Effect of the hemoglobin-based oxygen carrier HBOC-201 on laboratory instrumentation: cobas integra, chiron blood gas analyzer 840, Sysmex SE-9000 and BCT

Interference of bovine hemoglobin-based oxygen carrier-201 (Hemopure) on four hematology analyzers

INTRODUCTION

Hemoglobin-based oxygen carriers, for example HBOC-201 (Hemopure), are aimed to bridge acute anemia when blood transfusion is not available or refused by the patient. However, since HBOC-201 appears free in plasma, it interferes with laboratory tests. This study presents an overview of HBOC-201 interference on four commonly used hematology analyzers and suggests treatment monitoring possibilities.

METHODS

Blood samples were spiked with therapeutic doses of HBOC-201 and nine hematology parameters were measured with the Sysmex XN-20, Siemens Advia 2120i, Abbott Alinity Hq and Abbot Cell Dyn Sapphire hematology analyzers. The results were compared to control samples and the bias was determined.

RESULTS

Most parameters, including all cell counts, hematocrit and MCV, showed a non-significant bias compared to control. However, the standard, total hemoglobin (Hb) measurement as well as MCH and MCHC showed poor agreement with control, as HBOC-201 was included in this measurement. Yet, the flow cytometry-based Hb method quantified intracellular Hb in spiked samples, excluding HBOC-201.

CONCLUSION

Of all included hematology parameters, only total Hb and the associated MCH and MCHC suffered from interference. In contrast, the flow cytometry-based Hb measurement provided an accurate measure of intracellular Hb. The difference between total Hb and cellular Hb represents the HBOC-201 concentration and can be used to monitor HBOC-201 treatment.

Haemoglobin-based oxygen carriers and myocardial infarction

The incidence of investigator diagnosed myocardial infarction (MI) is greater in patients treated with haemoglobin-based oxygen carriers (HBOCs) than controls. Clinical trials and literature pertaining to possible HBOC toxicity mechanisms have been analyzed in order to identify possible reasons for this imbalance. MI diagnosis is hampered by potential interference of troponin assays by haemoglobin, haemolysis and bilirubin. Nevertheless, insofar as the reported incidence correlates with actual occurrence, there is a positive relationship between MI and HBOC dose and size. Preclinical and clinical data suggest that direct cardiac toxicity and coronary vasoconstriction are unlikely. More probable are detrimental intravascular interactions between HBOCs and components of the coagulation cascade, particularly dysfunctional endothelium. Elucidation of mechanisms is impeded by a lack of clinical data. Measurement of relevant biomarkers would be extremely useful in this regard and in improving patient selection criteria. Conduct of clinical trials in carefully selected patient populations after the development of improved protocols for MI diagnosis, along with concomitant biomarker data collection, is recommended.

Analytical interference of HBOC-201 (Hemopure, a synthetic hemoglobin-based oxygen carrier) on four common clinical chemistry platforms

BACKGROUND

There are 13 million blood transfusions each year in the US. Limitations in the donor pool, storage capabilities, mass casualties, access in remote locations and reactivity of donors all limit the availability of transfusable blood products to patients. HBOC-201 (Hemopure®) is a second-generation glutaraldehyde-polymer of bovine hemoglobin, which can serve as an "oxygen bridge" to maintain oxygen carrying capacity while transfusion products are unavailable. Hemopure presents the advantages of extended shelf life, ambient storage, and limited reactive potential, but its extracellular location can also cause significant interference in modern laboratory analyzers similar to severe hemolysis.

METHODS

Observed error in 26 commonly measured analytes was determined on 4 different analytical platforms in plasma from a patient therapeutically transfused Hemopure as well as donor blood spiked with Hemopure at a level equivalent to the therapeutic loading dose (10% v/v).

