Effect of membrane characteristics on phase separation and domain formation in cholesterol-lipid mixtures

Amyloid-β peptide dimers undergo a random coil to β-sheet transition in the aqueous phase but not at the neuronal membrane

Mounting evidence suggests that the neuronal cell membrane is the main site of oligomer-mediated neuronal toxicity of amyloid-β peptides in Alzheimer's disease. To gain a detailed understanding of the mutual interference of amyloid-β oligomers and the neuronal membrane, we carried out microseconds of all-atom molecular dynamics (MD) simulations on the dimerization of amyloid-β (Aβ)42 in the aqueous phase and in the presence of a lipid bilayer mimicking the in vivo composition of neuronal membranes. The dimerization in solution is characterized by a random coil to β-sheet transition that seems on pathway to amyloid aggregation, while the interactions with the neuronal membrane decrease the order of the Aβ42 dimer by attenuating its propensity to form a β-sheet structure. The main lipid interaction partners of Aβ42 are the surface-exposed sugar groups of the gangliosides GM1. As the neurotoxic activity of amyloid oligomers increases with oligomer order, these results suggest that GM1 is neuroprotective against Aβ-mediated toxicity.

Membrane domain modulation of Aβ1-42 oligomer interactions with supported lipid bilayers: an atomic force microscopy investigation

Alzheimer's disease is a devastating pathology affecting an increasing number of individuals following the general rise in life expectancy. Amyloid peptide Aβ_1-42 has been identified as one of the main culprits of the disease. The peptide has been shown to have major effects on lipid membranes, including membrane fragmentation. The membrane composition has been identified as a factor that plays a pivotal role in regulating peptide/membrane interactions and several results suggest that lipid domains, or rafts, can promote peptide-induced membrane damage. In this work, we examined the effects of lipid segregation on the membrane-perturbing ability of Aβ_1-42 and an oligomeric mutant (G37C), a peptide that shares common features with the suspected toxic intermediates involved in the neurodegeneration process. Atomic force microscopy (AFM) was used to determine the impact of these peptides on the supported lipid bilayers of various compositions. In 1,2-dioleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine/1,2-dipalmitoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine/cholesterol (DOPC/DPPC/cholesterol) and DOPC/sphingomyelin/cholesterol ternary mixtures, two systems exhibiting liquid-liquid phase separations, it was shown that Aβ_1-42 and G37C exclusively aggregated on liquid-disordered-phase domains, creating large deposits and even causing membrane fragmentation for the latter composition. Cholesterol and ganglioside GM1, the two most documented lipids in the context of Alzheimer's disease, are also considered to play a crucial role in promoting detrimental interactions with amyloid peptides. We show that, in model 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC) membranes, the presence of either cholesterol or GM1 in a proportion of 10 mol%, a content supposed to lead to domain formation, favoured the association of both Aβ_1-42 and G37C, leading to a harmful membrane fragmentation. The AFM results established that the presence of domains favoured membrane perturbations induced by the amyloid peptides. It is proposed that lipid packing defects at the domain interface could act as adsorption and nucleation sites for the amyloid peptides. The more extensive bilayer perturbations induced by G37C compared to Aβ_1-42 supported this hypothesis, indicating that oligomers that cannot mature to the fibril state can present considerable toxicity.

Comment on "Cholesterol solubility limit in lipid membranes probed by small angle neutron scattering and MD simulations" by S. Garg et al., Soft Matter, 2014, 10, 9313

In a recent article, Garg et al. used neutron scattering techniques to determine the limiting amount of cholesterol which vesicles of either POPS or POPC can accommodate. This amount was called "the cholesterol solubility limit". In light of extensive literature on cholesterol phase separation in phospholipid bilayers, the way in which "solubility limit" is defined in this article and the conclusions derived are misleading and require some clarification.

