Relationship between estrogen receptor status in the primary tumor and its regional and distant metastases. An immunohistochemical study in human breast cancer

Estrogen, progesterone, and HER2/neu receptor discordance between primary and metastatic breast tumours-a review

Discordance in estrogen (ER), progesterone (PR), and HER2/neu status between primary breast tumours and metastatic disease is well recognized. In this review, we highlight how receptor discordance between primary tumours and paired metastasis can help elucidate the mechanism of metastasis but can also effect patient management and the design of future trials. Discordance rates and ranges were available from 47 studies (3384 matched primary and metastatic pairs) reporting ER, PR, and HER2/neu expression for both primary and metastatic sites. Median discordance rates for ER, PR, and HER2/neu were 14 % (range 0-67 %, IQR 9-25 %), 21 % (range 0-62 %, IQR 15-41 %), and 10 % (range 0-44 %, IQR 4-17 %), respectively. Loss of receptor expression was more common (9.17 %) than gain (4.51 %). Discordance rates varied amongst site of metastasis with ER discordance being highest in bone metastases suggesting that discordance is a true biological phenomenon. Discordance rates vary for both the biomarker and the metastatic site. Loss of expression is more common than gain. This can affect patient management as it can lead to a reduction in both the efficacy and availability of potential therapeutic agents. Future studies are recommended to explore both the mechanisms of discordance as well as its impact on patient outcome and management.

Comparison of Predictive Immunohistochemical Marker Expression of Primary Breast Cancer and Paired Distant Metastasis using Surgical Material: A Practice-Based Study

Parallel studies of primary breast carcinomas and corresponding distant metastases samples reveal considerable differences. Our aim was to highlight this issue from another perspective and provide further data based on 98 patient samples: 69 primary breast carcinoma and 85 distant metastases from bone, central nervous system (CNS) and lung (56 paired). Two independent series of immunohistochemical reactions with different antibodies for estrogen receptor (ER), progesterone receptor (PgR) and human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (Her2), along with HER2 fluroscence in situ hybridization (FISH) were performed on tissue microarrays to classify breast carcinoma and distant metastases samples into Luminal A, Luminal B-proliferating, Luminal B-HER2+, HER2+ and triple negative (TNBC) surrogate breast cancer groups. Correlation and agreement between the two assessments of ER and PgR were fair-to-moderate, and almost perfect for HER2 and Ki67. There was 40% discordance concerning immunophenotype between breast carcinomas and distant metastases. Most common metastatic site of ER+ breast carcinoma was the skeletal system (59.2%), whereas that of TNBCs was the CNS (58.8%) and lungs (23.5%). Distant metastases in bones were mostly luminal (54.3%), in the CNS, Luminal B (53.2%), and in the lung, TNBC (37.5%). The change of drugable properties of primary breast cancers in the respective bone and CNS metastases suggests that characterization of the metastasis is necessary for appropriate treatment planning.

Association of estrogen receptor α gene PvuII and XbaI polymorphisms with non-small cell lung cancer

Single nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) of the estrogen receptor (ER)-α have been found to be associated with various diseases at significantly different frequencies. However, whether any relationship exists between ER-α polymorphisms and lung cancer remains to be determined. In this study, 84 non-smoking, female, non-small cell lung cancer patients with various stages of disease and 234 cancer-free reference controls were enrolled to examine the association of ER-α polymorphisms in lung cancer. Two restriction SNP sites, PvuII and XbaI, in the first intron of the ER-α gene were genotyped by polymerase chain reaction-restriction fragment length polymorphism. The frequencies of the PvuII-XbaI haplotypes and genotypes in a Taiwanese population were revealed for the first time. Although the genotypic frequencies of two polymorphic sites of ER- α were in linkage disequilibrium for the lung cancer group (χ(2)=50.013, d.f.=4) and reference controls (χ(2)=60.797, d.f.=4); and 7 and 8 combined genotypes were present, respectively, the distribution and the major genotypes are different in the two groups (p<0.0001). The p-values for PvuII and XbaI genotypes were significantly different between the lung cancer and reference controls. The PP genotype presence was found to be significantly lower in the lung cancer group (P=0.005), whereas presence of the xx genotype was significantly higher (P=0.042). These findings suggested that the PP genotype had a lower risk of lung cancer; whereas the xx genotype had a higher risk. In comparison with other studies conducted in various populations, it is of note that the pX haplotype frequency of this study was higher than that of other studies, whereas the px haplotype was lower. Moreover, the Xx genotypic frequency of XbaI polymorphisms in the ER-α gene of the reference control group was found to be extremely high, whereas the xx genotypic frequency was extremely low. In conclusion, PvuII-XbaI polymorphisms of the ER-α gene were found to be associated with the risk, but not cancer severity, of non-small cell lung cancer in a Taiwanese population.

