Leaching from denture base materials in vitro

High performance liquid chromatographic determination of residual monomer released from heat-cured acrylic resin. An in vivo study

PURPOSE

Heat-polymerized acrylic resins are used in dentistry for complete denture fabrication. Despite the polymerization method, conversion of monomer into polymer is often incomplete with free or unreacted residual monomer remaining in the polymerized resin. The aim of this study was to determine the amount of residual monomeric methyl methacrylate (MMA) leaching in the saliva of patients wearing complete dentures in their postinsertion period.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Thirty edentulous participants as first-time complete denture wearers (age 60 to 65 years) were selected. All the prostheses were fabricated using a similar standard technique with a heat-cured acrylic resin denture base material. Saliva samples were collected at time intervals of 1 hour, 1 day, and 3 days postdenture insertion. Participants were asked to discharge saliva every 30 seconds into a pre-weighed screw-capped container for a 5-minute period. MMA levels were measured using high performance liquid chromatography. Data were analyzed by ANOVA and Tukey-HSD.

RESULTS

The maximum concentration of monomer released into saliva peaked 1 day after insertion of the complete dentures. The mean (SD) MMA content was 0.04 ± 0.01 (μg/ml) 1 hour after insertion, and 0.3 ± 0.09 (μg/ml), and 0.05 ± 0.01 (μg/ml) on the first and third days postinsertion, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

Although the released monomeric MMA was not at toxic levels, it could potentially sensitize complete denture patients or elicit an allergic reaction. The risk of the residual material as a primary irritant for a sensitizing reaction could be minimized by immersion of the denture in water for 24 hours before insertion.

In vitro evaluation of long-term cytotoxic response of injection-molded polyamide and polymethyle metacrylate denture base materials on primary fibroblast cell culture

OBJECTIVE

This study investigated the long-term cytotoxic response of thermoplastic polyamide and conventional polymethyle metacrylate (PMMA) denture base materials.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Twenty discs were prepared for each polyamide, heat and cold cured PMMA denture base resins (totally 60) and divided into four sub-groups (n = 5). Cytotoxicity was assessed with the direct cell contact method using cell viability and neutral red (NR) uptake assay. Each sub-group was tested at initial and after being aged for 24 h, 1 week and 8 weeks with artificial saliva according to ISO 10993 standards.

RESULTS

There were no significantly difference among the materials and control groups after initial, 24 h and 1 week testing. In 24 h testing, only Deflex was more toxic according to the Control group (p < 0.05). After 8 weeks of aging with artificial saliva, all materials were significantly cytotoxic when compared to the control group. QC20 was more toxic than Deflex and SC Cold Cure (p < 0.05). There were significant differences between the 8 week aging group and the initial, 24 h and 1 week testing for all materials (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Cytotoxicity of all tested denture base materials increased significantly after the long-term aging. Therefore, long-term aging may be useful to determine a dental material's toxicity. Polyamide denture base material had a similar toxicity profile with conventional heat- and cold-cured PMMA.

Identification and quantification of leachable substances from polymer-based orthodontic base-plate materials

The aim of this study was to analyse leachable monomers, additives, and degradation products from polymer-based orthodontic base-plate materials. One heat-cured resin (Orthocryl), one light-cured (Triad VLC), and three thermoplastic materials (Biocryl C, Essix A+, and Essix Embrace) were investigated. Elution was performed in water at 37°C for 10 days. The extract medium was changed and analysed daily. Chromatographic methods were used to identify and quantify the leachables. In addition, the content of residual methyl methacrylate (MMA) was quantified in the poly(methyl methacrylate) (PMMA)-based materials. Statistical analysis of the quantitative results was performed using a t-test for comparison of two independent samples. Monomers and additives leached from the materials polymerized in situ and from the thermoplastic PMMA-based material. No leachable substances were found in the extracts from the other thermoplastic materials. Accumulated over 10 days, a larger amount of MMA leached from the powder-and-liquid material, Orthocryl (42 μg/cm(2)), than from the thermoplastic material, Biocryl C (0.49 μg/cm(2)). The accumulated amounts of monomers leached from Triad VLC were 91 μg/cm(2) of urethane dimethacrylate and 2.2 μg/cm(2) of 2-hydroxyethyl methacrylate. Formaldehyde was found to leach from methacrylate-based materials: 3.2 μg/cm(2) from Orthocryl and 0.16 μg/cm(2) from Triad VLC. However, formaldehyde was not detectable in extracts from Biocryl C. Residual MMA was 5.4 wt % in Orthocryl and 0.4 wt % in Biocryl C. No phthalates were detected in the tested materials. In this in vitro study, minimal leaching was found from the thermoplastic materials, while leaching of methacrylates and formaldehyde was observed from the powder-and-liquid type and the paste material. Within the limitations of this study, the results suggest that prefabricated thermoplastic plates should be preferred for patients with an allergy to methacrylates.

