Modified Bilhaut-Cloquet procedure for Wassel type-II and III polydactyly of the thumb

Radiographic features and subtypes of congenital thumb duplication type C3 according to Wu et al. and their potential implications for surgical management: new classification and preliminary results

BACKGROUND

Wu et al. introduced a modified radiographic system that allows classification of all forms of CTD with excellent interobserver and intraobserver reliability. No study to date has evaluated the radiographic characteristics of Wu et al. type C3 CTD with osseous attachment at the level of the metacarpal.

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to evaluate the radiographic features of type C3 CTD according to the system of Wu et al., to describe the different anatomical subtypes of the duplication, and to propose a categorization approach to distinguish diverse surgical strategies based on the radiographic anatomy of this specific subtype of duplication.

METHODS

We performed a retrospective analysis of 215 patients (221 thumbs) diagnosed with Wu et al. type C3 CTD at our Institution between 2015 and 2021. We evaluated all CTDs by examining the alignment of the interphalangeal (IP) and metacarpophalangeal (MP) joints and by assessing the presence of abnormal hypertrophic epiphysis of the primary thumb on posteroanterior (PA) radiographs. The proposed classification system has four types: Type I with good alignment of both MP and IP joints, Type II with ulnar deviation of the MP joint, Type III with radial deviation in the MP joint and Type IV with abnormal hypertrophic epiphysis of the distal phalanx of the main thumb with ulnar deviation of the IP joint with or without ulnar deviation of the MP joint.

RESULTS

There were 140 male and 75 female patients with CTD (221 thumbs). There were 65 left, 144 right and 6 bilateral forms. The right-to-left, male-to-female and unilateral-to-bilateral ratios were 2.2:1, 1.9:1 and 35.8:1 respectively. The mean age at surgery was 22.3 ± 11.8 months (range, 8-80). The proposed classification system allowed the classification of all CTDs (n = 221). Specifically, 53 fingers were classified as Type I (24%), 136 as Type II (61.5%), 21 as Type III (9.5%), and 11 as Type IV (5%).

CONCLUSION

The proposed system is based on radiographic pathoanatomy and complements that of Wu et al. by identifying four distinct subtypes of deformity. It has the potential to improve inter-professional communication and guide surgery in patients with Wu et al. type C3 CTD. However, our results are preliminary and further research is needed to validate them.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

III.

Classification of radial polydactyly based on physical characteristics

BACKGROUND

Previous classifications in polydactyly of the thumb were by the level of duplication on radiography. This study aimed to develop a practical algorithm based on physical characteristics for treatment guidelines.

METHODS

The polydactylies were stratified using four physical characteristics: floating, symmetry, dominant side, and joint angulation/nail size. The algorithm identified the hypoplastic type and then stratified the polydactylies as symmetric and asymmetric. The asymmetric type was divided into ulnar dominant and radial dominant. The symmetric type was divided into adequate type and inadequate type. The prediction of treatments was studied retrospectively by the distribution of surgical procedures in 500 patients with 545 affected thumbs, by the new classification and the Wassel-Flatt classification.

RESULTS

Of the 545 polydactylies, 78 (14.5%) were categorized as the hypoplastic type, 369 (67.5%) as the ulnar-dominant type, 8 (1.5%) as the radial-dominant type, 70 (12.8%) as the symmetric adequate nail type, and 20 (3.7%) as the symmetric inadequate type. Treatments were excision and reconstruction in 403 polydactylies (73.9%), simple excision in 135 polydactylies (24.8%), and the Bilhaut-Cloquet procedure, ray amputation, and on-top plasty procedures were only performed in 7 polydactylies (1.3%). The distribution of surgical procedures was distinct among the new classification types and was similar among the Wassel-Flatt types.

CONCLUSIONS

The new classification stratified polydactylies by physical findings in a stepwise manner. Though surgical technical details are not included, this simple classification is useful for paediatricians and parents to understand how a surgical decision is made.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Diagnostic Level IV.

Modified Bilhaut-Cloquet procedure for Wassel type III-IV polydactyly

BACKGROUND

To investigate the functional and aesthetic results of a new modified Bilhaut-Cloquet procedure for the treatment of Wassel type III-IV thumb polydactyly.