Comparison of hormonal receptor and HER-2 status between breast primary tumours and relapsing tumours: clinical implications of progesterone receptor loss

Differences in hormone receptor and HER-2 status between primary tumour and corresponding relapse could have a substantial impact on clinical management of patients. The aim of this study was to evaluate change in expression of hormone receptors and HER-2 status between primary tumour and corresponding local recurrence or distant metastasis. We analysed 140 primary tumours and related recurrent or metastatic samples. Hormone receptors status was evaluated by immunohistochemistry, while HER-2 status by immunohistochemistry and silver in situ hybridisation. A change in HER-2 was rare; 3.7% of cases by immunohistochemistry and only 0.7% by silver in situ hybridisation analysis. A change in estrogen and progesterone receptors was seen in 6.4% and 21.4% of cases, respectively. Estrogen receptor change was not affected by adjuvant therapy, whereas progesterone receptor was influenced by adjuvant chemotherapy associated to hormone therapy (P = 0.0005). A change in progesterone receptor was more frequent in distant metastases than in local recurrences (P = 0.03). In the setting of estrogen receptor positive tumours, patients with progesterone receptor loss in local recurrence had a statistically significant lower median metastasis free survival compared to others patients; progesterone receptor positive, 112 months; progesterone receptor negative, 24 months (P = 0.005). A change between primary tumour and corresponding relapse is frequent for progesterone receptor, infrequent for estrogen receptor and rare for HER-2. In cases with changes in HER-2, it is worthwhile reassessing HER-2 status with both immunohistochemistry and in situ hybridisation analysis. Progesterone receptor loss seems to be influenced by therapy and to correlate with a worse prognosis.

Comparative study of the expression of metalloproteases and their inhibitors in different localizations within primary tumours and in metastatic lymph nodes of breast cancer

Studies on metastasic lesions from human carcinomas are scarce. Therefore there is a need for such studies to identify the expression of the biological factors that will help in the assessment of the natural history of breast cancer. Here an immunohistochemical study was performed using tissue arrays and specific antibodies against matrix metalloproteinases (MMPs)-1, 2, 7, 9, 11, 13, 14 and tissue inhibitors of metalloproteases (TIMPs)-1, 2 and 3 in 39 patients with breast cancer. Specimens from 39 patients with node-positive carcinomas were examined and the analysis was performed at the central core of the tumour, at the invasive front, and in the metastasic axillary lymph nodes (MALNs). Global expression of MMP-1, 7 and 14, TIMP-1, and 3, were significantly higher at the centre of the tumour compared with the invasive front or the MALNs. Significantly higher expression of MMP-7 and 14, and TIMP-3, by fibroblast-like cells and mononuclear inflammatory cells (MICs) was seen in MALNs. In addition, in the tumour centre, the expression of MMP-11 and TIMP-1 and 2 by MICs, as well as TIMP-2 expression by fibroblast-like cells, were associated significantly with the occurrence of distant metastasis. In contrast, TIMP-3 expression by tumour cells or by fibroblast-like cells in this same tumour locations, as well as TIMP-1 expression by fibroblast-like cells at the invasive front, were associated significantly with poor prognosis. However, the expression of all of these biological factors in MALNs was not associated with the development of distant metastasis. Our data suggest that there is prognostic relevance to the expression of MMPs and TIMPs in the stromal cells of primary tumours, rather than to the expression of these enzymes in MALNs.

The expression of p53, bcl-2, bax, fas and fasL in the primary tumour and lymph node metastases of breast cancer

