Morphological Profiles of RNAi-Induced Gene Knockdown Are Highly Reproducible but Dominated by Seed Effects

A Decade in a Systematic Review: The Evolution and Impact of Cell Painting

High-content image-based assays have fueled significant discoveries in the life sciences in the past decade (2013-2023), including novel insights into disease etiology, mechanism of action, new therapeutics, and toxicology predictions. Here, we systematically review the substantial methodological advancements and applications of Cell Painting. Advancements include improvements in the Cell Painting protocol, assay adaptations for different types of perturbations and applications, and improved methodologies for feature extraction, quality control, and batch effect correction. Moreover, machine learning methods recently surpassed classical approaches in their ability to extract biologically useful information from Cell Painting images. Cell Painting data have been used alone or in combination with other - omics data to decipher the mechanism of action of a compound, its toxicity profile, and many other biological effects. Overall, key methodological advances have expanded Cell Painting's ability to capture cellular responses to various perturbations. Future advances will likely lie in advancing computational and experimental techniques, developing new publicly available datasets, and integrating them with other high-content data types.

A Decade in a Systematic Review: The Evolution and Impact of Cell Painting

High-content image-based assays have fueled significant discoveries in the life sciences in the past decade (2013-2023), including novel insights into disease etiology, mechanism of action, new therapeutics, and toxicology predictions. Here, we systematically review the substantial methodological advancements and applications of Cell Painting. Advancements include improvements in the Cell Painting protocol, assay adaptations for different types of perturbations and applications, and improved methodologies for feature extraction, quality control, and batch effect correction. Moreover, machine learning methods recently surpassed classical approaches in their ability to extract biologically useful information from Cell Painting images. Cell Painting data have been used alone or in combination with other -omics data to decipher the mechanism of action of a compound, its toxicity profile, and many other biological effects. Overall, key methodological advances have expanded Cell Painting's ability to capture cellular responses to various perturbations. Future advances will likely lie in advancing computational and experimental techniques, developing new publicly available datasets, and integrating them with other high-content data types.

Robust and unbiased estimation of the background distribution for automated quantitative imaging

Background estimation is the first step in quantitative analysis of images. It has an impact on all subsequent analyses, in particular for segmentation and calculation of ratiometric quantities. Most methods recover only a single value such as the median or yield a biased estimation in non-trivial cases. We introduce, to our knowledge, the first method to recover an unbiased estimation of background distribution. It leverages the lack of local spatial correlation in background pixels to robustly select a subset that accurately represents the background. The resulting background distribution can be used to test for foreground membership of individual pixels or estimate confidence intervals in derived quantities.

Image-based profiling for drug discovery: due for a machine-learning upgrade?

Image-based profiling is a maturing strategy by which the rich information present in biological images is reduced to a multidimensional profile, a collection of extracted image-based features. These profiles can be mined for relevant patterns, revealing unexpected biological activity that is useful for many steps in the drug discovery process. Such applications include identifying disease-associated screenable phenotypes, understanding disease mechanisms and predicting a drug's activity, toxicity or mechanism of action. Several of these applications have been recently validated and have moved into production mode within academia and the pharmaceutical industry. Some of these have yielded disappointing results in practice but are now of renewed interest due to improved machine-learning strategies that better leverage image-based information. Although challenges remain, novel computational technologies such as deep learning and single-cell methods that better capture the biological information in images hold promise for accelerating drug discovery.

Deep learning predicts function of live retinal pigment epithelium from quantitative microscopy

Increases in the number of cell therapies in the preclinical and clinical phases have prompted the need for reliable and noninvasive assays to validate transplant function in clinical biomanufacturing. We developed a robust characterization methodology composed of quantitative bright-field absorbance microscopy (QBAM) and deep neural networks (DNNs) to noninvasively predict tissue function and cellular donor identity. The methodology was validated using clinical-grade induced pluripotent stem cell-derived retinal pigment epithelial cells (iPSC-RPE). QBAM images of iPSC-RPE were used to train DNNs that predicted iPSC-RPE monolayer transepithelial resistance, predicted polarized vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF) secretion, and matched iPSC-RPE monolayers to the stem cell donors. DNN predictions were supplemented with traditional machine-learning algorithms that identified shape and texture features of single cells that were used to predict tissue function and iPSC donor identity. These results demonstrate noninvasive cell therapy characterization can be achieved with QBAM and machine learning.

