Is thyroid follicular cancer in Japanese caused by a specific t(2; 3)(q13; p25) translocation generating Pax8-PPAR gamma fusion mRNA?

Genetic differences in follicular thyroid carcinoma between Asian and Western countries: a systematic review

Thyroid cancer is the most common endocrine malignancy, and follicular thyroid carcinoma (FTC) is the second most common thyroid cancer following papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC). RAS mutation and PAX8/PPARγ rearrangement are the two representative genetic alterations in FTC, and there are studies from various countries on their regional frequencies. In this study, we systematically reviewed all available literature aiming to create a complete global map showing the frequencies of these common oncogenic drivers in FTC and to highlight the trends in Asian and Western countries. We performed a search in two electronic databases and identified 71 studies that fit our criteria from 1,329 studies found with our database search terms. There were 54 articles with 1,143 FTC patients and 39 articles with 764 FTC patients available for calculating the frequency of RAS mutation and PAX8/PPARγ rearrangement, respectively. NRAS mutation was the most frequent RAS mutation in all regions, followed by HRAS and KRAS mutation. The frequency of RAS mutation in Asian countries was higher than Western countries (34% vs. 27%, P=0.006) when the mutation detection method was not taken into account. In contrast, this difference in RAS mutation incidence between Asian and Western countries (28% vs. 25%, P=0.47) did not show up in our subgroup analysis incorporating only studies using direct sequencing method. The reported difference of RAS mutation frequency in the previous literature might not be due to the true prevalence of RAS mutation. They could be attributed to the difference in the detection method. As to PAX8/PPARγ rearrangement, Western countries overall had a much higher prevalence than Asian countries (23% vs. 4%, P<0.001), but some European countries had a low incidence, implying regional heterogeneity of PAX8/PPARγ rearrangement. A substantial lack of mutation data in FTC was found in several regions of the world such as Central Asia, Middle East, Africa, and Central and South America. Our results provide the most comprehensive global status of representative genetic alterations in FTC and highlight the similarities and differences between Asian and Western countries.

Mutational burdens and evolutionary ages of thyroid follicular adenoma are comparable to those of follicular carcinoma

Follicular thyroid adenoma (FTA) precedes follicular thyroid carcinoma (FTC) by definition with a favorable prognosis compared to FTC. However, the genetic mechanism of FTA to FTC progression remains unknown. For this, it is required to disclose FTA and FTC genomes in mutational and evolutionary perspectives. We performed whole-exome sequencing and copy number profiling of 14 FTAs and 13 FTCs, which exhibited previously-known gene mutations (NRAS, HRAS, BRAF, TSHR and EIF1AX) and copy number alterations (CNAs) (22q loss and 1q gain) in follicular tumors. In addition, we found eleven potential cancer-related genes with mutations (EZH1, SPOP, NF1, TCF12, IGF2BP3, KMT2C, CNOT1, BRIP1, KDM5C, STAG2 and MAP4K3) that have not been reported in thyroid follicular tumors. Of note, FTA genomes showed comparable levels of mutations to FTC in terms of the number, sequence composition and functional consequences (potential driver mutations) of mutations. Analyses of evolutionary ages using somatic mutations as molecular clocks further identified that FTA genomes were as old as FTC genomes. Whole-transcriptome sequencing did not find any gene fusions with potential significance. Our data indicate that FTA genomes may be as old as FTC genomes, thus suggesting that follicular thyroid tumor genomes during the transition from FTA to FTC may stand stable at genomic levels in contrast to the discernable changes at pathologic and clinical levels. Also, the data suggest a possibility that the mutational profiles obtained from early biopsies may be useful for the molecular diagnosis and therapeutics of follicular tumor patients.

Changes in the clinicopathological characteristics and genetic alterations of follicular thyroid cancer

OBJECTIVE

Changes in the clinicopathological characteristics and genetic alterations of follicular thyroid cancer (FTC) over time have not been reported. Moreover, the prognostic effects of RAS and TERT promoter mutations in FTC have not been clearly elucidated. We investigated changes in the clinicopathological characteristics of patients with FTC over four decades, as well as the clinical significance of genetic mutations of FTC.

DESIGN AND METHODS

This retrospective study included 690 patients with FTC who underwent thyroidectomy between 1973 and 2015 at the Seoul National University Hospital. In 134 samples, genetic tests for N/H/KRAS and TERT promoter mutations and PAX8/PPARγ rearrangement were performed.

