A Novel AXIN2 Missense Mutation Is Associated with Non-Syndromic Oligodontia

Tooth agenesis related to a novel KDF1 variant: A case report and literature review

OBJECTIVES

To investigate the role of Keratinocyte Differentiation Factor 1 (KDF1) in ectodermal dysplasia (ED) and nonsyndromic tooth agenesis (NSTA) and perform a literature review.

METHODS

Genome sequencing was used to identify genetic variants in a Thai, NSTA proband and validated through Sanger sequencing. Pathogenicity was assessed using ACMG guidelines, MetaRNN and AlphaMissense. A comprehensive review of KDF1/NSTA cases informed genotype-phenotype analysis of the proband.

RESULTS

The proband revealed multiple missing teeth, caries and extensive periodontal disease. Deep phenotyping showed no signs of ED beyond tooth agenesis. The identified novel KDF1 variant, p.Ile243Leu, was classified as 'likely pathogenic' by ACMG and predicted as 'detrimental' by MetaRNN and AlphaMissense analyses. A total of 14 reviewed KDF1 cases revealed ED-associated variants (3 variants in 8 patients) clustering in the region of amino acids 251-275, within the DUF4656 domain, while NSTA-causing variants (4 variants in 6 patients) were typically found in amino- or carboxy-termini to this region. KDF1/NSTA cases exhibited an average of 15 missing teeth, with a higher prevalence in the mandible.

CONCLUSION

This study identifies a novel KDF1 variant-related NSTA in Thai people. The genotype-phenotype correlates suggest a distinctive pattern and tooth agenesis of KDF1-related NSTA.

Identification and functional study of a novel variant of PAX9 causing tooth agenesis

OBJECTIVES

To search for pathogenic gene of a family with non-syndromic tooth agenesis, and explore the possible pathogenesis.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A Chinese family with non-syndromic tooth agenesis was recruited and screened for the pathogenic variants by whole exome sequencing technology and co-segregation analysis. The subcellular localization of wild-type and mutant protein was detected by immunofluorescence assay. Cycloheximide chase assay was performed to examine the difference in degradation rate between mutant protein and wild-type one. Dual-luciferase reporter assays were conducted to explore the alterations of mutant protein in the regulation of downstream target genes.

RESULTS

A novel missense variant of PAX9 (c.296C>A:p.A99D) was found in this family. Bioinformatics software showed β-return and the random coil were shortened in the p.A99D. The variant did not affect the subcellular localization of PAX9, but the degradation rate of p.A99D was accelerated (p < 0.05). p.A99D inhibited the activation of downstream target gene BMP4 (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

This novel variant expands the pathogenic gene spectrum. The variant impaired the protein structure, accelerated the degradation of protein, and inhibited the activation of the downstream target gene BMP4, an upstream molecule in the TGF-β/BMP pathway, which may contribute to tooth agenesis in this family.

Pan-cancer analysis reveals the characteristics and roles of tooth agenesis mutant genes

