A case of unilateral diaphragmatic eventration treated by plication with thoracoscopic surgery

Minimally Invasive Diaphragm Plication for Acquired Unilateral Diaphragm Paralysis: A Systematic Review

Objective: Diaphragm paralysis is a relatively uncommon entity that can be both congenital and acquired in nature. While commonly asymptomatic, it can also cause a significant decrease in pulmonary function and reserve, particularly in patients with underlying pulmonary diseases. Our aim was to summarize the current literature regarding the minimally invasive techniques used in the surgical correction of acquired diaphragm paralysis via traditional and robotic minimally invasive approaches. Methods: We conducted a systematic review of available literature using the Cochrane methodology and reported findings according to Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) standards. Results: A total of 6,561 citations were identified through initial database and reference searches, of which 90 articles met the inclusion criteria for review. After further assessment, 33 appropriate full-text studies were selected for the review. Of the selected publications, the majority represented case reports and single-center retrospective studies with level of evidence 4. Only 1 level 2b study (individual cohort study) was identified, comparing minimally invasive and open approaches. Conclusions: Each of the minimally invasive approaches has its unique benefits and disadvantages, which are summarized and delineated in this article. Ultimately, no preferred method of diaphragm plication for diaphragm paralysis can be recommended at this time based on clinical data. The choice of procedure and surgical approach continues to be selected based on the surgeon's experience and preference.

Diaphragmatic paralysis after phrenic nerve injury in newborns

BACKGROUND

Phrenic nerve injury (PNI) from birth trauma is a recognized phenomenon, generally occurring with ipsilateral brachial plexus palsy (BPP). In severe cases, PNI results in diaphragm paresis (DP) and respiratory insufficiency. Surgical diaphragmatic plication (SDP) is a potential management strategy for patients with PNI and DP, but timing and outcomes associated with SDP have not been rigorously studied.

METHODS

Records from 49 tertiary United States pediatric hospitals in the Pediatric Health Information System from 2004 to 2018 were analyzed. The study cohort included patients diagnosed with BPP from birth trauma who were documented to have PNI or DP. Patients who underwent congenital cardiac operations were excluded.

RESULTS

A total of 5832 patients were identified with BPP from birth trauma during the study period, 122 (2%) of whom were found to have concomitant DP. Of those, 65 (53%) were male, 39 (32%) were infants of diabetic mothers, 80 (65%) required mechanical ventilation, and 33 (27%) underwent SDP. SDP was performed at a median (range) age of 36 (7-95) days. Median (range) total and postoperative hospital lengths of stay (LOS) were 34 (6-180) and 15 (4-132) days, respectively. There was also an observed increase in post-operative LOS with increase in age at operation.

CONCLUSION

Neonatal DP is rare and is managed with SDP in a minority of instances. Age at repair affects total and postoperative length of stay, proxies for resource utilization and morbidity. Repair prior to 45 days of life appears to result in a shorter postoperative hospital stay. This analysis will help guide surgeons with respect to indications and operative timing for infant DP.

TYPE OF STUDY

Retrospective Comparative Study.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III.

Best Approach and Benefit of Plication for Paralyzed Diaphragm

Diaphragmatic eventration and diaphragmatic paralysis are 2 entities with different etiology and pathology, and are often clinically indistinguishable. When symptomatic, their treatment is the same, with the objective to reduce the dysfunctional cephalad excursion of the diaphragm during inspiration. This can be achieved with diaphragmatic plication through the thorax or the abdomen with either open or minimally invasive techniques. We prefer the laparoscopic approach, due to its easy access to the diaphragm and to avoid pain associated with intercostal incisions and instrument use. Short-term and long-term results are excellent with this technique.

Is video-assisted thoracoscopic diaphragmatic plication a widespread technique for diaphragmatic hernia in adults? Review of the literature and results of a national survey

Diaphragmatic plication is the most accepted treatment for symptomatic diaphragmatic hernia in adults. The fact that this pathology is infrequent and this procedure not been widespread means that this is an exceptional technique in our field. To estimate its use in the literature, we carried out a review in English and Spanish, to which we added our series. We found only six series that contribute 59 video-assisted mini-thoractomy for diaphragmatic plications in adults, and none in Spanish. Our series will be the second largest with 18 cases. Finally, we conducted a survey in all the Spanish Thoracic Surgery units in Spain: none reported more than 10 cases operated by thoracoscopy in the last 8 years (except our series) and most continue employing thoracotomy as the main approach. We believe that many patients with symptomatic diaphragmatic hernia could benefit from the use of such techniques.

