Tissue-engineered larynx using perfusion-decellularized technique and mesenchymal stem cells in a rabbit model

Evolution of biomimetic ECM scaffolds from decellularized tissue matrix for tissue engineering: A comprehensive review

Tissue engineering is essentially a technique for imitating nature. Natural tissues are made up of three parts: extracellular matrix (ECM), signaling systems, and cells. Therefore, biomimetic ECM scaffold is one of the best candidates for tissue engineering scaffolds. Among the many scaffold materials of biomimetic ECM structure, decellularized ECM scaffolds (dECMs) obtained from natural ECM after acellular treatment stand out because of their inherent natural components and microenvironment. First, an overview of the family of dECMs is provided. The principle, mechanism, advances, and shortfalls of various decellularization technologies, including physical, chemical, and biochemical methods are then critically discussed. Subsequently, a comprehensive review is provided on recent advances in the versatile applications of dECMs including but not limited to decellularized small intestinal submucosa, dermal matrix, amniotic matrix, tendon, vessel, bladder, heart valves. And detailed examples are also drawn from scientific research and practical work. Furthermore, we outline the underlying development directions of dECMs from the perspective that tissue engineering scaffolds play an important role as an important foothold and fulcrum at the intersection of materials and medicine. As scaffolds that have already found diverse applications, dECMs will continue to present both challenges and exciting opportunities for regenerative medicine and tissue engineering.

Characterization of a decellularized rat larynx: comparison between microscopy techniques

BACKGROUND

No effective method has yet been developed to efficiently reconstruct the larynx and restore its function. Decellularization has recently been tested for this purpose with very promising results. The goal of decellularization is to remove cells leaving an intact scaffold made of an extracellular matrix (ECM). Although the use of hematoxylin/eosin and Masson trichrome stains is widely accepted to highlight tissue structure, the methods based on evaluation of collagen and elastin are considered highly variable. The aim of this study was to develop a whole organ decellularization protocol and compare the qualitative and quantitative efficiency of some microscopy techniques for collagen and elastin detection in paraffin-embedded tissues.

METHODS

H&E, Masson Trichrome and DAPI staining as well as DNA quantification were used to evaluate decellularization efficiency. Van Gieson stain, Picrosirius Red stain (PRS) and multiphoton laser scanning microscopy (MPM) were carried out for collagen detection and quantitative assessment. Polarized PRS was used to investigate collagen network, and Weigert stain and MPM were used to detect and estimate elastin content.

RESULTS

The decellularization process removed the cellular components without affecting glycosaminoglycan, collagen and elastin content. Concerning collagen quantification, Van Gieson stain underestimated collagen content, while PRS, apparently less fading, did not reach reliable results when used as quantitative method. MPM effectively quantified collagen content. Collagen fibers were visualized much better under polarized light microscopy, allowing to underline that decellularization process affects the homogeneity of 3D collagen network. Concerning elastin detection, Weigert stain and MPM produced overlapping results.

CONCLUSIONS

An efficient protocol to decellularize the whole larynx was developed, allowing the removal of cells without affecting ECM integrity. The results supported the use of non-polarized PRS to highlight collagen, even the thin fibers, second harmonic generation for major fibrillar collagens and polarized PRS for 3D collagen network. Concerning elastin, Weigert stain and MPM showed similar results, thus the use of MPM, rather than that of the Weigert stain, may be suitable to avoid the additional time and costs of a histological staining.

Recellularization of Bioengineered Scaffolds for Vascular Composite Allotransplantation

