Evaluation of the Cepheid GeneXpert BCR-ABL assay

Estimating prognostic relevant cutoff values for a multiplex PCR detecting BCR::ABL1 in chronic myeloid leukemia patients on tyrosine kinase inhibitor therapy in resource-limited settings

The prognosis of chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) on tyrosine kinase inhibitor (TKI) treatment is based on the quantification of BCR::ABL1 fusion gene transcript copy number, harmonized by an international scale (IS) based on TaqMan-based real-time quantitative PCR (qRT-PCR). In Ethiopia, as in most low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), access to standard diagnostic, follow-up, and prognostic tools is very limited, and it has been challenging to strictly follow international guidelines. This seriously compromises clinical outcome, despite the availability of TKIs through the Glivec International Patient Assistance Program (GIPAP). Multiplex PCR (mpx-PCR), conventionally regarded as a "screening tool," offers a potential solution to this problem. A total of 219 samples from confirmed CML patients were assayed. In reference to qRT-PCR, the AUC of ROC curve for mpx-PCR was 0.983 (95% CI: 0.957 to 0.997). At the optimum cut-off value, equivalent to BCR::ABL1 (IS) transcript copy number of 0.6%, the specificity and sensitivity were 93% and 95%, respectively, with 94% accuracy. Albeit the sensitivity and accuracy of mpx-PCR decrease below the optimum cutoff of 0.6% (IS), the specificity at 0.1% (IS) was 100%, making it an attractive means to rule-out relapse and drug non-adherence at later stages of treatment, which is particularly an issue in a low income setting. We conclude that the relative simplicity and low cost of mpx-PCR and prognostic relevant cutoff values (0.1-0.6% IS) should allow its use in peripheral clinics and thus maximize the positive impact of TKIs made available through GIPAP in most LMICs.

Precision Medicine in Low- and Middle-Income Countries

Most cancer cases occur in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). The sophisticated technical and human infrastructure needed for optimal diagnosis, treatment, and monitoring of cancers is difficult enough in affluent countries; it is especially challenging in LMICs. In Western, educated, industrial, rich, democratic countries, there is a growing emphasis on and success with precision medicine, whereby targeted therapy is directed at cancers based on the specific genetic lesions in the cancer. Can such precision approaches be delivered in LMICs? We offer some examples of novel partnerships and creative solutions that suggest that precision medicine may be possible in LMICs given heavy doses of will, creativity, and persistence and a little luck.

Digital PCR for BCR-ABL1 Quantification in CML: Current Applications in Clinical Practice

Molecular monitoring of the BCR-ABL1 transcript for patients with chronic phase chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) has become increasingly demanding. Real-time quantitative PCR (qPCR) is the routinely used method, but has limitations in quantification accuracy due to its inherent technical variation. Treatment recommendations rely on specific BCR-ABL1 values set at timed response milestones, making precise measurement of BCR-ABL1 a requisite. Furthermore, the sensitivity of qPCR may be insufficient to reliably quantify low levels of residual BCR-ABL1 in patients in deep molecular response (DMR) who could qualify for an attempt to discontinue Tyrosine Kinase Inhibitor (TKI) therapy. We reviewed the current use of digital PCR (dPCR) as a promising alternative for response monitoring in CML. dPCR offers an absolute BCR-ABL1 quantification at various disease levels with remarkable precision and a clinical sensitivity reaching down to at least MR5.0. Moreover, dPCR has been validated in multiple studies as prognostic marker for successful TKI treatment discontinuation, while this could not be achieved using classical qPCR. dPCR may thus prospectively be the preferred method to reliably identify patients achieving treatment milestones after initiation of TKI therapy as well as for the selection and timing for TKI discontinuation.

The Journal of Molecular Diagnostics: 20 Years of Clinical Innovation

This guest editorial highlights 20 years of clinical innovation in JMD.

