RNA Analysis in Forensic Molecular Biology

BACKGROUND

Different types of RNA take on multiple crucial functions in living cells and tissues. Messenger RNA (mRNA) is a temporary molecular carrier of genetic information. Analysis of the composition of all mRNA contained in a cell at a given moment, the so-called transcriptome, enables the determination of the type of cell and its condition, e.g., in pathologically altered states.

METHODS

This review is based on pertinent publications retrieved by a selective literature search.

RESULTS

The analysis of differential gene expression has already been used in forensic molecular biology to determine the type of tissue contained in biological specimens. It is also being used in criminal investigations to determine the composition of mixed traces of various bodily fluids and/or organ tissues. The method is limited by degradation of the mRNA molecules through environmental influences. The use of newly developed molecular biological methods such as massive parallel sequencing can expand the information obtainable by this investigative method. Current research also addresses the forensic potential of deriving relevant information about the crime-e.g., its timing, or the condition of the involved persons-from the totality of mRNA species present in the specimens.

CONCLUSION

Forensic RNA analysis can yield a great deal of relevant information. It is likely to be applicable in a much wider variety of forensic situations in the near future.

Quantitative PCR analysis of bloodstains of different ages

An accurate method to estimate the age of a stain or the time since deposition (TsD) would represent an important tool in police investigations for evaluating the true relevance of a stain. In this study, two laboratories reproduced an mRNA-based method for TsD estimation published by another group. The qPCR-based assay includes four transcripts (B2M, LGALS2, CLC, and S100A12) and showed preferential degradation of the 5' end over the 3' end. In this study, the blood-specific marker ALAS2 was added to examine whether it would show the same degradation pattern. Based on our qPCR data several elastic net models with different penalty combinations were created, using training data from the two laboratories separately and combined. Each model was then used to estimate the age of bloodstains from two independent test sets each laboratory had prepared. The elastic net model built on both datasets with training samples up to 320 days old displayed the best prediction performance across all test samples (MAD=18.9 days). There was a substantial difference in the prediction performance for the two laboratories: Restricting TsD to up to 100 days for test data, one laboratory obtained an MAD of 2.0 days when trained on its own data, whereas the other laboratory obtained an MAD of 15 days.

A bacterial signature-based method for the identification of seven forensically relevant human body fluids

Detection and identification of body fluids plays a crucial role in criminal investigation, as it provides information on the source of the DNA as well as corroborative evidence regarding the crime committed, scene, and/or association with persons of interest. Historically, forensic serological methods have been chemical, immunological, catalytic, spectroscopic, and/or microscopic in nature. However, most of these methods are presumptive, with few robust confirmatory exceptions. In recent years several new molecular methods (mRNA, miRNA, DNA methylation, etc.) have been proposed; although promising, these methods require high quality human DNA or RNA. Additional steps are required in RNA based methods. Additionally, RNA based methods cannot be used for old cases where only DNA extracts remain to sample from. In this study, a novel non-human DNA (microbiome) based method was developed for the identification of the majority of forensically relevant human biological samples. Eight hundred and twelve (n = 812) biological samples (semen, vaginal fluid, menstrual blood, saliva, feces, urine, and blood) were collected and preserved using methods commonly used in forensic laboratories for evidence collection. Variable region four (V4) of 16 S ribosomal DNA (16 S rDNA) was amplified using a dual-indexing strategy and then sequenced on the MiSeq FGx sequencing platform using the MiSeq Reagent Kit v2 (500 cycles) and following the manufacturer's protocol. Machine learning prediction models were used to assess the classification accuracy of the newly developed method. As there was no significant difference in bacterial communities between vaginal fluid, menstrual blood, and female urine, these were combined as female intimate samples. Except in urine, the bacterial structures associated with male and female body fluid samples were not significantly different from one another. The newly developed method accurately identified human body fluid samples with an overall accuracy of more than 88%. This newly developed bacterial signature-based method is fast (no additional steps are needed as the same DNA can be used for both body fluid identification and STR typing), efficient (consume less sample as a single test can identify all major body fluids), sensitive (needs only 5 pg of bacterial DNA), accurate, and can be easily added into a forensic high throughput sequencing (HTS) panel.

On the Application of Microfluidic-Based Technologies in Forensics: A Review

Microfluidic technology is a powerful tool to enable the rapid, accurate, and on-site analysis of forensically relevant evidence on a crime scene. This review paper provides a summary on the application of this technology in various forensic investigation fields spanning from forensic serology and human identification to discriminating and analyzing diverse classes of drugs and explosives. Each aspect is further explained by providing a short summary on general forensic workflow and investigations for body fluid identification as well as through the analysis of drugs and explosives. Microfluidic technology, including fabrication methodologies, materials, and working modules, are touched upon. Finally, the current shortcomings on the implementation of the microfluidic technology in the forensic field are discussed along with the future perspectives.

