Connective tissue attachment to periodontally diseased roots after citric acid demineralization

Effect of scaling on the invasion of oral microorganisms into dentinal tubules including the response of pulpal cells-an in vitro study

Objectives

To investigate how scaling affects the penetration of microorganisms into dentinal tubules, how pulpal cells seeded into the pulp cavity respond to bacterial challenge, and how penetration and inflammatory response may depend on the bacterial composition.

Materials and methods

Root canals of 102 extracted human teeth underwent shaping and cleaning. Half of the teeth were subjected to scaling and root planing, the other half remained untreated. Teeth were exposed to either Streptococcus gordonii and Actinomyces oris or S. gordonii and Porphyromonas gingivalis for 10 weeks. Bacterial invasion was assessed in a depth of 1 mm to the root surface. Human pulpal cells were seeded into the cavities to assess the expression of interleukin-8 (IL-8), monocyte chemoattractant protein-1 (MCP-1), and matrix metalloproteinase-3 (MMP-3) by real-time polymerase chain reaction and immunoassay.

Results

The percentage of teeth with bacteria detected in dentine was higher when teeth received scaling than when they were untreated: 66.6% versus 44.4% when exposed to A. oris/S. gordonii, and 50% versus 25% when exposed to P. gingivalis/S. gordonii (p = 0.043). Scaling had no impact on IL-8 and MMP-3 expression in pulpal cells. P. gingivalis/S. gordonii caused higher levels of IL-8, MCP-1, and MMP-3 than A. oris/S. gordonii (p = 0.003, p = 0.011, p = 0.037).

Conclusion

Scaling supports the penetration of bacteria into the dentine of extracted human teeth. P. gingivalis may affect the immune response in pulpal cells.

Clinical relevance

Root surface debridement with hand instruments may facilitate bacterial penetration. Other kinds of mechanical instrumentation in this experimental setting should be investigated.

Comparing the effects of root surface scaling with ultrasound instruments and Er,Cr:YSGG laser

There are several studies done to show the comparability of laser scaling and root planing with routine methods. The most suitable wavelengths for such an application are reported as 2,940 and 2,780 nm. The superficial interactions of the current wavelength with root surface is investigated in this study to compare the crater and crack formation during the procedures between ultrasound and Er,Cr:yttrium-scandium-gallium garnet (YSGG; 2,780 nm) laser-treated teeth. Thirty human teeth with calculus on their root surface, which were extracted because of the severe periodontitis, were selected for this interventional in vitro study. Calculus area were divided into two equal parts: One of them was prepared for Er,Cr:YSGG (Biolase, Waterlase, USA) laser irradiation and the other one for ultrasound treatment (Dentsply cavitron, DENTSPLY International, USA). The Er,Cr:YSGG laser was specified as follows: pulse energy = 50 mJ, power = 1 W, wavelength = 2,780 nm, pulse repetition rate = 20 pulse per seconds, tip length = 6 mm, and tip diameter = 600 microm. Nineteen of the laser samples (95%) and eight of ultrasound ones (40%) out of 20 samples in each group had craters showing a statistical significant difference (p < 0.001). The number and depth of these craters are also evaluated. Thirteen samples of the laser cases (65%) and all samples of the ultrasound group showed cracks with significant differences (p = 0.008). In addition, the number and width of cracks in both groups are reported. As a general conclusion, the laser-treated samples show more craters but less cracks.

New composite endpoints to assess efficacy in periodontal therapy clinical trials

BACKGROUND

Clinical attachment level (CAL) and bone height (radiographic or clinical) are two well-accepted endpoint measures for periodontal clinical trials; however, neither one has been shown to be more predictive of long-term success than the other. We propose using a composite endpoint analysis combining clinical and radiological parameters to assess the beneficial effects on both hard and soft tissues following periodontal therapy using a single statistical test. To address this need, two composite endpoint alternatives are offered as a yardstick for clinical success; each includes the improvement in CAL and either improvement in linear bone growth or percent bone fill.

METHODS

The data for composite endpoint analyses were derived from a clinical trial evaluating two concentrations of recombinant human platelet-derived growth factor-BB (rhPDGF-BB) with beta-tricalcium phosphate (beta-TCP) compared to beta-TCP plus buffer as follows: group I, beta-TCP + 0.3 mg/ml rhPDGF-BB; group II, beta-TCP + 1.0 mg/ml rhPDGF-BB; and group III, beta-TCP + buffer. The construction of composite endpoints was based on the greatest values for change, accepted by the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA), for clinical attachment level (DeltaCAL), mean change in radiographic linear bone gain (LBG), and mean radiographic percent bone fill (%BF), with the following dual standards defining a successful clinical result: CAL gain > or =2.67 mm and radiographic LBG > or =1.1 mm at 6 months and CAL gain > or =2.67 mm and radiographic %BF > or =14.1% at 6 months.

RESULTS

Group I (beta-TCP + 0.3 mg/ml rhPDGF-BB) demonstrated statistically significant differences from group III (active control) for both composite endpoints. For the CAL/LBG composite endpoint, 61.7% of sites in group I versus 30.4% of sites in group III met the composite endpoint benchmarks (P <0.001). For the CAL/%BF composite endpoint, 70% of sites in group I versus 44.6% of sites in group III met the composite endpoint benchmarks (P = 0.003). A non-significant trend was observed for group II versus group III with 37.9% (P = 0.20) and 55.2% (P = 0.13) of sites meeting the CAL/LBG and CAL/%BF composite endpoints, respectively. These results are further emphasized by findings demonstrating a low correlation between the individual efficacy endpoints (DeltaCAL and %BF; DeltaCAL and LBG) for each of the three treatment groups.

CONCLUSIONS

Composite endpoints are advantageous in periodontal clinical trials where no single efficacy endpoint has been established as the most important. A composite endpoint, combining outcome measures of both hard and soft tissue components of the periodontium, may be preferable for assessing efficacy of periodontal regenerative therapies. Two composite endpoints are offered to meet this need.

Platelet-derived growth factor stimulates bone fill and rate of attachment level gain: results of a large multicenter randomized controlled trial

BACKGROUND

Growth factors are generally accepted to be essential mediators of tissue repair via well-established mechanisms of action that include stimulatory effects on angiogenesis and cellular proliferation, ingrowth, differentiation, and matrix biosynthesis. The aim of this study was to evaluate in a large-scale, prospective, blinded, and randomized controlled clinical trial the safety and effectiveness of purified recombinant human platelet-derived growth factor (rhPDGF-BB) mixed with a synthetic beta-tricalcium phosphate (beta-TCP) matrix for the treatment of advanced periodontal osseous defects at 6 months of healing.