Large amplicon droplet digital PCR for DNA-based monitoring of pediatric chronic myeloid leukaemia

Quantification of tumour‐specific molecular markers at the RNA and DNA level for treatment response monitoring is crucial for risk‐adapted stratification and guidance of individualized therapy in leukaemia and other malignancies. Most pediatric leukaemias and solid tumours of mesenchymal origin are characterized by a relatively low mutation burden at the single nucleotide level and the presence of recurrent chromosomal translocations. The genomic fusion sites resulting from translocations are stable molecular tumour markers; however, repeat‐rich DNA sequences flanking intronic breakpoints limit the design of high sensitivity PCR assays for minimal residual disease (MRD) monitoring. Here, we quantitatively evaluated the impact of repeat elements on assay selection and the feasibility of using extended amplicons (≤1330 bp) amplified by droplet digital PCR to monitor pediatric chronic myeloid leukaemia (CML). Molecular characterization of 178 genomic BCR‐ABL1 fusion sites showed that 64% were located within sequence repeat elements, impeding optimal primer/probe design. Comparative quantification of DNA and RNA BCR‐ABL1 copy numbers in 687 specimens from 55 pediatric patients revealed that their levels were highly correlated. The combination of droplet digital PCR, double quenched probes and extended amplicons represents a valuable tool for sensitive MRD assessment in CML and may be adapted to other translocation‐positive tumours.

Profiling of lymphoma from formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded tissue

Molecular profiling of lymphoma samples has contributed enormously to our understanding of disease biology leading to detailed descriptions of diagnostic categories. These studies have also helped the field to recognize different subtypes of disease, different diseases that share similar cellular pathway perturbations, different immune responses, and different prognostic groups. While nearly all of these discoveries were made using unfixed, snap-frozen materials, with few exceptions, clinical biopsy materials are comprised of formalin-fixed and paraffin-embedded (FFPE) tissues. Here, we describe the impact of molecular profiling on the field of lymphoma, the challenges associated with using FFPE tissues for downstream molecular diagnostic testing, the various molecular profiling techniques, and also provide an example of the clinical application of a molecular profiling test of lymphoma using FFPE tissues.

Precursor B cell lymphoid blast crisis of chronic myeloid leukemia with novel chromosomal abnormalities: A case report

Chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) is a clonal hematopoietic stem cell disorder. It is characterized by the presence of the Philadelphia (Ph) chromosome, t(9;22)(q34.1;q11.2), which carries the BCR-ABL1 fusion gene. Tyrosine kinase inhibitors (TKIs) have markedly changed the treatment approach of CML and have become the first-line agents for almost all CML patients. However, certain patients experience resistance to these medications, which occurs through several mechanisms, including the accumulation of TKI-resistant chromosomal abnormalities. The present study reports a case of a 27-year-old Saudi male with CML receiving TKI treatment, who presented with precursor B-cell lymphoblastic crisis demonstrating the presence of the novel combined chromosomal abnormalities; non-Ph der(22), i(9) and der(20), carrying the BCR-ABL1 fusion gene. This case report adds to the literature on novel TKI-resistance-conferring chromosomal abnormalities and links them to precursor B-cell lymphoblastic crisis.

Validation Strategy for Ultrasensitive Mutation Detection

BACKGROUND

Ultrasensitive detection of low-abundance DNA point mutations is a challenging molecular biology problem, because nearly identical mutant and wild-type molecules exhibit crosstalk. Reliable ultrasensitive point mutation detection will facilitate early detection of cancer and therapeutic monitoring of cancer patients.

OBJECTIVE

The objective of this study was to develop a method to correct errors in low-level cell line mixes.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We tested sample mixes with digital-droplet PCR (ddPCR) and next-generation sequencing.

RESULTS

We introduced two corrections: baseline variant allele frequency (VAF) in the parental cell line was used to correct for copy number variation; and haplotype counting was used to correct errors in cell counting and pipetting. We found ddPCR to have better correlation for detecting low-level mutations without applying any correction (R² = 0.80) and be more linear after introducing both corrections (R² = 0.99).

CONCLUSIONS

The VAF correction was found to be more significant than haplotype correction. It is imperative that various technologies be evaluated against each other and laboratories be provided with defined quality control samples for proficiency testing.

