Sources of prenatal care data and their association with birth outcomes of HIV-infected women

California's Comprehensive Perinatal Services Program and birth outcomes

Introduction

California's Medicaid (Medi-Cal) sponsors Comprehensive Perinatal Services Program (CPSP), a program with enhanced perinatal care for women (more education, nutritional supplements, and psychosocial counseling/support). Past evaluations of CPSP's effectiveness in birth outcomes were limited to pilot programs and yielded mixed results.

Methods

We used 2012-2016 California's statewide data about singleton live births with any receipt of prenatal care (N = 2,385,811) to examine whether Medi-Cal with CPSP enrollment was associated with lower odds of preterm birth (PTB), spontaneous PTB, and low birthweight (LBW) than non-CPSP births. With three binary variables of PTB, spontaneous PTB, and LBW as the response variables, three multilevel logistic models were used to compare the outcomes of participants enrolled in Medi-Cal with CPSP against those with private insurance, adjusting for maternal factors and county-level covariates.

Results

Logistic models showed that participants enrolled to Medi-Cal with CPSP [n (%) = 89,009 (3.7)] had lower odds of PTB, spontaneous PTB and LBW, respectively, as compared with those with private insurance [n (%) = 1,133,140 (47.2)]. Within the Medi-Cal sub-population, the CPSP enrollment was associated with lower odds of PTB, SPTB and LBW than Medicaid beneficiaries without CPSP [n (%) = 967,094 (40.3)].

Discussion

With statewide data, these findings revealed a robust link between CPSP enrollment and better birth outcomes. Expanding access to comprehensive prenatal services could be an important strategy to improve birth outcomes.

Adequacy of prenatal care and neonatal mortality in infants born to mothers with and without antenatal high-risk conditions

BACKGROUND

Previous studies have found that inadequate prenatal care was associated with increased neonatal mortality in the general pregnant women.

AIMS

To examine the association between adequacy of prenatal care and neonatal mortality in the presence and absence of antenatal high-risk conditions.

METHODS

We conducted a retrospective cohort study of infants based on 1995-2000 vital statistics data in the USA. The relative risk for neonatal death associated with adequacy of prenatal care was estimated by multivariate logistic regressions with adjustment of confounding factors.

RESULTS

Inadequate prenatal care was associated with increased neonatal mortality when pregnancies were complicated by anaemia, cardiac disease, lung disease, chronic hypertension, diabetes, renal disease, pregnancy-induced hypertension, and previous preterm/small-for-gestational-age birth. The observed association also existed in the absence of these antenatal high-risk conditions. Overutilisation of prenatal care was associated with increased risk of neonatal deaths in both the presence and the absence of antenatal high-risk conditions. When gestational age at delivery and birthweight were further adjusted, the observed association between inadequate prenatal care and neonatal mortality was not significant in pregnancies with various high-risk conditions.

CONCLUSIONS

Inadequate prenatal care is associated with increased neonatal death in both the presence and the absence of antenatal high-risk conditions. The observed association between inadequate prenatal care and neonatal mortality may be mediated by increased risk of preterm delivery and low birthweight in these pregnancies. Overutilisation of prenatal care is associated with potential risks for fetal and neonatal development, leading to increased neonatal mortality.

Adequação do pré-natal e peso ao nascer: uma revisão sistemática

Esta foi uma revisão sistemática da literatura de publicações em que o pré-natal foi investigado com uma das variáveis preditoras do peso ao nascer. Os bancos de dados MEDLINE, Cochrane Library e SciELO foram rastreados usando-se a combinação dos seguintes descritores: "prenatal care", "antenatal care", "quality", "adequacy", "birthweight", e "low birthweight". Foram localizados 25 estudos: 17 transversais, quatro coortes, três caso-controle e um ensaio randomizado. Os indicadores de adequação empregados foram os de utilização (quantitativos) e os de conteúdo do cuidado (de processo ou qualitativos). A maioria dos autores aplicou indicadores de utilização, principalmente o Índice de Kessner e o Adequacy of Prenatal Care Utilization Index. Somente dois estudos usaram critérios qualitativos. De modo geral, os estudos transversais detectaram efeito protetor do pré-natal sobre o baixo peso ao nascer, enquanto que os resultados de investigações com outros desenhos foram conflitantes. Os achados desta revisão evidenciam que o impacto do pré-natal sobre o peso ao nascer não é inequívoco, principalmente devido ao efeito do viés de auto-seleção. Há a necessidade de realização de ensaios randomizados para esclarecer essa relação.

Sensitivity of an AIDS case-finding algorithm: who are we missing?

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to determine the sensitivity of an AIDS case-finding algorithm.

METHOD

This study applied the AIDS case-finding algorithm to paid Medicaid claims linked to New Jersey AIDS surveillance data and assesses its sensitivity across subgroups of patients.

FINDINGS

Of the 7183 cases with confirmed AIDS, based on the state's registry information, 95% (n = 6818) were correctly detected using all Medicaid claims, including pharmacy. For patients in a community-based waiver program, covered by Medicare, diagnosed with a severe mental illness, or continuously enrolled in Medicaid, with regular contact with the medical system, the algorithm identified almost all patients. To further evaluate algorithm performance, it was used with 2 groups of interest to researchers. For AIDS patients in the last 6 months of life, 88% were correctly detected without use of pharmacy claims and 95% when pharmacy claims were included. For pregnant women, data from the 6 months before the latest delivery date identify 27% of pregnant women without pharmacy claims and 41% when pharmacy claims were included. Using claims made after the latest delivery date, 81% of pregnant women were detected without pharmacy claims and 93% when pharmacy claims were included

CONCLUSION

Results demonstrate that a multilevel screen can be used with Medicaid claims to effectively to detect most patients with AIDS. Detection is lower for some subgroups, and the absence of pharmacy claims can compromise detection.

Improved birth outcomes among HIV-infected women with enhanced Medicaid prenatal care

OBJECTIVES

This study evaluated the impact of enhanced prenatal care on the birth outcomes of HIV-infected women.

METHODS

Medicaid claims files linked to vital statistics were analyzed for 1723 HIV-infected women delivering a live-born singleton from January 1993 to October 1995. Prenatal care program visits were indicated by rate codes. Logistic models controlling for demographic, substance use, and health care variables were used to assess the program's effect on preterm birth (less than 37 weeks) and low birthweight (less than 2500 g).

RESULTS

Of the women included in the study, 75.3% participated in the prenatal care program. Adjusted program care odds were 0.58 (95% confidence interval [CI] = 0.42, 0.81) for preterm birth and 0.37 (95% CI = 0.24, 0.58) for low-birthweight deliveries in women without a usual source of prenatal care. Women with a usual source had lower odds of low-birthweight deliveries if they had more than 9 program visits. The effect of program participation persisted in sensitivity analyses that adjusted for an unmeasured confounder.

CONCLUSIONS

A statewide prenatal care Medicaid program demonstrates significant reductions in the risk of adverse birth outcomes for HIV-infected women.