METHODS

Eleven clinical centers enrolled 180 subjects, each requiring surgical treatment of a 4 mm or greater intrabony periodontal defect and meeting all inclusion and exclusion criteria. Subjects were randomized into one of three treatment groups: 1) beta-TCP + 0.3 mg/ml rhPDGF-BB in buffer; 2) beta-TCP + 1.0 mg/ml rhPDGF-BB in buffer; and 3) beta-TCP + buffer (active control). Safety data were assessed by the frequency and severity of adverse events. Effectiveness measurements included clinical attachment levels (CAL) and gingival recession (GR) measured clinically and linear bone growth (LBG) and percent bone fill (% BF) as assessed radiographically by an independent centralized radiology review center. The area under the curve (AUC), an assessment of the rate of healing, was also calculated for CAL measurements. The surgeons, clinical and radiographic evaluators, patients, and study sponsor were all masked with respect to treatment groups.

RESULTS

CAL gain was significantly greater at 3 months for group 1 (rhPDGF 0.3 mg/ml) compared to group 3 (beta-TCP + buffer) (3.8 versus 3.3 mm; P = 0.032), although by 6 months, this finding was not statistically significant (P = 0.11). This early acceleration of CAL gain led to group 1 exhibiting a significantly greater rate of CAL gain between baseline and 6 months than group 3 as assessed by the AUC (68.4- versus 60.1-mm weeks; P = 0.033). rhPDGF (0.3 mg/ml)-treated sites also had significantly greater linear bone gain (2.6 versus 0.9 mm, respectively; P < 0.001) and percent defect fill (57% versus 18%, respectively; P < 0.001) than the sites receiving the bone substitute with buffer at 6 months. There was less GR at 3 months in group 1 compared to group 3 (P = 0.04); at 6 months, GR for group 1 remained unchanged, whereas there was a slight gain in gingival height for group 3 resulting in comparable GR. There were no serious adverse events attributable to any of the treatments.

CONCLUSIONS

To our knowledge, this study is the largest prospective, randomized, triple-blinded, and controlled pivotal clinical trial reported to date assessing a putative periodontal regenerative and wound healing therapy. The study demonstrated that the use of rhPDGF-BB was safe and effective in the treatment of periodontal osseous defects. Treatment with rhPDGF-BB stimulated a significant increase in the rate of CAL gain, reduced gingival recession at 3 months post-surgery, and improved bone fill as compared to a beta-TCP bone substitute at 6 months.

Position Paper: Periodontal Regeneration

Untreated periodontal disease leads to tooth loss through destruction of the attachment apparatus and tooth-supporting structures. The goals of periodontal therapy include not only the arrest of periodontal disease progression,but also the regeneration of structures lost to disease where appropriate. Conventional surgical approaches (e.g., flap debridement) continue to offer time-tested and reliable methods to access root surfaces,reduce periodontal pockets, and attain improved periodontal form/architecture. However, these techniques offer only limited potential towards recovering tissues destroyed during earlier disease phases. Recently, surgical procedures aimed at greater and more predictable regeneration of periodontal tissues and functional attachment close to their original level have been developed, analyzed, and employed in clinical practice. This paper provides a review of the current understanding of the mechanisms, cells, and factors required for regeneration of the periodontium and of procedures used to restore periodontal tissues around natural teeth. Targeted audiences for this paper are periodontists and/or researchers with an interest in improving the predictability of regenerative procedures. This paper replaces the version published in 1993.

Er:YAG Laser in Defocused Mode for Scaling of Periodontally Involved Root Surfaces: An In Vitro Pilot Study

BACKGROUND

The Er:YAG laser may be used on periodontally involved teeth in combination with conventional periodontal therapy in order to improve the efficacy of root instrumentation. The aim of this study was to compare the effect of hand instrumentation on root surfaces of periodontally involved teeth with Er:YAG laser application.

METHODS

Thirty freshly extracted, non-carious, single-rooted, periodontally diseased human teeth from adult humans with advanced periodontal disease were used in this study. The teeth were divided into three groups of 10 specimens each. Group A was treated with scaling and root planing (SRP) with curets only (control). In group B, the root surfaces were scaled with curets and then lased with an Er:YAG laser (wavelength 2.94 microm). A handpiece with a water spray was used in non-contact mode (defocused) at a distance of 1 cm from root surface. Laser parameters were set at energy of 100 to 200 mJ/pulse, with 10 Hz of frequency. In group C, the root surfaces were lased only with power settings 250 to 300 mJ/pulse and 10 Hz frequency. An epon-araldite plastic embedding technique was used for light microscopic investigation.

RESULTS

Histologic findings showed significant differences between the test and control sites. In control sites, after hand instrumentation, the surface was smooth, without a cementum layer, and the dentin layer presented opened tubules. Defects on the dentin layer were also present along root surfaces. In the test sites (B, C) root surfaces revealed no thermal damage; no cracking or tissue carbonization were observed. The superficial layers of lased surfaces appeared smooth and melted without alterations.

CONCLUSION

Based on these findings, it appears that it may be feasible to use the Er:YAG laser for root instrumentation without prior root planing if the proper parameters are followed.

Loss of tooth substance during root planing with various periodontal instruments: an in vitro study

Ultrasonic and power-driven instrumentation is gaining in significance as an acceptable alternative to manual periodontal root treatment. Some question whether they do not remove too much tooth substance. Various ultrasonic scalers, hand instruments and two power-driven systems were compared by assessing the loss of tooth substance due to root instrumentation. Quantitative analysis of this effect of the instruments used was performed on 20 freshly extracted, non-periodontally involved, large human molars. In the first study, 40 specimens were randomly assigned to four groups of treatment: combined use of ultrasonic scaler and Periopolisher diamond-coated inserts (US-POL), hand instruments (MANUAL), Perioplaner-Periopolisher system (PPL-POL) and Periokit ultrasonic-designed scalers (PERIOKIT). The second study involved two treatment groups, ultrasonic scaler alone and hand instruments, each allocated with 20 teeth (small root fragments). An unpaired two-tailed t test was carried out for both studies to compare the average weight loss of root substance with the modes of instrumentation. The level of significance was set at p<or=0.05. The overall results of the first and second experimental trials did not reveal obvious differences in weight loss between the manual, ultrasonic or power-driven root treatments. Based on the results of these two comparative studies, the power-driven inserts or the various ultrasonic scalers tested did not remove more tooth substance than conventional hand instruments. They may thus be a useful alternative for the debridement of root surfaces.

Efficacy of Chemical Root Surface Modifiers in the Treatment of Periodontal Disease. A Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

Periodontal regeneration has been a relentless goal of the periodontist. Perhaps the oldest and most frequently attempted type of regeneration has involved chemical modification of the root surface. Varying results from histological and clinical studies have created controversy about the clinical effectiveness of root surface decalcification.