Tooth development is regulated by numerous genes and signaling pathways. Some studies suggest that mutations in these genes may be associated with several cancer types. However, the tooth agenesis mutated genes role in the prognosis and their clinical therapeutic potentials in pan-cancer have not been elaborately explored. Moreover, the intrinsic correlation between tooth agenesis and cancers also needs to be further verified. We preliminarily analyzed expression levels and prognostic values of causative genes of tooth agenesis, and explored the correlation between the expression of tooth agenesis mutated genes and TME, Stemness score, clinical characteristic, immune subtype, and drug sensitivity in pan-cancer, which based on updated public databases and integrated some bioinformatics analysis methods. In addition, we conducted the enrichment analysis of tooth agenesis mutant genes from KOBAS database. We observed that TA mutant genes had significant gene expression differences in multiple cancer types compared with normal tissues. The expression of causative genes of TA is associated with the prognosis in several cancers from different databases. For example, AXIN2 and MSX1 were correlated to the overall survival (OS) of uterine corpus endometrial carcinoma. PAX9 and TP63 were related to OS of lung squamous cell carcinoma. And TP63 was associated with OS in breast invasive carcinoma and pancreatic adenocarcinoma. Furthermore, the expression of TA mutant genes also has a significant correlation with stromal and immune scores, and RNA stemness score and DNA stemness score in pan-cancer. Besides, we observed that all causative genes of TA were significantly correlated with immune subtypes. Moreover, KEGG pathway analysis showed that causative genes of TA were associated with the development and progression of breast cancer, basal cell carcinoma, gastric cancer, and hepatocellular carcinoma. Finally, AXIN2 expression has a significantly positive or negative correlation with drug sensitivity. Our study indicates the great potential of TA mutant genes as biomarkers for prognosis and provides valuable strategies for further investigation of TA mutant genes as potential therapeutic targets in cancers. Our study can further verify that there may be an intrinsic correlation between tooth agenesis and the occurrence of multiple cancers.

Tooth agenesis patterns and variants in PAX9: A systematic review

Mutations in PAX9 are the most common genetic cause of tooth agenesis (TA). The aim of this study was to systematically review the profiles of the TA and PAX9 variants and establish their genotype-phenotype correlation. Forty articles were eligible for 178 patients and 61 mutations (26 in frame and 32 null mutations). PAX9 mutations predominantly affected molars, mostly the second molar, and the mandibular first premolar was the least affected. More missing teeth were found in the maxilla than the mandible, and with null mutations than in-frame mutations. The number of missing teeth was correlated with the locations of the in-frame mutations with the C-terminus mutations demonstrating the fewest missing teeth. The null mutation location did not influence the number of missing teeth. Null mutations in all locations predominantly affected molars. For the in-frame mutations, a missing second molar was commonly associated with mutations in the highly conserved paired DNA-binding domain, particularly the linking peptide (100% prevalence). In contrast, C-terminus mutations were rarely associated with missing second molars and anterior teeth, but were commonly related to an absent second premolar. These finding indicate that the mutation type and position contribute to different degrees of loss of PAX9 function that further differentially influences the manifestations of TA. This study provides novel information on the correlation of the PAX9 genotype-phenotype, aiding in the genetic counseling for TA.

The Profile of Articles on AXIN2 Mutations, Oligodontia, and Ethical Statements in Dental Research

PURPOSE

Editors often require ethical statements in research publications. This is particularly important with genetic data where discrimination may occur upon data disclosures. The purpose of this research is to determine if there was a positive trend of publishing ethical statements in dental genetic research. The study is limited to AXIN2 mutations which may be associated with oligodontia and cancer.

METHODS

A MEDLINE search of 2011-2021 articles concerning AXIN2, oligodontia, and ethical statements was conducted. Reviews, nonhuman subject research, abstracts, and articles not written nor translated into English were excluded.

RESULTS

Forty-four studies were found; 10 excluded. There were 25 (75.8%) with ethical statements, and 25 (75.8%) with participant consent statements. There was no significant difference by year in ethical statements over the ten years (p = 0.094).

CONCLUSION

There is a need to encourage more ethical statements in publications especially for genetically sensitive topics to reassure readers of ethical practices.

Non-syndromic familial congenital dental deficiency: two cases report

Congenital dental deficiency can lead to aesthetic and masticatory dysfunction, which have a great effect on the quality of life of patients. Genetic inheritance is the determining factor of congenital dental deficiency, which may follow the pattern of autosomal dominant, recessive, or sex chromosome inheritance. However, the specific genetic mechanisms are not clear. The prevalence of congenital absence of permanent teeth in the general population worldwide are not high, and familial oligodontia in clinically healthy patients is rare. This paper reported two cases of familial non-syndromic congenital teeth loss and included a review of literature referring to the etiology, clinical manifestations, and treatment of congenital dental deficiency.

