Titanium versus autograft ossiculoplasty

Hearing Outcomes After Ossiculoplasty With Bone or Titanium Prostheses-A Nationwide Register-Based Study

OBJECTIVES

This study compares hearing outcomes of two prosthesis materials, bone and titanium, used in ossiculoplasty.

DESIGN

This retrospective nationwide registry-based study uses data systematically collected by the Swedish Quality Registry for Ear Surgery (SwedEar).

SETTING

The data were obtained from clinics in Sweden that perform ossiculoplasty.

PARTICIPANTS

Patients who underwent ossiculoplasty using either bone or titanium prostheses were registered in SwedEar between 2013 and 2019.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Hearing outcome expressed as air-bone gap (ABG) gain.

RESULTS

The study found no differences between bone and titanium for ABG or air conduction (AC) for either partial ossicular replacement prostheses (PORP) or total ossicular replacement prostheses (TORP). In a comparison between PORP and TORP for ABG and AC outcomes, regardless of the material used, PORP showed a small advantage, with an additional improvement of 3.3 dB (95% CI [confidence interval], 0.1-4.4) in ABG and 2.2 dB (95% CI, 1.7-4.8) in AC. In secondary surgery using TORP, titanium produced slightly better results for high-frequency pure tone average. The success rate, a postoperative ABG ≤20 dB, was achieved in 62% of the operations for the whole group.

CONCLUSION

Both bone and titanium used to reconstruct the ossicular chain produce similar hearing outcomes for both PORP and TORP procedures. However, titanium may be a preferable option for secondary surgeries involving TORP. The success rate, a postoperative ABG ≤20 dB, is consistent with other studies, but there is room for improvement in patient selection criteria and surgical techniques.

Endoscopic ossiculoplasty in traumatic conductive hearing loss with intact tympanic membrane: a five-year experience

BACKGROUND

Exploratory tympanotomy in cases of traumatic ossicular disruption with intact tympanic membrane is crucial for both diagnostic and therapeutic purposes. Performing this procedure using the endoscope is gaining popularity. Hence, this study aimed to demonstrate varieties of ossicular pathology and their management in our institution.

METHODS

A retrospective evaluation was conducted of 136 ears in patients with traumatic ossicular disruption with an intact tympanic membrane, who underwent endoscopic exploratory tympanotomy. A proposed algorithm was followed, to incorporate different traumatic ossicular possibilities. Assessment of hearing outcomes and surgical complications was performed six months post-operatively.

RESULTS

Incudostapedial dislocation was the most commonly encountered type of traumatic ossicular disruption (35.3 per cent). Air conduction threshold improved significantly following endoscopic ossiculoplasty, from 50.9 ± 6.35 dB pre-operatively to 22.35 ± 3.27 dB post-operatively, with successful air-bone gap closure.

CONCLUSION

Endoscopic ear surgery is effective in the diagnosis and management of challenging cases of post-traumatic ossicular disruption with an intact tympanic membrane.

Which is Better for Ossiculoplasty Following Tympanomastoidectomy: Polycel® or Titanium?

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to compare the surgical outcomes of Polycel® and titanium in ossiculoplasty following tympanomastoidectomy (TM).

METHODS

A total of 221 patients underwent ossiculoplasty following TM by a single surgeon using either Polycel® or titanium as prosthesis. Hearing was tested preoperatively and postoperatively at 6 months by pure-tone audiometry. Successful surgery was defined if postoperative air-bone gap (ABG) was <20 dB, the gain in air conduction (AC) hearing was >15 dB HL, or postoperative AC was <30 dB HL. Multiple linear regression was conducted to identify the factors associated with the surgical outcomes.

RESULTS

In canal wall up mastoidectomy (CWUM), both Polycel® and titanium showed favorable successful rates if partial ossicular replacement prosthesis (PORP) was used (64.3% of Polycel® and 67.6% in titanium). If total ossicular replacement prosthesis (TORP) was used, both represented similar outcomes (54.5% of Polycel® and 75.0% in titanium). In canal wall down mastoidectomy (CWDM), significant ABG reductions were observed only in the titanium group (5.2 ± 14.7 dB of Polycel® [P = .083] and 7.0 ± 14.2 dB of titanium [P = .002] in PORP; 4.6 ± 13.5 dB of Polycel® [P = .097] and 9.5 ± 11.2 dB of titanium [P < .001] in TORP). In multivariate analysis, titanium had a positive effect on the reduction of postoperative AC thresholds (B: -4.772; 95% CI: -8.706--0.838).