RESULTS

Significant negative error ratios >50% of the total allowable error (>0.5tAE) were reported in 23/104 assays (22.1%), positive bias of >0.5tAE in 26/104 assays (25.0%), and acceptable bias between -0.5tAE and 0.5tAE error ratio was reported in 44/104 (42.3%). Analysis failed in the presence of Hemopure in 11/104 (10.6%). Observed error is further subdivided by platform, wavelength, dilution and reaction method.

CONCLUSION

Administration of Hemopure (or other hemoglobin-based oxygen carriers) presents a challenge to laboratorians tasked with analyzing patient specimens. We provide laboratorians with a reference to evaluate patient samples, select optimal analytical platforms for specific analytes, and predict possible bias beyond the 4 analytical platforms included in this study.

The effect HBOC-201 and sodium nitrite resuscitation after uncontrolled haemorrhagic shock in swine

BACKGROUND

Development of Haemoglobin-based oxygen carriers (HBOCs) as blood substitutes has reached an impasse due to clinically adverse outcomes attributed to vasoconstriction secondary to nitric oxide (NO) scavenging. Studies suggest haemoglobin exhibits nitrite reductase activity that generates NO and N(2)O(3); harnessing this property may offset NO scavenging. Therefore, the effects of concomitantly infusing sodium nitrite (NaNO(2)) with HBOC-201 were investigated.

METHODS

Swine underwent uncontrolled liver haemorrhage before receiving up to three 10min 10ml/kg infusions of HBOC-201 (HBOC) with or without concurrent NaNO(2) (5.4μmol/kg [LD NaNO(2)] or 10.8μmol/kg [HD NaNO(2)]) or 6% Hetastarch (HEX) with or without HD NaNO(2) during "prehospital" resuscitation (15, 30 and 45min after injury). Definitive surgical care occurred at 75min; anaesthetic recovery at 120min. Animals were euthanised at 72h.

RESULTS

NaNO(2) temporarily reduced systemic and pulmonary blood pressure increases from HBOC in a dose-dependent fashion. There was no significant effect between groups in indices of tissue oxygenation or survival. Adverse clinical signs requiring humane euthanasia occurred with highest frequency after HBOC+HD NaNO(2) (3 of 4 pigs) and HBOC+LD NaNO(2) (2 of 4 pigs). Gross evidence of pulmonary congestion was observed in 5 of 8 swine receiving a HBOC and NaNO(2) combination compared to 1 of 16 swine receiving HBOC alone, HEX alone, or HEX+NaNO(2). Gross lesions correlated with histological evidence of pulmonary oedema and congestion, and in 2 of 4 HBOC+HD NaNO(2) pigs, pulmonary fibrin thrombi also were found. No other pig had similar evidence of thrombi. Asymmetric pre-resuscitation cardiac index was a potential confounder.

CONCLUSIONS

A significant interaction between NaNO(2) and HBOC-201 ameliorated HBOC-201 vasoconstrictive effects, consistent with HBOC possessing a nitrite reductase activity that generates vasodilator NO equivalents. Results were relatively equivalent in survival and markers of tissue oxygenation. The highest dose of NaNO(2) was the most effective in reducing HBOC-associated pulmonary and systemic vasoactivity but also with the highest incidence of adverse events. In this model, the transient nature of NaNO(2) in off-setting HBOC-201 vasoconstriction makes it less clinically promising than anticipated and the combination of NaNO(2) and HBOC appear to increase the risk of pulmonary complications in a dose-dependent fashion independently of haemodilutional effects on haemostatic components.

Oxygen therapeutics: perfluorocarbons and blood substitute safety

Current demands over the blood supply in developed and developing nations will compound over time. Red cell substitutes have a promising value proposition for transfusion services, because they hold the promise of increasing the availability of blood products and removing donor and contamination safety risks. In this article, the authors note that existing products suffer from critical shortcomings such as vasoactivity; they also point out that substitutes not based on human blood introduce potentially more complex safety hurdles. The authors discuss the attributes of an ideal blood substitute, and the mechanism and current status of perfluorocarbons; they also review the shortcomings of all oxygen therapeutic products in development today.

