A 500 KHz localized current field hyperthermia system for use with ophthalmic plaque radiotherapy

Long-term followup comparing two treatment dosing strategies of (125) I plaque radiotherapy in the management of small/medium posterior uveal melanoma

Objective. To investigate the efficacy of two different dosing strategies of radioactive iodine-125 (¹²⁵I) in the management of small- and medium-sized posterior uveal melanoma. Patients and Methods. The medical records of consecutive patients with choroidal melanomas between 1.5 and 5.0 mm in apical height treated initially with ¹²⁵I plaque radiotherapy were reviewed. Patients were treated with one of the following two treatment dosing strategies: (1) 85 Gy to the apical height of the tumor (group 1) or (2) 85 Gy to a prescription point of 5.0 mm (group 2). Results. Of 95 patients, 55 patients were treated to the apical height of the tumor, and 40 were treated to a prescription point of 5.0 mm. Comparative analysis of the incidence rates of specific complications between the two groups demonstrates that group 2 had a significantly higher incidence of radiation retinopathy, radiation optic neuropathy, and/or visually significant cataract formation than group 1 (P = 0.028). Conclusion. Treatment of choroidal melanomas less than 5 mm in apical height with ¹²⁵I brachytherapy to the true apical height is equally effective when compared to treatment with 85 Gy to 5.0 mm. Treatment to the apical height of the tumor may result in lower incidence of radiation-related complications.

Episcleral plaque 125I radiotherapy with episcleral LCF hyperthermia: a prospective randomized trial

PURPOSE

The purpose of this study was to search for an optimal radiation dose in the treatment of patients with uveal melanoma using 125I episcleral plaque radiotherapy (EPRT) and episcleral hyperthermia (HT).

METHODS AND MATERIALS

From 1991-1998, 35 patients with uveal melanoma were enrolled in a phase II prospective randomized trial of 125I EPRT combined with episcleral HT. Two groups were closely matched for pre-treatment patient and tumor characteristics. Group 1: N = 16, and Group 2: N = 19. The median dose to the tumor apex for Group 1 was 80.0 Gy and 60.8 Gy for Group 2. Episcleral HT was given once for 45 min immediately prior to EPRT with a median temperature of 44 degrees C for both groups. The median follow-up was 5.5 years for Group 1 and 5.3 years for Group 2.

RESULTS

The median tumor height decreased 1.7 mm for patients of both groups. The 5- and 8-year probability of local recurrence was 33% for Group 1, and 25% for Group 2, p = 0.73. The 5-year probability of DFS was 54% for Group 1 and 67% for Group 2, p = 0.51. The 5- and 8-year overall survival was 68% and 34%, respectively, for Group 1, and 83% and 50%, respectively, for Group 2, p = 0.60. The rate of distant metastasis at 5- and 8-years for Group 1 was 29% and 62%, respectively, and 17% and 17%, respectively, for Group 2, p = 0.18. The incidence of enucleation was 4 (25%) in Group 1 vs. 4 (22%) in Group 2. The incidence of late complications was similar in either treatment group. The ambulatory visual acuity (> 5/200) at last follow-up was slightly better in Group 2 (80%) than Group 1 (64%).

CONCLUSIONS

Treatment outcomes were similar despite a 25% difference in radiation dose. In view of these findings and in an attempt to reduce the incidence of late treatment toxicity a still lower radiation dose in combination with HT needs to be studied. The reported outcomes need to be evaluated with caution due to the small number of patients in this study.

Radiation therapy for choroidal melanoma

Radiotherapy offers patients with malignant melanoma of the choroid an eye and a vision-sparing alternative to enucleation. The most commonly used forms of radiotherapy are ophthalmic plaque brachytherapy and charged-particle (external beam) radiotherapy. Unfortunately, after all forms of radiotherapy for choroidal melanoma many patients experience sight-limiting side effects, and an average of 16.3% of patients treated with radiotherapy subsequently require enucleation because of tumor regrowth or uncontrollable neovascular glaucoma. The severity, location, and incidence of radiation-induced complications are related to the type of radiation used, its method of delivery, amount of radiation delivered to normal ocular structures, the size and location of the tumor, as well as its response to irradiation. Current research is directed toward developing methods to reduce the amount of radiation delivered to normal structures, e.g., adding heat to radiotherapy. The true viability and metastatic potential of irradiated uveal melanoma cells has not been established, although clinical studies have reported local control of choroidal melanoma in 81-100% (mean = 92.8%) of cases. The purpose of this review is to present the world's experience with radiotherapy for choroidal melanoma, information that will contribute to patient education and informed consent.