Structure-based prediction of drug distribution across the headgroup and core strata of a phospholipid bilayer using surrogate phases

Solvation of drugs in the core (C) and headgroup (H) strata of phospholipid bilayers affects their physiological transport rates and accumulation. These characteristics, especially a complete drug distribution profile across the bilayer strata, are tedious to obtain experimentally, to the point that even simplified preferred locations are only available for a few dozen compounds. Recently, we showed that the partition coefficient (P) values in the system of hydrated diacetyl phosphatidylcholine (DAcPC) and n-hexadecane (C16), as surrogates of the H- and C-strata of the bilayer composed of the most abundant mammalian phospholipid, PC, agree well with the preferred bilayer location of compounds. High P values are typical for lipophiles accumulating in the core, and low P values are characteristic of cephalophiles preferring the headgroups. This simple pattern does not hold for most compounds, which usually have more even distribution and may also accumulate at the H/C interface. To model complete distribution, the correlates of solvation energies are needed for each drug state in the bilayer: (1) for the H-stratum it is the DAcPC/W P value, calculated as the ratio of the C16/W and C16/DAcPC (W for water) P values; (2) for the C-stratum, the C16/W P value; (3) for the H/C interface, the P values for all plausible molecular poses are characterized using the fragment DAcPC/W and C16/W solvation parameters for the parts of the molecule embedded in the H- and C-strata, respectively. The correlates, each scaled by two Collander coefficients, were used in a nonlinear, mass-balance based model of intrabilayer distribution, which was applied to the easily measurable overall P values of compounds in the DMPC (M = myristoyl) bilayers and monolayers as the dependent variables. The calibrated model for 107 neutral compounds explains 94% of experimental variance, achieves similar cross-validation levels, and agrees well with the nontrivial, experimentally determined bilayer locations for 27 compounds. The resulting structure-based prediction system for intrabilayer distribution will facilitate more realistic modeling of passive transport and drug interactions with those integral membrane proteins, which have the binding sites located in the bilayer, such as some enzymes, influx and efflux transporters, and receptors. If only overall bilayer accumulation is of interest, the 1-octanol/W P values suffice to model the studied set.

Limited perturbation of a DPPC bilayer by fluorescent lipid probes: a molecular dynamics study

The properties of lipid bilayer nanometer-scale domains could be crucial for understanding cell membranes. Fluorescent probes are often used to study bilayers, yet their effects on host lipids are not well understood. We used molecular dynamics simulations to investigate perturbations in a fluid DPPC bilayer upon incorporation of three indocarbocyanine probes: DiI-C18:0, DiI-C18:2, or DiI-C12:0. We find a 10-12% decrease in chain order for DPPC in the solvation shell nearest the probe but smaller effects in subsequent shells, indicating that the probes significantly alter only their local environment. We also observe order perturbations of lipids directly across from the probe in the opposite leaflet. Additionally, the DPPC headgroup phosphorus-to-nitrogen vector of lipids nearest the probe exhibits preferential orientation pointing away from the DiI. We show that, while DiI probes perturb their local environment, they do not strongly influence the average properties of "nanoscopic" domains containing a few hundred lipids.

Saturation with cholesterol increases vertical order and smoothes the surface of the phosphatidylcholine bilayer: a molecular simulation study

Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of a mono-cis-unsaturated 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-phosphatidylcholine (POPC) bilayer and a POPC bilayer containing 50mol% cholesterol (POPC-Chol50) were carried out for 200ns to compare the spatial organizations of the pure POPC bilayer and the POPC bilayer saturated with Chol. The results presented here indicate that saturation with Chol significantly narrows the distribution of vertical positions of the center-of-mass of POPC molecules and POPC atoms in the bilayer. In the POPC-Chol50 bilayer, the same moieties of the lipid molecules are better aligned at a given bilayer depth, forming the following clearly separated membrane regions: the polar headgroup, the rigid core consisting of steroid rings and upper fragments of the acyl chains, and the fluid hydrocarbon core consisting of Chol chains and the lower fragments of POPC chains. The membrane surface of the POPC-Chol50 bilayer is smooth. The results have biological significance because the POPC-Chol50 bilayer models the bulk phospholipid portion of the fiber-cell membrane in the eye lens. It is hypothesized that in the eye lens cholesterol-induced smoothing of the membrane surface decreases light-scattering and helps to maintain lens transparency.

