Associations of Community Water Lead Concentrations with Hemoglobin Concentrations and Erythropoietin-Stimulating Agent Use among Patients with Advanced CKD

Synergistic susceptibility to environmental lead toxicity in chronic kidney disease

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

While high levels of lead exposure, as occurs accidentally or occupationally, can cause toxicity across multiple organ systems, the hazard of commonly encountered levels of lead in the environment remains unresolved. Challenges to researching the health effects of lead include its complex interplay with renal function, rendering analyses at risk of unaccounted confounding, and the likely small effect size of environmental levels of exposure. While children are known to be disproportionately susceptible to lead toxicity, resulting in appropriately more stringent regulatory surveillance for those under 5 years old, emerging evidence suggests that those with chronic kidney disease (CKD) similarly are at a greater risk. This review summarizes the role of environmental lead toxicity as a potential cause and consequence of CKD.

RECENT FINDINGS

Whether environmental lead exposure causes CKD remains debatable, with little recent research advancing the conflicting, mostly cross-sectional, analyses from years ago. However, an emerging body of evidence suggests that CKD increases the susceptibility to lead toxicity. Higher circulating lead levels and lower urinary excretion result in greater lead accumulation in CKD, with simultaneous greater risk of clinically meaningful disease. Recent studies suggest that levels of lead found commonly in the United States drinking water supply, and currently permissible by the Environmental Protection Agency, associate with hematologic toxicity in those with advanced CKD. Whether environmental lead contamination may have additional negative health impact among this at-risk population, including cardiovascular and neurocognitive disease, warrants further study.

SUMMARY

The underlying pathophysiology of kidney disease synergizes the susceptibility to environmental lead toxicity for those with CKD. Low levels of exposure, as found commonly in the United States water supply, may have adverse health impact in CKD. Further research will be needed to determine if more stringent environmental regulations are warranted to protect the health of all.

Household Water Lead and Hematologic Toxic Effects in Chronic Kidney Disease

Importance

The consequences of low levels of environmental lead exposure, as found commonly in US household water, have not been established.

Objective

To examine whether commonly encountered levels of lead in household water are associated with hematologic toxicity among individuals with advanced kidney disease, a group known to have disproportionate susceptibility to environmental toxicants.

Design, Setting, and Participants

Cross-sectional analysis of household water lead concentrations and hematologic outcomes was performed among patients beginning dialysis at a Fresenius Medical Care outpatient facility between January 1, 2017, and December 20, 2021. Data analysis was performed from April 1 to August 15, 2023.

Exposure

Concentrations of lead in household water were examined in categorical proportions of the Environmental Protection Agency's allowable threshold (15 μg/L) and continuously.

Main Outcomes and Measures

Hematologic toxic effects were defined by monthly erythropoiesis-stimulating agent (ESA) dosing during the first 90 days of incident kidney failure care and examined as 3 primary outcomes: a proportion receiving maximum or higher dosing, continuously, and by a resistance index that normalized to body weight and hemoglobin concentrations. Secondarily, hemoglobin concentrations for patients with data prior to kidney failure onset were examined, overall and among those with concurrent iron deficiency, thought to increase gastrointestinal absorption of ingested lead.

Results

Among 6404 patients with incident kidney failure (male, 4182 [65%]; mean [SD] age, 57 [14] years) followed up for the first 90 days of dialysis therapy, 12% (n = 742) had measurable lead in household drinking water. A higher category of household lead contamination was associated with 15% (odds ratio [OR], 1.15 [95% CI, 1.04-1.27]) higher risk of maximum monthly ESA dosing, 4.5 (95% CI, 0.8-8.2) μg higher monthly ESA dose, and a 0.48% (95% CI, 0.002%-0.96%) higher monthly resistance index. Among patients with pre-kidney failure hemoglobin measures (n = 2648), a higher household lead categorization was associated with a 0.12 (95% CI, -0.23 to -0.002) g/dL lower hemoglobin concentration, particularly among those with concurrent iron deficiency (multiplicative interaction, P = .07), among whom hemoglobin concentrations were 0.25 (95% CI, -0.47 to -0.04) g/dL lower.