Ferromagnetic hyperthermia: functional and histopathologic effects on normal rabbit ocular tissue

Ferromagnetic (FM) hyperthermia has previously been evaluated in a rabbit tumour model of ocular melanoma. To study the effect of focal heating in normal rabbit eyes, FM seeds were implanted into a 14-mm episcleral plaque an heated to operating temperatures of 48 or 58 degrees C. Thermal induction was performed by placing rabbits in a uniform, oscillating (11 kHz) magnetic field operating at 1200 W and as H-field strength of 265 A/m. Eyes were heated for 60 min with continuous scleral temperature monitoring. Hyperthermic effects were monitored by direct opthalmic examination, fundus photography, serial electroretinography and histopathology. Intraocular temperatures were mapped with direct fiberoptic thermometry. All treatment effects were confined to the area covered by the episcleral plaque. Direct ophthalmoscopic examination revealed early retinal whitening during heat induction followed by localized exudative retinal detachments, limited to the area of the retinal surface overlying the plaque, that resolved spontaneously. Serial electroretinography was virtually indistinguishable between the 48 and 54 degrees C temperature groups. We noted a minimal alteration in a- and b-wave amplitudes with no changes in implicit times. Histopathology at 3 weeks post-treatment documented chorioretinal scarring overlying the thermal plaque treatment zone. No evidence of heamorrhage infection, cataract or scleral thinning was noted. This study documents the apparent focal containment of thermal effects with FM heating utilizing operating temperatures ad high as 54 degrees C for 60 min, and discloses no evidence of diffuse ocular toxicity.

Episcleral plaque thermoradiotherapy of posterior uveal melanomas

Episcleral plaque radiotherapy is a widely applied treatment for selected patients with uveal melanomas. This treatment is well tolerated but may produce severe late radiation complications resulting in decreased visual acuity that reduces the attractiveness of conservative therapy. The purpose of this study was to access if the addition of episcleral hyperthermia decreases late radiation complications through radiation dose reduction while maintaining high incidence of local tumor control. In a 3-year period, episcleral plaque thermoradiotherapy was given to 25 patients with uveal melanoma in a Phase I study. The mean tumor height was 6.2 mm and the mean tumor basal area was 173 mm(2). The mean radiation dose given to the tumor apex was 72.2 Gy and the mean hyperthermia temperature, given once for 45 min, was 43.5 degrees C. Of the 25 patients treated, 22 (88%) showed tumor height reduction, 2 (8%) showed no change, and 1 (4%) had an increase in tumor height. At the last follow-up (range, 20-68 months; mean, 31.2 months), a 43% mean tumor height reduction was recorded (p = 0.0002). Of the 22 patients initially showing tumor regression, 2 (9%) had subsequent tumor progression. At least ambulatory vision (>5/200) was maintained by 20 (80%) patients. Severe complications, including hemorrhagic retinal detachment and a large vitreous hemorrhage, were seen in 2 (8%) patients early in this Phase I study. The treatment program was well tolerated by the study patients. Severe late treatment toxicity was sharply reduced by limiting the mean scleral temperature to < or equal to 44 degrees C. This study employing 30% lower radiation doses, showed tumor regression in the majority of patients. Longer follow-up is needed to assess long-term treatment efficacy and late treatment complications.

