PIK3CA hotspot mutation scanning by a novel and highly sensitive high-resolution small amplicon melting analysis method

Direct comparison of an ultrasensitive real-time PCR assay with droplet digital PCR for the detection of PIK3CA hotspot mutations in primary tumors, plasma cell-free DNA and paired CTC-derived gDNAs

Introduction

Detection of PIK3CA mutations in primary tumors and liquid biopsy samples is of increasing importance for treatment decisions and therapy resistance in many types of cancer. The aim of the present study was to directly compare the efficacy of a relatively inexpensive ultrasensitive real-time PCR with the well-established and highly sensitive technology of ddPCR for the detection of the three most common hotspot mutations of PIK3CA, in exons 9 and 20, that are all of clinical importance in various types of cancer.

Patients and methods

We analyzed 42 gDNAs from primary tumors (FFPEs), 29 plasma-cfDNA samples, and 29 paired CTC-derived gDNAs, all from patients with ER+ metastatic breast cancer, and plasma from 10 healthy donors. The same blood draws were used for CTC isolation using EpCAM beads for positive immunomagnetic enrichment. All FFPEs and plasma-cfDNA samples were analyzed in parallel for PIK3CA mutations by ultrasensitive real-time PCR assay and droplet digital PCR.

Results

In gDNAs from FFPEs, using ultrasensitive real-time PCR, the p.E545K mutation was detected in 22/42(52.4%), and the p.E542K and p.H1047R mutations were detected in 14/42(33.3%) and 16/42(38.1%), respectively. Using ddPCR, the p.E545K mutation was detected in 22/42(52.4%), p.E542K in 17/42(40.5%), and p.H1047R in 19/42(45.2%) samples, revealing a concordance between the two methodologies of 81%, 78.6% and 78.6% for each mutation respectively. In plasma-cfDNA, using ultrasensitive real-time PCR, the p.E545K mutation was detected in 11/29(38%) and both p.E542K and p.H1047R mutations in 2/29(6.9%).In the same plasma-cfDNA samples using ddPCR, p.E545K was detected in 1/29(3.5%), p.E542K in 2/29(6.9%), and p.H1047R in 3/29(10.5%) samples, revealing a concordance of 65.5%,100% and 93.1% for each mutation respectively. In paired CTC-derived gDNAs p.E545K was detected in 11/29(38%), p.E542K in 3/29(10.3%), and p.H1047R in 7/29(24.1%) samples.

Conclusions

This low-cost, high-throughput and ultrasensitive real-time PCR assay provides accurate and specific detection of PIK3CA hotspot mutations in liquid biopsy samples and gives similar results to ddPCR. This assay can be performed in labs where digital PCR instrumentation is not available. In CTC-derived gDNA and paired plasma-cfDNA, PIK3CA mutations detected were not identical, revealing that CTC and plasma-cfDNA give complementary information.

Development and validation of a multi-marker liquid bead array assay for the simultaneous detection of PIK3CA and ESR1 hotspot mutations in single circulating tumor cells (CTCs)

Background

PIK3CA and ESR1 mutations are associated with progression and therapy resistance in metastatic breast cancer (MBC). CTCs are highly heterogeneous and their analysis at single cell level can provide unique information for mutational profiling and the existence of different sub-clones related to tumor progression. We have developed a novel multi-marker liquid bead array assay based on combination of an enzymatic mutation enrichment method, multiplex PCR-based assay, and liquid bead array technology for the simultaneous detection of PIK3CA and ESR1 hotspot mutations in liquid biopsy samples. We focus on single CTCs, however the assay can be used for bulk CTC and ctDNA analysis.

Materials and methods

Single CTCs were isolated from an ER+/HER2+ MBC patient from CellSearch® cartridges using the VyCAP Puncher System and subjected to whole genome amplification followed by nuclease-assisted minor-allele enrichment with probe-overlap (NaME-PrO) enrichment. The assay was validated for analytical sensitivity and specificity for the simultaneous detection of PIK3CA (E545K, E542K, H1047R, H1047L) and ESR1 (Y537S, Y537C, Y537N, D538G, L536H) mutations in single CTCs, while its clinical performance was evaluated on 22 single CTCs and three single white blood cells (WBCs).

Results

The developed multi-marker liquid bead array assay is novel, highly specific and sensitive for both mutation panels. The assay can reliably detect mutation-allelic-frequencies (MAFs) as low as 0.1 %. The presence of PIK3CA and ESR1 mutations was detected in 13.6 % and 72.7 % of single CTCs, respectively. The developed assay is sample-saving since it requires only 2 μL of amplified DNA to check for nine hotspot PIK3CA and ESR1 mutations in a single cell. The developed liquid bead array assay (Luminex, US), based on a 96 microwell plate format, enables the simultaneous analysis of 96 single cells.

Conclusions

The developed novel multi-marker liquid bead array assay for the simultaneous detection of PIK3CA and ESR1 hotspot mutations in single CTCs is highly specific, highly sensitive, high-throughput, and sample-, cost-, and time-saving. This multi-marker liquid bead array assay can be extended to detect up to 100 mutations in many genes at once and can be applied for bulk CTC and ctDNA analysis.

Highly Sensitive Detection of PIK3CA Mutations by Looping-Out Probes-Based Melting Curve Analysis

PIK3CA mutations have important therapeutic and prognostic implications in various cancer types. However, highly sensitive detection of PIK3CA hotspot mutations in heterogeneous tumor samples remains a challenge in clinical settings. To establish a rapid PCR assay for highly sensitive detection of multiple PIK3CA hotspot mutations. We described a novel melting curve analysis-based assay using looping-out probes that can enrich target mutations in the background of excess wild-type and concurrently reveal the presence of mutations. The analytical and clinical performance of the assay were evaluated. The developed assay could detect 10 PIK3CA hotspot mutations at a mutant allele fraction of 0.05-0.5% within 2 h in a single step. Analysis of 82 breast cancer tissue samples revealed 43 samples with PIK3CA mutations, 28 of which were confirmed by Sanger sequencing. Further testing of 175 colorectal cancer tissue samples showed that 24 samples contained PIK3CA mutations and 19 samples were confirmed by Sanger sequencing. Droplet digital PCR supported that all mutation-containing samples undetected by sequencing contained mutations with a low allele fraction. The rapidity, ease of use, high sensitivity and accuracy make the new assay a potential screening tool for PIK3CA mutations in clinical laboratories.

Aberrant methylation scanning by quantitative DNA melting analysis with hybridization probes as exemplified by liquid biopsy of SEPT9 and HIST1H4F in colorectal cancer

OBJECTIVE

The generally accepted method of quantifying hypermethylated DNA by qPCR using methylation-specific primers has the risk of underestimating DNA methylation and requires data normalization. This makes the analysis complicated and less reliable.