On the Identification of Body Fluids and Tissues: A Crucial Link in the Investigation and Solution of Crime

Body fluid and body tissue identification are important in forensic science as they can provide key evidence in a criminal investigation and may assist the court in reaching conclusions. Establishing a link between identifying the fluid or tissue and the DNA profile adds further weight to this evidence. Many forensic laboratories retain techniques for the identification of biological fluids that have been widely used for some time. More recently, many different biomarkers and technologies have been proposed for identification of body fluids and tissues of forensic relevance some of which are now used in forensic casework. Here, we summarize the role of body fluid/ tissue identification in the evaluation of forensic evidence, describe how such evidence is detected at the crime scene and in the laboratory, elaborate different technologies available to do this, and reflect real life experiences. We explain how, by including this information, crucial links can be made to aid in the investigation and solution of crime.

The effect of infertile semen on the mRNA-based body fluid identification

In the past decade, mRNA markers have been well demonstrated as promising molecular markers in forensic body fluid identification (BFI), and successfully used in wide applications. Several studies have assessed the performance of semen-specific mRNA markers in distinguishing semen from other common body fluids at the crime scene. Infertility has been reported as a global health problem that is affecting approximately 15% of couples worldwide. Therefore, it is important for forensic researchers to consider the impact of infertility on semen identification. This study aimed to explore the effect of semen from infertile men (hereinafter "infertile semen") on BFI and to identify semen-specific mRNAs that can efficiently and accurately distinguish normal and infertile semen samples from other body fluids. Results showed that the selected five mRNAs (KLK3, TGM4, SEMG1, PRM1, and PRM2) performed a significantly high semen specificity in normal semen. Moreover, KLK3 was slightly influenced by infertile semen samples with over 98% positive results in all semen samples. The accuracy to predict normal semen reached up to 96.6% using the discrimination function Y1 with KLK3 and PRM1. However, when the infertile semen samples were included in discrimination function (function Y2 with KLK3), the accuracy rate of semen identification (including the normal and infertile semen) was down to 89.5%. Besides, the sensitivity of multiplex assay could reach down to 50pg. Our results suggest that it is important to consider the presence of infertile semen when using mRNAs to identify semen samples, which would have a far-reaching impact in forensic identification.

Discrimination of menstrual and peripheral blood traces using attenuated total reflection Fourier transform-infrared (ATR FT-IR) spectroscopy and chemometrics for forensic purposes

Body fluid traces can provide highly valuable clues in forensic investigations. In particular, bloodstains are a common occurrence in criminal investigation, and the discrimination of menstrual and peripheral blood is a crucial step for casework involving rape and sexual assault. Most of the current protocols require the detection of characteristic menstrual blood components using sophisticated procedures that need to be performed in a laboratory. The present study uses attenuated total reflection Fourier transform-infrared (ATR FT-IR) spectroscopy as a nondestructive technique for discriminating menstrual and peripheral blood traces. This method incorporates statistical analysis and was evaluated by internal and external validation testing. A partial least squares discriminant analysis (PLSDA) classification model was created for differentiating the two types of blood in a binary manner. Excellent separation between menstrual and peripheral blood samples was achieved during internal validation. External validation resulted in 100% accuracy for predicting a sample as peripheral or menstrual blood. This study demonstrates that ATR FT-IR spectroscopy combined with chemometrics is a reliable approach for rapid and nondestructive discrimination of menstrual and peripheral bloodstains. It offers a significant advantage to forensic science due to the availability of portable instruments and the potential for bloodstain analysis at a crime scene. Graphical abstract.

mRNA profiling of mock casework samples: Results of a FoRNAP collaborative exercise