Four Novel PAX9 Variants and the PAX9-Related Non-Syndromic Tooth Agenesis Patterns

The purpose of this research was to investigate and identify PAX9 gene variants in four Chinese families with non-syndromic tooth agenesis. We identified pathogenic gene variants by whole-exome sequencing (WES) and Sanger sequencing and then studied the effects of these variants on function by bioinformatics analysis and in vitro experiments. Four novel PAX9 heterozygous variants were identified: two missense variants (c.191G > T (p.G64V) and c.350T > G (p.V117G)) and two frameshift variants (c.352delC (p.S119Pfs*2) and c.648_649insC(p.Y217Lfs*100)). The bioinformatics analysis showed that these variants might be pathogenic. The tertiary structure analysis showed that these four variants could cause structural damage to PAX9 proteins. In vitro functional studies demonstrated that (1) the p.Y217Lfs*100 variant greatly affects mRNA stability, thereby affecting endogenous expression; (2) the p. S119Pfs* 2 variant impairs the subcellular localization of the nuclear expression of the wild-type PAX9 protein; and (3) the four variants (p.G64V, p.V117G, p.S119Pfs*2, and p.Y217Lfs*100) all significantly affect the downstream transcriptional activity of the BMP4 gene. In addition, we summarized and analyzed tooth missing positions caused by PAX9 variants and found that the maxillary second molar (84.11%) and mandibular second molar (84.11%) were the most affected tooth positions by summarizing and analyzing the PAX9-related non-syndromic tooth agenesis positions. Our results broaden the variant spectrum of the PAX9 gene related to non-syndromic tooth agenesis and provide useful information for future genetic counseling.

Familial colorectal cancer and tooth agenesis caused by an AXIN2 variant: how do we detect families with rare cancer predisposition syndromes?

We present a three-generation family with an AXIN2 variant and a family history of colorectal cancer (CRC), colon polyps and tooth agenesis. A likely pathogenic variant was detected in the AXIN2 gene (c.1994dup; p.(Asn666Glnfs*41)). This variant has previously been associated with tooth agenesis and polyposis, only. In this case report we describe eight carriers with tooth agenesis and variable clinical findings, including polyps and CRC. Our case provides additional knowledge to the sparse data on genotype-phenotype association related to AXIN2 associated cancer syndrome. Further, our case highlights the importance of analysing an extended CRC and oligodontia/ectodermal dysplasia gene panel including AXIN2 but also raises awareness and discussion about appropriate surveillance program.

Patterns of molar agenesis associated with p.P20L and p.R77Q variants in PAX9

Nonsyndromic tooth agenesis is associated with variants in several genes. There are numerous genotype-phenotype publications involving many patients and kindreds. Here, we identified six Thai individuals in two families with nonsyndromic tooth agenesis, performed exome sequencing, and conducted functional experiments. Family 1 had four affected members carrying the heterozygous PAX9 variant, c.59C>T (p.Pro20Leu). The p.Pro20Leu was previously reported in two families having four and three affected members. These seven cases and Proband-1 had agenesis of at least three third molars. Family 2 comprised two affected members with agenesis of all 12 molars. Both individuals were heterozygous for c.230G>A (p.Arg77Gln) in PAX9, which has not been reported previously. This variant is predicted to be damaging, evolutionarily conserved, and resides in the PAX9 linking peptide. The BMP4 RNA levels in Proband-1's leukocytes were not significantly different from those in the controls, whereas BMP4 levels observed in Proband-2 were significantly increased. Moreover, the p.Arg77Gln variant demonstrated nuclear localization similar to the wild-type but resulted in significantly impaired transactivation of BMP4, a PAX9 downstream gene. In conclusion, we demonstrate that the PAX9 p.Pro20Leu is highly associated with absent third molars, while the novel PAX9 p.Arg77Gln impairs BMP4 transactivation and is associated with total molar agenesis.

