Impact of care provider network characteristics on patient outcomes: Usage of social network analysis and a multi-scale community detection

Representation of the hierarchical and functional structure of an ambulatory network of medical consultations through Social Network Analysis, with an emphasis on the role of medical specialties

BACKGROUND

Ambulatory Health Care Networks (Amb-HCN) are circuits of patient referral and counter-referral that emerge, explicitly or spontaneously, between doctors who provide care in their offices. Finding a meaningful analytical representation for the organic and hierarchical functioning of an Amb-HCN may have managerial and health policymaking implications. We aimed to characterize the structural and functional topology of an Amb-HCN of a private health insurance provider (PHIP) using objective metrics from graph theory.

METHODS

This is a cross-sectional quantitative study with a secondary data analysis study design. A Social Network Analysis (SNA) was conducted using office visits performed between April 1, 2021 and May 15, 2022, retrieved from secondary administrative claim databases from a PHIP in Belo Horizonte, Southeastern Brazil. Included were beneficiaries of a healthcare plan not restricting the location or physician caring for the patient. A directional and weighted network was constructed, where doctors were the vertices and patient referrals between doctors, within 7-45 days, were the network edges. Vertex-level SNA measures were calculated and grouped into three theoretical constructs: patient follow-up (aimed at assessing the doctor's pattern of patient follow-up); relationship with authorities (which assessed whether the doctor is an authority or contributes to his or her colleague's authority status); and centrality (aimed at positioning the doctor relative to the network graph). To characterize physician profiles within each dimension based on SNA metrics results, a K-means cluster analysis was conducted. The resulting physician clusters were assigned labels that sought to be representative of the observed values of the vertex metrics within the clusters.

FINDINGS

Overall, 666,263 individuals performed 3,863,222 office visits with 4,554 physicians. A total of 577 physicians (12.7%) had very low consultation productivity and contributed very little to the network (i.e., about 1.1% of all referrals made or received), being excluded from subsequent doctor profiles analysis. Cluster analysis found 951 (23.9%) doctors to be central in the graph and 1,258 (31.6%) to be peripheral; 883 (22.2%) to be authorities and 266 (6.7%) as seeking authorities; 3,684 (92.6%) mostly shared patients with colleagues, with patient follow-up intensities ranging from weak to strong. Wide profile dispersion was observed among specialties and, more interestingly, within specialties. Non-primary-care medical specialties (e.g., cardiology, endocrinology etc.) were associated with central profile in the graph, while surgical specialties predominated in the periphery, along with pediatrics. Only pediatrics was associated with strong and prevalent (i.e., low patient sharing pattern) follow-up. Many doctors from internal medicine and family medicine had unexpectedly weak and shared patient follow-up profiles. Doctor profiles exhibited pairwise relationships with each other and with the number of chronic comorbidities of the patients they treated. For example, physicians identified as authorities were frequently central and treated patients with more comorbidities. Ten medical communities were identified with clear territorial and specialty segregation.

CONCLUSIONS

Viewing the Amb-HCN as a social network provided a topological and functional representation with potentially meaningful and actionable emerging insights into the most influential actors and specialties, functional hierarchies, factors that lead to self-constituted medical communities, and dispersion from expected patterns within medical specialties.

Cardiac interventions in Wales: A comparison of benefits between NHS Wales specialties

OBJECTIVES

The study aimed to assess if specialised healthcare service interventions in Wales benefit the population equitably in work commissioned by the Welsh Health Specialised Services Committee (WHSSC).

APPROACH

The study utilised anonymised individual-level, population-scale, routinely collected electronic health record (EHR) data held in the Secure Anonymised Information Linkage (SAIL) Databank to identify patients resident in Wales receiving specialist cardiac interventions. Measurement was undertaken of associated patient outcomes 2-years before and after the intervention (minus a 6-month clearance period on either side) by measuring events in primary care, hospital attendance, outpatient and emergency department. The analysis controlled for comorbidity (Charlson) and deprivation (Welsh Index of Multiple Deprivation), stratified by admission type (elective or emergency) and membership of top 5% post-intervention costs. Costs were estimated by multiplying events by mean person cost estimates.