CONCLUSIONS

Both Polycel® and titanium showed favorable surgical outcomes for ossiculoplasty following CWUM. Titanium prosthesis is recommended for surgery after CWDM.

Extrusion and Dislocation in Titanium Middle Ear Prostheses: A Literature Review

Titanium middle ear (ME) prostheses are widely used in surgical practice due to their acoustic properties. However, they present a significant drawback shared by all synthetic materials currently in use for ME reconstruction: they can be rejected by the organism of the host. In this study, we aim to review the current literature on titanium partial ossicular replacement prostheses (PORPs) and total ossicular replacement prostheses (TORPs) extrusion and dislocation. Eighty articles were analysed after a full article review based on the inclusion and exclusion criteria. The most common indication for reconstruction was chronic otitis media with cholesteatoma. The average extrusion or dislocation rate was 5.2%, ranging from 0 to 35%. The average improvements in the air-bone gap were 12.1 dB (1.6 dB to 25.1 dB) and 13.8 (-0.5 dB to 22.7 dB) for the PORP and TORP groups, respectively. The data reported on this topic are highly variable, demonstrating that functional outcomes are difficult to predict in clinical practice. We believe that the current limitations could be overcome with technological developments, including bioengineering research focused on promoting prosthesis adaptation to the ME environment.

Can the unmodified incus be used for a simpler, more cost-effective functional ossicular chain reconstruction? A retrospective clinical study

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate patients' hearing outcomes after ossicular chain reconstruction using unmodified autologous incus.

METHODS

A single-centred, retrospective study of patients who underwent incus interposition between June 2010 and October 2017 was conducted at a Dutch secondary referral centre. This paper describes a chart review of patients who presented with erosion of the long process of the incus due to atelectasis or cholesteatoma who were treated with an unmodified incus interposition. The main outcome measures were: post-operative air-bone gap and level of air-bone gap closure.

RESULTS

Thirty-three ears of 32 patients were included. Follow-up duration ranged from six weeks to seven years. A mean post-operative air-bone gap under 25 dB was considered successful; this was achieved in 25 patients (76 per cent), 20 (91 per cent) in the partial ossicular reconstruction prosthesis group and 5 (45 per cent) in the total ossicular reconstruction prosthesis group. This difference was statistically significant (p = 0.007).

CONCLUSION

Successful preservation and improvement of hearing was observed in most patients. As expected, the closure rate in the partial ossicular reconstruction prosthesis group was better. Longer follow-up studies with larger case numbers are needed to assess whether further reconstruction techniques are necessary.

Incus Autograft Partial Ossicular Reconstruction Prosthesis vs. Titanium Angular Clip Prosthesis in Patients with Incudostapedial Joint Erosion Caused by Chronic Otitis Media; A Randomized Clinical Trial

Chronic otitis media (COM) is a common disease that can cause damage to the middle ear ossicles and thus lead to conductive hearing loss. The purpose of this study was to compare two methods of incus partial ossicular reconstruction prosthesis (PORP) and reconstruction with titanium angular clip prosthesis in patients with incudostapedial joint erosion. In this interventional randomized clinical trial carried out in a tertiary referral hospital, patients with chronic otitis media and incudostapedial joint erosion who were candidates for surgery, were randomly allocated into two groups of incus PORP surgery and reconstruction with a titanium angular clip prosthesis. Audiometry was performed for the patients prior to and six months after surgery. Pre- and post-operative air-bone gap (ABG) and bone conduction (BC) thresholds were calculated and means were compared by analysis of variances (ANOVA). A P value of <0.05 was considered statistically significant. The study consisted of 24 and 14 subjects in the incus PORP and angular clip groups, respectively. There was no statistically significant difference between the mean pre- and post-operative ABG, BC thresholds and ABG reduction in the compared groups. Considering issues such as high cost and inaccessibility of titanium angular clips in all centers, incus PORP may be a more acceptable method.

Critical analysis of moderate and severe retractions in the pars tensa and pars flaccida of the tympanic membrane

OBJECTIVES

Analyze the prevalence of retractions in different areas of the Tympanic Membrane (TM), the correlations between the involvement of the Pars Tensa (PT) and Pars Flaccida (PF), and the air-bone gaps.

METHODS

A cross-sectional study. Patients with moderate and/or severe TM retraction of 2200 consecutive patients with chronic otitis media between August 2000 and January 2019 were included. Ears with previous surgery were excluded. Ears were classified as isolated PF and PT retractions and association of both. The degrees of severity and presence of effusion were evaluated. The data were analyzed using the SPSS Statistics software program.