Thermoradiotherapy of intraocular tumors in an animal model: concurrent vs. sequential brachytherapy and ferromagnetic hyperthermia

PURPOSE

To compare concurrent vs. sequential ferromagnetic thermoradiotherapy in vivo.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Greene melanomas were implanted subretinally in rabbits and observed until they were 3-5 mm in diameter. Episcleral plaques were assembled with 125I seeds for radiation therapy, or with ferromagnetic (FM) thermoseeds and nonradioactive I seeds for hyperthermia. Rabbits were implanted by centering a plaque over the intraocular melanoma. After a given dose of radiation had been delivered, the plaque was removed and a nonradioactive plaque containing FM thermoseeds was inserted into the same extrascleral space. One hour later, hyperthermia (46-47 degrees C at the plaque-scleral interface) was initiated and continued for a period of 1 h by placing the rabbits in a magnetic induction coil powered to 1200 W. Tumor size was determined at 1- to 2-week intervals by indirect ophthalmoscopy and by ultrasound.

RESULTS

Dose-response analysis of 27 treated eye melanomas showed 50% local tumor control at 43 Gy for 125I alone and 29.4 Gy for 125I followed by FM hyperthermia. The thermal enhancement ratio was 1.4.

CONCLUSION

Comparison with a previously published thermal enhancement ratio of 4.4 (for concurrent 125I and FM hyperthermia) leads us to conclude that thermal enhancement of 125I brachytherapy is more efficient in this tumor model system when hyperthermia is delivered during, rather than after, the irradiation process.

Concurrent ferromagnetic hyperthermia and 125I brachytherapy in a rabbit choroidal melanoma model

Ferromagnetic (FM) thermoseeds and radioactive (125I) seeds were combined in an episcleral plaque to give concurrent hyperthermia and irradiation for enhanced tumour destruction. A Greene melanoma cell line was utilized to study the interaction between these treatment modalities. We attached five FM thermoseeds (with an operating temperature of 48 degrees C) in parallel with alternating rows of 125I seeds onto the inner surface of each 14 mm Silastic plaque. Plaques were centred over a 3-6 mm (diameter) intraocular melanoma in each rabbit. Some rabbits were then placed within a heating coil, and their eye tumours were warmed rapidly to therapeutic temperatures (43.6 degrees C across the tumour base) while the temperature of normal conjunctiva across the globe did not exceed 38.5 degrees C. Analysis of 49 treated eye melanomas showed 50% local tumour control at 41.7 Gy for 125I alone, whereas only 9.5 Gy were needed to give the same local control rate after 125I with concurrent FM hyperthermia. Thus, a thermal enhancement ratio of 4.4 was obtained. Hyperthermia alone gave a 20% tumour response rate, but responses were only temporary. We conclude that FM thermoseeds can be used to deliver biologically effective hyperthermia concurrently with radiation, thereby reducing the dose of radiation needed for tumour control.

Microwave plaque thermoradiotherapy for choroidal melanoma

Microwave thermoradiotherapy was used as a primary treatment for 44 patients with choroidal melanoma. An episcleral dish-shaped microwave antenna was placed beneath the tumour at the time of plaque brachytherapy. While temperatures were measured at the sclera, the tumour's apex was targeted to receive a minimum of 42 degrees C for 45 minutes. In addition, the patients received full or reduced doses of plaque radiotherapy. No patients have been lost to follow-up. Two eyes have been enucleated: one for rubeotic glaucoma, and one for uveitic glaucoma. Though six patients have died, only one death was due to metastatic choroidal melanoma (39 months after treatment). Clinical observations suggest that the addition of microwave heating to plaque radiation therapy of choroidal melanoma has been well tolerated. There has been a 97.7% local control rate (with a mean follow-up of 22.2 months). We have reduced the minimum tumour radiation dose (apex dose) to levels used for thermoradiotherapy of cutaneous melanomas (50 Gy/5000 rad). Within the range of this follow-up period no adverse effects which might preclude the use of this microwave heat delivery system for treatment of choroidal melanoma have been noted.

