Is there 'anther-anther interference' within a flower? Evidences from one-by-one stamen movement in an insect-pollinated plant

The Functional Dilemma of Nectar Mimic Staminodes in Parnassia wightiana (Celastraceae): Attracting Pollinators and Florivorous Beetles

While floral signaling plays a central role in the reproductive success of all animal-pollinated plants, it may also attract herbivores eager to feed on flowers. False nectaries with glossy surfaces reflecting incident light may produce signals that attract floral visitors guiding their movements to and within the flower. Whether false nectaries also attract herbivores that lower the reproductive success of natural populations requires attention. In this study, we focus on Parnassia wightiana, a subalpine species with a whorl of staminodes that act as false nectaries attracting bees, flies, and herbivorous beetles. We tested the functions of staminodes using controlled manipulative experiments under field and lab conditions. We found a significant decrease in pollinator visits, and subsequent seed set, in flowers in which we removed staminodes or staminode apices confirming the function of these organs. In our natural populations, we found that a beetle, Nonarthra variabilis (Alticinae; Chrysomelidae), chews first on staminode apices, then it eats the entire staminodes and other flower parts, but rarely feeds on ovaries. Additional experiments suggested these beetles preferred staminodes to ovaries. Our results suggest this is a case of selective florivory, in which staminodes play a dual role, attracting pollinators and herbivores at the same time causing the attractive dilemma. Although selective florivory by beetles did not directly damage fruits, it influenced plant-pollinator interactions, decreasing reproductive success in plant populations. Our study highlights the importance of plant-pollinator-herbivore interactions in selecting floral traits.

Successive stamen movement in Saxifraga candelabrum is responsive to weather and pollinator visits

BACKGROUND

Successive stamen movement is a complex plant behavior involving successive uplift of stamens and pollen release, which plays a role in reducing sexual interference, increasing pollen deposition and promoting pollen export. Although reported from several taxa, studies on whether the movement can be influenced by abiotic and biotic factors are scarce.

METHODS

In this study, we here for the first time described a pattern of successive stamen movement in Saxifraga candelabrum (Saxifragaceae). We then compared the rates of stamen movement in S. candelabrum under different weather and varying pollinator visits. Pollen packaging and presentation schedule of S. candelabrum were also investigated.

RESULTS

The results showed that the number of stamens bent per day in sunny days was significantly higher than overcast and rain. Flowers that receive more pollinator visits (control treatment) had significantly higher number of stamen movement than those that received fewer (removal treatment) and none (bagging treatment). Throughout the staminate phase of a flower, there was a progressive increase in both pollen quantity of individual stamens and pollen presentation during each day.

CONCLUSION

Our research demonstrates that successive stamen movement in S. candelabrum was accelerated by favorable weather and increased pollinator visits, which may promote pollen export. Moreover, incremental pollen packaging is likely an adaptation to seasonal regularity in variations of sex ratio resulting from protandry.

Effect of temporal changes in stamen position on reproductive success in flowers with many stamens: Manipulations of stamen position

PREMISE

Male and female reproductive success is enhanced (increased outcrossing and seed production, respectively) by stamen movement in species that have few stamens per flower. Does such enhancement also occur in species that have many stamens per flower?

METHODS

We examined the effects of stamen movement on male and female reproductive success in Anemone flaccida, which has many stamens per flower. We measured stamen movement, including temporal changes in anther-stigma and anther-anther distances. We experimentally fixed stamens in their pre- or post-movement positions.

RESULTS

The anthers moved horizontally away from the stigmas with increasing flower age, thus reducing female-male interference. The dehisced anthers tended to move farther from the stigmas, while the undehisced or dehiscing anthers remained closer to them. The number of anthers touched per flower visit was higher in flowers whose stamens were fixed in the pre-movement position than in flowers whose stamens were fixed in the post-movement position or in flowers that were not manipulated. Thus, this position may promote male reproductive success. Seed production was lower for the untreated flowers than for those with stamens fixed in the post-movement position, suggesting that the post-movement stamen position is advantageous and stamen movement is suboptimal for female reproductive success.

