Macula utriculi in four cases with Meniere's disease

Subcellular Abnormalities of Vestibular Nerve Morphology in Patients With Intractable Meniere's Disease

Objective: Few studies so far have focused on the retrocochlear lesions in Meniere's disease (MD). This study aims to investigate pathological alterations in the central portion of the vestibular nerve (VN) in patients with intractable Meniere's disease (MD) and to explore retrocochlear lesions and their relationship with disease severity. Methods: Eight MD patients with refractory vertigo received vestibular neurectomy via a retrosigmoid or translabyrinthine approach. Segments of VN were carefully removed and immediately fixed for histopathological examination. Five VN specimens were examined by light microscopy after hematoxylin/eosin staining; three specimens were extensively analyzed using transmission electron microscopy, to identify VN ultrastructural lesions. Correlations between lesions and patient clinical characteristics were examined. Results: Histopathological examination revealed evidence of various types of chronic VN impairment, including the formation of corpora amylacea (CA), axon atrophy, and severe damage to the myelin sheath. Electron microscopy revealed membranous whorls within dilated Schmidt-Lanterman incisures, the formation of myeloid bodies, dysmyelination, and demyelination. Unexpectedly, we observed a positive correlation between the density of CA in VN tissue and the duration of disease, as well as the degree of hearing impairment, independent of age. Conclusion: Our findings indicate that deformation of subcellular organelles in the central portion of the VN is one of the key pathological indicators for the progressive severity and intractability of vertigo and support a vestibular nerve degeneration.

Histopathological and ultrastructural analysis of vestibular endorgans in Meniere's disease reveals basement membrane pathology

BACKGROUND

We report the systematic analysis of the ultrastructural and cytological histopathology of vestibular endorgans acquired from labyrinthectomy in Meniere's disease.

METHODS

17 subjects with intractable Meniere's disease and ipsilateral non-serviceable hearing presenting to the Neurotology Clinic from 1997 to 2006 who chose ablative labyrinthectomy (average age = 62 years; range 29-83 years) participated. The average duration of symptoms prior to surgery was 7 years (range 1-20 years).

RESULTS

Nearly all vestibular endorgans demonstrated varying degrees of degeneration. A monolayer of epithelial cells occurred significantly more frequently in the horizontal cristae (12/13 = 92%) (p < 0.001), the superior cristae (5/5 = 100%) (p < 0.005), the posterior cristae (2/2) compared with the utricular maculae (4/17 = 24%). Basement membrane (BM) thickening was more common in all of the cristae ampullares (18 out of 20) than the utricular maculae. Although only four saccular maculae were obtained, 3 out of 4 exhibited BM thickening and monolayer degeneration. Monolayer degeneration was highly significantly correlated with the presence of BM thickening (p < 0.001). Other degenerative changes noted equally among the five vestibular endorgans which were not significantly correlated with BM thickening or monolayer degeneration included hair cell vacuolization and stereocilia loss, microvesicles in the supporting cells, and increased stromal intercellular spaces. Transmission electron microscopy demonstrated disorganization of the BM collagen-like fibrils, and normal ultrastructural morphology of the nerve terminals and myelinated fibers. Stromal fibroblasts and endothelial cells of stromal blood vessels demonstrated vacuolization, and stromal perivascular BMs were also thickened.

CONCLUSION

Systematic histopathological analysis of the vestibular endorgans from Meniere's disease demonstrated neuroepithelial degeneration which was highly correlated with an associated BM thickening. Other findings included hair cell and supporting cell microvessicles, increased intercellular clear spaces in the stroma, and endothelial cell vacuolization and stromal perivascular BM thickening.

Histopathology of the vestibular end organs after intratympanic gentamicin failure for Meniere's disease

CONCLUSION

To our knowledge, this is the first report of the histopathology of the vestibular end organs following intratympanic gentamicin for intractable Meniere's disease. There was relative sparing of the utricular macula, compared with the cristae ampullares. However, the utricular macula exhibited severe hair cell loss. Clinically, the patient has been free from vertigo spells for 3 years following labyrinthectomy.

OBJECTIVE

To describe the histopathology and morphometry of the vestibular end organs from a 59-year-old Meniere's patient who underwent transmastoid labyrinthectomy for recurrent vertigo after failed intratympanic gentamicin.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Light and transmission electron microscopy were utilized; with unbiased stereology-physical fractionator for type I, type II hair cell, and supporting cell counts. Comparison with end organ histopathology in a 56-year-old with Meniere's disease without gentamicin treatment was carried out.

RESULTS

Histopathological analysis of the semicircular canal cristae ampullares showed severe atrophy of the neuroepithelium with undifferentiated cells, and fibrosis and edema of the stroma. The utricular macula had some remaining type I and type II vestibular hair cells, and nerve fibers and terminals within the underlying stroma. Morphometric measures were obtained from the utricular macula: 2000 type I and 500 type II hair cells, representing 7.3% of type I hair cells and 4.9% of type II hair cells compared with normative controls, and 24 000 supporting cells were obtained.