Sensitive NPM1 Mutation Quantitation in Acute Myeloid Leukemia Using Ultradeep Next-Generation Sequencing in the Diagnostic Laboratory

Context Detection of measurable residual disease after therapy is an important predictor of outcome in acute myeloid leukemia. Objective To investigate the feasibility of using next-generation sequencing (NGS) in the diagnostic laboratory to perform quantitative NPM1 mutation assessment using ultradeep (approximately 300 000×-500 000×) sequencing (NGS-q NPM1) as a method of assessing residual disease burden in patients with acute myeloid leukemia. Design A flexible NGS-based assay for the detection and quantitation of NPM1 mutations was developed by polymerase chain reaction amplification of target DNA sequences, sequencing on an Illumina (San Diego, California) MiSeq, and analyzing data with an in-house-designed bioinformatic pipeline. NGS-q NPM1 was compared with current NPM1 quantitation methods (real-time quantitative-polymerase chain reaction and multiparameter flow cytometry). Results The NGS-q NPM1 assay had a sensitivity of between 10^-4 and 10^-5 and showed high concordance and correlation with reference methodologies. Moreover, the NGS-q NPM1 assay was able to be integrated into the laboratory's existing, targeted amplicon-based sequencing workflow. Conclusions An NGS-based, quantitative NPM1-mutation assessment can be used to monitor patients with acute myeloid leukemia, and it has some practical advantages over existing modalities.

Current developments in molecular monitoring in chronic myeloid leukemia

Molecular monitoring plays an essential role in the clinical management of chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) patients, and now guides clinical decision making. Quantitative reverse-transcriptase-polymerase-chain-reaction (qRT-PCR) assessment of BCR-ABL1 transcript levels has become the standard of care protocol in CML. However, further developments are required to assess leukemic burden more efficiently, monitor minimal residual disease (MRD), detect mutations that drive resistance to tyrosine kinase inhibitor (TKI) therapy and identify predictors of response to TKI therapy. Cartridge-based BCR-ABL1 quantitation, digital PCR and next generation sequencing are examples of technologies which are currently being explored, evaluated and translated into the clinic. Here we review the emerging molecular methods/technologies currently being developed to advance molecular monitoring in CML.

A longitudinal evaluation of performance of automated BCR-ABL1 quantitation using cartridge-based detection system

SummaryAn automated cartridge-based detection system (GeneXpert; Cepheid) is being widely adopted in low throughput laboratories for monitoring BCR-ABL1 transcript in chronic myelogenous leukaemia. This Australian study evaluated the longitudinal performance specific characteristics of the automated system.

The automated cartridge-based system was compared prospectively with the manual qRT-PCR-based reference method at SA Pathology, Adelaide, over a period of 2.5 years. A conversion factor determination was followed by four re-validations. Peripheral blood samples (n = 129) with international scale (IS) values within detectable range were selected for assessment. The mean bias, proportion of results within specified fold difference (2-, 3- and 5-fold), the concordance rate of major molecular remission (MMR) and concordance across a range of IS values on paired samples were evaluated.

The initial conversion factor for the automated system was determined as 0.43. Except for the second re-validation, where a negative bias of 1.9-fold was detected, all other biases fell within desirable limits. A cartridge-specific conversion factor and efficiency value was introduced and the conversion factor was confirmed to be stable in subsequent re-validation cycles. Concordance with the reference method/laboratory at >0.1–≤10 IS was 78.2% and at ≤0.001 was 80%, compared to 86.8% in the >0.01–≤0.1 IS range. The overall and MMR concordance were 85.7% and 94% respectively, for samples that fell within ± 5-fold of the reference laboratory value over the entire period of study.

Conversion factor and performance specific characteristics for the automated system were longitudinally stable in the clinically relevant range, following introduction by the manufacturer of lot specific efficiency values.