In recent years, forensic mRNA profiling has increasingly been used to identify the origin of human body fluids. By now, several laboratories have implemented mRNA profiling and also use it in criminal casework. In 2018 the FoRNAP (Forensic RNA Profiling) group was established among a number of these laboratories with the aim of sharing experiences, discussing optimization potential, identifying challenges and suggesting solutions with regards to mRNA profiling and casework. To compare mRNA profiling methods and results a collaborative exercise was organized within the FoRNAP group. Seven laboratories from four countries received 16 stains, comprising six pure body fluid / tissue stains and ten mock casework samples. The laboratories were asked to analyze the provided stains with their in-house method (PCR/CE or MPS) and markers of choice. Five laboratories used a DNA/RNA co-extraction strategy. Overall, up to 11 mRNA markers per body fluid were analyzed. We found that mRNA profiling using different extraction and analysis methods as well as different multiplexes can be applied to casework-like samples. In general, high input samples were typed with high accuracy by all laboratories, regardless of the method used. Irrespective of the analysis strategy, samples of low input or mixed stains were more challenging to analyze and interpret since, alike to DNA profiling, a higher number of markers dropped out and/or additional unexpected markers not consistent with the cell type in question were detected. It could be shown that a plethora of different but valid analysis and interpretation strategies exist and are successfully applied in the Forensic Genetics community. Nevertheless, efforts aiming at optimizing and harmonizing interpretation approaches in order to achieve a higher consistency between laboratories might be desirable in the future. The simultaneous extraction of DNA alongside RNA showed to be an effective approach to identify not only the body fluid present but also to identify the donor(s) of the stain. This allows investigators to gain valuable information about the origin of crime scene samples and the course of events in a crime case.

Current Methods for Body Fluid Identification Related to Sexual Crime: Focusing on Saliva, Semen, and Vaginal Fluid

Although, DNA typing plays a decisive role in the identification of persons from blood and body fluid stains in criminal investigations, clarifying the origin of extracted DNA has also been considered an essential task in proving a criminal act. This review introduces the importance of developing precise methods for body fluid identification. Body fluid identification has long relied on enzymatic methods as a presumptive assay and histological or serological methods as a confirmatory assay. However, because the latest DNA typing methods can rapidly obtain results from very small and even old, poorly preserved samples, the development of a novel corresponding body fluid identification method is required. In particular, an immunochromatographic method has been introduced to identify saliva and semen from sexual crimes. In addition, for vaginal fluid identification, attempts have been made in the past decade to introduce a method relying on body fluid-specific mRNA expression levels. At present, the development of molecular biological methods involving microRNA, DNA methylation, and resident bacterial DNA is ongoing. Therefore, in criminal investigations, body fluid identification is an essential task for correctly applying the results of DNA typing, although further research and development are required.

Development of a multiplex RT-PCR assay and statistical evaluation of its use in forensic identification of vaginal fluid

The identification of vaginal fluid from casework samples of sexual assaults provides important probative evidence of vaginal intercourse. The aim of this study was to establish a more specific procedure for identifying vaginal fluids for forensic purposes. Vaginal fluid marker candidates have been evaluated quantitatively and five of these markers (ESR1, SERPINB13, KLK13, CYP2B7P1, MUC4) have been amplified simultaneously by a multiplex reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) procedure. Each amplicon has been separated and quantified automatically using chip electrophoresis. Subsequently, in the present study, detectability and cross-reactivity of the developed multiplex procedure were assessed in detail using various forensically relevant body fluids. Then, a cutoff value for the positive detection of vaginal fluids was set for each marker by Youden index. The ability of the multiplex RT-PCR assay to distinguish between vaginal and other body fluids was evaluated statistically using a likelihood ratio (LR) that was estimated using a Bayesian estimation approach to consider the infrequency of detection. A high LR was obtained when all five markers showed positive results (LR = 4.33 × 109; 95% credible interval, 3.95 × 107 -2.87 × 1012). The developed procedure was validated using vaginal fluid samples under various conditions. High LRs were found for aged vaginal fluid stains, although each amplicon peak was low. It was also able to identify vaginal stains mixed with other body fluids. In conclusion, the multiplex RT-PCR-based procedure followed by the statistical evaluation using LR could be a powerful tool for the objective identification of vaginal fluids.

Forensic discrimination of menstrual blood and peripheral blood using attenuated total reflectance (ATR)-Fourier transform infrared (FT-IR) spectroscopy and chemometrics

Body fluids are one of the most important pieces of evidence encountered in forensic cases especially in cases of sexual assault. Analysis of such evidence can help to establish a link between the perpetrator, the victim, and the crime scene and thereby assist in crime reconstruction. However, one of the biggest challenges faced by the investigators in sexual assault cases is that of ascertaining the issue of consent of the victim. In this matter, differentiation of menstrual blood (either in dried or stained form) from traumatic peripheral blood can give a potential solution on this particular aspect. A number of studies have been attempted to differentiate these two body fluids using various biochemical and serological methods. However, the methods employed are limited by factors such as sample destructivity and non-specificity, and the methods are susceptible to false positive results. In the present study, the scope of attenuated total reflectance (ATR)-Fourier transform infrared (FT-IR) spectroscopy in discriminating samples of menstrual blood and peripheral blood has been investigated, in combination with chemometric tools such as principal component analysis (PCA), partial least square regression (PLSR), and linear discriminant analysis (LDA). PCA resulted in 93.3% accuracy, whereas PLSR and LDA resulted in 100% accuracy for the discrimination of peripheral blood from menstrual blood. Application of PCA for the discrimination of menstrual blood from vaginal fluid and seminal fluid delivered 100% classification. Similarly, 100% classification was achieved while differentiating between menstrual blood and blood look-alike substances. Furthermore, in the current study, the effect of substrates on the analysis of menstrual blood has also been studied and described. Graphical Abstract.