Variants in FtsJ RNA 2'-O-Methyltransferase 3 and Growth Hormone 1 are associated with small body size and a dental anomaly in dogs

Domesticated dogs show unparalleled diversity in body size across breeds, but within breeds variation is limited by selective breeding. Many heritable diseases of dogs are found among breeds of similar sizes, suggesting that as in humans, alleles governing growth have pleiotropic effects. Here, we conducted independent genome-wide association studies in the small Shetland Sheepdog breed and discovered a locus on chromosome 9 that is associated with a dental abnormality called maxillary canine-tooth mesioversion (MCM) (P = 1.53 × 10^-7) as well as two body size traits: height (P = 1.67 × 10^-5) and weight (P = 1.16 × 10^-7). Using whole-genome resequencing data, we identified variants in two proximal genes: FTSJ3, encoding an RNA methyltransferase, and GH1, encoding growth hormone. A substitution in FTSJ3 and a splice donor insertion in GH1 are strongly associated with MCM and reduced body size in Shetland Sheepdogs. We demonstrated in vitro that the GH1 variant leads to exon 3 skipping, predicting a mutant protein known to cause human pituitary dwarfism. Statistical modeling, however, indicates that the FTSJ3 variant is the stronger predictor of MCM and that each derived allele reduces body size by about 1 inch and 5 pounds. In a survey of 224 breeds, both FTSJ3 and GH1 variants are frequent among very small "toy" breeds and absent from larger breeds. Our findings indicate that a chromosome 9 locus harboring tightly linked variants in FTSJ3 and GH1 reduces growth in the Shetland Sheepdog and toy breed dogs and confers risk for MCM through vertical pleiotropy.

Mutations in COL1A1/A2 and CREB3L1 are associated with oligodontia in osteogenesis imperfecta

Background

Osteogenesis imperfecta (OI) is a heterogeneous connective tissue disorder characterized by an increased tendency for fractures throughout life. Autosomal dominant (AD) mutations in COL1A1 and COL1A2 are causative in approximately 85% of cases. In recent years, recessive variants in genes involved in collagen processing have been found. Hypodontia (< 6 missing permanent teeth) and oligodontia (≥ 6 missing permanent teeth) have previously been reported in individuals with OI. The aim of the present cross-sectional study was to investigate whether children and adolescents with OI and oligodontia and hypodontia also present with variants in other genes with potential effects on tooth development. The cohort comprised 10 individuals (7.7–19.9 years of age) with known COL1A1/A2 variants who we clinically and radiographically examined and further genetically evaluated by whole-genome sequencing. All study participants were treated at the Astrid Lindgren Children’s Hospital at Karolinska University Hospital, Stockholm (Sweden’s national multidisciplinary pediatric OI team). We evaluated a panel of genes that were associated with nonsyndromic and syndromic hypodontia or oligodontia as well as that had been found to be involved in tooth development in animal models.

Results

We detected a homozygous nonsense variant in CREB3L1, p.Tyr428*, c.1284C > A in one boy previously diagnosed with OI type III. COL1A1 and COL1A2 were the only two genes among 9 individuals which carried a pathogenic mutation. We found rare variants with unknown significance in several other genes related to tooth development.

Conclusions

Our findings suggest that mutations in COL1A1, COL1A2, and CREB3L1 may cause hypodontia and oligodontia in OI. The findings cannot exclude additive effects from other modifying or interacting genes that may contribute to the severity of the expressed phenotype. Larger cohorts and further functional studies are needed.