METHODS

The end-point PCR method, called qDMA-HP (for quantitative DNA Melting Analysis with hybridization probes), which excludes the normalization procedure, is multiplexed and quantitative, has been proposed. qDMA-HP is characterized by the following features: (i) asymmetric PCR with methylation-independent primers; (ii) fluorescent dual-labeled, self-quenched probes (commonly known as TaqMan probes) covering several interrogated CpGs; (iii) post-PCR melting analysis of amplicon/probe hybrids; (iv) quantitation of unmethylated and methylated DNA alleles by measuring the areas under the corresponding melt peaks.

RESULTS

qDMA-HP was tested in liquid biopsy of colorectal cancer by evaluating SEPT9 and HIST1H4F methylations simultaneously in the single-tube reaction. Differences in the methylation levels in healthy donors versus cancer patients were statistically significant (p < 0.0001), AUCROC values were 0.795-0.921 for various marker combinations.

CONCLUSIONS

This proof-of-concept study shows that qDMA-HP is a simple, normalization-independent, quantitative, multiplex and "closed tube" method easily adapted to clinical settings. It is demonstrated, for the first time, that HIST1H4F is a perspective marker for liquid biopsy of colorectal cancer.

Development and Validation of a Novel Dual-Drop-off ddPCR Assay for the Simultaneous Detection of Ten Hotspots PIK3CA Mutations

Breast cancer is the leading cause of cancer-related deaths in women worldwide. Approximately 40% of patients with hormone receptor-positive, human epidermal growth factor receptor-2-negative breast cancer have activating mutations in the PIK3CA gene. We developed a highly sensitive, specific, cost-effective, and reproducible dual-drop-off droplet digital polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assay for the simultaneous detection of ten hotspots of PIK3CA mutations in plasma cell-free (cf) DNA. We first evaluated the analytical specificity, sensitivity, limit of blank, repeatability, and reproducibility of the assay, which simultaneously detects seven mutations in exon9 and three in exon20. We further applied this assay in 11 gDNA and 18 plasma cfDNA samples from healthy donors and 35 plasma cfDNA samples from metastatic breast cancer patients. The assay is highly sensitive, specific, and applicable for clinical samples containing at least 1-5% mutant DNA. We detected PIK3CA mutations in 9/35(26%) plasma cfDNA samples in exon 9 and in 9/35(26%) in exon 20. Direct comparison of the developed assay with amplification refractory mutation system-based PCR (using plasma samples) and with the Food and Drug Administration-approved cobas PIK3CA mutation assay (using formalin fixed paraffin embedded samples) showed high concordance of our developed assay with the cobas PIK3CA assay. The developed assay is cost-effective and can reliably and simultaneously detect ten hotspot PIK3CA mutations in plasma cfDNA. The clinical performance of the assay will be further evaluated in liquid biopsy samples.

Preoperative Mutational Analysis of Circulating Tumor Cells (CTCs) and Plasma-cfDNA Provides Complementary Information for Early Prediction of Relapse: A Pilot Study in Early-Stage Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer

PURPOSE

We assessed whether preoperativemutational analyses of circulating tumor cells (CTCs) and plasma-cfDNA could be used as minimally invasive biomarkers and as complimentary tools for early prediction of relapse in early-stage non-small -cell lung cancer (NSCLC).

EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN

Using ddPCR assays, hotspot mutations of BRAF, KRAS, EGFR and PIK3CA were identified in plasma-cfDNA samples and size-based enriched CTCs isolated from the same blood samples of 49 early-stage NSCLC patients before surgery and in a control group of healthy blood donors (n= 22). Direct concordance of the mutational spectrum was further evaluated in 27 patient-matched plasma-cfDNA and CTC-derived DNA in comparison to tissue-derived DNA.

RESULTS

The prevalence of detectable mutations of the four tested genes was higher in CTC-derived DNA than in the corresponding plasma-cfDNA (38.8% and 24.5%, respectively).The most commonly mutated gene was PIK3CA, in both CTCs and plasma-cfDNA at baseline and at the time of relapse. Direct comparison of the mutation status of selected drug-responsive genes in CTC-derived DNA, corresponding plasma-cfDNA and paired primary FFPE tissues clearly showed the impact of heterogeneity both within a sample type, as well as between different sample components. The incidence of relapse was higher when at least one mutation was detected in CTC-derived DNA or plasma-cfDNA compared with patients in whom no mutation was detected (p =0.023). Univariate analysis showed a significantly higher risk of progression (HR: 2.716; 95% CI, 1.030-7.165; p =0.043) in patients with detectable mutations in plasma-cfDNA compared with patients with undetectable mutations, whereas the hazard ratio was higher when at least one mutation was detected in CTC-derived DNA or plasma-cfDNA (HR: 3.375; 95% CI, 1.098-10.375; p =0.034).

CONCLUSIONS

Simultaneous mutational analyses of plasma-cfDNA and CTC-derived DNA provided complementary molecular information from the same blood sample and greater diversity in genomic information for cancer treatment and prognosis. The detection of specific mutations in ctDNA and CTCs in patients with early-stage NSCLC before surgery was independently associated with disease recurrence, which represents an important stratification factor for future trials.

Comprehensive liquid biopsy analysis as a tool for the early detection of minimal residual disease in breast cancer

Liquid biopsy (LB) provides a unique minimally invasive tool to follow-up cancer patients over time, to detect minimal residual disease (MRD), to study metastasis-biology and mechanisms of therapy-resistance. Molecular characterization of CTCs offers additionally the potential to understand resistance to therapy and implement individualized targeted treatments which can be modified during the disease evolution and follow-up period of a patient. In this study, we present a long-term follow-up of operable breast cancer patients based on a comprehensive liquid biopsy analysis. We performed a comprehensive liquid biopsy analysis in peripheral blood of 13 patients with early-stage operable breast cancer at several time points for a period of ten years, consisting of: (a) CTC enumeration using the CellSearch system, (b) phenotypic analysis of CTCs using Immunofluorescence, (c) gene expression analysis, in EpCAM(+) CTCs for CK-19, CD24,CD44, ALDH1, and TWIST1, (d) analysis of PIK3CA and ESR1 mutations in EpCAM(+) CTCs and corresponding plasma ctDNA and (e) DNA methylation of ESR1 in CTCs. 10/13 (77%) patients were found negative for LB markers in PB during the whole follow-up period, and these patients did not relapse during the follow-up. However, 3/13(18%) patients that were positive for at least one LB marker relapsed within the follow-up period. The molecular characteristics of CTCs were highly different even for the same patient at different time points, and always increased before the clinical relapse. Our results indicate that liquid biopsy can reveal the presence of MRD at least 4 years before the appearance of clinically detectable metastatic disease demonstrating that a comprehensive liquid biopsy analysis provides highly important information for the therapeutic management of breast cancer patients.

