Determination of membrane protein transporter oligomerization in native tissue using spatial fluorescence intensity fluctuation analysis

On the accuracy bounds of high-order image correlation spectroscopy

High-order image correlation spectroscopy (HICS) or related image-based cumulant analysis of emitter species are important for identifying properties and concentrations of biomolecules or nanoparticles. However, lack of a thorough parameter space test limits its use in full potential. The current study focused on mapping accuracy bounds of bimodal species concentration space by simulating and analysing more than 2 × 105 images (∼1011 data points). Concentration space maps for four values of quantum yield contrast ratio between two species in a mixture and two sampling spaces (834 and 13357 beam areas in an image) were created, which showed clear accuracy bounds governed by two factors, Poisson fluctuation and quantum yield ratio. Typically, brighter species concentration was 1-3 orders of magnitude lower than that of dimmer species, and higher brightness contrast allowed higher concentration difference. Upper limit of accuracy bounds was governed by resolvable Poisson fluctuation, where this condition was violated for emitter density beyond 10 particles per beam area. The accuracy bounds are shown to be largely invariant under noise correction or the calculation method, and are compared against previous experimental results, showing consistent agreement. This study shows that concentration limit needs to be observed when using HICS or related image moment or cumulant analysis techniques. As a rule of thumb, a large quantum yield contrast and large sampling points allow more concentration difference between two species to be resolved in an analysis.

Revisiting the Role of Ser982 Phosphorylation in Stoichiometry Shift of the Electrogenic Na+/qHCO3- Cotransporter NBCe1

In most cell types and heterologous expression systems, the electrogenic sodium-bicarbonate cotransporter NBCe1 operates with a 1Na⁺-2HCO₃^- stoichiometry that, given typical transmembrane electrochemical gradients, promotes Na+ and HCO₃^- influx. However, NBCe1 in the kidney mediates HCO₃^- efflux (HCO₃^- reabsorption), a direction that has been predicted to be favored only if NBCe1 operates with a 1:3 stoichiometry. The phosphorylation state of Ser982 in the cytosolic carboxy-terminal domain of NBCe1 has been reported to be a key determinant of the transporter stoichiometry, with non-phosphorylated Ser982 favoring a 1:3 stoichiometry. Conversely, phosphoproteomic data from renal cortical preparations have revealed the presence of NBCe1 peptides including phosphoserine982 (pSer982) and/or pSer985 although it was not known what proportion of NBCe1 molecules were phosphorylated. In the present study, we report the generation, characterization, and application of a novel phosphospecific antibody raised against NBCe1/pSer982 and show that, contrary to expectations, Ser982 is more prevalently phosphorylated in murine kidneys (in which NBCe1 mediates HCO₃^- efflux) than in murine colons (in which NBCe1 mediates HCO₃^- influx). Using phosphomimetic mutants of murine NBCe1 expressed in Xenopus oocytes, we found no evidence that the phosphorylation state of Ser982 or Ser985 alone influences the transport stoichiometry or conductance. Furthermore, we found that the phosphorylation of NBCe1/Ser982 is enhanced in murine kidneys following a 24 h induction of metabolic acidosis. We conclude that the phosphorylation status of Ser982 is not a key determinant of NBCe1 stoichiometry but correlates with presumed NBCe1 activity.

CryoEM structure of the human SLC4A4 sodium-coupled acid-base transporter NBCe1

Na+-coupled acid-base transporters play essential roles in human biology. Their dysfunction has been linked to cancer, heart, and brain disease. High-resolution structures of mammalian Na+-coupled acid-base transporters are not available. The sodium-bicarbonate cotransporter NBCe1 functions in multiple organs and its mutations cause blindness, abnormal growth and blood chemistry, migraines, and impaired cognitive function. Here, we have determined the structure of the membrane domain dimer of human NBCe1 at 3.9 Å resolution by cryo electron microscopy. Our atomic model and functional mutagenesis revealed the ion accessibility pathway and the ion coordination site, the latter containing residues involved in human disease-causing mutations. We identified a small number of residues within the ion coordination site whose modification transformed NBCe1 into an anion exchanger. Our data suggest that symporters and exchangers utilize comparable transport machinery and that subtle differences in their substrate-binding regions have very significant effects on their transport mode.

