Microbial diversity in two traditional bacterial douchi from Gansu province in northwest China using Illumina sequencing

Culture-dependent and -independent analyses of bacterial compositions and its contributions to formation of γ-aminobutyric acid and poly-γ-glutamic acid in Cheonggukjang

This study was performed to unveil bacterial compositions and their contributions to the formation of γ-aminobutyric acid (GABA) and poly-γ-glutamic acid (γ-PGA) in Cheonggukjang. To predict possible key factors contributing to the content of the bioactive compounds in Cheonggukjang, commercial products were analyzed for various parameters. The content of GABA and γ-PGA showed a negative (R2 = 0.61 - 0.73) and positive correlation (R2 = 0.53 - 0.96) with antioxidative activity. Consistently, GABA content showed a moderate negative correlation with γ-PGA content (R2 = 0.58). Among the physicochemical and microbial parameters, only salinity showed a moderate negative correlation with γ-PGA content (R2 = 0.75), which might be due to the inhibition of bacterial growth. It was also suggested that multiple factors (including bacterial species) were involved in the formation of GABA and γ-PGA in Cheonggukjang. To reveal dominant bacterial species and further presume their contributions to the bioactive compound formation in Cheonggukjang, both culture-independent (metagenomic) and -dependent (culturomic) methods were used. Culture-independent method showed that Bacillus piscis was dominant (23.37 - 94.89 %), followed by B. hisashii (0.00 - 62.45 %) and B. coagulans (0.00 - 13.82 %). Considering the quantitative speciation data on the bioactive compound content in Cheonggukjang (and bacterial production capability) together, it was further elucidated that B. piscis contributed primarily to the bioactive compound formation. Unlike this, culture-dependent analysis revealed that B. licheniformis and B. subtilis were dominant (30.0 - 47.6 and 17.5 - 39.5 %, respectively). Based on the quantitative speciation data on the bacterial production capability of GABA and γ-PGA, B. subtilis was the primarily contributing bacterial species to the bioactive compound formation. Consequently, it was observed that the bacterial compositions and their contributions to the bioactive compound formation determined by the two methods differed considerably, i.e., B. piscis and B. subtilis were identified to be prominent bacterial contributors, respectively, depending on the method used.

Research on bacterial community characteristics of traditional fermented yak milk in the Tibetan Plateau based on high-throughput sequencing

Background

The Tibetan Plateau has an abundance of yak milk resources. The complex microbiota found in traditional fermented yak milk produced and sold by local Tibetans endows the yak milk with unique quality characteristics such as tissue morphology, flavor, and function. However, the diversity of bacterial flora in traditional fermented yak milk have not been elucidated.

Methods

In this study, 15 samples of fermented yak milk were collected for 16S rRNA high-throughput sequencing to analyze the bacterial community composition and function.

Results

After filtering for quality, 792,642 high-quality sequences were obtained, and 13 kinds of different phyla and 82 kinds of different genera were identified, of which the phylum Firmicutes (98.94%) was the dominant phylum, Lactobacillus (64.73%) and Streptococcus (28.48%) were identified as the dominant genus, in addition, the bacterial community richness and diversity were higher in Manang Village, followed by Bola Village. Bacterial community richness and diversity in Huage Village were relatively low. Based on the Kyoto Encyclopedia of Genes and Genomes (KEGG) functional classification, the microorganisms in traditional fermented yak milk have rich metabolic functions (77.60%). These findings suggest that a large number of bacteria in traditional fermented yak milk contain abundant metabolic genes and can carry out a variety of growth and metabolic activities. This study established a theoretical foundation for further exploring the microbial flora of traditional fermented yak milk in Gannan.

Dynamic Changes in Microbial Communities and Physicochemical Characteristics During Fermentation of Non-post Fermented Shuidouchi