Interference in clinical chemistry assays by the hemoglobin-based oxygen carrier, Hemospan

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate interference by the hemoglobin-based oxygen carrier Hemospan on clinical laboratory assays.

DESIGN AND METHODS

Interfering Hemospan concentrations were determined for general chemistry and cardiac marker analytes in pooled serum and the corresponding hemolysis index was calculated.

RESULTS

Hemospan did not interfere with 20 of 35 analytes. Hemospan produced a negative interference in serum creatinine, amylase, alkaline phosphatase, uric acid, and GGT assays and a positive interference in serum phosphate, LDH, iron, triglycerides, total protein, AST, cholesterol, magnesium, and albumin assays, and appeared to positively bias the serum cardiac troponin I (cTnI) assay only when cTnI is present in the sample.

CONCLUSIONS

We present a report of assays affected by Hemospan and the threshold concentrations for interference. This study highlights the importance of interference studies in understanding the effects of hemoglobin-based oxygen carriers on results reported by the clinical laboratory.

Current Status of Artificial o2 Carriers

This article describes currently evaluated artificial O2 carriers, summarizes their efficacy, and discusses their side effects, based on and restricted to published data. For compounds in phase III testing, approximately 500 to 1000 patients have been dosed, and similar numbers of control patients have been investigated. For compounds in phase I or II testing, the number of patients dosed is significantly less. Unfortunately, there is a significant amount of nonpublished data, which renders the overall assessment difficult, and the direct comparison among different types of artificial O2 carriers is significantly limited by the virtual nonexistence of studies that directly compare different products.

Lactate Measurement Interference by Hemoglobin-Based Oxygen Carriers (Oxyglobin??, Hemopure??, and Hemolink???)

We sought to determine whether hemoglobin-based oxygen carriers (HBOCs), hemoglobin glutamer-200 [bovine] (HBOC-200, Oxyglobin), hemoglobin glutamer-250 [bovine] (HBOC-201, Hemopure), and hemoglobin raffimer (Hemolink) interfere with the accuracy of lactate measurements. Combinations of concentrated L-lactate solution, HBOC, and blood or plasma with added PlasmaLyte-A were added to sample tubes to make a linear and constant increase in lactate concentration in consecutive samples. Sample lactate concentrations ranged from 5-110 mg/dL (0.6-12 mm) (physiological reference range: 5-20 mg/dL [0.56-2.2 mm]). Comparisons were made between machine measured lactate concentrations and calculated lactate concentrations. For Hb glutamer-250, the average difference between measured and calculated lactate concentrations was -5.1 mg/dL (-0.57 mm) (LX-20), with greater underestimation at larger lactate concentrations. For Hb raffimer, the average difference was -2.2 mg/dL (-0.24 mm) (LX-20). The veterinary product, Hb glutamer-200, was tested on 3 analyzers (LX-20(R), YSI 1500, and YSI 2300). The YSI 1500 was the most accurate instrument with the mean difference between measured minus calculated lactate being +1.3 mg/dL versus -2.6 mg/dL (YSI 2300) and -8.4 mg/dL (LX-20). The clinical implications of this study are that with increasing levels of an HBOC in plasma, lactate interpretation may become inaccurate, especially at larger lactate concentrations, causing underestimation of measured lactate values and possible under-treatment of the patient. Therefore, caution must be exercised when interpreting lactate results when a HBOC is present in plasma.