Present and future of molecular monitoring in chronic myeloid leukaemia

Currently, physicians treating chronic myeloid leukaemia (CML) patients can rely on a wide spectrum of therapeutic options: the best use of such options is essential to achieve excellent clinical outcomes and, possibly, treatment-free remission (TFR). To accomplish this, proper integration of expert clinical and laboratory monitoring of CML patients is fundamental. Molecular response (MR) monitoring of patients at defined time points has emerged as an important success factor for optimal disease management and BCR-ABL1 kinase domain mutation screening is useful to guide therapeutic reassessment in patients who do not achieve optimal responses to tyrosine kinase inhibitor therapy. Deeper MRs might be associated with improved long-term survival outcomes. More importantly, they are considered a gateway to TFR. In molecular biology, novel procedures and technologies are continually being developed. More sophisticated molecular tools and automated analytical solutions are emerging as CML treatment endpoints and expectations become more and more ambitious. Here we provide a critical overview of current and novel methodologies, present their strengths and pitfalls and discuss what their present and future role might be.

Comparison of molecular responses based on BCR-ABL1% (IS) results from an in-house TaqMan-based qPCR versus Xpert(®) assay in CML patients on tyrosine kinase inhibitor therapy

OBJECTIVES

Tyrosine kinase inhibitors (TKIs) have drastically changed the prospects for chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) patients. The European LeukemiaNet (ELN) recommends molecular monitoring of BCR-ABL1 mRNA levels at distinct time points to define an optimal response, warning, or failure of treatment.

METHODS

Sixty-four follow-up peripheral blood samples from CML patients on TKI were tested by two methods. Molecular responses based on BCR-ABL1% (IS) from an Xpert(®) BCR-ABL1 Monitor assay were compared with TaqMan-based qPCR.

RESULTS

Seven samples showed 'molecularly undetectable leukaemia' by both methods (11%). In-house qPCR showed 57 BCR-ABL1+ samples; 45/57 samples (79%) were concordant for 'major molecular response' (MMR, n = 32) and 'no MMR' (n = 13) by both assays, whereas nine were BCR-ABL1 negative by Xpert(®). Identical molecular responses (i.e. 'optimal') were defined in 41 samples. Discordances seen in patients < 10 months on TKI (n = 2) had no impact on clinical management, whereas for patients >12 months on TKI, a different molecular response was defined ('warning' versus 'optimal'). Thirteen samples had 'no MMR' by both methods. 10/13 showed identical intervals (>10%(IS), 1-10%(IS) or 0·1-1%(IS)), corresponding to seven 'failures' and three 'warnings'. Discordant intervals were seen in 3/13 samples (all defined as 'failures'). Deep molecular responses (MR(4·0) or MR(5·0)) with detectable BCR-ABL1 showed some fluctuations between both methods, nevertheless, all had 'optimal' responses. 'Molecularly undetectable leukaemia' was observed more frequently by Xpert(®) (n = 16) as by our in-house assay (n = 7).

DISCUSSION

Based on current ELN recommendations, Xpert(®) BCR-ABL1 assay defines identical molecular responses as TaqMan-based qPCR BCR-ABL1% (IS) data in 98% (63/64) of samples.

Possible incorrect genotyping of heterozygous factor V Leiden and Prothrombin 20210 gene mutations by the GeneXpert assay

BACKGROUND

The GeneXpert analyzer is a hands-off system for the detection of Factor V Leiden and of Prothrombin G20210A (GPRO) gene thrombophilic mutations. Although the system is efficient and easy to use, we report the rare possibility of incorrect genotyping.

METHODS

1648 samples were evaluated using the GeneXpert HemosIL Factor II and Factor V assay: 1319 were freshly analyzed while 329 were frozen, thawed and diluted with saline prior to analysis to avoid clogging of the instrument syringe.

RESULTS

Two samples, both heterozygous, one for the factor V Leiden and the other for the GPRO gene, were incorrectly genotyped as homozygous for the relative mutation. Inspection of the Ct values and amplification curves and genotyping with PCR revealed the correct genotype as heterozygous for factor V Leiden and GPRO mutation.

DISCUSSION

The GeneXpert HemosIL Factor II and Factor V assay is an automated, fast genotyping assay requiring almost no sample manipulation, advantageous characteristics if compared with other PCR-based methods. However, an inattentive use of it can generate incorrect diagnosis. A careful handling of the sample, in particular correct dilution of frozen/thawed samples before analysis, and the inspection of the amplification curves and Ct values are required to avoid artifacts.