Effect of post-polymerization heat treatments on the cytotoxicity of two denture base acrylic resins

INTRODUCTION

Most denture base acrylic resins have polymethylmethacrylate in their composition. Several authors have discussed the polymerization process involved in converting monomer into polymer because adequate polymerization is a crucial factor in optimizing the physical properties and biocompatibility of denture base acrylic resins. To ensure the safety of these materials, in vitro cytotoxicity assays have been developed as preliminary screening tests to evaluate material biocompatibility. (3)H-thymidine incorporation test, which measures the number of cells synthesizing DNA, is one of the biological assays suggested for cytotoxicity testing.

AIM

The purpose of this study was to investigate, using (3)H-thymidine incorporation test, the effect of microwave and water-bath post-polymerization heat treatments on the cytotoxicity of two denture base acrylic resins.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Nine disc-shaped specimens (10 x 1 mm) of each denture base resin (Lucitone 550 and QC 20) were prepared according to the manufacturers' recommendations and stored in distilled water at 37 degrees C for 48 h. The specimens were assigned to 3 groups: 1) post-polymerization in a microwave oven for 3 min at 500 W; 2) post-polymerization in water-bath at 55 degrees C for 60 min; and 3) without post-polymerization. For preparation of eluates, 3 discs were placed into a sterile glass vial with 9 mL of Eagle's medium and incubated at 37 degrees C for 24 h. The cytotoxic effect of the eluates was evaluated by (3)H-thymidine incorporation.

RESULTS

The results showed that the components leached from the resins were cytotoxic to L929 cells, except for the specimens heat treated in water bath (p<0.05). Compared to the group with no heat treatment, water-bath decreased the cytotoxicity of the denture base acrylic resins.

CONCLUSION

The in vitro cytotoxicity of the tested denture base materials was not influenced by microwave post-polymerization heat treatment.

Molecular mechanics and molecular orbital simulations on specific interactions between peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor PPARalpha and plasticizer

Peroxisome proliferator-activated receptor alpha (PPARalpha) has various physiological functions such as lipid and glucose metabolism, inflammation and fibrosis in living organisms. Many types of ligand molecules such as phthalate and adipate esters control these physiological functions. In the present study, to elucidate the dependence of PPARalpha properties on ligand binding, we investigated stable structures and electronic properties for the complexes of PPARalpha and phthalate as well as adipate esters, which are used as a plasticizer, by molecular simulations based on molecular mechanics and molecular orbital methods. Furthermore, to elucidate the influence of these esters in vivo, we injected them into male mice and observed the change in the expression of PPARalpha-related enzymes. The comparison between the calculated and observed results indicates that the change in the expression has a correlation with the size of energy gaps between highest occupied and lowest unoccupied molecular orbitals of the complexes with mouse PPARalpha and esters.

Biocompatibility of denture base acrylic resins evaluated in culture of L929 cells. Effect of polymerisation cycle and post-polymerisation treatments

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effect of two post-polymerisation treatments and different cycles of polymerisation on the cytotoxicity of two denture base resins.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The resins tested were Lucitone 550 and QC 20. Discs of resins were fabricated following the manufacturer's instructions. Lucitone 550 was processed by long cycle or short cycle. The resin QC 20 was processed by reverse cycle or normal cycle. The specimens were divided into groups: (i) post-polymerised in microwave for 3 min at 500 W; (ii) post-polymerised in water-bath at 55 degrees C for 60 min and (iii) without post-polymerisation. Eluates were prepared by placing three discs into a sterile glass vial with 9 ml of Eagle's medium and incubated at 37 degrees C for 24 hours. L929 cells were seeded into 96 well culture plates and DNA synthesis was assessed by (3)H-thymidine incorporation assay.

RESULTS

The results were submitted to two-way anova and Tukey HSD test. QC 20 specimens polymerised by the normal cycle and submitted to microwave post-polymerisation were graded as moderately cytotoxic. Similar results were observed for Lucitone 550 processed by long cycle without post-polymerisation. The other experimental groups were graded as not cytotoxic. After water-bath post-polymerisation, specimens of Lucitone 550 processed by long cycle produced significantly lower inhibition of DNA synthesis than the other groups.

CONCLUSION

The long cycle increased the cytotoxicity of Lucitone 550 and water-bath post-polymerisation reduced the cytotoxicity of Lucitone 550 processed by long cycle.

HPLC determination of residual monomers released from heat-cured acrylic resins

HPLC was used to examine the leachability of three non-phthalic and four phthalic post-polymerized residual monomers from three commercially available heat-cured acrylic resins. Specimens of equal dimensions were constructed from each brand of material by following the standardized procedure and were stored under three different conditions, namely, distilled water, artificial saliva, and a binary mixture of ethanol/water. The resulting liquids provided samples for analysis by HPLC. Three different experiments were performed for each brand of acrylic and each storage condition in order to examine the effects of parameters, particularly time and temperature. The results obtained from this study suggest that a wide spectrum of residues diffuse out of the three examined acrylic resin materials. The non-phthalic compounds were leached at high concentrations, whereas all the phthalates examined exhibited different degrees of elusion commensurate with the storage condition, brand of material, and type of experiment. It seems that a significant quantity of non-phthalic and phthalic residues diffuse out of the acrylic resin materials examined. The main component extracted was methyl methacrylate, the level of which seems to be time-dependent and decreases for a period of up to 5 days when resins are stored in distilled water at room temperature.

