Nondenaturing purification of co-transcriptionally folded RNA avoids common folding heterogeneity

Recent Advances and Innovations in the Preparation and Purification of In Vitro-Transcribed-mRNA-Based Molecules

The coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) pandemic poses a disruptive impact on public health and the global economy. Fortunately, the development of COVID-19 vaccines based on in vitro-transcribed messenger RNA (IVT mRNA) has been a breakthrough in medical history, benefiting billions of people with its high effectiveness, safety profile, and ease of large-scale production. This success is the result of decades of continuous RNA research, which has led to significant improvements in the stability and expression level of IVT mRNA through various approaches such as sequence optimization and improved preparation processes. IVT mRNA sequence optimization has been shown to have a positive effect on enhancing the mRNA expression level. The innovation of IVT mRNA purification technology is also indispensable, as the purity of IVT mRNA directly affects the success of downstream vaccine preparation processes and the potential for inducing unwanted side effects in therapeutic applications. Despite the progress made, challenges related to IVT mRNA sequence design and purification still require further attention to enhance the quality of IVT mRNA in the future. In this review, we discuss the latest innovative progress in IVT mRNA design and purification to further improve its clinical efficacy.

General Strategies for RNA X-ray Crystallography

An extremely small proportion of the X-ray crystal structures deposited in the Protein Data Bank are of RNA or RNA-protein complexes. This is due to three main obstacles to the successful determination of RNA structure: (1) low yields of pure, properly folded RNA; (2) difficulty creating crystal contacts due to low sequence diversity; and (3) limited methods for phasing. Various approaches have been developed to address these obstacles, such as native RNA purification, engineered crystallization modules, and incorporation of proteins to assist in phasing. In this review, we will discuss these strategies and provide examples of how they are used in practice.

The molecular structure of long non-coding RNAs: emerging patterns and functional implications

Long non-coding RNAs (lncRNAs) are recently-discovered transcripts that regulate vital cellular processes and are crucially connected to diseases. Despite their unprecedented molecular complexity, it is emerging that lncRNAs possess distinct structural motifs. Remarkably, the 3D shape and topology of full-length, native lncRNAs have been visualized for the first time in the last year. These studies reveal that lncRNA structures dictate lncRNA functions. Here, we review experimentally determined lncRNA structures and emphasize that lncRNA structural characterization requires synergistic integration of computational, biochemical and biophysical approaches. Based on these emerging paradigms, we discuss how to overcome the challenges posed by the complex molecular architecture of lncRNAs, with the goal of obtaining a detailed understanding of lncRNA functions and molecular mechanisms in the future.

Heterodimerization of Group I Ribozymes Enabling Exon Recombination through Pairs of Cooperative trans-Splicing Reactions

Group I (GI) self-splicing ribozymes are attractive tools for biotechnology and synthetic biology. Several trans-splicing and related reactions based on GI ribozymes have been developed for the purpose of recombining their target mRNA sequences. By combining trans-splicing systems with rational modular engineering of GI ribozymes it was possible to achieve more complex editing of target RNA sequences. In this study we have developed a cooperative trans-splicing system through rational modular engineering with use of dimeric GI ribozymes derived from the Tetrahymena group I intron ribozyme. The resulting pairs of ribozymes exhibited catalytic activity depending on their selective dimerization. Rational modular redesign as performed in this study would facilitate the development of sophisticated regulation of double or multiple trans-splicing reactions in a cooperative manner.

Iluminated by foreign letters - Strategies for site-specific cyclopropene modification of large functional RNAs via in vitro transcription