Allele-Specific PCR for PIK3CA Mutation Detection Using Phosphoryl Guanidine Modified Primers

Phosphoryl guanidine (PG) is the novel uncharged modification of internucleotide phosphates of oligonucleotides. Incorporating PG modification into PCR primers leads to increased discrimination between wild-type and mutated DNA, providing extraordinary detection limits in an allele-specific real-time polymerase chain reaction (AS-PCR). Herein, we used PG-modification to improve the specificity of AS primers with unfavorable Pyr/Pur primer's 3'-end mismatch in the template/primer complex. Two mutations of the PIK3CA gene (E542K, E545K) were chosen to validate the advantages of the PG modification. Several primers with PG modifications were synthesized for each mutation and assessed using AS-PCR with the plasmid controls and DNA obtained from formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) tissues. The assay allows the detection of 0.5% of mutated DNA on the wild-type DNA plasmid template's background with good specificity. Compared with ddPCR, the primers with PG-modification demonstrated 100% specificity and 100% sensitivity on the DNA from FFPE with mutation presence higher than 0.5%. Our results indicate the high potential of PG-modified primers for point mutation detection. The main principle of the developed methodology can be used to improve the specificity of primers regardless of sequences.

Detection of ESR1 Mutations in Primary Tumors and Plasma Cell-Free DNA in High-Grade Serous Ovarian Carcinoma Patients

Simple Summary

In the present study we evaluated the frequency and the clinical relevance of ESR1 mutations in high-grade serous ovarian cancer (HGSOC). Drop-off droplet digital PCR (ddPCR) was first used to screen for ESR1 mutations in primary tumors (formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded, FFPEs) from HGSOC patients and plasma cell-free DNA (cfDNA) samples from advanced and metastatic ovarian cancer patients. We further used the recently developed ESR1-NAPA assay to detect individual ESR1 mutations in drop-off ddPCR-positive samples. We report for the first time the presence of ESR1 mutations in 15% of FFPEs and in 13.8% of plasma cfDNA samples from advanced and metastatic ovarian cancer patients.

Abstract

ESR1 mutations have been recently associated with resistance to endocrine therapy in metastatic breast cancer and their detection has led to the development and current evaluation of novel, highly promising therapeutic strategies. In ovarian cancer there have been just a few reports on the presence of ESR1 mutations. The aim of our study was to evaluate the frequency and the clinical relevance of ESR1 mutations in high-grade serous ovarian cancer (HGSOC). Drop-off droplet digital PCR (ddPCR) was first used to screen for ESR1 mutations in 60 primary tumors (FFPEs) from HGSOC patients and in 80 plasma cell-free DNA (cfDNA) samples from advanced and metastatic ovarian cancer patients. We further used our recently developed ESR1-NAPA assay to identify individual ESR1 mutations in drop-off ddPCR-positive samples. We report for the first time the presence of ESR1 mutations in 15% of FFPEs and in 13.8% of plasma cfDNA samples from advanced and metastatic ovarian cancer patients. To define the clinical significance of this finding, our results should be further validated in a large and well-defined cohort of ovarian cancer patients.

DNA methylation analysis of tumor suppressor genes in liquid biopsy components of early stage NSCLC: a promising tool for early detection

Purpose

Circulating tumor cells (CTCs) and circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) analysis represents a liquid biopsy approach for real-time monitoring of tumor evolution. DNA methylation is considered to be an early event in the process of cancer development and progression. The aim of the present study was to evaluate whether detection of DNA methylation of selected tumor suppressor genes in CTC and matched ctDNA provides prognostic information in early stage NSCLC.

Experimental design

The methylation status of five selected gene promoters (APC, RASSFIA1, FOXA1, SLFN11, SHOX2) was examined by highly specific and sensitive real-time methylation specific PCR assays in: (a) a training group of 35 primary tumors and their corresponding adjacent non-cancerous tissues of early stage NSCLC patients, (b) a validation group of 22 primary tumor tissues (FFPEs) and 42 peripheral blood samples of early stage NSCLC patients. gDNA was isolated from FFPEs, CTCs (size-based enriched by Parsortix; Angle and plasma, and (c) a control group of healthy blood donors (n = 12).

Results

All five gene promoters tested were highly methylated in the training group; methylation of SHOX2 promoter in primary tumors was associated with unfavorable outcome. RASSFIA and APC were found methylated in plasma-cfDNA samples at 14.3% and 11.9%, respectively, whereas in the corresponding CTCs SLFN11 and APC promoters were methylated in 7.1%. The incidence of relapses was higher in patients with a) promoter methylation of APC and SLFN11 in plasma-cfDNA (P = 0.037 and P = 0.042 respectively) and b) at least one detected methylated gene promoter in CTC or plasma-cfDNA (P = 0.015).

Conclusions

DNA methylation of these five gene promoters was significantly lower in CTCs and plasma-cfDNA than in the primary tumors. Combination of DNA methylation analysis in CTC and plasma-cfDNA was associated with worse DFI of NSCLC patients. Additional studies are required to validate our findings in a large cohort of early stage NSCLC patients.

Supplementary Information

The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1186/s13148-022-01283-x.

DNA Methylation Analysis in Plasma Cell-Free DNA and Paired CTCs of NSCLC Patients before and after Osimertinib Treatment

Osimertinib has been an effective second-line treatment in EGFR mutant NSCLC patients; however, resistance inevitably occurs. DNA methylation has been previously implicated in NSCLC progression and often in therapy resistance, however its distinct role in osimertinib resistance is not elucidated as yet. In the present study, we directly compared DNA methylation of nine selected genes (RASSF1A, RASSF10, APC, WIF-1, BRMS1, SLFN11, RARβ, SHISA3, and FOXA1) in plasma-cfDNA and paired CTCs of NSCLC patients who were longitudinally monitored during osimertinib treatment. Peripheral blood (PB) from 42 NSCLC patients was obtained at two time points: (a) baseline: before treatment with osimertinib and (b) at progression of disease (PD). DNA methylation of the selected genes was detected in plasma-cfDNA (n = 80) and in paired CTCs (n = 74). Direct comparison of DNA methylation of six genes between plasma-cfDNA and paired CTC samples (n = 70) revealed a low concordance, indicating that CTCs and cfDNA give complementary information. DNA methylation analysis of plasma-cfDNA and CTCs indicated that when at least one of these genes was methylated there was a statistically significant increase at PD compared to baseline (p = 0.031). For the first time, DNA methylation analysis in plasma-cfDNA and paired CTCs of NSCLC patients during osimertinib therapy indicated that DNA methylation of these genes could be a possible resistance mechanism.