Non-post fermented Shuidouchi is a Chinese spontaneously fermented soybean food with multifunctionality in human health. The functionality and safety of this plant-based food will be affected by the microorganisms during fermentation. In this study, microbial diversity was investigated using culture-dependent and culture-independent methods. The functional metabolites such as polyamines and alkylpyrazines were also determined at different time points during fermentation. We found that Bacillus was the most dominant microbe throughout the fermentation process, while the temperature was the most important influencing factor. During fermentation, the microbial diversity increased at a moderate temperature and decreased at a high temperature (52^°C). High temperature caused the prosperity of the spore-producing bacteria such as Bacillus (more than 90% relative abundance in bacteria) and Aneurinibacillus (2% or so relative abundance in bacteria), and the inhibition of fungi. Furthermore, it was found by correlation analysis that the relative abundances of Bacillus and Aneurinibacillus were positively correlated with the relative content of amino acid metabolism pathway and the content of most alkylpyrazines and biogenic amines. Meanwhile, the relative abundances of many non-dominant bacteria were negatively correlated with the content of biogenic amines and positively correlated with the relative content of carbohydrate metabolism pathway. These effects were helpful to control the biogenic amine contents under the safety limits, increasing the alkylpyrazine type and product functionality. A two-stage temperature control strategy—a moderate temperature (35–42^°C) first, then a high temperature (52^°C)—was concluded from the spontaneous fermentation of non-post fermented Shuidouchi. This strategy could improve the safety of product by inhibiting or sterilizing the thermolabile microbes. The non-post fermented Shuidouchi product is rich in functional compounds such as polyamines and alkylpyrazines.

Influence of Tissue Type on the Bacterial Diversity and Community in Pork Bacon

In current study, bacterial diversity and community in different tissues of pork bacon were determined using high-throughput sequencing. In total, six phyla and 111 bacterial genera were identified. Among them, three dominant genera (Staphylococcus, Acinetobacter, and Macrococcus) were shared by all bacon samples. The linear discriminant analysis showed that 24 bacterial taxa significantly differentiated between the tissues. Results of non-metric Multidimensional Scaling and redundancy analysis showed that physicochemical characteristics of the tissue prominently structured the bacterial communities. Network analysis also illustrated that tissue type was an important factor impacting the bacterial interactions in different types of tissue. The results of current study can add valuable insights to the traditional homemade pork bacon.

Deciphering Bacterial Community Structure, Functional Prediction and Food Safety Assessment in Fermented Fruits Using Next-Generation 16S rRNA Amplicon Sequencing

Fermented fruits and vegetables play an important role in safeguarding food security world-wide. Recently, robust sequencing-based microbial community analysis platforms have improved microbial safety assessment. This study aimed to examine the composition of bacteria and evaluate the bacterial safety of fermented fruit products using high-throughput 16S-rRNA metagenomic analysis. The operational taxonomic unit-based taxonomic classification of DNA sequences revealed 53 bacterial genera. However, the amplicon sequencing variant (ASV)-based clustering revealed 43 classifiable bacterial genera. Taxonomic classifications revealed that the abundance of Sphingomonas, which was the predominant genus in the majority of tested samples, was more than 85–90% among the total identified bacterial community in most samples. Among these identified genera, 13 low abundance genera were potential opportunistic pathogens, including Acinetobacter, Bacillus, Staphylococcus, Clostridium, Klebsiella, Mycobacterium, Ochrobactrum, Chryseobacterium, Stenotrophomonas, and Streptococcus. Of these 13 genera, 13 major opportunistic pathogenic species were validated using polymerase chain reaction. The pathogens were not detected in the samples of different stages and the final products of fermentation, except in one sample from the first stage of fermentation in which S. aureus was detected. This finding was consistent with that of ASV-based taxonomic classification according to which S. aureus was detected only in the sample from the first stage of fermentation. However, S. aureus was not significantly correlated with the human disease pathways. These results indicated that fermentation is a reliable and safe process as pathogenic bacteria were not detected in the fermentation products. The hybrid method reported in this study can be used simultaneously to evaluate the bacterial diversity, their functional predictions and safety assessment of novel fermentation products. Additionally, this hybrid method does not involve the random detection of pathogens, which can markedly decrease the time of detection and food safety verification. Furthermore, this hybrid method can be used for the quality control of products and the identification of external contamination.