Reconstruction of recurrent diaphragmatic eventration with an elongated polytetrafluoroethylene sheet

We report the case of a 31-year old woman with recurrence of left diaphragmatic eventration 3 years after a previous surgery for this condition. At the initial occurrence, she had experienced dyspnoea on exercise and subsequently underwent laparoscopic plication of the diaphragm with an endo-stapler at a local hospital. Immediately after the operation, the diaphragm was torn and the intestine entered the thorax. Therefore, plication involving sewing was performed. Then, 3 years later, the patient again experienced dyspnoea and was diagnosed as having recurrence of left diaphragmatic eventration. Observation under thoracoscopy revealed that the centre of the left diaphragm was thin but not torn. We reconstructed the left diaphragm with an elongated polytetrafluoroethylene sheet on the naïve diaphragm. The patient was discharged from our hospital 5 days after surgery. Her respiratory function improved and she has not experienced recurrence.

Diaphragm plication for eventration or paralysis: a review of the literature

Although etiology and pathology of symptomatic diaphragm paralysis and eventration are distinct, their treatments are the same: to reduce dysfunctional caudal excursion of the diaphragm during inspiration by plication. Minimally invasive diaphragm plication techniques have emerged as equally effective and less morbid alternatives to open plication. This review focuses on the etiology, pathophysiology, diagnosis, and treatment of diaphragmatic eventration or paralysis in adults.

Diaphragmatic eventration

Symptomatic diaphragmatic eventration is an uncommon condition and is sometimes impossible to distinguish clinically from paralysis. Patients who are asymptomatic require no treatment; patients who are symptomatic benefit significantly from diaphragm plication. The choice of plication approach is dependent upon the expertise of the surgeon.

Video-assisted thoracoscopy for diaphragmatic plication: experimental study in a canine model

BACKGROUND

Plication of a nonfunctional hemidiaphragm usually restores altered ventilatory mechanics. This study compared two techniques in performing diaphragmatic plication: video-assisted thoracoscopy (group A) and thoracotomy (group B).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Twenty dogs with induced paralysis of the right hemidiaphragm were randomly assigned to one of the two groups. Evaluations were performed before and after plication of the respiratory frequency (f) and lung area (LA) of the affected side. Operative time, time to resumption of walking, ingestion of fluids and solid food, pain intensity, and postoperative complications were measured.

RESULTS

Group A had less pain after the surgery (P < 0.0001), earlier fluid ingestion (P < 0.05), and earlier resumption of walking (P < 0.019). Four weeks after the procedure, LA was similar in both groups, while a significant decrease in f was recorded in group A (P < 0.02). The remaining evaluated variables showed no differences.

CONCLUSION

Both approaches were effective. Pain recorded in the postoperative period was less and recovery was faster in group A. Complications and surgical times were similar. The video-assisted thoracoscopy is a safe and efficient option for performing diaphragmatic plication in dogs.

Surgical treatment of diaphragmatic eventration using video-assisted thoracic surgery: a prospective study

BACKGROUND

This study seeks to evaluate results regarding the repair of diaphragmatic eventration using video-assisted thoracic surgery (VATS).

METHODS

We performed a prospective observational study including patients referred to us for surgical treatment of diaphragmatic eventration during a 12-year period. Clinical, radiologic, and functional data were prospectively recorded. VATS was performed with two thoracoports and a 4-cm mini-thoracotomy. Diaphragmatic plication was performed using two nonresorbable running sutures from periphery to the cardio-phrenic angle. Follow-up data (clinical examination, chest roentgenogram, lung function tests at 3, 6, 12 months, and annually thereafter) were also prospectively recorded.

RESULTS

Twelve patients (4 male adults, mean age 57.7 +/- 14.8 years) were operated on between 1992 and 2003. The left side was involved in 8 patients and the mean height of diaphragm elevation was 7.5 +/- 1.8 cm. All patients experienced symptoms related to the disease; in 2 patients the operation was carried out to achieve weaning from mechanical ventilation. The etiologic mechanism could be identified in 11 out of 12 patients (trauma, n = 9; Charcot-Marie disease, n = 1; calcified para-aortic nodes, n = 1). Mean operative time, drainage output, and hospital stay were 77 +/- 15 minutes, 0.8 +/- 04 L, and 3.4 +/- 0.7 days, respectively. No mortality was observed; 1 patient experienced postoperative pneumonia, which was treated using antibiotics. All patients experienced amelioration of symptoms and long-term lung function tests revealed a marked improvement of both the forced volume capacity and the forced expiratory volume at 1 second. No relapses were observed at follow-up chest roentgenogram.