RATIONALE

This systematic review assesses the efficacy of root surface biomodification through the use of citric acid, tetracycline, or ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA) in patients with chronic periodontitis.

FOCUSED QUESTION

Does the use of chemical root declacification result in effective periodontal regeneration and improved clinical outcomes in patients with chronic periodontitis?

SEARCH PROTOCOL

The Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews; Database of Abstracts of Reviews of Effectiveness; Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials; American College of Physicians Journal Club, evidence-based MEDLINE journals; and National Center for Biotechnology Information PubMed Journals, as well as Dogpile, Google, and Copernic search engines were screened. Hand searches were performed on the Journal of Clinical Periodontology, Journal of Periodontology, Journal of Periodontal Research, and Periodontology 2000. Searches were performed for relevant clinical trials published through September 25, 2002.

SELECTION CRITERIA

INCLUSION CRITERIA

Histological and clinical studies evaluating the effects of citric acid, tetracycline, or EDTA on root surfaces of patients with chronic periodontitis were considered for inclusion.

EXCLUSION CRITERIA

Studies evaluating extracellular matrix proteins (e.g., fibronectin), enamel matrix proteins (e.g., amelogenins), or other proteins or growth factors applied to the root surface were not included.

DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS

Primary outcome measures included changes in connective tissue attachment, cementogenesis, clinical attachment levels, probing depths, and gingival recession. Secondary outcome measures included changes in bone level, gingival inflammation, and plaque levels. Results for continuous outcome measures for primary variables (clinical attachment levels, probing depths, and recession) were expressed as mean differences or standardized mean differences. Clinical attachment levels and reduction in probing depth were evaluated using meta-analysis. All papers were rated according to methodological strength of evidence.

MAIN RESULTS

1. Thirty-four studies incorporating a total patient population of 575 were analyzed: 26 for citric acid, 5 for tetracycline, and 3 for EDTA treatment. 2. Four of 8 human histological studies reported regeneration with the use of citric acid. Only 1 of 18 clinical studies reported attachment gain. 3. Of the 5 studies examined using tetracycline, 1 histological study and 1 clinical study reported attachment gain. 4. No regeneration was reported in the 3 studies evaluating the use of EDTA. 5. Meta-analysis performed on 28 clinical trials did not show any significant effects of acid root treatment on attachment level gains or probing depth.

REVIEWER'S CONCLUSIONS

1. Evidence to date suggests that the use of citric acid, tetracycline, or EDTA to modify the root surface provides no benefit of clinical significance to regeneration in patients with chronic periodontitis. 2. The best method for ascertaining the clinical efficacy of acid-treated root regeneration would be to conduct a randomized clinical trial with sufficient statistical power that is supported by quantitative histological evaluation. 3. The majority of the studies that evaluated the regenerative potential of root surface modifiers were observational in nature; therefore, the value of conclusions reached in this manuscript must be carefully considered.

Effect of ER:YAG and diode laser irradiation on the root surface: morphological and thermal analysis

BACKGROUND

The aim of the present study was to compare the effects of Er:YAG and diode laser treatments of the root surface on intrapulpal temperature after scaling and root planing with hand instruments.

METHODS

Fifteen extracted single-rooted teeth were scaled and root planed with hand instruments. The teeth were divided into 3 groups of 5 each and irradiated on their buccal and lingual surfaces: group A: Er:YAG laser, 2.94 microm/100 mJ/10 Hz/30 seconds; group B: diode laser, 810 nm/1.0 W/0.05 ms/30 seconds; group C: diode laser, 810 nm/1.4 W/0.05 ms/30 seconds. The temperature was monitored by means of a type T thermocouple (copper-constantan) positioned in the pulp chamber to assess pulpal temperature during and before irradiation. Afterwards, the specimens were longitudinally sectioned, and the buccal and lingual surfaces of each root were analyzed by scanning electron microscopy.

RESULTS

In the Er:YAG laser group, the thermal analysis revealed an average temperature of -2.2 +/- 1.5 degrees C, while in the diode laser groups, temperatures were 1.6 +/- 0.8 degrees C at 1.0 W and 3.3 +/- 1.0 degrees C at 1.4 W. Electronic micrographs revealed that there were no significant morphological changes, such as charring, melting, or fusion, in any group, although the specimens were found to be more irregular in the Er:YAG laser group.

CONCLUSIONS

The application of Er:YAG and diode lasers at the utilized parameters did not induce high pulpal temperatures. Root surface irregularities were more pronounced after irradiation with an Er:YAG laser than with a diode laser.

Treatment of plaque-induced gingivitis, chronic periodontitis, and other clinical conditions

The inflammatory components of plaque induced gingivitis and chronic periodontitis can be managed effectively for the majority of patients with a plaque control program and non-surgical and/or surgical root debridement coupled with continued periodontal maintenance procedures. Some patients may need additional therapeutic procedures. All of the therapeutic modalities reviewed in this position paper may be utilized by the clinician at various times over the long-term management of the patient's periodontal condition.

Pluronic polyol effects on human gingival fibroblast attachment and growth

BACKGROUND

Enhanced speed of human gingival fibroblast (HGF) spreading and attachment, as affected by ionic bonding interactions, may facilitate cell orientation and subsequent collagen synthesis to promote early wound healing. The purpose of this study was to determine the in vitro effects of pluronic polyols, a family of widely used surfactants currently used as drug carriers for antibiotic, anti-inflammatory, and anti-neoplastic agents, on the attachment and growth of human gingival fibroblasts (HGF) to dentin and plastic surfaces using established tissue culture techniques.

METHODS

Plastic culture wells containing Eagle's minimal essential media (EMEM) with 10% fetal calf serum and Pluronic F-68 or F-127 in concentrations from 1.2 x 10(-2) to 1.2 x 10(-10) M were incubated with HGF and run in replicates of ten. Attached cells were quantified by measuring the optical density of methylene blue-stained cells. Additional experiments were conducted using human dentin sections as a substrate and Pluronic F-68 or F-127 at a concentration of 1.2 x 10(-8) M. In these experiments, HGF were stained with acridine orange and quantified per unit area of dentin by fluorescence microscopy.

RESULTS

Attachment and growth of HGF to both plastic and dentin were significantly increased over serum controls by very low concentrations of Pluronic F-68 and F-127 by 30 minutes, with attachment reaching a plateau at 2 hours.

CONCLUSIONS

Pluronic polyols, a family of widely used surfactants, in very low dosages may be beneficial in early postsurgical wound healing by facilitating early attachment and enhancing the growth rate of human gingival fibroblasts.

Root substance removal with Er:YAG laser radiation at different parameters using a new delivery system

BACKGROUND

The recently introduced Er:YAG laser radiation appears to be a promising alternative in treating dental hard tissue due to its thermo-mechanical ablation properties and the lack of thermal side effects. The present in vitro study attempted to evaluate the use of Er:YAG laser radiation in combination with a specially developed delivery system in removing calculus from root surfaces.