Characterization of bacterial community and flavor differences of different types of Douchi

According to the appearance and technology, traditional fermented Douchi can be divided into dried Douchi and wet Douchi. However, there are few reports on the difference of bacterial community structure between them or the influence of bacterial community on product flavor. In this study, high-throughput sequencing technology and electronic nose were used to measure the bacterial diversity and flavor of 40 Douchi samples, and the correlation between them was explored by multivariate statistical means combined with COG database. Results showed that the cumulative average relative abundance of Firmicutes and Proteobacteria in the samples was as high as 95.93%, and the former was the core bacteria phylum. On the whole, the dominant bacteria in Douchi were Bacillus (50.67%), Staphylococcus (14.07%), Enterococcus (2.54%), Proteus (1.61%), Brevibacillus (1.46%), Providencia (1.26%), Weissella (1.24%), and Ureibacillus (1.19%). LEfSe analysis indicated that Bacillus can be used as a biomarker in dried fermented soybeans. Meanwhile, dried samples contained more intensive aromatic substances, but were significantly lower in W6S (selectivity to hydrogen) and W3S (methane-aliph) compared with the wet samples. Aneurinibacillus and Brevibacillus were helpful to the formation of aromatic flavor in Douchi, but Vagococcus and Corynebacterium were the opposite. Gene and microbial phenotypic prediction showed that microorganisms in dried Douchi use protein more efficiently, while in wet Douchi, microbial energy metabolism was more vigorous. The pathogenic potential of microorganisms in dried samples was higher than that in wet. This study can sound the alarm for improving the safety of home-brewed Douchi and provide guidance for the subsequent screening of strains that enhance the flavor of fermented soybeans.

Activity of Fengycin and Iturin A Isolated From Bacillus subtilis Z-14 on Gaeumannomyces graminis Var. tritici and Soil Microbial Diversity

Bacillus subtilis Z-14 can inhibit phytopathogenic fungi, and is used as a biocontrol agent for wheat take-all disease. The present study used the soil-borne fungus Gaeumannomyces graminis var. tritici (Ggt), which causes wheat take-all disease, and the soil microbial community as indicators, and investigated the antifungal effects of fengycin and iturin A purified from strain Z-14 using high performance liquid chromatography and matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization time-of-flight mass spectrometry, respectively. The results showed that fengycin destroyed the internal structure of Ggt cells by digesting the cytoplasm and organelles, forming vacuoles, and inducing hyphal shrinkage and distortion. Iturin A induced cell wall disappearance, membrane degeneration, intracellular material shrinkage, and hyphal fragmentation. A biocontrol test demonstrated a 100% control effect on wheat take-all when wheat seedlings were treated with fengycin at 100 μg/ml or iturin A at 500 μg/ml. Iturin A and fengycin both reduced the relative abundance of Aspergillus and Gibberella. At the genus level, iturin A reduced the relative abundance of Mortierella and Myrothecium, while fengycin reduced that of Fusarium. Only fengycin treatment for 7 days had a significant effect on soil bacterial diversity.

Analysis of microbial diversity and functional differences in different types of high-temperature Daqu

Bacterial communities that enrich in high-temperature Daqu are important for the Chinese maotai-flavor liquor brewing process. However, the bacterial communities in three different types of high-temperature Daqu (white Daqu, black Daqu, and yellow Daqu) are still undercharacterized. In this study, the bacterial diversity of three different types of high-temperature Daqu was investigated using Illumina MiSeq high-throughput sequencing. The bacterial community of high-temperature Daqu is mainly composed of thermophilic bacteria, and seven bacterial phyla along with 262 bacterial genera were identified in all 30 high-temperature Daqu samples. Firmicutes, Actinobacteria, Proteobacteria, and Acidobacteria were the dominant bacterial phyla in high-temperature Daqu samples, while Thermoactinomyces, Staphylococcus, Lentibacillus, Bacillus, Kroppenstedtia, Saccharopolyspora, Streptomyces, and Brevibacterium were the dominant bacterial genera. The bacterial community structure of three different types of high-temperature Daqu was significantly different (p < .05). In addition, the results of microbiome phenotype prediction by BugBase and bacterial functional potential prediction using PICRUSt show that bacteria from different types of high-temperature Daqu have similar functions as well as phenotypes, and bacteria in high-temperature Daqu have vigorous metabolism in the transport and decomposition of amino acids and carbohydrates. These results offer a reference for the comprehensive understanding of bacterial diversity of high-temperature Daqu.