RESULTS

The age at diagnosis has increased (P < 0.001) in recent decades and extrathyroidal extension of the tumor has become less common (P = 0.033). Other clinicopathological characteristics and prognosis of FTC have not significantly changed. The prevalence of RAS mutations decreased (P = 0.042) over time, whereas that of TERT promoter mutations remained stable. RAS mutations were associated with distant metastasis and persistent disease, and TERT promoter mutations were associated with distant metastasis, advanced TNM stage, recurrence and disease-specific mortality. FTC patients with coexistent RAS and TERT promoter mutations showed a higher recurrence risk than those with only one mutation.

CONCLUSIONS

The age at diagnosis of FTC and the frequency of extrathyroidal extension have changed over four decades. Moreover, the prevalence of RAS mutations decreased. RAS and TERT promoter mutations may be associated with poor clinical outcomes in FTC, especially when the two mutations coexist.

Mutation Profile of Well-Differentiated Thyroid Cancer in Asians

Recent advances in molecular diagnostics have led to significant insights into the genetic basis of thyroid tumorigenesis. Among the mutations commonly seen in thyroid cancers, the vast majority are associated with the mitogen-activated protein kinase pathway. B-Raf proto-oncogene (BRAF) mutations are the most common mutations observed in papillary thyroid cancers (PTCs), followed by RET/PTC rearrangements and RAS mutations, while follicular thyroid cancers are more likely to harbor RAS mutations or PAX8/peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor γ (PPARγ) rearrangements. Beyond these more common mutations, alterations in the telomerase reverse transcriptase (TERT) promoter have recently been associated with clinicopathologic features, disease prognosis, and tumorigenesis in thyroid cancer. While the mutations underlying thyroid tumorigenesis are well known, the frequency of these mutations is strongly associated with geography, with clear differences reported between Asian and Western countries. Of particular interest is the prevalence of BRAF mutations, with Korean patients exhibiting the highest rate of BRAF-associated thyroid cancers in the world. Here, we review the prevalence of each of the most common mutations in Asian and Western countries, and identify the characteristics of well-differentiated thyroid cancer in Asians.

Low frequency of PAX8-PPARγ rearrangement in follicular thyroid carcinomas in Japanese patients

Paired-box gene 8 (PAX8)-peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor-γ (PPARγ) gene fusion has been identified at significant frequency in follicular thyroid carcinomas (FTCs) with cytogenetically detectable translocation t(2;3)(q13;p25). This represents a possible specific molecular marker for follicular carcinoma. In this study, we examined PAX8-PPARγ rearrangement in 24 FTC samples from Japanese patients by reverse transcribed-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) using two upstream PAX8 primers located in exons 7 and 8 and a downstream primer in exon 1 of PPARγ. The fusion gene was detected in only one of 24 FTCs (4%). The FTC with PAX8-PPARγ rearrangement from a 56-year-old man showed a product consistent with fusion between exon 8 of PAX8 and exon 1 of PPARγ. It was confirmed by direct sequencing. This FTC was histologically encapsulated, composed of trabeculae and small follicles and had complete penetration of the capsule by tumor tissues (minimally invasive type). The frequency of the fusion gene in this study was much lower than the 29-63% noted in reports from other countries suggesting that FTCs in Japanese patients may have a special genetic background, and that the high iodine intake from a typical Japanese diet might influence the frequency of the fusion gene in FTCs.

Pax-8-PPAR-γ fusion protein in thyroid carcinoma

Thyroid carcinoma is the most common endocrine malignancy, and its incidence is continuing to increase. Most thyroid carcinomas contain one of several known driver mutations, such as the Val600Glu substitution in B-Raf, Ras mutations, RET gene fusions, or PAX8-PPARG gene fusions. The PAX8-PPARG gene fusion results in the production of a Pax-8-PPAR-γ fusion protein (PPFP), which is found in approximately one-third of follicular thyroid carcinomas, as well as some follicular-variant papillary thyroid carcinomas. In vitro and in vivo evidence indicates that PPFP is an oncoprotein. Although specific mechanisms of action remain to be defined, PPFP is considered to act as a dominant-negative inhibitor of wild-type PPAR-γ and/or as a unique transcriptional activator of subsets of PPAR-γ-responsive and Pax-8-responsive genes. Detection of the fusion transcript in thyroid nodule biopsy specimens can aid clinical decision-making when cytological findings are indeterminate. The PPAR-γ agonist pioglitazone is highly therapeutic in a transgenic mouse model of PPFP-positive thyroid carcinoma, suggesting that PPAR-γ agonists might be beneficial in patients with PPFP-positive thyroid carcinomas.