Human Organ Tissue Identification by Targeted RNA Deep Sequencing to Aid the Investigation of Traumatic Injury

Molecular analysis of the RNA transcriptome from a putative tissue fragment should permit the assignment of its source to a specific organ, since each will exhibit a unique pattern of gene expression. Determination of the organ source of tissues from crime scenes may aid in shootings and other investigations. We have developed a prototype massively parallel sequencing (MPS) mRNA profiling assay for organ tissue identification that is designed to definitively identify 10 organ/tissue types using a targeted panel of 46 mRNA biomarkers. The identifiable organs and tissues include brain, lung, liver, heart, kidney, intestine, stomach, skeletal muscle, adipose, and trachea. The biomarkers were chosen after iterative specificity testing of numerous candidate genes in various tissue types. The assay is very specific, with little cross-reactivity with non-targeted tissue, and can detect RNA mixtures from different tissues. We also demonstrate the ability of the assay to successful identify the tissue source of origin using a single blind study.

Novel messenger RNAs for body fluid identification

In forensic investigations, the identification of the cellular or body fluid source of biological evidence can provide crucial probative information for the court. Messenger RNA (mRNA) profiling has become a valuable tool for body fluid and cell type identification due to its high sensitivity and compatibility with DNA analysis. However, using a single marker to determine the somatic origin of a sample can lead to misinterpretation as a result of cross-reactions. While false positives may be avoided through the simultaneous detection of multiple markers per body fluid, this approach is currently limited by the small number of known differentially expressed mRNAs. Here we characterise six novel mRNAs, partly identified from RNA-Seq, which can supplement existing markers for the detection of circulatory blood, semen (with and without spermatozoa), and menstrual fluid: HBD and SLC4A1 for blood, TNP1 for spermatozoa, KLK2 for seminal fluid, and MMP3 and STC1 for menstrual fluid. Respective expression profiles were evaluated by singleplex endpoint reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). HBD, SLC4A1, and KLK2 were specific to their target body fluids. TNP1, MMP3, and STC1 each cross-reacted with two non-target samples; however, these signals were below 350RFU, not reproducible, and likely resulted from large body fluid inputs. All candidates were more sensitive for the detection of their target body fluids than corresponding well-known mRNAs, in particular those for menstrual fluid. The increased sensitivities were statistically significant, except for KLK2. Thus, the new mRNAs introduced here are promising new targets for improved body fluid profiling.

RNA/DNA co-analysis on aged bloodstains from adhesive tapes used for gunshot residue collection from hands

In cases of firearm related fatalities a systematic investigation at the scene of death is indispensable to differentiate between self-inflicted and homicidal gunshot injuries. A common method to preserve gunshot residues (GSR) is their collection using adhesive tapes. However, the biological material gathered at the same time by the tapes would be of special interest if backspatter, ejected from the entrance wound against the direction of fire, could be detected. In the present study we examined the success rate of co-analysis of RNA and DNA recovered from biological traces sampled with adhesive tapes. The material originated from eight cases of fatal gunshots, taken from the hands of suspects or victims, examined 5 to 19 years ago for GSR. For all types of adhesive tapes tested, quantity and quality of the co-extracted nucleic acids was insufficient for successful DNA profiling, but was sufficient for the detection of blood-specific micro RNA (miRNA). In summary, sampling trace evidence from the hands of persons involved in fatal gunshots with adhesive tapes has a long-term detrimental effect on biological traces.

mRNA Profiling for Vaginal Fluid and Menstrual Blood Identification

Recently mRNA profiling has been widely proposed as a universal tool for biological fluids identification. Here, we describe a test for vaginal fluid identification that combines detection of five markers: vaginal mRNAs and Lactobacilli in end-point PCR reaction. The test detects the following transcripts: HBD1 (Human beta-defensin 1), MUC4 (Mucin 4), MMP11 (Matrix metalloproteinase 11), housekeeping gene G6PDH (glucose 6-phosphate dehydrogenase), and the 16S-23S rRNA intergenic spacer regions of L. crispatus and L. gasseri/L. johnsonii. Simultaneous analysis of five vaginal markers and a housekeeping gene ensures high specificity and reliability in the detection of vaginal material, which could not be obtained using detection of a single marker.