METHODS

Thirteen patients with Wassel type III-IV thumb polydactyly who visited the Department of Orthopedics of Hebei Provincial Children's Hospital from 2019 to 2022 were selected. The surgical procedure involved a modified Bilhaut-Cloquet surgery, where two-thirds of the distal part of the dominant finger was retained as the p body of the reconstructed thumb. The triangular bone block of the ablated distal thumb that did not contain the epiphysis and articular cartilage was sutured and fixed, and the neurovascular flap of the ablated distal thumb was used as an augmenting segment of the reconstructed thumb, with the nail bed and nail matrix exquisitely sutured. The evaluation performed according to the Japanese Society for Surgery of the Hand (JSSH) system.

RESULTS

All 13 children showed bone healing, no wound infection, nonunion, or deformity healing. None of the children showed a significant reduction in the active and passive mobility of the thumb postoperatively compared with preoperatively. Postoperative evaluation was performed based on the JSSH score, with a mean of 17.15 points (14-19 points), with 11 children rated as excellent and two as good. No severe nail ridges, nail gaps, or nail split deformities of the thumb were observed postoperatively. Postoperative metacarpophalangeal and interphalangeal joint movements were not reduced compared with preoperative movements. All parents were satisfied with the appearance and function of the reconstructed thumb.

CONCLUSION

The modified Bilhaut-Cloquet procedure designed in this study was satisfactory for Wassel type III-IV thumb polydactyly without affecting the stability of the interphalangeal joints and preserving joint mobility. The postoperative thumb has a comparable circumference and nail width and was cosmetically and functionally satisfactory, especially for the asymmetric two thumbs, which achieved favorable results.

Radiographic features of congenital thumb duplication type C2 of Wu et al. classification: new subtypes and surgical strategies

Objective

This study aimed (i) to evaluate the radiographic characteristics of patients with congenital thumb duplication (CTD) type C2 according to the classification of Wu et al., (ii) to describe the various subtypes of type C2 CTD, and (iii) to propose a classification system that allows the identification of different surgical strategies based on the radiographic anatomy of this specific subtype of duplication.

Methods

We retrospectively reviewed 92 patients (92 thumbs) with type C2 CTD according to the Wu et al. classification in our institution between August 2015 and April 2021. All CTDs were classified according to the interphalangeal joint alignment of the main thumb at the posteroanterior radiograph of the thumb before operation: type I (no deviation), type II (ulnar deviation), and type III (radial deviation).

Results

All CTDs (n = 92) could be classified according to the proposed classification system: 76 (82.6%) were type I, 10 (10.9%) were type II, and six were type III (6.5%). According to the Kim system of subtype classification, there were 55 (59.8%) type 1, 24 (26.1%) type 2, and 13 (14.1%) type 3 cases.

Conclusions

The suggested classification completes the Wu et al. system and has the potential to guide surgical treatment in children with type C2 CTD.

Level of evidence

III.

On-Top Osteotomy of the Phalanx Base Combined With Modified Bilhaut: Cloquet Procedure for Atypical Radial Polydactyly

In this report, we present the combination of on-top plasty with a modified Bilhaut-Cloquet procedure for treating atypical radial polydactyly with duplication at the metacarpophalangeal (MP) joint and triphalangism of the radial and ulnar phalanges, hypoplastic middle phalanx of the radial thumb, and hypoplastic phalanx base of the ulnar thumb. To preserve the stable MP and interphalangeal joints of the radial and ulnar thumbs, respectively, on-top plasty involved osteotomizing the middle phalanx and transferring the distal end of the middle phalanx of the ulnar finger to the phalanx base of the radial thumb. A modified Bilhaut-Cloquet procedure was used to combine the tips and nails of both thumbs. Twelve months postoperatively, good joint alignment and thumb tip appearance were achieved. On-top plasties effectively combined the desirable parts of both thumbs. The modified Bilhaut-Cloquet technique is particularly well-suited for atypical cases, such as the present case.

Common Pediatric Hand Anomalies

Upper extremity congenital anomalies in the newborn are second only to congenital heart anomalies. Some of the more commonly encountered upper extremity anomalies are trigger thumb, thumb hypoplasia, polydactyly, syndactyly, and amniotic band syndrome. While some conditions occur in isolation, others are known to commonly occur in association with syndromes. Familiarity with these conditions is important not only to provide adequate evaluation and workup of these patients but also to deliver appropriate surgical intervention and prepare parents with appropriate expectations. In this article, we outline the etiology, classification, surgical management, and outcomes of these five commonly encountered upper extremity congenital anomalies.