Doping with Artificial Oxygen Carriers

There is a long history of science seeking to develop artificial substitutes for body parts damaged by disease or trauma. While defective teeth and limbs are commonly replaced by imitations without major loss of functionality, the development of a substitute for red blood cells has proved elusive. There is a permanent shortage of donor blood in western societies. Nevertheless, despite whole blood transfusions carrying measurable risks due to immunogenicity and the transmission of blood-borne infectious diseases, red blood cells are still relatively inexpensive, well tolerated and widely available. Researchers seeking to develop products that are able to meet and perhaps exceed these criteria have responded to this difficult challenge by adopting many different approaches. Work has focussed on two classes of substances: modified haemoglobin solutions and perfluorocarbon emulsions. Other approaches include the creation of artificial red cells, where haemoglobin and supporting enzyme systems are encapsulated into liposomes. Haemoglobin is ideally suited to oxygen transport when encased by the red cell membrane; however, once removed, it rapidly dissociates into dimers and is cleared by the kidney. Therefore, it must be stabilised before it can be safely re-infused into humans. Modifications concomitantly alter the vascular half-life, oxygen affinity and hypertensive characteristics of raw haemoglobin, which can be sourced from outdated blood stores, genetically-engineered Escherichia coli or even bovine herds. In contrast, perfluorocarbons are entirely synthetic molecules that are capable of dissolving oxygen but biologically inert. Since they dissolve rather than bind oxygen, their capacity to serve as a blood substitute is determined principally by the oxygen pressure gradients in the lung and at the target tissue. Blood substitutes have important potential areas of clinical application including red cell replacement during surgery, emergency resuscitation of traumatic blood loss, oxygen therapeutic applications in radiography (oxygenation of tumour cells is beneficial to the effect of certain chemotherapeutic agents), other medical applications such as organ preservation, and finally to meet the requirements of patients who cannot receive donor blood because of religious beliefs. Given the elite athlete's historical propensity to experiment with novel doping strategies, it is likely that the burgeoning field of artificial oxygen carriers has already attracted their attention. Scientific data concerning the performance benefits associated with blood substitutes are virtually nonexistent; however, international sporting federations have been commendably proactive in adding this category to their banned substance lists. The current situation is vulnerable to exploitation by immoral athletes since there is still no accepted methodology to test for the presence of artificial oxygen carriers.

Pretreatment of serum containing hemoglobin vesicles (oxygen carriers) to prevent their interference in laboratory tests

Hemoglobin vesicles (HbV, diameter: 251 +/- 81 nm) are artificial oxygen (O2) carriers encapsulating concentrated hemoglobin (Hb) solution with phospholipid bilayer membrane, and their O2 transporting ability in vivo has been extensively studied. It is important to clarify the interference of the HbV suspension in clinical laboratory tests performed on serum and to establish a pretreatment method to avoid such an interference. The HbV suspension, acellular Hb solution ([Hb] = 10 g/dl) or saline, was mixed with a pooled human serum at various ratios up to 50 vol% ([Hb] = 5 g/dl), and the magnitude of the interference effect of HbV and Hb on 30 analytes was studied. The mixture of the HbV suspension and serum was ultracentrifuged (50,000 g, 20 min) to remove the HbV particles as precipitate, and the supernatant was analyzed and compared with the saline control group. The HbV particles were also removed by centrifugation (2,700 g, 30 min) in the presence of dextran (Mw 200 kDa). The HbV suspension showed considerable interference effects in most analytes. The majority of these effects was more serious than those of the acellular Hb solution. These findings are thought to be due to the light absorption of Hb in HbV and/or the light scattering generated in the suspension that interferes with the colorimetric and turbidimetric measurements. The components of HbV may also interfere with the chemical reactions of the studied assays. However, removal of the HbV from the supernatant diminished the interference in most of the assays: this is an advantage of HbV in comparison with acellular chemically modified Hb solutions.