CONCLUSIONS

Treatment using VATS is a safe and effective alternative to conventional surgery. Functional improvement persists at long-term follow-up.

Thoracoscopic diaphragmatic procedures under artificial pneumothorax

Diaphragmatic plication is technically simple using a conventional operative technique, but it requires a large skin incision and rib injury. We present an alternative technique for thoracoscopic plication of the diaphragm and evaluate the advantages of the procedure. Six patients (five with diaphragmatic eventration and one with diaphragmatic hernia with a sac) ranging in age from 8 to 20 months were treated by this method. Three of the six cases were right-sided, and three were left-sided. The operation was performed under artificial pneumothorax using carbon dioxide gas at 4 mmHg. Three trocars for laparoscopy were inserted at the 4th and 5th intercostal spaces. An adequate operative view was obtained by pressing the diaphragm throughout the operation. The eventrated diaphragm was plicated with several rows of nonabsorbable sutures in the anterolateral-to-posterolateral direction to prevent injury to the main phrenic nerve. A tight diaphragm was confirmed by decompressing the artificial pneumothorax. The technique was successfully performed in all cases, and the patients' postoperative courses were uneventful. During the operation, the hemodynamic effects of carbon dioxide gas at 4 mmHg were minimal. Over a mean follow-up period of 3.1 years (range, 1-6 years), no recurrence of diaphragmatic eventration was seen. Judging from the satisfactory postoperative course, this procedure is suitable for children with all forms of diaphragmatic eventration.

Thoracoscopic repair of diaphragmatic eventration

We report a 6-month-old child who presented with recurrent chest infections associated with a right diaphragmatic eventration. Failure in conservative management lead to thoracoscopic plication at 17 months of age and discharge on the third postoperative day. At one year followup he is completely free from all symptoms, and his chest x-ray demonstrates a marked improvement in the position of the diaphragm. We recommend thoracoscopy as a viable approach in treating this condition in children.

Congenital diaphragmatic eventration as a cause of anterior mediastinal mass in the children: imaging modalities and literature review

Congenital eventration of the diaphragm, as a cause of mediastinal mass, is an unusual condition and it may be unilateral or bilateral. Although this entity is frequently asymptomatic and firstly detected on the chest radiography, it may be difficult to distinguish a partial eventration from the other diaphragmatic lesions or mediastinal pathologies on the chest radiographs. US may present valuable information about diaphragm integrity with eventration content or the other diaphragmatic pathologies. Although the other imaging modalities such as fluoroscopy, computed tomography, and MR imaging may be performed as adjunct techniques in cases of the diagnosis still in doubt, they are frequently unnecessary after US. Our goal is to present imaging features and management of this entity together with a literature review.

Minimally invasive surgery in the neonate: review of current evidence

Minimally invasive surgery has been one of the most important surgical advances in the last 15 years. The development of smaller instruments has allowed pediatric surgeons to apply this rapidly evolving technology to neonates. Congenital neonatal deformities including tracheoesophageal fistula, patent ductus arteriosus, duodenal atresia and anorectal malformations are now being managed with minimally invasive surgery. This article summarizes the status of these techniques in neonates.

[Surgery for diaphragmatic palsy]

Diaphragmatic palsy leads to a permanent ascension of one or both hemi-diaphragms with highly variable functional impact. The underlying mechanisms can be divided into two main categories: neurological or muscular disorder leading to peripheral dysfunction; defective or non-transmitted central command causing central dysfunction. A complete morphological and functional work-up is required to determine the circumstances leading to diaphragmatic palsy and the uni- or bilateral nature of the paralysis. The entire phreno-diaphragmatic transmission chain from the cranium to the diaphragmatic muscle must be analyzed to search for a local cause. Function tests are used to examine central command and transmission, function of the phrenic nerve, and the capacity of the diaphragmatic muscle to generate sufficient pressure for efficacious ventilation. Once indirect causes of diaphragmatic ascension (independent of the phreno-diaphragmatic system) have been ruled out, surgery may be proposed for symptomatic, permanent and irreversible diaphragmatic paralysis. A tension procedure may be sufficient in the event of eventration with or without phrenic palsy. For well-selected patients with central paralysis due to supraspinal lesions with intact nerves and muscles, implantation of a phrenic pacemaker may be helpful to eliminate positive pressure mechanical ventilation and restore more physiological respiration.

Video-assisted diaphragm plication in children

BACKGROUND

Diaphragm paralysis after cardiac surgery may be secondary to phrenic nerve injury by ice, electrocautery, or dissection. Although most are asymptomatic, some patients, particularly children, have significant respiratory compromise. Video-assisted plication may offer more rapid improvement and recovery than thoracotomy in pediatric patients.

