The evolution of transthyretin synthesis in vertebrate liver, in primitive eukaryotes and in bacteria

A review of species differences in the control of, and response to, chemical-induced thyroid hormone perturbations leading to thyroid cancer

This review summarises the current state of knowledge regarding the physiology and control of production of thyroid hormones, the effects of chemicals in perturbing their synthesis and release that result in thyroid cancer. It does not consider the potential neurodevelopmental consequences of low thyroid hormones. There are a number of known molecular initiating events (MIEs) that affect thyroid hormone synthesis in mammals and many chemicals are able to activate multiple MIEs simultaneously. AOP analysis of chemical-induced thyroid cancer in rodents has defined the key events that predispose to the development of rodent cancer and many of these will operate in humans under appropriate conditions, if they were exposed to high enough concentrations of the affecting chemicals. There are conditions however that, at the very least, would indicate significant quantitative differences in the sensitivity of humans to these effects, with rodents being considerably more sensitive to thyroid effects by virtue of differences in the biology, transport and control of thyroid hormones in these species as opposed to humans where turnover is appreciably lower and where serum transport of T4/T3 is different to that operating in rodents. There is heated debate around claimed qualitative differences between the rodent and human thyroid physiology, and significant reservations, both scientific and regulatory, still exist in terms of the potential neurodevelopmental consequences of low thyroid hormone levels at critical windows of time. In contrast, the situation for the chemical induction of thyroid cancer, through effects on thyroid hormone production and release, is less ambiguous with both theoretical, and actual data, showing clear dose-related thresholds for the key events predisposing to chemically induced thyroid cancer in rodents. In addition, qualitative differences in transport, and quantitative differences in half life, catabolism and turnover of thyroid hormones, exist that would not operate under normal situations in humans.

Lamprey metamorphosis: Thyroid hormone signaling in a basal vertebrate

As one of the most basal living vertebrates, lampreys represent an excellent model system to study the evolution of thyroid hormone (TH) signaling. The lamprey hypothalamic-pituitary-thyroid and reproductive axes overlap functionally. Lampreys have 3 gonadotropin-releasing hormones and a single glycoprotein hormone from the hypothalamus and pituitary, respectively, that regulate both the reproductive and thyroid axes. TH synthesis in larval lampreys takes place in an endostyle that transforms into typical vertebrate thyroid tissue during metamorphosis; both the endostyle and follicular tissue have all the typical TH synthetic components found in other vertebrates. Furthermore, lampreys also have the vertebrate suite of peripheral regulators including TH distributor proteins (THDPs), deiodinases and TH receptors (TRs). Although at the molecular level the components of the lamprey thyroid system are ancestral to other vertebrates, their functions have been largely conserved. TH signaling as it relates to lamprey metamorphosis represents a particularly interesting phenomenon. Unlike other metamorphosing vertebrates, lamprey THs increase throughout the larval period, peak prior to metamorphosis and decline rapidly at the onset of metamorphosis; patterns of deiodinase activity are consistent with these increases and declines. Moreover, goitrogens (which suppress TH levels) initiate precocious metamorphosis, and exogenous TH treatment blocks goitrogen-induced metamorphosis and disrupts natural metamorphosis. Despite this clear physiological difference, TH action via TRs is consistent with higher vertebrates. Based on observations that TRs are upregulated in a tissue-specific fashion during morphogenesis and the finding that lamprey TRs upregulate genes via THs in a fashion similar to higher vertebrates, we propose the following hypothesis for further testing. THs have a dual role in lampreys where high TH levels promote larval feeding and growth and then at the onset of metamorphosis TH levels decrease rapidly; at this time the relatively low TH levels function via TRs in a fashion similar to that of other metamorphosing vertebrates.

Evolutionary changes to transthyretin: evolution of transthyretin biosynthesis

Thyroid hormones are involved in growth and development, particularly of the brain. Thus, it is imperative that these hormones get from their site of synthesis to their sites of action throughout the body and the brain. This role is fulfilled by thyroid hormone distributor proteins. Of particular interest is transthyretin, which in mammals is synthesized in the liver, choroid plexus, meninges, retinal and ciliary pigment epithelia, visceral yolk sac, placenta, pancreas and intestines, whereas the other thyroid hormone distributor proteins are synthesized only in the liver. Transthyretin is synthesized by all classes of vertebrates; however, the tissue specificity of transthyretin gene expression varies widely between classes. This review summarizes what is currently known about the evolution of transthyretin synthesis in vertebrates and presents hypotheses regarding tissue-specific synthesis of transthyretin in each vertebrate class.

