Recording from the inferior colliculus following cochlear inner hair cell damage

Measurements From Ears With Endolymphatic Hydrops and 2-Hydroxypropyl-Beta-Cyclodextrin Provide Evidence That Loudness Recruitment Can Have a Cochlear Origin

Background: Loudness recruitment is commonly experienced by patients with putative endolymphatic hydrops. Loudness recruitment is abnormal loudness growth with high-level sounds being perceived as having normal loudness even though hearing thresholds are elevated. The traditional interpretation of recruitment is that cochlear amplification has been reduced. Since the cochlear amplifier acts primarily at low sound levels, an ear with elevated thresholds from reduced cochlear amplification can have normal processing at high sound levels. In humans, recruitment can be studied using perceptual loudness but in animals physiological measurements are used. Recruitment in animal auditory-nerve responses has never been unequivocally demonstrated because the animals used had damage to sensory and neural cells, not solely a reduction of cochlear amplification. Investigators have thus looked for, and found, evidence of recruitment in the auditory central nervous system (CNS). While studies on CNS recruitment are informative, they cannot rule out the traditional interpretation of recruitment originating in the cochlea.

Design: We used techniques that could assess hearing function throughout entire frequency- and dynamic-range of hearing. Measurements were made from two animal models: guinea-pig ears with endolymphatic-sac-ablation surgery to produce endolymphatic hydrops, and naïve guinea-pig ears with cochlear perfusions of 13 mM 2-Hydroxypropyl-Beta-Cyclodextrin (HPBCD) in artificial perilymph. Endolymphatic sac ablation caused low-frequency loss. Animals treated with HPBCD had hearing loss at all frequencies. None of these animals had loss of hair cells or synapses on auditory nerve fibers.

Results: In ears with endolymphatic hydrops and those perfused with HPBCD, auditory-nerve based measurements at low frequencies showed recruitment compared to controls. Recruitment was not found at high frequencies (> 4 kHz) where hearing thresholds were normal in ears with endolymphatic hydrops and elevated in ears treated with HPBCD.

Conclusions: We found compelling evidence of recruitment in auditory-nerve data. Such clear evidence has never been shown before. Our findings suggest that, in patients suspected of having endolymphatic hydrops, loudness recruitment may be a good indication that the associated low-frequency hearing loss originates from a reduction of cochlear amplification, and that measurements of recruitment could be used in differential diagnosis and treatment monitoring of Ménière's disease.

Inner Hair Cell Loss Disrupts Hearing and Cochlear Function Leading to Sensory Deprivation and Enhanced Central Auditory Gain

There are three times as many outer hair cells (OHC) as inner hair cells (IHC), yet IHC transmit virtually all acoustic information to the brain as they synapse with 90–95% of type I auditory nerve fibers. Here we review a comprehensive series of experiments aimed at determining how loss of the IHC/type I system affects hearing by selectively destroying these cells in chinchillas using the ototoxic anti-cancer agent carboplatin. Eliminating IHC/type I neurons has no effect on distortion product otoacoustic emission or the cochlear microphonic potential generated by OHC; however, it greatly reduces the summating potential produced by IHC and the compound action potential (CAP) generated by type I neurons. Remarkably, responses from remaining auditory nerve fibers maintain sharp tuning and low thresholds despite innervating regions of the cochlea with ~80% IHC loss. Moreover, chinchillas with large IHC lesions have surprisingly normal thresholds in quiet until IHC losses exceeded 80%, suggesting that only a few IHC are needed to detect sounds in quiet. However, behavioral thresholds in broadband noise are elevated significantly and tone-in-narrow band noise masking patterns exhibit greater remote masking. These results suggest the auditory system is able to compensate for considerable loss of IHC/type I neurons in quiet but not in difficult listening conditions. How does the auditory brain deal with the drastic loss of cochlear input? Recordings from the inferior colliculus found a relatively small decline in sound-evoked activity despite a large decrease in CAP amplitude after IHC lesion. Paradoxically, sound-evoked responses are generally larger than normal in the auditory cortex, indicative of increased central gain. This gain enhancement in the auditory cortex is associated with decreased GABA-mediated inhibition. These results suggest that when the neural output of the cochlea is reduced, the central auditory system compensates by turning up its gain so that weak signals once again become comfortably loud. While this gain enhancement is able to restore normal hearing under quiet conditions, it may not adequately compensate for peripheral dysfunction in more complex sound environments. In addition, excessive gain increases may convert recruitment into the debilitating condition known as hyperacusis.