Validation of oxygen saturation measurements in a canine model of hemoglobin-based oxygen carrier infusion

This study was designed to validate oxygen saturation measurements from the NOVA CO-Oximeter (NOVA Biomedical Corporation, Waltham, MA), the i-STAT System (Sensor Devices, Waukesha, WI), and the Corning 170 blood gas analyzer (Bayer Corporation, East Walpole, MA) under conditions similar to the clinical application of a hemoglobin-based oxygen carrier (HBOC, hemoglobin glutamer-200 [bovine]; Oxyglobin, Biopure Corporation, Cambridge, MA). A canine model was used for both in vitro and in vivo experiments. In vivo experiments were conducted in a canine laboratory, and in vitro experiments were conducted in a tonometry laboratory. Study subjects were six mixed-breed dogs, each weighing approximately 30 kg. In the first set of experiments, the target blood po(2) levels were reached by tonometry. In the second set of experiments, quantitative measurements of total oxygen content with the LEXO2CON-K (HOSPEX Fiberoptics, Chestnut Hill, MA) were performed, immediately followed by measurements with the NOVA CO-Oximeter and the i-STAT system. HBOC was added in concentrations of 16.2, 32.5, 65, and 97.5 g/L. To analyze the clinical significance of the differences in the results obtained with the each investigated instrument, blood samples from dogs treated with HBOC after acute hemorrhagic shock were used. Oxygen saturation, oxygen content, and po(2) were measured. There was a strong correlation between the oxygen saturation values measured with the investigated instruments in samples after tonometry and known po(2). The total calculated oxygen content varied by 5% based on results generated by calculations using the investigated instruments. The results did not change with different oxygenation of the sample. The differences among methods were not significant when the HBOC concentration was 16.2 g/L. Higher concentrations of HBOC increased the difference between calculated and measured oxygen content; the i-STAT system demonstrated a greater deviation compared with the results of the other two instruments. Systemic oxygen uptake using the investigated instruments showed a high correlation with values based on LEXO2CON-K measurements (R = 0.97 for CO-Oximeter, R = 0.96 for Corning 170 blood gas analyzer, and R = 0.79 for i-STAT system). Systemic oxygen uptake values based on CO-Oximeter and Corning 170 blood gas analyzer data showed 75% accuracy; i-STAT system accuracy was 63% for control samples and 50% for samples after HBOC infusion.

Oxygen saturation measurements in canine blood containing hemoglobin glutamer-200 (Bovine): in vitro validation of the NOVA CO-Oximeter

This study was designed to validate in vitro oxygen saturation (SO2) measurements with the NOVA CO-Oximeter (Nova Biomedical Corp, Waltham, Mass, USA) in canine blood containing hemoglobin (Hb) glutamer-200 bovine (Hb-200; Oxyglobin, Biopure, Cambridge, Mass, USA) as a Hb-based oxygen carrier recently introduced into clinical practice. In the first set of experiments, stored blood from 6 mixed-breed canine blood donors was used. Target PO2 levels were reached in aliquots of blood samples by tonometry. Oxygen saturation was then measured with the test device and calculated based on known PO2 values. In the second set of experiments, total oxygen content was directly measured by means of an oxygen-specific electrode in aliquots of fresh whole arterial, venous, and mixed (arterial-venous) blood withdrawn from the same canine blood donors. Hb-200 was added to those blood samples to yield plasma Hb concentrations of 1.62, 3.25, 6.50, and 9.75 g/dL. Based on Hb content and SO2 measured by the NOVA CO-Oximeter in these samples, total oxygen content was also calculated for each sample and compared with measured values. A strong correlation was found between SO2 values measured with the co-oximeter in samples after tonometry, and calculated SO2 based on known PO2. Directly measured total blood O2 content varied by </=5% from values computed based on co-oximeter measurements of Hb content and SO2. These results did not change with different levels of oxygenation of the samples or different plasma Hb-200 concentrations. In conclusion, the NOVA CO-Oximeter is an accurate analyzer for measurement of SO2 after Hb-200 administration to canine blood.