Bacterial diversity and flavor profile of Zha-Chili, a traditional fermented food in China

Zha-chili is a traditional Chinese fermented food with special flavor, which is often used as an appetizer in condiments and an important energy source. The final quality of zha-chili is closely related to its microbial community structure. However, the differences of bacterial diversity in zha-chili from different regions and how bacterial species affect zha-chili fermentation process and flavor quality have not been reported. In this study, the bacterial diversity and flavor quality of zha-chili samples from different regions were analyzed using Illumina Miseq high-throughput sequencing, electronic nose and electronic tongue technology. Twenty-three bacterial phyla and 665 bacterial genera were identified in all zha-chili samples. Firmicutes, Proteobacteria and Actinobacteria were the dominant bacterial phyla in zha-chili samples, while Lactobacillus, Pseudomonas, Pediococcus, Weissella and Staphylococcus were the dominant bacterial genera. The bacterial community structure of zha-chili samples from different regions was significantly diverse (p < 0.05). The flavor of zha-chili samples also varied in different regions, and the discrepancy of taste was much greater than that of aroma. Moreover, there were significant correlations (p < 0.05) between 6 dominant bacterial genera and 8 flavor indicators (3 aroma indicators, 5 taste indicators). In addition, the results of microbiome phenotypes prediction by BugBase and bacterial functional potential prediction using PICRUSt showed that eight out of nine predicted phenotypic functions of zha-chili samples from different regions were significantly different (p < 0.05), bacterial metabolism was vigorous in the zha-chili samples, and Lactobacillus was the dominant bacterial genus involved in metabolism during fermentation.

High-throughput sequencing-based analysis of fungal diversity and taste quality evaluation of Douchi, a traditional fermented food

Douchi, a popular traditional fermented soybean product, is mainly made by natural fermentation. However, its taste quality is affected by specific fungal communities which vary greatly according to fermentation conditions and production technologies used in different regions. Therefore, the taste quality of Douchi samples from different regions was digitally evaluated using electronic tongue technology. In addition, the fungal community structures and its association of them were also identified using high-throughput sequencing technology. Results showed that there were obvious differences in the taste quality of samples from different regions, while the tastes of different types of samples from the same region were similar. Sourness, umami, richness, and saltiness were the main reasons for regional differences in taste. Similarly, the results of high-throughput sequencing indicated that samples from different regions displayed important differences in dominant fungal genus, among which Debaryomyces, Fusarium, Pichia, Aspergillus, and Saccharomyces were the main dominant fungi. Debaryomyces and Trichosporon were conducive to the formation of taste qualities of Douchi, while Cladosporium and Candida have a negative impact on the taste quality of Douchi var correlation analysis. This study indicated the effects of dominant fungi on the formation of Douchi taste quality, allowing a deeper understanding of the role of microbial species in generating fermented soybean products in China. Our work provides theoretical support to guide the improvement of the industrial production process of Douchi.

Effects of environmental factors on microbiota of fruits and soil of Coffea arabica in Brazil

In recent years, several studies have been developed to understand the impact of fermentation on the final quality of coffee and have indicated that postharvest processing could be a determinant of quality. However, a trend has appeared as a scientific counterpoint, indicating that the interactions between soil, fruit, altitude, and slope exposures with respect to the Sun are important to understand the behavior of the microbiome in coffee. Studies on the microbiota of coffee have addressed its role during the fermentation process, however the knowledge of indigenous microorganisms harbored in fruits and soil of coffee trees growing in fields are essential, as they can contribute to fermentation. Therefore, the aim of this work was to evaluate the influence of topographic and edaphic factors on the bacterial and fungal communities present in the soil and in the fruits of Coffea arabica trees. Samples of fruits and soil were collected from different growing areas at different altitudes and soil conditions. The microbial DNA was extracted and sequenced. The results showed the contribution of environmental factors in the structure of bacterial and fungal communities. The richness, evenness and diversity of the mycobiome and bacteriome were higher in the soil than in the fruits, independent of altitude. In addition, coffee trees at higher altitudes tended to have more bacteria shared between the soil and fruits. The co-occurrence/co-exclusion network showed that bacteria-bacteria connections were greater in higher altitudes. On another hand, fungi-fungi and fungi-bacteria connections were higher in low altitudes. This was the first study that evaluates in deep the influence of environmental factors in the microbiota habiting fruits and soil coffee trees, which may affect the coffee beverage quality.