Evolutionary changes to transthyretin: structure and function of a transthyretin-like ancestral protein

The structure of the thyroid hormone distributor protein, transthyretin, has been highly conserved during the evolution of vertebrates. Over the last decade, studies into the evolution of transthyretin have revealed the existence of a transthyretin homolog, transthyretin-like protein, in all kingdoms. Phylogenetic studies have suggested that the transthyretin gene in fact arose as a result of a duplication of the transthyretin-like protein gene in early protochordate evolution. Structural studies of transthyretin-like proteins from various organisms have revealed the remarkable conservation of the transthyretin-like protein/transthyretin fold. The only significant differences between the structures of transthyretin-like protein and transthyretin were localized to the dimer-dimer interface and indicated that thyroid hormones could not be bound by transthyretin-like protein. All transthyretin-like proteins studied to date have been demonstrated to function in purine metabolism by hydrolysing the oxidative product of uric acid, 5-hydroxyisourate. The residues characterizing the catalytic site in transthyretin-like proteins are 100% conserved in all transthyretin-like protein sequences but are absent in transthyretins. Therefore, it was proposed that following duplication of the transthyretin-like protein gene, loss of these catalytic residues resulted in the formation of a deep, negatively charged channel that runs through the centre of the transthyretin tetramer. The results thus demonstrate the remarkable evolution of the transthyretin-like protein/transthyretin protein from a hydrolytic enzyme to a thyroid hormone distributor protein.

Hormone affinity and fibril formation of piscine transthyretin: the role of the N-terminal

Transthyretin (TTR) transports thyroid hormones (THs), thyroxine (T4) and triiodothyronine (T3) in the blood of vertebrates. TH-binding sites are highly conserved in vertebrate TTR, however, piscine TTR has a longer N-terminus which is thought to influence TH-binding affinity and may influence TTR stability. We produced recombinant wild type sea bream TTR (sbTTRWT) plus two mutants in which 6 (sbTTRM6) and 12 (sbTTRM12) N-terminal residues were removed. Ligand-binding studies revealed similar affinities for T3 (Kd=10.6+/-1.7nM) and T4 (Kd=9.8+/-0.97nM) binding to sbTTRWT. Affinity for THs was unaltered in sbTTRM12 but sbTTRM6 had poorer affinity for T4 (Kd=252.3+/-15.8nM) implying that some residues in the N-terminus can influence T4 binding. sbTTRM6 inhibited acid-mediated fibril formation in vitro as shown by fluorometric measurements using thioflavine T. In contrast, fibril formation by sbTTRM12 was significant, probably due to decreased stability of the tetramer. Such studies also suggested that sbTTRWT is more resistant to fibril formation than human TTR.

Marsupial models for understanding evolution of thyroid hormone distributor proteins

Marsupials are a group of mammals that are under-exploited, in particular in developmental and evolutionary studies of biological systems. In this review, the roles that marsupials have played in elucidating the evolution of thyroid hormone distribution systems are summarised. Marsupials are born at very early developmental stages, and most development occurs during lactation rather than in utero. Studying thyroid hormone distribution systems during marsupial development, in addition to comparing the two Orders of marsupials, gave clues as to the selection pressures acting on the hepatic gene expression of transthyretin (TTR), one of the major thyroid hormone distributor proteins in blood. The structure of TTR in marsupials is intermediate between that of avian/reptilian TTRs and eutherian ("placental mammalian") TTRs. Consequently, the function of marsupial TTR is intermediate between those of avian/reptilian TTRs and eutherian TTRs. Thus, in some respects marsupials can be considered as "missing links" in vertebrate evolution.

Molecular cloning, tissue distribution, and developmental expression of lamprey transthyretins

We isolated and cloned full-length cDNAs of transthyretin (TTR) from 2 genera of lamprey, Petromyzon marinus and Lampetra appendix. These sequences represent the first report of TTR sequences in vertebrates basal to teleost fishes. The deduced amino acid sequence of lamprey TTR cDNAs showed 36-47% identity with those from other vertebrates; secondary structure predictions and homology-based modeling were both consistent with TTRs from other vertebrates, and these cDNAs lacked the signatures found in TTR-like sequences of non-vertebrates. Of evolutionary interest is the observation that the N-termini of the lamprey TTR subunits are nine amino acids longer than those of eutherian TTRs and four to six amino acids longer than those from all other vertebrates. Sequencing of intron 1 confirmed that this longer N-terminal region is a result of the position of the intron 1/exon 2 splice site, further supporting previous studies. TTR mRNA was detected in a variety of larval lamprey tissues, with the highest levels found in the liver. TTR mRNA was also readily detected by Northern blotting, in the livers of animals at all phases of the lifecycle and was significantly elevated during metamorphosis. The upregulation of lamprey TTR gene expression during a major developmental event is consistent with observations in other vertebrates. In all other vertebrates studied to date, the transient upregulation of TTR gene expression or some other thyroid hormone distributor protein coincides with, and is thought to facilitate, the surge in serum thyroid hormone concentrations required for normal development. However, in lampreys, the upregulation of TTR gene expression occurs when serum thyroid hormone concentrations are at their lowest.