Episcleral plaque thermoradiotherapy in patients with choroidal melanoma

From 1988 to 1991, 21 patients with uveal melanoma were treated in a Phase I study with episcleral plaque radiotherapy (EPRT). This irradiation was combined with localized current field episcleral hyperthermia (LCFHT). Tumor stage was: T3 = 15 (71%) and T2 = 6 (29%). Follow-up ranged from 2 to 42 months (mean 9.2 months). EPRT was given using custom built I-125 gold plaques. Radiation doses to the tumor apex ranged from 13 to 123 Gy (mean dose 70.0 Gy) given at a mean dose rate of 55 cGy/hr. LCFHT was given with 500 KHz frequency for 45 min immediately before EPRT. The temperature was controlled on the scleral surface using four thermocouples. T mean ranged from 42.5 degrees C to 45 degrees C +/- 0.5 degrees C (mean 43.4 degrees C). The study patients showed rapid tumor necrosis. A 25% mean decrease of apical tumor dimension was noted, p = 0.0007. At least ambulatory vision (greater than 5/200) was maintained by 17/21 (81%) patients. Visual acuity was seen to improve greater than 6 months post-plaque therapy in 10 (48%) study patients. This was following an intermediate decrease in visual acuity. Severe complications, including large hemorrhagic retinal detachment and large vitreous hemorrhage, were seen in two (9.5%) of the early study patients. A mean scleral temperature reduction to less than or equal to 44 degrees C +/- 0.5 degrees C resulted in good treatment tolerance and a lack of serious complications in subsequently treated patients. A Phase II prospective randomized trial comparing LCFHT with 60 versus 80 Gy EPRT dose to the tumor apex is currently being activated for patients with choroidal melanoma.

Combined localized current field hyperthermia and irradiation for intraocular tumors

Ten patients with large melanomas and one patient with recurrent retinoblastoma were treated with combined localized current field (LCF) hyperthermia and iodine 125 irradiation delivered by episcleral plaque. Tumors were heated to 43 degrees to 45 degrees C for 28 to 45 minutes. Localized current field hyperthermia when combined with irradiation appeared to induce rapid tumor necrosis. One eye enucleated 17 hours after treatment showed only focal necrosis of the melanoma, while another eye demonstrated extensive necrosis 60 hours after treatment. In all remaining eyes, tumor regression occurred within the first month of treatment. Complications included cataract formation in six eyes, hemorrhagic retinal detachment in five eyes, and phthisis in two eyes. Complications from combined therapy of large intraocular tumors in this series appeared to result from the rapid necrosis of the tumor and secondary intraocular inflammation. Intraocular temperature dosimetry measurements demonstrated a temperature gradient of not more than -0.23 degrees C/mm-1 per axial millimeter from the episcleral plaque surface to the apex of the tumor. The authors believe that LCF hyperthermia could be a suitable means of application of hyperthermia in patients with intraocular tumors if further modifications were performed to reduce ocular complications.

Localized current field hyperthermia: effect on normal ocular tissue

Using a 500 kHz radiofrequency electromagnetic heating system, the effects of localized current field hyperthermia in normal rabbit eyes were examined. A specially designed scleral plaque placed on normal rabbit eyes was heated to temperatures of 43 degrees C, 45 degrees C, and 47 degrees C for a period of 45 min. The effects of hyperthermia were monitored by clinical examination, fluorescein angiography, electroretinography and histopathology. A graded effect with increasing temperature was found at the lower temperature, and it was confined to the treatment field. At 47 degrees C the electroretinogram was extinguished due to diffuse photoreceptor damage outside the treatment field, as demonstrated by histopathology and electron microscopy. This study indicates that hyperthermia at 45 degrees C for 45 min is the maximum allowable temperature without causing diffuse retinal damage in the normal rabbit eye.