Scanning number and brightness yields absolute protein concentrations in live cells: a crucial parameter controlling functional bio-molecular interaction networks

Biological function results from properly timed bio-molecular interactions that transduce external or internal signals, resulting in any number of cellular fates, including triggering of cell-state transitions (division, differentiation, transformation, apoptosis), metabolic homeostasis and adjustment to changing physical or nutritional environments, amongst many more. These bio-molecular interactions can be modulated by chemical modifications of proteins, nucleic acids, lipids and other small molecules. They can result in bio-molecular transport from one cellular compartment to the other and often trigger specific enzyme activities involved in bio-molecular synthesis, modification or degradation. Clearly, a mechanistic understanding of any given high level biological function requires a quantitative characterization of the principal bio-molecular interactions involved and how these may change dynamically. Such information can be obtained using fluctation analysis, in particular scanning number and brightness, and used to build and test mechanistic models of the functional network to define which characteristics are the most important for its regulation.

Methods used to study the oligomeric structure of G-protein-coupled receptors

G-protein-coupled receptors (GPCRs), which constitute the largest family of cell surface receptors, were originally thought to function as monomers, but are now recognized as being able to act in a wide range of oligomeric states and indeed, it is known that the oligomerization state of a GPCR can modulate its pharmacology and function. A number of experimental techniques have been devised to study GPCR oligomerization including those based upon traditional biochemistry such as blue-native PAGE (BN-PAGE), co-immunoprecipitation (Co-IP) and protein-fragment complementation assays (PCAs), those based upon resonance energy transfer, FRET, time-resolved FRET (TR-FRET), FRET spectrometry and bioluminescence resonance energy transfer (BRET). Those based upon microscopy such as FRAP, total internal reflection fluorescence microscopy (TIRFM), spatial intensity distribution analysis (SpIDA) and various single molecule imaging techniques. Finally with the solution of a growing number of crystal structures, X-ray crystallography must be acknowledged as an important source of discovery in this field. A different, but in many ways complementary approach to the use of more traditional experimental techniques, are those involving computational methods that possess obvious merit in the study of the dynamics of oligomer formation and function. Here, we summarize the latest developments that have been made in the methods used to study GPCR oligomerization and give an overview of their application.

A novel mutant Na+ /HCO3- cotransporter NBCe1 in a case of compound-heterozygous inheritance of proximal renal tubular acidosis

KEY POINTS

The inheritance of two defective alleles of SLC4A4, the gene that encodes the widely-expressed electrogenic sodium bicarbonate cotransporter NBCe1, results in the bicarbonate-wasting disease proximal renal tubular acidosis (pRTA). In the present study, we report the first case of compound-heterozygous inheritance of pRTA (p.Arg510His/p.Gln913Arg) in an individual with low blood pH, blindness and neurological signs that resemble transient ischaemic attacks. We employ fluorescence microscopy on non-polarized (human embryonic kidney) and polarized (Madin-Darby canine kidney) renal cell lines and electrophysiology on Xenopus oocytes to characterize the mutant transporters (R510H and Q913R). Both mutant transporters exhibit enhanced intracellular retention in renal cells, an observation that probably explains the HCO₃^- transport deficit in the individual. Both mutants retain a close-to-normal per molecule Na⁺ /HCO₃^- cotransport activity in Xenopus oocytes, suggesting that they are suitable candidates for folding-correction therapy. However, Q913R expression is uniquely associated with a depolarizing, HCO₃^- independent, Cl^- -conductance in oocytes that could have pathological consequences if expressed in the cells of patients.