Using spin-label electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) to discriminate and characterize the cholesterol bilayer domain

Electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spin-labeling methods make it possible not only to discriminate the cholesterol bilayer domain (CBD) but also to obtain information about the organization and dynamics of cholesterol molecules in the CBD. The abilities of spin-label EPR were demonstrated for Chol/POPC (cholesterol/1-palmitoyl-2-oleoylphosphatidylcholine) membranes, with a Chol/POPC mixing ratio that changed from 0 to 3. Using the saturation-recovery (SR) EPR approach with cholesterol analogue spin labels, ASL and CSL, and oxygen or NiEDDA relaxation agents, it was confirmed that the CBD was present in all membrane suspensions when the mixing ratio exceeded the cholesterol solubility threshold (CST). Conventional EPR spectra of ASL and CSL in the CBD were similar to those in the surrounding POPC bilayer (which is saturated with cholesterol), indicating that in both domains, cholesterol exists in the lipid-bilayer-like structures. The behavior of ASL and CSL (and, thus, the behavior of cholesterol molecules) in the CBD was compared with that in the surrounding POPC-cholesterol domain (PCD). In the CBD, ASL and CSL molecules are better ordered than in the surrounding PCD. This difference is small and can be compared to that induced in the surrounding domain by an ~10°C decrease in temperature. Thus, cholesterol molecules are unexpectedly dynamic in the CBD, which should enhance their interaction with the surrounding domain. The polarity of the water/membrane interface of the CBD is significantly greater than that of the surrounding PCD, which significantly enhances penetration of the water-soluble relaxation agent, NiEDDA, into that region. Hydrophobicity measured in the centers of both domains is similar. The oxygen transport parameter (oxygen diffusion-concentration product) measured in the center of the CBD is about ten times smaller than that measured in the center of the surrounding domain. Thus, the CBD can form a significant barrier to oxygen transport. The results presented here point out similarities between the organization and dynamics of cholesterol molecules in the CBD and in the surrounding PCD, as well as significant differences between CBDs and cholesterol crystals.

Direct visualization of phase separation induced by phenothiazine-type antipsychotic drugs in model lipid membranes

Lipid rafts constitute dynamic assemblies within a bilayer, engaged in, e.g., signal transduction, membrane trafficking and cell polarization. Despite wide interest in the process of domain formation in binary or ternary lipid model systems, only a limited number of papers are devoted to the influence of different additives on this process. In particular, works devoted to the role of drugs in raft formation are missing. In the present study, the influence of trifluoperazine, thioridazine and chlorpromazine on domain organization in raft-mimicking model membranes was investigated. Using giant unilamellar vesicles formed from an equimolar DOPC:sphingomyelin:cholesterol mixture, we found that phenothiazines elevated the number of domains, decreased their area and markedly increased the total length of the domain border. The impact of studied drugs on phase separation in the raft lipid mixture was also confirmed by Laurdan generalized polarization measurements. Alteration of domain organization induced by antipsychotic drugs was very likely to arise from selective accumulation of phenothiazines in interfacial regions between liquid ordered and liquid disordered domains. Interpretation of the results allowed us to demonstrate new aspects underlaying mechanisms of action of phenothiazine-type antipsychotic drugs. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first report demonstrating the influence of drugs on domain morphology directly visualized in giant unilamellar vesicles.