Traumatic injuries or cancer resection resulting in large volumetric soft tissue loss requires surgical reconstruction. Vascular composite allotransplantation (VCA) is an emerging reconstructive option that transfers multiple, complex tissues as a whole subunit from donor to recipient. Although promising, VCA is limited due to side effects of immunosuppression. Tissue-engineered scaffolds obtained by decellularization and recellularization hold great promise. Decellularization is a process that removes cellular materials while preserving the extracellular matrix architecture. Subsequent recellularization of these acellular scaffolds with recipient-specific cells can help circumvent adverse immune-mediated host responses and allow transplantation of allografts by reducing and possibly eliminating the need for immunosuppression. Recellularization of acellular tissue scaffolds is a technique that was first investigated and reported in whole organs. More recently, work has been performed to apply this technique to VCA. Additional work is needed to address barriers associated with tissue recellularization such as: cell type selection, cell distribution, and functionalization of the vasculature and musculature. These factors ultimately contribute to achieving tissue integration and viability following allotransplantation. The present work will review the current state-of-the-art in soft tissue scaffolds with specific emphasis on recellularization techniques. We will discuss biological and engineering process considerations, technical and scientific challenges, and the potential clinical impact of this technology to advance the field of VCA and reconstructive surgery.

Decellularization in Tissue Engineering and Regenerative Medicine: Evaluation, Modification, and Application Methods

Reproduction of different tissues using scaffolds and materials is a major element in regenerative medicine. The regeneration of whole organs with decellularized extracellular matrix (dECM) has remained a goal despite the use of these materials for different purposes. Recently, decellularization techniques have been widely used in producing scaffolds that are appropriate for regenerating damaged organs and may be able to overcome the shortage of donor organs. Decellularized ECM offers several advantages over synthetic compounds, including the preserved natural microenvironment features. Different decellularization methods have been developed, each of which is appropriate for removing cells from specific tissues under certain conditions. A variety of methods have been advanced for evaluating the decellularization process in terms of cell removal efficiency, tissue ultrastructure preservation, toxicity, biocompatibility, biodegradability, and mechanical resistance in order to enhance the efficacy of decellularization methods. Modification techniques improve the characteristics of decellularized scaffolds, making them available for the regeneration of damaged tissues. Moreover, modification of scaffolds makes them appropriate options for drug delivery, disease modeling, and improving stem cells growth and proliferation. However, considering different challenges in the way of decellularization methods and application of decellularized scaffolds, this field is constantly developing and progressively moving forward. This review has outlined recent decellularization and sterilization strategies, evaluation tests for efficient decellularization, materials processing, application, and challenges and future outlooks of decellularization in regenerative medicine and tissue engineering.

Development of a decellularized hypopharynx with vascular pedicle scaffold for use in reconstructing hypopharynx

BACKGROUND

Hypopharynx reconstruction after hypopharyngectomy is still a great challenge. Perfusion decellularization is for extracellular matrix (ECM) scaffolding and had been used in organ reconstruction. Our study aimed to prepare an acellular, natural, three-dimensional biological hypopharynx with vascular pedicle scaffold as the substitute materials to reconstruct hypopharynx.

RESULT

Scanning electron microscope and histology staining showed that the decellularized hypopharynx with vascular pedicle scaffold retained intact native anatomical ECM structure. Myoblasts were observed on the recellularized scaffolds with bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells induced by 5-azacytidine implanted in the rabbit greater omentum by immunohistochemical analysis.

CONCLUSION

The decellularized hypopharynx with vascular pedicle scaffold prepared by detergent perfusion in our study has a potential to be an alternative material to pharynx reconstruction.

Perfusion-Decellularized Larynx as a Natural 3D Scaffold in a Rabbit Model

INTRODUCTION

Decellularized larynges could be used as scaffolds to regenerate the larynx. The purpose of this study was to establish a perfusion decellularization protocol to produce a 3-dimensional whole laryngeal extracellular matrix (ECM) scaffold in a rabbit model.

METHODS

The larynges of 20 rabbits assigned to the study group were harvested and decellularized using a perfusion decellularization protocol, while the larynges of 10 rabbits in the control group were harvested and untreated. Macroscopic and microscopic morphological analyses, a molecular analysis, a cellular content analysis, and scanning electron microscopy were performed.