Persistent Thalamic Sound Processing Despite Profound Cochlear Denervation

Neurons at higher stages of sensory processing can partially compensate for a sudden drop in peripheral input through a homeostatic plasticity process that increases the gain on weak afferent inputs. Even after a profound unilateral auditory neuropathy where >95% of afferent synapses between auditory nerve fibers and inner hair cells have been eliminated with ouabain, central gain can restore cortical processing and perceptual detection of basic sounds delivered to the denervated ear. In this model of profound auditory neuropathy, auditory cortex (ACtx) processing and perception recover despite the absence of an auditory brainstem response (ABR) or brainstem acoustic reflexes, and only a partial recovery of sound processing at the level of the inferior colliculus (IC), an auditory midbrain nucleus. In this study, we induced a profound cochlear neuropathy with ouabain and asked whether central gain enabled a compensatory plasticity in the auditory thalamus comparable to the full recovery of function previously observed in the ACtx, the partial recovery observed in the IC, or something different entirely. Unilateral ouabain treatment in adult mice effectively eliminated the ABR, yet robust sound-evoked activity persisted in a minority of units recorded from the contralateral medial geniculate body (MGB) of awake mice. Sound driven MGB units could decode moderate and high-intensity sounds with accuracies comparable to sham-treated control mice, but low-intensity classification was near chance. Pure tone receptive fields and synchronization to broadband pulse trains also persisted, albeit with significantly reduced quality and precision, respectively. MGB decoding of temporally modulated pulse trains and speech tokens were both greatly impaired in ouabain-treated mice. Taken together, the absence of an ABR belied a persistent auditory processing at the level of the MGB that was likely enabled through increased central gain. Compensatory plasticity at the level of the auditory thalamus was less robust overall than previous observations in cortex or midbrain. Hierarchical differences in compensatory plasticity following sensorineural hearing loss may reflect differences in GABA circuit organization within the MGB, as compared to the ACtx or IC.

Central Gain Restores Auditory Processing following Near-Complete Cochlear Denervation

Sensory organ damage induces a host of cellular and physiological changes in the periphery and the brain. Here, we show that some aspects of auditory processing recover after profound cochlear denervation due to a progressive, compensatory plasticity at higher stages of the central auditory pathway. Lesioning >95% of cochlear nerve afferent synapses, while sparing hair cells, in adult mice virtually eliminated the auditory brainstem response and acoustic startle reflex, yet tone detection behavior was nearly normal. As sound-evoked responses from the auditory nerve grew progressively weaker following denervation, sound-evoked activity in the cortex-and, to a lesser extent, the midbrain-rebounded or surpassed control levels. Increased central gain supported the recovery of rudimentary sound features encoded by firing rate, but not features encoded by precise spike timing such as modulated noise or speech. These findings underscore the importance of central plasticity in the perceptual sequelae of cochlear hearing impairment.

Neural Hyperactivity of the Central Auditory System in Response to Peripheral Damage

It is increasingly appreciated that cochlear pathology is accompanied by adaptive responses in the central auditory system. The cause of cochlear pathology varies widely, and it seems that few commonalities can be drawn. In fact, despite intricate internal neuroplasticity and diverse external symptoms, several classical injury models provide a feasible path to locate responses to different peripheral cochlear lesions. In these cases, hair cell damage may lead to considerable hyperactivity in the central auditory pathways, mediated by a reduction in inhibition, which may underlie some clinical symptoms associated with hearing loss, such as tinnitus. Homeostatic plasticity, the most discussed and acknowledged mechanism in recent years, is most likely responsible for excited central activity following cochlear damage.