USP44 Promoter Methylation in Plasma Cell-Free DNA in Prostate Cancer

Simple Summary

Liquid biopsy provides real-time monitoring of tumor evolution and response to therapy through analysis of circulating tumor cells (CTCs) and plasma-circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA). USP44 is a member of family proteins deubiquitinases, and plays an important role in cell growth; however, its accurate role in other cellular networks is under research. In this study, we examined for the first time USP44 promoter methylation in plasma cell-free DNA (cfDNA) of patients with prostate cancer (early stage n = 32, metastatic n = 39) and 10 healthy donors (HD). USP44 promoter methylation was detected in plasma cell-free DNA by a newly developed highly specific and sensitive real-time MSP method. We report for the first time that detection of USP44 promoter methylation in plasma cell free DNA provides significant prognostic information in metastatic prostate cancer.

Abstract

Liquid biopsy provides real-time monitoring of tumor evolution and response to therapy through analysis of circulating tumor cells (CTCs) and plasma-circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA). USP44 is a critical gene which plays an important role in cell proliferation; however, its accurate role in other cellular networks is under research. USP44 promoter methylation has been so far reported in colorectal neoplasia and metastatic breast cancer. In this study, we examined for the first time USP44 promoter methylation in plasma cell-free DNA (cfDNA) of patients with prostate cancer (early stage n = 32, metastatic n = 39) and 10 healthy donors (HD). USP44 promoter methylation was detected in plasma cell-free DNA by a newly developed highly specific and sensitive real-time MSP method. Our findings indicate that USP44 promoter is methylated in plasma cell-free DNA of metastatic prostate cancer patients and that detection of USP44 promoter methylation is significantly associated with overall survival (OS) (p = 0.008). We report for the first time that detection of USP44 promoter methylation in plasma cell free DNA provides significant prognostic information in metastatic prostate cancer.

Single Cell Genetic Profiling of Tumors of Breast Cancer Patients Aged 50 Years and Older Reveals Enormous Intratumor Heterogeneity Independent of Individual Prognosis

PURPOSE

Older breast cancer patients are underrepresented in cancer research even though the majority (81.4%) of women dying of breast cancer are 55 years and older. Here we study a common phenomenon observed in breast cancer which is a large inter- and intratumor heterogeneity; this poses a tremendous clinical challenge, for example with respect to treatment stratification. To further elucidate genomic instability and tumor heterogeneity in older patients, we analyzed the genetic aberration profiles of 39 breast cancer patients aged 50 years and older (median 67 years) with either short (median 2.4 years) or long survival (median 19 years). The analysis was based on copy number enumeration of eight breast cancer-associated genes using multiplex interphase fluorescence in situ hybridization (miFISH) of single cells, and by targeted next-generation sequencing of 563 cancer-related genes.

RESULTS

We detected enormous inter- and intratumor heterogeneity, yet maintenance of common cancer gene mutations and breast cancer specific chromosomal gains and losses. The gain of COX2 was most common (72%), followed by MYC (69%); losses were most prevalent for CDH1 (74%) and TP53 (69%). The degree of intratumor heterogeneity did not correlate with disease outcome. Comparing the miFISH results of diploid with aneuploid tumor samples significant differences were found: aneuploid tumors showed significantly higher average signal numbers, copy number alterations (CNAs) and instability indices. Mutations in PIKC3A were mostly restricted to luminal A tumors. Furthermore, a significant co-occurrence of CNAs of DBC2/MYC, HER2/DBC2 and HER2/TP53 and mutual exclusivity of CNAs of HER2 and PIK3CA mutations and CNAs of CCND1 and PIK3CA mutations were revealed.

CONCLUSION

Our results provide a comprehensive picture of genome instability profiles with a large variety of inter- and intratumor heterogeneity in breast cancer patients aged 50 years and older. In most cases, the distribution of chromosomal aneuploidies was consistent with previous results; however, striking exceptions, such as tumors driven by exclusive loss of chromosomes, were identified.

Genetic differences between benign phyllodes tumors and fibroadenomas revealed through targeted next generation sequencing

Breast fibroepithelial lesions are biphasic tumors which comprise the common benign fibroadenomas (FAs) and the rarer phyllodes tumors (PTs). This study analyzed 262 (42%) conventional FAs, 45 (7%) cellular FAs, and 321 (51%) benign PTs contributed by the International Fibroepithelial Consortium, using a previously curated 16 gene panel. Benign PTs were found to possess a higher number of mutations, and higher rates of cancer driver gene alterations than both groups of FAs, in particular MED12, TERT promoter, RARA, FLNA, SETD2, RB1, and EGFR. Cases with MED12 mutations were also more likely to have TERT promoter, RARA, SETD2, and EGFR. There were no significant differences detected between conventional FAs and cellular FAs, except for PIK3CA and MAP3K1. TERT promoter alterations were most optimal in discriminating between FAs and benign PTs. Our study affirms the role of sequencing and key mutations that may assist in refining diagnoses of these lesions.

ESR1 NAPA Assay: Development and Analytical Validation of a Highly Sensitive and Specific Blood-Based Assay for the Detection of ESR1 Mutations in Liquid Biopsies

Simple Summary

A considerable number of estrogen-receptor–positive (ER+) breast cancer patients develop resistance to endocrine treatment. One of the most important resistance mechanisms is the presence of ESR1 mutations. In the present study, we developed and analytically validated a novel, highly sensitive and specific nuclease-assisted minor-allele enrichment with probe-overlap (NaME-PrO)-assisted Amplification refractory mutation system (ARMS) (NAPA) assay for the detection of four ESR1 mutations (Y537S, Y537C, Y537N and D538G). The assay was further applied in 13 ER+ breast cancer (BrCa) primary tumour tissues (FFPEs), 13 non-cancerous breast tissues (mammoplasties), and 32 pairs of liquid biopsy samples [circulating tumour cells (CTCs) and paired plasma circulating tumour DNA (ctDNA)] obtained at different time points from 8 ER+ metastatic breast cancer patients. In the plasma ctDNA, the ESR1 mutations were not identified at the baseline, whereas the D538G mutation was detected during the follow-up period at five consecutive time points in one patient. In the CTCs, only the Y537C mutation was detected in one patient sample at the baseline. A direct comparison of the ESR1 NAPA assay with the drop-off ddPCR using 32 identical plasma ctDNA samples gave a concordance of 90.6%. We present a low-cost, highly specific, sensitive and robust assay for blood-based ESR1 profiling.

