Vaccinia viral A26 protein is a fusion suppressor of mature virus and triggers membrane fusion through conformational change at low pH

A new MVA ancestor-derived oncolytic vaccinia virus induces immunogenic tumor cell death and robust antitumor immune responses

Vaccinia viruses (VACVs) are versatile therapeutic agents and different features of various VACV strains allow for a broad range of therapeutic applications. Modified VACV Ankara (MVA) is a particularly altered VACV strain that is highly immunogenic, incapable of replicating in mammalian hosts, and broadly used as a safe vector for vaccination. Alternatively, Western Reserve (WR) or Copenhagen (Cop) are VACV strains that efficiently replicate in cancer cells and, therefore, are used to develop oncolytic viruses. However, the immune evasion capacity of WR or Cop hinders their ability to elicit antitumor immune responses, which is crucial for efficacy in the clinic. Here, we describe a new VACV strain named Immune-Oncolytic VACV Ankara (IOVA), which combines efficient replication in cancer cells with induction of immunogenic tumor cell death (ICD). IOVA was engineered from an MVA ancestor and shows superior cytotoxicity in tumor cells. In addition, the IOVA genome incorporates mutations that lead to massive fusogenesis of tumor cells, which contributes to improved antitumor effects. In syngeneic mouse tumor models, the induction of ICD results in robust antitumor immunity directed against tumor neo-epitopes and eradication of large established tumors. These data present IOVA as an improved immunotherapeutic oncolytic vector.

The vaccinia chondroitin sulfate binding protein drives host membrane curvature to facilitate fusion

Cellular attachment of viruses determines their cell tropism and species specificity. For entry, vaccinia, the prototypic poxvirus, relies on four binding proteins and an eleven-protein entry fusion complex. The contribution of the individual virus binding proteins to virion binding orientation and membrane fusion is unclear. Here, we show that virus binding proteins guide side-on virion binding and promote curvature of the host membrane towards the virus fusion machinery to facilitate fusion. Using a membrane-bleb model system together with super-resolution and electron microscopy we find that side-bound vaccinia virions induce membrane invagination in the presence of low pH. Repression or deletion of individual binding proteins reveals that three of four contribute to binding orientation, amongst which the chondroitin sulfate binding protein, D8, is required for host membrane bending. Consistent with low-pH dependent macropinocytic entry of vaccinia, loss of D8 prevents virion-associated macropinosome membrane bending, disrupts fusion pore formation and infection. Our results show that viral binding proteins are active participants in successful virus membrane fusion and illustrate the importance of virus protein architecture for successful infection.

Identification of a Potential Entry-Fusion Complex Based on Sequence Homology of African Swine Fever and Vaccinia Virus

African swine fever virus (ASFV) belongs to the family of Asfarviridae, part of the group of nucleocytoplasmic large DNA viruses (NCLDV). Little is known about the internalization of ASFV in the host cell and the fusion membrane events that take place at early stages of the infection. Poxviruses, also members of the NCLDV and represented by vaccinia virus (VACV), are large, enveloped, double-stranded DNA viruses. Poxviruses were considered unique in having an elaborate entry-fusion complex (EFC) composed of 11 highly conserved proteins integrated into the membrane of mature virions. Recent advances in methodological techniques have again revealed several connections between VACV EFC proteins. In this study, we explored the possibility of an analogous ASFV EFC by identifying ten candidate proteins exhibiting structural similarities with VACV EFC proteins. This could reveal key functions of these ASFV proteins, drawing attention to shared features between the two virus families, suggesting the potential existence of an ASFV entry-fusion complex.

Structural and functional analyses of viral H2 protein of the vaccinia virus entry fusion complex

IMPORTANCE

Vaccinia virus infection requires virus-cell membrane fusion to complete entry during endocytosis; however, it contains a large viral fusion protein complex of 11 viral proteins that share no structure or sequence homology to all the known viral fusion proteins, including type I, II, and III fusion proteins. It is thus very challenging to investigate how the vaccinia fusion complex works to trigger membrane fusion with host cells. In this study, we crystallized the ectodomain of vaccinia H2 protein, one component of the viral fusion complex. Furthermore, we performed a series of mutational, biochemical, and molecular analyses and identified two surface loops containing 170LGYSG174 and 125RRGTGDAW132 as the A28-binding region. We also showed that residues in the N-terminal helical region (amino acids 51-90) are also important for H2 function.

