Lack of effect of methimazole on thyrocyte cell-surface antigen expression

Thyroid peroxidase forms thionamide-sensitive homodimers: relevance for immunomodulation of thyroid autoimmunity

Thyroid peroxidase (TPO) is the key enzyme in thyroid hormone production and a universal autoantigen in Graves’ and other autoimmune thyroid diseases. We wished to explore the expression of TPO and whether it was affected by thionamide antithyroid drugs. We studied recombinant TPO, stably expressed by a Chinese hamster ovary cell line (CHO-TPO) and transiently expressed TPO-enhanced green fluorescent protein (eGFP) and -FLAG fusion proteins. Immunoblotting of CHO-TPO cell extracts showed high-molecular weight (HMW) TPO isoforms that were resistant to reduction, as well as 110 kDa monomeric TPO. Co-immunoprecipitation and enzyme-linked-immunosorbent assay (ELISA) binding studies of FLAG- and eGFP-tagged TPO demonstrated TPO dimerisation. CHO-TPO cells cultured in methimazole (MMI) for 10 days showed a significant reduction in HMW-TPO isoforms at MMI concentrations of 1 µM and above (p < 0.01), whereas monomeric TPO expression was unchanged. We observed a similar reduction in HMW-TPO in CHO-TPO cells cultured in propylthiouracil (10 µM and above). Binding of Graves’ disease patient sera and TPO-Fabs to enzymatically active TPO that was captured onto solid phase was not abrogated by MMI. The cellular localisation of TPO in CHO-TPO cells was unchanged by MMI treatment. Our demonstration of homodimeric TPO and the reduction in HMW-TPO isoforms during thionamide treatment of CHO-TPO cells shows, for the first time, an effect of thionamides on TPO structure. This suggests a structural correlate to the effect of thionamides on TPO enzymatic activity and opens up a novel potential mechanism for thionamide immunomodulation of autoimmune thyroid disease.

The Pathogenesis of Graves’ Disease

We have hypothesized over many years that Graves' disease (GD) and the other autoimmune thyroid diseases (AITD) are each due to antigen-specific defects in suppressor (regulatory) T lymphocyte function. There have been several reports dealing with the role of regulatory T lymphocyte subsets, ie., that will prevent autoimmune disease in these and other organ-specific autoimmune diseases. In AITD, suppressor T cells have been shown to be less well activated by relevant antigen, but are normally activated by irrelevant antigen; suppressor T cells from normal persons react equally well to both. In GD, these cells have been shown to be inadequately activated by TSH receptor antigen, but are normally activated by irrelevant autoantigen. This reduction is partial only, and insufficient itself to precipitate the autoimmune disease; further insults from the environment are necessary to further reduce generalized regulatory cell activity, adding to the genetically induced specific regulatory cell dysfunction, which appears in turn to be due to a specific defect in the presentation of a specific antigen. This, in turn, may relate to abnormalities of the genes responsible for antigen presentation. The end result is activation of appropriate helper and effector T cells, the stimulation by these of appropriate B lymphocytes, and the concurrent production of cytokines. These events lead to functional changes within the target cell which itself will express Class II antigens, heat shock proteins, and intercellular adhesion molecules, all of which amplify the immune response. Moreover, the activation of helper T lymphocytes by specific antigen depends on the availability of normal amounts of antigen being presented to them by antigen-presenting cells. Thus, there is no need to invoke any primary abnormality or infection of the thyroid cell, or any cross-reacting antigen of microorganismic origin to initiate this process. What is required is an abnormality of antigen-presentation such that regulatory cells are not properly activated, plus some additive environmental disturbance acting on the immune system. GD specifically results from the production by B lymphocytes of an antibody directed against the TSH receptor which stimulates the thyrocyte in a manner similar to TSH, but for a much longer interval. There are also antibodies to the thyrotrophin (TSH) receptor which block the action of TSH. Thyroid stimulating antibody is typical of GD and is detectable in about 95% of cases, but is also seen in destructive thyroiditis transiently. It tends to decline with antithyoid drug therapy, and rises further (for several months) after 131 I treatment. It may slowly decline after subtotal thyroidectomy. It also declines in the third trimester of pregnancy but sometimes is sufficiently high to cause foetal and neonatal passive transfer GD. It tends to rebound in the mother after delivery and may result in postpartum GD. The blocking antibody may cause atrophic thyroiditis and hypothyroidism. Antimicrosomal antibody has now been shown to be antithyroperoxidase. It correlates moderately well with thyroid dysfunction in Hashimoto's thyroiditis (HT) and GD, while antithyroglobulin is of much less value. Graves' ophthalmopathy is still not well understood, and its precise relationship to Graves' hyperthyroidism has yet to be worked out. However the retroorbital fibroblast is now emerging as the most likely target cell, with retroorbital muscle involvement possibly secondary. A recent observation of a genomic point mutation on the TSH receptor on fibroblasts from patients with Graves' ophthalmopathy but not normal persons raises interesting possibilities.