Diversity of navel microbiome in young adults

Introduction. Human skin microbial communities represent a tremendous source of genetic diversity that evolves as a function of human age. Microbiota differs between regions of oily and moist skin, and appears to stabilize with age.Aim. We have a minimal understanding of the time frame required for the stabilization of skin microbiota, and the role played by gender. In the current study, we examined the microbiota present in the navel region of college-attending young adults in the age group of 18-25 years and investigated if diversity is associated with gender (male and female).Method. The study involved 16 female and six male subjects. Isolated DNA samples from navel swabs were processed using the Nextera XT library preparation kit and sequenced using the MiSeq platform. Data were analysed using QIIME and statistical analysis performed in R.Results. Microbiota of navel skin is dominated by Corynebacterium and Staphylococcus and includes opportunistic pathogens like Clostridium and Pseudomonas. Also present as the major component of the flora were the organisms normally associated with the gastrointestinal tract such as Acinetobacter, Campylobacter, Klebsiella and organisms from the Enterobacteriaceae and Moraxellaceae families. Comparison of alpha and beta diversity of the microbiota in the male and female navel regions suggests that the flora is not statistically different (P>0.05). However, pairwise comparison suggests that the abundance of 12 specific genera varied with gender, including higher abundance of Klebsiella and Enterobacter in females.Conclusion. Our findings indicate that the navel skin microbiota of young adults has a core microbiota of Corynebacterium and Staphylococcus. We also noted the presence of a significant number of opportunistic pathogens. A minor gender difference in the abundance of individual organisms was also observed.

Variations in Fungal Community and Diversity in Doushen With Different Flavors

Doushen, a traditional Chinese fermented soybean product, may be spiced or spicy depending on whether pepper powder is added. While numerous studies have investigated the microbial communities of other fermented foods, little is known on the fungal diversity of Doushen. Therefore, in this study, we investigated the fungal community and diversity in both spiced and spicy Doushen. Our results revealed that fungal species richness significantly differed between the samples with different flavors. A total of nine phyla and 188 fungal genera were identified, and Ascomycota and Aspergillus were predominant in all samples. Based on linear discriminant analysis, a total of 57 OTUs were significantly different between the two samples. Results of non-metric multidimensional scaling and unweighted pair-group analysis suggested that the presence of pepper powder affects the microbial community in Doushen. Network analysis showed that microbial interactions between fungal communities in Doushen with different flavors were significantly different. The results on the enumeration and identification of fungi were consistent with the composition of the dominant genera in the samples with different flavors. This study provides a theoretical basis for future research on food ecology in Doushen.

Preventive Effects of Different Fermentation Times of Shuidouchi on Diphenoxylate-Induced Constipation in Mice

This study compares the prevention effects of Shuidouchi with different fermentation times on constipation in mice. Shuidouchi is a short-time fermented soybean product. By improving its processing technology, it can incur better biological activity and become a health food. The Shuidouchi-treated mice were evaluated using constipation-related kits, quantitative polymerase chain reaction (qPCR), and Western blot assays. After the mice were fed 72-h-fermented Shuidouchi (72-SDC) for 9 d, the defecation time to excrete the first black stool was lower than that of the control and 24-SDC and 48-SDC groups, but was much higher than that of the normal group. The gastrointestinal (GI) transit of the small intestine of the 72-SDC group was higher than that of the control and the 24-SDC and 48-SDC groups, but lower that of the normal group. Meanwhile, 72-SDC could significantly increase the levels of ghrelin, endothelin-1 (ET-1), vasoactive intestinal peptide (VIP), and acetylcholinesterase (AchE) in the serum of constipated mice compared to the levels in mice in the control group. Moreover, 72-SDC could raise c-Kit, stem cell factor (SCF), glial cell-derived neurotrophic factor (GNDF), neuronal nitric oxide synthase (nNOS), and endothelial nitric oxide synthase (eNOS) messenger RNA (mRNA) and protein expression levels, and reduce transient receptor potential cation channel subfamily V member 1 (TRPV1) and inducible nitric oxide synthase (iNOS) expression levels in small-intestinal tissue compared to the levels in the control group. Meanwhile, 72-SDC also raised ghrelin mRNA expression in gastric tissue and transient receptor potential ankyrin 1 (TRPA1) mRNA expression in colon tissue compared to the control group mice; these effects were stronger than those of 24-SDC and 48-SDC. Shuidouchi has good preventative effects on constipation and performs best when fermented for at least 72 h.