Structural and functional analysis of vaccinia viral fusion complex component protein A28 through NMR and molecular dynamic simulations

Host cell entry of vaccinia virus (a poxvirus) proceeds through multiple steps that involve many viral proteins to mediate cell infection. Upon binding to cells, vaccinia virus membrane fuses with host membranes via a viral entry fusion protein complex comprising 11 proteins: A16, A21, A28, F9, G3, G9, H2, J5, L1, L5 and O3. Despite vaccinia virus having two infectious forms, mature and enveloped, that have different membrane layers, both forms require an identical viral entry fusion complex for membrane fusion. Components of the poxvirus entry fusion complex that have been structurally assessed to date share no known homology with all other type I, II and III viral fusion proteins, and the large number of fusion protein components renders it a unique system to investigate poxvirus-mediated membrane fusion. Here, we determined the NMR structure of a truncated version of vaccinia A28 protein. We also expressed a soluble H2 protein and showed that A28 interacts with H2 protein at a 1:1 ratio in vitro. Furthermore, we performed extensive in vitro alanine mutagenesis to identify A28 protein residues that are critical for H2 binding, entry fusion complex formation, and virus-mediated membrane fusion. Finally, we used molecular dynamic simulations to model full-length A28-H2 subcomplex in membranes. In summary, we characterized vaccinia virus A28 protein and determined residues important in its interaction with H2 protein and membrane components. We also provide a structural model of the A28-H2 protein interaction to illustrate how it forms a 1:1 subcomplex on a modeled membrane.

Targeting envelope proteins of poxviruses to repurpose phytochemicals against monkeypox: An in silico investigation

The monkeypox virus (MPXV) has become a major threat due to the increasing global caseload and the ongoing multi-country outbreak in non-endemic territories. Due to limited research in this avenue and the lack of intervention strategies, the present study was aimed to virtually screen bioactive phytochemicals against envelope proteins of MPXV via rigorous computational approaches. Molecular docking, molecular dynamic (MD) simulations, and MM/PBSA analysis were used to investigate the binding affinity of 12 phytochemicals against three envelope proteins of MPXV, viz., D13, A26, and H3. Silibinin, oleanolic acid, and ursolic acid were computationally identified as potential phytochemicals that showed strong binding affinity toward all the tested structural proteins of MPXV through molecular docking. The stability of the docked complexes was also confirmed by MD simulations and MM/PBSA calculations. Results from the iMODS server also complemented the findings from molecular docking and MD simulations. ADME analysis also computationally confirmed the drug-like properties of the phytochemicals, thereby asserting their suitability for consumption. Hence, this study envisions the candidature of bioactive phytochemicals as promising inhibitors against the envelope proteins of the MPXV, serving as template molecules that could further be experimentally evaluated for their efficacy against monkeypox.

The Art of Viral Membrane Fusion and Penetration

As obligate pathogens, viruses have developed diverse mechanisms to deliver their genome across host cell membranes to sites of virus replication. While enveloped viruses utilize viral fusion proteins to accomplish fusion of their envelope with the cellular membrane, non-enveloped viruses rely on machinery that causes local membrane ruptures and creates an opening through which the capsid or viral genome is released. Both membrane fusion and membrane penetration take place at the plasma membrane or in intracellular compartments, often involving the engagement of the cellular machinery and antagonism of host restriction factors. Enveloped and non-enveloped viruses have evolved intricate mechanisms to enable virus uncoating and modulation of membrane fusion in a spatiotemporally controlled manner. This chapter summarizes and discusses the current state of understanding of the mechanisms of viral membrane fusion and penetration. The focus is on the role of lipids, viral scaffold uncoating, viral membrane fusion inhibitors, and host restriction factors as physicochemical modulators. In addition, recent advances in visualizing and detecting viral membrane fusion and penetration using cryo-electron microscopy methods are presented.