Evidence that the immunosuppressive effects of antithyroid drugs are mediated through actions on the thyroid cell, modulating thyrocyte-immunocyte signaling: a review

The mechanism of action of the immunosuppressive effects of antithyroid drugs has remained a matter of controversy, despite our earlier contention that such effects in vivo were indirect, i.e., it was our view that the drugs were acting on the thyroid cells, reducing their hormone production and other activities, with a consequent reduction in thyrocyte-immunocyte signaling. The reduction in the activation of CD4+ cells, the increased number and activation of CD8+ (and CD8+CDIIb+) cells, and the reduction of soluble interleukin-2 receptors, thought once to be direct effects of the medication, are now shown to be due to amelioration of the hyperthyroidism. Thus the reduction in thyroid hormone production induced by the drugs is central to these actions. In addition, the iodination of thyroglobulin is inhibited by these agents, which may affect antigen presentation by the thyrocyte. Furthermore, there is now evidence that the thionamides interfere with thyrocyte expression of Class I antigen, interleukin-1, interleukin-6, prostaglandin E2, and heat shock protein. The expression of thyrocyte Class II antigen is probably not inhibited by these drugs, although one group has shown that lectin-stimulated thyrocyte Class II expression is diminished by this treatment; this group postulated that this effect might be mediated by reduced interferon-gamma production by T lymphocytes, but in vitro experiments do not corroborate this proposal. In any event, the actions as described, of the antithyroid drugs on the thyroid cells, would certainly suffice to explain the diminution of thyroid antibodies (including thyroid stimulating antibody), the reduced immunological response, and the increased remission rate in Graves' disease, without the need to invoke a direct immunosuppressive effect.

Has the use of antithyroid drugs for Graves' disease become obsolete?

In spite of an experience of almost 50 years of use of antithyroid drugs and radioiodine for the treatment of Graves' disease, the rationale for choice is often obscure. Early reports of high remission rates during thiourea therapy were followed by less optimistic ones, which along with other factors may have fueled the current major shift toward use of radioiodine. This review examines whether or not the use of antithyroid drugs indeed may have become obsolete. The intrathyroidal and extrathyroidal mechanisms of action of the drugs are reviewed with emphasis on their potential immunosuppressive effects. The latter may involve a direct effect on thyroid follicular cells, a direct suppression of TSH receptor antibody formation, or indirect effects mediated via heat shock proteins, oxygen free radicals, and the immune system. Potential factors associated with success or failure with antithyroid drug therapy are discussed, such as the effects of dose and duration of treatment, iodine milieu, and concomitant L-thyroxine therapy. The risks inherent to radioiodine therapy are only briefly described with emphasis on the possible aggravation by radioiodine of preexistent ophthalmopathy. The reader must decide whether the evidence marshalled convincingly indicates that the use of the thiourea compounds should be abandoned. The author thinks not, and is optimistic that imminent discovery of the yet elusive and enigmatic pathogenesis of Graves' disease will permit new and innovative treatment or more effective use of currently available therapies.

A perspective on human autoimmune thyroid disease: is there an abnormality of the target cell which predisposes to the disorder?

It has been suggested recently that autoimmunity could be regarded as a physiological response of the normal immune system to autoantigens caught up in an inflammatory response to viral or bacterial antigen expressed in the target tissue. Other theories to explain autoimmunity include molecular mimicry whereby a viral or microbial hapten similar to an autoantigen initiates the production of autoantibodies that cross react with an autoantigen, with a subsequent immune response reacting with autologous cell structures which are homologous with the particular microorganism. There has also been a suggestion that there may be a genetic abnormality of the target cell which is necessary for the initiation of autoimmune thyroid disease. The present review examines these proposals and provides evidence against an antigen-driven origin for autoimmune thyroid disease (AITD). Currently, there is no valid evidence for viral involvement, and likewise the evidence for molecular mimicry as an initiating factor does not hold up to scrutiny. While a genetic abnormality of the thyrocyte may be important in certain animal models of AITD, in the human there is no evidence for such an abnormality. Evidence that AITD is derived from a disturbance of immunoregulatory mechanisms has been documented elsewhere and would appear to be the most appropriate explanation for these disorders. The immunoregulatory disturbance itself may be related to an abnormality of the mechanism of specific antigen (i.e. normal autoantigen) presentation to appropriately induce T lymphocytes and that theory will require further illumination.