Spontaneous formation of temperature-responsive assemblies by molecular recognition of a β-cyclodextrin containing block copolymer and poly(N-isopropylacrylamide)

We report the construction of novel temperature-responsive assemblies based on a double hydrophilic block copolymer (consisting of a PEG block and a β-cyclodextrin-containing block, PEG-b-PCD) and poly(N-isopropylacrylamide) (PNIPAm). Thus formed nano-assemblies exhibit a spherical morphology and have a temperature-responsive loose core. The driving force for the formation of these assemblies was found to be the inclusion complexation interaction between the hydrophobic cavity of β-cyclodextrin and the isopropyl group of PNIPAm. The particle size of these assemblies changed reversibly in response to the external temperature change. The particle size also changed with the PNIPAm/PEG-b-PCD weight ratio. A model hydrophobic drug (indomethacin) was loaded into these assemblies with a high efficiency. An in vitro release study showed that the payload could be released in a sustained manner after an initial burst release. The release rate could be switched between high and low in an ON/OFF fashion by temperature. These results demonstrate that the nano-assemblies have high potential for applications in controlled drug delivery and biomedicine when temperature responsiveness is desired.

Instability of cholesterol clusters in lipid bilayers and the cholesterol's Umbrella effect

The instability of cholesterol clusters and the Umbrella effect of cholesterol in dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC) and dioleoylphosphatidylcholine (DOPC) lipid bilayers were investigated via atomistic molecular dynamics (MD) simulation. Cholesterol clusters in phosphatidylcholine (PC) bilayers are found to be very unstable and to readily disperse into cholesterol monomers. This instability results from the difficulty of the bilayer system in preventing water exposure to cholesterol's bulky hydrophobic bodies in a cluster. The system responds to artificially arranged cholesterol clusters in several interesting manners: (i) cholesterol clusters quickly form a "frustum" shape to reduce water penetration between cholesterol headgroups; (ii) many clusters bury themselves deeper into the bilayer interior, causing bilayer deformation; and (iii) cholesterol fluctuates rapidly, both laterally and vertically, to escape clusters. These fluctuations result in the disintegration of clusters and, in one incidence, a highly unusual flip-flop event of cholesterol across the DOPC bilayer. Our results show that cholesterols have a strong tendency to avoid forming clusters in lipid bilayers and that the fundamental cholesterol-cholesterol interaction is unfavorable. Furthermore, the radial distribution functions of cholesterol hydroxyl oxygen to various headgroup atoms of PC reveal that the PC headgroups surrounding cholesterol have a clear tendency to reorient and to extend toward cholesterol. This reorientation has a layered structure that extends 2-3 nm from the cholesterol molecule. This study demonstrates that the Umbrella hypothesis is valid in both saturated and unsaturated lipid bilayers.

Solubilization of hydrophobic guest molecules in the monoolein discontinuous QL cubic mesophase and its soft nanoparticles

Hydrophobic bioactive guest molecules were solubilized in the discontinuous cubic mesophase (QL) of monoolein. Their effects on the mesophase structure and thermal behavior, and on the formation of soft nanoparticles upon dispersion of the bulk mesophase were studied. Four additives were analyzed. They were classified into two types based on their presumed location within the lipid bilayer and their influence on the phase behavior and structure. Differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS), polarized light microscopy, cryogenic-transmission electron microscopy (cryo-TEM), and dynamic light scattering (DLS) were used for the analysis. We found that carbamazepine and cholesterol (type I molecules) likely localize in the hydrophobic domains, but close to the hydrophobic-hydrophilic region. They induce strong perturbation to the mesophase packing by influencing both the order of the lipid acyl chains and interactions between lipid headgroups. This results in significant reduction of the phase transition enthalpy, and phase separation into lamellar and cubic mesophases above the maximum loading capacity. The inclusion of type I molecules in the mesophase also prevents the formation of soft nanoparticles with long-range internal order upon dispersion. In their presence, only vesicles or sponge-like nanoparticles form. Phytosterols and coenzyme Q10 (type II molecules) present only moderate effects. These molecules reside in the hydrophobic domains, where they cannot alter the lipid curvature or transform the QL mesophase into another phase. Therefore, above maximum loading, excess solubilizate precipitates in crystal forms. Moreover, when type II-loaded QL is dispersed, nanoparticles with long-range order and cubic symmetry (i.e., cubosomes) do form. A model for the growth of the ordered nanoparticles was developed from a series of intermediate structures identified by cryo-TEM. It proposes the development of the internal structure by fusion events between bilayer segments.

