Relevance of micrometastases detected by reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction for melanoma recurrence: systematic review and meta-analysis

A Systematic Quality Evaluation of Meta-Analyses Related to Plastic Surgery

INTRODUCTION

Meta-analyses are considered to be an important source of evidence. This review aims to systematically assess the quality of meta-analyses addressing topics in plastic surgery.

METHODS

Electronic databases were selected for systematic review. A search was performed focusing on communication addresses containing terms related to plastic surgery, and detailed inclusion criteria were used. Related data were extracted and recorded according to the items of the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) statement. To assess the quality of the meta-analyses over time, studies published before and after PRISMA were evaluated.

RESULTS

A total of 116 meta-analyses were included. There was 1 study that was fully in compliance with the PRISMA items. The main flaws impacting the overall quality of the included studies were in the following areas: structured summary (48%), protocol and registration (2%), full electronic search strategy (35%), risk of bias in individual studies (41%), additional analyses (27%), risk of bias within studies (47%), additional analysis (30%), and funding (47%). Study quality was evaluated using relative risks (RR) with a 95% confidence interval (95% CI); this revealed that there were few significant improvements in adherence to the PRISMA statement after its release, especially in selection (RR, 1.80; 95% CI, 1.08-2.99), results of individual studies (RR, 2.88; 95% CI, 1.41-5.91), synthesis of results (RR, 3.08; 95% CI, 1.32-7.17), and funding (RR, 1.65; 95% CI, 1.21-2.24).

CONCLUSIONS

There have been measurable improvements in the quality of meta-analyses over recent years. However, several serious deficiencies remain according to the PRISMA statement. Future reviewers should pay more attention to not only reporting the main findings but also encouraging compliance with proper standards.

[Evidence-based practices published in Brazil: identification and analysis of their types and methodological approches]

This is an integrative review of Brazilian studies on evidence-based practices (EBP) in health, published in ISI/JCR journals in the last 10 years. The aim was to identify the specialty areas that most accomplished these studies, their foci and methodological approaches. Based on inclusion criteria, 144 studies were selected. The results indicate that most EBP studies addressed childhood and adolescence, infectious diseases, psychiatrics/mental health and surgery. The predominant foci were prevention, treatment/rehabilitation, diagnosis and assessment. The most used methods were systematic review with or without meta-analysis, protocol review or synthesis of available evidence studies, and integrative review. A strong multiprofessional expansion of EBP is found in Brazil, contributing to the search for more selective practices by collecting, recognizing and critically analyzing the produced knowledge. The study also contributes to the analysis itself of ways to do research and new research possibilities.

[Brazilian gamma detection device for sentinel lymph node biopsy]

OBJECTIVE

To test the effectiveness of an intra-operative gamma detection Brazilian device (IPEN) on sentinel lymph node biopsy (SLNB) procedures.

METHODS

Forty melanoma or breast cancer patients with indication for undergoing SLNB were studied. Lymphoscintigraphy was done 2 to 24 hours prior to surgery. Lymphatic mapping with vital dye and gamma detection were performed intraoperatively. For gamma detection Neoprobe 1500 was used followed by IPEN (equipment under test) in the first 20 patients and for the remaining half IPEN was used first to verify its ability to locate the sentinel node (SN). Measurements were taken from the radiopharmaceutical product injection site, from SN (in vivo and ex vivo) and from background. It was recorded if the SN was stained or not and if it was found easily by surgeon.

RESULTS

There were 33 (82.5%) breast cancer and 7 (17.5%) melanoma patients. Ages varied from 21 to 68 year-old (median age of 46). Sex distribution was 35 (87.5%) women and 5 (12.5%) men. Sentinel node was found in all but one patient. There was no statistical difference between the reasons ex vivo/ background obtained with the measures of both equipments (p=0, 2583-ns). The SN was easily found by the surgeon with both devices.

CONCLUSION

The SLNB was successfully performed using either equipment. It was possible to do SLNB with the Brazilian device developed by IPEN without prejudice for the patient.

Laparoscopic Sentinel Node Biopsy in Cervical Cancer Using a Combined Detection: 5–Years Experience

BACKGROUND

To evaluate the feasibility after 5 years experience of a laparoscopic sentinel node (SN) procedure with combined radioisotopic and patent blue labeling in patients with cervical cancer.

METHODS

Sixty-seven patients (median age 48.9 years) with cervical cancer underwent a laparoscopic SN procedure using an endoscopic gamma probe, after both radioactive and patent blue injections. After the procedure, all the patients underwent complete laparoscopic pelvic/para-aortic lymphadenectomy.

RESULTS

At least one SN was identified in 57 patients (85.1%). According to the Stage, the SN identification rate was 91.2% in early-stage cervical cancer and 78.5% in locally advanced cervical cancer. The mean number of SN was 2.3 per patient (range 1-5). A total of 129 SNs were removed. Lymph node metastasis involvement was identified in the 20 SNs (15.5%) from 14 patients (24.6%). Nine of the 14 patients had at least one macrometastases, three patients presented micrometastases in H&S, and two patients presented isolated single cells. Six patients presented a pelvic non-SN involvement including two patients whose SNs were uninvolved. The false-negative SNs rate was 12.5% (two patients out of 16). Both patients have locally advanced cervical cancer.

CONCLUSION

This study confirms that laparoscopic SN detection with a combination of radiocolloid and patent blue is accurate in patients with early cervical cancer to assess pelvic lymph node status.