Virtual organelle self-coding for fluorescence imaging via adversarial learning

SIGNIFICANCE

Our study introduces an application of deep learning to virtually generate fluorescence images to reduce the burdens of cost and time from considerable effort in sample preparation related to chemical fixation and staining.

AIM

The objective of our work was to determine how successfully deep learning methods perform on fluorescence prediction that depends on structural and/or a functional relationship between input labels and output labels.

APPROACH

We present a virtual-fluorescence-staining method based on deep neural networks (VirFluoNet) to transform co-registered images of cells into subcellular compartment-specific molecular fluorescence labels in the same field-of-view. An algorithm based on conditional generative adversarial networks was developed and trained on microscopy datasets from breast-cancer and bone-osteosarcoma cell lines: MDA-MB-231 and U2OS, respectively. Several established performance metrics-the mean absolute error (MAE), peak-signal-to-noise ratio (PSNR), and structural-similarity-index (SSIM)-as well as a novel performance metric, the tolerance level, were measured and compared for the same algorithm and input data.

RESULTS

For the MDA-MB-231 cells, F-actin signal performed the fluorescent antibody staining of vinculin prediction better than phase-contrast as an input. For the U2OS cells, satisfactory metrics of performance were archieved in comparison with ground truth. MAE is <0.005, 0.017, 0.012; PSNR is >40  /  34  /  33  dB; and SSIM is >0.925  /  0.926  /  0.925 for 4',6-diamidino-2-phenylindole/hoechst, endoplasmic reticulum, and mitochondria prediction, respectively, from channels of nucleoli and cytoplasmic RNA, Golgi plasma membrane, and F-actin.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings contribute to the understanding of the utility and limitations of deep learning image-regression to predict fluorescence microscopy datasets of biological cells. We infer that predicted image labels must have either a structural and/or a functional relationship to input labels. Furthermore, the approach introduced here holds promise for modeling the internal spatial relationships between organelles and biomolecules within living cells, leading to detection and quantification of alterations from a standard training dataset.

Heterogeneous response of endothelial cells to insulin-like growth factor 1 treatment is explained by spatially clustered sub-populations

A common strategy to measure the efficacy of drug treatment is the in vitro comparison of ensemble readouts with and without treatment, such as proliferation and cell death. A fundamental assumption underlying this approach is that there exists minimal cell-to-cell variability in the response to a drug. Here, we demonstrate that ensemble and non-spatial single-cell readouts applied to primary cells may lead to incomplete conclusions due to cell-to-cell variability. We exposed primary fetal pulmonary artery endothelial cells (PAEC) isolated from healthy newborn sheep and persistent pulmonary hypertension of the newborn (PPHN) sheep to the growth hormone, insulin-like growth factor 1 (IGF-1). We found that IGF-1 increased proliferation and branch points in tube formation assays but not angiogenic signaling proteins at the population level for both cell types. We hypothesized that this molecular ambiguity was due to the presence of cellular sub-populations with variable responses to IGF-1. Using high throughput single-cell imaging, we discovered a spatially localized response to IGF-1. This suggests localized signaling or heritable cell response to external stimuli may ultimately be responsible for our observations. Discovering and further exploring these rare cells is critical to finding new molecular targets to restore cellular function.