Conclusion

The findings of this study suggest that levels of lead found commonly in US drinking water may be associated with lead poisoning among susceptible individuals.

Do we underestimate risk of cardiovascular mortality due to lead exposure?

BACKGROUND

Studies using data from the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey-III (NHANES-III) have demonstrated significant prospective associations between blood lead levels and increased mortality. Bone lead represents cumulative lead burden and thus is a better biomarker for assessing chronic impacts, but its in vivo assessment requires special K-x-ray fluorescence (KXRF) instrumentation. Our team recently developed an algorithm predicting bone lead levels from a combination of blood lead levels, age and other socioeconomic and behavioral variables. We examined the associations of our algorithm-estimated bone lead levels and mortality in NHANES-III.

METHODS

We included 11,628 adults followed up to December 31, 2019. Estimated tibia lead and patella lead levels were calculated using our prediction algorithms. We used survey-weighted Cox proportional hazards models to compute hazard ratios (HRs) and 95 % confidence intervals (CIs).

RESULTS

During the median follow-up of 26.8 years, 4900 participants died (mortality rate = 1398 per 100,000 adults/year). Geometric means (95 % CIs) of blood lead, predicted tibia lead, and predicted patella lead were 2.69 μg/dL (2.54, 2.84), 6.73 μg/g (6.22, 7.25), and 16.3 μg/g (15.9, 16.8), respectively. The associations for all-cause mortality were similar between blood lead and bone lead. However, the associations for cardiovascular mortality were much greater with predicted bone lead markers compared to blood lead: for comparing participants at the 90th vs. 10th percentiles of exposure, HR = 3.32 (95 % CI: 1.93-5.73) for tibia lead, 2.42 (1.56-3.76) for patella lead, 1.63 (1.25-2.14) for blood lead. The population attributable fractions for cardiovascular disease mortality if everyone's lead concentrations were declined to the 10th percentiles were 45.8 % (95 % CI: 28.1-59.4) for tibia lead, 33.1 % (18.1-45.8) for patella lead, and 22.8 % (10.4-33.8) for blood lead.

CONCLUSIONS

These findings suggest that risk assessment for cardiovascular mortality based on blood lead levels may underestimate the true mortality risk of lead exposure.

US drinking water quality: exposure risk profiles for seven legacy and emerging contaminants

BACKGROUND

Advances in drinking water infrastructure and treatment throughout the 20th and early 21st century dramatically improved water reliability and quality in the United States (US) and other parts of the world. However, numerous chemical contaminants from a range of anthropogenic and natural sources continue to pose chronic health concerns, even in countries with established drinking water regulations, such as the US.

OBJECTIVE/METHODS

In this review, we summarize exposure risk profiles and health effects for seven legacy and emerging drinking water contaminants or contaminant groups: arsenic, disinfection by-products, fracking-related substances, lead, nitrate, per- and polyfluorinated alkyl substances (PFAS) and uranium. We begin with an overview of US public water systems, and US and global drinking water regulation. We end with a summary of cross-cutting challenges that burden US drinking water systems: aging and deteriorated water infrastructure, vulnerabilities for children in school and childcare facilities, climate change, disparities in access to safe and reliable drinking water, uneven enforcement of drinking water standards, inadequate health assessments, large numbers of chemicals within a class, a preponderance of small water systems, and issues facing US Indigenous communities.

RESULTS

Research and data on US drinking water contamination show that exposure profiles, health risks, and water quality reliability issues vary widely across populations, geographically and by contaminant. Factors include water source, local and regional features, aging water infrastructure, industrial or commercial activities, and social determinants. Understanding the risk profiles of different drinking water contaminants is necessary for anticipating local and general problems, ascertaining the state of drinking water resources, and developing mitigation strategies.

IMPACT STATEMENT

Drinking water contamination is widespread, even in the US. Exposure risk profiles vary by contaminant. Understanding the risk profiles of different drinking water contaminants is necessary for anticipating local and general public health problems, ascertaining the state of drinking water resources, and developing mitigation strategies.

