Compound heterozygous variants in OTULIN are associated with fulminant atypical late-onset ORAS

OTULIN-related conditions: Report of a new case and review of the literature using GenIA

OTULIN encodes an eponymous linear deubiquitinase (DUB) essential for controlling inflammation as a negative regulator of the canonical NF-κB signaling pathway via the regulation of M1-Ub dynamics. Biallelic loss-of-function (LOF) mutations in OTULIN cause an autosomal recessive condition named Otulin-Related Autoinflammatory Syndrome (ORAS), also known as Otulipenia or AutoInflammation, Panniculitis, and Dermatosis Syndrome (AIPDS). Monoallelic OTULIN LOF, also known as OTULIN Haploinsufficiency (OHI) or Immunodeficiency 107 (IMD107), has been linked to an incompletely penetrant, dominantly inherited susceptibility to invasive Staphylococcal infections. At the same time, a recent novel ORAS-like inflammatory syndrome was described in association with a heterozygous missense mutation that appears to exert dominant negative (DN) effects. In this manuscript, we report the identification of a novel homozygous missense mutation, c.595 T > A; p.(Trp199Arg), in a Moroccan infant with an ORAS phenotype and provide experimental evidence for its pathogenicity. We go on to systematically review the literature for OTULIN-associated conditions by using the GenIA database (www.geniadb.net) to collect, extract and harmonize all clinical, laboratory and functional data for published patients and variants. Our comprehensive synthesis of genotypic, phenotypic, and mechanistic data enables a more in-depth view of the diverse mechanisms and pathways by which the OTULIN pathogenic variants may lead to human immune disease. This review may help variant classification activities and inform future variant evaluation, as well as the development of diagnostic and management guidelines. It also identifies current knowledge gaps and raises additional questions warranting future investigation.

Dominant negative OTULIN-related autoinflammatory syndrome

OTU deubiquitinase with linear linkage specificity (OTULIN) regulates inflammation and cell death by deubiquitinating linear ubiquitin chains generated by the linear ubiquitin chain assembly complex (LUBAC). Biallelic loss-of-function mutations causes OTULIN-related autoinflammatory syndrome (ORAS), while OTULIN haploinsuffiency has not been associated with spontaneous inflammation. However, herein, we identify two patients with the heterozygous mutation p.Cys129Ser in OTULIN. Consistent with ORAS, we observed accumulation of linear ubiquitin chains, increased sensitivity to TNF-induced death, and dysregulation of inflammatory signaling in patient cells. While the C129S mutation did not affect OTULIN protein stability or binding capacity to LUBAC and linear ubiquitin chains, it did ablate OTULIN deubiquitinase activity. Loss of activity facilitated the accumulation of autoubiquitin chains on LUBAC. Altered ubiquitination of LUBAC inhibits its recruitment to the TNF receptor signaling complex, promoting TNF-induced cell death and disease pathology. By reporting the first dominant negative mutation driving ORAS, this study expands our clinical understanding of OTULIN-associated pathology.

A de novo dominant-negative variant is associated with OTULIN-related autoinflammatory syndrome

OTULIN-related autoinflammatory syndrome (ORAS), a severe autoinflammatory disease, is caused by biallelic pathogenic variants of OTULIN, a linear ubiquitin-specific deubiquitinating enzyme. Loss of OTULIN attenuates linear ubiquitination by inhibiting the linear ubiquitin chain assembly complex (LUBAC). Here, we report a patient who harbors two rare heterozygous variants of OTULIN (p.P152L and p.R306Q). We demonstrated accumulation of linear ubiquitin chains upon TNF stimulation and augmented TNF-induced cell death in mesenchymal stem cells differentiated from patient-derived iPS cells, which confirms that the patient has ORAS. However, although the de novo p.R306Q variant exhibits attenuated deubiquitination activity without reducing the amount of OTULIN, the deubiquitination activity of the p.P152L variant inherited from the mother was equivalent to that of the wild-type. Patient-derived MSCs in which the p.P152L variant was replaced with wild-type also exhibited augmented TNF-induced cell death and accumulation of linear chains. The finding that ORAS can be caused by a dominant-negative p.R306Q variant of OTULIN furthers our understanding of disease pathogenesis.

