Competency-based education in general surgery: Are Canadian residents ready?

Assessing operative competence in core surgical training: A reliability analysis

BACKGROUND

This study quantifies the number of observations required to reliably assess the operative competence of Core Surgical Trainees (CSTs) in Ireland, using the Supervised Structured Assessment of Operative Performance (SSAOP) tool.

METHODS

SSAOPs (April 2016-February 2021) were analysed across a mix of undifferentiated procedures, as well as for three commonly performed general surgery procedures in CST: appendicectomy, abdominal wall hernia repair, and skin/subcutaneous lesion excision. Generalizability and Decision studies determined the number of observations required to achieve dependability indices ≥0.8, appropriate for use in high-stakes assessment.

RESULTS

A total of 2,294 SSAOPs were analysed. Four assessors, each observing 10 cases, can generate scores sufficiently reliable for use in high-stakes assessments. Focusing on a selection of core procedures yields more favourable reliability indices.

CONCLUSION

Trainers should conduct repeated assessments across a smaller number of procedures to improve reliability. Programs should increase the assessor mix to yield sufficient dependability indices for high-stakes assessment.

Global assessment of surgical skills (GASS): validation of a new instrument to measure global technical safety in surgical procedures

BACKGROUND

Broad implementation of the American Board of Surgery's entrustable professional activities initiative will require assessment instruments that are reliable and easy to use. Existing assessment instruments of general laparoscopic surgical skills have limited reliability, efficiency, and validity across the spectrum of formative (low-stakes) and summative (high-stakes) assessments. A novel six-item global assessment of surgical skills (GASS) instrument was developed and evaluated with a focus upon safe versus unsafe surgical practice scoring rubric.

METHODS

The GASS was developed by iterative engagement with expert laparoscopic surgeons and includes six items (economy of motion, tissue handling, appreciating operative anatomy, bimanual dexterity, achievement of hemostasis, overall performance) with a uniform three-point scoring rubric ("poor-unsafe", "adequate-safe", "good-safe"). To test inter-rater reliability, a cross-sectional study of four bariatric surgeons with experience ranging from 4 to 28 years applied the GASS and the global operative assessment of laparoscopic skills (GOALS) to 30 consecutive Roux-en-Y gastric bypass procedure operative videos. Inter-rater reliability was assessed for a simplified dichotomous "safe" versus "unsafe" scoring rubric using Gwet's AC2.

RESULTS

The GASS inter-rater reliability was very high across all six domains (0.88-1.00). The GASS performed comparably to the GOALS inter-rater reliability scores (0.96-1.00). The economy of motion and bimanual dexterity items had the highest percentage of unsafe ratings (9.2% and 5.8%, respectively).

CONCLUSION

The GASS, a novel six-item instrument of general laparoscopic surgical skills, was designed with a simple scoring rubric (poor-safe, adequate-safe, good-safe) to minimize rater burden and focus feedback to trainees and promotion evaluations on safe surgical performance. Initial evaluation of the GASS is promising, demonstrating high inter-rater reliability. Future research will seek to assess the GASS against a broader spectrum of laparoscopic procedures.

Review of Challenges to the Implementation of Competence by Design in Post-Graduate Medical Education: What Can Diagnostic Radiology Learn from the Experience of Other Specialty Disciplines?

Competence by Design (CBD) is a medical education initiative instituted by the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada to improve the training of resident physicians in specialty disciplines. CBD integrates Competency Based Medical Education with traditional specialty discipline post-graduate medical education (PGME) training through the application of an organizational framework of competencies. Various specialty disciplines in Canada have transitioned to CBD since 2017 in a staggered approach. Diagnostic radiology PGME programs in Canada are expected to transition to CBD in 2022 for the incoming resident physician cohort. This article reviews potential challenges to the implementation of CBD in diagnostic radiology PGME programs and proposes evidence-informed targeted strategies and solutions to address these challenges. It is important for diagnostic radiology PGME programs to understand the challenges pertaining to the implementation of CBD so that they may be able to successfully implement this or similar medical education initiatives in their programs. Moreover, as radiology subspecialty PGME programs, such as nuclear medicine, interventional radiology, neuroradiology, and pediatric radiology, likewise transition to CBD and diagnostic radiology PGME programs internationally increasingly implement other Competency Based Medical Education models, the implications of the challenges pertaining to the implementation of CBD will further become of increasing importance.