RESULTS

661 ears were included. The prevalence of isolated atical retractions was 24.9%, of isolated posterior quadrants was 10.6%, and of association of quadrants was 64%. There was no correlation between the retractions in the different areas of the TM (posterior and attic quadrants: r = 0.13; p = 0.041; anterior and posterior quadrants: r = 0.23; p = 0.013, anterior and attic quadrants: r = 0.06; p = 0.043). Effusion was present in 30.7% of the ears. ABG median was lower in ears with PF retraction (6.25 dB HL) than PT retraction, isolated (15 dB HL) or not (13.75 dB HL; p < 0.05); 72% of the ears had an ABG ≤ 20 dB HL. For severity of the retraction of PF, the ABG was similar across groups. For the PT, there was a global difference in the medians of ABG in terms of the degree of severity, with a moderate correlation.

CONCLUSION

The prevalence of moderate and severe retractions was 24.5%; 64% of the ears had an association of affected regions. There was no correlation between the retraction in the different areas of the TM. We found a significant correlation between the severity of retraction and the worsening of ABG threshold, only for PT.

EVIDENCE LEVEL

4.

Audiometric Pattern in Moderate and Severe Tympanic Membrane Retraction

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the audiometric pattern in moderate/severe retractions of the tympanic membrane and correlate it with the severity of the otoscopy findings.

STUDY DESIGN

Cross-sectional study.

SETTING

Tertiary hospital.

PATIENTS

Consecutive patients with moderate or severe tympanic membrane retraction in at least one ear (451 ears) between August 2000 and January 2019, and no surgical history or effusion (mean [standard deviation] age, 32.8 [20.2] yr; 54% female and 42.4% children).

INTERVENTION

Pure-tone audiometry.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Air conduction (AC) and bone conduction thresholds, and air-bone gap (ABG) measured at the four-frequency pure-tone average.

RESULTS

The median in decibel hearing level (dB HL) (minimum-maximum) of the AC, BC, and ABG were 25 dB HL (0-120 dB HL), 10 dB HL (0-75 dB HL), and 12.5 dB HL (0-55 dB HL), respectively. Seventy-two percent of the ears had an ABG ≤ 20 dB HL. For severity of the retraction of pars flaccida (PF), the AC, bone conduction, and ABG were similar across groups, with a weak correlation. For the pars tensa (PT), there was a global difference in the medians of AC and ABG in terms of the degree of severity, with a moderate correlation. Retraction in PF and PT at the same time was observed in 6 4% of the ears. ABG median was lower in ears with PF retraction (6.25 dB HL) than PT retraction, isolated (15 dB HL) or not (13.75 dB HL; p < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

The ABG pure-tone average median was higher when PT was involved. We found a significant correlation between the retraction severity and worsening of AC and ABG thresholds, only for PT.

Success rates in restoring hearing loss in patients with chronic otitis media: A systematic review

OBJECTIVE

To assess the effectiveness of tympanoplasty in treating chronic otitis media-related hearing loss, published literature was systematically reviewed to determine the clinical success rate of tympanoplasty at restoring hearing in chronic otitis media patients at a minimum follow-up period of 12-months.

DATA SOURCES

PubMed, Embase and the Cochrane Library.

METHODS

Two independent reviewers performed literature searches. Publications reporting long-term (≥12-month) hearing outcomes and complications data on adult and pediatric patients with chronic otitis media were included and assessed for risk of bias and strength of evidence. To assess how tympanoplasty influences long-term hearing outcomes, data on pure tone audiometry (air-bone gap) and complications were extracted and synthesized.

RESULTS

Thirty-nine studies met the inclusion criteria. Data from 3162 patients indicated that 14.0% of patients encountered postoperative complications. In adult patients, mean weighted air-bone gap data show closure from 26.5 dB hearing level (HL) (preoperatively) to 16.1 dB HL (postoperatively). In studies that presented combined adult and pediatric data, the mean preoperative air-bone gap of 26.7 dB HL was closed to 15.4 dB HL. In 1370 patients with synthesizable data, 70.7% of patients had a postoperative air-bone gap ˂ 20 dB HL at long-term follow-up. Finally, subgroup analysis identified that mean improvement in ABG closure for patients with and without cholesteatoma was 10.0 dB HL and 12.4 dB HL, respectively.