OTULIN haploinsufficiency predisposes to environmentally directed inflammation

Recently, OTULIN haploinsufficiency was linked to enhanced susceptibility to Staphylococcus aureus infections accompanied by local necrosis and systemic inflammation. The pathogenesis observed in haploinsufficient patients differs from the hyperinflammation seen in classical OTULIN-related autoinflammatory syndrome (ORAS) patients and is characterized by increased susceptibility of dermal fibroblasts to S. aureus alpha toxin-inflicted cytotoxic damage. Immunological abnormalities were not observed in OTULIN haploinsufficient patients, suggesting a non-hematopoietic basis. In this research report, we investigated an Otulin+/- mouse model after in vivo provocation with lipopolysaccharide (LPS) to explore the potential role of hematopoietic-driven inflammation in OTULIN haploinsufficiency. We observed a hyperinflammatory signature in LPS-provoked Otulin+/- mice, which was driven by CD64+ monocytes and macrophages. Bone marrow-derived macrophages (BMDMs) of Otulin+/- mice demonstrated higher proinflammatory cytokine secretion after in vitro stimulation with LPS or polyinosinic:polycytidylic acid (Poly(I:C)). Our experiments in full and mixed bone marrow chimeric mice suggest that, in contrast to humans, the observed inflammation was mainly driven by the hematopoietic compartment with cell-extrinsic effects likely contributing to inflammatory outcomes. Using an OTULIN haploinsufficient mouse model, we validated the role of OTULIN in the regulation of environmentally directed inflammation.

OTULIN deficiency: focus on innate immune system impairment

OTULIN deficiency is a complex disease characterized by a wide range of clinical manifestations, including skin rash, joint welling, lipodystrophy to pulmonary abscess, and sepsis shock. This disease is mechanistically linked to mutations in the OTULIN gene, resulting in an immune disorder that compromises the body's ability to effectively combat pathogens and foreign stimuli. The OTULIN gene is responsible for encoding a deubiquitinating enzyme crucial for hydrolyzing Met1-poly Ub chains, and its dysfunction leads to dysregulated immune responses. Patients with OTULIN deficiency often exhibit an increase in monocytes, including neutrophils and macrophages, along with inflammatory clinical features. The onset of symptoms typically occurs at an early age. However, individuals with OTULIN haploinsufficiency are particularly susceptible to life-threatening staphylococcal infections. Currently, the most effective treatment for patients with OTULIN biallelic mutations involves the use of TNF-blocking agents, which target the dysregulated immune response. In conclusion, OTULIN deficiency presents a complex clinical picture with diverse manifestations, attributed to mutations in the OTULIN gene. Understanding the underlying mechanisms is crucial for developing targeted therapeutic interventions to address this challenging condition. Further research into the pathophysiology of OTULIN deficiency is essential for improving clinical management and outcomes for affected individuals.

Biallelic human SHARPIN loss of function induces autoinflammation and immunodeficiency

The linear ubiquitin assembly complex (LUBAC) consists of HOIP, HOIL-1 and SHARPIN and is essential for proper immune responses. Individuals with HOIP and HOIL-1 deficiencies present with severe immunodeficiency, autoinflammation and glycogen storage disease. In mice, the loss of Sharpin leads to severe dermatitis due to excessive keratinocyte cell death. Here, we report two individuals with SHARPIN deficiency who manifest autoinflammatory symptoms but unexpectedly no dermatological problems. Fibroblasts and B cells from these individuals showed attenuated canonical NF-κB responses and a propensity for cell death mediated by TNF superfamily members. Both SHARPIN-deficient and HOIP-deficient individuals showed a substantial reduction of secondary lymphoid germinal center B cell development. Treatment of one SHARPIN-deficient individual with anti-TNF therapies led to complete clinical and transcriptomic resolution of autoinflammation. These findings underscore the critical function of the LUBAC as a gatekeeper for cell death-mediated immune dysregulation in humans.