Association of Axis Inhibition Protein 2 Polymorphisms with Non-Syndromic Cleft Lip with or without Cleft Palate in Iranian Children

Background: Previously, only a few studies have investigated the association of AXIN2 polymorphisms with nonsyndromic cleft lip with or without cleft palate (NSCLP) risk. Objective: The aim of this study was to examine the association of rs2240308 C > T, rs1133683 C > T, and rs7224837 A > G polymorphisms of the AXIN2 gene with NSCLP risk in Iranian children. Methods: The study was comprised of 120 NSCLP cases and 120 controls. The AXIN2 polymorphisms were genotyped using PCR-RFLP assay. Results: The mutant homozygote genotype (TT) of AXIN2 rs1133683 C > T polymorphism was associated with increased risk of NSCLP. There was no significant association between rs2240308 C > T and rs7224837 A > G polymorphisms of the AXIN2 gene with an increased risk of NSCLP. Conclusion: This study indicates that AXIN2 rs1133683 C > T polymorphism may modify NSCLP susceptibility in the Iranian children, but not the rs2240308 C > T and rs7224837 A > G polymorphisms.

A biallelic ANTXR1 variant expands the anthrax toxin receptor associated phenotype to tooth agenesis

Tooth development is regulated by multiple genetic pathways, which ultimately drive the complex interactions between the oral epithelium and mesenchyme. Disruptions at any time point during this process may lead to failure of tooth development, also known as tooth agenesis (TA). TA is a common craniofacial abnormality in humans and represents the failure to develop one or more permanent teeth. Many genes and potentially subtle variants in these genes contribute to the TA phenotype. We report the clinical and genetic impact of a rare homozygous ANTXR1 variant (c.1312C>T), identified by whole exome sequencing (WES), in a consanguineous Turkish family with TA. Mutations in ANTXR1 have been associated with GAPO (growth retardation, alopecia, pseudoanodontia, and optic atrophy) syndrome and infantile hemangioma, however no clinical characteristics associated with these conditions were observed in our study family. We detected the expression of Antxr1 in oral and dental tissues of developing mouse embryos, further supporting a role for this gene in tooth development. Our findings implicate ANTXR1 as a candidate gene for isolated TA, suggest the involvement of specific hypomorphic alleles, and expand the previously known ANTXR1-associated phenotypes.

Expanding the genotype-phenotype spectrum in hereditary colorectal cancer by gene panel testing

Hereditary syndromes causing colorectal cancer include both polyposis and non-polyposis syndromes. Overlapping phenotypes between the syndromes have been recognized and this make targeted molecular testing for single genes less favorable, instead there is a gaining interest for multi-gene panel-based approaches detecting both SNVs, indels and CNVs in the same assay. We applied a panel including 19 CRC susceptibility genes to 91 individuals of six phenotypic subgroups. Targeted NGS-based sequencing of the whole gene regions including introns of the 19 genes was used. The individuals had a family history of CRC or had a phenotype consistent with a known CRC syndrome. The purpose of the study was to demonstrate the diagnostic difficulties linked to genotype-phenotype diversity and the benefits of using a gene panel. Pathogenicity classification was carried out on 46 detected variants. In total we detected sixteen pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants and 30 variants of unknown clinical significance. Four of the pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants were found in BMPR1A in patients with unexplained familial adenomatous polyposis or atypical adenomatous polyposis, which extends the genotype-phenotype spectrum for this gene. Nine patients had more than one variant remaining after the filtration, including three with truncating mutations in BMPR1A, PMS2 and AXIN2. CNVs were found in three patients, in upstream regions of SMAD4, MSH3 and CTNNB1, and one additional individual harbored a 24.2 kb duplication in CDH1 intron1.

Language Impairments in ASD Resulting from a Failed Domestication of the Human Brain