On-top plasty combined with modified Bilhaut-Cloquet procedure for reconstructing complicated radial polydactyly

PURPOSE

To present a surgical technique of combining the on-top plasty with modified Bilhaut-Cloquet procedure for reconstructing a rare type of complicated radial polydactyly and evaluate the outcomes.

METHODS

Fourteen complicated radial polydactyly in 13 patients were corrected by combining the on-top plasty with modified Bilhaut-Cloquet procedure. Osteotomies were performed as required, and the acral part of the ulnar thumb was transposed onto the proximal part of the radial thumb. The distal parts of the two thumbs were isolated as neurovascular pedicled composite tissue flaps, including part of the distal phalanx and nail bed, and were attached together in an extra-articular way. The tendons were rebalanced, and the nail bed was reconstructed. Objective and subjective outcomes were assessed.

RESULTS

The average follow-up time was 32.4 months (6-60 months). All reconstructed thumbs were rated as good in appearance and function. The mean Vancouver Scar Scale score was 1.3 (range 1-2) and the mean Wang-Gao score of the reconstructed thumbnail was 9.4 (range 8-11). The Tada score for the function of the reconstructed thumb was 5.5 (range 5-6). The main active range of motion (ROM) of the interphalangeal joint (IPJ) was 2.1-38.9°. All parents were satisfied with the outcomes.

CONCLUSIONS

Because of the diverse manifestations of thumb polydactyly, individualized surgical treatment is recommended, and careful preoperative planning should be made with the principle of combining the best parts of the two thumbs. By combining an on-top plasty with modified Bilhaut-Cloquet procedure, a satisfactory result can be achieved for treating complicated radial polydactyly.

Pedicle complex tissue flap transfer for reconstruction of duplicated thumbs with unequal size

BACKGROUND

Thumb polydactyly is one of the most common congenital hand deformities, and the Bilhaut-Cloquet procedure or a modified one is often used. However, controversy remains over the rare instances in which both thumbs are not of similar length or far apart in distance.

AIM

To evaluate the clinical outcomes of pedicle complex tissue flap transfer in the treatment of duplicated thumbs with unequal size.

METHODS

From January 2014 to December 2020, 15 patients underwent duplicated thumb reconstruction by pedicle complex tissue flap transfer at our hand surgery center. The technique was used when it was necessary to combine different tissues from both severed and preserved thumbs that were not of similar length or far apart in distance. Subjective parents’ evaluations and functional outcomes (ALURRA and TATA criteria) were obtained. The alignment deviation, instability, range of motion (percent of opposite thumb) of the interphalangeal and metacarpophalangeal joints, and the aesthetic aspects, including circumference, length, nail size, and nail deformity, were used to assess the clinical outcomes.

RESULTS

The average age of patients at the time of surgery was 13 mo, and the mean final follow-up occurred at 42 mo. An appropriate volume with a stable joint and good appearance was obtained in 14 reconstructed thumbs. An unstable interphalangeal joint occurred in one thumb. The flexion-extension arc at the metacarpophalangeal joint was good, while that at the interphalangeal joint was poor. Most of the parents were satisfied with the cosmetic and functional results of the reconstructed thumbs. The mean ALURRA score was 21.8 (range: 20-24), and the Tada score was 6.9 (range: 5-8). Compared with the non-operated side, the length of the operated thumb was approximately 95%, the girth was 89%, and the nail width was 82.9%. The mean ranges of motion were 62.1% of that of the unaffected thumb in the interphalangeal joint and 78.3% in the metacarpophalangeal joint.

CONCLUSION

Harvesting a pedicle flap from a severed thumb is a safe and reliable procedure. Defects of the preserved thumb, such as the skin, nail, and bone, can be effectively restored using the complex tissue flap.