PURPOSE. It is unknown to what extent lymph node metastases differ from primary tumours of breast cancer. Our aim was to investigate the similarity between primary breast tumours and the matching lymph node metastases in 59 breast cancer patients. EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN. Immunohistochemical stainings of p53, bax, bc-l2, fas and fasL were performed in primary tumours and the parallel lymph node metastases. RESULTS. When using a cut point of 10%, the concordance between primary tumours and parallel lymph node metastases in the expression of p53 was 85%, bcl-2 79%, bax 69%, fas 59% and fasL 43%. In most tumours the staining status of p53, bcl-2 and bax in the primary tumour and the corresponding lymph node did not change more than 20%. However, these variables could fluctuate in both directions. In 15-25% of the cases, nodal expression was more than 20% lower than in the primary tumours, while in 10-17% of the cases, nodal expression was more than 20% higher than in the primary tumours. In half of the tumours, fas status did not change. Most fasL positive tumours lost positivity in the lymph node metastases or showed positively staining cancer cells only in the peripheral region of the node. A phenotype analysis of combined information of tumour fas/tumour fasL/nodal fas/nodal fasL expression (+/ - ) was assessed. The most frequently observed phenotype was tumour fas - /tumour fasL + /nodal fas - /nodal fasL- (22% of the tumours), although almost all combinations were seen. CONCLUSIONS. The expression of p53, bax, bcl - 2, fas and fasL is not maintained in the matching lymph node metastases of breast cancer. Large studies comparing the expression of relevant tumour biology factors in primary tumours and parallel lymph node metastases and their impact on therapy outcome, especially in the adjuvant setting, are warranted.

On the way to specifically targeting minimal residual disease?

The target of all adjuvant systemic therapies after surgery in breast cancer is the eradication of a minimal subclinical residual disease. Although it is well known that tumor cell dissemination takes place already at an early stage of the disease, little is known about the tumorbiological parameters of these residual cells. Selection of patients eligible for adjuvant endocrine therapies is based on the analysis of receptor expression in the primary tumor – although the analysis is directed against disseminated tumor cells, these cells may vary in receptor expression in comparison with the primary tumor.

Does breast cancer grade worsen with time? Evidence from breast screening

It has been suggested that alteration of the distribution of histological grades, that has been found in screening programmes, is evidence for progression in histological grade with increasing size. A predictive model, that was based upon estimated growth data from an unselected series of 98 new primary breast cancers, is used to estimate the proportions of tumors that would be diagnosed according to limiting screen diagnostic and clinical diagnostic sizes after particular screening intervals; windows of opportunity are created. The results show that the limitations imposed by time and size criteria alter the distribution of growth rates of tumours that may appear in the windows. Small screen diagnostic sizes and short screening intervals allow only the most rapidly growing tumours to reach large sizes. This produces an apparent association of grade 3 tumours with large size. Interval cancers are also likely to be more rapidly growing while the more slowly growing tumours will be diagnosed at the subsequent screen to produce a spurious association of slowly growing grade 1 tumours with small size. We conclude that the evidence from screening does not support the thesis of progression of histological grade with the ageing of the tumour, since the changes that have been observed are predictable from a simple model based upon patterns of tumour growth rates and the relationships between growth rate and histology.

Effect of interferon alpha-2a on hormone receptor status in patients with advanced breast cancer

The aim of this study was to assess the effect of recombinant interferon alpha-2a (rh-IFN) on estrogen (ER) and progesterone (PR) receptor expression in patients with advanced breast cancer and the evaluation of the effect of rh-IFN pretreatment on response to endocrine therapy with tamoxifen (TAM). Between June 1990 and November 1992, 20 patients with disseminated breast cancer and with metastatic skin nodules suitable for biopsy were entered into this study. Eighteen assessable patients underwent biopsy before and 2 weeks after treatment with rh-INF. rh-INF 3 x 10(6) IU were administered subcutaneously per day. Patients with ER expression at second biopsy were subsequently treated with 20 mg TAM daily. One patient had rapid disease progression and died before rebiopsy could be performed, and an additional patient refused second biopsy. All other patients were considered assessable. Thirteen patients showed ER expression before rh-IFN treatment, and 5 PR presented with expression. Rh-IFN increased ER expression in three patients and PR in four patients. No change was observed in 8 patients for ER and in 12 patients for PR. ER expression decreased in seven patients and PR expression decreased in two patients, respectively. Two patients showed a partial remission after subsequent treatment with TAM. Adverse reactions caused by rh-IFN were mainly flu-like symptoms. In this trial we found no systematic impact of rh-IFN on hormone receptor expression and, subsequently, on the response rate in patients with advanced breast cancer.

