Magnetically driven middle ear ossicles with laser vibrometry as a new diagnostic tool to quantify ossicular fixation

Radiological and Audiological Prediction for Ossicular Fixation in Chronic Otitis Media and Tympanic Membrane Perforation

OBJECTIVES

Recurrent middle-ear infection can lead to ossicular fixation, adversely affecting post-tympanoplasty hearing outcomes. Preoperative prediction of ossicular fixation remains challenging. We aimed to investigate potential predictors of ossicular fixation in patients with chronic otitis media.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective.

SETTING

Tertiary academic medical center.

PATIENTS

Patients with noncholesteatomatous chronic otitis media and tympanic membrane perforation, without ossicular discontinuities.

INTERVENTIONS

Diagnostic.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The fixation of each ossicle was assessed during tympanoplasty. The impact of preoperative otoscopic findings, computed tomography (CT) features, and hearing levels on the prediction of ossicular fixation was evaluated using uni- and multivariable logistic regression analyses.

RESULTS

One hundred thirty-five patients were included. Soft-tissue density between the malleus head and the anterior wall (odds ratio, 3.789 [95% confidence interval, 1.177-12.196]; p = 0.0255) and poor development of mastoid cells (16.826 [2.015-134.520]; p = 0.0078) were independent predictors of malleus fixation. In addition, ≥50% tympanic membrane perforation (5.412 [1.908-15.353]; p = 0.0015), poor development of mastoid cells (3.386 [1.039-11.034]; p = 0.0431), and a ≥40-dB preoperative air-bone gap (ABG) at 500 Hz (4.970 [1.732-14.261]; p = 0.0029) were independent predictors of incus fixation. Soft-tissue density surrounding the stapes (18.833 [1.856-191.104]; p = 0.0119) and a ≥40-dB preoperative ABG at 500 Hz (13.452 [1.640-∞]; p = 0.0138) were correlated with stapes fixation.

CONCLUSIONS

The accurate prediction of ossicular fixation in patients with chronic otitis media based on CT features and the ABG may facilitate decision-making regarding the need for ossiculoplasty, possibly avoiding unnecessary manipulation or overlooking of fixation.

Handheld laser-fiber vibrometry probe for assessing auditory ossicles displacement

SIGNIFICANCE

Measurements of auditory ossicles displacement are commonly carried out by means of laser-Doppler vibrometry (LDV), which is considered to be a gold standard. The limitation of the LDV method, especially for in vivo measurements, is the necessity to expose an object in a straight line to a laser beam operating from a distance. An alternative to this approach is the use of a handheld laser-fiber vibrometry probe (HLFVP) with a curved tip.

AIM

We evaluate the feasibility of an HLFVP with a curved tip for measuring sound-induced displacement of the auditory ossicles.

APPROACH

A handheld vibrometer probe guiding the laser beam with a fiber-optic cable was used for displacement measurements of the incus body and the posterior crus of the stapes. Tonal stimuli at frequencies of 0.5, 1, 2, and 4 kHz were presented by means of an insert earphone positioned in the outer ear canal. The probe was fixed at the measurement site using a tripod or hand-held by one of the two surgeons.

RESULTS

The measurements were carried out on six fresh temporal bones. Multivariate analysis of variance showed statistically significant differences for stimulus frequency (F3,143  =  29.37, p  <  0.001, and η2  =  0.35), bone (F5,143  =  4.61, p  =  0.001, and η2  =  0.01), and measurement site (F1,143  =  4.74, p  =  0.03, and η2  =  0.02) in the absence of statistically significant differences for the probe fixation method (F2,143  =  0.15, p  =  0.862, and η2  =  0.001). Standard deviations of the means were 6.9, 2.6, 1.9, and 0.6  nm  /  Pa for frequency, bone, site, and fixation, respectively. Ear transfer functions were found to be consistent with literature data.

CONCLUSIONS

The feasibility of applying HLFVP to measure the displacement of auditory ossicles has been confirmed. HLFVP offers the possibility of carrying out measurements at various angles; however, this needs to be standardized taking into account anatomical limitations and surgical convenience.

Measurement of middle ear transfer function in temporal bones using electromagnetic excitation: Comparison to sound excitation and evaluation of influencing factors

Hearing a sound produces vibrations of the ossicles in the middle ear, which can be measured in the micrometer to nanometer range. Destruction of middle ear structures results most commonly from chronic inflammatory diseases. In these cases, passive and active middle ear implants are used for reconstruction of the ossicular chain. The positioning of the implants depends primarily on the surgeon's experience. So far, no objective assessment has been conducted to affirm if the chosen positioning is the best in each specific case. We have established a new method, allowing us to measure the middle ear transfer function (METF) intraoperatively. Using the new method, a magnet is placed on the umbo of the malleus handle and is stimulated by a coil positioned underneath the head. The resulting vibration is measured on the stapes footplate using Laser Doppler vibrometry (LDV). Acoustic and electromagnetic excitation show comparable METF in lower frequencies, which differ up to 10 dB in frequencies over 1 kHz. The position of the coil does not play a relevant part in the METF, whereas the location of the magnet on the tympanic membrane highly impacts the METF. This technique demonstrates reproducible results. Electromagnetic excitation is comparable to sound excitation and is suited for measuring the METF. A stable positioning of the magnet on the umbo is essential in order to acquire valid data.