Bacterial diversity and community in Qula from the Qinghai-Tibetan Plateau in China

Qula is a cheese-like product usually prepared with unpasteurized yak milk under open conditions, with both endogenous and exogenous microorganisms involved in the fermentation process. In the present study, 15 Qula samples were collected from five different regions in China to investigate the diversity of microbial communities using high-throughput sequencing targeting the V3–V4 region of 16S rRNA gene. The bacterial diversity significantly differed among samples of different origins, indicating a possible effect of geography. The result also showed that microbial communities significantly differed in samples of different origin and these differences were greater at the genus than the phylum level. A total of six phyla were identified in the samples, and Firmicutes and Proteobacteria had a relative abundance >20%. A total of 73 bacterial genera were identified in the samples. Two dominant genera (Lactobacillus and Acetobacter) were common to all samples, and a total of 47 operational taxonomic units at different levels significantly differed between samples of different origin. The predicted functional genes of the bacteria present in samples also indicated differences in bacterial communities between the samples of different origin. The network analysis showed that microbial interactions between bacterial communities in Qula were very complex. This study lays a foundation for further investigations into its food ecology.

Ignatzschineria cameli sp. nov., isolated from necrotic foot tissue of dromedaries (Camelus dromedarius) and associated maggots (Wohlfahrtia species) in Dubai

Five bacterial strains, UAE-HKU57^T, UAE-HKU58, UAE-HKU59, UAE-HKU60 and UAE-HKU61, were isolated in Dubai, UAE, from necrotic foot tissue samples of four dromedaries (Camelus dromedarius) and associated maggots (Wohrlfartia species). They were non-sporulating, Gram-negative, non-motile bacilli. They grew well under aerobic conditions at 37 °C, but not anaerobically. The pH range for growth was pH 7.0-9.0 (optimum, pH 7.5-8.0) and the strains could tolerate NaCl concentrations (w/v) up to 2 % (optimum, 0.5 %). They were catalase- and cytochrome oxidase-positive, but caseinase-, gelatinase- and urease-negative. Their phenotypic characters were distinguishable from other closely related species. Phylogenetic analyses of the almost-complete 16S rRNA gene and partial 23S rRNA gene, gyrB, groEL and recA sequences revealed that the five isolates were most closely related to undescribed Ignatzschineria strain F8392 and Ignatzschineria indica, but in most phylogenies clustered separately from these close relatives. Average nucleotide identity analysis showed that genomes of the five isolates (2.47-2.52 Mb, G+C content 41.71-41.86 mol%) were 98.00-99.97% similar to each other, but ≤87.18 % similar to other Ignatzschineriaspecies/strains. Low DNA relatedness between the five isolates to other Ignatzschineriaspecies/strains was also supported by Genome-to-Genome Distance Calculator analysis. The chemotaxonomic traits of the five strains were highly similar. They were non-susceptible (intermediate or resistant) to tetracycline and resistant to trimethoprim/sulphamethoxazole. The name Ignatzschineria cameli sp. nov. is proposed to accommodate these five strains, with strain UAE-HKU57^T (=CCOS1165^T=NBRC 113042^T) as the type strain.

Biogenic amines analysis and microbial contribution in traditional fermented food of Douchi

Biogenic amines (BAs) have been reported to threaten the Douchi safety, while the BAs formation mechanism and corresponding control method have not been clarified for Douchi. The present study aims to investigate the microbial contribution to BAs in Douchi, and to find the beneficial strain for BAs control. Firstly, the BAs profiles of 15 Douchi samples were analyzed, and common 6 kinds of BAs were detected from different samples. All the samples showed the total BAs contents within the safe dosage range, while the histamine concentrations in 2 samples and β-phenethylamine in 6 samples were above the toxic level. Then, the bacterial and fungal communities were investigated by high-throughput sequencing analysis, and Bacillus and Candida were identified as the dominant bacteria and fungi genus, respectively. Furthermore, nineteen strains were selected from the dominant species of Douchi samples, including 14 Bacillus strains, 2 Staphylococcus strains, 1 Enterococcus strain and 2 Candida strains, and their BAs formation and degradation abilities were evaluated. B. subtilis HB-1 and S. pasteuri JX-2 showed no BAs producing ability, and B. subtilis GD-4 and Candida sp. JX-3 exhibited high BAs degradation ability. Finally, fermented soybean model analysis further verified that B. subtilis HB-1 and S. pasteuri JX-2 could significantly reduce BAs. This study not only contributed to understanding the BAs formation mechanism in Douchi, but also provided potential candidates to control the BAs in fermented soybean products.