ABSTRACT

Proximal renal tubular acidosis (pRTA) is a rare, recessively-inherited disease characterized by abnormally acidic blood, blindness, as well as below average height and weight. pRTA is typically associated with homozygous mutation of the solute carrier 4 family gene SLC4A4. SLC4A4 encodes the electrogenic sodium bicarbonate cotransporter NBCe1, a membrane protein that acts to maintain intracellular and plasma pH. We present the first description of a case of compound-heterozygous inheritance of pRTA. The individual has inherited two mutations in NBCe1: p.Arg510His (R510H) and p.Gln913Arg (Q913R), one from each parent. In addition to the usual features of pRTA, the patient exhibits unusual signs, such as muscle spasms and fever. We have recreated these mutant transporters for expression in model systems. We find that both of the mutant proteins exhibit substantial intracellular retention when expressed in mammalian renal cell lines. When expressed in Xenopus oocytes, we find that the R510H and Q913R-mutant NBCe1 molecules exhibit apparently normal Na⁺ /HCO₃^- cotransport activity but that Q913R is associated with an unusual HCO₃^- independent anion-leak. We conclude that a reduced accumulation of NBCe1 protein in the basolateral membrane of proximal-tubule epithelia is the most probable cause of pRTA in this case. We further note that the Q913R-associated anion-leak could itself be pathogenic if expressed in the plasma membrane of mammalian cells, compromising the benefit of strategies aiming to enhance mutant NBCe1 accumulation in the plasma membrane.

Spatial Intensity Distribution Analysis Reveals Abnormal Oligomerization of Proteins in Single Cells

Knowledge of membrane receptor organization is essential for understanding the initial steps in cell signaling and trafficking mechanisms, but quantitative analysis of receptor interactions at the single-cell level and in different cellular compartments has remained highly challenging. To achieve this, we apply a quantitative image analysis technique-spatial intensity distribution analysis (SpIDA)-that can measure fluorescent particle concentrations and oligomerization states within different subcellular compartments in live cells. An important technical challenge faced by fluorescence microscopy-based measurement of oligomerization is the fidelity of receptor labeling. In practice, imperfect labeling biases the distribution of oligomeric states measured within an aggregated system. We extend SpIDA to enable analysis of high-order oligomers from fluorescence microscopy images, by including a probability weighted correction algorithm for nonemitting labels. We demonstrated that this fraction of nonemitting probes could be estimated in single cells using SpIDA measurements on model systems with known oligomerization state. Previously, this artifact was measured using single-step photobleaching. This approach was validated using computer-simulated data and the imperfect labeling was quantified in cells with ion channels of known oligomer subunit count. It was then applied to quantify the oligomerization states in different cell compartments of the proteolipid protein (PLP) expressed in COS-7 cells. Expression of a mutant PLP linked to impaired trafficking resulted in the detection of PLP tetramers that persist in the endoplasmic reticulum, while no difference was measured at the membrane between the distributions of wild-type and mutated PLPs. Our results demonstrate that SpIDA allows measurement of protein oligomerization in different compartments of intact cells, even when fractional mislabeling occurs as well as photobleaching during the imaging process, and reveals insights into the mechanism underlying impaired trafficking of PLP.

Phosphatidylinositol 4,5-bisphosphate degradation inhibits the Na+/bicarbonate cotransporter NBCe1-B and -C variants expressed in Xenopus oocytes

KEY POINTS

We previously reported that the phospholipid phosphatidylinositol 4,5-bisphosphate (PIP2 ) directly stimulates heterologously expressed electrogenic Na(+)/bicarbonate cotransporter NBCe1-A in an excised macropatch from the Xenopus oocyte, and indirectly stimulates NBCe1-B and -C in the intact oocyte primarily through inositol 1,4,5-trisphosphate/Ca(2+). In the current study, we expand on a previous observation that PIP2 may also directly stimulate NBCe1 in the intact oocyte. In this study on oocytes, we co-expressed either NBCe1-B or -C and a voltage-sensitive phosphatase (VSP), which depletes PIP2 without changing inositol 1,4,5-trisphosphate, and monitored NBCe1-mediated currents with the two-electrode voltage-clamp technique or pHi changes using Vm/pH-sensitive microelectrodes. Activating VSP inhibited NBCe1-B and -C outward currents and NBCe1-mediated pHi increases, and changes in NBCe1 activity paralleled changes in surface PIP2. This study is a quantitative assessment of PIP2 itself as a regulator of NBCe1-B and -C in the intact cell, and represents the first use of VSP to characterize the PIP2 sensitivity of a transporter. These data combined with our previous work demonstrate that NBCe1-B and -C are regulated by two PIP2-mediated signalling pathways. Specifically, a decrease in PIP2 per se can inhibit NBCe1, whereas hydrolysis of PIP2 to inositol 1,4,5-trisphosphate/Ca(2+) can stimulate the transporter.