Selective Inner Hair Cell Dysfunction in Chinchillas Impairs Hearing-in-Noise in the Absence of Outer Hair Cell Loss

Poorer hearing in the presence of background noise is a significant problem for the hearing impaired. Ototoxic drugs, ageing, and noise exposure can damage the sensory hair cells of the inner ear that are essential for normal hearing sensitivity. The relationship between outer hair cell (OHC) loss and progressively poorer hearing sensitivity in quiet or in competing background noise is supported by a number of human and animal studies. In contrast, the effect of moderate inner hair cell (IHC) loss or dysfunction shows almost no impact on behavioral measures of hearing sensitivity in quiet, when OHCs remain intact, but the relationship between selective IHC loss and hearing in noise remains relatively unknown. Here, a moderately high dose of carboplatin (75 mg/kg) that produced IHC loss in chinchillas ranging from 40 to 80 % had little effect on thresholds in quiet. However, when tested in the presence of competing broadband (BBN) or narrowband noise (NBN), thresholds increased significantly. IHC loss >60 % increased signal-to-noise ratios (SNRs) for tones (500-11,300 Hz) in competing BBN by 5-10 dB and broadened the masking function under NBN. These data suggest that IHC loss or dysfunction may play a significant role in listening in noise independent of OHC integrity and that these deficits may be present even when thresholds in quiet are within normal limits.

Insensitivity of the audiogram to carboplatin induced inner hair cell loss in chinchillas

Noise trauma, aging, and ototoxicity preferentially damage the outer hair cells of the inner ear, leading to increased hearing thresholds and poorer frequency resolution. Whereas outer hair cells make synaptic connections with less than 10% of afferent auditory nerve fibers (type-II), inner hair cells make connections with over 90% of afferents (type-I). Despite these extensive connections, little is known about how selective inner hair cell loss impacts hearing. In chinchillas, moderate to high doses of the anticancer compound carboplatin produce selective inner hair cell and type-I afferent loss with little to no effect on outer hair cells. To determine the effects of carboplatin-induced inner hair cell loss on the most widely used clinical measure of hearing, the audiogram, pure-tone thresholds were determined behaviorally before and after 75 mg/kg carboplatin. Following carboplatin treatment, small effects on audiometric thresholds were observed even with extensive inner hair cell losses that exceed 80%. These results suggest that conventional audiometry is insensitive to inner hair cell loss and that only small populations of inner hair cells appear to be necessary for detecting tonal stimuli in a quiet background.

Tinnitus behavior and hearing function correlate with the reciprocal expression patterns of BDNF and Arg3.1/arc in auditory neurons following acoustic trauma

The molecular changes following sensory trauma and the subsequent response of the CNS are poorly understood. We focused on finding a molecular tool for monitoring the features of excitability which occur following acoustic trauma to the auditory system. Of particular interest are genes that alter their expression pattern during activity-induced changes in synaptic efficacy and plasticity. The expression of brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF), the activity-dependent cytoskeletal protein (Arg3.1/arc), and the immediate early gene c-Fos were monitored in the peripheral and central auditory system hours and days following a traumatic acoustic stimulus that induced not only hearing loss but also phantom auditory perception (tinnitus), as shown in rodent animal behavior models. A reciprocal responsiveness of activity-dependent genes became evident between the periphery and the primary auditory cortex (AI): as c-Fos and BDNF exon IV expression was increased in spiral ganglion neurons, Arg3.1/arc and (later on) BDNF exon IV expression was reduced in AI. In line with studies indicating increased spontaneous spike activity at the level of the inferior colliculus (IC), an increase in BDNF and GABA-positive neurons was seen in the IC. The data clearly indicate the usefulness of Arg3.1/arc and BDNF for monitoring trauma-induced activity changes and the associated putative plasticity responses in the auditory system.

