A Major Step Forward in the Routine Measurement of Serum Free Thyroid Hormones

Mass spectrometry in measurement of thyroid biomarkers

In 2022, the number of patients with thyroid disease in China exceeded 200 million (10 million with hyperthyroidism, 90 million with hypothyroidism, and 100 million with other thyroid disease such as goiter, thyroid nodules, and thyroid cancer). Well-established markers include FT3, FT4, TT3, TT4, and TSH tested by a number of immunoassay methods. This approach is based on the primary binding of antigen with antibody and a subsequent secondary chemical reaction that provides an indirect measure. The use of traceable standards for quantitation remains an important factor to ensure inter-assay reliability and precision. Recently, mass spectrometry (MS) has received considerable attention as an analytic tool due to high resolution and quantitative accuracy. In addition, MS allows for sensitive determination of low-abundance markers making it ideal for development of traceable standards. Furthermore, this technology will allow for the development of highly accurate thyroid biomarker assays to facilitate diagnosis, enable early treatment and improve outcomes. Herein, we provide a systematic review and summary of MS in enhancing the analysis of thyroid biomarkers.

Free thyroxine measurement in clinical practice: how to optimize indications, analytical procedures, and interpretation criteria while waiting for global standardization

Thyroid dysfunctions are among the most common endocrine disorders and accurate biochemical testing is needed to confirm or rule out a diagnosis. Notably, true hyperthyroidism and hypothyroidism in the setting of a normal thyroid-stimulating hormone level are highly unlikely, making the assessment of free thyroxine (FT4) inappropriate in most new cases. However, FT4 measurement is integral in both the diagnosis and management of relevant central dysfunctions (central hypothyroidism and central hyperthyroidism) as well as for monitoring therapy in hyperthyroid patients treated with anti-thyroid drugs or radioiodine. In such settings, accurate FT4 quantification is required. Global standardization will improve the comparability of the results across laboratories and allow the development of common clinical decision limits in evidence-based guidelines. The International Federation of Clinical Chemistry and Laboratory Medicine Committee for Standardization of Thyroid Function Tests has undertaken FT4 immunoassay method comparison and recalibration studies and developed a reference measurement procedure that is currently being validated. However, technical and implementation challenges, including the establishment of different clinical decision limits for distinct patient groups, still remain. Accordingly, different assays and reference values cannot be interchanged. Two-way communication between the laboratory and clinical specialists is pivotal to properly select a reliable FT4 assay, establish reference intervals, investigate discordant results, and monitor the analytical and clinical performance of the method over time.

Implementing reference systems for thyroid function tests - A collaborative effort

Measurements of thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH) and free thyroxine (fT4) are critical for the early detection of thyroid diseases and for monitoring treatment. The IFCC Committee for Standardization of Thyroid Function Tests (C-STFT) established reference systems for TSH harmonization and FT4 standardization, and is now working national partners on implementing these reference systems. These implementation activities include the maintenance of the reference systems, their use to standardize and harmonize assays, and educational activities to inform stakeholders about anticipated changes in measurement values as a result of standardization and harmonization. The IFCC C-STFT formed a network of reference laboratories for FT4 and is creating a new harmonization panel for TSH. The U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention is a member of the reference laboratory network and is launching a formal standardization program for FT4. In Japan, national organizations successfully implemented TSH harmonization and established harmonized reference intervals for TSH. The C-STFT made available on its website research findings about potential concerns, communication needs and benefits of FT4 standardization and is assisting local organizations with communicating changes related to these standardization and harmonization efforts. Implementation of fT4 standardization and TSH harmonization is a complex, continuous task that requires collaboration with IVD manufacturers, laboratories, physicians and health care providers. C-STFT is working successfully with national organizations and local groups on improving FT4 and TSH measurements.

Determination of free thyroid hormones

Timely diagnosis and treatment of thyroid dysfunction is compelling given the prevalence and severity of the disease. It requires reliance on adequate laboratory testing of serum TSH as a hallmark in combination with free thyroxine/triiodothyronine. Free hormone methods have to accommodate variations in the concentration and binding capacity of binding proteins. This is a challenge because none of the methodologies developed so far measures the actual unbound hormone in serum. The indirect methods provide an approximation while the direct ones estimate the free hormone concentration either in the presence of the protein-bound counterpart, or after physical separation of the free from bound fraction. The ongoing controversy on the validity and lack of comparability of methodologies points to their imperfectness to reflect real in-vivo free hormone concentrations. Therefore, laboratories and clinicians should know the window of validity and limitations of their methods. The recently developed reference measurement system is a key advance towards improved standardization and clinical validity of free thyroid hormone measurements.

The relationship between TSH and free T₄ in a large population is complex and nonlinear and differs by age and sex

CONTEXT

The relationship between TSH and T₄ is thought to be inverse log-linear, but recent studies have challenged this. There are limited data regarding age and sex differences in the TSH-T₄ relationship.

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the TSH-free T₄ relationship in a large sample.

METHODS

In a cross-sectional, retrospective study, we analyzed TSH and free T₄ results from 152 261 subjects collected over 12 years by a single laboratory. For each free T₄ value (in picomoles per liter), the median TSH was calculated and analyzed by sex and age (in 20-year bands).