Clinical significance of lympho vascular space involvement and lymph node micrometastases in early-stage cervical cancer: A retrospective case-control surgico-pathological study

OBJECTIVE

Several studies have shown that lympho vascular space involvement (LVSI) and lymph node micrometastases (LNmM) may be risk factors for recurrence in early-stage cervical cancer with no apparent lymph node metastases. We performed a retrospective case-control study to reassess whether the presence of lymph node micrometastases and LVSI is predictive of subsequent recurrence following surgical resection of early-stage cervical cancer.

METHODS

In a series of 292 patients diagnosed with early cervical cancer and treated by the same surgical procedure (laparoscopic-vaginal radical hysterectomy) during the same time period, two paired series were selected. The first series consisted of 26 cases who recurred in a median time of 36.8 months and the second series were 26 cases matched for age, histological sub-type, surgico-pathological stage and maximal tumor diameter, who did not recur after a median follow-up of 122 months. Sections taken from the hysterectomy specimens were reassessed for LVSI. All the lymph node blocks which have initially been considered as uninvolved were submitted to serial sectioning. Immunohistochemical staining using anti-cytokeratins AE1 and AE3 was used for identifying LNmM.

RESULTS

LVSI was twice more frequent and LNmM ten-fold more frequent in the group of patients who recurred: 20/26 (77%) versus 9/26 (35%) and 11/26 (42%) versus 1/26 (4%) respectively. The relative risk of recurrence is 2.64 (1.67-5.49, P < 0.01) in the presence of LVSI and 2.44 (1.58-3.78, P < 0.01) in the presence of LNmM. All the patients with LNmM were LVSI positive. At bivariate analysis, the true LNmM (deposits more than 200 um in size) was the only independent risk factor.

CONCLUSIONS

LNmM is an important risk factor of tumor recurrence in patients with early cervical cancer with no apparent lymph node metastases. LNmM seems to occur only in LVSI positive tumors. These data may lead to improve management of early-stage cervical cancer to reduce the risk of recurrence in those cases.

Recorrência em pacientes portadores de melanoma cutâneo submetidos a biópsia de linfonodo sentinela: seguimento mediano de 37 meses

OBJETIVO: A biópsia de linfonodo sentinela (BLS) representa um avanço na cirurgia oncológica para o microestadiamento do melanoma. Apresentamos nossa experiência dando ênfase para a recorrência. MÉTODO: A BLS foi realizada em 133 pacientes portadores de melanoma cutâneo localizado envolvendo linfocintilografia, mapeamento linfático e detecção gama intra-operatórios em todos os pacientes. O exame histopatológico foi realizado por HE e imunohistoquímica (IHC). RESULTADOS: Encontrou-se LS em 128 pacientes (96,2%). Micrometástase foi diagnosticada em 20 pacientes (15,6%). Houve nove recorrências, sendo quatro no grupo com LS negativo (108 pacientes). Neste grupo, houve uma recorrência sistêmica e três (2,8%) na região linfática de drenagem (falso negativo). No grupo com LS positivo (20 pacientes) ocorreram cinco recorrências. Houve diferença significativa de recorrência entre os grupos, tendo sido menor no grupo LS negativo (p=0,0048). Através de análise de regressão logística univariada a ulceração (p=0,029) e a positividade do LS (p=0,003) apresentaram significância estatística como fatores de risco. Porém, apenas a positividade do LS manteve singificância na análise multivariada (p=0,024). O seguimento mediano foi de 37 meses. CONCLUSÕES: Pacientes com LS positivo apresentam recorrência significativamente maior que pacientes com LS negativo. O índice de falso negativo foi de 2,8% e os pacientes não apresentaram seqüelas o que permite considerar a BLS como procedimento seguro para o microestadiamento do melanoma cutâneo.

J, Lewin S, Marone MMS. Pesquisa do linfonodo sentinela em pacientes com melanoma: experiência com fitato marcado com Tecnécio-99m e revisão da literatura

FUNDAMENTOS: A progressão linfática do melanoma maligno habitualmente se inicia pelo linfonodo sentinela (LNS), cuja análise histopatológica permite predizer o acometimento de toda a cadeia. OBJETIVO: O trabalho tem por objetivo descrever a utilização do 99mTc-Fitato na detecção do LNS em pacientes com melanoma maligno, revisando as indicações e informações fornecidas por sua biópsia. MÉTODO: A pesquisa de LNS foi realizada por meio da linfocintilografia com 99mTc-Fitato em 92 pacientes com melanoma (54,0±14,3 anos). Após 18-24 horas, 88 pacientes foram submetidos à localização intra-operatória com detector portátil, seguida da ressecção e análise histopatológica do LNS. RESULTADOS: A linfocintilografia permitiu a identificação do LNS em todos os estudos, havendo detecção intra-operatória em 98,8% dos casos. O LNS estava acometido em 23 pacientes (26%). O valor preditivo negativo foi de 100% e não se observaram reações adversas pelo uso do 99mTc-Fitato. CONCLUSÃO: A detecção do LNS pode ser realizada com diferentes radiofármacos, incluindo o 99mTc-Fitato, que apresenta vantagens de custo e disponibilidade no Brasil. A pesquisa de LNS resulta em maior acurácia e menor morbidade no estadiamento de pacientes com melanoma maligno