RESULTS

A histological analysis showed the absence of cellular components, the presence of the ECM, and an intact cartilage structure filled with chondrocytes. The mean total DNA amounts of the native larynx, decellularized larynx, and decellularized cartilage-free larynx were 1,826.40, 434.70, and 41.40 μg/µL, respectively; those for the decellularized larynx and decellularized cartilage-free larynx were significantly lower (p < 0.001 and p < 0.001, respectively). The total amount of DNA in the decellularized sample was significantly lower compared to that in the native sample, at 57.2% in cartilage (p < 0.001), 2.4% in the thyroid gland (p < 0.001), 2.7% in muscle (p < 0.001), 1.6% in vessels (p < 0.001), and 4.8% in the vocal cords (p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

Our perfusion decellularization protocol is feasible and reproducible to produce a 3-dimensional whole laryngeal ECM scaffold in a rabbit.

Tissue-engineered esophagus: recellular esophageal extracellular matrix based on perfusion-decellularized technique and mesenchymal stem cells

Perfusion-decellularization was an interesting technique to generate a natural extracellular matrix (ECM) with the complete three-dimensional anatomical structure and vascular system. In this study, the esophageal ECM (E-ECM) scaffold was successfully constructed by perfusion-decellularized technique through the vascular system for the first time. And the physicochemical and biological properties of the E-ECM scaffolds were evaluated. The bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells (BMSCs) were induced to differentiate into myocytesin vitro. E-ECM scaffolds reseeded with myocytes were implanted into the greater omenta to obtain recellular esophageal ECM (RE-ECM), a tissue-engineered esophagus. The results showed that the cells of the esophagi were completely and uniformly removed after perfusion. E-ECM scaffolds retained the original four-layer organizational structure and vascular system with excellent biocompatibility. And the E-ECM scaffolds had no significant difference in mechanical properties comparing with fresh esophagi,p> 0.05. Immunocytochemistry showed positive expression ofα-sarcomeric actin, suggesting that BMSCs had successfully differentiated into myocytes. Most importantly, we found that in the RE-ECM muscularis, the myocytes regenerated linearly and continuously and migrated to the deep, and the tissue vascularization was obvious. The cell survival rates at 1 week and 2 weeks were 98.5 ± 3.0% and 96.4 ± 4.6%, respectively. It was demonstrated that myocytes maintained the ability for proliferation and differentiation for at least 2 weeks, and the cell activity was satisfactory in the RE-ECM. It follows that the tissue-engineered esophagus based on perfusion-decellularized technique and mesenchymal stem cells has great potential in esophageal repair. It is proposed as a promising alternative for reconstruction of esophageal defects in the future.

An Exploratory Study into the Implantation of Arytenoid Cartilage Scaffold in the Horse

Respiratory function in the horse can be severely compromised by arytenoid chondritis, or arytenoid chondropathy, a pathologic condition leading to deformity and dysfunction of the affected cartilage. Current treatment in cases unresponsive to medical management is removal of the cartilage, which can improve the airway obstruction, but predisposes the patient to other complications like tracheal penetration of oropharyngeal content and dynamic collapse of the now unsupported soft tissue lateral to the cartilage. A tissue engineering approach to reconstructing the arytenoid cartilage would represent a significant advantage in the management of arytenoid chondritis. In this study, we explored if decellularized matrix could potentially be incorporated into the high motion environment of the arytenoid cartilages of horses. Equine arytenoid cartilages were decellularized and a portion of the resultant acellular scaffolds was implanted in a full-thickness defect created in the arytenoids of eight horses. The implantation was performed bilaterally in each horse, with one side randomly selected to receive an implant seeded with autologous bone marrow-derived nucleated cells (BMNCs). Arytenoids structure and function were monitored up to 4 months. In vivo assessments included laryngeal ultrasound, and laryngeal endoscopy at rest and during exercise on a high-speed treadmill. Histologic evaluation of the arytenoids was performed postmortem. Implantation of the cartilaginous graft had no adverse effect on laryngeal respiratory function or swallowing, despite induction of a transient granuloma on the medial aspect of the arytenoids. Ultrasonographic monitoring detected a postoperative increase in the thickness and cross-sectional area of the arytenoid body that receded faster in the arytenoids not seeded with BMNCs. The explanted tissue showed epithelialization of the mucosal surface, integration of the implant into the native arytenoid, with minimal adverse cellular reaction. Remodeling of the scaffold material was evident by 2 months after implantation. Preseeding the scaffold with BMNCs increased the rate of scaffold degradation and incorporation. Replacement of arytenoid portion with a tissue-engineered cartilaginous graft preseeded with BMNCs is surgically feasible in the horse, is well tolerated, and results in appropriate integration within the native tissue, also preventing laryngeal tissue collapse during exercise.

