A porcine model for teaching surgical cricothyridootomy

Everything but the squeal: a guide for head and neck surgery training on the live porcine model

PURPOSE

The porcine model has been demonstrated to be cost-effective for head and neck surgery training. There is no literature describing the porcine head and neck anatomy. The purpose of this study is to provide a porcine surgical guide for training head and neck residents.

METHODS

Five head and neck dissections were performed under general anesthesia on the Large White pig model in the animal facilities of the University Hospital Fundación Jiménez. Sessions were photographed, and reference anatomical measurements were taken.

RESULTS

The sternum-chin distance (x = 15.80 cm, σ = 0.44), chin-chin distance (x = 11.10 cm, σ = 2.30), prelaryngeal musculature length (x = 10.30 cm, σ = 1.92) and supraomohyoid triangle area (x = 7.07 cm², σ = 3.91) were among the measurements obtained. The porcine head and neck anatomy was detailed.

CONCLUSIONS

Head and neck porcine anatomy was thoroughly described, with emphasis on the similarities with human anatomy. The porcine model is capable of simulating human anatomy for surgery training.

Evaluation of a Novel Three-Dimensional Emergency Cricothyrotomy Task Trainer

Background

Emergency cricothyrotomy is a critical, yet infrequently performed and time-sensitive procedure that requires practice in order to be reliably completed in emergent airway situations. Many physicians never have the opportunity to practice this rarely performed but highly impactful procedure during their training due to a lack of an affordable, high-fidelity training model. In this study, the educational impact and realism of a new synthetic cricothyrotomy training model (high-fidelity emergency cricothyrotomy, HiFEC) were compared with those of a standard porcine explant model.

Methodology

A total of thirty-one attending physicians from four medical specialties were recruited on a volunteer basis to participate in a cricothyrotomy simulation workshop. Participants were randomly assigned to complete the initial workshop using one of the two models but had the opportunity to practice on both trainers. Pre- and post-workshop comfort level as well as the realism of the models were surveyed using questionnaires and evaluated using a five-point Likert scale.

Results

Improvements in self-reported comfort levels were seen in both the porcine group (p = 0.0014) and HiFEC group (p = 0.0036) as well as overall (p < 0.001). The realism rating of both training models was similar with a median score of 4 on a five-point Likert scale. When comparing the cost of conducting our workshop using these models, the synthetic model saved over $650.

Conclusions

Given the similar realism of the models and the improvement in participant comfort level, the synthetic HiFEC trainer is an effective and more affordable alternative training model for emergency cricothyrotomies.

Feasibility of ovine and porcine models for simulation training in parotid surgery and facial nerve dissection

PURPOSE

To assess and compare the feasibility of using ovine and porcine models as surgical simulation training tools for otolaryngology trainees performing parotid surgery and facial nerve dissection.

METHODS

Trainees performed parotid surgery (total parotidectomy, retrograde facial nerve dissection and facial nerve grafting) on an ovine and porcine model. Participants completed a 22-item, five-point Likert scale questionnaire on each model, assessing three validation domains; face validity (FV), global content validity (GCV) and task-specific content validity (TSCV). Data were prospectively collected and analysed using descriptive and non-parametric statistics.

RESULTS

Twelve trainees completed two consecutive parotidectomies and facial nerve dissections on an ovine and porcine model. Twenty-four dissections were completed. Validation questionnaires were completed for each model by all trainees. The ovine model achieved median validation threshold scores (≥ 4/5) for all aspects of FV, GCV and TSCV. The porcine model did not achieve validation threshold scores for any aspect of the validation questionnaire. Comparison of the ovine and porcine model demonstrated that the ovine model was statistically superior to the porcine model across most validation criteria excluding realistic appearance of skin, identification and ligation of the trans-oral parotid duct and facial nerve grafting.

CONCLUSION

Adequate experience with facial nerve dissection during parotid surgery is vital to ensuring good outcomes and avoiding complications. This study is the first to compare validity of two animal models for simulation training in parotid surgery and facial nerve dissection. We have validated the ovine model as a useful tool for simulation training and advocate its incorporation into otolaryngology training programmes.

Training Residents to Perform Tracheotomy Using a Live Swine Model

A tracheotomy is a basic operation for the otorhinolaryngologist. According to reports from the United States and from our experience, there has been a steady decline in the number of tracheostomies performed by young resident doctors. Due to concerns for inadequate training of young residents, we developed a tracheotomy course consisting of a lecture, a live animal model, and questionnaires. The aim of this study was to evaluate the effectiveness of this training model. Twelve volunteer resident doctors joined the training course and, following a lecture by a senior surgeon, practiced tracheostomies with a 4-month-old female swine weighing 32 kg. We recorded the procedure time, blood loss, and complications. The doctors' procedural competence was recorded using questionnaires before and after the training. All operations were completed within 30 minutes, and the blood loss was less than 5 ml. There were no serious acute complications. After the training, young residents had improved scores on surgical landmark recognition, overall procedural competence, confidence in performing the procedure, and understanding of the surgical procedures and equipment (P < .05). Our findings reveal that an animal model-based tracheotomy course is an effective training model for young resident doctors.

Surgical model pig ex vivo for venous dissection teaching in medical schools

PURPOSE

To investigate a method for development of surgical skills in medical students simulating venous dissection in surgical ex vivo pig model.

METHODS

Prospective, analytical, experimental, controlled study with four stages: selection, theoretical teaching, training and assessment. Sample of 312 students was divided into two groups: Group A - 2nd semester students; Group B - students of 8th semester. The groups were divided into five groups of 12 students, trained two hours per week in the semester. They set up four models to three students in each skill station assisted by a monitor. Teaching protocol emergency procedures training were applied to venous dissection, test goal-discursive and OSATS scale.

RESULTS

The pre-test confirmed that the methodology has not been previously applied to the students. The averages obtained in the theoretical evaluation reached satisfactory parameters in both groups. The results of applying OSATS scale showed the best performance in group A compared to group B, however, both groups had satisfactory medium.

CONCLUSION

The method was enough to raise a satisfactory level of skill both groups in venous dissection running on surgical swine ex vivo models.