METHODS

We performed five procedures. The diaphragm was elevated, clamped, oversewn, and tacked down into the pleural gutter. The procedure was performed on 2 infants after repair of total anomalous pulmonary venous connection, on 1 child after the Fontan procedure, on 1 child after repair of tetralogy of Fallot, and on 1 child with congenital eventration. Indications included ventilator dependency, post-Fontan protein losing enteropathy with elevated venous pressures and chronic right lower lobe collapse, persistent atelectasis with recurrent pneumonias, and asymptomatic severe eventration.

RESULTS

Ventilator-dependent patients were extubated after 2 and 3 days. The remaining patients were immediately extubated. One patient was discharged the day of surgery and 2 were discharged at 1 and 3 days postoperatively. The remaining 2 were discharged on postoperative day 30 and 45 after continued issues with feeding and prematurity. The child with the eventration had rapid expansion and growth of the left lung over the next few weeks with a normal chest radiograph 3 weeks later. The child with recurrent pneumonia reexpanded her left lower lobe and remains free of infection. There were no wound infections, lung or vascular injuries, or complications from the procedure. All the patients had successful flattening of the hemidiaphragm as documented by chest radiograph, with successful lung reexpansion.

CONCLUSIONS

Video-assisted plication of paralyzed diaphragms is effective and safe, involves less morbidity, and has quicker recovery times than traditional open techniques.

A simple technique for the thoracoscopic plication of the diaphragm

We describe a simple technique for video-assisted thoracoscopic plication in patients with diaphragmatic eventration. During the plication, which is performed with a continuous running suture, a surgical assistant maintains the continuous suture traction using a homemade hook through the port. The technique can be performed easily, without any kind of thoracotomy.

Long term results of diaphragmatic plication for unilateral diaphragm paralysis

OBJECTIVES

To examine whether diaphragmatic plication is an effective and lasting treatment option for non-malignant diaphragmatic paralysis.

METHODS

Nineteen patients who had undergone diaphragm plication (1983-1990) were recalled for interview, pulmonary function testing and chest X-ray.

RESULTS

There were 13 men and six women aged 24-73 (mean 55). Diaphragm paralysis was idiopathic (n=9), postsurgical (n=3), related to cervical spondylosis (n=4) and neck injury (n=2). Patients presented with breathlessness (18/19) or orthopnoea (1/19). Symptoms had lasted 3-60 months (mean 24 months). All patients had a raised hemidiaphragm on chest X-ray with paradoxical movement on ultrasound. Mean preoperative FVC was 71% predicted (range 38-93, SD 12.9) and mean FEV(1) was 67% predicted (range 33-90, SD 10.8). Supine lung volumes were 81% (mean) of sitting values. There were six right plications and 13 left. There were no postoperative deaths. One patient required re-plication. Follow-up (18/19 of original operated patients) ranged from 7-14 years (mean 10 years). Three patients had died of unrelated causes and one patient failed to attend long term follow-up, leaving 15 patients of the original 19 operated on. Positional change in lung volumes was not affected by surgery at early (6 week) or late (>5 year) follow-up. FVC, FEV(1), FRC and TLC improved by 10.1*, 11.8*, 16.9* and 9.2*%, respectively, at early follow-up and 11.8*, 15.4*, 26 and 13.3*% at late follow-up (*P<0.005 signed rank). Dyspnoea scores at long term follow-up improved 1 point (n=5), 2 points (n=5) and 3 points (n=2), remained unchanged (n=1) or dropped 1 point (n=2). Of the 15 patients followed up all but one who had been employed returned to work. 14/15 patients expressed satisfaction with their surgery.

CONCLUSION

Diaphragm plication is an effective procedure with lasting results.

Thoracoscopic plication of diaphragmatic eventration using endostaplers

Unilateral diaphragmatic eventration and paralysis require plication in cases of progressive dyspnea on exertion and recurrent respiratory infection. The patient, a 40-year-old woman, who had complained of worsening dyspnea on exertion and elevation of the left diaphragm on chest radiographs for 4 years, underwent plication by thoracoscopy with knifeless endostaplers. Improvements in pulmonary functions and dyspnea on exertion have been maintained for 14 months.

Surgical embryology and anatomy of the diaphragm with surgical applications

This article reviews the development, surgical anatomy, and teratology of the diaphragm, and discusses the diagnostic procedures, surgical therapy, and prognosis of congenital disturbances. Special attention is paid to the traumatic rupture of the diaphragm, concerning incidence, cause, diagnosis, prognosis, and surgical repair.