Combined Use of Detergents and Ultrasonication for Generation of an Acellular Pig Larynx

The larynx is a fairly complex organ comprised of different muscles, cartilages, mucosal membrane, and nerves. Larynx cancer is generally the most common type of head and neck cancer. Treatment options are limited in patients with total or partial laryngectomy. Tissue-engineered organs have shown to be a promising alternative treatment for patients with laryngectomy. In this report we present an alternative and simple procedure to construct a whole pig larynx scaffold consisting of complete acellular structures of integrated muscle and cartilage. Larynges were decellularized (DC) using perfusion-agitation with detergents coupled with ultrasonication. DC larynges were then characterized to investigate the extracellular matrix (ECM) proteins, residual DNA, angiogenic growth factors, and morphological and ultrastructural changes to ECM fibers. After 17 decellularization cycles, no cells were observed in all areas of the larynx as confirmed by hematoxylin and eosin and DAPI (4',6-diamidino-2-phenylindole) staining. However, DC structures of dense thyroid and cricoid cartilage showed remnants of cells. All structures of DC larynges (epiglottis [p < 0.0001], muscle [p < 0.0001], trachea [p = 0.0045], and esophagus [p = 0.0008]) showed DNA <50 ng/mg compared with native larynx. Immunohistochemistry, Masson's trichrome staining, and Luminex analyses showed preservation of important ECM proteins and angiogenic growth factors in DC larynges. Compared with other growth factors, mostly retained growth factors in DC epiglottis, thyroid muscle, and trachea include granulocyte colony-stimulating factor, Leptin, fibroblast growth factor-1, Follistatin, hepatocyte growth factor, and vascular endothelial growth factor-A. Scanning electron microscopy and transmission electron microscopy analysis confirmed the structural arrangements of ECM fibers in larynges to be well preserved after DC. Our findings suggest that larynges can be effectively DC using detergent ultrasonication. ECM proteins and angiogenic growth factors appear to be better preserved using this method when compared with the native structures of larynges. This alternative DC method could be helpful in building scaffolds from dense tissue structures such as cartilage, tendon, larynx, or trachea for future in vitro recellularization studies or in vivo implantation studies in the clinic.

Decellularization of the Porcine Ear Generates a Biocompatible, Nonimmunogenic Extracellular Matrix Platform for Face Subunit Bioengineering

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to assess whether perfusion-decellularization technology could be applied to facial grafts.

BACKGROUND

Facial allotransplantation remains an experimental procedure. Regenerative medicine techniques allow fabrication of transplantable organs from an individual's own cells, which are seeded into extracellular matrix (ECM) scaffolds from animal or human organs. Therefore, we hypothesized that ECM scaffolds also can be created from facial subunits. We explored the use of the porcine ear as a clinically relevant face subunit model to develop regenerative medicine-related platforms for facial bioengineering.

METHODS

Porcine ear grafts were decellularized and histologic, immunologic, and cell culture studies done to determine whether scaffolds retained their 3D framework and molecular content; were biocompatible in vitro and in vivo, and triggered an anti-MHC immune response from the host.

RESULTS

The cellular compartment of the porcine ear was completely removed except for a few cartilaginous cells, leaving behind an acellular ECM scaffold; this scaffold retained its complex 3D architecture and biochemical components. The framework of the vascular tree was intact at all hierarchical levels and sustained a physiologically relevant blood pressure when implanted in vivo. Scaffolds were biocompatible in vitro and in vivo, and elicited no MHC immune response from the host. Cells from different types remained viable and could even differentiate at the scale of a whole-ear scaffold.

CONCLUSIONS

Acellular scaffolds were produced from the porcine ear, and may be a valuable platform to treat facial deformities using regenerative medicine approaches.