Developed and evaluated a multiplex mRNA profiling system for body fluid identification in Chinese Han population

In forensic casework, identification the cellular origin from a biological sample is crucial to the case investigation and reconstruction in crime scene. DNA/RNA co-extraction for STR typing and human body fluids identification has been proposed as an efficient and comprehensive assay for forensic analysis. Several cell-specific messenger RNA (mRNA) markers for identification of the body fluids have been proposed by previous studies. In this study, a novel multiplex mRNA profiling system included 19 markers was developed and performed by reverse transcription endpoint polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). The multiplex combined 3 housekeeping gene markers and 16 cell-specific markers that have been used to identify five types of human body fluids: peripheral blood, semen, saliva, vaginal secretions and menstrual blood. The specificity, sensitivity, stability and detectability of the mixture were explored in our study. Majority of the cell-specific mRNA markers showed high specificity, although cross-reactivity was observed sporadically. Specific profiling for per body fluid was obtained. Moreover, the interpretation guidelines for inference of body fluid types were performed according to the A. Lindenbergh et al. The scoring guidelines can be applied to any RNA multiplex, which was based on six different scoring categories (observed, observed and fits, sporadically observed and fits, not observed, sporadically observed, not reliable, and non-specific due to high input). The simultaneous extraction of DNA showed positive full or partial profiling results of all samples. It demonstrated that the approach of combined STR-profiling and RNA profiling was suitable and reliable to detect the donor and origin of human body fluids in Chinese Han population.

Validation of an immunochromatographic D-dimer test to presumptively identify menstrual fluid in forensic exhibits

Identifying the biological source of a crime scene stain can be crucial for police investigations in many scenarios. Blood is one of the most common fluids found, and accurate differentiation between peripheral blood and menstrual fluid could provide valuable information regarding the issue of consent in sexual assault cases. For the detection of menstrual fluid, no easy-to-use presumptive test is available to date. Therefore, this study aimed to validate a simple immunochromatographic test for the indication of menstrual fluid, focusing on a D-dimer assay. The Clearview® rapid D-dimer test provides a diagnostic assay for the detection of fibrin degradation products. We validated the sensitivity and robustness of the assay using fresh and dried menstrual fluid samples, body fluid mixtures, diluted samples, and casework swabs. Cross reactivity was tested for saliva, semen, vaginal fluid, and blood. No false positive results were obtained; it was possible to successfully analyze mixtures, highly diluted samples, and casework swabs. The results of this study indicate that the D-dimer assay reliably detects menstrual fluid in forensic exhibits and is easy to implement into the current workflow of body fluid identification.

mRNA heptaplex protocol for distinguishing between menstrual and peripheral blood

The identification of menstrual blood is an important issue in forensic biology, but currently, there are no confirmatory methods for its detection. Here, we demonstrate a highly reliable simple heptaplex method that allows for the discrimination between menstrual and peripheral blood. The test has been used successfully in criminal casework, in which the origin of blood on a rape victim's underwear and trousers was questioned as being menstrual or traumatic peripheral blood. To solve this problem, transcripts of the following genes were used: mucin 4 (MUC4), human β-defensin 1 (HBD1), two matrix metalloproteinases (MMP7, MMP11), δ-aminolevulinate synthase 2 (ALAS2), hemoglobin alpha (HBA) and glucose 6-phosphate dehydrogenase (G6PDH). The sensitivity of the test is 0.3ng of RNA. The possibility of the detection and differentiation of menstrual and peripheral blood in mixtures that contain other body fluids was investigated. Reliable detection is possible for menstrual blood stains that are up to 1-2 years old if stored at room temperature. This easy approach, thanks to the amplification of 4 vaginal and 2 blood markers, minimizes the risk of false negative results.