Suture osteosynthesis in the bony reconstruction of thumb duplication

Metacarpal osteotomies are done to correct deviation deformity in thumb duplication. We describe a suture-only technique of metacarpal osteosynthesis, without using K-wires. Thirteen Flatt Type IV thumbs and five Wassel Type VII thumbs were reconstructed with this technique. The median follow-up was 23 months. After osteotomy, the metacarpal bone fragments were sutured together with 5-0 polyglactin or 4-0 polydioxanone sutures. Metacarpal fragment displacement was not observed on postoperative radiographs obtained at 1 and 2 weeks. Bony union was achieved at 6 weeks without loss of alignment. The metacarpophalangeal joint alignment was anatomical (≤5° deviation) in eight cases. The mean pre- and postoperative metacarpophalangeal joint alignments were 27° and 9°, respectively. The 11 patients who were available for grading with the Japanese Society for Surgery of the Hand Score were assessed as good. Complete internalization of the bony fixation eliminates infections associated with exposed K-wires without compromising the overall outcome.Level of evidence: IV.

Costal osteochondral graft for a postoperative cartilage defect in a patient with polydactyly

We present a case of a postoperative cartilage defect in a patient with polydactyly who was treated with a costal osteochondral graft. Excision of the radial digit and ligamentous periosteal flap with longitudinal osteotomy were performed when the patient was 1 year old. The alignment of the interphalangeal joint was straight after surgery, but the deviation gradually developed. A revision surgery using a costal osteochondral graft was performed when the patient was 3 years old. A satisfactory outcome was obtained at the 3-year follow-up. The authors suggest that a costal osteochondral graft may be a reasonable option for revision surgery for a postoperative cartilage defect.

Congenital thumb differences- current concepts

Anomalies of the thumb development are not uncommon and may be associated with a number of syndromes also. These anomalies range from total absence to duplication. Reconstructive surgery for the creation of an opposable thumb is the most rewarding aspect of Hand Surgery and also the most challenging. Classification systems have been modified for better description. A number of procedures have been introduced to improve the functionality of the hand in anomalies and age old concepts are undergoing a metamorphosis to further this. A brief description of the common conditions and their treatment are discussed here and highlighted by selected clinical cases.

Nail size and appearance following nail fusion plasty of thumb duplication✰

PURPOSE

To evaluate nail appearance after nail fusion plasty to treat thumb duplication.

METHODS

A modified form of nail fusion plasty was performed on 17 reconstructed thumbs of 16 children with thumb duplications, commencing in January 2010. We assessed nail width and nail, lunular, and nail fold deformities using the Wang-Gao scoring system. All 17 thumbs were evaluated over an average of 32 months (range, 12-48 months) of follow-up.

RESULTS

One patient with bilateral thumb deformities was excluded. The width ratios of 15 reconstructed nails (compared with those of the contralateral thumbs) were 82-118% (average, 97%). Nine thumbs exhibited nail ridges or gaps; the average ridge/gap score was 1.23 (maximum, 2). Six thumbs exhibited lunular deformities; the average score was 1.58 (maximum, 2). Another six thumbs evidenced nail fold deformities; the average score was 1.64 (maximum, 2). Only one thumb exhibited nail dehiscence. Two thumbs had no nail deformity. The final assessments were excellent in 14 cases, good in 2 cases, and fair in 1 case.

CONCLUSIONS

We could not significantly reduce the deformity rate of the nail plate, nail fold, or lunula using our new technique, but the deformities were much less marked than previously. Nail fusion plasty usefully enlarges the nail and pulp in patients with hypoplastically duplicated thumbs.

[Recent progress in research of congenital polydactyly]

Surgery is still the main treatment for congenital polydactyly, and the aim of surgical reconstruction is to obtain a thumb with excellent function and appearance. A systematic assessment of polydactyly is required prior to surgery, including bone stress lines, joint deviation, joint activity and joint instability, size and development of finger and nail. Bone shape, joint incongruency, and abnormal tendon insertions must be corrected completely, in order to obtain good function and to avoide secondary surgery. Bilhault-Cloquet procedure can reconstruct the size of the finger and nails. Fine manipulation can improve the postoperative nail deformity, so that the reconstructed nail reaches a satisfactory aesthetic score.

Polydactyly of the Hand

Polydactyly is one of the most common congenital hand deformities managed by orthopaedic surgeons. It is most often found in isolation; however, rarely, it may be associated with genetic syndromes. Polydactyly is classified as postaxial, preaxial, or central depending on the radioulnar location of the duplicated digits. Postaxial polydactyly, which affects the ulnar side of the hand, is most common and is typically managed with excision or suture ligation of the supernumerary digit. Preaxial polydactyly, which affects the thumb or radial side of the hand, often requires reconstructive techniques to ensure a functional, stable thumb. Central polydactyly is much less common, and reconstruction can be challenging.