Systematic exploration of cell morphological phenotypes associated with a transcriptomic query

Cell morphological phenotypes, including shape, size, intensity, and texture of cellular compartments have been shown to change in response to perturbation with small molecule compounds. Image-based cell profiling or cell morphological profiling has been used to associate changes of cell morphological features with alterations in cellular function and to infer molecular mechanisms of action. Recently, the Library of Integrated Network-based Cellular Signatures (LINCS) Project has measured gene expression and performed image-based cell profiling on cell lines treated with 9515 unique compounds. These data provide an opportunity to study the interdependence between transcription and cell morphology. Previous methods to investigate cell phenotypes have focused on targeting candidate genes as components of known pathways, RNAi morphological profiling, and cataloging morphological defects; however, these methods do not provide an explicit model to link transcriptomic changes with corresponding alterations in morphology. To address this, we propose a cell morphology enrichment analysis to assess the association between transcriptomic alterations and changes in cell morphology. Additionally, for a new transcriptomic query, our approach can be used to predict associated changes in cellular morphology. We demonstrate the utility of our method by applying it to cell morphological changes in a human bone osteosarcoma cell line.

Growth-restricting effects of siRNA transfections: a largely deterministic combination of off-target binding and hybridization-independent competition

Perturbation of gene expression by means of synthetic small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) is a powerful way to uncover gene function. However, siRNA technology suffers from sequence-specific off-target effects and from limitations in knock-down efficiency. In this study, we assess a further problem: unintended effects of siRNA transfections on cellular fitness/proliferation. We show that the nucleotide compositions of siRNAs at specific positions have reproducible growth-restricting effects on mammalian cells in culture. This is likely distinct from hybridization-dependent off-target effects, since each nucleotide residue is seen to be acting independently and additively. The effect is robust and reproducible across different siRNA libraries and also across various cell lines, including human and mouse cells. Analyzing the growth inhibition patterns in correlation to the nucleotide sequence of the siRNAs allowed us to build a predictor that can estimate growth-restricting effects for any arbitrary siRNA sequence. Competition experiments with co-transfected siRNAs further suggest that the growth-restricting effects might be linked to an oversaturation of the cellular miRNA machinery, thus disrupting endogenous miRNA functions at large. We caution that competition between siRNA molecules could complicate the interpretation of double-knockdown or epistasis experiments, and potential interactions with endogenous miRNAs can be a factor when assaying cell growth or viability phenotypes.

Evaluation and control of miRNA-like off-target repression for RNA interference

RNA interference (RNAi) has been widely adopted to repress specific gene expression and is easily achieved by designing small interfering RNAs (siRNAs) with perfect sequence complementarity to the intended target mRNAs. Although siRNAs direct Argonaute (Ago), a core component of the RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC), to recognize and silence target mRNAs, they also inevitably function as microRNAs (miRNAs) and suppress hundreds of off-targets. Such miRNA-like off-target repression is potentially detrimental, resulting in unwanted toxicity and phenotypes. Despite early recognition of the severity of miRNA-like off-target repression, this effect has often been overlooked because of difficulties in recognizing and avoiding off-targets. However, recent advances in genome-wide methods and knowledge of Ago-miRNA target interactions have set the stage for properly evaluating and controlling miRNA-like off-target repression. Here, we describe the intrinsic problems of miRNA-like off-target effects caused by canonical and noncanonical interactions. We particularly focus on various genome-wide approaches and chemical modifications for the evaluation and prevention of off-target repression to facilitate the use of RNAi with secured specificity.

RNA Interference (RNAi) Screening in Drosophila

In the last decade, RNA interference (RNAi), a cellular mechanism that uses RNA-guided degradation of messenger RNA transcripts, has had an important impact on identifying and characterizing gene function. First discovered in Caenorhabditis elegans, RNAi can be used to silence the expression of genes through introduction of exogenous double-stranded RNA into cells. In Drosophila, RNAi has been applied in cultured cells or in vivo to perturb the function of single genes or to systematically probe gene function on a genome-wide scale. In this review, we will describe the use of RNAi to study gene function in Drosophila with a particular focus on high-throughput screening methods applied in cultured cells. We will discuss available reagent libraries and cell lines, methodological approaches for cell-based assays, and computational methods for the analysis of high-throughput screens. Furthermore, we will review the generation and use of genome-scale RNAi libraries for tissue-specific knockdown analysis in vivo and discuss the differences and similarities with the use of genome-engineering methods such as CRISPR/Cas9 for functional analysis.