METHODS

Fifty extracted anterior teeth, premolars and molars, were divided into 2 groups of 25 each with (group A) and without (group B) subgingival calculus. Source of radiation was an Er:YAG laser device with a wavelength of 2.94 microm, in the infrared optical spectrum, a pulse duration of 250 ns, and a pulse repetition rate of 15 pps. In each group, 6 teeth were irradiated with 300 laser pulses either at 60 mJ, 80 mJ, 100 mJ, or 150 mJ. The samples were continually moved linearly using a computer numeric controlled device. The volumetric evaluation of root substance removal was performed with a 3-dimensional laser scanning system (100,000 surface points per sample, accuracy: 5 microm) and special image analyzing software. A scanning electron microscopic (SEM) observation was performed to assess the laser induced ultrastructural changes on the root surfaces. Statistical analysis was carried out with ANOVA followed by the Scheff*e test and with regression analysis according to Pearson-Bravais at a level of significance of 5% (P <0.05).

RESULTS

The linear measurement of substance removal on calculus samples (group A) revealed average depths between 174.38 (+/-16.13) microm and 501.85 (+/-111.01) microm. Defect depths on the teeth without calculus (group B) ranged from 37.78 (+/-14.03) microm to 484.44 (+/-80.63) microm. The SEM observation of laser-treated root surfaces revealed no signs of thermal damage; e.g., melting, fusion, or cracking.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of the present study showed that a substance removal with Er:YAG laser radiation at lower energy densities is comparable, in effect, to that after conventional root surface instrumentation with curets. The results seem to indicate that calculus removal can be selectively done using lower radiation energies. Considering the favorable results of the SEM investigation, the use of the Er:YAG laser in periodontal therapy may be possible in the future.

Clinical comparison of bioabsorbable barriers with non-resorbable barriers in guided tissue regeneration in the treatment of human intrabony defects

The purpose of the study was to compare the effects of guided tissue regeneration (GTR) with expanded polytetrafluoroethylene (ePTFE) non-resorbable barriers and polylactic acid bioabsorbable barriers in humans with intrabony defects due to periodontitis. Ten patients presented with 2 intrabony defects each. Mucoperiosteal flaps were performed. One of the defects was randomly assigned for placement of the ePTFE barrier over the roots and alveolar bone and the other defect with placement of the polylactic acid barrier. A minimum of 9 months after barrier placement, surgical reentry was performed. The data were evaluated by the Wilcoxon matched-pairs signed-ranks test and the Fisher exact test. Treatment with both types of barriers produced significant changes from baseline for all parameters, except in the ePTFE group for the amount of bony crest resorption (P = 0.055) and in the polylactic acid group for increased recession (P = 0.109). The results showed no significant differences between the barriers for any parameters: probing depth reduction (polylactic acid 2.60 +/- 1.90, ePTFE 2.80 +/- 1.40; P = 1.000); attachment gain (polylactic acid 1.40 +/- 1.43, ePTFE 1.90 +/- 1.29; P = 0.336); increased recession (polylactic acid 0.80 +/- 1.40, ePTFE 1.10 +/- 0.99; P = 0.531); amount of vertical bone fill (polylactic acid 1.60 +/- 1.84, ePTFE 2.00 +/- 2.49; P = 0.984); bony crest resorption (polylactic acid -1.30 +/- 1.06, ePTFE -1.30 +/- 1.63; P = 1.000); depth of bony defect reduction (polylactic acid 2.90 +/- 1.20, ePTFE 3.30 +/- 1.70; P = 0.750); width of bony defect reduction (polylactic acid 2.20 +/- 1.23, ePTFE 2.20 +/- 1.23; P = 0.875); or volumetric changes (polylactic acid 33.50 +/- 19.70 microl, ePTFE 34.00 +/- 18.40 microl; P = 0.750).

Tetracycline demineralization of dentin: the effects of concentration and application time

The current investigation was initiated to study the effect concentration and application time has on the rate of tetracycline demineralization of dentin. Buccal and lingual surfaces of extracted bovine molars were ground to a smooth flat dentin surface using wetted silicon carbide discs. Standardized depressions were made in the dentin surface with a #909-055 diamond round wheel. Fresh tetracycline HCl (TTC-HCl) (Flavine Int. Inc.) solutions, i.e., 0, 25, 50, 75, 100, 125 and 150 mg/ml were prepared. A 30% citric acid solution was used as a positive control. The pH of each solution was recorded. 7 microl of each solution were pipetted into a depression and remained undisturbed for 1, 3, or 5 min. At the end of each application time period a fresh #3 cotton pellet was placed in the depression, once every 20 s for 1 min, to soak up the solution. The 3 pellets were placed in a 2.00 ml of 18 M omega H2O sample. As a measure of the rate of demineralization, the parts per million calcium (ppm Ca++) found in each sample were determined using atomic absorption spectrophotometry. Two-way analysis of variance was used to determine effects of TTC-HCI concentration and time on the rate of demineralization. No significant differences were found in the mean ppm Ca++ released at 1-, 3- and 5-min application times for 0, 25, or 50 mg/ml TTC. No significant differences were found in the mean ppm Ca++ released (i) between 3- and 5-min application times for 75, 100, 125 and 150 mg/ml TTC-HCl solutions and (ii) between 75, 100, 125 and 150 mg/ml TTC-HCl solutions within either the 3- or 5-min application times. The mean ppm Ca++ released at 3- and 5-min application times for 75, 100, 125 and 150 mg/ml TTC-HCI solutions were all significantly greater than the respective readings at the 1-min application time. The mean ppm Ca++ recorded for the 30% citric acid solution for all 3 application times were 3 to 5.5 x greater than the highest mean ppm Ca++ recording for TTC-HCl. The results of this study show that a 3-min application time of 75 mg/ml TTC-HCl solution is equally as effective at demineralizing dentin as is higher concentrations and/or longer application times, but was far less effective than a 30% citric acid solution.