Estrogenic activity of tissue conditioners in vitro

OBJECTIVES

In order to assess the estrogenic activities of plasticizers used in tissue conditioners and four commercial tissue conditioners, we carried out in vitro tests.

METHODS

Seven plasticizers and two metabolites were diluted to concentrations ranging from 10(-9) to 10(-4)M. Four commercial tissue conditioners were also diluted to concentrations ranging from 2 x 10(-8) to 2 x 10(-3)g/ml. Estrogenic activities were tested by the E-screen test using MCF-7 cells. When estrogen is present, the cells proliferate. Instead of counting the cells or nuclei directly, cell numbers were assessed by measurement of the total protein content using the sulforhodamine B assay. The liquid compositions of the four commercial tissue conditioners were examined by high-performance liquid chromatography.

RESULTS

n-Butyl benzyl phthalate, dibutyl phthalate, n-butyl phthalyl n-butyl glycolate, di-2-ethylhexyl phthalate and benzyl salicylate significantly increased proliferation of MCF-7 cells. The remaining two plasticizers, di-2-ethylhexyl adipate and benzyl benzoate, as well as two metabolites of dibutyl phthalate and di-2-ethylhexyl phthalate, i.e. monobutyl phthalate and mono-2-ethylhexyl phthalate, respectively, did not increase proliferation of MCF-7 cells at the concentrations tested. Four commercial tissue conditioners, Coe comfort (CC), Tissue Conditioner (TC), Hydro Cast (HC) and Denture Soft (DS) II, significantly increased proliferation of MCF-7 cells. HPLC data revealed the commercial products contained plasticizers: benzyl benzoate and dibutyl phthalate in CC, dibutyl phthalate in TC, n-butyl benzyl phthalate in HC and n-butyl phthalyl n-butyl glycolate in DS II.

SIGNIFICANCE

Except for benzyl benzoate and di-2-ethylhexyl adipate, the plasticizers tested showed estrogenic activity. The four commercial tissue conditioners tested also showed estrogenic activity, and HC showed especially strong estrogenicity.

Release of methyl methacrylate from heat-cured and autopolymerized resins: cytotoxicity testing related to residual monomer

Three heat-cured and three autopolymerized acrylic denture bases with different mixing proportions and/or processing methods were investigated for the amount of residual monomer content and methyl methacrylate (MMA) released into saliva after incubation during the first and second 24 hours after processing. A corresponding range of concentrations of MMA was also used to test for cell cytotoxicity using a culture of human oral fibroblasts. The results showed that the amount of residual monomer was dependent not only on the type of polymerization but also on the amount of liquid in the mixture ratio and the processing method. The acrylic resin that had the lowest residual monomer also released the smallest amount of MMA but resins which have higher residual monomer may not necessarily release higher amounts of MMA. MMA, tested in the same range of concentration as the MMA found leached from acrylic resin in this study, was found to be toxic in the cell culture. Therefore, it is recommended that dentists attempt to reduce the amount of leachable substances before insertion of new dentures. In addition, it is recommended that dentists advise their patients not to wear newly made dentures overnight, as this may cause mucosal irritation from the potential accumulation of leachable substances.

Biologic testing of leachable aromatic compounds from denture base materials

The aromatic compounds phenyl benzoate (PB), phenyl salicylate (PS), and biphenyl (BP), which have previously been found to leach from poly(methyl methacrylate) denture base materials, were tested for cytotoxicity and biologic effects by L929 cells in culture. The octanol-water partition coefficient (log P(ow), a descriptor for the lipophilicity, was determined for the compounds. Cytotoxicity was evaluated by total cell growth and the plating efficiency test, and biologic effects by the total fatty acid composition of L929 cells. The commonly used tests, total cell growth and plating efficiency, did not show any significant changes of the cells due to the compounds. On the other hand, BP and PS, in particular, induced changes in the total fatty acid composition of L929 cells. The problem of bioavailability of aromatic compounds in cell culture assays and the relation to lipophilicity was addressed.

Fatty acid composition of palatal tissue from denture stomatitis patients

Palatal biopsy specimens were obtained from patients with denture stomatitis. The fatty acids were extracted from the tissue, then separated, identified, and quantified by a gas-chromatographic technique. The sensitivity of this method enabled analyses of specimens with a wet weight of less than 1 mg. The concentration of the fatty acids C16:1 (n-7) and C24:1 (n-9) differed significantly between samples from hyperplastic and clinically healthy tissue in the denture stomatitis patients. By comparing specimens from denture stomatitis patients and non-denture subjects, the concentration of seven fatty acids, two saturated and five unsaturated, was found to be significantly different. A multivariate data-analytical method distinguished between the fatty acid composition in specimens from denture stomatitis patients and from non-denture subjects.