A Modified Bilhaut-Cloquet Procedure for Zigzag Thumb Polydactyly Types III and IV

Background:

A review of the English literature over the least 43 years revealed only a total of 53 cases of Wassel types III, IV, and VII treated by the Bilhaut–Cloquet (B–C) procedure. Furthermore, the detailed results and range of motion were only given in 2 series (a total of 9 cases).

Methods:

Four cases of Wassel types III and IV thumb duplications with zigzag deformity were treated with a modified B–C procedure. The main modification was minimal central resections at the joints aiming for joint preservation to improve the postoperative range of motion of the new thumb.

Results:

The results showed an excellent overall functional score (Tada score of 5 of 5 in all cases). The mean range of motion at the metacarpophalangeal joint was excellent (60°), but the mean at the interphalangeal joint was only 20°. Cosmetically, all thumbs were “too wide” and a panel of 3 hand surgeons scored the cosmetic result (0–10 scoring system) between 5.7 and 6.7. No secondary procedures were done, and all parents were “very satisfied” despite the wide thumbs and split nails. This was attributed to the presence of an ugly preoperative zigzag appearance, and hence the comparative postoperative appearance was satisfactory.

Conclusion:

The modified B–C procedure gives a satisfactory function, but the cosmetic outcome is suboptimal.

On-top and side-to-side plasties for thumb polydactyly

•

“On-top” and “side-to-side” plasties are techniques used for treating thumb duplications.

•

The functional results of these techniques have not been reported in the literature.

•

We report on two cases and document excellent functional results.

Introduction

“On-top” and “side-to-side” plasties are techniques used for treating thumb duplications in which one thumb is adequate proximally and the other thumb contains a better pulp and nail distally. The detailed functional results of these techniques have not been reported in the literature. We report on two cases.

Presentation of cases

The first case had Wassel type VI duplication. The ulnar duplicate had a functioning interphalangeal joint and the radial duplicate had a functioning carpometacarpal joint. “On-top” plasty was done by putting the distal part of the ulnar duplicate on top of the proximal part of the radial duplicate. At 10 years after surgery, the outcome was excellent both cosmetically and functionally. In the second case (Wassel type VII with a zigzag deformity), the radial duplicate had a hypoplastic distal phalanx with no nail. The ulnar duplicate had a functioning interphalangeal joint and the radial duplicate had a functioning carpometacarpal joint. “Side-to-side” plasty was done by joining both thumbs side-to-side at the level of the proximal phalanx. At 3 years after surgery, the outcome we considered acceptable cosmetically and excellent functionally.

Discussion

We could not find similar cases in the literature with detailed long-term postoperative results.

Conclusion

“On-top” and “side-to-side” plasties in the management of specific cases of thumb polydactyly obtain excellent functional results with excellent or acceptable cosmetic outcome.

The Duplicated Thumb: A Review

Preaxial polydactyly is a common, often sporadic, congenital anomaly that must be addressed surgically early in life. Ideally, the surgeon seeks to accomplish three goals: construction of a thumb that is adequate in size, preservation of pinch function, and reconstruction of all components in one procedure. Although each case is unique, several classification systems attempt to describe the various types. In this article, the authors discuss the various classification systems, procedures, and outcomes after surgery for pediatric thumb duplication.

A Matched Comparative Study of the Bilhaut Procedure Versus Resection and Reconstruction for Treatment of Radial Polydactyly Types II and IV

PURPOSE

To compare outcomes of the Bilhaut procedure with outcomes of conventional resection and reconstruction in radial polydactyly types II and IV.

METHODS

Patients treated with the Bilhaut procedure were radiologically matched with patients treated with reconstruction. Evaluated outcomes included the Rotterdam assessment system, pinch strength, and thumb size measurements. To determine objectively which aesthetic outcome scores truly depended on surgical technique rather than observer opinion, we analyzed evaluations by a panel of 22 individuals with varying clinical experience who were blinded to the study protocol, using a linear mixed regression model.

