Application of vibration to the soles reduces minimum toe clearance variability during walking

An exploration of the agreement, inter- and intra-rater reliability, and reproducibility of three common methods used to measure minimum toe clearance with optical motion capture systems under three shoe conditions

BACKGROUND

The gait variable minimum toe clearance (MTC) has been investigated concerning trip-related fall research in older adults. However, comparing studies is difficult due to the different methods used to measure MTC and shoe conditions, which may affect agreement. Measurement methods can include using a single virtual point (SVP), multiple virtual points (MVPS), or metatarsal head markers (marker-based). The shoe types used in MTC studies include standard shoes (SS), personal shoes (PS), and barefoot (BF) conditions.

RESEARCH QUESTION

What is the agreement, inter and intra-rater reliability, and repeatability for the 3 commonly used methods of measuring MTC (SVP, MVPS, marker-based) under the 3 shoe conditions for optical motion capture systems (SS, PS, BF)?

METHODS

Twelve healthy young adults (mean [SD] 23.8 [1.9] years,7 males) participated in this observational study. In a randomized order, participants completed 25 walking trials at self-selected normal and slow speeds in SS, PS, and BF conditions while infrared cameras recorded the maker trajectories. Each participant performed a familiarization trial for at least 1 minute before collecting data on each shoe condition. Statistical analyses included Bland-Altman 95 % limits of agreement (LOA) analyses, interclass correlation coefficient (ICC) analyses for inter- and intra-rater reliability, and the repeatability coefficient (RC).

RESULTS

The SVP and MVPS had a tighter 95 % LOA than the marker-based method, particularly under SS and BF conditions. The inter-rater reliability was good to excellent under these shoe conditions. Intra-reliability for all methods under all shoe conditions was excellent (ICC >.90). The RC was very similar for each method, with none exceeding 1.02 cm.

SIGNIFICANCE

The study provides estimates of the agreement between MTC methods and suggests that only SVP or MVPS produced similar results in SS/BF conditions. Additionally, a "true" change in MTC requires a difference greater than 1.02 cm.

The effects of vibrating shoe insoles on standing balance, walking, and ankle-foot muscle activity in adults with diabetic peripheral neuropathy

BACKGROUND

Peripheral neuropathy is one of the most common complications of type 2 diabetes, which can lead to impaired balance and walking. Innovative footwear devices designed to stimulate foot sensory receptors, such as vibrating insoles, could offer a new route to improve motor impairments in people with diabetic peripheral neuropathy (DPN).

RESEARCH QUESTION

Does wearing vibrating insoles for the first time alter measures of balance, walking, and ankle-foot muscle activity, in people with DPN?

METHODS

A randomised cross-over study was conducted with 18 ambulant men and women with a diagnosis of DPN. Participants performed tests of standing balance (Bertec® force platform) under four conditions (foam/firm surface, eyes open/closed) and level-ground walking (GAITRite® instrumented walkway), whilst wearing vibrating and non-vibrating (control) insoles on two separate occasions (one insole/session). Electromyography (EMG) was used to assess soleus, medial gastrocnemius, tibialis anterior, peroneus longus activity during balance tests. Outcomes included centre of pressure (CoP) sway, EMG amplitude, spatiotemporal gait patterns, and Timed Up and Go test. One sample t-tests were used to explore %differences in outcomes between insole conditions.

RESULTS

Wearing vibrating insoles led to a reduction (improvement) in CoP elliptical area, when standing on a foam surface with eyes closed, relative to non-vibrating insoles (P=0.03). Applying perceptible vibrations to the soles of the feet also reduced the EMG amplitude in soleus (P=0.01 and P=0.04) and medial gastrocnemius (P=0.03 and P=0.09) when standing with eyes closed on firm and foam surfaces.

SIGNIFICANCE

Our findings of signs of improved balance and altered muscle activity with suprasensory vibrating insoles provides new insights into how these devices can be used to inform innovative rehabilitation approaches in individuals with DPN. This will be strengthened by further research into possible clinical benefits of these devices - given that the effects we detected were small with uncertain clinical meaning.