RESULTS

We identified 5,999 percutaneous coronary interventions (PCI) and 1,640 coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) between 2014-06-01 to 2020-02-29. The ratio of emergency to elective interventions was 2.85 for PCI and 1.04 for CABG. In multivariate analysis significant associations were identified for comorbidity (OR = 1.52, CI = (1.01-2.27)), deprivation (OR = 1.34, CI = (1.03-1.76)) and rurality (OR = 0.81, CI = (0.70-0.95)) for PCI interventions, and comorbidity (OR = 1.47, CI = (1.10-1.98)) for CABG. Higher costs post-intervention were associated with increased comorbidity for PCI and CABG in the top 5% cost groups, but for PCI this was not seen outside the top 5%. For PCI, moderate cost increase was associated with increased deprivation, but the picture was more mixed following CABG interventions. For both interventions, lower costs post intervention were seen in rural locations.

CONCLUSION

We identified and compared health outcomes for selected specialist cardiac interventions amongst patients resident in Wales, with these methods and analyses, providing a template for comparing other cardiac interventions.

Regional medical inter-institutional cooperation in medical provider network constructed using patient claims data from Japan

The aging world population requires a sustainable and high-quality healthcare system. To examine the efficiency of medical cooperation, medical provider and physician networks were constructed using patient claims data. Previous studies have shown that these networks contain information on medical cooperation. However, the usage patterns of multiple medical providers in a series of medical services have not been considered. In addition, these studies used only general network features to represent medical cooperation, but their expressive ability was low. To overcome these limitations, we analyzed the medical provider network to examine its overall contribution to the quality of healthcare provided by cooperation between medical providers in a series of medical services. This study focused on: i) the method of feature extraction from the network, ii) incorporation of the usage pattern of medical providers, and iii) expressive ability of the statistical model. Femoral neck fractures were selected as the target disease. To build the medical provider networks, we analyzed the patient claims data from a single prefecture in Japan between January 1, 2014 and December 31, 2019. We considered four types of models. Models 1 and 2 use node strength and linear regression, with Model 2 also incorporating patient age as an input. Models 3 and 4 use feature representation by node2vec with linear regression and regression tree ensemble, a machine learning method. The results showed that medical providers with higher levels of cooperation reduce the duration of hospital stay. The overall contribution of the medical cooperation to the duration of hospital stay extracted from the medical provider network using node2vec is approximately 20%, which is approximately 20 times higher than the model using strength.

Effectiveness of a targeted telephone-based case management service on activity in an Emergency Department in the UK: a pragmatic difference-in-differences evaluation

BACKGROUND

This study evaluates the effectiveness of a targeted telephone-based case management service that aimed to reduce ED attendance amongst frequent attenders, known to disproportionately contribute to demand. Evidence on the effectiveness of these services varies.

METHODS

A 24-month controlled before-and-after study, following 808 patients (128 cases and 680 controls (41 were non-compliant)) who were offered the service in the first four months of operation within a UK ED department. Patients stratified as high-risk of reattending ED within 6 months by a predictive model were manually screened. Those positively reviewed were offered a non-clinical, nurse-led, telephone-based health coaching, consisting of care planning, coordination and goal setting for up to 9 months. Service effectiveness was estimated using a difference-in-differences (DiD) analysis. Incident rate of ED and Minor Injury Unit (MIU) attendances and average length of stay in intervention recipients and controls over 12 months after receiving their service offer following ED attendance were compared, adjusting for the prior 12-month period, sex and age, to give an incidence rate ratio (IRR).

RESULTS

Intervention recipients were more likely to be female (63.3% versus 55.4%), younger (mean of 69 years versus 76 years), and have higher levels of ED activity (except for MIU) than controls. Mean rates fell between periods for all outcomes (except for MIU attendance). The Intention-to-Treat analysis indicated non-statistically significant effect of the intervention in reducing all outcomes, except for MIU attendances, with IRRs: ED attendances, 0.856 (95% CI: 0.631, 1.160); ED admissions, 0.871 (95% CI: 0.628, 1.208); length of stay for emergency and elective admissions: 0.844 (95% CI: 0.619, 1.151) and 0.781 (95% CI: 0.420, 1.454). MIU attendance increased with an IRR: 2.638 (95% CI: 1.041, 6.680).