Diagnostic biomarkers of differentiated thyroid cancer

The incidence of thyroid cancer has been increasing all around the world in the past decades. Early detection is one of the keys to reduce the mortality. Currently, fine-needle aspiration (FNA) guides the management of patients with a thyroid nodule. The use of FNA can reduce unnecessary thyroid surgery by twenty-five percent. However, the prevalence of non-diagnostic and indeterminate cytology from FNA is still high, approximately thirty percent. Many biomarkers were developed to differentiate between the benign and malignant thyroid nodule. This review summarizes each diagnostic biomarker of differentiated thyroid cancer. Sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values of individual cytological laboratory need to be considered before implementation of each biomarker. Moreover, follow-up is still mandatory in negative biomarker tests because all genomic and proteomic alterations in thyroid cancer are still unknown.

Diagnostic and prognostic implications of the PAX8-PPARγ translocation in thyroid carcinomas-a TMA-based study of 226 cases

AIMS

Follicular thyroid carcinoma (FTC) has been a diagnostic challenge for decades. The PAX8-PPARγ rearrangement has been detected in FTC and classic papillary thyroid carcinomas (PTCs). The aims of this study were to assess the presence of PAX8-PPARγ by using tissue microarrays in a large cohort of different thyroid neoplasms, and to assess its diagnostic and prognostic implications.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Fluorescence in-situ hybridization (FISH) analysis for PAX8-PPARγ was performed on 226 thyroid tumours, comprising FTCs (n = 59), PTCs (n = 126), poorly differentiated thyroid carcinomas (PDs; n = 34), follicular thyroid adenomas (FTAs; n = 5), and follicular tumours of unknown malignant potential (FTUMPs; n = 2). PAX8-PPARγ was detected in 12% of FTCs, 1% of PTCs, 7% of PDs, and in both cases of FTUMP. There was no correlation between the extent of capsular or vascular invasion and PAX8-PPARγ, or between lymph node or haematogenous metastasis and PAX8-PPARγ. Overall survival (OS), tumour-specific survival (TSS) and relapse-free-survival (RFS) were not influenced by PAX8-PPARγ.

CONCLUSIONS

In this study, we demonstrate for the first time the presence of PAX8-PPARγ in PDs and FTUMPs, whereas in FTCs and PTCs the prevalence of PAX8-PPARγ is lower than previously reported. PAX8-PPARγ did not correlate with invasiveness or affect prognosis in any tumour type.

On the prevalence of the PAX8-PPARG fusion resulting from the chromosomal translocation t(2;3)(q13;p25) in adenomas of the thyroid

The chromosomal translocation t(2;3)(q13;p25) characterizes a subgroup of tumors originating from the thyroid follicular epithelium and was initially discovered in a few cases of adenomas. Later, a fusion of the genes PAX8 and PPARG resulting from this translocation was frequently observed in follicular carcinomas and considered as a marker of follicular thyroid cancer. According to subsequent studies, however, this rearrangement is not confined to carcinomas but also occurs in adenomas, with considerably varying frequencies. Only five cases of thyroid adenomas with this translocation detected by conventional cytogenetics have been documented. In contrast, studies using reverse-transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) detected fusion transcripts resulting from that translocation in an average of 8.2% of adenomas. The aim of this study was to determine the frequency of the PAX8-PPARG fusion in follicular adenomas and to use the HMGA2 mRNA level of such tumors as an indicator of malignancy. In cytogenetic studies of 192 follicular adenomas, the t(2;3)(q13;p25) has been identified in only two cases described herein. Histopathology revealed no evidence of malignancy in either case, and, concordantly, HMGA2 mRNA levels were not elevated. In summary, the fusion is a rare event in follicular adenomas and its prevalence may be overestimated in many RT-PCR-based studies.

Genetic markers differentiating follicular thyroid carcinoma from benign lesions

Thyroid nodules are commonly encountered during routine medical care. The main problem established by a discovery of a thyroid nodule is to discriminate between a benign and malignant lesion. Fine-needle aspiration (FNA) is the most widely used and cost-effective preoperative test for initial evaluation of a thyroid nodule. While the overall accuracy of FNA for classical papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC) approaches 100%, it has limited accuracy with follicular lesions. Patients with a cytological report of indeterminate or follicular lesions are referred to surgery for a more accurate diagnosis. A more acute molecular-based test for thyroid nodules is needed not only to improve treatment decisions, but also to potentially reduce the long-term health costs. Several studies have looked into biologic markers that could be used as an adjuvant to distinguish the benign from malignant nodules. This review will focus on those biomarkers that are potentially useful in the diagnosis of thyroid lesions commonly classified as indeterminate.