Multimodal approaches for inequality in kidney care: turning social determinants of health into opportunities

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Kidney disease is associated with major health and economic burdens worldwide, disproportionately carried by people in low and middle socio-demographic index quintile countries and in underprivileged communities. Social determinants such as education, income and living and working conditions strongly influence kidney health outcomes. This review synthesised recent research into multimodal interventions to promote kidney health equity that focus on the social determinants of health.

RECENT FINDINGS

Inequity in kidney healthcare commonly arises from nationality, race, sex, food insecurity, healthcare access and environmental conditions, and affects kidney health outcomes such as chronic kidney disease progression, dialysis and transplant access, morbidity and mortality. Multimodal approaches to addressing this inequity were identified, targeted to: patients, families and caregivers (nutrition, peer support, financial status, patient education and employment); healthcare teams (workforce, healthcare clinician education); health systems (data coding, technology); communities (community engagement); and health policy (clinical guidelines, policy, environment and research).

SUMMARY

The engagement of diverse patients, families, caregivers and communities in healthcare research and implementation, as well as clinical care delivery, is vital to counteracting the deleterious effects of social determinants of kidney health.

Geospatial Assessment of Racial/Ethnic Composition, Social Vulnerability, and Lead Water Service Lines in New York City

BACKGROUND

The state of New York expects to receive $ 115  million in 2022 alone from the U.S. Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act to support the replacement of lead water service lines.

OBJECTIVES

Our objective was to determine the number and proportion of potential lead water service lines across New York City (NYC) and to evaluate the association between census tract-level racial/ethnic composition, housing vulnerability, and child lead exposure vulnerability with service line type (Potential Lead, Unknown) for n = 2,083 NYC tracts.

METHODS

We conducted a descriptive analysis assessing water service line material recorded in the NYC Department of Environmental Protection's Lead Service Line Location Coordinates database. We used conditional autoregressive Bayesian Poisson models to assess the relative risk [RR; median posterior estimates, and 95% credible interval (CrI)] of service line type per 20% higher proportion of residents in a given racial/ethnic group and per higher housing vulnerability and child lead exposure vulnerability index scores corresponding to the interquartile range. We also evaluated the associations in flexible natural cubic spline models.

RESULTS

Out of 854,672 residential service line records, 136,891 (16.0%) were Potential Lead, and 227,443 (26.6%) were Unknown. In fully adjusted models, higher proportions of Hispanic/Latino residents and higher child lead exposure vulnerability were associated with Potential Lead service lines in flexible spline models and linear models [RR = 1.15 (95% CrI: 1.11, 1.21) and RR = 1.11 (95% CrI: 1.02, 1.20), respectively]. Associations were modified by borough; Potential Lead service lines were associated with higher proportions of non-Hispanic White and non-Hispanic Asian residents in the Bronx and Manhattan, and with higher proportions of non-Hispanic Black residents in Queens.

DISCUSSION

NYC has a high number of Potential Lead and Unknown water service lines. Communities with a high proportion of Hispanic/Latino residents and those with children who are already highly vulnerable to lead exposures from numerous sources are disproportionately impacted by Potential Lead service lines. These findings can inform equitable service line replacement across New York state and NYC. https://doi.org/10.1289/EHP12276.

Environmental Exposures and Kidney Disease

Accumulating evidence underscores the large role played by the environment in the health of communities and individuals. We review the currently known contribution of environmental exposures and pollutants on kidney disease and its associated morbidity. We review air pollutants, such as particulate matter; water pollutants, such as trace elements, per- and polyfluoroalkyl substances, and pesticides; and extreme weather events and natural disasters. We also discuss gaps in the evidence that presently relies heavily on observational studies and animal models, and propose using recently developed analytic methods to help bridge the gaps. With the expected increase in the intensity and frequency of many environmental exposures in the decades to come, an improved understanding of their potential effect on kidney disease is crucial to mitigate potential morbidity and mortality.

Susceptibility to Environmental Heavy Metal Toxicity among Americans with Kidney Disease

Background

The consequences of low levels of environmental heavy metal exposure, as found widely in the United States, in those with impaired renal function remain underexplored.