Perfusion-decellularization of human ear grafts enables ECM-based scaffolds for auricular vascularized composite tissue engineering

INTRODUCTION

Human ear reconstruction is recognized as the emblematic enterprise in tissue engineering. Up to now, it has failed to reach human applications requiring appropriate tissue complexity along with an accessible vascular tree. We hereby propose a new method to process human auricles in order to provide a poorly immunogenic, complex and vascularized ear graft scaffold.

METHODS

12 human ears with their vascular pedicles were procured. Perfusion-decellularization was applied using a SDS/polar solvent protocol. Cell and antigen removal was examined by histology and DNA was quantified. Preservation of the extracellular matrix (ECM) was assessed by conventional and 3D-histology, proteins and cytokines quantifications. Biocompatibility was assessed by implantation in rats for up to 60 days. Adipose-derived stem cells seeding was conducted on scaffold samples and with human aortic endothelial cells whole graft seeding in a perfusion-bioreactor.

RESULTS

Histology confirmed cell and antigen clearance. DNA reduction was 97.3%. ECM structure and composition were preserved. Implanted scaffolds were tolerated in vivo, with acceptable inflammation, remodeling, and anti-donor antibody formation. Seeding experiments demonstrated cell engraftment and viability.

CONCLUSIONS

Vascularized and complex auricular scaffolds can be obtained from human source to provide a platform for further functional auricular tissue engineered constructs, hence providing an ideal road to the vascularized composite tissue engineering approach.

STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE

The ear is emblematic in the biofabrication of tissues and organs. Current regenerative medicine strategies, with matrix from donor tissues or 3D-printed, didn't reach any application for reconstruction, because critically missing a vascular tree for perfusion and transplantation. We previously described the production of vascularized and cell-compatible scaffolds, from porcine ear grafts. In this study, we ---- applied findings directly to human auricles harvested from postmortem donors, providing a perfusable matrix that retains the ear's original complexity and hosts new viable cells after seeding. This approach unlocks the ability to achieve an auricular tissue engineering approach, associated with possible clinical translation.

Decellularization Methods for Scaffold Fabrication

Decellularization is the process of removal of native cells from tissue, leaving behind a three-dimensional (3D) ultrastructure of extracellular matrix (ECM) proteins while preserving the bioactivity and mechanics of the tissue. It offers a unique top-down approach for fabricating ECM based natural scaffold for tissue engineering application. Herein, this chapter presents the fabrication of decellularized scaffold employing different methods: whole organ perfusion, immersion and agitation, pressure gradient, and supercritical fluid. The decellularized scaffold aims to exploit the nature-designed 3D architecture, a successful platform technology, for creating scaffolding materials for tissue engineering and regenerative medicine.

Glottic regeneration with a tissue-engineering technique, using acellular extracellular matrix scaffold in a canine model

Acellular extracellular matrix scaffold derived from porcine urinary bladder (UBM) is decellularized material that has shown success for constructive remodelling of various tissues and organs. The regenerative effects of UBM were reported for the tympanic membrane, oesophagus, trachea, larynx, pleura and pericardium in animal studies, with promising results. The aim of this study was to investigate the regenerative effects of UBM on hemilarynx, using a canine model. A left partial hemilaryngectomy was performed and the surgical defects were reconstructed by insertion of UBM scaffold. Although local infection was observed in one dog in 1 week after implantation of the scaffold, all dogs showed good re-epithelialization with minimum complication in 1 month. The effect of regeneration of the larynx was evaluated 6 months after the operation. The excised larynx experiments were performed to measure phonation threshold pressure (PTP), normalized mucosal wave amplitude (NMWA) and normalized glottal gap (NGG). The results of the measurements showed that PTP was normal or near normal in two cases and NMWA was within normal range in three cases, although there were individual variations. Histological examination was completed to evaluate structural changes in the scaffold with the appearance of the new cartilaginous structure. However, the regenerated vocal fold mucosa was mostly scarred. The UBM scaffold has shown to be biocompatible, biodegradable and useful for tissue regeneration of the hemilarynx, with possible restoration of function of the vocal fold. The vocal fold mucosa was scarred, which is the next challenge to be addressed. Copyright © 2014 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Extracellular Matrix for Vocal Fold Lamina Propria Replacement: A Review