Electrophysiological correlates of progressive sensorineural pathology in carboplatin-treated chinchillas

Carboplatin produces progressive damage to auditory nerve fibers, spiral ganglion neurons (SGNs) and inner hair cells (IHC) in the chinchilla cochlea but leaves outer hair cells intact. Within 1 h after injection, many afferent terminals beneath IHCs and myelin lamellae surrounding SGN processes are vacuolated. One day after injection, approximately half of the nerve fibers are missing. IHCs are intact at 2 days, but 20-30% are missing at 3 days. We studied the electrophysiological correlates of this progressive morphological damage by recording cochlear microphonics (CM), distortion product otoacoustic emissions (DPOAE), summating potentials (SP), compound action potentials (CAP) and midbrain evoked potentials (IC-EVP) before and 1 h, 12 h, 1 days, 3 days, 5 days, 7 days and 14 days after carboplatin injection (75 mg/kg IP) in four chinchillas. CM and DPOAEs tended to be unchanged or enhanced. CAP and SP showed little change until Day 3, when amplitudes were reduced in all animals and CAP thresholds were elevated by 9 dB; amplitudes declined further between Days 3 and 5 but not thereafter. IC-EVP amplitudes decreased on Days 3 or 5 but thresholds were relatively unchanged. All animals showed some recovery of IC-EVP between Days 7 and 14, including one with 70% enhancement on Day 14. The results indicate that threshold and amplitude measures fail to detect peripheral pathology until some relatively high threshold level of damage has been exceeded. This has important implications for monitoring peripheral damage and interpreting electrophysiological test results in animals and humans.

Reduction of inhibition in the inferior colliculus after inner hair cell loss

Effects of carboplatin-induced partial loss of inner hair cells on rate-level functions of neurons in the central nucleus of the inferior colliculus of the same chinchillas before and 1-3 months after carboplatin treatment were examined. Partial inner hair cell loss caused only a small elevation of response thresholds but induced a significant increase in the proportion of monotonic and a significant decrease in the proportion of non-monotonic rate-level functions at the characteristic frequency of 210 multiunits. This indicates that inhibition in the inferior colliculus is reduced after sensory deafferentation. We conclude that some of the functional changes reported in the auditory cortex after peripheral deafferentation are already realized at the level of the inferior colliculus.

Understanding drug ototoxicity: molecular insights for prevention and clinical management

Ototoxicity is a trait shared by aminoglycoside and macrolide antibiotics, loop diuretics, platinum-based chemotherapeutic agents, some NSAIDs and antimalarial medications. Because their benefits in combating certain life-threatening diseases often outweigh the risks, the use of these ototoxic drugs cannot simply be avoided. In this review, the authors discuss some of the most frequently used ototoxic drugs and what is currently known about the cell and molecular mechanisms underlying their noxious effects. The authors also provide suggestions for the clinical management of ototoxic medications, including ototoxic detection and drug monitoring. Understanding the mechanisms of drug ototoxicity may lead to new strategies for preventing and curing drug-induced hearing loss, as well as developing new pharmacological drugs with less toxic side effects.

Carboplatin-induced oxidative injury in rat inferior colliculus

Carboplatin is currently being used as an anticancer drug against human cancers. However, high dose of carboplatin chemotherapy resulted in ototoxicity in cancer patients. Carboplatin-induced ototoxicity was related to oxidative stress to the cochlea and inner hair cell loss in animals. It is likely that initial oxidative injury spreads throughout the neuroaxis of the auditory system later. The study aim was to evaluate carboplatin-induced hearing loss and oxidative injury to the central auditory system (inferior colliculus) of the rat. Male Wistar rats were divided into two groups of seven animals each and treated as follows: (1) control (normal saline, intraperitoneal [i.p.]) and (2) carboplatin (256 mg/kg, i.p.). Auditory brain-evoked responses (ABRs) were recorded before and 4 days after treatments. The animals were sacrificed on the 4th day and inferior colliculus from brain stem and cerebellum were isolated and analyzed. Carboplatin significantly elevated the hearing threshold shifts at clicks, 2-, 4-, 8-, 16-, and 32-kHz tone burst stimuli. Carboplatin significantly increased nitric oxide and lipid peroxidation, xanthine oxidase, and manganese superoxide dismutase activities in the inferior colliculus, but not in the cerebellum, indicating an enhanced flux of free radicals in the central auditory system. Carboplatin significantly depressed the reduced to oxidized glutathione ratio, antioxidant enzyme activities, such as copper-zinc superoxide dismutase, catalase, glutathione peroxidase, glutathione reductase, and glutathione S-transferase, and enzyme protein expressions in the inferior colliculus, but not in the cerebellum, 4 days after treatment. The data suggest that carboplatin induced oxidative injury specifically in the inferior colliculus of the rat leading to hearing loss.