Abstract

A considerable number of estrogen receptor-positive breast cancer (ER⁺ BrCa) patients develop resistance to endocrine treatment. One of the most important resistance mechanisms is the presence of ESR1 mutations. We developed and analytically validated a highly sensitive and specific NaME-PrO-assisted ARMS (NAPA) assay for the detection of four ESR1 mutations (Y537S, Y537C, Y537N and D538G) in circulating tumour cells (CTCs) and paired plasma circulating tumour DNA (ctDNA) in patients with ER⁺ BrCa. The analytical specificity, analytical sensitivity and reproducibility of the assay were validated using synthetic oligos standards. We further applied the developed ESR1 NAPA assay in 13 ER⁺ BrCa primary tumour tissues, 13 non-cancerous breast tissues (mammoplasties) and 64 liquid biopsy samples: 32 EpCAM-positive cell fractions and 32 paired plasma ctDNA samples obtained at different time points from 8 ER+ metastatic breast cancer patients, during a 5-year follow-up period. Peripheral blood from 11 healthy donors (HD) was used as a control. The developed assay is highly sensitive (a detection of mutation-allelic-frequency (MAF) of 0.5% for D538G and 0.1% for Y537S, Y537C, Y537N), and highly specific (0/13 mammoplasties and 0/11 HD for all mutations). In the plasma ctDNA, ESR1 mutations were not identified at the baseline, whereas the D538G mutation was detected in five sequential ctDNA samples during the follow-up period in the same patient. In the EpCAM-isolated cell fractions, only the Y537C mutation was detected in one patient sample at the baseline. A direct comparison of the ESR1 NAPA assay with the drop-off ddPCR using 32 identical plasma ctDNA samples gave a concordance of 90.6%. We present a low cost, highly specific, sensitive and robust assay for blood-based ESR1 profiling. The clinical performance of the ESR1 NAPA assay will be prospectively evaluated in a large number of well-characterized patient cohorts.

Concurrent Aspirin Use Is Associated with Improved Outcome in Rectal Cancer Patients Who Undergo Chemoradiation Therapy

BACKGROUND

The benefit of aspirin in rectal cancer during chemoradiation therapy (CRT) and the factors affecting its efficacy are not well characterized. We compared the outcomes of rectal patients undergoing neoadjuvant CRT based on aspirin use.

METHODS

Patients undergoing CRT for rectal cancer from 2010 to 2018 were evaluated. Aspirin use was determined by medication list prior to treatment. RNA sequencing and subsequent gene set enrichment analysis was performed on surgically resected specimens.

RESULTS

147 patients underwent neoadjuvant CRT with a median follow-up of 38.2 months. Forty-two patients were taking aspirin prior to CRT. Aspirin users had significantly less local and distant progression, and improved progression-free and overall survival. On RNA-sequencing, neither PI3KCA nor KRAS mutational status were associated with the benefit of aspirin use or tumor downstaging. PTGS2/COX2 expression trended lower in aspirin users, but not with tumor response. Aspirin use was associated with increases of M1 macrophages, plasma cells, CD8+ T cells, and reduction of M2 macrophages in the resected tumor.

CONCLUSIONS

Concurrent aspirin use during neoadjuvant CRT was associated with improved local and distant tumor control leading to significantly improved survival. Neither mutations in KRAS or PI3CKA, nor the levels of COX-2 expression at the time of resection of the residual tumor were predictive of these aspirin benefits.

KMT2C promoter methylation in plasma-circulating tumor DNA is a prognostic biomarker in non-small cell lung cancer

MLL3 histone methyltransferase, encoded by the KMT2C gene, is a tumor suppressor that has an essential role in cell‐type‐specific gene expression. We evaluated the prognostic significance of KMT2C promoter methylation as a circulating epigenetic biomarker in plasma cell‐free DNA (cfDNA) in non‐small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). We examined the methylation status of KMT2C promoter using a novel highly specific and sensitive real‐time methylation‐specific PCR (MSP) assay in (a) operable NSCLC: 48 fresh‐frozen NSCLC tissues, their corresponding adjacent non‐neoplastic tissues, and 48 matched plasma samples; (b) metastatic NSCLC: 91 plasma samples; and (c) 60 plasma samples from healthy donors (HD). KMT2C promoter methylation in plasma cfDNA was detected in 7/48 (14.6%) patients with operable and in 18/91 (19.8%) patients with advanced NSCLC but in none (0/60, 0%) of the plasma samples from HD. In operable NSCLC, in corresponding adjacent non‐neoplastic tissue samples, KMT2C promoter methylation was detected in 3/48 (6.3%) cases. Moreover, in operable NSCLC, KMT2C promoter methylation in plasma cfDNA was related to reduced disease‐free survival (ΗR = 0.239; P = 0.001) and worse overall survival (OS; HR = 0.342, P = 0.023). In metastatic NSCLC, KMT2C promoter methylation in plasma cfDNA was related to worse progression‐free survival (PFS; HR = 0.431; P = 0.005) and worse OS (HR = 0.306; P < 0.001). Our data strongly suggest that the detection of KMT2C promoter methylation in plasma cfDNA predicts poor prognosis in patients with both operable and metastatic NSCLCs. KMT2C promoter methylation in plasma cfDNA therefore merits further evaluation and validation as a noninvasive circulating epigenetic biomarker.

Droplet-digital PCR reveals frequent mutations in TERT promoter region in breast fibroadenomas and phyllodes tumours, irrespective of the presence of MED12 mutations

BACKGROUND

Breast fibroadenoma (FA) and phyllodes tumour (PT) often have variations of gene mediator complex subunit 12 (MED12) and mutations in the telomerase reverse transcriptase promoter region (TERTp). TERTp mutation is usually tested by Sanger sequencing. In this study, we compared Sanger sequencing and droplet-digital PCR (ddPCR) to measure TERTp mutations in FA and PT samples.

METHODS

FA and PT samples were collected from 82 patients who underwent surgery at our institution from 2005 to 2016. MED12 mutations for all cases and TERTp mutations for 17 tumours were detected by Sanger sequencing. ddPCR was performed to analyse TERTp mutation in all cases.

RESULTS

A total of 75 samples were eligible for analysis. Sanger sequencing detected MED12 mutations in 19/44 FA (42%) and 21/31 PT (68%). Among 17 Sanger sequencing-tested samples, 2/17 (12%) were TERTp mutation-positive. In ddPCR analyses, a significantly greater percentage of PT (19/31, 61%) was TERTp mutation-positive than was FA (13/44, 30%; P = 0.0046). The mutation positivity of TERTp and MED12 did not correlate, in either FA or PT.

CONCLUSIONS

ddPCR was more sensitive for detecting TERTp mutation than Sanger sequencing, being able to elucidate tumorigenesis in FA and PT.