The synthesis of sequence-specifically modified long RNA molecules, which cannot entirely be prepared via solid phase synthesis methods is experimentally challenging. We are using a new approach based on an expanded genetic alphabet preparing site-specifically modified RNA molecules via standard in vitro transcription. In this report, the site-specific labeling of functional RNAs, in particular ribozymes and a long non-coding RNA with cyclopropene moieties, is presented. We provide detailed instructions for RNA labeling via in vitro transcription and include required analytical methods to verify production and identity of the transcript. We further present post-transcriptional inverse electron demand Diels-Alder cycloaddition reactions on the cyclopropene-modified sequences and discuss applications of the genetic alphabet expansion transcription for in vitro preparation of labeled functional RNAs with complex foldings. In detail, the glmS and CPEB3 ribozymes were site-specifically decorated with methyl cyclopropene moieties using the unnatural TPT3^CP triphosphate and were proven to be still functional. In addition, the structurally complex A region of the Xist lncRNA (401nt) was site-specifically modified with methyl cyclopropene and detected by fluorescence after cycloaddition reaction with a tetrazine-BODIPY conjugate.

A cyclopropene-modified nucleotide for site-specific RNA labeling using genetic alphabet expansion transcription

Site-specific RNA modification with methyl cyclopropene moieties is performed by T7 in vitro transcription. An existing unnatural base is functionalized with a cyclopropene moiety and used in transcription reactions to produce site-specifically cyclopropene-modified RNA molecules. The posttranscriptional inverse electron demand Diels-Alder cycloaddition reaction with a selected tetrazine-fluorophore conjugate is demonstrated.

Using Molecular Replacement Phasing to Study the Structure and Function of RNA

In recent years a wide variety of RNA molecules regulating fundamental cellular processes has been discovered. Therefore, RNA structure determination is experiencing a boost and many more RNA structures are likely to be determined in the years to come. The broader availability of experimentally determined RNA structures implies that molecular replacement (MR) will be used more and more frequently as a method for phasing future crystallographic structures. In this report we describe various aspects relative to RNA structure determination by MR. First, we describe how to select and create MR search models for nucleic acids. Second, we describe how to perform MR searches on RNA using available crystallographic software. Finally, we describe how to refine and interpret the successful MR solutions. These protocols are applicable to determine novel RNA structures as well as to establish structural-functional relationships on existing RNA structures.

Native purification and labeling of RNA for single molecule fluorescence studies

The recent discovery that non-coding RNAs are considerably more abundant and serve a much wider range of critical cellular functions than recognized over previous decades of research into molecular biology has sparked a renewed interest in the study of structure-function relationships of RNA. To perform their functions in the cell, RNAs must dominantly adopt their native conformations, avoiding deep, non-productive kinetic traps that may exist along a frustrated (rugged) folding free energy landscape. Intracellularly, RNAs are synthesized by RNA polymerase and fold co-transcriptionally starting from the 5' end, sometimes with the aid of protein chaperones. By contrast, in the laboratory RNAs are commonly generated by in vitro transcription or chemical synthesis, followed by purification in a manner that includes the use of high concentrations of urea, heat and UV light (for detection), resulting in the denaturation and subsequent refolding of the entire RNA. Recent studies into the nature of heterogeneous RNA populations resulting from this process have underscored the need for non-denaturing (native) purification methods that maintain the co-transcriptional fold of an RNA. Here, we present protocols for the native purification of an RNA after its in vitro transcription and for fluorophore and biotin labeling methods designed to preserve its native conformation for use in single molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer (smFRET) inquiries into its structure and function. Finally, we present methods for taking smFRET data and for analyzing them, as well as a description of plausible overall preparation schemes for the plethora of non-coding RNAs.

RNA complex purification using high-affinity fluorescent RNA aptamer tags

RNA plays important roles in cellular processes, but RNA-protein complexes are notoriously hard to isolate and study. We compare and contrast existing RNA- and protein-purification strategies with the potential of new RNA-tagging systems such as RNA Spinach and RNA Mango. Each RNA aptamer binds a small fluorophore, resulting in a highly fluorescent complex that is thousands of times brighter than the unbound fluorophore. Provided that the aptamer binding affinity is high enough, derivatized dyes can be used in conjunction with these aptamers to purify RNA complexes while simultaneously using their intrinsic fluorescence to track the complex of interest. The known strengths and weakness of these RNA tagging systems are discussed.