Neuronal responses in the inferior colliculus of mutant mice (Bronx waltzer) with hereditary inner hair cell loss

Bronx waltzer mice lose a great proportion of their cochlear inner hair cells during early development. Hair cell counts revealed that these mice lacked on average 86% of their inner hair cells. Outer hair cells were present in a normal number, but appeared disarranged. The effect of this inner hair cell loss on the properties of central auditory neurons was investigated by recording neuronal responses in the inferior colliculus. Neuronal thresholds were on average elevated by 40 dB compared to CBA controls. The frequency tuning curves of the mutants were broad, and in part (18.5%) multi-peaked. The tonotopy found in the inferior colliculus of the Bronx waltzer mice appeared diffuse. Both the driven and spontaneous discharge rates were not statistically significantly different from the controls. However, the average first spike latency was significantly longer in the Bronx waltzer mice.

Functional reorganization in chinchilla inferior colliculus associated with chronic and acute cochlear damage

This paper describes some of the unexpected functional changes that occur in the inferior colliculus (IC) following noise- and drug-induced cochlear pathology. A striking example of this is the compensation that is seen in IC responsiveness after drug-induced selective inner hair cell (IHC) loss. Despite a massive reduction in the compound action potential (CAP) caused by partial IHC loss, the evoked potential amplitude from the IC shows little or no reduction. Acoustic trauma, which impairs cochlear sensitivity and tuning, also reduces the CAP amplitude. Despite this reduced neural input, IC amplitude sometimes increases at a faster than normal rate and the response amplitude is enhanced at frequencies below the hearing loss. Single unit recordings suggest the IC enhancement phenomenon may be due to the loss of lateral inhibition. After an acute traumatizing exposure to a tone located above the characteristic frequency (CF), approximately 50% of IC neurons show a significant increase in their spike rate, a significant expansion of the low frequency tail of the tuning curve and a significant improvement in sensitivity in the tail of the tuning curve. These changes suggest that IC neurons receive inhibition from a high frequency side band and that this inhibition is diminished by acoustic trauma above CF. To determine if side band inhibition was locally mediated, specific antagonist(s) to inhibitory neurotransmitters were applied and found to produce effects similar to acoustic trauma. The results suggest that lesioned-induced central auditory plasticity could contribute to several symptoms associated with sensorineural hearing loss such as loudness recruitment, tinnitus and poor speech discrimination in noise.

Auditory plasticity and hyperactivity following cochlear damage

This paper will review some of the functional changes that occur in the central auditory pathway after the cochlea is damaged by acoustic overstimulation or by carboplatin, an ototoxic drug that selectively destroys inner hair cells (IHCs) in the chinchilla. Acoustic trauma typically impairs the sensitivity and tuning of auditory nerve fibers and reduces the neural output of the cochlea. Surprisingly, our results show that restricted cochlear damage enhances neural activity in the central auditory pathway. Despite a reduction in the auditory-nerve compound action potential (CAP), the local field potential from the inferior colliculus (IC) increases at a faster than normal rate and its maximum amplitude is enhanced at frequencies below the region of hearing loss. To determine if this enhancement was due to loss of sideband inhibition, we recorded from single neurons in the IC and dorsal cochlear nucleus before and after presenting a traumatizing above the unit's characteristic frequency (CF). Following the exposure, some neurons showed substantial broadening of tuning below CF, less inhibition, and a significant increase in discharge rate, consistent with a model involving loss of sideband inhibition. The central auditory system of the chinchilla can be deprived of some of its cochlear inputs by selectively destroying IHCs with carboplatin. Selective IHC loss reduces the amplitude of the CAP without affecting the threshold and tuning of the remaining auditory nerve fibers. Although the output of the cochlea is reduced in proportion to the amount of IHC loss, the IC response shows only a modest amplitude reduction, and remarkably, the response of the auditory cortex is enhanced. These results suggest that the gain of the central auditory pathway can be up- or down regulated to compensate for the amount of neural activity from the cochlea.