Autism spectrum disorders (ASD) are pervasive neurodevelopmental disorders entailing social and cognitive deficits, including marked problems with language. Numerous genes have been associated with ASD, but it is unclear how language deficits arise from gene mutation or dysregulation. It is also unclear why ASD shows such high prevalence within human populations. Interestingly, the emergence of a modern faculty of language has been hypothesized to be linked to changes in the human brain/skull, but also to the process of self-domestication of the human species. It is our intention to show that people with ASD exhibit less marked domesticated traits at the morphological, physiological, and behavioral levels. We also discuss many ASD candidates represented among the genes known to be involved in the “domestication syndrome” (the constellation of traits exhibited by domesticated mammals, which seemingly results from the hypofunction of the neural crest) and among the set of genes involved in language function closely connected to them. Moreover, many of these genes show altered expression profiles in the brain of autists. In addition, some candidates for domestication and language-readiness show the same expression profile in people with ASD and chimps in different brain areas involved in language processing. Similarities regarding the brain oscillatory behavior of these areas can be expected too. We conclude that ASD may represent an abnormal ontogenetic itinerary for the human faculty of language resulting in part from changes in genes important for the “domestication syndrome” and, ultimately, from the normal functioning of the neural crest.

Mutations in WNT10B Are Identified in Individuals with Oligodontia

Tooth agenesis is one of the most common developmental anomalies in humans. Oligodontia, a severe form of tooth agenesis, is genetically and phenotypically a heterogeneous condition. Although significant efforts have been made, the genetic etiology of dental agenesis remains largely unknown. In the present study, we performed whole-exome sequencing to identify the causative mutations in Chinese families in whom oligodontia segregates with dominant inheritance. We detected a heterozygous missense mutation (c.632G>A [p.Arg211Gln]) in WNT10B in all affected family members. By Sanger sequencing a cohort of 145 unrelated individuals with non-syndromic oligodontia, we identified three additional mutations (c.569C>G [p.Pro190Arg], c.786G>A [p.Trp262(∗)], and c.851T>G [p.Phe284Cys]). Interestingly, analysis of genotype-phenotype correlations revealed that mutations in WNT10B affect the development of permanent dentition, particularly the lateral incisors. Furthermore, a functional assay demonstrated that each of these mutants could not normally enhance the canonical Wnt signaling in HEPG2 epithelial cells, in which activity of the TOPFlash luciferase reporter was measured. Notably, these mutant WNT10B ligands could not efficiently induce endothelial differentiation of dental pulp stem cells. Our findings provide the identification of autosomal-dominant WNT10B mutations in individuals with oligodontia, which increases the spectrum of congenital tooth agenesis and suggests attenuated Wnt signaling in endothelial differentiation of dental pulp stem cells.

Functional analysis of a novel missense mutation in AXIN2 associated with non-syndromic tooth agenesis

Tooth agenesis is a congenital anomaly frequently seen in humans. Several genes have been associated with non-syndromic tooth agenesis, including msh homeobox 1 (MSX1), paired box 9 (PAX9), axis inhibition protein 2 (AXIN2), ectodysplasin A (EDA), and wingless-type MMTV integration site family member 10A (WNT10A). In this study, we investigated a Chinese family with non-syndromic tooth agenesis. A novel missense mutation (c.C1978T) in AXIN2 was identified in affected members. The mutation results in a His660Tyr substitution located between the Axin beta-catenin binding domain and the DIX domain of the axis inhibition protein 2 (AXIN2). We analysed this novel AXIN2 mutant, together with two reported AXIN2 mutants [c.1966C>T (p.Arg656Stop) and c.1994delG (p.Leu688Stop)] that cause colorectal cancer with and without oligodontia, to study the effect of the mutant p.His660Tyr on the Wnt/β-catenin signaling pathway and to compare the molecular pathogenesis of different AXIN2 mutants in tooth agenesis and carcinogenesis. Further in vitro experiments indicated that the mutant p.His660Tyr caused inhibition of the Wnt/β-catenin pathway, and the mutants p.Arg656Stop and p.Leu688Stop resulted in over-activation of the Wnt/β-catenin pathway. In line with previous AXIN2 mutation studies, we suggest that AXIN2 mutations with different levels of severity may have distinct effects on the Wnt pathway and the phenotype of disease. Our study provides functional evidence supporting the notion that both inhibition and over-activation of the Wnt pathway may lead to tooth agenesis.