Single-molecule studies of riboswitch folding

The folding dynamics of riboswitches are central to their ability to modulate gene expression in response to environmental cues. In most cases, a structural competition between the formation of a ligand-binding aptamer and an expression platform (or some other competing off-state) determines the regulatory outcome. Here, we review single-molecule studies of riboswitch folding and function, predominantly carried out using single-molecule FRET or optical trapping approaches. Recent results have supplied new insights into riboswitch folding energy landscapes, the mechanisms of ligand binding, the roles played by divalent ions, the applicability of hierarchical folding models, and kinetic vs. thermodynamic control schemes. We anticipate that future work, based on improved data sets and potentially combining multiple experimental techniques, will enable the development of more complete models for complex RNA folding processes. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled: Riboswitches.

HDV family of self-cleaving ribozymes

The hepatitis delta virus (HDV) ribozymes are catalytic RNAs capable of cleaving their own sugar-phosphate backbone. The HDV virus possesses the ribozymes in both sense and antisense genomic transcripts, where they are essential for processing during replication. These ribozymes have been the subject of intense biochemical scrutiny and have yielded a wealth of mechanistic insights. In recent years, many HDV-like ribozymes have been identified in nearly all branches of life. The ribozymes are implicated in a variety of biological events, including episodic memory in mammals and retrotransposition in many eukaryotes. Detailed analysis of additional HDV-like ribozyme isolates will likely reveal many more biological functions and provide information about the evolution of this unique RNA.

Advances in methods for native expression and purification of RNA for structural studies

Many RNAs present unique challenges in obtaining material suitable for structural or biophysical characterization. These issues include synthesis of chemically and conformationally homogeneous RNAs, refolding RNA purified using denaturing preparation techniques, and avoiding chemical damage. To address these challenges, new methodologies in RNA expression and purification have been developed seeking to emulate those commonly used for proteins. In this review, recent developments in the preparation of high-quality RNA for structural biology and biophysical applications are discussed, with an emphasis on native methods.

RNA synthesis and purification for structural studies

RNAs play pivotal roles in the cell, ranging from catalysis (e.g., RNase P), acting as adaptor molecule (tRNA) to regulation (e.g., riboswitches). Precise understanding of its three-dimensional structures has given unprecedented insight into the molecular basis for all of these processes. Nevertheless, structural studies on RNA are still limited by the very special nature of this polymer. The most common methods for the determination of 3D RNA structures are NMR and X-ray crystallography. Both methods have their own set of requirements and give different amounts of information about the target RNA. For structural studies, the major bottleneck is usually obtaining large amounts of highly pure and homogeneously folded RNA. Especially for X-ray crystallography it can be necessary to screen a large number of variants to obtain well-ordered single crystals. In this mini-review we give an overview about strategies for the design, in vitro production, and purification of RNA for structural studies.

Affinity purification of T7 RNA transcripts with homogeneous ends using ARiBo and CRISPR tags

Affinity purification of RNA using the ARiBo tag technology currently provides an ideal approach to quickly prepare RNA with 3' homogeneity. Here, we explored strategies to also ensure 5' homogeneity of affinity-purified RNAs. First, we systematically investigated the effect of starting nucleotides on the 5' heterogeneity of a small SLI RNA substrate from the Neurospora VS ribozyme purified from an SLI-ARiBo precursor. A series of 32 SLI RNA sequences with variations in the +1 to +3 region was produced from two T7 promoters (class III consensus and class II 2.5) using either the wild-type T7 RNA polymerase or the P266L mutant. Although the P266L mutant helps decrease the levels of 5'-sequence heterogeneity in several cases, significant levels of 5' heterogeneity (≥1.5%) remain for transcripts starting with GGG, GAG, GCG, GGC, AGG, AGA, AAA, ACA, AUA, AAC, ACC, AUC, and AAU. To provide a more general approach to purifying RNA with 5' homogeneity, we tested the suitability of using a small CRISPR RNA stem-loop at the 5' end of the SLI-ARiBo RNA. Interestingly, we found that complete cleavage of the 5'-CRISPR tag with the Cse3 endoribonuclease can be achieved quickly from CRISPR-SLI-ARiBo transcripts. With this procedure, it is possible to generate SLI-ARiBo RNAs starting with any of the four standard nucleotides (G, C, A, or U) involved in either a single- or a double-stranded structure. Moreover, the 5'-CRISPR-based strategy can be combined with affinity purification using the 3'-ARiBo tag for quick purification of RNA with both 5' and 3' homogeneity.