CONCLUSIONS

Telephone-based health coaching appears to be effective in reducing ED attendances and admissions, with shorter lengths of stay, in intervention recipients over controls. Future studies need to capture outcomes beyond acute activity, and better understand how services like this provide added value.

Collaboration between general practitioners and social workers: a scoping review

OBJECTIVES

Aim of the study is to present an overview of collaboration structures and processes between general practitioners and social workers, the target groups addressed as well the quality of available scientific literature.

DESIGN

A scoping review following the guidelines of the PRISMA-ScR (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for Scoping Reviews).

INCLUDED SOURCES AND ARTICLES

According to a pre-published protocol, three databases (PubMed, Web of Science, DZI SoLit) were searched using the participant-concept-context framework. The searches were performed on 21 January 2021 and on 10 August 2021. Literature written in English and German since the year 2000 was included. Two independent researchers screened all abstracts for collaboration between general practitioners and social workers. Articles selected were analysed regarding structures, processes, outcomes, effectiveness and patient target groups.

RESULTS

A total of 72 articles from 17 countries were identified. Collaborative structures and their routine differ markedly between healthcare systems: 36 publications present collaboration structures and 33 articles allow an insight into the processual routines. For all quantitative studies, a level of evidence was assigned. Various measurements are used to determine the effectiveness of collaborations, for example, hospital admissions and professionals' job satisfaction. Case management as person-centred care for defined patient groups is a central aspect of all identified collaborations between general practitioners and social workers.

CONCLUSION

This scoping review showed evidence for benefits on behalf of patients, professionals and healthcare systems by collaborations between general practitioners and social workers, yet more rigorous research is needed to better understand the impact of these collaborations.

TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

www.osf.io/w673q.

What Types of Networks Do Professionals Build, and How Are They Affected by the Results of Network Evaluation?

Background: We aimed to explore what kind of social networks characterizable as "consult/be consulted" are built among healthcare professionals in a community and the impact of providing the professionals with these findings. Methods: We adopted mixed methods exploratory study using social network analysis (SNA) and content analysis. SNA can visualize social network structures such as relationships between individuals. The healthcare professionals were asked about the key persons they consulted and were consulted by concerning these healthcare issues: (1) daily work; (2) a person with acute back pain; (3) a garbage-filled house reported by a neighbor; (4) a person with dementia; and (5) a study meeting. We identified the key roles depending on the issues using SNA. After analysis, the analytical findings were shared with the participants. To explore their cognitive responses, an open-ended questionnaire was delivered and a content analysis was implemented. Results: Of 54 healthcare professional participants, the data of 52 were available for analysis. The findings (in the respective order of the five topics above) were as follows: the number of nodes was 165, 95, 85, 82, and 68; clustering coefficient was 0.19, 0.03, 0.02, 0.11, and 0.23; assortativity was -0.043, -0.11, -0.23, -0.17, and -0.23; reciprocity was 0.35, 0.31, 0.39, 0.29, and 0.48. The top three centralities included nurses. Eighty-seven free comments were received, of which 39 were categorized as descriptive, 10 as analytical, and 38 as critical. Discussion: The structure of "consult/be consulted" networks differed by topic. SNA is available to detect the healthcare resources network and it may have helped them to reflect on their own networks.

The Effect of Interdependences of Referral Behaviors on the Quality of Ambulatory Care: Evidence from Taiwan

Purpose

The purpose of this study is to investigate the effect of interdependences of healthcare providers’ referral behaviors on the quality of ambulatory care. The significance of this study is to address the concern regarding the low quality of ambulatory care due to the lack of a compulsory referral system under Taiwan’s National Health Insurance system.

Methods

We applied the dynamic connectedness network analysis to estimate the total connectedness index of the referral behavior network, which was separated into the horizontal and vertical referral behavior components in order to measure the interdependences of horizontal and vertical referral behaviors across hospitals and local clinics, respectively.

Results

Our results suggest that the interdependences of referral behaviors increase the quality of ambulatory care. The harmful effect on the quality of ambulatory care from the interdependences of horizontal referral behaviors within the local clinics sector is more significant than that from the interdependences of horizontal referral behaviors within the hospital sector, and the negative effect on the overall and chronic composite measures of avoidable hospital admissions from the interdependences of vertical behaviors associated with local clinics is more substantial than that from the interdependences of vertical behaviors within the hospital sector.