CONCLUSION

In patients with chronic otitis media, tympanoplasty successfully closed the air-bone gap to within 20 dB HL in 7/10 cases and had an overall complication rate of 14.0%.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

2a.

Short and Long-Term Outcomes of Titanium Clip Ossiculoplasty

OBJECTIVE

To report short (∼4 mo) and long-term (>12 mo) audiometric outcomes following ossiculoplasty using a titanium clip partial ossicular reconstruction prosthesis.

METHODS

Case series at a single tertiary referral center reviewing 130 pediatric and adult patients with conductive hearing loss (CHL) secondary to chronic otitis media (n = 121, 93%) or traumatic ossicular disruption (n = 9, 7%) who underwent partial ossiculoplasty from January 2005 to December 2015 with the CliP prosthesis.

RESULTS

At both short and long-term follow-up, postoperative air-bone gap (ABG) was significantly improved (18 dB HL, IQ range 13-26, p < 0.0001 and 18 dB HL, IQ range 13-29, p = 0.0002, respectively) when compared with preoperative values (29 dB HL, IQ range 19-37). No significant change in ABG was noted when comparing short and long-term intervals (18 versus 18 dB HL, p = 0.44). Fifty seven percent of cases (51/89) achieved a long-term ABG less than or equal to 20 dB at the time of their last follow-up. The extrusion and displacement rates were 1.5% (2/130), and 0.8% (1/130), respectively. There were no cases of iatrogenic sensorineural hearing loss.

CONCLUSIONS

Partial ossiculoplasty with the titanium CliP produces good hearing outcomes with a favorable safety profile. At long-term follow-up (minimum of 12 mo), median ABG was 18 dB and remained stable when compared with short-term follow-up. The majority of patients had successful long-term results, with 57% of patients achieving an ABG is less than or equal to 20 dB. Low rates of extrusion (1.5%) and prosthesis displacement off the stapes (0.8%) support the long-term stability of the CliP prosthesis in the middle ear.

Utilization of incus with bone cement for total ossicular reconstruction

Background: Total ossicular chain reconstructions are performed to connect mobile stapes footplate and tympanic membrane. Data on the use of incus for total ossicular reconstruction is quite limited in the literature. Objective: The main objective of this study is to describe a novel surgical method that utilizes incus with bone cement to stabilize the ossicular chain for total ossicular reconstruction. Materials and methods: 16 patients who underwent total ossicular reconstruction using our method were included in this study. We evaluated hearing by comparing preoperative and postoperative air-bone gap (ABG), air conduction (AC) and bone conduction (BC). The percentage of patients achieving ABG ≤20 dB was determined. Results: The mean preoperative ABG was 35.3 ± 8.2 and postoperative ABG decreased significantly to 23.7 ± 7.6 (p < .001). The mean preoperative AC (57.5 ± 10) decreased significantly postoperatively to (46.5 ± 13.3)(p = .014). There was not any difference between pre- and post-operative BC. We achieved successful hearing results (ABG ≤ 20dB) in 44% of patients. Conclusion: The use of incus with bone cement stabilization for total ossicular reconstruction seems a feasible option. Good hearing outcomes, and low cost, complication, and extrusion rate may be the main reasons to prefer this method.

The benefit of trans-attic endoscopic control of ossicular prosthesis after cholesteatoma surgery

OBJECTIVE

To show the efficiency of using transmastoid atticotomy (TMA) endoscopy on the outcome of ossiculoplasty in patients with cholesteatoma. TMA is often performed as part of the surgical management of patients with middle ear cholesteatoma extending to the epitympanum. TMA can also be used as an access for endoscopic view to confirm the right alignment and stability of the ossicular prosthesis because the reconstruction of the tympanic membrane will obscure the visualization of the prosthesis.

METHODS

A retrospective study was done at a tertiary referral institute, including 133 ears with cholesteatoma that underwent canal wall-up tympanomastoidectomy (CWU) with ossicular reconstruction using titanium prosthesis between August 2013 and August 2015. Post packing of the ear canal and position, stability, and axis of the prosthesis were checked using endoscope positioned in the attic through TMA. A postoperative pure-tone average air-bone gap (ABG) of 20 dB or less was considered as a successful hearing result. Results are compared with historical control groups.

RESULTS

Of the 133 ears, 88 patients underwent reconstruction with partial ossicular replacement prosthesis (PORP), whereas the rest (45 patients) had total ossicular replacement prosthesis (TORP). A postoperative ABG ≤ 20 dB was obtained in 77.4% of all the patients (79.5% for PORP; 73.3% for TORP).