Nucleic acid structure characterization by small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS)

Small angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) is a powerful method for investigating macromolecular structure in solution. SAXS data provide information about the size and shape of a molecule with a resolution of ∼2 to 3 nm. SAXS is particularly useful for the investigation of nucleic acids, which scatter X-rays strongly due to the electron-rich phosphate backbone. Therefore, SAXS has become an increasingly popular method for modeling nucleic acid structures, an endeavor made tractable by the highly regular helical nature of nucleic acid secondary structures. Recently, SAXS was used in combination with NMR to filter and refine all-atom models of a U2/U6 small nuclear RNA complex. In this unit, general protocols for sample preparation, data acquisition, and data analysis and processing are given. Additionally, examples of correctly and incorrectly processed SAXS data and expected results are provided.

Preparation of λN-GST fusion protein for affinity immobilization of RNA

Affinity purification of in vitro transcribed RNA is becoming an attractive alternative to purification using standard denaturing gel electrophoresis. Affinity purification is particularly advantageous because it can be performed in a few hours under non-denaturing conditions. However, the performance of affinity purification methods can vary tremendously depending on the RNA immobilization matrix. It was previously shown that RNA immobilization via an optimized λN-GST fusion protein bound to glutathione-Sepharose resin allows affinity purification of RNA with very high purity and yield. This Chapter outlines the experimental procedure employed to prepare the λN-GST fusion protein used for RNA immobilization in successful affinity purifications of RNA. It describes the details of protein expression and purification as well as routine quality control analyses.

Affinity purification of RNA using an ARiBo tag

The increased awareness of the importance of RNA in biology, illustrated by the recent attention given to RNA interference research and applications, has spurred structural and functional investigations of RNA. For these studies, the traditional purification method for in vitro transcribed RNA is denaturing polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis. However, gel-based procedures denature the RNA and can be very tedious and time-consuming. Thus, several alternative schemes have been developed for fast non-denaturing purification of RNA transcribed in vitro. In a recent report, a quick affinity purification procedure was developed for RNAs transcribed with a 3'-ARiBo tag and shown to provide RNA with exceptionally high purity and yield. The ARiBo tag contains the λboxB RNA and the glmS ribozyme, allowing immobilization on GSH-Sepharose resin via a λN-GST fusion protein and elution by activation of the glmS ribozyme with glucosamine-6-phosphate. This Chapter outlines the experimental details for affinity batch purification of RNAs using ARiBo tags. Although the procedure was originally developed for purification of a stable purine riboswitch mutant, it is demonstrated here for purification of the terminal loop of the let-7g precursor miRNA, an important target of the pluripotency factor Lin28.

Ultraviolet shadowing of RNA can cause significant chemical damage in seconds

Chemical purity of RNA samples is important for high-precision studies of RNA folding and catalytic behavior, but photodamage accrued during ultraviolet (UV) shadowing steps of sample preparation can reduce this purity. Here, we report the quantitation of UV-induced damage by using reverse transcription and single-nucleotide-resolution capillary electrophoresis. We found photolesions in a dozen natural and artificial RNAs; across multiple sequence contexts, dominantly at but not limited to pyrimidine doublets; and from multiple lamps recommended for UV shadowing. Irradiation time-courses revealed detectable damage within a few seconds of exposure for 254 nm lamps held at a distance of 5 to 10 cm from 0.5-mm thickness gels. Under these conditions, 200-nucleotide RNAs subjected to 20 seconds of UV shadowing incurred damage to 16-27% of molecules; and, due to a 'skin effect', the molecule-by-molecule distribution of lesions gave 4-fold higher variance than a Poisson distribution. Thicker gels, longer wavelength lamps, and shorter exposure times reduced but did not eliminate damage. These results suggest that RNA biophysical studies should report precautions taken to avoid artifactual heterogeneity from UV shadowing.