Conclusion

These results not only highlight the significance of care collaboration between local clinics and hospitals to restrain avoidable hospital admissions of chronic diseases for a better overall quality of ambulatory care, but they also suggest that the surveillance system established for the quality of ambulatory care under the global budget payment scheme for the local clinics sector should target ambulatory care for patients with acute conditions.

Complexity of Documentation Needs for Children With Medical Complexity: Implications for Hospital Providers

OBJECTIVES

Care coordination is a core component of pediatric complex care programs (CCPs) supporting children with medical complexity (CMC) and their families. In this study, we aim to describe the purpose and characteristics of clinical care notes used within a pediatric CCP.

METHODS

We conducted observations of provider-family interactions during CCP clinic visits and 5 focus groups with members of the CCP. Focus groups were recorded and transcribed. Field observation notes and focus group transcripts were subjected to qualitative content analyses.

RESULTS

Four major themes help characterize clinical care notes: (1) Diversity of note types and functions: program staff author and use a number of unique note types shared across multiple stakeholders, including clinicians, families, and payers. (2) motivations for care note generation are different and explain how, why, and where they are created. (3) Program staff roles and configuration vary in relation to care note creation and use. (4) Sources of information for creating and updating notes are also diverse. Given the disparate information sources, integrating and maintaining up-to-date information for the child is challenging. To minimize information gaps, program staff devised unique but resource-intensive strategies, such as accompanying families during specialty clinic visits or visiting them inpatient.

CONCLUSIONS

CMC have complex documentation needs demonstrated by a variety of professional roles, care settings, and stakeholders involved in the generation and use of notes. Multiple opportunities exist to redesign and streamline the existing notes to support the cognitive work of clinicians providing care for CMC.

Assessing Association Between Team Structure and Health Outcome and Cost by Social Network Analysis

BACKGROUND/OBJECTIVE

To assess the impact of team structure composition and degree of collaboration among various providers on process and outcomes of primary care.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional study.

SETTING

Data from 20% randomly selected primary care service areas in the 2015 Medicare claims were used to identify primary care practices.

PARTICIPANTS

449,460 patients with diabetes, heart failure, or chronic obstructive pulmonary disease cared for by the identified primary care practices.

MEASUREMENTS

Social network analysis measures, including edge density, degree centralization, and betweenness centralization for each practice.

RESULTS

When compared with practices with MDs and nurse practitioners (NPs) or/and physicians assistants (PAs), the practices with MDs had only lower degree of centralization and higher MD-to-MD connectedness. Within the primary care practices comprising MDs, NPs, or/and PAs, the nonphysician providers were more connected (measured as edge density) to all providers in the practice but with higher degree of centralization compared with the MDs in the practice. After adjusting for patient characteristics and type of practice, higher edge density was associated with lower odds of hospitalization (odds ratio (OR) = 0.89, 95% confidence interval (CI) = 0.79-0.99), emergency department (ER) admission (OR = 0.80, 95% CI = 0.70-0.92), and total spending (cost ratio (CR) = 0.86, standard error of the mean (SE) = 0.038). Conversely, higher degree centralization was associated with higher rates of hospitalization (OR = 1.15, 95% CI = 1.03-1.28), ER admission (OR = 1.23, 95% CI = 1.08-1.40), and total spending (CR = 1.14, SE = 0.037). However, higher degree centralization was associated with lower rates of potentially inappropriate medications (OR = 0.90, 95% CI = 0.81-0.99). Team leadership by an NP versus an MD was similar in the rate of ER admissions, hospitalizations, or total spending.

CONCLUSION

Our findings showed that highly connected primary care practices with high collaborative care and less top-down MD-centered authority have lower odds of hospitalization, fewer ER admissions, and less total spending; findings likely reflecting better communication and more coordinated care of older patients.

Geographical fragmentation of the global network of Twitter communications

Understanding the geography of society represents a challenge for social and economic sciences. The recent availability of data from social media enables the observation of societies at a global scale. In this paper, we study the geographical structure of the Twitter communication network at the global scale. We find a complex structure where self-organized patches with clear cultural, historical, and administrative boundaries are manifested and first-world economies centralize information flows. These patches unveil world regions that are socially closer to each other with direct implications for processes of collective learning and identity creation.