Minimally invasive versus transcatheter closure of secundum atrial septal defects: a systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Limited data exists demonstrating the efficacy of minimally invasive surgery (MIS) compared to transcatheter (TC) closure of atrial septal defects (ASD). This systematic review and meta-analysis aims to compare post-operative outcomes of MIS versus TC repair in ASD closure.

METHODS

PubMed, Medline and EMBASE were searched from inception until June 2018 for randomised and observational studies comparing post-operative outcomes for MIS and TC repair. The studies were reviewed for bias using the ROBINS-I Score and pooled in a meta-analysis using STATA (version 15).

RESULTS

Six observational studies, involving 1524 patients assessing three primary and five secondary outcomes were included. Evidence suggests TC repair yielded shorter hospital stay (MD = 3.32, 95% CI 1.04-5.60) and lower rates of transient atrial fibrillation (AF) (RR = 0.48, 95% CI 0.20-1.15). TC repair patients also had fewer pericardial effusions (RR = 0.27, 95% CI 0.05-1.54, I² = 0.0%) and pneumothoraxes (RR = 0.18, 95% CI 0.04-0.80, I² = 0.0%). However, TC repair results in more minor residual shunts (RR = 6.04, 95% CI 1.69-21.63 in favour of MIS, I² = 39.0%). No differences were found for incidences of strokes (RR = 1.58, 95% CI 0.23-10.91, I² = 19.3%), unexpected bleeding (RR = 0.44, 95% CI 0.19-1.04, I² = 0.0%) and blood transfusion (RR = 0.39, 95% CI 0.09-1.59, I² = 0.0%).

CONCLUSIONS

MIS closure for ASD has similar outcomes compared to TC repair. However, the lack of randomised literature related to MIS versus TC repair for ASD closure warrants further evidence in the form of RCTs to further support these findings.

Atrial Septal Defect Closure via Ministernotomy in Children

Atrial septal defect (ASD) closure is usually performed in children via a conventional sternotomy. In striving to improve the cosmetic result, we have adopted a lower ministernotomy approach with a very small skin incision. We present a single surgeon experience of 110 consecutive patients undergoing surgical closure of ASD, comparing conventional (n=55) and mini-sternotomy (n=55) approaches. Our ministernotomy technique avoids direct superior vena cava cannulation, allowing for a smaller incision, while providing adequate exposure. The ministernotomy approach is safe and provides an excellent cosmetic result.

Evaluation of Different Minimally Invasive Techniques in Surgical Treatment for Ventricular Septal Defect

BACKGROUND

Minimally invasive cardiac surgery is becoming a safe and cosmetic alternative to standard median sternotomy (SMS). This retrospective study reviews our results and experience with the lower mini-sternotomy (LMS) technique and the right lateral thoracotomy (RLT) technique for ventricular septal defect (VSD) closure compared with SMS.

METHODS

Between January 2013 and Dec 2015, 198 patients underwent repair VSD through lower mini-sternotomy (LMS Group, n=66), right lateral thoracotomy (RLT Group, n=59), standard median sternotomy (SMS Group, n=73). Cardiopulmonary bypass was achieved directly in the three different approaches.

RESULTS

Procedures were performed successfully in all patients among the three groups and no in-hospital mortality occurred. No patient was reverted to standard median sternotomy in the LMS Group and RLT Group. The CPB time was 37.73±11.46 mins in the LMS Group, 41.3±13.97 mins in the RLT Group and 36.99±10.84 mins in the SMS Group (p=0.078); the cross-clamp times were 23.85±9.78 mins in the LMS Group, 22.54±9.08 mins in the RLT Group and 19.23±6.92 mins in the SMS Group (p=0.009). The total incision length of the procedure in the SMS Group (7.45±1.54cm) was longer than the other groups (LMS Group, 5.58±0.8cm and RLT Group, 5.96±1.48cm) and the difference was significant (p<0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Both the LMS and RLT approach can be performed with favourable cosmetic and acceptable clinical results for closing VSD. They are the promising alternatives to standard median sternotomy and merit further study.

Ministernotomy for correction of ventricular septal defect

Background

The development of minimally invasive surgery in the adult has created motivation for similar approaches in the congenital heart domain. Over the past 20 years, this type of surgery has been advocated in an effort to reduce costs related to hospital stay, and to improve the cosmetic results. We report our experience with ventricular septal defect repair utilizing a ministernotomy incision.

Methods

From August 2014 to August 2015, 26 patients underwent ministernotomy for correction of ventricular septal defect at our center. All patients were between the ages of 14 months-old to 24 years-old with weight ranged from 7.5 to 54 kg (median weight 12 kg). Diagnoses were confirmed with echocardiography. We analysed in-hospital and 6 months follow-up outcomes of the group.

Results

All defects were corrected successfully with satisfactory exposure. The median cardiopulmonary bypass time was 64 min, and median cross clamp time was 42 min. The intensive care unit stay ranged from 1 day to 3 days (median ICU stay, 1.5 days) and the hospital stay ranged from 4 to 13 days (median hospital stay, 5 days). There were no deaths during the operation or severe postoperative complications. No residual shunts were observed.

Conclusion

Our results demonstrated the safety and efficacy of ministernotomy for the correction of ventricular septal defect with improved cosmetic results in patients greater than 7.5 kg. This aprroach can be used in either the transatrial or transarterial approach, and in smaller weight infants.

Minimally invasive pediatric cardiac surgery. Atrial septal defect closure through axillary and submammary approaches

INTRODUCTION AND OBJECTIVES

Minimally invasive approaches in less-complex cardiac procedures can avoid unpleasant cosmetic results. Moreover, surgery can be scheduled in younger patients. In previous papers, we compared submammary and midline sternotomy. We present our initial experience with an axillary, compared to submammary, approach to repair atrial septal defects under extracorporeal circulation.

METHODS

20 patients are included: 10 in the submammary group (7 ostium secundum, 2 sinus venosus, 1 ostium primum) and 10 in the axillary group (7 ostium secundum, 3 sinus venosus). Mean age and weight are 6.4±3.62 years (range 3-13) and 23.5±8.74 Kg (range 12-38) in the submammary group, and 5.5±2.04 years (range 3-9) and 19.7±5.88 Kg (range 14-29) in the axillary one, respectively. Muscles are spared (pectoralis in submammary and latissimus in axillary). The whole procedure (cannulation and correction) is performed through a single incision, with no side ports.

RESULTS

No residual defects were found at discharge. Surgical approach maneuvers are more cumbersome through the axillary than the submammary approach. In a peer comparison, extracorporeal circulation and cross-clamp time were similar in both groups (P>.05).

CONCLUSIONS

1. Axillary approach is as safe as submammary access in selected patients and for defects approached through the atrium. 2. Cosmetic result is excellent.