RNAs synthesized using photocleavable biotinylated nucleotides have dramatically improved catalytic efficiency

Obtaining homogeneous population of natively folded RNAs is a crippling problem encountered when preparing RNAs for structural or enzymatic studies. Most of the traditional methods that are employed to prepare large quantities of RNAs involve procedures that partially denature the RNA. Here, we present a simple strategy using ‘click’ chemistry to couple biotin to a ‘caged’ photocleavable (PC) guanosine monophosphate (GMP) in high yield. This biotin-PC GMP, accepted by T7 RNA polymerase, has been used to transcribe RNAs ranging in size from 27 to 527 nt. Furthermore we show, using an in-gel fluorescence assay, that natively prepared 160 and 175 kDa minimal group II intron ribozymes have enhanced catalytic activity over the same RNAs, purified via denaturing conditions and refolded. We conclude that large complex RNAs prepared by non-denaturing means form a homogeneous population and are catalytically more active than those prepared by denaturing methods and subsequent refolding; this facile approach for native RNA preparation should benefit synthesis of RNAs for biophysical and therapeutic applications.

The shape-shifting quasispecies of RNA: one sequence, many functional folds

E Unus pluribum, or "Of One, Many", may be at the root of decoding the RNA sequence-structure-function relationship. RNAs embody the large majority of genes in higher eukaryotes and fold in a sequence-directed fashion into three-dimensional structures that perform functions conserved across all cellular life forms, ranging from regulating to executing gene expression. While it is the most important determinant of the RNA structure, the nucleotide sequence is generally not sufficient to specify a unique set of secondary and tertiary interactions due to the highly frustrated nature of RNA folding. This frustration results in folding heterogeneity, a common phenomenon wherein a chemically homogeneous population of RNA molecules folds into multiple stable structures. Often, these alternative conformations constitute misfolds, lacking the biological activity of the natively folded RNA. Intriguingly, a number of RNAs have recently been described as capable of adopting multiple distinct conformations that all perform, or contribute to, the same function. Characteristically, these conformations interconvert slowly on the experimental timescale, suggesting that they should be regarded as distinct native states. We discuss how rugged folding free energy landscapes give rise to multiple native states in the Tetrahymena Group I intron ribozyme, hairpin ribozyme, sarcin-ricin loop, ribosome, and an in vitro selected aptamer. We further describe the varying degrees to which folding heterogeneity impacts function in these RNAs, and compare and contrast this impact with that of heterogeneities found in protein folding. Embracing that one sequence can give rise to multiple native folds, we hypothesize that this phenomenon imparts adaptive advantages on any functionally evolving RNA quasispecies.

The ARiBo tag: a reliable tool for affinity purification of RNAs under native conditions

Although RNA-based biological processes and therapeutics have gained increasing interest, purification of in vitro transcribed RNA generally relies on gel-based methods that are time-consuming, tedious and denature the RNA. Here, we present a reliable procedure for affinity batch purification of RNA, which exploits the high-affinity interaction between the boxB RNA and the N-peptide from bacteriophage λ. The RNA of interest is synthesized with an ARiBo tag, which consists of an activatable ribozyme (the glmS ribozyme) and the λBoxB RNA. This ARiBo-fusion RNA is initially captured on Glutathione-Sepharose resin via a GST/λN-fusion protein, and the RNA of interest is subsequently eluted by ribozyme self-cleavage using glucosamine-6-phosphate. Several GST/λN-fusion proteins and ARiBo tags were tested to optimize RNA yield and purity. The optimized procedure enables one to quickly obtain (3 h) highly pure RNA (>99%) under native conditions and with yields comparable to standard denaturing gel-based protocols. It is widely applicable to a variety of RNAs, including riboswitches, ribozymes and microRNAs. In addition, it can be easily adapted to a wide range of applications that require RNA purification and/or immobilization, including isolation of RNA-associated complexes from living cells and high-throughput applications.