Transthyretin and familial amyloidotic polyneuropathy

Familial amyloidotic polyneuropathy (FAP) is an inherited autosomal dominant disease that is commonly caused by accumulation of deposits of transthyretin (TTR) amyloid around peripheral nerves. The only effective treatment for FAP is liver transplantation. However, recent studies on TTR aggregation provide clues to the mechanism of the molecular pathogenesis of FAP and suggest new avenues for therapeutic intervention. It is increasingly recognized that there are common features of a number of protein-misfolding diseases that can lead to neurodegeneration. As for other amyloidogenic proteins, the most toxic forms of aggregated TTR are likely to be the low-molecular-mass diffusible species, and there is increasing evidence that this toxicity is mediated by disturbances in calcium homeostasis. This article reviews what is already known about the mechanism of TTR aggregation in FAP and describes how recent discoveries in other areas of amyloid research, particularly Alzheimer's disease, provide clues to the molecular pathogenesis of FAP.

Cell and Molecular Biology of Transthyretin and Thyroid Hormones

Advances in four areas of transthyretin (TTR) research result in this being a timely review. Developmental studies have revealed that TTR is synthesized in all classes of vertebrates during development. This leads to a new hypothesis on selection pressure for hepatic TTR synthesis during development only, changing the previous hypotheses from "onset" of hepatic TTR synthesis in adulthood to "maintaining" hepatic TTR synthesis into adulthood. Evolutionary studies have revealed the existence of TTR-like proteins (TLPs) in nonvertebrate species and elucidated some of their functions. Consequently, TTR is an excellent model for the study of the evolution of protein structure, function, and localization. Studies of human diseases have demonstrated that TTR in the cerebrospinal fluid can form amyloid, but more recently there has been recognition of the roles of TTR in depression and Alzheimer's disease. Furthermore, amyloid mutations in human TTR that are the normal residues in other species result in cardiac deposition of TTR amyloid in humans. Finally, a revised model for TTR-thyroxine entry into the cerebrospinal fluid via the choroid plexus, based on data from studies in TTR null mice, is presented. This review concentrates on TTR and its thyroid hormone binding, in development and during evolution, and summarizes what is currently known about TLPs and the role of TTR in diseases affecting the brain.

Structural and functional evolution of transthyretin and transthyretin-like proteins

Transthyretin (TTR) is a tetrameric protein involved in the distribution of thyroid hormones in vertebrates. The amino acid sequence of TTR is highly conserved across vertebrates. Hypothetical TTR-like proteins (TLPs) were inferred from the identification of genes in nonvertebrate species. Here, we identified five motifs defining TLPs and three motifs defining both TTRs and TLPs. These motifs were mapped onto structurally conserved and functionally important regions of TTRs. These motifs were used to build hidden Markov models for accurate identification of TLPs in other organisms. TLPs were divided into three main groups based on their N-terminal regions. Most TLPs are cytosolic, but in plants and slime mold, we predict they are peroxisomal. We verified that the TLPs from enterobacteria were periplasmic. We demonstrated that TLP genes are expressed in a bacterium (E. coli), an invertebrate animal (C. elegans), and a plant (A. thaliana). These TLPs have similar subunit molecular weights to TTRs, are tetramers, and are predicted to have similar three-dimensional (3D) structures to TTRs, but do not bind thyroid hormones or similar ligands. We suggest that like TTRs, the N-terminal and C-terminal regions of TLPs are integral in defining the function of TLPs in nonvertebrate species and that the TLP gene duplicated in primitive vertebrates to produce the TTR gene. TLP/TTR has retained its overall structure, but changed function and localization during evolution in bacteria, invertebrates, plants, and vertebrates.

Evolution of the thyroid hormone distributor protein transthyretin in microbes, C. elegans, and vertebrates

Transthyretin (TTR) is an extracellular thyroid hormone distributor protein in vertebrates, whose structure has been highly conserved between fish and humans. However, the ligand preferentially bound by TTR has changed during evolution from 3',3,5-L-triiodothyronine (T3) to 3',5',3,5-l-tetraiodothyronine (T4). We identified genes in the genomes of >50 species of nonvertebrates, which could code for TTR-like proteins. Molecular modeling suggested most would have similar 3D structures and electrostatic surface potentials to vertebrate TTRs. We amplified TTR-like genes from a C. elegans cDNA library, demonstrating that it is transcribed. We synthesized recombinant TTR-like proteins from S. dublin and C. elegans. These proteins form tetramers similarly to vertebrate TTRs, but their ligands remain elusive.