RESULTS

The Bilhaut procedure reduced the risk of suboptimal outcome for metacarpophalangeal joint instability in type IV radial polydactyly. Conversely, the Bilhaut procedure increased the risk of suboptimal scar appearance, residual prominence at amputation site, thumb size, and nail appearance. Tip pinch strength was more significantly reduced after the Bilhaut compared with reconstruction, whereas pulp circumference and nail width exceeded 100% of the unaffected contralateral hand after the Bilhaut reconstruction. There was no significant difference in active range of motion between procedures. Nail appearance proved the only aesthetic drawback of the Bilhaut procedure after adjustment for clinical experience.

CONCLUSIONS

There was superior metacarpophalangeal joint stability after the Bilhaut procedure for radial polydactyly type IV, but this did not result in the presumed benefit to thumb strength. For experienced surgeons, both procedures resulted in comparable thumb active range of motion. However, aesthetic results were more likely perceived as pleasing after conventional reconstruction, even after adjusting for observer experience with regard to nail appearance. Despite possible benefits of modified Bilhaut procedures that preserve the nail, conventional reconstruction is the preferred procedure until otherwise proven.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic III.

Congenital Anomalies of the Hand--Principles of Management

Physicians who specialize in pediatric orthopedics and hand surgery frequently encounter congenital hand abnormalities, despite their relative rarity. The treating physician should be aware of the associated syndromes and malformations that may, in some cases, be fatal if not recognized and treated appropriately. Although these congenital disorders have a wide variability, their treatment principles are similar in that the physician should promote functional use and cosmesis for the hand. This article discusses syndactyly, preaxial polydactyly and post-axial polydactyly, and the hypoplastic thumb.

Congenital deformities of the upper limbs. Part II: failure of formation and duplications

This article, presented in three sections, review the most common upper limb malformations and their treatments. In this section two there's a discussion about failure of formation and duplication of the parts. The bibliography is continuous since section one.

Bifid thumb type IV in children: transferring an epiphyseal segment of the proximal phalanx with insertion of the abductor pollicis brevis tendon

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the clinical and functional results of the surgical treatment of bifid thumb type IV in children.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A retrospective study was undertaken from January 1995 to December 2006. Clinical and radiographic evaluations were made according to Wassel's classification. The patients were performed by transferring an epiphyseal segment of the proximal phalanx with insertion of the abductor pollicis brevis tendon into the radial side of the epiphyseal proximal phalanx of the ulnar thumb. All patients were operated using one of five surgical procedures for bicephalous metacarpus, cartilaginous connection between the radial and ulnar proximal phalanges, the angular deformity of the metacarpophalangeal joint (MPJ) is >20°, and zigzag deformities. The postoperative results of the patients were evaluated for both function and cosmesis according to Tien's modified Tada scoring system.

RESULTS

One hundred and sixty-four patients (102 females, 62 males) were included in this study. The MPJ was stable in 170 thumbs, 15 thumbs had 10° of radial instability, and new collateral ligaments were augmented in 27 thumbs. The alignment was normal in 75 thumbs, with alignment of the interphalangeal joint (IPJ) in 101 thumbs and alignment of the MPJ in 75 thumbs. Postoperatively, there were zigzag deformities in four thumbs (developed zigzag in two thumbs, recurrent zigzag in two thumbs); there was no first web space in those hands. There were four of 185 thumbs with thumb stiffness. The abductor function of 185 thumbs was as follows: >70° in 158 thumbs (85.4%), 50°-70° in 21 thumbs (11.4%), and <50° in six thumbs (3.2%). At the latest follow-up evaluation, no evidence of physeal growth injury or growth arrest was observed in any patient. Overall, we attained good results in 140 thumbs (75.7%), fair results in 36 thumbs (19.4%), and poor results in nine thumbs (4.9%).

CONCLUSION

We recommend the use of an epiphyseal segment of the proximal phalanx with insertion of the abductor pollicis brevis tendon into the radial side of the epiphyseal proximal phalanx of the ulnar thumb and to restore anatomical insertion of the abductor pollicis brevis muscle. The technique is simple, safe, and effective for thumb abductor function in the treatment of bifid thumb type IV in children.

Treatment of common congenital hand conditions

LEARNING OBJECTIVES

After reading this article, the participant should be able to: 1. Recognize the clinical features associated with five common congenital hand conditions. 2. Describe the indications and appropriate timing for various surgical procedures used to treat congenital hand anomalies. 3. Identify the pearls and pitfalls of these surgical treatments to avoid complications. 4. Understand the expected postoperative outcomes associated with these surgical procedures.