Application of vibration to the soles increases long-range correlations in the stride parameters during walking

Temporal fluctuations in the stride parameters during human walking exhibit long-range correlations, but these long-range correlations in the stride parameters decrease due to aging or neuromuscular diseases. These observations suggest that any quantified index of the long-range correlation can be regarded as an indicator of gait functionality. Considering the effect of task-relevant sensory feedback on augmenting human motor performance, we devised shoes with active insoles that could deliver noisy vibration to the soles of feet and assessed their efficacy in enhancing the long-range correlations in the stride parameters for healthy young adults. The vibration could be wirelessly controlled using a smartphone. The actuators, control unit, and battery in the devised shoes were light and embedded in the shoes. By virtue of this compactness, the shoes could be easily used for daily walking outside a laboratory. We performed walking experiments with 20 healthy adults and evaluated the effects of sub- and supra-threshold vibration on long-range correlations in stride interval and length. We performed detrended fluctuation analysis to quantify the long-range correlation of temporal changes in stride interval and length. We found that supra-threshold vibration, applied to the soles with the amplitude of 130 % of the sensory threshold, significantly increased the long-range correlations in stride interval and length by 10.3 % (p = 0.009) and 10.1 % (p = 0.021), respectively. On the other hand, sub-threshold vibration with the amplitude of 90 % of the sensory threshold had no significant effect. These results demonstrate that additional somatosensory feedback through barely detectable vibrations, which are supplied by compact shoes with active insoles, can enhance the indices of "healthy" complexity of locomotor function.

Feasibility of mitigating out-toeing gait using compression tights with inward-directing taping lines

Out-toeing gait may cause alterations in lower limb biomechanics that could lead to an increased risk of overuse injuries. Surgery and physical therapy are conventional methods for mitigating such gait, but they are costly and time-consuming. Wearable devices like braces and orthoses are used as affordable alternatives, but they apply non-negligible stress on the skin. Haptic feedback-delivering shoes were also recently developed, but they require actuators and power sources. The purpose of our study is to develop compression tights with inward directing taping lines that apply compression to lower limb muscles and segments to facilitate inward rotation of the foot, overcoming the drawbacks of previous methods. These compression tights were manufactured to fit the average height, leg length, hip girth, and waist girth of South Korean females in their twenties. The efficacy of these compression tights was evaluated by comparing walking kinematics and user satisfaction of 12 female dancers with an out-toeing gait under three conditions: wearing tights with taping lines, tights without taping lines, and basic bicycle shorts. The foot rotation angles and joint kinematics were recorded using a pressure-pad treadmill and motion capture system, respectively. Multiple pairwise comparisons revealed that the compression tights with inward-directing lines significantly reduced foot rotation angles (up to an average of 20.1%) compared with the bicycle shorts (p = 0.002 and 0.001 for dominant and non-dominant foot, respectively) or the compression tights without taping lines (p = 0.005 and p = 0.001 for dominant and non-dominant foot, respectively). Statistical parametric mapping revealed significant main effects of the tight type on joint kinematics. Also, t-tests revealed that the participants reported significantly higher ratings of perceived functionality and usability on the compression tights with inward-directing taping lines. In conclusion, we developed a comfortable and practical apparel-type wearable and demonstrated its short-term efficacy in mitigating out-toeing gait.

The effect of mechanical vibration-based stimulation on dynamic balance control and gait characteristics in healthy young and older adults: A systematic review of cross-sectional study

BACKGROUND

A good dynamic balance control and stable gait played an important role in the daily ambulation, especially for older adults with sensorimotor degeneration. This study aimed to systematically review the effects and potential mechanisms of mechanical vibration-based stimulation (MVBS) on dynamic balance control and gait characteristics in healthy young and older adults.

METHOD

Five bioscience and engineering databases, including MEDLINE via PubMed, CINAHL via EBSCO, Cochrane Library, Scopus, and Embase, were searched until September 4th, 2022. Studies published between 2000 and 2022 in English and Chinese involving mechanical vibration related to gait and dynamic balance were included. The procedure was followed via the preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analysis method. The methodological quality of included studies was assessed using the NIH study quality assessment tool for observational cohort and cross-sectional studies.

RESULTS

A total of 41 cross-sectional studies met the inclusion criteria and were included in this study. Eight studies were good-quality while 26 were moderate-quality and 7 were poor-quality. There were six categories of MVBS at various frequencies and amplitudes utilized in included studies, including plantar vibration, focal muscle vibration, Achilles tendon vibration, vestibular vibration, cervical vibration, and vibration on nail of hallux.

SIGNIFICANCE

Different types of MVBS targeting different sensory systems affected the dynamic balance control and gait characteristics differently. MVBS could be used to provide improvement or perturbation to specific sensory systems, to induce different sensory reweight strategies during gait.