Short-term tissue response to potential root-end filling materials in infected root canals

The short-term tissue responses to two potential root-end filling materials, a light-cured glass ionomer cement (Vitrebond) and a reinforced zinc oxide-eugenol cement (Kalzinol), were compared with that to amalgam using a previously devised experimental model. In 24 premolar teeth of beagle dogs (47 roots), a collection of endodontic pathogenic bacteria was first inoculated into the root canals to induce periradicular lesions. On each root, an apicoectomy was performed and root-end cavities prepared to receive fillings of each material. The teeth and surrounding jaw were removed after 2 weeks (23 roots) and 1 week (24 roots); they were then prepared for histological examination. The tissue response to amalgam fillings after 2 weeks and 1 week was marked by moderate or severe inflammation on all roots, and extended to < or = 0.5 mm or > 0.5 mm in 15 out of 16 roots. In contrast, after 2 weeks, the majority of roots filled with Kalzinol showed little or moderate inflammation, while the tissue response to Vitrebond was the best of the three materials, and was also the least extensive. After 1 week, the overall best tissue response was with Vitrebond, followed by Kalzinol. The differences between materials for both time periods with either none or few inflammatory cells when compared with that with either moderate or severe inflammation were not statistically significant (P < 0.02). However, the differences between materials for both time periods with no inflammation or inflammation extending < 0.2 mm when compared with that with inflammation extending > 0.2 mm (< or = 0.5 mm or > 0.5 mm) were statistically significant (P < 0.01). Apart from amalgam, in which healing was marked by the persistence of a localized focus of inflammation adjacent to the root-end filling, even though there were intersample variations, there was little overall difference in the temporal and qualitative healing response to Vitrebond and Kalzinol. Both Vitrebond and Kalzinol have potential as root-end filling materials, as the tissue response was considerably more favourable than that to amalgam even in the short-term.

Periodontal regeneration around natural teeth

1. Evidence is conclusive (Table 2) that periodontal regeneration in humans is possible following the use of bone grafts, guided tissue regeneration procedures, both without and in combination with bone grafts, and root demineralization procedures. 2. Clinically guided tissue regeneration procedures have demonstrated significant positive clinical change beyond that achieved with debridement alone in treating mandibular and maxillary (buccal only) Class II furcations. Similar data exist for intraosseous defects. Evidence suggests that the use of bone grafts or GTR procedures produce equal clinical benefit in treating intraosseous defects. Further research is necessary to evaluate GTR procedures compared to, or combined with, bone grafts in treating intraosseous defects. 3. Although there are some data suggesting hopeful results in Class II furcations, the clinical advantage of procedures combining present regenerative techniques remains to be demonstrated. Additional randomized controlled trials with sufficient power are needed to demonstrate the potential usefulness of these techniques. 4. Outcomes following regenerative attempts remain somewhat variable with differences in results between studies and individual subjects. Some of this variability is likely patient related in terms of compliance with plaque control and maintenance procedures, as well as personal habits; e.g., smoking. Variations in the defects selected for study may also affect predictability of outcomes along with other factors. 5. There is evidence to suggest that present regenerative techniques lead to significant amounts of regeneration at localized sites on specific teeth. However, if complete regeneration is to become a reality, additional stimuli to enhance the regenerative process are likely needed. Perhaps this will be accomplished in the future, with combined procedures that include appropriate polypeptide growth factors or tissue factors to provide additional stimulus.

Periradicular healing in response to Diaket root-end filling material with and without tricalcium phosphate

The healing of the periradicular tissues was evaluated when the polyvinyl resin Diaket with and without tricalcium phosphate was used as surgical root-end filling material. Non-surgical root canal treatment was performed on 56 mandibular premolar roots in mongrel dogs. Following root-end resection, root-end cavity preparations were filled with Diaket, the comparative material, or Diaket in combination with tricalcium phosphate, the experimental material. Postsurgically, healing of the tissues adjacent to the filling materials and in the surrounding surgical site were evaluated at 30 and 60 days. There was virtually no statistically significant difference between the experimental and comparative group at or within the 30- or 60-day period with regard to inflammation, connective tissue formation, root-end encapsulation, cementum formation, or bone apposition. Findings suggest that cementogenesis occurred over both materials. The overall healing of the periradicular tissues was favourable.

Does root surface conditioning with citric acid delay healing?

Effects of topical citric acid application on tissue maturation was studied in standardized periodontal defects in 6 beagle dogs. Following elevation of facial mucoperiosteal flaps, fenestration defects, 3 mm in diameter, were made through the cortical bone and recessed 0.5 mm into the dentin of maxillary canines. 1 defect in each dog was conditioned with a saturated solution of citric acid for 3 min and then rinsed with saline. Control defects in contralateral teeth were treated with saline only for the same length of time. The defects were covered with an expanded polytetrafluoroethylene membrane and the flaps repositioned and sutured. 14 days postsurgery, healing appeared more advanced along the defect walls and floor than in the center of the defect in all instances. Histometrically, citric acid-conditioned defects exhibited a higher density of collagen fibers along the defect walls and floor and adjacent to the barrier membrane as well as more advanced resolution of the residual blood clot than the surgical controls. Differences in fibroblast density within specimen pairs were non-significant. All control defects but none of the acid-conditioned defects showed an artifactual split between the dentin walls and the granulation tissue. This study failed to support the contention that topical application of citric acid to root surfaces may delay healing following periodontal surgery.

Effect of ND:YAG laser irradiation and root planing on the root surface: structural and thermal effects

Effects of ND:YAG laser irradiation on untreated and root planed tooth roots were investigated to determine whether a cleaning effect and/or removal of smear layer could be achieved without concomitant microstructural or thermal damage. Sixty (60) healthy extracted teeth were either untreated, irradiated only, root planed only, or irradiated and root planed. Intra-pulpal and surface temperatures were monitored during irradiation, then SEM was performed. Smear layer elimination was achieved without inducing hard tissue microstructural damage at 5W, using pulse durations and intervals of 0.1 s, a fluence of 0.77 J/cm2, and a total energy density of approximately 700 J/cm2. However, these results were not consistent in all samples. At these parameters, intra-pulpal temperature increases of 9 to 22 degrees C and surface temperature increases of 18 to 36 degrees C were recorded. Thus, despite their effectiveness for smear layer removal, these parameters may not be appropriate for clinical use as an adjunct to conventional periodontal therapy.

The origin of fibroblasts and their role in the early stages of horizontal furcation defect healing in the beagle dog

The origin of fibroblasts, their proliferative activity and roles in the early stages of periodontal repair were investigated in order to better understand the periodontal healing process in furcation defects of the beagle dog after guided tissue regenerative therapy. Newly divided cells were identified by immunolocalization of bromodeoxyuridine (BrdU) injected 1 hour prior to sacrificing the animals. At 1 and 2 weeks after creation of the defects, the lesions were occupied primarily by granulation tissue. Under this condition, periodontal ligaments (PDL) fibroblasts in a coronal portion of the remaining PDL close to wounds proliferated actively, migrated along the root surface and formed fibrous connective tissue on the surface. Similarly, the fibroblasts adjacent to the bone surface also showed proliferative activity and engaged in active formation of fibrous connective tissue on the bone surface. The majority of labeled cells in both areas were located in the extravascular area. At 3 and 4 weeks, the defects were filled with an increased amount of new connective tissue and bone. The labeled fibroblasts were preferentially found in the most coronal portion of connective tissue formed on the root surface that was in direct contact with inflamed tissue, and the collagen fibers projected into granulation tissue. In areas of active bone formation, numerous labeled fibroblasts were located in connective tissue adjacent to the newly-formed bone. However, fibroblasts in the endosteum of new bone were rarely labeled These results indicate that fibroblasts involved in periodontal repair originate primarily from both the remaining PDL and alveolar bone, and actively engage in fibrous connective tissue formation in the early stages of periodontal repair The ability of PDL fibroblasts to proliferate, migrate, and form connective tissue on the root surfaces in the early repair stages appears to play a crucial role in the formation of the PDL and cementum, and consequently, in periodontal regeneration in the absence of root resorption and ankylosis. As the formation of new connective tissue and bone continues, the precursor cells for fibroblasts and osteoblasts are supplied locally through the continued divisions of the fibroblastic cells in association with the newly-formed connective tissue. Paravascular and endosteal cells appear to be minor contributors to new cell population during furcation defect repair in the beagle dog.