Development of highly sensitive and specific mRNA multiplex system (XCYR1) for forensic human body fluids and tissues identification

The identification of human body fluids or tissues through mRNA-based profiling is very useful for forensic investigations. Previous studies have shown mRNA biomarkers are effective to identify the origin of biological samples. In this study, we selected 16 tissue specific biomarkers to evaluate their specificities and sensitivities for human body fluids and tissues identification, including porphobilinogen deaminase (PBGD), hemoglobin beta (HBB) and Glycophorin A (GLY) for circulatory blood, protamine 2 (PRM2) and transglutaminase 4 (TGM4) for semen, mucin 4 (MUC4) and human beta defensin 1(HBD1) for vaginal secretion, matrix metalloproteinases 7 and 11 (MMP7 and MMP11) for menstrual blood, keratin 4(KRT4) for oral mucosa, loricrin (LOR) and cystatin 6 (CST6) for skin, histatin 3(HTN3) for saliva, statherin (STATH) for nasal secretion, dermcidin (DCD) for sweat and uromodulin (UMOD) for urine. The above mentioned ten common forensic body fluids or tissues were used in the evaluation. Based on the evaluation, a reverse transcription (RT) PCR multiplex assay, XCYR1, which includes 12 biomarkers (i.e., HBB, GLY, HTN3, PRM2, KRT4, MMP11, MUC4, DCD, UMOD, MMP7, TGM4, and STATH) and 2 housekeeping genes [i.e., glyceraldehyde-3-phosphate dehydrogenase (GAPDH) and 18SrRNA], was developed. This assay was further validated with real casework samples and mock samples (with both single source and mixture) and it was approved that XCYR1 is effective to identify common body fluids or tissues (i.e., circulatory blood, saliva, semen, vaginal secretion, menstrual blood, oral mucosa, nasal secretion, sweat and urine) in forensic casework samples.

Raman spectroscopy coupled with advanced statistics for differentiating menstrual and peripheral blood

Body fluids are a common and important type of forensic evidence. In particular, the identification of menstrual blood stains is often a key step during the investigation of rape cases. Here, we report on the application of near-infrared Raman microspectroscopy for differentiating menstrual blood from peripheral blood. We observed that the menstrual and peripheral blood samples have similar but distinct Raman spectra. Advanced statistical analysis of the multiple Raman spectra that were automatically (Raman mapping) acquired from the 40 dried blood stains (20 donors for each group) allowed us to build classification model with maximum (100%) sensitivity and specificity. We also demonstrated that despite certain common constituents, menstrual blood can be readily distinguished from vaginal fluid. All of the classification models were verified using cross-validation methods. The proposed method overcomes the problems associated with currently used biochemical methods, which are destructive, time consuming and expensive.

Rapid and inexpensive body fluid identification by RNA profiling-based multiplex High Resolution Melt (HRM) analysis

Positive identification of the nature of biological material present on evidentiary items can be crucial for understanding the circumstances surrounding a crime. However, traditional protein-based methods do not permit the identification of all body fluids and tissues, and thus molecular based strategies for the conclusive identification of all forensically relevant biological fluids and tissues need to be developed. Messenger RNA (mRNA) profiling is an example of such a molecular-based approach. Current mRNA body fluid identification assays involve capillary electrophoresis (CE) or quantitative RT-PCR (qRT-PCR) platforms, each with its own limitations. Both platforms require the use of expensive fluorescently labeled primers or probes. CE-based assays require separate amplification and detection steps thus increasing the analysis time. For qRT-PCR assays, only 3-4 markers can be included in a single reaction since each requires a different fluorescent dye.

To simplify mRNA profiling assays, and reduce the time and cost of analysis, we have developed single- and multiplex body fluid High Resolution Melt (HRM) assays for the identification of common forensically relevant biological fluids and tissues. The incorporated biomarkers include IL19 (vaginal secretions), IL1F7 (skin), ALAS2 (blood), MMP10 (menstrual blood), HTN3 (saliva) and TGM4 (semen).  The HRM assays require only unlabeled PCR primers and a single saturating intercalating fluorescent dye (Eva Green). Each body-fluid-specific marker can easily be identified by the presence of a distinct melt peak. Usually, HRM assays are used to detect variants or isoforms for a single gene target. However, we have uniquely developed duplex and triplex HRM assays to permit the simultaneous detection of multiple targets per reaction. Here we describe the development and initial performance evaluation of the developed HRM assays. The results demonstrate the potential use of HRM assays for rapid, and relatively inexpensive, screening of biological evidence.