OTULIN-related conditions: Report of a new case and review of the literature using GenIA

OTULIN encodes an eponymous linear deubiquitinase (DUB), which through the regulation of M1-Ub dynamics, is essential for controlling inflammation as a negative regulator of the canonical NF-κB signaling pathway. Biallelic loss-of-function (LOF) mutations in OTULIN cause an autosomal recessive condition named Otulin-Related Autoinflammatory Syndrome (ORAS), also known as Otulipenia or AutoInflammation, Panniculitis, and Dermatosis Syndrome (AIPDS). Monoallelic OTULIN LOF, also known as OTULIN Haploinsufficiency (OHI) or Immunodeficiency 107 (IMD107), has been linked to an incompletely penetrant, dominantly inherited susceptibility to invasive Staphylococcal infections. At the same time, a recent novel ORAS-like inflammatory syndrome was described in association with a heterozygous missense mutation that appears to exert dominant negative effects. In this manuscript, we report the identification of a novel homozygous missense mutation, c.595T>A; p.(Trp199Arg), in a Moroccan infant with an ORAS phenotype. We go on to systematically review the literature for OTULIN-related human disease phenotypes by using the GenIA database to collect, extract and harmonize all clinical, laboratory and functional data for published patients and variants. Our comprehensive synthesis of genotypic, phenotypic, and mechanistic data enables a more in-depth view of the diverse mechanisms and pathways by which the OTULIN pathogenic variants may lead to human immune disease. This review may help variant classification activities and the drafting of diagnostic and management guidelines; but it also identifies outstanding knowledge gaps and raises additional questions for future investigation.

SADS-CoV nsp1 inhibits the STAT1 phosphorylation by promoting K11/K48-linked polyubiquitination of JAK1 and blocks the STAT1 acetylation by degrading CBP

The newly discovered zoonotic coronavirus swine acute diarrhea syndrome coronavirus (SADS-CoV) causes acute diarrhea, vomiting, dehydration, and high mortality rates in newborn piglets. Although SADS-CoV uses different strategies to evade the host's innate immune system, the specific mechanism(s) by which it blocks the interferon (IFN) response remains unidentified. In this study, the potential of SADS-CoV nonstructural proteins (nsp) to inhibit the IFN response was detected. The results determined that nsp1 was a potent antagonist of IFN response. SADS-CoV nsp1 efficiently inhibited signal transducer and activator of transcription 1 (STAT1) phosphorylation by inducing Janus kinase 1 (JAK1) degradation. Subsequent research revealed that nsp1 induced JAK1 polyubiquitination through K11 and K48 linkages, leading to JAK1 degradation via the ubiquitin-proteasome pathway. Furthermore, SADS-CoV nsp1 induced CREB-binding protein degradation to inhibit IFN-stimulated gene production and STAT1 acetylation, thereby inhibiting STAT1 dephosphorylation and blocking STAT1 transport out of the nucleus to receive antiviral signaling. In summary, the results revealed the novel mechanisms by which SADS-CoV nsp1 blocks the JAK-STAT signaling pathway via the ubiquitin-proteasome pathway. This study yielded valuable findings on the specific mechanism of coronavirus nsp1 in inhibiting the JAK-STAT signaling pathway and the strategies of SADS-CoV in evading the host's innate immune system.

Myeloid OTULIN deficiency couples RIPK3-dependent cell death to Nlrp3 inflammasome activation and IL-1β secretion

Loss-of-function mutations in the deubiquitinase OTULIN result in an inflammatory pathology termed "OTULIN-related autoinflammatory syndrome" (ORAS). Genetic mouse models revealed essential roles for OTULIN in inflammatory and cell death signaling, but the mechanisms by which OTULIN deficiency connects cell death to inflammation remain unclear. Here, we identify OTULIN deficiency as a cellular condition that licenses RIPK3-mediated cell death in murine macrophages, leading to Nlrp3 inflammasome activation and subsequent IL-1β secretion. OTULIN deficiency uncoupled Nlrp3 inflammasome activation from gasdermin D-mediated pyroptosis, instead allowing RIPK3-dependent cell death to act as an Nlrp3 inflammasome activator and mechanism for IL-1β release. Accordingly, elevated serum IL-1β levels in myeloid-specific OTULIN-deficient mice were diminished by deleting either Ripk3 or Nlrp3. These findings identify OTULIN as an inhibitor of RIPK3-mediated IL-1β release in mice.