Large-scale image-based profiling of single-cell phenotypes in arrayed CRISPR-Cas9 gene perturbation screens

High‐content imaging using automated microscopy and computer vision allows multivariate profiling of single‐cell phenotypes. Here, we present methods for the application of the CISPR‐Cas9 system in large‐scale, image‐based, gene perturbation experiments. We show that CRISPR‐Cas9‐mediated gene perturbation can be achieved in human tissue culture cells in a timeframe that is compatible with image‐based phenotyping. We developed a pipeline to construct a large‐scale arrayed library of 2,281 sequence‐verified CRISPR‐Cas9 targeting plasmids and profiled this library for genes affecting cellular morphology and the subcellular localization of components of the nuclear pore complex (NPC). We conceived a machine‐learning method that harnesses genetic heterogeneity to score gene perturbations and identify phenotypically perturbed cells for in‐depth characterization of gene perturbation effects. This approach enables genome‐scale image‐based multivariate gene perturbation profiling using CRISPR‐Cas9.

Am I ready for CRISPR? A user's guide to genetic screens

Exciting new technologies are often self-limiting in their rollout, as access to state-of-the-art instrumentation or the need for years of hands-on experience, for better or worse, ensures slow adoption by the community. CRISPR technology, however, presents the opposite dilemma, where the simplicity of the system enabled the parallel development of many applications, improvements and derivatives, and new users are now presented with an almost paralyzing abundance of choices. This Review intends to guide users through the process of applying CRISPR technology to their biological problems of interest, especially in the context of discovering gene function at scale.

Evaluation of RNAi and CRISPR technologies by large-scale gene expression profiling in the Connectivity Map

The application of RNA interference (RNAi) to mammalian cells has provided the means to perform phenotypic screens to determine the functions of genes. Although RNAi has revolutionized loss-of-function genetic experiments, it has been difficult to systematically assess the prevalence and consequences of off-target effects. The Connectivity Map (CMAP) represents an unprecedented resource to study the gene expression consequences of expressing short hairpin RNAs (shRNAs). Analysis of signatures for over 13,000 shRNAs applied in 9 cell lines revealed that microRNA (miRNA)-like off-target effects of RNAi are far stronger and more pervasive than generally appreciated. We show that mitigating off-target effects is feasible in these datasets via computational methodologies to produce a consensus gene signature (CGS). In addition, we compared RNAi technology to clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeat (CRISPR)-based knockout by analysis of 373 single guide RNAs (sgRNAs) in 6 cells lines and show that the on-target efficacies are comparable, but CRISPR technology is far less susceptible to systematic off-target effects. These results will help guide the proper use and analysis of loss-of-function reagents for the determination of gene function.

Data-analysis strategies for image-based cell profiling

Image-based cell profiling is a high-throughput strategy for the quantification of phenotypic differences among a variety of cell populations. It paves the way to studying biological systems on a large scale by using chemical and genetic perturbations. The general workflow for this technology involves image acquisition with high-throughput microscopy systems and subsequent image processing and analysis. Here, we introduce the steps required to create high-quality image-based (i.e., morphological) profiles from a collection of microscopy images. We recommend techniques that have proven useful in each stage of the data analysis process, on the basis of the experience of 20 laboratories worldwide that are refining their image-based cell-profiling methodologies in pursuit of biological discovery. The recommended techniques cover alternatives that may suit various biological goals, experimental designs, and laboratories' preferences.

Genome-scale CRISPR pooled screens

Genome editing technologies such as clustered regularly interspaced short palindromic repeats (CRISPR) systems have ushered in a new era of targeted DNA manipulation. The easy programmability of CRISPR using short oligonucleotides enables rapid synthesis of large-scale libraries for functional genetic screens. Here we present fundamental concepts and methods for pooled CRISPR screens and review biological results from recent genome-scale loss-of-function and gain-of-function screens. We also discuss new frontiers in pooled screens, including novel effector domains for functional screens and applications in the noncoding genome.