RNA/DNA co-analysis from human menstrual blood and vaginal secretion stains: results of a fourth and fifth collaborative EDNAP exercise

The European DNA Profiling Group (EDNAP) organized a fourth and fifth collaborative exercise on RNA/DNA co-analysis for body fluid identification and STR profiling. The task was to identify dried menstrual blood and vaginal secretion stains using specific RNA biomarkers, and additionally test 3 housekeeping genes for their suitability as reference genes. Six menstrual blood and six vaginal secretion stains, two dilution series (1/4-1/64 pieces of a menstrual blood/vaginal swab) and, optionally, bona fide or mock casework samples of human or non-human origin were analyzed by 24 participating laboratories, using RNA extraction or RNA/DNA co-extraction methods. Two novel menstrual blood mRNA multiplexes were used: MMP triplex (MMP7, MMP10, MMP11) and MB triplex (MSX1, LEFTY2, SFRP4) in conjunction with a housekeeping gene triplex (B2M, UBC, UCE). Two novel mRNA multiplexes and a HBD1 singleplex were used for the identification of vaginal secretion: Vag triplex (MYOZ1, CYP2B7P1 and MUC4) and a Lactobacillus-specific Lacto triplex (Ljen, Lcris, Lgas). The laboratories used different chemistries and instrumentation and all were able to successfully isolate and detect mRNA in dried stains. The simultaneous extraction of RNA and DNA allowed for positive identification of the tissue/fluid source of origin by mRNA profiling as well as a simultaneous identification of the body fluid donor by STR profiling, also from old and compromised casework samples. The results of this and the previous collaborative RNA exercises support RNA profiling as a reliable body fluid identification method that can easily be combined with current STR typing technology.

Circulating microRNA for the identification of forensically relevant body fluids

The development of molecular genetics-based body fluid identification methods in forensic science has become necessary to provide greater sensitivity and specificity than that obtained using conventional serological and immunological methods. Numerous studies have demonstrated the ability to identify the body fluid origin of forensically relevant biological stains using messenger RNA expression analysis. However, the length of the amplified products used in these assays may not be ideal for use with highly degraded or environmentally compromised forensic casework samples. Therefore a novel approach to body fluid identification using small RNA profiling (e.g., microRNA or miRNA profiling) was developed in an attempt to improve the success of analysis with highly degraded samples. We have identified a set of nine differentially expressed miRNAs that permit the identification of the body fluid origin of forensic biological stains and in this chapter provide the detailed procedures for performing these assays.

The determination of tissue-specific DNA methylation patterns in forensic biofluids using bisulfite modification and pyrosequencing

The goal of this study is to explore the application of epigenetic markers in the identification of biofluids that are commonly found at the crime scene. A series of genetic loci were examined in order to define epigenetic markers that display differential methylation patterns between blood, saliva, semen, and epithelial tissue. Among the different loci tested, we have identified a panel of markers, C20orf117, ZC3H12D, BCAS4, and FGF7, that can be used in the determination of these four tissue types. Since methylation modifications occur at cytosine bases that are immediately followed by guanine bases (CpG sites), methylation levels were measured at CpG sites spanning each marker. Up to 11 samples of each tissue type were collected and subjected to bisulfite modification to convert unmethylated CpG-associated cytosine bases to thymine bases. The bisulfite modified DNA was then amplified via nested PCR using a primer set of which one primer was biotin labeled. Biotinylated PCR products were in turn analyzed and the methylation level at each CpG site was quantitated by pyrosequencing. The percent methylation values at each CpG site were determined and averaged for each tissue type. The results indicated significant methylation differences between the tissue types. The methylation patterns at the ZC3H12D and FGF7 loci differentiated sperm from blood, saliva, and epithelial cells. The C20orf117 locus differentiated blood from sperm, saliva, and epithelial cells and saliva was differentiated from blood, sperm, and epithelial cells at a fourth locus, BCAS4. The results of this study demonstrate the applicability of epigenetic markers as a novel tool for the determination of biofluids using bisulfite modification and pyrosequencing.

DNA methylation-specific multiplex assays for body fluid identification

Recent advances in whole-genome epigenetic analysis indicate that chromosome segments called tissue-specific differentially methylated regions (tDMRs) show different DNA methylation profiles according to cell or tissue type. Therefore, body fluid-specific differential DNA methylation is a promising indicator for body fluid identification. However, DNA methylation patterns are susceptible to change in response to environmental factors and aging. Therefore, we investigated age-related methylation changes in semen-specific tDMRs using body fluids from young and elderly men. After confirming the stability of the body fluid-specific DNA methylation profile over time, two different multiplex PCR systems were constructed using methylation-sensitive restriction enzyme PCR and methylation SNaPshot, in order to analyze the methylation status of specific CpG sites from the USP49, DACT1, PRMT2, and PFN3 tDMRs. Both multiplex systems could successfully identify semen with spermatozoa and could differentiate menstrual blood and vaginal fluids from blood and saliva. Although including more markers for body fluid identification might be necessary, this study adds to the support that body fluid identification by DNA methylation profiles could be a valuable tool for forensic analysis of body fluids.