Effects of citric acid treatment on the Ca, P and Mg contents of human dental roots

An electron microprobe analyser associated with a scanning electronic microscope was used to measure Ca, P and Mg contents of the human dental root hard tissues, before and after a citric acid treatment (pH = 1). The measurements were made on transverse sections through the cervical 1/3 of the molar roots. The measurements were performed at the following 8 levels: the internal cementum, the cementum-dentine junction, cementum-related dentine, 4 external dentine levels located at 220 microns, 420 microns, 620 microns and 820 microns from the cementum-dentine junction, and finally the juxta-pulpal dentine. After the citric acid treatment, the losses in Ca and P, but not in Mg, varied significantly with the level; an acid-resistant dentine layer of approximately 600 microns was found under the cementum-dentine junction. An increase in the Ca/P ratio was also observed in this layer. Since this external dentine zone is less demineralized by the citric acid than the underlying dentine, the collagen matrix in this region may also be less exposed. These differences in the response to citric acid that depend on the distance from the root surface may explain the unpredictability of periodontal healing after citric acid treatment of diseased root surfaces, because the amount of tissue removed during root planing is not constant.

Effects of tetracycline-containing gel and a mixture of tetracycline and citric acid-containing gel on non-surgical periodontal therapy

The purpose of this study was to assess the clinical and microbiological effects of a newly developed root conditioning gel system containing tetracycline or a mixture of tetracycline and citric acid on non-surgical periodontal therapy. Sixty-four (64) single-rooted teeth with a probing depth of 4 to 6 mm were randomly subjected to one of the following four treatments; 1) root planing alone (RP group); 2) tetracycline-containing gel alone (TCG group); 3) root planing plus tetracycline-containing gel (RP + TCG group); or 4) root planing plus a mixture of tetracycline and citric acid-containing gel (RP + TC-CAG group). Probing depth, attachment level, and tooth mobility were measured and the presence of dental plaque and gingival inflammation was recorded at baseline and after 2, 4, 8, and 12 weeks. Subgingival plaque samples from each site were collected at the same visits and examined with phase contrast microscopy for proportions of motile rods and spirochetes. Plaque index, gingival sulcus bleeding index (SBI), probing depth, and attachment level decreased significantly in all groups compared to the baseline values (P < 0.05). A significant decrease in probing pocket depth was noted after 12 weeks in RP + TC-CAG group compared to the other groups (P < 0.05). Significantly more gain in attachment was detected in the RP + TC-CAG group compared to the TCG group (P < 0.05). Tooth mobility scores also decreased later in the study. A significant decrease in the proportion of motile rods was found primarily in the RP + TC-CAG group.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Treatment of periodontal furcation defects. Coronally positioned flap with or without citric acid root conditioning in class II defects

A total of 27 mandibular, buccal class II furcation defects were treated in 16 subjects using a coronally positioned flap procedure, with or without citric acid conditioning of the root surfaces. The effect of the therapies was evaluated from a series of soft and hard tissue measurements. Mean improvements were slightly greater for acid treated than for non-acid treated defects. However, none of the mean differences reached statistical significance, indicating that citric acid conditioning may not be a necessary part of the regenerative, coronally positioned flap procedure in mandibular furcations.

Effects of Nd:YAG laser radiation on removal of a root surface smear layer after root planing: a scanning electron microscopic study

A scanning electron microscopy (SEM) study was conducted to evaluate the effects of Nd:YAG laser radiation on removal of a root surface smear layer after root planing in comparison with citric acid treatment. The experimental materials were 15 human teeth affected by severe periodontal disease, which were extracted because of a hopeless prognosis. The teeth had at least 5 mm of attachment loss on the proximal surface tested. After removing all visible calculus using an ultrasonic scaler, each proximal surface was vigorously scaled and root planed with a Gracey curet. Thirty specimens were cut from the root-planed proximal surfaces and assigned randomly to one of two groups: Group A (25 specimens) was divided into 5 subgroups and irradiated with a Nd:YAG laser, using non-contact delivery (3 mm beam diameter, distance from the tip to the specimen 5 cm), at a measured power of 20 W for 0.3, 0.5, 1.0, 2.0, or 3.0 seconds corresponding to energy densities of 84.93, 141.54, 283.09, 566.17, or 849.26 J/cm2; Group B (5 specimens) was not irradiated, but treated for 3 minutes with saturated citric acid (pH 1). The center of each specimen in Group A was used as the experimental area (Exp A) treated by laser irradiation and the peripheral area of the specimen served as a control (Cont A). In Group B, one half of the specimen was used as the experimental area (Exp B) treated by citric acid and the other half served as a control (Cont B). The specimens were then fixed and examined by SEM. The surface of the root-planed specimens (Cont A and B) was irregular, corresponding to the presence of a smear layer, and had an amorphous appearance. Both root surfaces of Exp A and B exhibited clear orifices of dentinal tubules and intertubular dentin without a smear layer. Although the root surface of Exp A showed clear orifices of dentinal tubules with a flat morphology, the root surface of Exp B showed widened funnel-shaped dentinal tubule orifices with a fibrillar, mat-like morphology. The present results indicate that Nd:YAG radiation effectively removes the smear layer, uncovers dentinal tubules, and exposes collagen fibers on the root surface without widening the orifices of dentinal tubules after root planing.