Different types of plantar vibration affect gait characteristics differently while walking on different inclines

Background

Plantar vibration has been widely used to strengthen the sensation of the somatosensory system, further enhancing balance during walking on a level surface in patients with stroke. However, previous studies with plantar vibration only involved the level surface, which neglected the importance of inclined/declined walking in daily life. Thus, combining the plantar vibration and inclined/declined walking might answer a critical research question: whether different types of plantar vibration had different effects on gait characteristics during walking on different inclines.

Methods

Eighteen healthy young adults were recruited. Fifteen walking conditions were assigned randomly to these healthy adults (no, sub-, and supra-threshold plantar vibration × five different inclines: +15%, +8%, 0%, -8%, -15% grade). A motion capture system with eight cameras captured 12 retro-reflective markers and measured the stride time, stride length, step width, and respective variabilities.

Results

A significant interaction between vibration and inclination was observed in the stride time (p < 0.0001) and step width (p = 0.015). Post hoc comparisons found that supra-threshold vibration significantly decreased the stride time (-8%: p < 0.001; -15%: p < 0.001) while the sub-threshold vibration significantly increased the step width (-8%: p = 0.036) in comparison with no plantar vibration.

Conclusions

When walking downhill, any perceivable (supra-threshold) vibration on the plantar area decreased the stride time. Also, the increase in step width was observed by non-perceivable (sub-threshold) plantar vibration while walking uphill. These observations were crucial as follows: (1) applying sub-threshold plantar vibrations during uphill walking could increase the base of support, and (2) for those who may need challenges in locomotor training, applying supra-threshold vibration during downhill walking could reach this specific training goal.

Taping-induced cutaneous stimulation to the ankle tendons reduces minimum toe clearance variability

Large variability of minimum toe clearance (MTC) leads to a higher risk of tripping. Visual feedback-based gait training systems have been used to regulate MTC distribution, but these systems are expensive and bulky. Furthermore, the effect of such training lasts only for a short period of time. Considering the efficacy of elastic adhesive tape-induced cutaneous stimulation to the ankle tendons in improving proprioception and movement detection, we hypothesize that application of tapes to the ankle tendons as a practical method for modifying MTC distribution. To test this hypothesis, we recruited 13 young and healthy adults and instructed them to walk on a treadmill under four conditions: no taping, taping the tibialis anterior tendon, taping the Achilles tendon, and taping both tendons. We measured MTC distribution, lower limb joint angles and muscle activations of the tibialis anterior and gastrocnemius medialis, and compared these outcomes under the four conditions. The application of elastic adhesive tape to the ankle tendons had no significant effect on the average MTC height, but tapes applied to the Achilles tendon and both tendons significantly reduced MTC variability. Taping decreased the variability of some lower limb joint angles, but taping did not induce significant changes in the activation levels of the shank muscles. These results demonstrate that elastic adhesive tape applied to the shank can reduce MTC variability with minimal resistance, inertia and cumbersomeness.

Effect of vibrotactile stimulation of the hallux nail on segmental coordination: A secondary analysis using uncontrolled manifold analysis

Controlling center of mass (CoM) movement in the mediolateral direction is imperative for stable walking. During walking, CoM movement is adjusted by the coordination of each body segment, which can be evaluated using uncontrolled manifold (UCM) analysis. UCM analysis evaluates segmental coordination by analyzing variablity in motor movement among the different segments of the body. The vibrotactile stimulation of the hallux nail can augment the sensory information of the plantar surface for necessary motor control. This study aims to investigate the effect of the vibrotactile stimulation of the hallux nail on segmental coordination to control CoM movement in the mediolateral direction during walking. Thirteen healthy men participated in the study. A vibrator was attached to each hallux nail, and pressure sensors were placed under the hallux balls. When the hallux ball was in contact with the floor, vibration stimulation was applied. A three-dimensional motion analysis system was used to measure the segment angles during walking, and UCM analysis was used to evaluate kinematic synergy for controlling CoM movement in the mediolateral direction. Subsequently, segment angles were used as an elemental variable. The synergy index and bad variability as motor noise were negatively related to the status without the stimulation. Vibrotactile stimulation in young people was more effective for people with large motor noise and a small synergy index during the single-stance phase. Thus, kinematic synergy can be immediately changed by sensory input using vibrotactile stimulation of the hallux nail, although applying vibration stimulation should be considered in advance.