Molecular markers in thyroid cancer diagnostics

Although fine-needle aspiration biopsy (FNA) remains the mainstay of the preoperative workup of thyroid nodules, it does not provide a diagnosis in up to 20% of nodules. This group of indeterminate lesions, including lesions with cellular atypia, suspicious cytology, and demonstrating a follicular pattern, provides one of the greatest challenges to researchers in thyroid cancer today. Over the last 2 decades, considerable work has been done to find molecular markers to resolve this diagnostic dilemma. This article explores some of the markers including galectin-3, HBME-1, BRAF, RET/PTC, PAX8-PPARgamma, hTERT, telomerase, miRNA, and microarray and multigene assays. Although no one marker has proven to be a panacea, several combinations of markers have shown great promise as an adjunct to FNA.

QPRT: a potential marker for follicular thyroid carcinoma including minimal invasive variant; a gene expression, RNA and immunohistochemical study

Background

The differential diagnosis between follicular thyroid adenoma and minimal invasive follicular thyroid carcinoma is often difficult for several reasons. One major aspect is the lack of typical cytological criteria in well differentiated specimens. New marker molecules, shown by poly- or monoclonal antibodies proved helpful.

Methods

We performed global gene expression analysis of 12 follicular thyroid tumours (4 follicular adenomas, 4 minimal invasive follicular carcinomas and 4 widely invasive follicular carcinomas), followed by immunohistochemical staining of 149 cases. The specificity of the antibody was validated by western blot analysis

Results

In gene expression analysis QPRT was detected as differently expressed between follicular thyroid adenoma and follicular thyroid carcinoma. QPRT protein could be detected by immunohistochemistry in 65% of follicular thyroid carcinomas including minimal invasive variant and only 22% of follicular adenomas.

Conclusion

Consequently, QPRT is a potential new marker for the immunohistochemical screening of follicular thyroid nodules.

The Role of the PAX8/PPARgamma Fusion Oncogene in Thyroid Cancer

Thyroid cancer is uncommon and exhibits relatively low mortality rates. However, a subset of patients experience inexorable growth, metastatic spread, and mortality. Unfortunately, for these patients, there have been few significant advances in treatment during the last 50 years. While substantial advances have been made in recent years about the molecular genetic events underlying papillary thyroid cancer, the more aggressive follicular thyroid cancer remains poorly understood. The recent discovery of the PAX8/PPARγ translocation in follicular thyroid carcinoma has promoted progress in the role of PPARγ as a tumor suppressor and potential therapeutic target. The PAX8/PPARγ fusion gene appears to be an oncogene. It is most often expressed in follicular carcinomas and exerts a dominant-negative effect on wild-type PPARγ, and stimulates transcription of PAX8-responsive promoters. PPARγ agonists have shown promising results in vitro, although very few studies have been conducted to assess the clinical impact of these agents.

Trisomy 17 as a marker for a subset of noninvasive thyroid nodules with focal features of papillary carcinoma: cytogenetic and molecular analysis of 62 cases and correlation with histological findings

CONTEXT

Differentiated carcinomas of the thyroid are divided into follicular thyroid carcinoma and papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC), based on their propensity to invade and their cytological features [papillary carcinoma-type nuclear changes (PTC-NCs)]. PTC typically exhibits a diploid karyotype sometimes with inv10(q11.2q21.2), leading to rearranged RET gene. Follicular thyroid carcinomas are often aneuploid and may exhibit t(2;3)(q13;p25), resulting in PAX8-PPARgamma1 gene fusion. Isolated trisomy 17 has rarely been reported in thyroid lesions, and its significance is unknown.

OBJECTIVE/DESIGN

Our objective was to determine whether isolated trisomy 17 corresponds to a specific histological or molecular thyroid tumor subset. Nine cases with isolated trisomy 17 were critically reviewed and investigated for RAS and BRAF mutations and for RET and PAX8-PPARgamma1 rearrangements.