An interactive treatment planning system for ophthalmic plaque radiotherapy

Brachytherapy using removable episcleral plaques containing sealed radioisotope sources is being studied as an alternative to enucleation in the treatment of choroidal melanoma and other tumors of the eye. Encouraging early results have been reported, but late complications which lead to loss of vision continue to be a problem. A randomized national study, the Collaborative Ocular Melanoma Study (COMS) is currently in progress to evaluate the procedure. The COMS specified isotope is 125I. Precise dosimetric calculations near the plaque may correlate strongly with complications and could also be used to optimize isotope loading patterns in the plaques. A microcomputer based treatment planning system has been developed for ophthalmic plaque brachytherapy. The program incorporates an interactive, 3-dimensional, solid-surface, color-graphic interface. The program currently supports 125I and 192Ir seeds which are treated as anisotropic line sources. Collimation effects related to plaque structure are accounted for, permitting detailed study of shielding effectiveness near the lip of a plaque. A dose distribution matrix may be calculated in any subregion of a transverse, sagittal, or coronal planar cross section of the eye, in any plane transecting the plaque and crossing the eye diametrically, or on a spherical surface within or surrounding the eye. Spherical surfaces may be displayed as 3-dimensional perspective projections or as funduscopic diagrams. Isodose contours are interpolated from the dose matrix. A pointer is also available to explicitly calculate and display dose at any location on the dosimetry surface. An interactive editing capability allows new plaque designs to be rapidly added to the system.

Effects of microwave-induced hyperthermia on the anterior segment of healthy rabbit eyes

Hyperthermia was induced in nine healthy rabbit eyes by means of a microwave 2450 MHz stripline applicator. The anterior segment of each eye was heated to a fixed temperature of between 42 degrees C and 46 degrees C for 30 min. The temperature distribution in the eye was calculated using a thermal model and the actual boundary temperatures and microwave intensity were measured. The effects of treatment were evaluated by daily macroscopic examination, fluorescein angiography and fluorophotometry, as well as by histology. Histological examination of changes induced by this hyperthermic delivery system revealed a sharp transition at 44 degrees-45 degrees C from no permanent damage to the anterior chamber at lower temperatures to serious damage such as local necrosis, pigment disruption and local cataract at high temperatures. A sharp transition in the same temperature range was observed in vivo in the fluorescein leakage of the iris vessels by comparative fluorescein angiography and by anterior segment fluorophotometry.

The current and potential role of hyperthermia in radiotherapy

Current clinical experience strongly suggests that hyperthermia will become an important modality as an adjuvant to radiotherapy in the treatment of locally advanced solid tumors. Hyperthermia must therefore be considered a topic of general interest. Biologically, hyperthermia has two different types of interactions with radiation. Firstly, heat has a radiosensitizing effect. This is most prominent with simultaneous application, but is of the same magnitude in both tumor and normal tissue and will not improve the therapeutic ratio unless the tumor is heated to a higher temperature than the normal tissue. Secondly, hyperthermia exhibits a direct cytotoxic effect, and a moderate heat treatment alone can almost selectively destroy tumor cells in a nutritionally deprived chronically hypoxic and acidic environment. Because such cells are the most radioresistant, a smaller radiation dose is needed to control the remaining more radiosensitive cells. If critical, irradiated normal tissues are also heated, the cytotoxicity is best utilised if heat is given at least 3-4 hours after irradiation. The magnitude of both the sensitizing and the cytotoxic effect depends on temperature and heating time. Clinically, heating of superficial tumors (e.g. breast, neck nodes and malignant melanoma) has confirmed the biological rationale for using hyperthermia as an adjuvant to radiotherapy. An overview of available data gives thermal enhancement ratios of approximately 1.5 in several superficial tumor sites after external heating. From a practical point of view, true simultaneous treatment is almost impossible using external heating, and the major effect of the combined treatment will have to rely on hyperthermic cytotoxicity. This makes the design of clinical schedules less complicated since only a few heat fractions may be needed to achieve an optimal effect. On this basis, several randomized clinical trials have been activated with the aim to evaluate the role of adjuvant hyperthermia in the primary treatment of advanced (superficial) tumors. In addition, studies are underway to specifically elucidate the clinical relevance of thermotolerance and other biological issues. So far, the clinical evaluation has almost solely been limited to superficial tumors, or to situations where interstitial heating is feasible. External heating of "deep" seated tumors is still preliminary, and most studies are in Phase I-II, with emphasis on toxicity and feasibility. The initial results are promising with regard to improved tumor control and acceptable toxicity.