Identification of β2 microglobulin, the product of B2M gene, as a Host Factor for Vaccinia Virus Infection by Genome-Wide CRISPR genetic screens

Genome-wide genetic screens are powerful tools to identify genes that act as host factors of viruses. We have applied this technique to analyze the infection of HeLa cells by Vaccinia virus, in an attempt to find genes necessary for infection. Infection of cell populations harboring single gene inactivations resulted in no surviving cells, suggesting that no single gene knock-out was able to provide complete resistance to Vaccinia virus and thus allow cells to survive infection. In the absence of an absolute infection blockage, we explored if some gene inactivations could provide partial protection leading to a reduced probability of infection. Multiple experiments using modified screening procedures involving replication restricted viruses led to the identification of multiple genes whose inactivation potentially increase resistance to infection and therefore cell survival. As expected, significant gene hits were related to proteins known to act in virus entry, such as ITGB1 and AXL as well as genes belonging to their downstream related pathways. Additionally, we consistently found β2-microglobulin, encoded by the B2M gene, among the screening top hits, a novel finding that was further explored. Inactivation of B2M resulted in 54% and 91% reduced VV infection efficiency in HeLa and HAP1 cell lines respectively. In the absence of B2M, while virus binding to the cells was unaffected, virus internalization and early gene expression were significantly diminished. These results point to β2-microglobulin as a relevant factor in the Vaccinia virus entry process.

LINE-1 retrotransposons facilitate horizontal gene transfer into poxviruses

There is ample phylogenetic evidence that many critical virus functions, like immune evasion, evolved by the acquisition of genes from their hosts through horizontal gene transfer (HGT). However, the lack of an experimental system has prevented a mechanistic understanding of this process. We developed a model to elucidate the mechanisms of HGT into vaccinia virus, the prototypic poxvirus. All identified gene capture events showed signatures of long interspersed nuclear element-1 (LINE-1)-mediated retrotransposition, including spliced-out introns, polyadenylated tails, and target site duplications. In one case, the acquired gene integrated together with a polyadenylated host U2 small nuclear RNA. Integrations occurred across the genome, in some cases knocking out essential viral genes. These essential gene knockouts were rescued through a process of complementation by the parent virus followed by nonhomologous recombination during serial passaging to generate a single, replication-competent virus. This work links multiple evolutionary mechanisms into one adaptive cascade and identifies host retrotransposons as major drivers for virus evolution.

pH Sensitive Erythrocyte-Derived Membrane for Acute Systemic Retention and Increased Infectivity of Coated Oncolytic Vaccinia Virus

Oncolytic viruses have emerged as a promising modality in cancer treatment given their high synergy with highly efficient immune checkpoint inhibitors. However, their potency is limited by their rapid in vivo clearance. To overcome this, we coated oncolytic vaccinia viruses (oVV) with erythrocyte-derived membranes (EDMs), hypothesizing that they would not only remain in systemic circulation for longer as erythrocytes would when administered intravenously, but also respond to environmental pH cues due to their membrane surface sialic acid residues. For this, we developed a model based on DLVO theory to show that the acidic moieties on the surface of EDM confers it the ability to respond to pH-based stimuli. We corroborate our modeling results through in vitro cell culture models and show that EDM-coated oVV infects cancer cells faster under acidic conditions akin to the tumor microenvironment. When EDM-coated oVVs were intravenously injected into wild-type mice, they exhibited prolonged circulation at higher concentrations when compared to the unprocessed oVV. Furthermore, when EDM-coated oVV was directly injected into xenografted tumors, we observed that they were suppressed earlier than the tumors that received regular oVV, suggesting that the EDM coating does not hinder oVV infectivity. Overall, we found that EDM was able to serve as a multi-functional encapsulant that allowed the payload to remain in circulation at higher concentrations when administered intravenously while simultaneously exhibiting pH-responsive properties.