SLAM-MS: Mutation scanning of stem-loop amplicons with TaqMan probes by quantitative DNA melting analysis

DNA Melting Analysis (DMA) with a TaqMan probe covering the mutation “hot spot” is a simple, sensitive, and “closed tube” method of mutation detection. However, DMA requires asymmetric PCR to produce single-stranded amplicons capable of interacting with TaqMan probes. This makes quantitative analysis impossible owing to low amplification efficiency. Moreover, bi-strand mutation detection necessitates two independent PCRs. The SLAM-MS (Stem-Loop AMplicon Mutation Scanning) assay, in which symmetric PCR is performed using primers with 5'-universal primer sequence (UPS), has been developed to detect KRAS mutations. Some of the resulting amplicons, sense and antisense, adopt single-stranded stem-loop conformation and become unable to renature, but able to hybridize with TaqMan probes. Hybrids of stem-loops and complementary TaqMan probes are suitable for melting analysis and simultaneous bi-strand mutation scanning. In addition, the areas under the melting peaks are determined by the PeakFit software, a non-linear iterative curve fitting program, to evaluate the wild-type/mutant allele ratio. Thus, the SLAM-MS assay permits quantification of both the number of copies of the target sequence and the percentage of mutant alleles. For mutant enrichment, the SLAM-MS assay uses TaqMan probes as PCR blocking agents allowing an ~10 times higher mutation detection sensitivity than High Resolution Melting (HRM) assay.

Asymmetric mutant-enriched polymerase chain reaction and quantitative DNA melting analysis of KRAS mutation in colorectal cancer

Identification of mutant genes in tumor tissues and blood plasma (solid and liquid biopsy samples, respectively) is a necessity for individualized treatment of cancer patients. Here we report the use of a novel mutant-enriched PCR - quantitative DNA melting curve analysis (mePCR-qDMA) with TaqMan probes. The TaqMan probes served as blocking agents during PCR and as hybridization probes during DNA melting curve analyses. The end-point measurement of melt peaks areas by PeakFit software, a nonlinear iterative curve-fitting program, permitted quantification of the mutant/wild-type allele ratios. Approximately 6% and 0.1% of mutant KRAS allele in an excess of wild-type allele is detected with the standard and mePCR-qDMA processes, respectively. The application of the approach was tested for detecting the KRAS codon 12/13 mutation in paired tumor and blood plasma samples from 20 colorectal cancer patients. KRAS mutants were detected in 7 and 18 FFPE tumor samples, and in 3 and 7 plasma samples by the standard and mePCR-qDMA process, respectively. The results were confirmed by Sanger sequencing. This simple, rapid, cost-effective, and quantitative method carried out in a closed-tube format could be applied for the clinical analyses of other cancer genes.

A Systematic Literature Review of the Prognostic and Predictive Value of PIK3CA Mutations in HR+/HER2- Metastatic Breast Cancer

PIK3CA mutations may have prognostic value for patients with hormone receptor-positive/human epidermal growth factor receptor 2-negative metastatic breast cancer, representing an important potential target for systemic therapy. Prognostic and predictive values associated with PIK3CA mutations are not well understood. A comprehensive search of PubMed/MEDLINE, EMBASE, Cochrane Central, and conference abstracts was performed for English-language articles published January 1993 through April 2019. Articles were categorized by treatment arms based on experimental and treatment drug classes. Information on progression-free survival (PFS), hazard ratios, overall survival, response rate, and clinical benefit rate was obtained. A total of 17 studies were included. Among those evaluating non-PI3Ki based therapies, 91% showed numerically shorter median PFS, ranging from 1.5 to 19.2 months and 1.8 to 29.6 months for the mutant versus non-mutant subgroups, respectively. Where reported (n = 13 studies), PFS was shorter between those arms offering endocrine monotherapy (range, 1.6-14.7 months) compared with a corresponding targeted therapy + endocrine monotherapy (range, 3.9-29.6 months). Of 5 PI3Ki-based arms comparing PFS, higher median PFS in PIK3CA mutant versus non-mutant cases was demonstrated. PFS was shorter for patients with PIK3CA mutant (range, 1.6-19.2 months) compared with PIK3CA wild-type (range, 1.8-29.6 months) in 10 (71%) of 14 treatment arms reporting PFS. Studies (n = 4) not reporting PFS reported response rate, but there were no clear directional trends. The presence of PIK3CA mutations may be associated with worse clinical outcomes in patients with hormone receptor-positive/human epidermal growth factor receptor 2-negative metastatic breast cancer. Clinical outcomes such as PFS may be improved using a combination of PI3Ki-based therapies and endocrine therapies among this population. However, more research is warranted to fully elucidate this association.

The genomic mutation spectrums of breast fibroadenomas in Chinese population by whole exome sequencing analysis

Fibroadenomas (FAs) are the most common fibroepithelial lesions and the most common benign tumors of the breast in women of reproductive age. Although MED12 mutations, an overwhelming majority of all mutations, and some other gene mutations have been found in FAs, the genomic landscapes of FAs are still not completely clear and the genomic mutation spectrums of FAs in Chinese population remains unknown. Here, by performing whole exome sequencing of 12 FAs and the corresponding normal breast tissues in Chinese Han population, we observed the somatic and germline landscapes of genetic alterations. We identified 16 recurrently mutated genes with 37 nonsynonymous or frameshift somatic mutations and 27 recurrent somatic copy number variants (CNVs). In these mutated genes, MED12 was the most common in FAs, harboring 6 nonsynonymous/frameshift somatic mutations and 1 CNV. In addition, 6 germline mutations of tumor susceptibility genes in 5 FAs were identified and the tumor mutational burden of the 5 FAs was significantly higher than the other 7 FAs without germline mutations. This study provides genomic mutation spectrums of FAs in Chinese population and expand the genetic spectrum of FAs.