Characterizing stability properties of supported bilayer membranes on nanoglassified substrates using surface plasmon resonance

Supported bilayer membranes (SBMs) formed on solid substrates, in particular glass, provide an ideal cell mimicking model system that has been found to be highly useful for biosensing applications. Although the stability of the membrane structures is known to determine the applicability, the subject has not been extensively investigated, largely because of the lack of convenient methods to monitor changes of membrane properties on glass in real time. This work reports the evaluation of the stability properties of a series of SBMs against chemical and air damage by use of surface plasmon resonance spectroscopy and nanoglassified gold substrates. Seven SBMs composed of phosphatidylcholine and DOPC+, including single-component, mixed, protein-reinforced SBMs (rSBMs) and protein-tethered bilayer membranes (ptBLMs), are studied. The stability properties under various conditions, especially the effects of surfactants, organic solvents, and dehydration damage on the bilayers, are compared. PC membranes are found to be easily removed from the glassy surfaces using relatively low concentrations of the surfactants, while DOPC+ is markedly more stable toward nonionic surfactant. DOPC+ membranes also demonstrated remarkable air stability while PC films exhibited considerable damage from dehydration. Doping of cholesterol does not improve PC's stability against SDS and Triton but changes the lipid membrane packing enough to protect against dehydration damage. Although rSBMs and ptBLMs improve air stability to a certain degree, they are still quite susceptible to significant damage/removal from ionic and nonionic surfactants at lower concentrations. Overall, DOPC+ has noted higher stability on glass, likely due to the favorable electrostatic interaction between the silicate surface and the lipid headgroup, making it a good candidate for application. Nanoglassy SPR proves to be an attractive platform capable of rapidly screening film stability in real-time, providing critical information for future work using supported membranes for sensing applications.

Cationic amphiphiles and the solubilization of cholesterol crystallites in membrane bilayers

Cationic amphiphiles used for transfection can be incorporated into biological membranes. By differential scanning calorimetry (DSC), cholesterol solubilization in phospholipid membranes, in the absence and presence of cationic amphiphiles, was determined. Two different systems were studied: 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (POPC)+cholesterol (1:3, POPC:Chol, molar ratio) and 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-[phospho-l-serine] (POPS)+cholesterol (3:2, POPS:Chol, molar ratio), which contain cholesterol in crystallite form. For the zwitterionic lipid POPC, cationic amphiphiles were tested, up to 7 mol%, while for anionic POPS bilayers, which possibly incorporate more positive amphiphiles, the fractions used were higher, up to 23 mol%. 1,2-dioleoyl-3-trimethylammonium-propane (DOTAP) and DOTAP in methyl sulfate salt form (DOTAPmss) were found to cause a small decrease on the enthalpy of the cholesterol transition of pure cholesterol aggregates, possibly indicating a slight increase on the cholesterol solubilization in POPC vesicles. With the anionic system POPS:Chol, the cationic amphiphiles dramatically change the cholesterol crystal thermal transition, indicating significant changes in the cholesterol aggregates. For structural studies, phospholipids spin labeled at the 5th or 16th carbon atoms were incorporated. In POPC, at the bilayer core, the cationic amphiphiles significantly increase the bilayer packing, decreasing the membrane polarity, with the cholesterol derivative 3 beta-[N-(N',N'-dimethylaminoethane)-carbamoyl]-cholesterol (DC-chol) displaying a stronger effect. In POPS and POPS:Chol, DC-chol was also found to considerably increase the bilayer packing. Hence, exogenous cationic amphiphiles used to deliver nucleic acids to cells can change the bilayer packing of biological membranes and alter the structure of cholesterol crystals, which are believed to be the precursors to atherosclerotic lesions.