Methods

We examined the cross-sectional association of indices of renal function with lead and cadmium levels in blood and urine among National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES) participants. We used the 1999-2002 cycle, which included measures of cystatin C, in order to quantify renal function most precisely and defined chronic kidney disease (CKD) as an estimated glomerular filtration rate (eGFR) <60 ml/min per 1.73 m².

Results

In weighted and adjusted analyses of 5638 participants, lead levels were 0.23 (95% CI, 0.03 to 0.42) μg/dl higher among participants with CKD, and 0.05 (95% CI, 0.01 to 0.09) μg/dL higher per 10 ml/min per 1.73 m² lower eGFR. Cadmium levels were 0.02 (95% CI, 0.01 to 0.03) μg/L higher per 10 ml/min per 1.73 m² lower eGFR. Black race significantly modified the association of lower eGFR with higher circulating lead levels (P interaction <0.001). A 10 ml/min per 1.73 m² lower eGFR was associated with a 0.13 (95% CI, 0.06 to 0.21) μg/dl higher lead level among Black participants compared with 0.03 (95% CI, -0.04 to 0.11) μg/dl higher level among White participants. Among the 1852 participants with urinary metal measurements, despite higher circulating levels, those with CKD had significantly lower urinary lead levels (-0.16 [95% CI, -0.30 to -0.01] ng/ml) and urinary lead/creatinine ratios (-0.003 [95% CI, -0.004 to -0.001]).

Conclusions

CKD is associated with higher blood lead levels, particularly among Blacks, and simultaneously, lower urinary lead levels, consistent with the hypothesis that CKD confers a state of heighted susceptibility to heavy metal environmental exposure by reducing its elimination. Given that low levels of exposure remain highly prevalent in the United States, further efforts to protect patients with CKD from heavy metal toxicity may be warranted.

Levels of Lead in Residential Drinking Water and Iron Deficiency among Patients with End Stage Kidney Disease

Background

Although those with kidney disease may have heightened susceptibility to heavy metal toxicity, whether low levels of drinking water lead contamination have clinical consequence is unknown.

Methods

Given that lead toxicity is known to associate with iron deficiency, we merged data from the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) Safe Drinking Water Information and United States Renal Data Systems to examine whether municipal 90th percentile drinking water lead levels associate with iron deficiency among incident dialysis patients. Iron deficiency was defined across thresholds of transferrin saturation (<10% and 20%) and ferritin (<100 and <200 ng/ml), and simultaneous transferrin saturation <20% and ferritin <200 ng/ml, all obtained within 30 days of dialysis initiation. The average 90th percentile of drinking water lead samples per patient city of residence over a 5-year period before dialysis initiation was examined at the <1 μg/L level of detection, and at the 25th, 50th, and 100th percentile of the EPA's actionable level (15 μg/L).

Results

Among 143,754 incident ESKD patients, those in cities with drinking water lead contamination had 1.06 (95% CI, 1.03 to 1.09), 1.06 (95% CI, 1.02 to 1.10), and 1.07 (95% CI, 1.03 to 1.11) higher adjusted odds of a transferrin saturation <20%, ferritin <200 ng/ml, and simultaneous transferrin saturation <20% and ferritin <200 ng/ml, respectively. These associations were apparent across the range of lead levels found commonly in the United States and were significantly greater among Black patients (multiplicative interaction P values between lead and race <0.05).

Conclusions

Even exposure to low levels of lead contamination, as commonly found in US drinking water, may have adverse hematologic consequence in patients with advanced kidney disease. These associations are particularly evident among Black people and, although consistent with other environmental injustices facing minorities in the United States, might reflect a greater susceptibility to lead intoxication.

Staying on track to achieve racial justice in kidney care

The nephrology community is leading by example to address harms of racialized medical practices in clinical algorithms by removing the long-standing inclusion of a Black race modifier in equations to estimate kidney function in patients⁷.

Efforts to ensure equitable access to transplantation and equitable outcomes for all transplant patients will remain unrealized unless we acknowledge and counter systemic, institutional and interpersonal racism^6,8.

Associations between racial disparities in the built environment, such as the integrity of community water sources, can be linked with racial disparities between Black and white patients diagnosed with kidney failure⁹.