ABSTRACT

The electrogenic Na(+)/bicarbonate cotransporter (NBCe1) of the Slc4 gene family is a powerful regulator of intracellular pH (pHi) and extracellular pH (pHo), and contributes to solute reabsorption and secretion in many epithelia. Using Xenopus laevis oocytes expressing NBCe1 variants, we have previously reported that the phospholipid phosphatidylinositol 4,5-bisphosphate (PIP2) directly stimulates NBCe1-A in an excised macropatch, and indirectly stimulates NBCe1-B and -C in the intact oocyte primarily through inositol 1,4,5-trisphosphate (InsP3)/Ca(2+). In the current study, we used the two-electrode voltage-clamp technique alone or in combination with pH/voltage-sensitive microelectrodes or confocal fluorescence imaging of plasma membrane PIP2 to characterize the PIP2 sensitivity of NBCe1-B and -C in whole oocytes by co-expressing a voltage-sensitive phosphatase (VSP) that decreases PIP2 and bypasses the InsP3/Ca(2+) pathway. An oocyte depolarization that activated VSP only transiently stimulated the NBCe1-B/C current, consistent with an initial rapid depolarization-induced NBCe1 activation, and then a subsequent slower VSP-mediated NBCe1 inhibition. Upon repolarization, the NBCe1 current decreased, and then slowly recovered with an exponential time course that paralleled PIP2 resynthesis as measured with a PIP2-sensitive fluorophore and confocal imaging. A subthreshold depolarization that minimally activated VSP caused a more sustained increase in NBCe1 current, and did not lead to an exponential current recovery following repolarization. Similar results were obtained with oocytes expressing a catalytically dead VSP mutant at all depolarized potentials. Depleting endoplasmic reticulum Ca(2+) did not inhibit the NBCe1 current recovery following repolarization from VSP activation, demonstrating that changes in InsP3/Ca(2+) were not responsible. This study demonstrates for the first time that depleting PIP2 per se inhibits NBCe1 activity. The data in conjunction with previous findings implicate a dual PIP2 regulatory pathway for NBCe1 involving both PIP2 itself and generated InsP3/Ca(2+).

Effects of Nt-truncation and coexpression of isolated Nt domains on the membrane trafficking of electroneutral Na+/HCO3- cotransporters

The SLC4 genes are all capable of producing multiple variants by alternative splicing or using alternative promoters. The physiological consequences of such diversity are of great interest to investigators. Here, we identified two novel variants of the electroneutral Na⁺/ cotransporter NBCn1, one full-length starting with “MIPL” and the other Nt-truncated starting with “MDEL”. Moreover, we identified a new promoter of Slc4a10 encoding NBCn2 and a novel type of Nt-truncated NBCn2 starting with “MHAN”. When heterologously expressed, the new NBCn1 variants were well localized to the plasma membrane and exhibited characteristic NBCn1 activity. However, MHAN-NBCn2 was poorly localized on the plasma membrane. By deletion mutations, we identified the Nt regions important for the surface localization of NBCn2. Interestingly, coexpressing the full-length NBCn2 greatly enhances the surface abundance of the Nt-truncated NBCn2. Co-immunoprecipitation and bimolecular fluorescence complementation studies showed that the full-length and Nt-truncated NBCn2 interact with each other to form heterodimers in neuro-2A cells. Finally, we showed that the isolated Nt domain interacts with and enhances the surface abundance of the Nt-truncated NBCn2. The present study expands our knowledge of the NBCn1 and NBCn2 transcriptome, and provides insights into how the Nt domain could affect transporter function by regulating its membrane trafficking.