Low cholesterol solubility in DODAB liposomes

Through the analysis of the ESR spectra of spin labels, we investigated the thermotropic properties of dioctadecyl dimethylammonium bromide (DODAB) liposomes, in low and high ionic strength, with different cholesterol contents. The cationic lipid gel phase is stabilized by the presence of ions, the bilayer having a higher gel/fluid transition temperature (Tm) in high ionic strength. As found for low ionic strength [Benatti, C.R., Feitosa, E., Fernandez, R.M., Lamy-Freund, M.T., 2001. Structural and thermal characterization of dioctadecyldimethylammonium bromide dispersions by spin labels. Chem. Phys. Lipids, 111, 93-104], high salt DODAB membranes also present a clear coexistence of the two phases around Tm. Cholesterol solubility in DODAB bilayers seems to be rather low, as the coexistence of DODAB and cholesterol-rich domains can be clearly detected by spin labels, for cholesterol concentration as low as 15 mol% of the total lipid. For lower cholesterol concentrations, the effect of cholesterol in DODAB bilayers is similar to that in phospholipids. For concentrations at or above 45 mol% of cholesterol, spin labels do not detect the coexistence of structurally different domains.

Thermodynamic characterization of the prevailing molecular interactions in mixed floating monolayers of phospholipids and usnic acid

The investigation of the characteristics of mixed floating monolayers of phospholipids and usnic acid (UA), an active metabolite from lichens, can provide valuable information on how to prepare stable liposomes that could serve as carriers of UA for therapeutic proposes. The present paper is concerned with the thermodynamic analysis of the behavior of Langmuir monolayers formed by mixing different phospholipids (dibehenoylphosphatidylcholine, DBPC, dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine, DPPC, and dioleoylphosphatidylcholine, DOPC) and UA at varied molar fractions. Relevant thermodynamic parameters such as excess areas, excess free energies and free energy of mixing were derived from the surface pressure data obtained from compression measurements performed in a Langmuir trough. For the largest lateral pressure examined (25 mN/m), negative values of the excess free energy were found only for the DOPC/UA monolayer, which should be the most stable of them. Based on the calculated values of the free energy of mixing, we note that the DBPC/UA and DPPC/UA systems present the best mixed character at low pressures and when the molar fraction of the UA is 0.5; at that relative concentration and at low values of the external pressure, the UA molecules can better mix and interact with the phospholipid molecules. The compression isotherms for mixed monolayers show no visible transitions, exhibiting a more organized phase that corresponds to a negative free energy of mixing. We have established that the most stable monolayers were those corresponding to DOPC/UA mixtures with a UA molar fraction of 0.75.

Phase behavior of lipid monolayers containing DPPC and cholesterol analogs

We investigate the miscibility phase behavior of lipid monolayers containing a wide variety of sterols. Six of the sterols satisfy a definition from an earlier study of "membrane-active sterols" in bilayers (cholesterol, epicholesterol, lathosterol, dihydrocholesterol, ergosterol, and desmosterol), and six do not (25-hydroxycholesterol, lanosterol, androstenolone, coprostanol, cholestane, and cholestenone). We find that monolayers containing dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine mixed with membrane-active sterols generally produce phase diagrams containing two distinct regions of immiscible liquid phases, whereas those with membrane-inactive sterols generally do not. This observation establishes a correlation between lipid monolayers and bilayers. It also demonstrates that the ability to form two regions of immiscibility in monolayers is not one of the biophysical attributes that explains cholesterol's predominance in animal cell membranes. Furthermore, we find unusual phase behavior for dipalmitoyl phosphatidylcholine monolayers containing 25-hydroxycholesterol, which produce both an upper and a lower miscibility transition. The lower transition correlates with a sharp change of slope in the pressure-area isotherm.