CONCLUSIONS

Stamen movement promotes male reproductive success in the early flowering stage and female reproductive success in the late flowering stage. In species having many stamens per flower, female-male interference can be reduced, but not eliminated, by stamen movement due to the conflict between female and male reproductive successes.

Effects of continuous variation in vertical and lateral herkogamy on reproductive success in Euphorbia fischeriana (Euphorbiaceae)

Continuous variation in herkogamy has been well reported, however, less attention has been paid to the phenomena that the consecutive expression of two types of herkogamy in the same flower. Euphorbia fischeriana, which have both vertical and lateral herkogamy, show vertical herkogamy during the female phase. However, their gynophores bend to one side with the male phase and show lateral herkogamy. In this study, we observed the effect of successive sexual organs movement on variation in herkogamy traits. By artificially manipulating the flower to present gynophore straightened in the floral center or bend to one side, we attempted to investigate whether herkogamy movement affects pollinator access efficiency, pollen removal and deposition, and seed set ratio. Furthermore, we conducted artificial pollination in the female phase to evaluate the effect of changes in pollination environment on the variations in herkogamy traits. The results showed that gynophore straightened in female phase favors pollen deposition, whereas gynophore bending in male phase was conducive to the removal of pollen. Visitation frequency, pollen deposition and removal, and seed set ratio decreased significantly when the gynophore movement was manipulated. Finally, the bending of gynophore was obviously promoted by pollination. Therefore, the continuous variation of herkogamy in the same flower of E. fischeriana caused by the bending of the gynophore could improve the accuracy of pollination and avoid the interference of the ovary with access efficiency. That may be an adaptive strategy when pollinators are scarce. Furthermore, our study also provides good support for the hypothesis that variations in herkogamy traits are strongly selected by differences in pollination environments.

Identification of an anther-specific promoter from a male sterile AB line in Chinese cabbage (Brassica rapa L. ssp. pekinensis)

The promoter of the male sterile gene is important for studying male sterility. In this study, BraA08g014780.3C which differentially expressed between male sterile and fertile plants was identified from a genetic male sterile AB line of Chinese cabbage by RNA-seq. qRT-PCR revealed that BraA08g014780.3C was mainly expressed in the early stage of floral bud development in fertile plants, and preferentially expressed in their anthers. The promoter of BraA08g014780.3C was cloned and analyzed. Cis acting element analysis showed that the promoter of BraA08g014780.3C contains POLLEN1LELAT52 and GTGANTG10, which are both pollen-specific expression elements. The BraA08g014780.3Cp::GUS vector was constructed, then transformed to Arabidopsis thaliana Col-0. PCR analysis and sequencing of the transgenic Arabidopsis revealed that the GUS gene driven by the BraA08g014780.3C promoter was successfully transformed to the Arabidopsis. GUS staining indicated that the promoter of BraA08g014780.3C was an anther-specific promoter. Identifying the anther-specific promoter laid a foundation for revealing BraA08g014780.3C function in male sterility of Chinese cabbage.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s13205-022-03160-z.

Pollination adaptations of group-by-group stamen movement in a meadow plant with temporal floral closure

Floral sexual organ (stamen and pistil) movements are selective adaptations that have different functions in male-female reproduction and the evolution of flowering plants. However, the significance of stamen movements in the spatial-temporal function and separation of male and female organs has not been experimentally determined in species exhibiting floral temporal closure. The current study investigated the role of slow stamen (group-by-group) movement in male-female sexual function, and the effect of stamen movement on pollen removal, male-male and male-female interference, and mating patterns of Geranium pratense, a plant with temporal floral closure. This species uses stamen group-by-group movement and therefore anther-stigma spatial-temporal separation. Spatial separation (two whorls of stamen and pistil length) was shown to be stronger than temporal separation. We found that stamen movements to the center of the flower increase pollen removal, and the most common pollinators visited more frequently and for longer durations during the male floral stage than during the female floral stage. Petal movements increased both self-pollen deposition rate and sexual interference in G. pratense. The fruit and seed set of naturally and outcrossed pollinated flowers were more prolific than those of self-pollinated flowers. Group-by-group stamen movement, dehiscence of stamens, pistil movement, and male-female spatial-temporal functional separation of G. pratense before floral temporal closure may prevent male-female and stamen-stamen interference and pollen discounting, and may increase pollen removal and cross-pollination.