Engineered Promoter-Switched Viruses Reveal the Role of Poxvirus Maturation Protein A26 as a Negative Regulator of Viral Spread

Vaccinia virus produces two types of virions known as single-membraned intracellular mature virus (MV) and double-membraned extracellular enveloped virus (EV). EV production peaks earlier when initial MVs are further wrapped and secreted to spread infection within the host. However, late during infection, MVs accumulate intracellularly and become important for host-to-host transmission. The process that regulates this switch remains elusive and is thought to be influenced by host factors. Here, we examined the hypothesis that EV and MV production are regulated by the virus through expression of F13 and the MV-specific protein A26. By switching the promoters and altering the expression kinetics of F13 and A26, we demonstrate that A26 expression downregulates EV production and plaque size, thus limiting viral spread. This process correlates with A26 association with the MV surface protein A27 and exclusion of F13, thus reducing EV titers. Thus, MV maturation is controlled by the abundance of the viral A26 protein, independently of other factors, and is rate limiting for EV production. The A26 gene is conserved within vertebrate poxviruses but is strikingly lost in poxviruses known to be transmitted exclusively by biting arthropods. A26-mediated virus maturation thus has the appearance to be an ancient evolutionary adaptation to enhance transmission of poxviruses that has subsequently been lost from vector-adapted species, for which it may serve as a genetic signature. The existence of virus-regulated mechanisms to produce virions adapted to fulfill different functions represents a novel level of complexity in mammalian viruses with major impacts on evolution, adaptation, and transmission. IMPORTANCE Chordopoxviruses are mammalian viruses that uniquely produce a first type of virion adapted to spread within the host and a second type that enhances transmission between hosts, which can take place by multiple ways, including direct contact, respiratory droplets, oral/fecal routes, or via vectors. Both virion types are important to balance intrahost dissemination and interhost transmission, so virus maturation pathways must be tightly controlled. Here, we provide evidence that the abundance and kinetics of expression of the viral protein A26 regulates this process by preventing formation of the first form and shifting maturation toward the second form. A26 is expressed late after the initial wave of progeny virions is produced, so sufficient viral dissemination is ensured, and A26 provides virions with enhanced environmental stability. Conservation of A26 in all vertebrate poxviruses, but not in those transmitted exclusively via biting arthropods, reveals the importance of A26-controlled virus maturation for transmission routes involving environmental exposure.

NMR assignments of vaccinia virus protein A28: an entry-fusion complex component

Vaccinia virus (VACV) belonging to the poxvirus family enters the host cell via two different entry pathways; either endocytosis or virus/host cell membrane fusion. With respect to the virus/host cell membrane fusion, there are eleven viral membrane proteins forming a complicated entry-fusion complex (EFC), including A28, A21, A16, F9, G9, G3, H2, J5, L5, L1 and O3, to conduct the fusion function. These EFC components are highly conserved in all poxviruses and each of them is essential and necessary for the fusion activity. So far, with the exceptions of L1 and F9 whose crystal structures were reported, the structural information about other EFC components remains largely unclear. We aim to conduct a structural and functional investigation of VACV virus-entry membrane protein A28. In this work, we expressed and purified a truncated form of A28 (14 kDa; residues 38-146, abbreviated as tA28 hereinafter), with deletion of its transmembrane domain (residues 1-22) and a hydrophobic segment (residues 23-37). And the assignments of its backbone and side chain ¹H, ¹³C and ¹⁵N chemical shifts of tA28 are reported. The secondary structure propensity from TALOS+ indicates that tA28 does contain three α-helices, six β-strands and connecting loops. Aside from this, we demonstrated that tA28 does interact with fusion suppressor viral protein A26 (residues 351-500) by the ¹H-¹⁵N HSQC spectrum. We interpret that A28 binding to A26 deactivates EFC fusion activity. The current study provides a valuable framework towards further structural analyses of this protein and for better understanding virus/host cell membrane fusion mechanism in association with virus entry.