Co-oximetry interference by hemoglobin-based blood substitutes

The blood substitutes now being developed from molecularly modified hemoglobin interfere with a wide variety of clinical analyzers, but their effects on cooximeters are unknown. Therefore, we investigated the effects of five hemoglobin-based blood substitutes on the measurements of eight different oximeters and cooximeters: the AVL Omni 6, the AVOXimeters 1000 and 4000, the Ciba Corning (now Bayer) CC270 CO-Oximeter, the Instrumentation Laboratory Synthesis 35, the IL482 and IL682 CO-Oximeters, and the Radiometer OSM3 Hemoximeter. The five blood substitutes in this study were obtained from Apex Bioscience (Research Triangle Park, NC), Baxter Healthcare Corp. (Deerfield, IL), Biopure Corp. (Cambridge, MA), Hemoglobin Therapeutics, and Hemosol, Inc. (Etobicoke, Ontario, Canada). A cooximeter control was used to compare the eight different instruments' measurements on unaltered human hemoglobin. The instruments yielded measurements of total hemoglobin concentration in undiluted blood substitutes that were generally not more variable than those on the control material. By contrast, when compared with readings on controls, the test instruments yielded measurements of the fractional concentrations of oxy-, deoxy-, carboxy-, and methemoglobin that showed greater instrument-to-instrument disparities and larger standard deviations about the all-instrument means. In some cases, the interference was even more obvious: five of six cooximeters gave negative carboxyhemoglobin readings on one particular product. Our findings indicate that the instruments will give less accurate but clinically useful measurements in the presence of these hemoglobin-based blood substitutes.

IMPLICATIONS

We investigated the effects of five hemoglobin-based blood substitutes on the measurements of eight different cooximeters. Some blood substitutes caused obvious interference, such as negative carboxyhemoglobin readings; however, the findings indicate that cooximeters will generally give less accurate but clinically useful measurements in the presence of the hemoglobin-based blood substitutes that were tested.

The reduction of the allogenic transfusion requirement in aortic surgery with a hemoglobin-based solution

OBJECTIVE

Because of allogenic red blood cell (RBC) availability and infection problems, novel alternatives, including hemoglobin-based oxygen-carrying solutions (HBOC), are being explored to minimize the perioperative requirement of RBC transfusions. This study evaluated HBOC-201, a room-temperature stable, polymerized, bovine-HBOC, as a substitute for allogenic RBC transfusion in patients undergoing elective infrarenal aortic operations.

METHODS

In a single blind, multicenter trial, 72 patients were prospectively randomized two-to-one to HBOC (n = 48) or allogenic RBC (n = 24) at the time of the first transfusion decision, either during or after elective infrarenal aortic reconstruction. Patients randomized to the HBOC group received 60 g of HBOC for the initial transfusion and had the option to receive three more doses (30 g each) within 96 hours. In this group, any further blood requirement was met with allogenic RBCs. Patients randomized to the allogenic RBC group received only standard RBC transfusions. The efficacy analysis was a means of assessing the ability of HBOC to eliminate the requirement for any allogenic RBC transfusions from the time of randomization through 28 days. Safety was evaluated by means of standard clinical trial methods.

RESULTS

The two treatment groups were comparable for all baseline characteristics. Although all patients in the allogenic RBC group required at least one allogenic RBC transfusion, 13 of 48 patients (27%; 95% CI, 15% to 42%) in the HBOC group did not require any allogenic RBC transfusions. The only significant changes documented were a 15% increase in mean arterial pressure and a three-fold peak increase in serum urea nitrogen concentration after HBOC. The complications were similar in both groups, with no allergic reactions. There were two perioperative deaths (8%) in the allogenic RBC group and three perioperative deaths (6%) in the HBOC group (P = 1.0).

CONCLUSION

HBOC significantly eliminated the need for any allogenic RBC transfusion in 27% of patients undergoing infrarenal aortic reconstruction, but did not reduce the median allogenic RBC requirement. HBOC transfusion was well tolerated and did not influence morbidity or mortality rates.