High-Throughput Imaging for the Discovery of Cellular Mechanisms of Disease

High-throughput imaging (HTI) is a powerful tool in the discovery of cellular disease mechanisms. While traditional approaches to identify disease pathways often rely on knowledge of the causative genetic defect, HTI-based screens offer an unbiased discovery approach based on any morphological or functional defects of disease cells or tissues. In this review, we provide an overview of the use of HTI for the study of human disease mechanisms. We discuss key technical aspects of HTI and highlight representative examples of its practical applications for the discovery of molecular mechanisms of disease, focusing on infectious diseases and host-pathogen interactions, cancer, and rare genetic diseases. We also present some of the current challenges and possible solutions offered by novel cell culture systems and genome engineering approaches.

RIsearch2: suffix array-based large-scale prediction of RNA-RNA interactions and siRNA off-targets

Intermolecular interactions of ncRNAs are at the core of gene regulation events, and identifying the full map of these interactions bears crucial importance for ncRNA functional studies. It is known that RNA-RNA interactions are built up by complementary base pairings between interacting RNAs and high level of complementarity between two RNA sequences is a powerful predictor of such interactions. Here, we present RIsearch2, a large-scale RNA-RNA interaction prediction tool that enables quick localization of potential near-complementary RNA-RNA interactions between given query and target sequences. In contrast to previous heuristics which either search for exact matches while including G-U wobble pairs or employ simplified energy models, we present a novel approach using a single integrated seed-and-extend framework based on suffix arrays. RIsearch2 enables fast discovery of candidate RNA-RNA interactions on genome/transcriptome-wide scale. We furthermore present an siRNA off-target discovery pipeline that not only predicts the off-target transcripts but also computes the off-targeting potential of a given siRNA. This is achieved by combining genome-wide RIsearch2 predictions with target site accessibilities and transcript abundance estimates. We show that this pipeline accurately predicts siRNA off-target interactions and enables off-targeting potential comparisons between different siRNA designs. RIsearch2 and the siRNA off-target discovery pipeline are available as stand-alone software packages from http://rth.dk/resources/risearch.

Systematic morphological profiling of human gene and allele function via Cell Painting

We hypothesized that human genes and disease-associated alleles might be systematically functionally annotated using morphological profiling of cDNA constructs, via a microscopy-based Cell Painting assay. Indeed, 50% of the 220 tested genes yielded detectable morphological profiles, which grouped into biologically meaningful gene clusters consistent with known functional annotation (e.g., the RAS-RAF-MEK-ERK cascade). We used novel subpopulation-based visualization methods to interpret the morphological changes for specific clusters. This unbiased morphologic map of gene function revealed TRAF2/c-REL negative regulation of YAP1/WWTR1-responsive pathways. We confirmed this discovery of functional connectivity between the NF-κB pathway and Hippo pathway effectors at the transcriptional level, thereby expanding knowledge of these two signaling pathways that critically regulate tumor initiation and progression. We make the images and raw data publicly available, providing an initial morphological map of major biological pathways for future study.

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.24060.001

Many human diseases are caused by particular changes, called mutations, in patients’ DNA. A genome is the complete DNA set of an organism, which contains all the information to build the body and keep it working. This information is stored as a code made up of four chemicals called bases. Humans have about 30,000 genes built from DNA, which contain specific sequences of bases. Genome sequencing can determine the exact order of these bases, and has revealed a long list of mutations in genes that could cause particular diseases. However, over 30% of genes in the human body do not have a known role. Genes can serve multiple roles, some of which are not yet discovered, and even when a gene’s purpose is known, the impact of each particular mutation in a given gene is largely uncatalogued. Therefore, new methods need to be developed to identify the biological roles of both normal and abnormal gene sequences.

For hundreds of years, biologists have used microscopy to study how living cells work. Rohban et al. have now asked whether modern software that extracts data from microscopy images could create a fingerprint-like profile of a cell that would reflect how its genes affect its role and appearance. While some genes do not necessarily carry a code with instructions of what a cell should look like, they can indirectly modify the structure of the cell. The resulting changes in the shape of the cell can then be captured in images. The idea was that two cells with matching profiles would indicate that their combinations of genes had matching biological roles too.