ESR1 Methylation: A Liquid Biopsy-Based Epigenetic Assay for the Follow-up of Patients with Metastatic Breast Cancer Receiving Endocrine Treatment

Purpose: Liquid biopsy provides real-time monitoring of tumor evolution and response to therapy through analysis of circulating tumor cells (CTCs) and plasma-circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA). ESR1 epigenetic silencing potentially affects response to endocrine treatment. We evaluated ESR1 methylation in CTCs and paired plasma ctDNA. We evaluated ESR1 methylation in CTCs and paired plasma ctDNA as a potential biomarker for response to everolimus/exemestane treatment.Experimental Design: A highly sensitive and specific real-time MSP assay for ESR1 methylation was developed and validated in (i) 65 primary breast tumors formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE), (ii) EpCAM⁺ CTC fractions (122 patients and 30 healthy donors; HD), (iii) plasma ctDNA (108 patients and 30HD), and (iv) in CTCs (CellSearch) and in paired plasma ctDNA for 58 patients with breast cancer. ESR1 methylation status was investigated in CTCs isolated from serial peripheral blood samples of 19 patients with ER⁺/HER2^- advanced breast cancer receiving everolimus/exemestane.Results:ESR1 methylation was detected in: (i) 25/65 (38.5%) FFPEs, (ii) EpCAM⁺ CTC fractions: 26/112 (23.3%) patients and 1/30 (3.3%) HD, and (iii) plasma ctDNA: 8/108 (7.4%) patients and 1/30 (3.3%) HD. ESR1 methylation was highly concordant in 58 paired DNA samples, isolated from CTCs (CellSearch) and corresponding plasma. In serial peripheral blood samples of patients treated with everolimus/exemestane, ESR1 methylation was observed in 10/36 (27.8%) CTC-positive samples, and was associated with lack of response to treatment (P = 0.023, Fisher exact test).Conclusions: We report for the first time the detection of ESR1 methylation in CTCs and a high concordance with paired plasma ctDNA. ESR1 methylation in CTCs was associated with lack of response to everolimus/exemestane regimen. ESR1 methylation should be further evaluated as a potential liquid biopsy-based biomarker. Clin Cancer Res; 24(6); 1500-10. ©2017 AACR.

SLCO1B3 screening in colorectal cancer patients using High-Resolution Melting Analysis method and immunohistochemistry

Personalized medicine has made some major advances in colorectal cancer, but new biomarkers still remain a hot issue as an emerging tool with potential prognostic and therapeutic potential. We investigated for SLCO1B3 gene alterations and protein expression in colorectal cancer, using the novel high-resolution melting analysis technique and immunohistochemistry. Formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded tumor samples from 30 colorectal cancer patients were used. The screening for gene alterations was done by high-resolution melting analysis for all exons of SLCO1B3 gene. Organic anion-transporting polypeptide 1B3 protein expression was assessed by immunohistochemistry using the monoclonal mouse MDQ antibody. High level of polymorphism was observed in the SLCO1B3 gene. We identified three previously reported polymorphisms in exons 7, 12, and 14, 699G>A, 1557A>G, and 1833G>A, respectively. In the exon 5, one variant seems to correspond to an as yet unknown SLCO family member. The immunohistochemical study revealed that organic anion-transporting polypeptide 1B3 was expressed in 27/30 samples. Of great interest, the three samples, which were immunohistochemically negative, all appeared to accommodate mutations which lead to either early stop codons or other conformations of the tertiary protein structures affecting the antibody-epitope binding. The results of this study are of much interest as high-resolution melting analysis proved to be a reliable and rapid genotyping/scanning method for mutation detection of SLCO1B3 gene.

TaqMan probes as blocking agents for enriched PCR amplification and DNA melting analysis of mutant genes

Asymmetric PCR and DNA melting analysis with TaqMan probes applied for mutation detection is effectively used in clinical diagnostics. The method is simple, cost-effective, and carried out in a closed-tube format, minimizing time, labor, and risk of sample cross-contamination. Although DNA melting analysis is more sensitive than Sanger sequencing (mutation detection thresholds are ∼5% and 15%–20%, respectively), it is less sensitive than more labor-intensive and expensive techniques such as pyrosequencing and droplet digital PCR. Here, we demonstrate that, under specially selected conditions of asymmetric PCR, TaqMan probes can play the role of blocking agents. Preferential blocking of the wild-type allele brings about enriched amplification of mutant alleles. As a result, an ∼10-fold increase in the detection sensitivity for mutant BRAF and NRAS genes was achieved.

Highly Selective Capture Surfaces on Medical Wires for Fishing Tumor Cells in Whole Blood

The detection of circulating tumor cells (CTCs) in the blood of cancer patients is a challenging task. CTCs are, especially at the early stages of cancer development, extremely rare cells hidden in a vast background of regular blood cells. We describe a new strategy for the isolation of CTCs from whole blood. The key component is a medical wire coated with a multilayer assembly that allows highly specific capture of EpCAM (epithelial cell adhesion molecule) positive CTCs from blood. The assembly is generated in a layer-by-layer fashion through photochemically induced C,H insertion reactions and consists of a protective layer, which shields the contacting solution from the metal, a protein resistant layer, which prevents nonspecific interactions with proteins and a layer containing the EpCAM antibodies. In vitro experiments show that these surfaces can capture tumor cells from whole blood with enrichment factors (specifically vs nonspecifically bound cells) of up to about 3000 compared to the number of leucocytes in the blood. The purity of the isolated cells is greater than 90%. After "fishing" them from the blood, the cells, still bound to the wire, can be genetically analyzed. This demonstrates that this strategy might prove useful for next generation sequencing.

Asymmetric real-time PCR and multiplex melting curve analysis with TaqMan probes for detecting PIK3CA mutations

The data in this article are related to the research article entitled "Optimization of melting analysis with TaqMan probes for detection of KRAS, NRAS, and BRAF mutations" Botezatu et al. [1]. Somatic mutations in the PIK3CA gene ("hot spots" in exons 9 and 20) are found in many human cancers, and their presence can determine prognosis and a treatment strategy. An effective method of mutation scanning PIK3CA in clinical laboratories is DNA Melting Analysis (DMA) (Vorkas et al., 2010; Simi et al., 2008) [2], [3]. It was demonstrated recently that the TaqMan probes which have been long used in Real Time PCR may also be utilized in DMA (Huang et al., 2011) [4]. After optimization of this method Botezatu et al. [1], it was used for multiplex scanning PIK3CA hotspot mutations in formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) samples from patients with colorectal and lung cancer.

Investigating the Inhibitory Effect of Wortmannin in the Hotspot Mutation at Codon 1047 of PIK3CA Kinase Domain: A Molecular Docking and Molecular Dynamics Approach

Oncogenic mutations in phosphatidylinositol-4,5-bisphosphate 3-kinase, catalytic subunit alpha (PIK3CA) are the most frequently reported in association with various forms of cancer. Several studies have reported the significance of hotspot mutations in a catalytic subunit of PIK3CA in association with breast cancer. Mutations are frequently observed in the highly conserved region of the kinase domain (797-1068 amino acids) of PIK3CA are activating or gain-of-function mutations. Mutation in codon 1047 occurs in the C-terminal region of the kinase domain with histidine (H) replaced by arginine (R), lysine (L), and tyrosine (Y). Pathogenicity and protein stability predictors PhD-SNP, Align GVGD, HANSA, iStable, and MUpro classified H1047R as highly deleterious when compared to H1047L and H1047Y. To explore the inhibitory activity of Wortmannin toward PIK3CA, the three-dimensional structure of the mutant protein was determined using homology modeling followed by molecular docking and molecular dynamics analysis. Docking studies were performed for the three mutants and native with Wortmannin to measure the differences in their binding pattern. Comparative docking study revealed that H1047R-Wortmannin complex has a higher number of hydrogen bonds as well as the best binding affinity next to the native protein. Furthermore, 100 ns molecular dynamics simulation was initiated with the docked complexes to understand the various changes induced by the mutation. Though Wortmannin was found to nullify the effect of H1047R over the protein, further studies are required for designing a better compound. As SNPs are major genetic variations observed in disease condition, personalized medicine would provide enhanced drug therapy.