Dentin demineralization. The effects of citric acid concentration and application time

Preliminary work has shown that the rate of dentin demineralization increases with increasing concentrations of citric acid. This rate subsequently diminishes at much higher concentrations. The purpose of this study was to more precisely identify the citric acid concentration which produces peak dentin demineralization and to determine if this demineralization process is time dependent. Flat dentin surfaces were prepared on the buccal and lingual sides of 15 bovine molars. 8 depressions were made in each dentin surface using a #8 round bur in a high-speed handpiece with air-water coolant. Various concentrations of citric acid solutions (weight per cent) were prepared, e.g., 0%, 10%, 20%, 25%, 30%, 35%, 40%, 65% and their respective pH's recorded. 3 microliters of each citric acid solution were placed in individual depressions on the dentin surfaces and left undisturbed for 1, 2 or 3 min. Cotton pellets were used to soak up the citric acid solution, along with any dissolved calcium, and were subsequently placed in 10 ml of 18 Me omega water. The parts per million calcium found in each water sample were determined using atomic absorption spectrophotometry. Peak dentin demineralization for 1-, 2- and 3-min application times occurred at 30% (pH = 1.55), 25% (pH = 1.62) and 25% (pH = 1.62) citric acid concentrations/(pH), respectively. Dentin demineralization was found to be time-dependent for all citric acid solution concentrations. The clinical significance of these findings is discussed.

Histologic evaluation of periodontal attachment apparatus following the insertion of a biodegradable copolymer barrier in humans

The purpose of this study was to histologically evaluate the effectiveness of polylactide:polyglycolide 50:50 (DL-PLGA) as a barrier to prevent epithelial migration and to promote new connective tissue attachment. Mucoperiosteal flaps were performed on 17 human teeth. DL-PLGA membrane was placed over the roots and alveolar bone. DL-PLGA was not placed over control teeth. Ninety days following surgery, block sections were obtained and processed for histologic evaluation. All specimens revealed a mean length of epithelial attachment within physiologic limits and recession of the gingival margin. There was little or no reattachment of the connective tissue. It is concluded that this copolymer barrier did not prevent epithelial migration nor enhance connective tissue attachment to human roots with severe horizontal bone loss and active periodontal disease.

The histologic evaluation of new attachment in periodontally diseased human roots treated with tetracycline-hydrochloride and fibronectin

The purpose of this study was to determine how the treatment of human tooth roots with tetracycline-HCl and fibronectin during periodontal surgery influences the attachment of the gingiva to the root surface. Mucoperiosteal flap surgery was performed on 22 teeth with periodontal disease. Teeth were assigned to three groups. Group one received surgery with degranulation and root planing. Group two received surgery with treatment of roots with tetracycline-HCl. Group three received surgery with treatment of roots with tetracycline-HCl and fibronectin. At 90 days, block sections were taken and teeth, gingiva, alveolar bone, and periodontal ligament were evaluated histologically. Controls healed with a long junctional epithelial attachment. Tetracycline and tetracycline with fibronectin groups demonstrated some reattachment, but only within the notches placed in the root at the original level of the bone. There was a trend for greater connective tissue attachment following tetracycline-HCl treatment of roots. The additional application of fibronectin to tetracycline treated roots appeared to partially negate the enhanced connective tissue attachment observed with tetracycline treatment alone.

A quantitative study of cementum removal with hand curettes

An in vitro study was conducted to quantitatively measure the depth of root surface removal using curettes of standardized sharpness and with definite stroke number. Extracted periodontally healthy teeth from patients 10 to 15, 16 to 25, and 26 to 40 years old had periodontal ligament remnants removed with dry gauze before being secured in a vertical position during root planing. The force applied to the root surface was measured with a tension load cell. The "bright line" test was used to assess curette sharpness. After histologic processing, the thickness of cementum adjacent to the root defect, the cementum (if any) in the root defect, total amount of cementum removed, and depth of root defect were measured by a microscopic ocular grid. Teeth from each age range were evenly distributed into 6 groups of 10 teeth each. In the majority of teeth from the 20 stroke group through the 70 stroke group, complete cementum removal was observed at the site of planing. However, in some sections from each group, fragments of cementum remained on the root surface. A positive relationship (r/s = 1) was found between the number of strokes and the force applied to the root surface and the mean depth of defect (P less than 0.05). However, an inverse relationship existed between mean force per stroke and mean defect depth (r/s = -.99) such that as mean force per stroke increased, the mean defect depth decreased. As the root surface became smoother with an increasing number of strokes, the forces increased and were more consistent.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Citric acid burnishing of dentinal root surfaces. A scanning electron microscopy report

The integrity of formalin-fixed periodontally diseased root surfaces was assessed following root planing to dentin and citric acid application. Extracted human teeth (fixed in 10% formalin), with crowns removed, were vertically sectioned in half. A horizontal groove on each proximal surface marked the extent of attachment loss. The diseased root surface was vigorously root planed to expose dentin. Cotton pellets, soaked in a saturated solution of citric acid, were either "placed" (control) or "burnished" (vigorously rubbed using root planing pressure) (experimental) on the prepared root surface for 5 min. Pellets were changed 2 times/min. The teeth were fixed and prepared for scanning electron microscope viewing and photography. A representative print was selected for each specimen. To confirm differences between test and control groups, untrained raters were asked to perform 2 sorting exercises. First, they were asked to sort the representative photographs of each specimen into 2 piles based on surface characteristics. Second, they were asked to choose from pairs of photographs, representing matched specimens, the one photograph which appeared to have the greatest collagen surface area. The surfaces of experimental specimens revealed patent dentinal tubules and an intertubular area with a very distinct "shag carpet" appearance of deeply tufted collagen fibrils. Control samples also exhibited open dentinal tubules, yet the intertubular surface displayed a "matted collagen" surface. Results of the 2 sorting exercises confirm that burnishing of formalin-fixed dentin root surfaces for 5 min with cotton pellets soaked in a saturated solution of citric acid consistently produces a distinct tufted collagen fibril surface.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Effect of citric acid treatment on the migration of epithelium on root surfaces in vitro

Explants of bovine gingival mucosa were cultured for four days on scaled and citric acid-conditioned root surfaces. Demineralization of the hard tissue with citric acid exposed the collagenous matrix of the root. Undemineralized islands were frequently seen among the collagen fibers of the treated roots. When cultured on scaled, control root surfaces, the epithelium migrated inwards between the connective tissue of the explant and the root surface. On citric acid-treated roots, epithelial migration in this direction was rare although it was possible. Citric acid treatment of the substratum directed the epithelium to migrate outwards from the explant. Only a few of the controls showed epithelial migration to the outward direction. The findings indicate that demineralization of the root surface has an influence on the direction in which the epithelium initially starts to migrate. An induced delay of epithelial migration between the gingival connective tissue and the hard tissue may be favorable for connective tissue attachment to the root surface.

Root coverage with the free gingival graft. Factors associated with incomplete coverage

The free soft tissue autograft when used for increasing the amount of attached gingiva is a relatively simple surgical procedure. The use of the free soft tissue autograft for root coverage, however, is a much more technically demanding procedure requiring the periodontist to consider additional factors. Overlooking or failing to properly address a single one of these factors can result in incomplete coverage. The purpose of this paper is to outline those factors that must be considered when complete root coverage is attempted.