Estrogen receptor mutations and changes in estrogen receptor and progesterone receptor protein expression in metastatic or recurrent breast cancer

To investigate the frequency of estrogen receptor (ER) gene mutation in metastatic or recurrent breast cancer, metastatic lymph nodes or recurrent breast cancer tissue from 35 patients with ER-positive primary tumors were screened for mutations in the hormone-binding domain of the ER gene by sequence analysis. Four missense mutations, Val316Ile, Gly344Val, Ala430Val and Gly494Val, were identified in these lesions. Second, to clarify whether there is any disparity in hormone receptor status between primary and metastatic or recurrent tumors, we immunohistochemically studied 117 specimens including the above 35 specimens obtained from metastatic or recurrent breast cancer patients using monoclonal anti-ER and progesterone receptor (PgR) antibodies. Although hormone receptor status, especially ER, was highly maintained through disease progression, negative change in PgR expression at relapse (33%) was identified more frequently than in metastatic lymph nodes (6.7%). Therefore, it was suggested that development of PgR-negative phenotype might correlate with disease progression in some breast cancer patients. These results suggest that ER mutations in metastatic or recurrent breast cancer may be more frequent than in primary lesions, irrespective of high maintenance of ER protein expression through disease progression.

Determination of estrogen receptors in paraffin-embedded tissue. Techniques and the value in breast cancer treatment

Estrogen receptor (ER) analysis in breast cancer has been used in three clinical situations: to select patients with advanced breast cancer for hormonal therapy, as a prognostic parameter, and for selection of women with early breast cancer to adjuvant hormonal treatment. ER has traditionally been measured using labelled hormone in binding assays--often in dextran-coated charcoal assays (DCC). Monoclonal antibodies to ER has permitted development of a solid phase enzyme immunoassay (ER-EIA) used for quantitative determination of ER in tissue homogenates, and have also been used for determination of ER using an immunohistochemical assay in frozen sections (ER-ICA) or in formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue (ER-PAR). A large number of studies has compared ER-EIA with ER-DCC assays. There is a good linear correlation between the two types of assay but ER-EIA measure more ER and classify a larger fraction of tumors ER-positive than conventional ER assays. Lack of clinical data makes the significance of this uncertain. Numerous studies have reported on the correlation between ER-ICA and ER-DCC or ER-EIA. There is a good correlation among the assays on classification of ER status with a median 86% concordance, but a somewhat poorer correlation between semiquantified ER of immunohistochemical assays and ER determined by the quantitative methods (median coefficient of correlation 0.67). There is a large variation in the cut-off level for definition of ER-positive in immunohistochemical assays emphasizing the need for quality control studies. The major problem involved in ER analysis in paraffin-embedded tissue is a considerable loss of immunoreactivity compared to sections from frozen tissue. This can partly be overcome by modifications of the immunohistochemical technique using enzyme pretreatment and other amplification systems, but the sensitivity of ER-PAR remains lower than ER-ICA despite these modifications, and the ER status is less reliably determined in tumors with low ER contents (< 100 fmol). The prognostic value of ER-PAR was evaluated with a multivariate analysis. The endpoint was disease-free interval in systemically untreated patients with early breast cancer, and the variables used were: ER-DCC, ER-PAR, age, tumor size, tumor grade, and nodal status. A total of 133 patients from the Danish Breast Cancer Cooperative Group's (DBCG) 77c protocols had a complete set of variables. The analysis showed that only nodal status, ER-DCC, and tumor grade were significant and independent prognostic variables. An overview of larger multivariate studies on mainly node-negative patients failed to show independent prognostic significance of ER-DCC.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

Heterogeneity in hormone receptor status in primary and metastatic endometrial cancer

The rationale for endocrine therapy in patients with advanced endometrial carcinoma may be based on the presence of estrogen or progesterone receptors in the primary tumor. A study was designed to evaluate tumor cell heterogeneity of steroid hormone receptors in the primary and metastatic sites in endometrial cancer. Primary endometrial cancer tissue samples from 10 patients and 16 metastatic tumor sites were simultaneously analyzed for estrogen and progesterone receptors, using a radioligand biochemical assay. The primary tumor was estrogen receptor (ER) and progesterone receptor (PR) positive in 70 and 60% of the patients, respectively. The metastatic sites were ER positive in 63% and PR positive in 25%. The primary tumor tissue and the metastatic disease showed an identical ER and PR status in only 25 and 19%, respectively. Four patients had multiple metastatic sites analyzed. In two of four patients the PR values, and in three of four patients the ER values, in these metastatic sites were discordant. These data support the concept of tumor cell heterogeneity for steroid hormone receptors in endometrial cancer. To optimize treatment planning, it may be important to biopsy primary, metastatic, and recurrent tumor sites for individual analysis of receptor activity.