Unbiased stereologic type I and type II hair cell counts in human utricular macula

OBJECTIVE

The objective of the study was to obtain unbiased estimates of the total number of type I and type II hair cells in human utricular macula from individuals with documented normal vestibular function.

STUDY DESIGN

Application of unbiased stereology using microdissected human temporal bone specimens was conducted in an observational study.

METHODS

Postmortem temporal bones were obtained from 10 normal patients (age range, 42-96 y; mean age, 82 y). The utricular maculae were microdissected, embedded in plastic, and cut into serial 2-microm sections. Unbiased estimates of the total number of type I and type II hair cells were obtained using the physical fractionator technique of stereology.

RESULTS

The average total number of hair cells was 27,508 (CV = 11%) consisting of 17,326 (coefficient of variation [CV] = 11%) type I hair cells and 10,182 (CV = 13%) type II hair cells. The ratio of type I to type II hair cells was 1.70:1. In the age range of the study, there was no statistically significant correlation between hair cell counts and age.

CONCLUSIONS

Morphometric studies of the human utricular sensory epithelium can be accomplished using unbiased stereology on microdissected specimens. There was no effect of age on total hair cell counts or on the ratio of type I to type II hair cells in the age range of the study. Further studies on younger subjects are needed to establish the effect of age. The results from the present study are closely aligned with prior studies that estimated total hair cell counts using surface mount preparations. The current data represent the first total type I and type II hair cell counts in human utricular neuroepithelium.

Ultrastructural changes in the hydropic cochlea of the guinea-pig

Transmission electron microscopy of the cochlear organ of Corti in experimental endolymphatic hydrops revealed two principal features. Starting 1 month after induction of hydrops, osmiophilic inclusions thought to represent lipofuscin accumulation were frequently observed in the subcuticular cytoplasm of the outer hair cells along the length of the cochlea. Starting 3 months after induction of hydrops the efferent terminals on the outer hair cells appeared to be vacuolated. These data suggest that oxidative insult is likely to contribute to the pathology associated with endolymphatic hydrops and thus that free radical scavengers might be useful in the treatment of Menière's disease patients. In addition the early modification of the efferent innervation of the hydropic cochlea might underlie the known hypersensitivity to various insults, including noise stimulation, glycerol administration and hypoxia.

Degeneration of vestibular sensory cells caused by ablation of the vestibular aqueduct in the gerbil ear

The vestibular aqueduct of the gerbil has a unique anatomic feature that makes it possible to selectively obliterate the endolymphatic sac with or without interfering with its venous drainage. In animals in which only the endolymphatic sac was ablated, endolymphatic hydrops was slight in the cochlea and was absent in the vestibular labyrinth. The cochlear and vestibular sensory cells were normal. In animals in which both the endolymphatic duct and the vein were obliterated, hydrops was slight, with the exception of a few cochleas that showed moderate hydrops. The sensory cells of the posterior canal cristae had degenerated in all specimens, while varied pathologic changes in cochlear and vestibular sensory cells were present in some specimens. These results suggest that hydrops is primarily due to blockage of the endolymphatic duct and sac and that degeneration of sensory cells occurs when blood flow in the vestibular aqueduct is impeded. Pathologic changes in the endolymphatic sac, including the vascular plexus at the endolymphatic sac, may play an important role in the production of endolymphatic hydrops and vestibular symptoms in Meniere's disease.

Vestibular sensory epithelia in patients with acoustic neurinoma

The human vestibular sensory epithelia of the macula utriculi were examined ultrastructurally in 13 cases with acoustic neurinoma. The sensory epithelia were fairly well preserved, with several morphological changes such as lipofuscin granules, intraepithelial cysts, pyknosis, vacuoles, laminated structures, banded structures and degeneration of subepithelial myelinated nerves evident. The pathological significance of these findings was discussed. There were thickened irregular membrane formations in spaces between the nerve calyces and type I hair cells which might be related to acoustic neurinoma. Some type I hair cells were incompletely surrounded by nerve calyces. The neck regions of these cells received direct contact from the efferent nerve endings.

Light and electron microscopic study of vestibular sensory epithelia in 17 cases with acoustic neurinoma

Vestibular sensory epithelia were studied histologically and ultrastructurally in 17 cases with acoustic neurinoma (AN). The superior vestibular nerve (SVN) near the fundus was also histologically studied in 5 of these 17 cases. Histologically, severe fibrotic change of the vestibular sensory epithelia was found in 1 case, and severe fibrotic change of the SVN was also found in this case. Intra-epithelial cysts were found at the edge of the utricular sensory epithelia in 2 cases. The cysts consisted of the transitional epithelium and were filled with the darkly stained substances. Ultrastructurally, abnormal accumulation of darkly stained masses within the nerve ending and abnormal accumulation of the fibrillar material below the normal basal lamina were frequently observed. These morphological changes described above were regarded as the pathological changes due to AN. In addition, the relationship among the histologic changes, ultrastructural changes and clinical data were fully investigated, and some histologic and ultrastructural changes were regarded as artifacts or age-related changes.