Change in structure of the N-terminal region of transthyretin produces change in affinity of transthyretin to T4 and T3

The relationship between the structure of the N-terminal sequence of transthyretin (TTR) and the binding of thyroid hormone was studied. A recombinant human TTR and two derivatives of Crocodylus porosus TTRs, one with the N-terminal sequence replaced by that of human TTR (human/crocTTR), the other with the N-terminal segment removed (truncated crocTTR), were synthesized in Pichia pastoris. Subunit mass, native molecular weight, tetramer formation, cross-reactivity to TTR antibodies and binding to retinol-binding protein of these recombinant TTRs were similar to TTRs found in nature. Analysis of the binding affinity to thyroid hormones of recombinant human TTR showed a dissociation constant (Kd) for triiodothyronine (T3) of 53.26+/-3.97 nM and for thyroxine (T4) of 19.73+/-0.13 nM. These values are similar to those found for TTR purified from human serum, and gave a Kd T3/T4 ratio of 2.70. The affinity for T4 of human/crocTTR (Kd=22.75+/-1.89 nM) was higher than those of both human TTR and C. porosus TTR, but the affinity for T3 (Kd=5.40+/-0.25 nM) was similar to C. porosus TTR, giving a Kd T3/T4 ratio of 0.24. A similar affinity for both T3 (Kd=57.78+/-5.65 nM) and T4 (Kd=59.72+/-3.38 nM), with a Kd T3/T4 ratio of 0.97, was observed for truncated crocTTR. The obtained results strongly confirm the hypothesis that the unstructured N-terminal region of TTR critically influences the specificity and affinity of thyroid hormone binding to TTR.

The crystal structure of the transthyretin-like protein from Salmonella dublin, a prokaryote 5-hydroxyisourate hydrolase

The mechanism of binding of thyroid hormones by the transport protein transthyretin (TTR) in vertebrates is structurally well characterised. However, a homologous family of transthyretin-like proteins (TLPs) present in bacteria as well as eukaryotes do not bind thyroid hormones, instead they are postulated to perform a role in the purine degradation pathway and function as 5-hydroxyisourate hydrolases. Here we describe the 2.5 Angstroms X-ray crystal structure of the TLP from the Gram-negative bacterium Salmonella dublin, and compare and contrast its structure with vertebrate TTRs. The overall architecture of the homotetramer is conserved and, despite low sequence homology with vertebrate TTRs, structural differences within the monomer are restricted to flexible loop regions. However, sequence variation at the dimer-dimer interface has profound consequences for the ligand binding site and provides a structural rationalisation for the absence of thyroid hormone binding affinity in bacterial TLPs: the deep, negatively charged thyroxine-binding pocket that characterises vertebrate TTR contrasts with a shallow and elongated, positively charged cleft in S. dublin TLP. We have demonstrated that Sdu_TLP is a 5-hydroxyisourate hydrolase. Furthermore, using site-directed mutagenesis, we have identified three conserved residues located in this cleft that are critical to the enzyme activity. Together our data reveal that the active site of Sdu_TLP corresponds to the thyroxine binding site in TTRs.

Developmentally regulated thyroid hormone distributor proteins in marsupials, a reptile, and fish

Thyroid hormones are essential for vertebrate development. There is a characteristic rise in thyroid hormone levels in blood during critical periods of thyroid hormone-regulated development. Thyroid hormones are lipophilic compounds, which readily partition from an aqueous environment into a lipid environment. Thyroid hormone distributor proteins are required to ensure adequate distribution of thyroid hormones, throughout the aqueous environment of the blood, and to counteract the avid partitioning of thyroid hormones into the lipid environment of cell membranes. In human blood, these proteins are albumin, transthyretin and thyroxine-binding globulin. We analyzed the developmental profile of thyroid hormone distributor proteins in serum from a representative of each order of marsupials ( M. eugenii; S.crassicaudata), a reptile ( C. porosus), in two species of salmonoid fishes ( S. salar; O. tshawytsch), and throughout a calendar year for sea bream ( S. aurata). We demonstrated that during development, these animals have a thyroid hormone distributor protein present in their blood which is not present in the adult blood. At least in mammals, this additional protein has higher affinity for thyroid hormones than the thyroid hormone distributor proteins in the blood of the adult. In fish, reptile and polyprotodont marsupial, this protein was transthyretin. In a diprotodont marsupial, it was thyroxine-binding globulin. We propose an hypothesis that an augmented thyroid hormone distributor protein network contributes to the rise in total thyroid hormone levels in the blood during development.