In an experimental myocardial infarction model, L-arginine pre-intervention may exert cardioprotective effects by regulating OTULIN levels and mitochondrial dynamics

The experimental myocardial infarction (MI) model originating from isoproterenol (ISO) is frequently preferred in research due to its similarity to MI-induced damage in humans. Beneficial effects of L-arginine (L-Arg), a semi-essential amino acid, in cardiovascular diseases have been shown in many studies. This study was carried out to determine whether L-Arg pre-intervention has protective effects on heart tissue in the experimental MI model. The 28 rats used in the study were randomly divided into 4 equal groups: control, L-Arg, ISO, and L-Arg+ISO. Upon completion of all applications, cardiac markers in serum and biochemical, histopathological, and immunohistochemical examinations in cardiac tissues were performed. Cardiac markers, histopathological changes, oxidative stress, inflammation, and apoptosis were increased in the experimental MI model. In addition, administration of ISO deregulated OTULIN levels and mitochondrial dynamics in heart tissue. However, L-Arg pre-intervention showed a significant protective effect against changes in ISO-induced MI. L-Arg supplementation with cardioprotective effect may reduce the risks of possible pathophysiological processes in MI.

Cell death checkpoints in the TNF pathway

Tumor necrosis factor (TNF) plays a central role in orchestrating mammalian inflammatory responses. It promotes inflammation either directly by inducing inflammatory gene expression or indirectly by triggering cell death. TNF-mediated cell death-driven inflammation can be beneficial during infection by providing cell-extrinsic signals that help to mount proper immune responses. Uncontrolled cell death caused by TNF is instead highly detrimental and is believed to cause several human autoimmune diseases. Death is not the default response to TNF sensing. Molecular brakes, or cell death checkpoints, actively repress TNF cytotoxicity to protect the organism from its detrimental consequences. These checkpoints therefore constitute essential safeguards against inflammatory diseases. Recent advances in the field have revealed the existence of several new and unexpected brakes against TNF cytotoxicity and pathogenicity.

Role of linear ubiquitination in inflammatory responses and tissue homeostasis

Polyubiquitination is a post-translational modification involved in a wide range of immunological events, including inflammatory responses, immune cell differentiation, and development of inflammatory diseases. The versatile functions of polyubiquitination are based on different types of ubiquitin linkage, which enable various UBD (ubiquitin binding domain)-containing adaptor proteins to associate and induce distinct biological outputs. A unique and atypical type of polyubiquitin chain comprising a conjugation between the N-terminal methionine of the proximal ubiquitin moiety and the C-terminal glycine of the distal ubiquitin moiety, referred to as a linear or M1-linked ubiquitin chain, has been studied exclusively within the field of immunology because it is distinct from other polyubiquitin forms: linear ubiquitin chains are generated predominantly by various inflammatory stimulants, including tumor necrosis factor-α (TNF-α) and interleukin-1β (IL-1β), and act as a critical modulator of transient and optimal signal transduction. Moreover, accumulating evidence suggests that linear ubiquitin chains are of physiological significance. Dysregulation of linear ubiquitination triggers chronic inflammation and immunodeficiency via downregulation of linear ubiquitin-dependent nuclear factor-kappa B (NF-κB) signaling and by triggering TNF-α-induced cell death, suggesting that linear ubiquitination is a homeostatic regulator of tissue-specific functions. In this review, we focus on our current understating of the molecular and cellular mechanisms by which linear ubiquitin chains control inflammatory environments. Furthermore, we review the role of linear ubiquitination on T cell development, differentiation, and function, thereby providing insight into its direct association with maintaining the immune system.

Death by TNF: a road to inflammation

Tumour necrosis factor (TNF) is a central cytokine in inflammatory reactions, and biologics that neutralize TNF are among the most successful drugs for the treatment of chronic inflammatory and autoimmune pathologies. In recent years, it became clear that TNF drives inflammatory responses not only directly by inducing inflammatory gene expression but also indirectly by inducing cell death, instigating inflammatory immune reactions and disease development. Hence, inhibitors of cell death are being considered as a new therapy for TNF-dependent inflammatory diseases.