Unravelling the mechanism of pH-regulation in dinoflagellate luciferase

Dinoflagellates are the dominant source of bioluminescence in coastal waters. The luminescence reaction involves the oxidation of luciferin by a luciferase enzyme, which only takes place at low pH. The pH-dependence has previously been linked to four conserved histidines. It has been suggested that their protonation might induce a conformational change in the enzyme, thereby allowing substrate access to the binding pocket. Yet, the precise mechanism of luciferase activation has remained elusive. Here, we use computational tools to predict the open structure of the luciferase in Lingulodinium polyedra and to decipher the nature of the opening mechanism. Through accelerated molecular dynamics simulations, we demonstrate that the closed-open conformational change likely takes place via a tilt of the pH-regulatory helix-loop-helix domain. Moreover, we propose that the molecular basis for the transition is electrostatic repulsion between histidine-cation pairs, which destabilizes the closed conformation at low pH. Finally, by simulating truncated mutants, we show that eliminating the C-terminus alters the shape of the active site, effectively inactivating the luciferase.

Tumour vasculature: Friend or foe of oncolytic viruses?

In the past two decades there have been substantial advances in understanding the anti-cancer mechanisms of oncolytic viruses (OVs). OVs can mediate their effects directly, by preferentially infecting and killing tumour cells. Additionally, OVs can indirectly generate anti-tumour immune responses. These differing mechanisms have led to a paradoxical divergence in strategies employed to further increase the potency of oncolytic virotherapies. On one hand, the tumour neovasculature is seen as a vital lifeline to the survival of the tumour, leading some to use OVs to target the tumour vasculature in hopes to starve cancers. Therapeutics causing vascular collapse can potentiate tumour hypoxia, nutrient restriction and pro-inflammatory cytokine release, which has shown promise in oncological studies. On the other hand, the same vasculature plays an important role for the dissemination of OVs, trafficking of effector cells and other therapeutics, which has prompted researchers to find ways of normalizing the vasculature to enhance infiltration of leukocytes and delivery of therapeutic agents. This article describes the recent developments of therapies aimed to shut down versus normalize tumour vasculature in order to inform researchers striving to optimize OV-based therapies.

Inactivation of Genes by Frameshift Mutations Provides Rapid Adaptation of an Attenuated Vaccinia Virus

Unlike RNA viruses, most DNA viruses replicate their genomes with high-fidelity polymerases that rarely make base substitution errors. Nevertheless, experimental evolution studies have revealed rapid acquisition of adaptive mutations during serial passage of attenuated vaccinia virus (VACV). One way in which adaptation can occur is by an accordion mechanism in which the gene copy number increases followed by base substitutions and, finally, contraction of the gene copy number. Here, we show rapid acquisition of multiple adaptive mutations mediated by a gene-inactivating frameshift mechanism during passage of an attenuated VACV. Attenuation had been achieved by exchanging the VACV A8R intermediate transcription factor gene with the myxoma virus ortholog. A total of seven mutations in six different genes occurred in three parallel passages of the attenuated virus. The most frequent mutations were single-nucleotide insertions or deletions within runs of five to seven As or Ts, although a deletion of 11 nucleotides also occurred, leading to frameshifts and premature stop codons. During 10 passage rounds, the attenuated VACV was replaced by the mutant viruses. At the end of the experiment, virtually all remaining viruses had one fixed mutation and one or more additional mutations. Although nucleotide substitutions in the transcription apparatus accounted for two low-frequency mutations, frameshifts in genes encoding protein components of the mature virion, namely, A26L, G6R, and A14.5L, achieved 74% to 98% fixation. The adaptive role of the mutations was confirmed by making recombinant VACV with A26L or G6R or both deleted, which increased virus replication levels and decreased particle/PFU ratios.IMPORTANCE Gene inactivation is considered to be an important driver of orthopoxvirus evolution. Whereas cowpox virus contains intact orthologs of genes present in each orthopoxvirus species, numerous genes are inactivated in all other members of the genus. Inactivation of additional genes can occur upon extensive passaging of orthopoxviruses in cell culture leading to attenuation in vivo, a strategy for making vaccines. Whether inactivation of multiple viral genes enhances replication in the host cells or has a neutral effect is unknown in most cases. Using an experimental evolution protocol involving serial passages of an attenuated vaccinia virus, rapid acquisition of inactivating frameshift mutations occurred. After only 10 passage rounds, the starting attenuated vaccinia virus was displaced by viruses with one fixed mutation and one or more additional mutations. The high frequency of multiple inactivating mutations during experimental evolution simulates their acquisition during normal evolution and extensive virus passaging to make vaccine strains.