CONCLUSION

Endoscopic assessment of the ossicular prosthesis via the attic, after repositioning of the tympanomeatal flap and packing the ear canal, decreases the risk of immediate ossiculoplasty failure and improves the functional outcome after ossicular chain reconstruction in cholesteatoma surgery.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

4 Laryngoscope, 129:2754-2759, 2019.

Comparative study of new autologous material, bone-cartilage composite graft, for ossiculoplasty with Polycel® and Titanium

OBJECTIVE

Ossiculoplasty is a surgical procedure that recreates sound transmission of the middle ear in conductive hearing loss. Various materials have been used for ossicular reconstruction, but the most ideal material for ossiculoplasty remains controversial. The purpose of this study was to introduce a novel method of autologous ossiculoplasty, bone-cartilage composite graft (BCCG) and to compare its surgical results with different types of ossiculoplastic prostheses.

STUDY DESIGN

A retrospective study was performed in a tertiary referral centre.

METHODS

Data of 275 patients who received ossiculoplasty using the three different materials of BCCG, Polycel^® and titanium were analysed according to type of ossiculoplasty: partial or total ossicular replacement prosthesis (PORP or TORP). Hearing results, complication rates and clinical parameters including age, sex, past history, preoperative diagnosis and surgery type were compared among different groups.

RESULTS

Ossiculoplasty with BCCG showed satisfactory hearing outcomes and the lowest complication rate among the three different materials. In particular, its extrusion rate was 0%.

CONCLUSION

We propose that the BCCG technique is a useful alternative method for ossiculoplasty, with proper patient selection.

Comparison of various bone cement ossiculoplasty techniques and functional results

OBJECTIVE

In this study, functional results of different bone cement ossiculoplasty techniques are compared.

METHODS

Retrospective case review at a tertiary referral center. Patients who underwent middle ear surgery and bone cement ossiculoplasty between 2006-2012 were included. A total of 52 patients, including 30 patients with 'Incus to stapes' (Group 1) and 13 patients with 'malleus to stapes' (Group 2), five patients with 'incudoplasty + stapedotomy' (Group 3), and four patients with 'malleus to incus' (Group 4) ossiculoplasty were enrolled in the study. Pre-operative and post-operative audiological findings of each group were evaluated.

RESULTS

The mean hearing gain (the difference between pre-operative and post-operative air bone gap (ABG)) was 13 dB for Group 1, 30 dB for Group 2, 24 dB for Group 3, and 9 dB for Group 4. The pre-operative air pure tone averages (PTA) of groups 1, 2, and 3 improved significantly in the post-operative period (p < 0.05). Closure of post-operative ABG of patients to less than 20 dB and 10 dB were as follows: ∼70% and 43% in group 1; 86% and 76% in group 2; 100% and 60% in group 3; and 75% and 50% in group 4, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

The results showed that glass ionomer cement is a simple and effective method for reconstruction of ossicular discontinuity in various ossicular chain pathologies and can be an alternative to conventional rebridging techniques such as sculpted incus interposition or partial ossicular replacement prosthesis (PORP).

Titanium prosthesis or autologous incus for total ossicular reconstruction in the absence of the stapes suprastructure and presence of mobile footplate

The purpose of this study was to compare the hearing results after total ossicular replacement with a titanium prosthesis or autologous incus in the absence of stapes suprastructure and presence of mobile footplate as a retrospective medical record review in a tertiary referral center setting. There were 49 patients who had total ossicular reconstruction (titanium prosthesis, 40 patients; autologous incus, 9 patients). Medical records were reviewed after total ossicular replacement. Air-bone gap at 1 and 2 years after surgery were determined with the 4-frequency average (0.5, 1, 2, and 4 kHz) and the American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery 4-frequency average (0.5, 1, 2, and 3 kHz). The number of patients who had air-bone gap <20 dB was determined. For comparisons that were based on American Academy of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery 4-frequency average, mean air-bone gap at 2 years after surgery was significantly smaller for the titanium prosthesis (21 dB) than autologous incus group (31 dB; P ≤ 0.03); the frequency of patients who had air-bone gap <20 dB at 1 or 2 years after surgery was significantly greater for the titanium prosthesis (1 year, 40%; 2 years, 56%) than autologous incus group [1 year, 0% (P ≤ 0.03); 2 years, 0% (P ≤ 0.04)]. Titanium prosthesis ossiculoplasty gave better results than autologous incus in the absence of the stapes suprastructure and presence of a mobile footplate.