Taxonomic note of Parnassia (Celastraceae) in China II: population surveys reveal that P.guilinensis is conspecific to P.xinganensis

Based on investigation of populations of Parnassiaguilinensis and P.xinganensis, examination of herbarium specimens (including types), as well as consultation of protologues and distributions, P.guilinensis is hereby reduced to a synonym of P.xinganensis. P.xinganensis is endemic to northeastern Guangxi Province of China and characterized by having elliptic to ovate leaves and staminodes 3-5-branched with globose glands. Field photographs and an updated morphological description of P.xinganensis are provided.

Flowers anticipate revisits of pollinators by learning from previously experienced visitation intervals

Plants - and their pollinating counterparts - display complex and sophisticated mechanisms to achieve successful pollination. It probably was only a matter of time for proof of plant intelligence in the context of floral ecology to surface, i.e. the memorization of previous events and a corresponding adjustment of flower behavior. In a recent study we presented a large experimental dataset on the evolution of stamen movement patterns observed in Loasaceae and the apparent role of plant behavior in the diversification of this plant group. The findings at species level suggest that individual plants may be able to adjust the timing of their pollen presentation to the actual pollination scenario they experience. Here we provide first evidence for a pre-emptive stamen presentation in Nasa poissoniana (Loasaceae), based on previously experienced pollinator visitation intervals. Using the unique ability of fast and precise stamen movements in response to a previous stimulus of the nectar scales, the plants should be able to reduce pollen loss and increase outbreeding success via optimizing the timing of male function. We discuss this behavior and its implications in the light of the recent literature and propose questions for future investigations.

A case of behavioural diversification in male floral function - the evolution of thigmonastic pollen presentation

Obvious movements of plant organs have fascinated scientists for a long time. They have been studied extensively, but few behavioural studies to date have dealt with them, and hardly anything is known about their evolution. Here, we present a large experimental dataset on the stamen movement patterns found in the Loasaceae subfam. Loasoideae (Cornales). An evolutionary transition from autonomous-only to a combination of autonomous and thigmonastic stamen movement with increased complexity was experimentally demonstrated. We compare the stamen movement patterns with extensive pollinator observations and discuss it in the context of male mating behavior. Thigmonastic pollen presentation via stamen movements appears to be a crucial component of floral adaptation to pollinator behaviour, evolving in concert with complex adjustments of flower signal, reward and morphology. We hypothesize that rapid adjustments of pollen presentation timing may play a significant role in the diversification of this plant group, representing a striking example for the evolutionary significance of plant behaviour.

Effect of expanded variation in anther position on pollinator visitation to wild radish, Raphanus raphanistrum

BACKGROUND AND AIMS

Plant-pollinator interactions shape the evolution of flowers. Floral attraction and reward traits have often been shown to affect pollinator behaviour, but the possible effect of efficiency traits on visitation behaviour has rarely been addressed. Anther position, usually considered a trait that influences efficiency of pollen deposition on pollinators, was tested here for its effect on pollinator visitation rates and visit duration in flowers of wild radish, Raphanus raphanistrum .

METHODS

Artificial selection lines from two experiments that expanded the naturally occurring phenotypic variation in anther position were used. In one experiment, plant lines were selected either to increase or to decrease anther exsertion. The other experiment decreased anther dimorphism, which resulted in increased short stamen exsertion. The hypothesis was that increased exsertion would increase visitation of pollen foragers due to increased visual attraction. Another hypothesis was that exsertion of anthers above the corolla would interfere with nectar foragers and increase the duration of visit per flower.