The vocal folds (VFs) are exposed to a number of injurious stimuli that frequently lead to aberrant structural alterations and altered biomechanical properties that clinically manifest as voice disorders. Therapies to restore both structure and function of this delicate tissue are ideal. However, such methods have not been adequately developed. Our group and others hypothesize that tissue engineering and regenerative medicine approaches, previously described for other tissue systems, hold significant promise for the VFs. In this review, we explore the concept of tissue engineering as it relates to the VFs, as well as recent studies employing both naturally and synthetically derived biomaterials, including those from laryngeal and nonlaryngeal sources, in combination with stem cells for a tissue-engineered approach to VF repair.

Derivation and characterization of porcine vocal fold extracellular matrix scaffold

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS

To optimize decellularization of porcine vocal folds (VF) and quantify human bone marrow-derived mesenchymal stem cell (BM-MSC) interactions with this matrix to provide a foundation for regenerative approaches to VF repair.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

Vocal folds were dissected from porcine larynges and three decellularization protocols were compared, each consisting of washes and mechanical agitations with different combinations of reagents. DNA content was analyzed via Quant-iT Picogreen assay and hematoxylin and eosin staining. Bone marrow-derived MSCs were then seeded onto the decellularized VF matrices. Morphology, metabolic activity, DNA content, and gene expression were assessed using LIVE/DEAD Cell Viability, alamarBlue Cell Viability Assay, Quant-iT Picogreen assay, and quantitative polymerase chain reaction, respectively.

RESULTS

The most successful decellularization protocol removed 95% DNA content within 1 day, compared to several days required for previously described protocols. Histology confirmed the retention of extracellular matrix (ECM) and its components, including glycosaminoglycans, collagen, and fibrin, while void of nuclear/cellular content. Decellularized scaffolds were then seeded with BM-MSCs. Similar DNA quantities were observed after 24 hours of seeding within the VF-ECM scaffold when compared to cells on tissue culture plastic (TCP). LIVE/DEAD staining of the seeded VF-ECM confirmed excellent cell viability, and the metabolic activity of BM-MSCs increased significantly on VF-ECM compared to TCP. Endoglin gene expression decreased, suggestive of differentiation.

CONCLUSION

Porcine VFs can be efficiently decellularized within 5 hours using a combination of sodium deoxycholate and peracetic acid. Decellularized VF-ECM supported attachment and growth of human BM-MSCs, with evidence of differentiation.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

N/A.

Acceleration of vascularized bone tissue-engineered constructs in a large animal model combining intrinsic and extrinsic vascularization

During the last decades, a range of excellent and promising strategies in Bone Tissue Engineering have been developed. However, the remaining major problem is the lack of vascularization. In this study, extrinsic and intrinsic vascularization strategies were combined for acceleration of vascularization. For optimal biomechanical stability of the defect site and simplifying future transition into clinical application, a primary stable and approved nanostructured bone substitute in clinically relevant size was used. An arteriovenous (AV) loop was microsurgically created in sheep and implanted, together with the bone substitute, in either perforated titanium chambers (intrinsic/extrinsic) for different time intervals of up to 18 weeks or isolated Teflon(®) chambers (intrinsic) for 18 weeks. Over time, magnetic resonance imaging and micro-computed tomography (CT) analyses illustrate the dense vascularization arising from the AV loop. The bone substitute was completely interspersed with newly formed tissue after 12 weeks of intrinsic/extrinsic vascularization and after 18 weeks of intrinsic/extrinsic and intrinsic vascularization. Successful matrix change from an inorganic to an organic scaffold could be demonstrated in vascularized areas with scanning electron microscopy and energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy. Using the intrinsic vascularization method only, the degradation of the scaffold and osteoclastic activity was significantly lower after 18 weeks, compared with 12 and 18 weeks in the combined intrinsic-extrinsic model. Immunohistochemical staining revealed an increase in bone tissue formation over time, without a difference between intrinsic/extrinsic and intrinsic vascularization after 18 weeks. This study presents the combination of extrinsic and intrinsic vascularization strategies for the generation of an axially vascularized bone substitute in clinically relevant size using a large animal model. The additional extrinsic vascularization promotes tissue ingrowth and remodeling processes of the bone substitute. Extrinsic vessels contribute to faster vascularization and finally anastomose with intrinsic vasculature, allowing microvascular transplantation of the bone substitute after a shorter prevascularization time than using the intrinsic method only. It can be reasonably assumed that the usage of perforated chambers can significantly reduce the time until transplantation of bone constructs. Finally, this study paves the way for further preclinical testing for proof of the concept as a basis for early clinical applicability.