An animal model of auditory neuropathy

OBJECTIVE

We describe an animal model of auditory neuropathy in which subjects have extensive, scattered inner haircell loss but with a relatively intact outer haircell population.

DESIGN

Such a pattern of cochlear haircell damage can be produced in the chinchilla by treatment with the anticancer agent carboplatin.

RESULTS

In these subjects, otoacoustic emissions (OAEs) and cochlear microphonics remain normal while auditory brain stem evoked potential (ABR) thresholds are significantly elevated. However, in the same subjects, central auditory neurons (in the inferior colliculus) have response thresholds that are considerably lower (by up to 50 dB) than ABR thresholds. These findings parallel the characteristics of auditory neuropathy in humans, in which absent or abnormal ABRs are recorded in patients with only mild to moderate audiometric thresholds and preserved OAEs.

CONCLUSIONS

We suggest that scattered inner haircell lesions also can result from long-term cochlear hypoxia, and we propose that this is a likely candidate for the etiology of many types of auditory neuropathy in human subjects.

Effects of inner hair cell loss on inferior colliculus evoked potential thresholds, amplitudes and forward masking functions in chinchillas

The effects of outer hair cell (OHC) loss on evoked potential (EVP) thresholds, amplitudes and forward masking (FWM) functions have been fairly well characterized. In contrast, the effects of inner hair cell (IHC) losses are largely unknown, primarily due to the difficulty of producing selective IHC lesions. Recent studies have shown that IHCs of the chinchilla are preferentially damaged by the anticancer drug, carboplatin. In this study, we administered a single 100 mg/kg dose of carboplatin to four chinchillas, to examine the effects of IHC lesions on EVPs measured from the inferior colliculus (IC-EVPs). Thresholds and amplitude functions were measured for 0.25-16 kHz tone bursts, and FWM functions were measured at 1, 2 and 4 kHz, using masker probe intervals of 2, 5, 10, 20, 40 and 80 ms, before and 1-2 months after carboplatin treatment. Histology revealed IHC lesions ranging from approximately 15 to 90%, with virtually no loss of OHCs. Surprisingly, even massive IHC lesions were not associated with elevations of IC-EVP thresholds. IC-EVP amplitudes at suprathreshold levels were sometimes depressed, sometimes enhanced, and in some cases unchanged. IHC lesions increased susceptibility to FWM, particularly at intermediate (10-20 ms) masker-probe intervals, without significantly changing the overall time course of FWM. The results provide new perspectives on the contribution of IHCs to FWM, and on the ability of the central auditory system to adapt to a significant reduction of neural input from the cochlea.

The effects of click level, click rate, and level of background masking noise on the inferior colliculus potential (ICP) in the normal and carboplatin-treated chinchilla

Carboplatin produces a selective loss of inner hair cells in chinchilla, substantially reducing the amplitude of the compound action potential. A key question that arises from these experiments is: What effect does a reduction in IHC-eighth-nerve fiber input have on the central auditory nervous system? This investigation evaluated the inferior colliculus potential (ICP) in chinchillas treated with carboplatin. The left ear was surgically destroyed and a recording electrode was placed in the left inferior colliculus. Following thirteen days of recovery time, the ICP was recorded in the awake animal. Click level was varied from 10-20 to 80 dB pSPL. Click rate was varied from 10 to 1000 Hz using both conventional averaging and a cross-correlation procedure. Broadband masking noise was varied from 30 to 70 dB SPL with click level held constant at 80 dB pSPL. The dependent variables were the positive peak latency and peak-to-following trough amplitude of the evoked potential. Following baseline studies, the animals were administered carboplatin (50 mg/kg IP) and retested two weeks later. Prior to carboplatin administration, there was an increase in ICP latency and a decrease in ICP amplitude with decreasing stimulus level, increasing rate and increasing noise level. Mean ICP threshold was 30 dB pSPL. Following carboplatin administration, there was little change in threshold or peak latencies. In contrast, the amplitude of the ICP was reduced on average by one-third, although this effect varied considerably across animals. The magnitude of this amplitude decrement was not strongly dependent on click level, click rate, or the level of background noise.