An Optimal Partial Ossicular Prosthesis Should Connect Both to the Tympanic Membrane and Malleus: A Temporal Bone Study Using Laser Doppler Vibrometry

OBJECTIVE

To compare stapes vibrations in different partial ossicular replacement prosthesis (PORP) applications.

METHODS

Stapedial vibrations were measured on fresh frozen human temporal bones with laser Doppler vibrometry. Eight different types of common ossiculoplasty methods were compared regarding recovery of stapes vibrations in relation with the normal ossicular chain. The PORPs were divided into three groups: 1) PORPs with the lateral contact only with the tympanic membrane, 2) PORPs with lateral contact only to the malleus handle, and 3) PORPs with lateral contact with both the malleus handle and the tympanic membrane.

RESULTS

The PORPs with lateral contact only to the malleus handle performed better than the PORPs with lateral contact to the tympanic membrane only at 2 kHZ, but the best recovery was found in the group with contact both to the malleus handle and the tympanic membrane.

CONCLUSION

The best sound transmission might be achieved by placing a PORP in contact with both the tympanic membrane and the handle of the malleus.

Sequential motion of the ossicular chain measured by laser Doppler vibrometry

OBJECTIVE

In order to help a surgeon make the best decision, a more objective method of measuring ossicular motion is required.

METHODS

A laser Doppler vibrometer was mounted on a surgical microscope. To measure ossicular chain vibrations, eight patients with cochlear implants were investigated. To assess the motions of the ossicular chain, velocities at five points were measured with tonal stimuli of 1 and 3 kHz, which yielded reproducible results. The sequential amplitude change at each point was calculated with phase shifting from the tonal stimulus. Motion of the ossicular chain was visualized from the averaged results using the graphics application.

RESULTS

The head of the malleus and the body of the incus showed synchronized movement as one unit. In contrast, the stapes (incudostapedial joint and posterior crus) moved synchronously in opposite phase to the malleus and incus. The amplitudes at 1 kHz were almost twice those at 3 kHz.

CONCLUSIONS

Our results show that the malleus and incus unit and the stapes move with a phase difference.

Ossiculoplasty on Isolated Malleus Fractures: A Human Temporal Bone Study Using Laser Doppler Vibrometry

HYPOTHESIS

In the literature several surgical methods have been reported that aim to improve hearing in patients with isolated malleus fractures; however, it is still not clear which method gives the best results.

BACKGROUND

In this study, laser Doppler vibrometry (LDV) was used to compare the outcome of different surgical methods on malleus fractures in fresh frozen human temporal bones.

METHODS

Fractured malleus shafts of defrosted human temporal bones were repaired with bone cement, with a malleus prosthesis from cortical bone, or with a partial ossicular replacement prosthesis (PORP) from cortical bone, and LDV measurements were obtained for analysis.

RESULTS

The best result was achieved with the bone cement only, applied directly at the site of the fracture. The malleus prosthesis and the PORP gave similar results.

CONCLUSION

All three surgical methods gave good results, but when the distal end of the fractured malleus can be attached close to the proximal end, the technique using only cement tends to be the best option. If the parts are too far apart, a malleus prosthesis or a PORP would be good options.

Towards quantitative diagnosis of ossicular fixation: Measurement of stapes fixations using magnetically driven ossicles in human temporal bones

CONCLUSION

Information on the degree of stapes fixation can be found by measuring the ratio of stapes to umbo and stapes to incus velocity.

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate a method of quantifying ossicular fixation in an ear with elevated tympanic membrane.

METHOD

Measurements were made on four fresh-frozen human temporal bones. After elevating the tympanic membrane, a small magnet was attached to the manubrium and an electromagnetic excitation coil was used to vibrate the ossicles. The vibration response of the umbo, the tip of the incus long process, and the posterior crus of the stapes were measured before and after partially fixing the footplate with luting cement.

RESULTS

The velocities at the different measurement points were unequally affected by the fixation. The difference in the velocity ratio between different points provides an indication of the degree of footplate fixation.

Nonlinear Vibration Response Measured at Umbo and Stapes in the Rabbit Middle ear

Using laser vibrometry and a stimulation and signal analysis method based on multisines, we have measured the response and the nonlinearities in the vibration of the rabbit middle ear at the level of the umbo and the stapes. With our method, we were able to detect and quantify nonlinearities starting at sound pressure levels of 93-dB SPL. The current results show that no significant additional nonlinearity is generated as the vibration signal is passed through the middle ear chain. Nonlinearities are most prominent in the lower frequencies (125 Hz to 1 kHz), where their level is about 40 dB below the vibration response. The level of nonlinearities rises with a factor of nearly 2 as a function of sound pressure level, indicating that they may become important at very high sound pressure levels such as those used in high-power hearing aids.