RESULTS

The relationship between log TSH and free T₄ was nonlinear. Mathematical modeling confirmed that it was described by 2 sigmoid curves with inflexion points at free T₄ concentrations of 7 and 21 pmol/L. For free T₄ within the reference range (10-20 pmol/L), median TSH was higher in men than in women (P < .001) and increased across age bands with the highest values in those 80 years and older (P < .001). In contrast, in overt hypothyroidism (n = 4403), TSH was lower in older age groups than in those aged 20-39 years (P < .001).

CONCLUSIONS

The TSH-free T₄ relationship is not inverse log-linear but can be described by 2 overlapping negative sigmoid curves. At physiological free T₄ concentrations, TSH is higher in men and in older people, whereas the TSH response to hypothyroidism is more robust in younger people. These results advance understanding of the TSH-free T₄ relationship, which is central to thyroid pathophysiology and laboratory diagnosis of thyroid disease.

The Use of TSH in Determining Thyroid Disease: How Does It Impact the Practice of Medicine in Pregnancy?

During the last four decades, there have been considerable advances in the efficacy and precision of serum thyroid function testing. The development of the third generation assays for the measurement of serum thyroid stimulating hormone (TSH, thyrotropin) and the log-linear relationship with free thyroxine (T4) established TSH as the hallmark of thyroid function testing. While it is widely accepted that TSH outside of the normal range is consistent with thyroid dysfunction, a vast multitude of additional factors must be considered before an accurate clinical diagnosis can be made. This is especially important during pregnancy, when the thyroid is under considerable additional pregnancy-related demands requiring significant maternal physiological changes. This paper examines serum TSH measurement in pregnancy and some associated potential confounding factors.

TSH - Clinical Aspects of its Use in Determining Thyroid Disease in the Elderly. How Does it Impact the Practice of Medicine in Aging?

The last four decades have seen enormous growth in the efficacy of serum thyroid stimulating hormone (thyrotropin, TSH) assay methodology, establishing TSH as the hallmark of thyroid testing. At the center of the considerations is the strong inverse correlation between serum thyrotropin and free thyroxine concentrations. While it is widely accepted that elevated serum TSH concentrations are consistent with thyroid dysfunction, a vast multitude of additional factors must be considered before an accurate clinical diagnosis can be made followed by an appropriate treatment. Epidemiological studies have demonstrated slightly elevated serum TSH concentrations among the elderly population. There is, however, a debate whether these elevated TSH levels reflect an increased prevalence of hypothyroidism among the elderly or a normal aspect of healthy aging. A comprehensive analysis of the many variables associated with this debate and TSH measurement as a diagnostic tool in aging should provide insight into the clinical efforts to diagnose and treat thyroid disease, particularly in the elderly population.

A review of clinical diagnostic applications of liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry

Liquid chromatography coupled with tandem mass spectrometry (LC/MS/MS) technology is emerging as a complementary method to traditional methodology used for clinical applications. Enhanced specificity and high-throughput capabilities are providing significant benefits to clinical diagnostic laboratories conducting routine analyses. This technology is expected to expand rapidly as scientists focus on more complicated challenges that can be solved efficiently by adding LC/MS/MS to their arsenal of techniques.

Thyroid hormone testing by tandem mass spectrometry

In the euthyroid person, absolute free thyroxine concentrations remain constant and correlate with the tissue hormone level, its biologic effect and the metabolic status of the patient. However, most circulating thyroid hormone is bound to plasma proteins and only a minute amount is in the unbound free form. Studies have shown that current free thyroxine immunoassays are binding protein dependent. Novel high-performance liquid chromatography tandem mass spectrometry (LC/MS/MS) methods have successfully dealt with problems inherent in many immunoassays for thyroid hormones and afforded improved specificity and accuracy in thyroid hormone measurements. We emphasize problems with thyroid hormone testing employing immunoassays including direct and indirect thyroid hormone immunoassays, sample processing, methods of free hormone separation and review the emerging role of liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry in thyroid hormone testing. The latest generation of tandem mass spectrometers has superior limits of quantification, permitting omission of previously employed derivatization steps. Liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry affords the specificity, precision, and limits of quantification necessary for the reliable measurement of thyroid hormones, enhancing diagnostic capabilities, and affording the profiles of the iodothyronines and thyronamines. These methods are especially important in states of disease and during pregnancy when protein binding is a factor that interferes with other methods for thyroid hormone analysis.

Medications that distort in vitro tests of thyroid function, with particular reference to estimates of serum free thyroxine

The combination of serum thyroid-stimulating hormone (TSH) with measurement of circulating thyroid hormones greatly improves sensitivity and specificity of thyroid diagnosis, but these assays are not impeccable. Estimation of serum free T4 conveniently accommodates variations in the concentration of thyroxine-binding globulin (TBG), but no current technique reliably reflects the in vivo free T4 concentration in numerous other situations. The effect of circulating competitors that increase T4 and T3 in vivo, in particular, many medications, is under-estimated by current free hormone estimates that involve sample dilution. Non-esterified fatty acids generated during sample storage and incubation can spuriously increase the measured free T4 estimate, especially after in vivo treatment with heparin. These artefacts are unlikely to be overcome by current assay strategies. Total serum T4, corrected for alterations in TBG concentration, gives a more robust estimate of thyroxine concentration than current methods of free hormone estimation and should now be reintroduced as the 'gold standard'.