A point-of-care PCR test for HIV-1 detection in resource-limited settings

A low-cost, fully integrated sample-to-answer, quantitative PCR (qPCR) system that can be used for detection of HIV-1 proviral DNA in infants at the point-of-care in resource-limited settings has been developed and tested. The system is based on a novel DNA extraction method, which uses a glass fiber membrane, a disposable assay card that includes on-board reagent storage, provisions for thermal cycling and fluorescence detection, and a battery-operated portable analyzer. The system is capable of automated PCR mix assembly using a novel reagent delivery system and performing qPCR. HIV-1 and internal control targets are detected using two spectrally separated fluorophores, FAM and Quasar 670. In this report, a proof-of-concept of the platform is demonstrated. Initial results with whole blood demonstrate that the test is capable of detecting HIV-1 in blood samples containing greater than 5000 copies of HIV-1. In resource-limited settings, a point-of-care HIV-1 qPCR test would greatly increase the number of test results that reach the infants caregivers, allowing them to pursue anti-retroviral therapy.

Comparative study of BCR-ABL1 quantification: Xpert assay, a feasible solution to standardization concerns

The level of BCR-ABL1 reached after treatment with tyrosine kinase inhibitors is an effective marker of the therapeutic response and a good survival predictor in chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) patients. However, no agreement has yet been achieved about either the standardization of the technique to determine BCR-ABL1 or the interpretation of the results. The aim of this study was to compare the method currently recommended by the European Leukemia Net, which includes the application of a conversion factor to express the results in international scale, with an automated method (Xpert BCR-ABL™, Cepheid). BCR-ABL1 transcript quantification was performed in 117 samples from CML patients in two different laboratories by both methods, and the results were compared by statistical procedures. A high linear correlation was obtained in the results between the two methods. The concordance at logarithmic intervals reached 62 %. When the major molecular response (MMR) was analyzed, 85 % agreement was achieved. The automated method provides reproducible results and does not show significant differences compared with the traditional method. As a clinical tool, Xpert correctly classified the patients in MMR and can be considered a useful alternative for the molecular follow-up of CML patients.

Cartridge-based automated BCR-ABL1 mRNA quantification: solving the issues of standardization, at what cost?

BACKGROUND

Molecular monitoring of chronic myeloid leukemia patients treated with tyrosine kinase inhibitors is essential for therapeutic stratification. Inter-laboratory reproducibility is, therefore, a crucial issue which requires standardization and strict alignment of BCR-ABL1 values to the international scale. An automated cartridge-based assay (Xpert BCR-ABL Monitor(™), Cepheid) had been proposed as a robust alternative to non-automated assays. This study aimed to compare inter-laboratory reproducibility of automated and non-automated quantification, the possibility of converting automated results to the international scale, and the potential economic impact of automation.

DESIGN AND METHODS

One hundred and eighteen blood samples from chronic myeloid leukemia patients treated with tyrosine kinase inhibitors were prospectively analyzed in two laboratories using both automated and non-automated assays. The economic evaluation involved a micro-costing study and average costs were assessed as a function of sample throughput.

RESULTS

Automated assays achieved similar inter-laboratory reproducibility to highly standardized non-automated assays and a short delay (≤6 h) between sampling and blood lysis had a positive impact on inter-laboratory reproducibility. Reporting automated BCR-ABL1 ratios on the international scale was possible using a specific conversion factor which may vary with batches. Cost assessment showed that automated assays could be relevant for annual activity levels below 300 since average costs were lower than those of the non-automated assays.

CONCLUSIONS

The Xpert BCR-ABL Monitor(™) assay could be appropriately used in a near-patient setting for routine quantification of e13/e14-a2 transcripts, preferably in partnership with a regional reference laboratory. However, its prognostic impact relative to non-automated quantification remains to be tested prospectively within appropriate clinical trials.

