Performance of Multidrug-Resistant Tuberculosis Surveillance in Yemen: Interview Study

Evaluation of the National Tuberculosis Program and Tuberculosis Surveillance System, Jordan 2021

Objectives

Evaluate and determine the gaps in the National Tuberculosis Program and Tuberculosis Surveillance System in Jordan.

Methods

A concurrent embedded mixed quantitative/qualitative methods study was conducted to assess the National Tuberculosis Program and Tuberculosis Surveillance System in Jordan. A semi-structured questionnaire was developed based on the Updated CDC Guideline for Evaluating Public Health Surveillance System to collect necessary information from service providers and other stakeholders.

Results

The National Tuberculosis Program and Tuberculosis Surveillance System encounter various gaps and challenges across several critical domains, including infrastructure, human resources, National Tuberculosis Program functions, surveillance system performance, coordination, case findings, and data collection and notification. Regrettably, not all of the Tuberculosis Surveillance System's objectives were successfully achieved in the past. Coordination of tuberculosis services has been repeatedly reported as inadequate. This deficiency manifests in the delay in diagnosing tuberculosis patients and, in some instances, misdiagnoses. The root cause is often traced back to insufficient knowledge of tuberculosis case definitions among healthcare providers at peripheral tuberculosis clinics. Additionally, a structured approach to active case finding is conspicuously absent. Furthermore, the tuberculosis management guidelines remain unfamiliar to many healthcare providers in tuberculosis centers, leaving them inadequately equipped to handle tuberculosis cases effectively. The utilization and analysis of the system's data are also far from optimal. A glaring concern is the delay in tuberculosis case notifications received from the stakeholders involved in the Tuberculosis Surveillance System.

Conclusions

Our study showed different gaps in the National Tuberculosis Program and Tuberculosis Surveillance Systems across several areas. The structure of National Tuberculosis Program and the clinical expertise of human resources do not support tuberculosis elimination. An electronic data collection and notification system is essential to facilitate tuberculosis case detection, reporting, and follow-up. Decision-makers should push the tuberculosis epidemic on the national health agenda. Jordan should focus on allocating national and international resources for tuberculosis control programs.

Evaluation of the multidrug-resistant tuberculosis surveillance system in Maputo City, Mozambique in the period 2017-2018

Introduction

multidrug-resistant tuberculosis (MDR-TB) remains a public health problem worldwide. In Mozambique, cases of MDR-TB have increased annually. In 2018, 1,206 cases were reported, as compared to 943 cases in 2017. The aim of this study was to assess the surveillance system for multidrug-resistant tuberculosis in Maputo City.

Methods

an extract from the national database was considered for a cut-out of the City of Maputo in the period 2017-2018; the study was conducted per the guidelines of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, where the description of the system was carried out, and evaluation of the attributes. Each attribute was evaluated according to the established criteria and parameters.

Results

the surveillance system is based on the collection of data in health centers. Four hundred and six cases of MDR-TB were notified, of which 56.8% (231/406) were male and 95.9% (386/406) were ≥15 years. The system was complex with 4 levels of information transmission. With regard to flexibility, there was no changing the variables in the database. Acceptability was good. The quality of the data was regular with discrepancy of data of 14.5%. The system was considered stable as there was no system interruption. Timeliness with case notification monthly. The system sensitivity was 72.9%, the positive predictive value (PPV) was 2.3% and regarding utility the system has fulfilled its objectives.

Conclusion

the system was not flexible, the data quality was regular, had moderate sensitivity and low positive predictive value. Continuous assessment of data and scale up the diagnosis for the detection of cases of MDR-TB is recommended.

Evaluation of the National Tuberculosis Surveillance System in Sana'a, Yemen, 2018: Observational Study

Background

Tuberculosis remains a public problem that is considered one of the top causes of morbidity and mortality worldwide. The National Tuberculosis Control Program in Yemen was established in 1970 and included in the national health policy under the leadership of the Ministry of Public Health and Population to monitor tuberculosis control. The surveillance system must be evaluated periodically to produce recommendations for improving performance and usefulness.