Effect of an air-powder abrasive system on root surfaces in periodontal surgery

The purpose of this study was to compare the effectiveness of an air-powder abrasive technique to conventional root planing during periodontal surgery. 7 patients scheduled for multiple extractions of periodontally-involved teeth were selected. Full thickness mucoperiosteal flaps were reflected, and proximal surfaces of 32 teeth were either ultrasonically scaled and exposed to the air-powder abrasive, or ultrasonically scaled and then manually root planed. Following extraction, teeth were stained for residual plaque and photographed, or prepared for scanning electron microscopy. The air-powder abrasive technique used for surgical root preparation was found to produce a root surface favorably comparable to manual root planing with regard to removal of plaque, calculus, and exposed cementum. A mean of 80 micron of cementum was abraded away after 40 s of exposure to the air-powder spray. The air-powder abrasive spray demonstrated an advantageous ability to remove plaque and cementum from areas of difficult access, such as furcations and root flutings.

The effect on healing of the application of citric acid during replaced flap surgery

The aim of this double-blind controlled clinical trial was to assess the effect on healing following conditioning the root surface with citric acid during replaced flap surgery. Healing was assessed in 18 pairs of sites in 12 patients before surgery and after 3 months; healing was also assessed in 13 pairs of these sites in 10 of the patients after 9 months. During surgery, the root surface at 1 site from each pair was treated with citric acid pH 0.6 for 3 min and the contralateral site was exposed to sterile saline. Healing was assessed by measuring attachment levels, probing depths and recession; in addition, gingival crevicular fluid flow was measured, as was the degree of bleeding on probing. The mean gain of attachment (mm) in the acid and control groups were 1.0 and 1.2, respectively, at 3 months and 1.1 and 0.9 respectively, at 9 months. The results of this study indicate, both clinically and statistically, that the difference in healing between the acid and the non-acid sites is not significant. Thus no additional benefit is shown by using citric acid in conjunction with replaced flap surgery on anterior teeth.

The effectiveness of citric acid as an adjunct to surgical re-attachment procedures in humans

The purpose of this study was to clinically evaluate the effect of citric acid on re-attachment and re-adaptation in conjunction with periodontal surgery. A split-mouth design was used in 10 patients involving 30 quadrants of surgery. A total of 120 teeth were treated. Each quadrant consisted of at least 2 teeth from cuspid to second molar. One quadrant was treated with a modified Widman flap alone while the root surfaces of the contralateral side were also treated with a 3 min application of citric acid. Immediately following hygienic phase and at 3 and 6 months postsurgically, the following measurements were taken in this sequence: gingival index, gingival crevicular fluid flow, plaque index, furcation involvement, level of attachment and probing depth. All the data were statistically analyzed using the paired t-test, chi 2 and Fisher exact probability test. The biometric results showed that both surgical techniques resulted in a loss of attachment in shallow pockets and a gain in deeper pockets. Both techniques resulted in similar amounts of recession and probing depth reduction at 6 months. Gingival index, plaque index and furcation values decreased at 3 and 6 months postsurgically. The gingival crevicular fluid values remained essentially the same up to 6 months postsurgically.

Lack of effect of citric acid treatment of root surfaces on the formation of new connective tissue attachment

Previous reports have described an accelerated induction of new attachment and repair of furcations in dogs after treatment of roots surfaces with citric acid, but few controlled clinical studies have examined its usefulness in surgical treatments for periodontitis. This study compared the effects of a comprehensive surgical plaque control procedure with or without citric acid treatment for generalized and localized effects on gingival height, probing pocket depth and attachment level in 72 teeth in 3 patients who were treated surgically for moderate periodontitis and examined every 3 months for 1 year. No statistically significant differences in the effects of the 2 treatments were observed. These observations suggest that there is no clinical advantage of citric acid conditioning of the root surface during surgical treatment of periodontitis.

The effect of citric acid and fibronectin application on healing following surgical treatment of naturally occurring periodontal disease in beagle dogs

It has recently been suggested that following the exposure of root surface collagen with citric acid, the addition of topically applied fibronectin might promote healing with a fibrous re-attachment. The purpose of this study was to determine the benefit of citric acid demineralization and fibronectin application in the surgical treatment of severe, naturally occurring periodontal disease in Beagle dogs. The 4 treatment modalities employed were: (1) surgery alone (mucoperiosteal flaps); (2) surgery plus fibronectin; (3) surgery plus citric acid; (4) surgery plus citric acid followed by fibronectin application. Coronal and root surface notches were used as biometric and histometric reference points. Final clinical measurements were recorded 6 weeks post surgically, on the day of sacrifice. Significantly increased amounts of connective tissue reattachment were observed in the areas treated with the citric acid/fibronectin combination. Fibrous re-attachment was enhanced at the expense of epithelial downgrowth and occurred directly to both new and old cementum and exposed dentin, often in a functional manner, i.e., perpendicular to the root surface. Areas treated with the surgery and citric acid technique attained moderate amounts of fibrous re-attachment while the other treatment modalities were associated with a long junctional epithelium. The enhanced fibrous re-attachment may be the product of an accelerated coalescing of exposed soft tissue and root surface collagen fibrils, while under the mediating effect of fibronectin.

Healing after treatment of periodontal intraosseous defects. III. Effect of osseous grafting and citric acid conditioning

The present study was performed to determine whether the healing of periodontal intraosseous defects could be improved through the combined use of citric acid conditioning of the root surfaces and grafting of autogenous intraoral cancellous bone. 28 proximal defects in 19 patients were treated surgically including acid conditioning of the root surfaces. Another 25 defects in these patients were treated with acid conditioning combined with osseous grafts using the maxillary tuberosity areas as donor sites. Both therapies, e.g., citric acid conditioning alone and acid conditioning combined with osseous grafting resulted in approximately 1 mm gains of probing attachment and probing bone levels. Within the parameters of this study, osseous grafting did not enhance the effect of citric acid conditioning alone. Limited improvement of the treated defects of the present study was obtained in spite of the use of supplementary regenerative techniques.

The production of a root surface smear layer by instrumentation and its removal by citric acid

The purpose of this study was to characterize, using the scanning electron microscope, the nature of root surfaces denuded by (1) root planing alone or (2) root planing plus citric acid treatment. Six teeth were extracted from three squirrel monkeys, and the coronal half of the root surface was planed to remove attached periodontal ligament fibers and cementum. Citric acid, pH 1, was topically applied to the denuded surfaces of 3 teeth. The surface of only root-planed specimens had an irregular surface which corresponded to a smear layer. Root surfaces that had received acid treatment after root planing exhibited funnel-shaped orifices of dentinal tubules, and intertubular zones with a fibrillar, mat-like morphology. The implications of the different root-surface characteristics are discussed.