Partitioning of humic acids between aqueous solution and hydrogel: concentration profiling of humic acids in hydrogel phases

The partitioning of the natural polyelectrolyte humic acid (HA) from an aqueous dispersion into a model biomimetic gel (alginate) and a synthetic polyacrylamide gel (PAAm) is explored. In both gels, the spatial distribution of HA in the gel body, as measured by confocal laser scanning microscopy, is markedly nonhomogeneous. A striking feature is the enhanced accumulation of HA in a thin film of thickness ca. 15 μm at the surface of the gel body, resulting in average local concentrations that are, for PAAm and alginate respectively, a factor of 10 and 4 greater than that in the bulk solution. The time dependence of accumulation in the surface film is predominantly controlled by the diffusive supply of HA from the aqueous medium, with a time constant on the order of 10(3) s for both gels. The concentration of HA within the bulk gel body differs significantly from that in the bulk aqueous medium: substantially higher for PAAm but much lower for alginate. The results are significant for understanding the nature and rate of sink/source functioning at permeable phases in contact with aqueous media, e.g., biofilms and gel-like layers at biological interfaces or employed in chemical speciation sensors.

Quantifying intracellular dynamics using fluorescence fluctuation spectroscopy

Originally developed for the field of physical chemistry, fluorescence fluctuation spectroscopy (FFS) has evolved to a family of methods to quantify concentrations, diffusion rates and interactions of fluorescently labelled molecules. The possibility to measure at the nanomolar concentration level and to combine these techniques with microscopy allow to study biological processes with high sensitivity in the living cell. In this review, the basic principles, challenges and recent developments of the most common FFS methods are being discussed and illustrated by intracellular applications.

Structure, function, and regulation of the SLC4 NBCe1 transporter and its role in causing proximal renal tubular acidosis

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

There has been significant progress in our understanding of the structural and functional properties and regulation of the electrogenic sodium bicarbonate cotansporter NBCe1, a membrane transporter that plays a key role in renal acid-base physiology. The NBCe1 variant NBCe1-A mediates basolateral electrogenic sodium-base transport in the proximal tubule and is critically required for transepithelial bicarbonate absorption. Mutations in NBCe1 cause autosomal recessive proximal renal tubular acidosis (pRTA). The review summarizes recent advances in this area.

RECENT FINDINGS

A topological model of NBCe1 has been established that provides a foundation for future structure-functional studies of the transporter. Critical residues and regions have been identified in NBCe1 that play key roles in its structure, function (substrate transport, electrogenicity) and regulation. The mechanisms of how NBCe1 mutations cause pRTA have also recently been elucidated.

SUMMARY

Given the important role of proximal tubule transepithelial bicarbonate absorption in systemic acid-base balance, a clear understanding of the structure-functional properties of NBCe1 is a prerequisite for elucidating the mechanisms of defective transepithelial bicarbonate transport in pRTA.

NBCe1 as a model carrier for understanding the structure-function properties of Na⁺ -coupled SLC4 transporters in health and disease

SLC4 transporters are membrane proteins that in general mediate the coupled transport of bicarbonate (carbonate) and share amino acid sequence homology. These proteins differ as to whether they also transport Na(+) and/or Cl(-), in addition to their charge transport stoichiometry, membrane targeting, substrate affinities, developmental expression, regulatory motifs, and protein-protein interactions. These differences account in part for the fact that functionally, SLC4 transporters have various physiological roles in mammals including transepithelial bicarbonate transport, intracellular pH regulation, transport of Na(+) and/or Cl(-), and possibly water. Bicarbonate transport is not unique to the SLC4 family since the structurally unrelated SLC26 family has at least three proteins that mediate anion exchange. The present review focuses on the first of the sodium-dependent SLC4 transporters that was identified whose structure has been most extensively studied: the electrogenic Na(+)-base cotransporter NBCe1. Mutations in NBCe1 cause proximal renal tubular acidosis (pRTA) with neurologic and ophthalmologic extrarenal manifestations. Recent studies have characterized the important structure-function properties of the transporter and how they are perturbed as a result of mutations that cause pRTA. It has become increasingly apparent that the structure of NBCe1 differs in several key features from the SLC4 Cl(-)-HCO3 (-) exchanger AE1 whose structural properties have been well-studied. In this review, the structure-function properties and regulation of NBCe1 will be highlighted, and its role in health and disease will be reviewed in detail.