Rohban et al. tested their approach with human cells grown in the laboratory. In each sample of cells, they ‘turned on’ one of a few hundred relatively well-known human genes, some of which were known to have similar roles. The cells were then stained via a technique called ‘Cell Painting’ to reveal eight specific components of each cell, including its DNA and its surface membrane. The stained cells were imaged under a microscope and the resulting microscopy images analyzed to create a profile of each type of cell. Rohban et al. confirmed that turning on genes known to perform similar biological roles lead to similar-looking cells. The analysis also revealed a previously unknown interaction between two major pathways in the cell that control how cancer starts and develops.

In the future, this approach could predict the biological roles of less-understood genes by looking for profiles that match those of well-known genes. Applying this strategy to every human gene, and mutations in genes that are linked to diseases, could help to answer many mysteries about how genes build the human body and keep it working.

DOI:http://dx.doi.org/10.7554/eLife.24060.002

Profiling DNA damage response following mitotic perturbations

Genome integrity relies on precise coordination between DNA replication and chromosome segregation. Whereas replication stress attracted much attention, the consequences of mitotic perturbations for genome integrity are less understood. Here, we knockdown 47 validated mitotic regulators to show that a broad spectrum of mitotic errors correlates with increased DNA breakage in daughter cells. Unexpectedly, we find that only a subset of these correlations are functionally linked. We identify the genuine mitosis-born DNA damage events and sub-classify them according to penetrance of the observed phenotypes. To demonstrate the potential of this resource, we show that DNA breakage after cytokinesis failure is preceded by replication stress, which mounts during consecutive cell cycles and coincides with decreased proliferation. Together, our results provide a resource to gauge the magnitude and dynamics of DNA breakage associated with mitotic aberrations and suggest that replication stress might limit propagation of cells with abnormal karyotypes.

DNA damage arising from replication stress is well studied, but the effect of mitotic errors on genome integrity is less understood. Here the authors knock down 47 mitotic regulators and record how they impact on DNA breakage events, providing a resource for future studies on the relation between cell division and genome integrity.

Cell Painting, a high-content image-based assay for morphological profiling using multiplexed fluorescent dyes

In morphological profiling, quantitative data are extracted from microscopy images of cells to identify biologically relevant similarities and differences among samples based on these profiles. This protocol describes the design and execution of experiments using Cell Painting, which is a morphological profiling assay that multiplexes six fluorescent dyes, imaged in five channels, to reveal eight broadly relevant cellular components or organelles. Cells are plated in multiwell plates, perturbed with the treatments to be tested, stained, fixed, and imaged on a high-throughput microscope. Next, an automated image analysis software identifies individual cells and measures ∼1,500 morphological features (various measures of size, shape, texture, intensity, and so on) to produce a rich profile that is suitable for the detection of subtle phenotypes. Profiles of cell populations treated with different experimental perturbations can be compared to suit many goals, such as identifying the phenotypic impact of chemical or genetic perturbations, grouping compounds and/or genes into functional pathways, and identifying signatures of disease. Cell culture and image acquisition takes 2 weeks; feature extraction and data analysis take an additional 1-2 weeks.

Applications in image-based profiling of perturbations

A dramatic shift has occurred in how biologists use microscopy images. Whether experiments are small-scale or high-throughput, automatically quantifying biological properties in images is now widespread. We see yet another revolution under way: a transition towards using automated image analysis to not only identify phenotypes a biologist specifically seeks to measure ('screening') but also as an unbiased and sensitive tool to capture a wide variety of subtle features of cell (or organism) state ('profiling'). Mapping similarities among samples using image-based (morphological) profiling has tremendous potential to transform drug discovery, functional genomics, and basic biological research. Applications include target identification, lead hopping, library enrichment, functionally annotating genes/alleles, and identifying small molecule modulators of gene activity and disease-specific phenotypes.