Ultrasensitive hybridization capture: Reliable detection of <1 copy/mL short cell-free DNA from large-volume urine samples

Metagenomic DNA sequencing to quantify Mycobacterium tuberculosis DNA and diagnose tuberculosis

Tuberculosis (TB) remains a significant cause of mortality worldwide. Metagenomic next-generation sequencing has the potential to reveal biomarkers of active disease, identify coinfection, and improve detection for sputum-scarce or culture-negative cases. We conducted a large-scale comparative study of 428 plasma, urine, and oral swab samples from 334 individuals from TB endemic and non-endemic regions to evaluate the utility of a shotgun metagenomic DNA sequencing assay for tuberculosis diagnosis. We found that the composition of the control population had a strong impact on the measured performance of the diagnostic test: the use of a control population composed of individuals from a TB non-endemic region led to a test with nearly 100% specificity and sensitivity, whereas a control group composed of individuals from TB endemic regions exhibited a high background of nontuberculous mycobacterial DNA, limiting the diagnostic performance of the test. Using mathematical modeling and quantitative comparisons to matched qPCR data, we found that the burden of Mycobacterium tuberculosis DNA constitutes a very small fraction (0.04 or less) of the total abundance of DNA originating from mycobacteria in samples from TB endemic regions. Our findings suggest that the utility of a minimally invasive metagenomic sequencing assay for pulmonary tuberculosis diagnostics is limited by the low burden of M. tuberculosis and an overwhelming biological background of nontuberculous mycobacterial DNA.

Characterizing the molecular composition and diagnostic potential of Mycobacterium tuberculosis urinary cell-free DNA using next-generation sequencing

BACKGROUND

Urine cell-free DNA (cfDNA) is an attractive target for diagnosing pulmonary Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MTB) infection, but has not been thoroughly characterized as a biomarker.

METHODS

This study was performed to investigate the size and composition of urine cfDNA from tuberculosis (TB) patients with minimal bias using next-generation sequencing (NGS). A combination of DNA extraction and single-stranded sequence library preparation methods demonstrated to recover short, highly degraded cfDNA fragments was employed. Urine cfDNA from 10 HIV-positive patients with pulmonary TB and two MTB-negative controls was examined.

RESULTS

MTB-derived cfDNA was identifiable by NGS from all MTB-positive patients and was absent from negative controls. MTB cfDNA was significantly shorter than human cfDNA, with median fragment lengths of ≤19-52 bp and 42-92 bp, respectively. MTB cfDNA abundance increased exponentially with decreased fragment length, having a peak fragment length of ≤19 bp in most samples. In addition, we identified a larger fraction of short human genomic cfDNA, ranging from 29 to 53 bp, than previously reported. Urine cfDNA fragments spanned the MTB genome with relative uniformity, but nucleic acids derived from multicopy elements were proportionately over-represented.

CONCLUSIONS

TB urine cfDNA is a potentially powerful biomarker but is highly fragmented, necessitating special procedures to maximize its recovery and detection.

Progress toward Developing Sensitive Non-Sputum-Based Tuberculosis Diagnostic Tests: the Promise of Urine Cell-Free DNA

A highly accurate, non-sputum-based test for tuberculosis (TB) detection is a key priority for the field of TB diagnostics. A recent study in the Journal of Clinical Microbiology by Oreskovic and colleagues (J Clin Microbiol 59:e00074-21, 2021, https://doi.org/10.1128/JCM.00074-21) reports the performance of an optimized urine cell-free DNA (cfDNA) test using sequence-specific purification combined with short-target PCR to improve the accuracy of TB detection. Their retrospective clinical study utilized frozen urine samples (n = 73) from study participants diagnosed with active pulmonary TB in South Africa and compared results to non-TB patients in South Africa and the United States in an early-phase validation study. Overall, this cfDNA technique detected TB with a sensitivity of 83.7% (95% CI: 71.0 to 91.5) and specificity of 100% (95% CI: 86.2 to 100), which meet the World Health Organization's published performance criteria. Sensitivity was 73.3% in people without HIV (95% CI: 48.1 to 89.1) and 76% in people with smear-negative TB (95% CI: 56.5 to 88.5). In this commentary, we discuss the results of this optimized urine TB cfDNA assay within the larger context of TB diagnostics and pose additional questions for further research.

Diagnosing Pulmonary Tuberculosis by Using Sequence-Specific Purification of Urine Cell-Free DNA

Transrenal urine cell-free DNA (cfDNA) is a promising tuberculosis (TB) biomarker, but is challenging to detect because of the short length (<100 bp) and low concentration of TB-specific fragments. We aimed to improve the diagnostic sensitivity of TB urine cfDNA by increasing recovery of short fragments during sample preparation. We developed a highly sensitive sequence-specific purification method that uses hybridization probes immobilized on magnetic beads to capture short TB cfDNA (50 bp) with 91.8% average efficiency. Combined with short-target PCR, the assay limit of detection was ≤5 copies of cfDNA in 10 ml urine. In a clinical cohort study in South Africa, our urine cfDNA assay had 83.7% sensitivity (95% CI: 71.0 to 91.5%) and 100% specificity (95% CI: 86.2 to 100%) for diagnosis of active pulmonary TB when using sputum Xpert MTB/RIF as the reference standard. The detected cfDNA concentration was 0.14 to 2,804 copies/ml (median 14.6 copies/ml) and was inversely correlated with CD4 count and days to culture positivity. Sensitivity was nonsignificantly higher in HIV-positive (88.2%) compared to HIV-negative patients (73.3%), and was not dependent on CD4 count. Sensitivity remained high in sputum smear-negative (76.0%) and urine lipoarabinomannan (LAM)-negative (76.5%) patients. With improved sample preparation, urine cfDNA is a viable biomarker for TB diagnosis. Our assay has the highest reported accuracy of any TB urine cfDNA test to date and has the potential to enable rapid non-sputum-based TB diagnosis across key underserved patient populations.