Long-term progression of Meniére's disease

A retrospective study of 161 Meniére patients followed up for 9 years or more is presented. The development with respect to hearing, caloric response, vertigo and ability to work was analysed. The main functional loss was found to take place early in the course of the disease. There was an increase in bilaterality with time. Spontaneous relief in vertigo over the years has been noticed.

Ultrastructural aspects of the human peripheral vestibular system

The sensory epithelia from the membranous labyrinths of 4 patients were examined by transmission electron microscopy. The distribution ratio of type 1 to type 2 cells was recorded, compared for each sensory area and correlated with age. An ultrastructural assessment confirmed generalized patterns consistent with autolytic and preparation artefact, viz. calyceal dilatation, cytoplasmic protrusions and some sensory hair loss. More specific features, i.e. lipofuscin accumulation, membrane-bound inclusions and neural degeneration were consistent with pre-mortem pathological change. In 2 patients, total nerve fibre counts of 15,766 and 19,741 were obtained. Total fibre counts correlated with the sensory cell density of the innervated areas. Differential counts of the superior and inferior vestibular nerves suggested that there was a reduced number of fibres in the superior division of both patients, in comparison with established normative data. Morphometric analysis of the constituent fibre diameters revealed a skewed distribution with a modal value of 6 microns for both patients.

Ultrastructure of the vestibular sensory organs in delayed endolymphatic hydrops

Vestibular sensory organs were examined ultrastructurally in two cases of delayed endolymphatic hydrops. The patients, two women, 27 and 16 years of age, suffered profound sensory hearing loss in childhood and experienced severe, recurrent vertigo. Specimens were obtained by a translabyrinthial vestibular nerve transection. We studied the utricular macula and the lateral and posterior cristae in one case, and the utricular macula, the anterior and posterior cristae, and the vestibular ganglion in the other. The otoconia and the otoconial membrane, the sensory epithelia, and the vestibular ganglion appeared fairly normal. Although the entire vestibular end organs were not studied in these cases, it was surprising that the ultrastructural findings did not conclusively identify vestibular end organ pathology as the cause of the vertigo attacks.

Ultrastructural findings in a case of Menière's disease

The temporal bones of an individual with documented unilateral Meniere's disease were prepared for light and electron microscopy. A morphometric analysis was performed on hair cells, spiral ganglion cells, dendritic fibers in the osseous spiral lamina, afferent and efferent endings, and afferent synaptic contacts. In the ear with Meniere's disease, we found hair cell damage, including disruption of the cuticular bodies and basalward displacement of some outer hair cells. There was no significant difference in the number of hair cells or spiral ganglion cells on the two sides. There was a significant decrease, however, in the number of afferent nerve endings and afferent synapses at the base of both inner and outer hair cells in the ear with Meniere's disease as compared to the contralateral ear.

Investigations into the cause of canal paresis in Menière's disease

Since the literature has a paucity of documented lesions of the vestibular hair cells and neurons in Menière's disease, the cause of canal paresis remains unexplained. A clinicopathological correlation was sought and demonstrated between ampullary distortion of lateral canal and reduced caloric response. The findings in this investigation make a strong case for ampullary distortion disrupting the tenuous but vital cupulary attachment resulting in canal paresis. This concept is attractive because it explains an important clinical event in Menière's disease on the basis of the only consistent histopathological finding, namely, membrane distension.

The natural course of Meniere's disease

A retrospective study of 161 Meniere patients followed up for 9 years or more is presented. The development with respect to hearing, caloric response, vertigo and ability to work was analysed. The main functional loss was found to take place early in the course of the disease. There was an increase in bilaterality with time.

[Electron microscopic investigation of connective tissue in vestibular ganglion and nerve in morbus Menière]

Vestibular ganglia of 17 patients with Menière's disease, obtained by transtemporal or translabyrinthine neurectomy, were studied by electron microscopy. Three ganglia removed because of other disease and four ganglia of normal ears taken post mortem served as controls. The neuronal fibrous tissue of Menière cases showed without exception pathologic changes of various extent. The amount of collagen was increased, whereby different fiber diameters were observed as well as changes in the periodicity of cross banding. Signs of continuing collagen formation were found: active fibroblasts and an increased number of isolated Schwann cells without axons, showing deerhorn-like ramifications which enveloped collagen bundles. The blood vessels were frequently surrounded by multiple basal membranes and broad bands of homogenous matrix. The pericytes were either necrotic or nonexistent. The endothelial cell cytoplasma was usually not in an active state. Sometimes it seemed to be autolytic. The pinocytotic activity was strikingly diminished. These qualitative changes of the interstitial tissue might point to a local pathologic event in the region of the vestibular nerve and ganglion.

Adrenergic innervation of the eighth nerve and vestibular end organs in man

Fluorescence microscopy was used to examine the adrenergic, blood-vessel-independent innervation of the 8th nerve and inner ear specimens in patients with otoneurological diseases. Specifically fluorescent adrenergic axons were scantily seen among the myelinated nerve fibers in the 8th nerve and in the subepithelial regions of the end organs but not in the endolymphatic sac.