Desirable performance characteristics for BCR-ABL measurement on an international reporting scale to allow consistent interpretation of individual patient response and comparison of response rates between clinical trials

An international basis for comparison of BCR-ABL mRNA levels is required for the common interpretation of data derived from individual laboratories. This will aid clinical decisions for individual patients with chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) and assist interpretation of results from clinical studies. We aligned BCR-ABL values generated by 38 laboratories to an international scale (IS) where a major molecular response (MMR) is 0.1% or less. Alignment was achieved by application of laboratory-specific conversion factors calculated by comparisons performed with patient samples against a reference method. A validation procedure was completed for 19 methods. We determined performance characteristics (bias and precision) for consistent interpretation of MMR after IS conversion. When methods achieved an average BCR-ABL difference of plus or minus 1.2-fold from the reference method and 95% limits of agreement within plus or minus 5-fold, the MMR concordance was 91%. These criteria were met by 58% of methods. When not met, the MMR concordance was 74% or less. However, irrespective of precision, when the bias was plus or minus 1.2-fold as achieved by 89% of methods, there was good agreement between the overall MMR rates. This indicates that the IS can deliver accurate comparison of molecular response rates between clinical trials when measured by different laboratories.

Development of an integrated assay for detection of BCR-ABL RNA

BACKGROUND

Current practice guidelines for managing patients with chronic myelogenous leukemia (CML) call for monitoring BCR-ABL transcript concentrations with a quantitative reverse transcription-PCR (qRT-PCR) assay. Because the available laboratory-developed assays lack consensus on the appropriate design, reporting of results, and reference intervals, we developed and evaluated an integrated BCR-ABL assay that yields standardized results for any laboratory and can be performed by technicians with no specialized training.

METHODS

We used the Cepheid Xpert BCR-ABL Monitor assay to measure both BCR-ABL and ABL (endogenous control) transcripts in blood samples from CML patients and healthy individuals. The assay involves 8 manual pipetting steps, fully automated nucleic acid purification, a nested qRT-PCR step, and data analysis.

RESULTS

The BCR-ABL assay requires approximately 2 h 20 min and covers a 5-log concentration range with a lower detection limit for the BCR-ABL:ABL ratio of approximately 0.005%. Assay results were negative for 100% of the 56 known CML-negative samples (12 patients with other hematologic disorders and 44 healthy blood donors). Testing of CML-positive patients undergoing disease monitoring showed 85% agreement with negative results (17 of 20) and 100% agreement with positive results (26 of 26). An imprecision/portability study revealed no differences in performance between sites, days, instruments, and operators.

CONCLUSIONS

The Xpert BCR-ABL Monitor assay provides a robust and reproducible alternative to laboratory-developed assays. Its ease of use may allow more laboratories to offer BCR-ABL testing for patients, and the short assay time enables same-day results for treating physicians.

Chronic myeloid leukemia: molecular monitoring in clinical practice

The role of molecular monitoring for patients with chronic myeloid leukemia (CML) is multifaceted. Milestone measurements up to 18 months of first-line imatinib therapy are prognostic and provide warning signals of suboptimal response. Serial measurements for patients with a complete cytogenetic response determine ongoing treatment efficacy or signal pending relapse. The pattern of molecular and cytogenetic response is generally comparable, but only cytogenetic analysis can monitor for the acquisition of clonal abnormalities and has an important role in case of loss of molecular response. For patients treated with imatinib, a rising level of BCR-ABL is a trigger for kinase domain mutation analysis. The characterization of BCR-ABL inhibitor-resistant mutations is important to direct therapeutic intervention because it is now apparent that each resistant mutation functions as a distinct protein with unique biological properties that may confer a gain or loss of function. The benefit to patients of regular molecular analysis is a reassurance of ongoing response using the most sensitive of techniques or a potential improvement in outcome for those where relapse is indicated early. However, despite the obvious benefits of molecular analysis, the measurement techniques may not be quite ready for acceptance into the routine clinical monitoring practices of all clinicians. The challenge now is to standardize and simplify the method so that it can be readily and reliably incorporated into routine laboratory testing procedures.