Investigating Viruses During the Transformation of Molecular Biology: Part II

My scientific career started at an extraordinary time, shortly after the discoveries of the helical structure of DNA, the central dogma of DNA to RNA to protein, and the genetic code. Part I of this series emphasizes my education and early studies highlighted by the isolation and characterization of numerous vaccinia virus enzymes, determination of the cap structure of messenger RNA, and development of poxviruses as gene expression vectors for use as recombinant vaccines. Here I describe a shift in my research focus to combine molecular biology and genetics for a comprehensive understanding of poxvirus biology. The dominant paradigm during the early years was to select a function, isolate the responsible proteins, and locate the corresponding gene, whereas later the common paradigm was to select a gene, make a mutation, and determine the altered function. Motivations, behind-the-scenes insights, importance of new technologies, and the vital roles of trainees and coworkers are emphasized.

Experimental Evolution To Isolate Vaccinia Virus Adaptive G9 Mutants That Overcome Membrane Fusion Inhibition via the Vaccinia Virus A56/K2 Protein Complex

For cell entry, vaccinia virus requires fusion with the host membrane via a viral fusion complex of 11 proteins, but the mechanism remains unclear. It was shown previously that the viral proteins A56 and K2 are expressed on infected cells to prevent superinfection by extracellular vaccinia virus through binding to two components of the viral fusion complex (G9 and A16), thereby inhibiting membrane fusion. To investigate how the A56/K2 complex inhibits membrane fusion, we performed experimental evolutionary analyses by repeatedly passaging vaccinia virus in HeLa cells overexpressing the A56 and K2 proteins to isolate adaptive mutant viruses. Genome sequencing of adaptive mutants revealed that they had accumulated a unique G9R open reading frame (ORF) mutation, resulting in a single His44Tyr amino acid change. We engineered a recombinant vaccinia virus to express the G9^H44Y mutant protein, and it readily infected HeLa-A56/K2 cells. Moreover, similar to the ΔA56 virus, the G9^H44Y mutant virus on HeLa cells had a cell fusion phenotype, indicating that G9^H44Y-mediated membrane fusion was less prone to inhibition by A56/K2. Coimmunoprecipitation experiments demonstrated that the G9^H44Y protein bound to A56/K2 at neutral pH, suggesting that the H44Y mutation did not eliminate the binding of G9 to A56/K2. Interestingly, upon acid treatment to inactivate A56/K2-mediated fusion inhibition, the G9^H44Y mutant virus induced robust cell-cell fusion at pH 6, unlike the pH 4.7 required for control and revertant vaccinia viruses. Thus, A56/K2 fusion suppression mainly targets the G9 protein. Moreover, the G9^H44Y mutant protein escapes A56/K2-mediated membrane fusion inhibition most likely because it mimics an acid-induced intermediate conformation more prone to membrane fusion.IMPORTANCE It remains unclear how the multiprotein entry fusion complex of vaccinia virus mediates membrane fusion. Moreover, vaccinia virus contains fusion suppressor proteins to prevent the aberrant activation of this multiprotein complex. Here, we used experimental evolution to identify adaptive mutant viruses that overcome membrane fusion inhibition mediated by the A56/K2 protein complex. We show that the H44Y mutation of the G9 protein is sufficient to overcome A56/K2-mediated membrane fusion inhibition. Treatment of virus-infected cells at different pHs indicated that the H44Y mutation lowers the threshold of fusion inhibition by A56/K2. Our study provides evidence that A56/K2 inhibits the viral fusion complex via the latter's G9 subcomponent. Although the G9^H44Y mutant protein still binds to A56/K2 at neutral pH, it is less dependent on low pH for fusion activation, implying that it may adopt a subtle conformational change that mimics a structural intermediate induced by low pH.