Tissue engineered scaffolds for an effective healing and regeneration: reviewing orthotopic studies

It is commonly stated that tissue engineering is the most promising approach to treat or replace failing tissues/organs. For this aim, a specific strategy should be planned including proper selection of biomaterials, fabrication techniques, cell lines, and signaling cues. A great effort has been pursued to develop suitable scaffolds for the restoration of a variety of tissues and a huge number of protocols ranging from in vitro to in vivo studies, the latter further differentiating into several procedures depending on the type of implantation (i.e., subcutaneous or orthotopic) and the model adopted (i.e., animal or human), have been developed. All together, the published reports demonstrate that the proposed tissue engineering approaches spread toward multiple directions. The critical review of this scenario might suggest, at the same time, that a limited number of studies gave a real improvement to the field, especially referring to in vivo investigations. In this regard, the present paper aims to review the results of in vivo tissue engineering experimentations, focusing on the role of the scaffold and its specificity with respect to the tissue to be regenerated, in order to verify whether an extracellular matrix-like device, as usually stated, could promote an expected positive outcome.

Adipose stem cells can secrete angiogenic factors that inhibit hyaline cartilage regeneration

Introduction

Adipose stem cells (ASCs) secrete many trophic factors that can stimulate tissue repair, including angiogenic factors, but little is known about how ASCs and their secreted factors influence cartilage regeneration. Therefore, the aim of this study was to determine the effects ASC-secreted factors have in repairing chondral defects.

Methods

ASCs isolated from male Sprague Dawley rats were cultured in monolayer or alginate microbeads supplemented with growth (GM) or chondrogenic medium (CM). Subsequent co-culture, conditioned media, and in vivo cartilage defect studies were performed.

Results

ASC monolayers and microbeads cultured in CM had decreased FGF-2 gene expression and VEGF-A secretion compared to ASCs cultured in GM. Chondrocytes co-cultured with GM-cultured ASCs for 7 days had decreased mRNAs for col2, comp, and runx2. Chondrocytes treated for 12 or 24 hours with conditioned medium from GM-cultured ASCs had reduced sox9, acan, and col2 mRNAs; reduced proliferation and proteoglycan synthesis; and increased apoptosis. ASC-conditioned medium also increased endothelial cell tube lengthening whereas conditioned medium from CM-cultured ASCs had no effect. Treating ASCs with CM reduced or abolished these deleterious effects while adding a neutralizing antibody for VEGF-A eliminated ASC-conditioned medium induced chondrocyte apoptosis and restored proteoglycan synthesis. FGF-2 also mitigated the deleterious effects VEGF-A had on chondrocyte apoptosis and phenotype. When GM-grown ASC pellets were implanted in 1 mm non-critical hyaline cartilage defects in vivo, cartilage regeneration was inhibited as evaluated by radiographic and equilibrium partitioning of an ionic contrast agent via microCT imaging. Histology revealed that defects with GM-cultured ASCs had no tissue ingrowth from the edges of the defect whereas empty defects and defects with CM-grown ASCs had similar amounts of neocartilage formation.

Conclusions

ASCs must be treated to reduce the secretion of VEGF-A and other factors that inhibit cartilage regeneration, which can significantly influence how ASCs are used for repairing hyaline cartilage.