PIK3CA mutational status in circulating tumor cells can change during disease recurrence or progression in patients with breast cancer

PURPOSE

Molecular characterization of circulating tumor cells (CTC) is crucial for the investigation of molecular-targeted therapies while PIK3CA somatic mutations play a crucial role in therapy response. We investigated the presence of PIK3CA mutations in CTC and whether this is associated with clinical outcome.

EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN

We developed and validated an ultrasensitive methodology for the detection of PIK3CA mutations that is based on a combination of allele-specific, asymmetric rapid PCR and melting analysis. We analyzed PIK3CA hotspot mutations in: (i) a training group consisting of EpCAM-positive CTC fraction from 37 patients with clinically confirmed metastasis, and 26 healthy female volunteers and 15 primary breast tumor tissues and (ii) an independent group consisting of EpCAM-positive CTC fraction from 57 metastatic and 118 operable breast cancer patients and 76 corresponding primary tumors.

RESULTS

The assay could detect 0.05% of mutated dsDNA in the presence of 99.95% wtDNA for both exons (9 and 20) and was highly specific (0/26 healthy donors). PIK3CA mutations were identified in EpCAM-positive CTC in 20 of 57(35.1%) and in 23 of 118 (19.5%) patients with metastatic and operable breast cancer, and in 45 of 76(59.2%) corresponding FFPEs. Our data indicate that PIK3CA mutational status in CTCs can change during disease progression and is associated with worse survival (P = 0.047).

CONCLUSIONS

PIK3CA hotspot mutations are present at a relatively high frequency in CTCs and their presence is associated with worse survival in patients with breast cancer with metastasis. Evaluation of PIK3CA mutational status in CTCs is a strategy with potential clinical application.

Rapid and efficient zebrafish genotyping using PCR with high-resolution melt analysis

Zebrafish is a powerful vertebrate model system for studying development, modeling disease, and performing drug screening. Recently a variety of genetic tools have been introduced, including multiple strategies for inducing mutations and generating transgenic lines. However, large-scale screening is limited by traditional genotyping methods, which are time-consuming and labor-intensive. Here we describe a technique to analyze zebrafish genotypes by PCR combined with high-resolution melting analysis (HRMA). This approach is rapid, sensitive, and inexpensive, with lower risk of contamination artifacts. Genotyping by PCR with HRMA can be used for embryos or adult fish, including in high-throughput screening protocols.

Analysis of PIK3CA exon 9 and 20 mutations in breast cancers using PCR-HRM and PCR-ARMS: correlation with clinicopathological criteria

Phosphatidylinositol-3-kinases (PI3K) are essential for cell signaling, proliferation, differentiation and survival. The catalytic subunit of PI3K, encoded by the PIK3CA oncogene, is mutated in 18-45% of breast carcinomas. These mutations, involved in tumorigenic processes, activate the PI3K/AKT/mTOR signaling pathway. Resistance to anti‑human epidermal growth factor receptor, hormonal or anti-PI3K therapies have been described in breast carcinomas bearing activation of the PI3K signaling pathway. The present study reports the evaluation of PIK3CA exon 9 and 20 mutations in 149 invasive breast cancer cases using a validated PCR-high resolution melting assay (PCR-HRM). An amplification refractory mutation system (PCR-ARMS) using allele-specific scorpion primers was used to detect hotspot mutations in exons 9 (c.1624G→A and c.1633G→A) and 20 (c.3140A→G and c.3140A→T) in 118 tumor specimens. No correlation was observed with age at diagnosis, histological type, hormone receptor and HER2 status. PIK3CA exon 9 and 20 mutations were found to be related to Scarff-Bloom-Richardson (SBR) grade with a lower rate of mutations and a higher frequency of exon 9 mutations in SBRI and exon 20 mutations in SBRII/III tumors. No difference was observed in the incidence rates of the two different mutations screened for each exon in any subcategory. A statistically significant correlation was found between PCR-HRM and PCR-ARMS (κ=0.845; P<0.001). PCR-ARMS was found to be more sensitive than PCR-HRM (sensitivity 0.5 and 5-10% of mutated DNA, respectively). We propose that PCR-HRM and PCR-ARMS can be combined for the cost-effective routine clinical identification of PIK3CA mutations for the purpose of personalizing therapy for invasive breast cancers.

Phosphatidylinositol-3-kinase pathway mutations are common in breast columnar cell lesions

The phosphatidylinositol-3-kinase pathway is one of the most commonly mutated pathways in invasive breast carcinoma, with PIK3CA mutations in ∼25% of invasive carcinomas, and AKT1 mutations in up to 5%. Ductal carcinoma in situ, and benign papillomas harbor similar mutations. However, activating point mutations in breast columnar cell lesions have been infrequently studied. Twenty-three breast resection specimens containing columnar cell lesions were identified; 14 with associated invasive carcinoma or carcinoma in situ. DNA extracts were prepared from formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded tissue and screened for a panel of point mutations (321 mutations in 30 genes) using a multiplex PCR panel with mass-spectroscopy readout. PIK3CA mutations were identified in 13/24 columnar cell lesions (54%) and 3/8 invasive carcinomas (37%). The mutation status of columnar cell lesions and associated carcinoma was frequently discordant. Of the 14 cases, only 5 demonstrated the same genotype in matched samples of columnar cell lesions and carcinoma (4 wild type, 1 PIK3CA H1047R). Interestingly, five patients had mutations in columnar cell lesions with wild-type carcinoma; two patients had different point mutations in columnar cell lesions and carcinoma. Only three cases had wild-type columnar cell lesion and mutated carcinoma. The 50% PIK3CA mutation prevalence in columnar cell lesions is greater than reported in most studies of invasive breast cancer. Further, columnar cell lesions and carcinoma were frequently discordant for PIK3CA/AKT1 mutation status. These findings raise interesting questions about the role of PIK3CA/AKT pathway in breast carcinogenesis, and the biologic/precursor potential of columnar cell lesions.