SUMMARY

This article provides an introduction to congenital hand differences by focusing on practical surgical strategies for treating five commonly encountered conditions, including syndactyly, constriction ring syndrome, duplicated thumb, hypoplastic thumb, and trigger thumb. The accompanying videos demonstrate common and reliable surgical techniques for syndactyly release, duplicated thumb reconstruction, and pollicization for hypoplastic thumb.

Reconstruction for Wassel type III radial polydactyly with two digits equal in size

PURPOSE

To report the surgical outcomes for Wassel type III radial polydactyly thumbs of equal or nearly equal size treated by excising the radial thumb with augmentation.

METHODS

We have reconstructed 15 cases of Wassel type III radial polydactyly, in which the duplicated digits were equal or almost equal in size, by ablation of a radial digit. The distal articular surface of the radial proximal phalanx was preserved in order to maintain stability of the interphalangeal joint. The stability of the retained thumb was further augmented by tendon repositioning, restoration of the radial collateral ligament, and transfer of soft tissues from the radial digit. Eleven of 15 cases were followed up for more than 2 years and were available for assessment using the Japanese Society for Surgery of the Hand evaluation form. The average age at follow-up was 8 years and 3 months. The size of the nail and distal phalanx was measured to assess the growth of the thumb.

RESULTS

An average functional point was 12 points (maximum 14 points), and restricted interphalangeal joint motion and extension lag were the disadvantages of this technique. The width of the distal phalanx was increased from 62% of the size of the metacarpal before surgery to 78% at the final follow-up. The cosmetic score averaged 3.6 (maximum 4 points), and slightly small nails without a central ridge were deemed acceptable.

CONCLUSIONS

Our technique can provide a functionally good thumb for Wassel type III radial polydactyly.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic IV.

Congenital hand differences

This article explores recent developments for 6 common congenital hand differences, including polydactyly, syndactyly, camptodactyly, clinodactyly, trigger thumb, and cleft hand. These differences are challenging because the surgeon must understand the potential for both functional and social (ie, appearance) issues in order to provide ideal treatment for each child and family. Therapy or surgical correction plays a role for most of these children. Recent investigations have provided additional data on the expected outcomes following intervention.

Congenital hand surgery: what's new and what's coming

Congenital hand surgery has advanced during the last 10 years with surgical technique improvements, the incorporation of new technologies, and an enhanced understanding of the basic pathology of upper extremity anomalies. This article reviews the literature with a survey of 70 articles from seven leading journals published in the last 12 years. The author concludes that the next decade should be even more exciting with the incorporation of an improved understanding of tissue engineering and molecular genetics into classification and treatment algorithms. Understanding the genetic pathways of normal, and therefore abnormal, development should allow improved classification schemes and intervention to prevent, modify, or remedy these birth abnormalities.

Thumb size and appearance following reconstruction of radial polydactyly

PURPOSE

To evaluate thumb size, shape, and appearance after surgical correction of radial polydactyly.

METHODS

Thirty-one reconstructed thumbs in 26 children with radial polydactyly were evaluated at an average of 45 months after surgery. The length, girth, nail width, and joint angulation were measured and compared with the contralateral side of patients with unilateral polydactyly and with standard thumb measurements for patients with bilateral involvement. A surgeon, therapist, and caregiver each subjectively assessed the aesthetic outcome, using a visual analog scale (VAS); raters also provided the principal reasons for their assessment of the altered appearance.

RESULTS

The average length of the reconstructed thumb relative to the index finger proximal phalanx was 81%; that of the unaffected, contralateral thumb was 80%. The girth of the reconstructed thumb relative to the index finger was 102%; that of the contralateral thumb was 103%. Thumbnail width in proportion to index fingernail width was significantly decreased in the reconstructed thumbs, at 111% (compared with the contralateral value of 136%). The VAS scores averaged 7.7; the most common reason cited for decreased VAS score was an angulated thumb. Lower VAS scores were associated with Wassel type VI and VII thumbs and with increased interphalangeal, but not metacarpophalangeal, joint angulation.

CONCLUSIONS

Thumb polydactyly reconstruction typically provides a satisfactory thumb appearance. The primary issues affecting appearance after reconstruction are reduced nail width, interphalangeal joint angulation, and presence of type VI and VII radial polydactyly.