Human OTULIN haploinsufficiency impairs cell-intrinsic immunity to staphylococcal α-toxin

The molecular basis of interindividual clinical variability upon infection with Staphylococcus aureus is unclear. We describe patients with haploinsufficiency for the linear deubiquitinase OTULIN, encoded by a gene on chromosome 5p. Patients suffer from episodes of life-threatening necrosis, typically triggered by S. aureus infection. The disorder is phenocopied in patients with the 5p- (Cri-du-Chat) chromosomal deletion syndrome. OTULIN haploinsufficiency causes an accumulation of linear ubiquitin in dermal fibroblasts, but tumor necrosis factor receptor-mediated nuclear factor κB signaling remains intact. Blood leukocyte subsets are unaffected. The OTULIN-dependent accumulation of caveolin-1 in dermal fibroblasts, but not leukocytes, facilitates the cytotoxic damage inflicted by the staphylococcal virulence factor α-toxin. Naturally elicited antibodies against α-toxin contribute to incomplete clinical penetrance. Human OTULIN haploinsufficiency underlies life-threatening staphylococcal disease by disrupting cell-intrinsic immunity to α-toxin in nonleukocytic cells.

Cell Death-Related Ubiquitin Modifications in Inflammatory Syndromes: From Mice to Men

Aberrant cell death can cause inflammation and inflammation-related diseases. While the link between cell death and inflammation has been widely established in mouse models, evidence supporting a role for cell death in the onset of inflammatory and autoimmune diseases in patients is still missing. In this review, we discuss how the lessons learnt from mouse models can help shed new light on the initiating or contributing events leading to immune-mediated disorders. In addition, we discuss how multiomic approaches can provide new insight on the soluble factors released by dying cells that might contribute to the development of such diseases.

Deubiquitinases in cell death and inflammation

Apoptosis, pyroptosis, and necroptosis are distinct forms of programmed cell death that eliminate infected, damaged, or obsolete cells. Many proteins that regulate or are a part of the cell death machinery undergo ubiquitination, a post-translational modification made by ubiquitin ligases that modulates protein abundance, localization, and/or activity. For example, some ubiquitin chains target proteins for degradation, while others function as scaffolds for the assembly of signaling complexes. Deubiquitinases (DUBs) are the proteases that counteract ubiquitin ligases by cleaving ubiquitin from their protein substrates. Here, we review the DUBs that have been found to suppress or promote apoptosis, pyroptosis, or necroptosis.

Disorders of ubiquitylation: unchained inflammation

Ubiquitylation is an essential post-translational modification that regulates intracellular signalling networks by triggering proteasomal substrate degradation, changing the activity of substrates or mediating changes in proteins that interact with substrates. Hundreds of enzymes participate in reversible ubiquitylation of proteins, some acting globally and others targeting specific proteins. Ubiquitylation is essential for innate immune responses, as it facilitates rapid regulation of inflammatory pathways, thereby ensuring sufficient but not excessive responses. A growing number of inborn errors of immunity are attributed to dysregulated ubiquitylation. These genetic disorders exhibit broad clinical manifestations, ranging from susceptibility to infection to autoinflammatory and/or autoimmune features, lymphoproliferation and propensity to malignancy. Many autoinflammatory disorders result from disruption of components of the ubiquitylation machinery and lead to overactivation of innate immune cells. An understanding of the disorders of ubiquitylation in autoinflammatory diseases could enable the development of novel management strategies.

Linear ubiquitination in immune and neurodegenerative diseases, and beyond

Ubiquitin regulates numerous aspects of biology via a complex ubiquitin code. The linear ubiquitin chain is an atypical code that forms a unique structure, with the C-terminal tail of the distal ubiquitin linked to the N-terminal Met1 of the proximal ubiquitin. Thus far, LUBAC is the only known ubiquitin ligase complex that specifically generates linear ubiquitin chains. LUBAC-induced linear ubiquitin chains regulate inflammatory responses, cell death and immunity. Genetically modified mouse models and cellular assays have revealed that LUBAC is also involved in embryonic development in mice. LUBAC dysfunction is associated with autoimmune diseases, myopathy, and neurodegenerative diseases in humans, but the underlying mechanisms are poorly understood. In this review, we focus on the roles of linear ubiquitin chains and LUBAC in immune and neurodegenerative diseases. We further discuss LUBAC inhibitors and their potential as therapeutics for these diseases.