Effects of long-term, high-dose bovine thyrotropin administration on human thyroid tissues from patients with graves' disease and normal subjects xenografted into nude mice

We have attempted to determine whether the administration of thyrotropin would have any different functional or histological effects on Graves' tissue as opposed to human normal thyroid tissue in an in vivo situation (i.e., after xenograft into nude athymic mice). A dosage of 0.03 units per mouse of bovine thyroid-stimulating hormone (b-TSH) was injected intraperitoneally daily for 6 consecutive weeks into xenografted mice. The parameters measured included the free T₄ index and thyroid autoantibodies during the course of b-TSH injections. Tritiated (³H)-thymidine incorporation into thyroid epithelial cells (TECs) and TEC HLA-DR expression were measured in the thyroid tissue at the time of human surgery and at sacrifice; in addition, light-microscopical observations were made at those times. Although there was a decline in free T₄ index values during the course of the study, there was light-microscopical evidence suggestive of hyperplasia in both types of xenografted thyroid tissue. The TSH appeared to result in thyrocyte down-regulation, possibly of receptor or postreceptor origin. The administration of the b-TSH seemed to induce TEC HLA-DR expression in this study. Because these results differ from the effects of TSH on TEC in vitro with respect to TEC HLA-DR expression, it may be postulated that there are other factors liberated in vivo in the nude mice that interact with the TEC and TSH and initiate the TEC HLA-DR expression. We conclude that there are no significant differences between the responses of Graves' tissue and the normal human thyroid tissue in these studies.

In vitro production of interferon-gamma by peripheral blood from patients with Graves' disease, Hashimoto's thyroiditis and rheumatoid arthritis

The production of interferon-gamma (IFN-gamma) by peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC), CD4 cells, or CD8 cells in response to interleukin-2 (IL-2) stimulation has been studied; the samples were obtained from 12 healthy control subjects, 19 patients with Graves' disease (10 hyperthyroid and nine euthyroid), 13 patients with Hashimoto's thyroiditis (four hypothyroid and nine euthyroid), and 15 patients with rheumatoid arthritis (11 active and four inactive). A dose of IL-2 (25 U/ml) was utilized to induce IFN-gamma by PBMC from all four groups. The incremental increase in IFN-gamma values (with IL-2 stimulation minus without stimulation) was significantly less in PBMC from patients with Graves' disease, Hashimoto's thyroiditis, and rheumatoid arthritis than that in PBMC from control subjects. The values from PBMC in patients with Graves' disease in a euthyroid state were below normal but greater than those from patients with Graves' disease in a hyperthyroid state. The incremental increase in IFN-gamma values from Graves' disease PBMC correlated with the serum TSH values (r = 0.622, P less than 0.01), but not with thyroid autoantibodies (anti-thyroid microsomal antibodies, anti-thyroid microsomal antibodies, nor TSH-binding inhibitory immunoglobulin activities). The incremental increase in IFN-gamma from PBMC from both control subjects and Graves' disease was correlated with that from CD4 cells (r = 0.711, P less than 0.01), but not with that from CD8 cells. The production of IFN-gamma in response to IL-2 from PBMC in Graves' disease correlated inversely with thyroid function, appearing to reflect the very effect of hyperthyroidism in this process. The precise explanation of these phenomena remains unclear. The decreased response of IFN-gamma to IL-2 stimulation by PBMC from patients with Graves' disease, Hashimoto's thyroiditis, and rheumatoid arthritis seems to be a non-specific phenomenon occurring in both organ specific autoimmune disease and systemic autoimmune disease. It may be due to a down-regulation in autoimmune disease of CD4 cells in response to IL-2, a decreased level of IL-2 cellular receptors or a decreased receptor affinity, associated increased soluble IL-2 receptors, or a defect of the intra-CD4 cellular IL-2 signal to produce or release IFN-gamma in the conditions studied.