Proximal renal tubular acidosis mediated by mutations in NBCe1-A: unraveling the transporter's structure-functional properties

NBCe1 belongs to the SLC4 family of base transporting membrane proteins that plays a significant role in renal, extrarenal, and systemic acid-base homeostasis. Recent progress has been made in characterizing the structure-function properties of NBCe1 (encoded by the SLC4A4 gene), and those factors that regulate its function. In the kidney, the NBCe1-A variant that is expressed on the basolateral membrane of proximal tubule is the key transporter responsible for overall transepithelial bicarbonate absorption in this nephron segment. NBCe1 mutations impair transepithelial bicarbonate absorption causing the syndrome of proximal renal tubular acidosis (pRTA). Studies of naturally occurring NBCe1 mutant proteins in heterologous expression systems have been very helpful in elucidation the structure-functional properties of the transporter. NBCe1 mutations are now known to cause pRTA by various mechanisms including the alteration of the transporter function (substrate ion interaction, electrogenicity), abnormal processing to the plasma membrane, and a perturbation in its structural properties. The elucidation of how NBCe1 mutations cause pRTA in addition to the recent studies which have provided further insight into the topology of the transporter have played an important role in uncovering its critically important structural-function properties.

A cell-free assay to determine the stoichiometry of plasma membrane proteins

Plasma membrane receptors, transporters, and ion channel molecules are often found as oligomeric structures that participate in signaling cascades essential for cell survival. Different states of protein oligomerization may play a role in functional control and allosteric regulation. Stochastic GFP-photobleaching (SGP) has emerged as an affordable and simple method to determine the stoichiometry of proteins at the plasma membrane. This non-invasive optical approach can be useful for total internal reflection of fluorescence microscopy (TIRFM), where signal-to-noise ratio is very high at the plasma membrane. Here, we report an alternative methodology implemented on a standard laser scanning confocal microscope (LSCM). The simplicity of our method will allow for its implementation in any epifluorescence microscope of choice.

The divergence, actions, roles, and relatives of sodium-coupled bicarbonate transporters

The mammalian Slc4 (Solute carrier 4) family of transporters is a functionally diverse group of 10 multi-spanning membrane proteins that includes three Cl-HCO3 exchangers (AE1-3), five Na(+)-coupled HCO3(-) transporters (NCBTs), and two other unusual members (AE4, BTR1). In this review, we mainly focus on the five mammalian NCBTs-NBCe1, NBCe2, NBCn1, NDCBE, and NBCn2. Each plays a specialized role in maintaining intracellular pH and, by contributing to the movement of HCO3(-) across epithelia, in maintaining whole-body pH and otherwise contributing to epithelial transport. Disruptions involving NCBT genes are linked to blindness, deafness, proximal renal tubular acidosis, mental retardation, and epilepsy. We also review AE1-3, AE4, and BTR1, addressing their relevance to the study of NCBTs. This review draws together recent advances in our understanding of the phylogenetic origins and physiological relevance of NCBTs and their progenitors. Underlying these advances is progress in such diverse disciplines as physiology, molecular biology, genetics, immunocytochemistry, proteomics, and structural biology. This review highlights the key similarities and differences between individual NCBTs and the genes that encode them and also clarifies the sometimes confusing NCBT nomenclature.

Spatial intensity distribution analysis (SpIDA): a new tool for receptor tyrosine kinase activation and transactivation quantification

This chapter presents a general approach for the application of spatial intensity distribution analysis (SpIDA) to pharmacodynamic quantification of receptor tyrosine kinase homodimerization in response to direct ligand activation or transactivation by G protein-coupled receptors. A custom graphical user interface developed for MATLAB is used to extract quantal brightness and receptor density information from intensity histograms calculated from single fluorescence microscopy images. This approach allows measurement of monomer/oligomer protein mixtures within subcellular compartments using conventional confocal laser scanning microscopy. Application of quantitative pharmacological analysis to data obtained using SpIDA provides a universal method for comparing studies between cell lines and receptor systems. In addition, because of its compatibility with conventional immunostaining approaches, SpIDA is suitable not only for use in recombinant systems but also for the characterization of mechanisms involving endogenous proteins. Therefore, SpIDA enables these biological processes to be monitored directly in their native cellular environment.