Objective

This study aims to assess the usefulness and the performance of the tuberculosis surveillance system attributes and to identify the strengths and weaknesses of the system.

Methods

A quantitative and qualitative evaluation of the national tuberculosis surveillance system was conducted using the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention’s updated guidelines. The study was carried out in 10 districts in Sana’a City. A total of 28 public health facilities providing tuberculosis services for the whole population in their assigned catchment areas were purposively selected. All participants were interviewed based on their involvement with key aspects of tuberculosis surveillance activities.

Results

The tuberculosis surveillance system was found to have an average performance in usefulness (57/80, 71%), flexibility (30/40, 75%), acceptability (174/264, 66%), data quality (4/6, 67%), and positive predictive value (78/107, 73%), and poor performance in simplicity (863/1452, 59%) and stability (15%, 3/20). In addition, the system also had a good performance in sensitivity (78/81, 96%).

Conclusions

The tuberculosis surveillance system was found to be useful. The flexibility, positive predictive value, and data quality were average. Stability and simplicity were poor. The sensitivity was good. The main weaknesses in the tuberculosis surveillance system include a lack of governmental financial support, a paper-based system, and a lack of regular staff training. Developing an electronic system, securing governmental finances, and training the staff on tuberculosis surveillance are strongly recommended to improve the system performance.

Emerging Status of Multidrug-Resistant Bacteria and Fungi in the Arabian Peninsula

Simple Summary

The incidence and developing status of multidrug-resistant bacteria and fungi, as well as their related mortality, is reviewed by a systematic published literature search from nine countries in the Arabian Peninsula. In order to analyse the emerging status and mortality, a total of 382 research articles were selected from a comprehensive screening of 1705 papers. More than 850 deaths reported since 2010 in the Arabian Peninsula due to the infection of multidrug-resistant bacteria and fungi. Multidrug-resistant bacteria Acinetobacter baumannii, Mycobacterium tuberculosis, Staphylococcus aureus, and fungi Candida auris are the most prevalent and causing high deaths. To control these infections and associated deaths in the Arabian Peninsula, continuous preventive measures, accurate methods for early diagnosis of infection, active surveillance, constant monitoring, developing vaccines, eradicating multidrug resistance modulators, and data sharing among countries are required.

Abstract

We aimed to identify the prevalence and emerging status of multidrug-resistant bacteria and fungi and their associated mortality in nine countries in the Arabian Peninsula. Original research articles and case studies regarding multidrug-resistant bacteria and fungi in the Arabian Peninsula, published during the last 10 years, were retrieved from PubMed and Scopus. A total of 382 studies were included as per the inclusion and exclusion criteria, as well as the PRISMA guidelines, from a thorough screening of 1705 articles, in order to analyse the emerging status and mortality. The emerging nature of >120 multidrug-resistant (MDR) bacteria and fungi in the Arabian Peninsula is a serious concern that requires continuous monitoring and immediate preventive measures. More than 50% (n = 453) of multidrug-resistant, microbe-associated mortality (n = 871) in the Arabian Peninsula was due to MDR Acinetobacter baumannii, Mycobacterium tuberculosis and Staphylococcus aureus infection. Overall, a 16.51% mortality was reported among MDR-infected patients in the Arabian Peninsula from the 382 articles of this registered systematic review. MDR A. baumannii (5600 isolates) prevailed in all the nine countries of the Arabian Peninsula and was one of the fastest emerging MDR bacteria with the highest mortality (n = 210). A total of 13,087 Mycobacterium tuberculosis isolates were reported in the region. Candida auris (580 strains) is the most prevalent among the MDR fungal pathogen in the Arabian Peninsula, having caused 54 mortalities. Active surveillance, constant monitoring, the development of a candidate vaccine, an early diagnosis of MDR infection, the elimination of multidrug resistance modulators and uninterrupted preventive measures with enhanced data sharing are mandatory to control MDR infection and associated diseases of the Arabian Peninsula. Accurate and rapid detection methods are needed to differentiate MDR strain from other strains of the species. This review summarises the logical relation, prevalence, emerging status and associated mortality of MDR microbes in the Arabian Peninsula.