RESULTS

All nine cases were noninvasive, exhibited follicular growth pattern, and showed PTC-NCs focally defined within the nodule: four were PTCs follicular variant within larger tumors, and five were follicular-patterned nodules with incomplete cytological features of papillary carcinoma (variable proportion of cells with PTC-NCs scattered inside the lesion). RAS, BRAF V600E mutation, RET or PAX8-PPARgamma1 rearrangements were not identified. One case had BRAF K601E mutation. Only two of the 53 control cases showed focal PTC-NCs.

CONCLUSIONS

Isolated trisomy 17 is associated with focal papillary carcinoma changes in follicular-patterned thyroid nodules and may be a marker for this subset of thyroid lesions that are often difficult to classify.

Follicular thyroid carcinoma: From diagnosis to treatment

Unusual presentations with bone, lung or soft tissue metastases in initial diagnosis of follicular thyroid carcinoma have been reported occasionally. This implies how difficult it is to diagnosis this type of cancer at the pre-operative or intra-operative stage of treatment. Fine needle aspiration cytology has been shown to be an ineffective method for diagnosing vascular or capsule invasion of follicular thyroid cancer. Multiple frozen sections, usually 5 to 12 depending on the size of the tumor, can achieve a diagnostic accuracy of 98%. Clinical application of various gene expressions in thyroid follicular tumors by needle aspiration using in situ hybridization requires further investigation. Although radioactive iodide (131I) has been used as the standard treatment for follicular thyroid carcinoma with distant metastases, the effectiveness of 131I treatment for follicular thyroid carcinoma depends on the differentiation of cancer cells. The possibility of 131I for thyroid remnant ablation replacing a secondary operation for follicular thyroid carcinoma has been debated. Recent studies applied more expressions of sodium iodide symporters to attain the effect of 131I treatment and slow the proliferation of thyroid cancer cell which, in turn, slows the progression of follicular carcinoma. Consensus for the surgical procedures for the specific prognostic risks for follicular thyroid carcinoma is needed. Dedifferentiated, anti-angiogenic, or gene therapies for follicular thyroid cancer with distant metastases or anaplastic transformation comprise the principal directions in future research for this cancer.

ECM1 and TMPRSS4 Are Diagnostic Markers of Malignant Thyroid Neoplasms and Improve the Accuracy of Fine Needle Aspiration Biopsy

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to determine whether genes that regulate cellular invasion and metastasis are differentially expressed and could serve as diagnostic markers of malignant thyroid nodules.

SUMMARY AND BACKGROUND DATA

Patients whose thyroid nodules have indeterminate or suspicious cytologic features on fine needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy require thyroidectomy because of a 20% to 30% risk of thyroid cancer. Cell invasion and metastasis is a hallmark of malignant phenotype; therefore, genes that regulate these processes might be differentially expressed and could serve as diagnostic markers of malignancy.

METHODS

Differentially expressed genes (2-fold higher or lower) in malignant versus benign thyroid neoplasms were identified by extracellular matrix and adhesion molecule cDNA array analysis and confirmed by real-time quantitative polymerase chain reaction (PCR). The area under the receiver operating characteristic (AUC) curve was calculated to determine diagnostic accuracy of gene expression level cutoffs established by logistic regression analysis.

RESULTS

By cDNA array analysis, ADAMTS8, ECM1, MMP8, PLAU, SELP, and TMPRSS4 were upregulated, and by quantitative PCR, ECM1, SELP, and TMPRSS4 mRNA expression was higher in malignant (n = 57) than in benign (n = 38) thyroid neoplasms (P< 0.002). ECM1 and TMPRSS4 mRNA expression levels were independent predictors of a malignant thyroid neoplasm (P < 0.003). The AUC was 0.956 for ECM1 and 0.926 for TMPRSS4. Combining both markers improved their diagnostic use (AUC 0.985; sensitivity, 91.7%; specificity, 89.8%; positive predictive value, 85.7%; negative predictive value, 82.8%). ECM1 and TMPRSS4 expression analysis improved the diagnostic accuracy of FNA biopsy in 35 of 38 indeterminate or suspicious results. The level of ECM1 mRNA expression was higher in TNM stage I differentiated thyroid cancers than in stage II and III tumors (P < or = 0.031).

CONCLUSIONS

ECM1 and TMPRSS4 are excellent diagnostic markers of malignant thyroid nodules and may be used to improve the diagnostic accuracy of FNA biopsy. ECM1 is also a marker of the extent of disease in differentiated thyroid cancers.