Can an incomplete ossicular discontinuity be predicted by audiometric and clinical findings?

OBJECTIVE

To investigate a pathology of conductive hearing loss caused by an incomplete ossicular discontinuity. It can manifest as a triad of the following: 1) conductive hearing loss most prominent in the high frequencies (hfCHL), defined as [ABG for 4 kHz] > [mean ABG for 0.25-0.5 kHz] + 10 dB or more; 2) fluctuating hearing loss; and 3) short-lasting improvement of hearing after Valsalva maneuver.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective clinical trial.

SETTING

Tertiary referral center.

PATIENTS

Fourteen patients with an incomplete ossicular discontinuity who underwent incus interposition were included.

INTERVENTION

Incus interposition, mathematical model.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

First, the prevalence of the triad was documented. Second, the hypothesis that mechanical ossicular compliance was responsible for the triad of symptoms was evaluated and simulated in a mathematical model. Finally, the postoperative hearing results with a follow-up of 12 months were analyzed and compared with those reported in the literature.

RESULTS

The presence of the triad of symptoms is a strong indicator for detecting patients with an incomplete ossicular discontinuity. High frequency conductive hearing loss was present in 93% (13/14 patients). Ten (71%) of the 14 patients presented with fluctuating hearing loss and improvement of hearing after Valsalva maneuver. The hfCHL could be simulated adequately in the mathematical model. Success rate for surgical intervention (ABG < 20 dB; 0.5, 1, 2, and 3 kHz) was 93% and was comparable to the results reported in the literature.

CONCLUSION

Patients with hfCHL, fluctuating hearing loss, and improvement of hearing after Valsalva maneuver are likely to have an incomplete ossicular discontinuity. A favorable postoperative hearing recovery by incus interposition can be expected.

PORP vs. TORP: a meta-analysis

After the surgical procedure of ossicular chain reconstruction, the effectiveness and/or stability of partial ossicular replacement prosthesis (PORP) or total ossicular replacement prosthesis (TORP) were systematically compared and evaluated using meta-analysis. A total of 40 eligible investigations with 4,311 subjects were included in our study. There was a significant difference in the effectiveness of the reconstruction of the ossicular chain between PORP and TORP; the data showed a combined risk ratio (RR) of 1.28 (95 % CI 1.17-1.41, p < 0.00001), but no notable difference was obtained in staged procedures subgroup and cholesteatoma subgroup, with a combined RR of 1.13 (95 % CI 0.60-2.11, p = 0.70) in staged procedures subgroup and RR of 2.60 (95 % CI 0.20-36.21, p = 0.59 in cholesteatoma subgroup). There was a statistically significant difference in the stability of the prostheses in long-term follow-up, with a combined RR of 0.37 (95 % CI 0.16-0.85, p = 0.02), but no significant difference was observed in the total sample, with a combined RR of 0.64 (95 % CI 0.40-1.03, p = 0.06). Our overall results suggest that the effectiveness of PORP was higher than TORP, except within staged procedures subgroup and cholesteatoma subgroup. In addition, the stability of PORP was significantly superior to TORP in long-term follow-ups, but no significant effect was detected in the general study.

Titanium versus non-titanium prostheses in ossiculoplasty: a meta-analysis

CONCLUSION

The papers collected in our study demonstrated that there were no significant differences in the effectiveness of sound transmission and stability of the prosthesis between the titanium and non-titanium group. However, further randomized controlled trials with large sample sizes are needed to improve the estimation.

OBJECTIVE

To compare the effectiveness of sound transmission and stability of the prostheses in the titanium or non-titanium ossiculoplasty groups by meta-analysis for clinical implications and applications.

METHODS

Previous studies comparing the hearing status of patients with titanium and non-titanium prostheses were reviewed on PubMed, accompanied by a manual search of all the related references. The eligibility of the investigation was independently confirmed by two reviewers, who extracted all the data from the papers included accordingly for the standard meta-analysis.

RESULTS

The study included 12 eligible investigations covering 1388 patients, with the pooled risk ratio (RR) estimating the effectiveness of the postoperational prostheses between the titanium and non-titanium group, with a combined RR of 1.12 (95% confidence interval (CI): 0.98-1.27, p = 0.09), as well as their stability, with a combined RR of 1.47 (95% CI: 0.76-2.84, p = 0.26).