KEY RESULTS

In the exsertion selection experiment, increased exsertion of both short and long stamens resulted in an increased number of fly visits per plant, and in the dimorphism experiment bee visits increased with increased short stamen exsertion. The duration of visits of nectar feeders declined significantly with increasing long stamen exsertion, which was opposite to the hypothesis.

CONCLUSIONS

Until now, anther position was considered to be an efficiency trait to enhance pollen uptake and deposition. Anther position in wild radish is shown here also to have an ecological significance in attracting pollen foragers. This study suggests an additional adaptive role for anther position beyond efficiency, and highlights the multiple ecological functions of floral traits in plant-pollinator interactions.

Slow stamen movement in a perennial herb decreases male-male and male-female interference

Approximately 80 % of angiosperm species produce hermaphroditic flowers, which face the problem of male-male sexual interference (one or more anthers gets in the way of disseminating pollen from other anthers) or male-female sexual interference (the pistil interferes with disseminating pollen from the anthers by preventing the anther from touching a pollinator, or the anther prevents pollinator from depositing outcross pollen on the stigma). Slow stamen movement in hermaphrodite flowers has been interpreted as an adaptation for reducing male-male sexual interference. Using slow stamen movement in Lychnis cognata (Caryophyllaceae), this study presents new evidence that this phenomenon can reduce both male-male and male-female sexual interference. Ten stamens in L. cognata flowers vertically elongated their filaments in two batches and displayed similar patterns in pollen dispensing. More importantly, 10 stamens bend out of the floral centre by curving the filament also in 2 batches and pollen grains located at the flower centre displayed the highest viability. Thus, three stages of stamen movement can be identified, comprising two male stages (M1 and M2) and one female stage (F). We found that the main pollinator for L. cognata, Bhutanitis yulongensis (Papilionodae) generally preferred M1 flowers. Manipulation experiments show that vertical stamen movement enabled the anthers to dehisce at different times to prolong the presentation of pollen grains. Horizontal movement of the stamen decreased both male-male and male-female interference. However, vertical stamen movement had a minor role in increasing amount of pollen received by the stigma. This study provides the first direct experimental evidence of concurrent male-male and male-female interference in a flower. We suggest that the selection pressure to reduce such interference might be a strong force in floral evolution. We also propose that other selective pressure, including pollen dispensing mechanisms, pollen longevity, pollinator behaviour and weather, might contribute to floral evolution.

Sequential stamen maturation and movement in a protandrous herb: mechanisms increasing pollination efficiency and reducing sexual interference

Successive stamen movement directly controls pollen presentation schedules through sequential stamen maturation and changes the extent of herkogamy by altering the positions of sexual organs. However, the implications of such movements in terms of pollination are not well understood. Pollen presentation theory predicts that staggered pollen presentation should be favoured when plants are subject to diminishing returns on pollen transfer. Herkogamy on the other hand, has been interpreted as an adaptive trait that reduces sexual interference in hermaphrodite flowers. In this study, we conducted floral manipulations to determine the function of successive stamen movement in pollen transfer. By artificially manipulating the flowers to present two anthers simultaneously in the floral centre, we attempted to investigate whether changes in the anther presentation strategy affect pollen removal, deposition and the efficiency of pollinators. Compared with the natural treatment, the pollen transfer efficiency of halictid bees decreased significantly when the flowers were manipulated to present two anthers simultaneously. Although the presentation of two anthers simultaneously led to a similar pollen removal rate, there was a significant reduction in pollen deposition on neighbouring stigmas. To evaluate the effect of movement herkogamy on pollen export and deposition and seed set, the flowers were manipulated with or without the movement of stamen bending out from the floral centre. Pollen export decreased significantly when the central anther was moved away from the pistil, and pollen deposition and seed set declined significantly when the five spent anthers were retained on the pistil. Our study provides good support for the pollen presentation theory and provides direct experimental evidence that successive stamen movement could increase pollen transfer efficiency by sequential stamen maturation. Moreover, movement herkogamy promotes pollen export, deposition and seed set, and could therefore be regarded as an effective mechanism to reduce interference between male and female functions.