatchlings was not affected by the thermal environment. This study demonstrated that even for a low-latitude margin population of the high-latitude lizard, Lacerta agilis, moderate warming (i.e., 27 and 30°C) would benefit embryonic and hatchling development. This was indicated by the results showing higher hatching success, growth rate, and survival rate. However, if temperatures increase above 33°C, development and survival would be depressed significantly. Thus, low-latitude margin population of high-latitude species Lacerta agilis would benefit from climate warming in the near future but would be under stress if the nest temperature exceeded 30°C.

High incubation temperatures enhance mitochondrial energy metabolism in reptile embryos

Developmental rate increases exponentially with increasing temperature in ectothermic animals, but the biochemical basis underlying this thermal dependence is largely unexplored. We measured mitochondrial respiration and metabolic enzyme activities of turtle embryos (Pelodiscus sinensis) incubated at different temperatures to identify the metabolic basis of the rapid development occurring at high temperatures in reptile embryos. Developmental rate increased with increasing incubation temperatures in the embryos of P. sinensis. Correspondingly, in addition to the thermal dependence of mitochondrial respiration and metabolic enzyme activities, high-temperature incubation further enhanced mitochondrial respiration and COX activities in the embryos. This suggests that embryos may adjust mitochondrial respiration and metabolic enzyme activities in response to developmental temperature to achieve high developmental rates at high temperatures. Our study highlights the importance of biochemical investigations in understanding the proximate mechanisms by which temperature affects embryonic development.

Heart rates increase after hatching in two species of Natricine snakes

Experimental studies have shown heart rates to decrease from embryo to hatchling stage in turtles, remain steady in skinks, and increase in birds. However, no snake species has been studied in this regard. I recorded heart rate evolution trajectories from embryo to juvenile stage in 78 eggs from two species of European Natricine snakes. Unexpectedly, snakes behaved more like birds than turtles or lizards: heart rates increased after hatching in both N. maura and N. natrix, respectively by 43.92 ± 22.84% and 35.92 ± 24.52%. Heart rate shift was not related to an abrupt elevation of metabolism per se (snakes that increased their heart rates the most sharply grew the least after birth), but rather due to a number of smaller eggs that experienced lower than normal heart rates throughout the incubation and recovered a normal heart rate post-birth. This finding is discussed in the light of hatching synchrony benefits.

Heat tolerance during embryonic development has not diverged among populations of a widespread species (Sceloporus undulatus)

The frequency and magnitude of heat waves have increased in recent decades, imposing additional stresses on organisms in extreme environments. Most reptilian embryos are regularly exposed to thermal stress because they develop in shallow, warm soils for weeks to months. We studied cardiac performance during warming to infer lethal temperatures for embryonic lizards in the Sceloporus undulatus complex. Embryos from four populations throughout the geographical range (New Jersey, South Carolina, Colorado, and Arizona) were warmed at a rate observed in natural nests. Embryos from all populations exhibited a similar pattern of thermal sensitivity, as follows: heart rate rose between 34 and 41°C, remained stable between 41 and 44°C, and dropped sharply between 44 and 47°C. No embryos recovered from cardiac arrest, indicating that the upper lethal temperature was ≤47°C. Despite the putative selective pressures, the thermal limit to cardiac performance seems to have been conserved during the evolution of this species.