Identification of nasal blood by real-time RT-PCR

A new approach for the identification of body fluid stains by comparing specific mRNA expression levels has been extensively studied in recent years. Here, we examine whether nasal blood, which is regarded as one of the most difficult types of blood to identify, can be identified by comparing mRNA expression levels of target genes specific to saliva, nasal secretion, and blood. The saliva-specific statherin gene (STATH) was found to be expressed at high levels in not only saliva (dCt value: 1.32±1.39, n=5), but also nasal secretions (dCt value: 0.90±1.14, n=5), while the histatin gene (HTN3) was only expressed at high levels in saliva (dCt value: 1.08±2.35, n=5). We also confirmed that the hemoglobin-beta gene (HBB) showed high expression levels in blood (dCt value: -9.51±0.40, n=5). Four nasal blood stains were found to highly express STATH (dCt value: 5.65±3.98) and HBB (dCt value: -8.79±1.67) but not HTN3, suggesting that the stain samples contained both nasal secretions and blood and can therefore be identified as nasal blood stains. Although menstrual blood showed the same expression pattern as nasal blood, the menstrual blood-specific protein matrix metallopeptidase 7 (MMP7) was not expressed in all nasal blood stain samples. Therefore, its expression levels could be used to discriminate between nasal and menstrual blood. In conclusion, real-time RT-PCR was able to identify nasal blood, although the stability of gene expression in nasal blood stains was low over time, suggesting that this assay may not be effective for older stains. Future work should examine the usefulness of this assay under various environmental conditions.

Development of an immunoassay for the differentiation of menstrual blood from peripheral blood

Forensic identification of body fluids is a crucial aspect of the discipline. To date, there are no robust tests to make a distinction between menstrual blood and peripheral blood. Past techniques have fallen short of producing clear and consistent results while present mRNA techniques are still in their infancy. The aim of this study was to develop of an accurate and rapid immunoassay based identification method. Three different targets were evaluated: matrix metalloproteinase 14 (MMP14), oestrogen receptor α (ERα), and fibrinogen. Cellular or membrane bound antigens were analyzed using immunocytochemical staining while soluble antigens were analyzed by indirect ELISA. Results showed that ERα and MMP14 are present in the endometrial cells of menstrual blood but absent in peripheral blood. At a total protein concentration of 10 μg/mL or lower, fibrinogen was detected in menstrual blood but absent in peripheral. If evaluated on a larger scale, immunoassays may prove to be beneficial in discriminating menstruum and peripheral blood.

Capillary electrophoresis of a multiplex reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction to target messenger RNA markers for body fluid identification

The analysis of cell-specific mRNA expression is a promising new method for the identification of body fluids. A number of mRNA markers have been identified for the forensically most relevant body fluids: blood, saliva, semen, vaginal secretions, and menstrual blood. Apart from a significant improvement in specificity compared to conventional protein-based methods, other important advantages of body fluid identification by mRNA profiling include the possibility of simultaneously isolating RNA and DNA from the same piece of stain and the ability to multiplex numerous RNA markers for the identification of one or several body fluids. RNA profiling can be incorporated into current DNA analysis pipelines.

Evaluation of latex agglutination tests for fibrin-fibrinogen degradation products in the forensic identification of menstrual blood

The identification of menstrual blood is important when discriminating menstruation from vaginal trauma in sexual assault cases. The aim of this study was to evaluate two fibrin-fibrinogen degradation product (FDP)-latex agglutination test kits, FDPL® Test (FDP-L) and FDP Plasma "RD" (FDP-P), for their ability to forensically identify menstrual blood. Sensitivity and specificity of the two kits were compared for menstrual blood and various body fluids, and the sensitivity of the FDP-latex agglutination test kit was also compared with that of an immunochromatographic test for human hemoglobin. The robustness of the FDP-latex agglutination test was compared with that of gene expression analysis of menstrual blood specific markers. The FDP-L kit was more sensitive than the FDP-P kit, but it cross-reacted with peripheral bloodstains from healthy volunteers. The FDP-P kit was specific for menstrual blood, with the exception of postmortem blood samples, and was not affected by other body fluids. In an FDP-negative menstrual blood sample, the sensitivity of human hemoglobin detection was lower than for FDP-positive samples and peripheral blood stains, suggesting that determination of human hemoglobin could be useful in interpreting negative results in the FDP-latex agglutination test. In menstrual blood samples incubated in wet conditions, FDP was found to be a robust marker in the identification of menstrual blood compared with mRNA markers. FDP-P testing was shown to be a suitable and highly efficient rapid screening test for the laboratory identification of menstrual blood.