Genetic factors in toxicology: implications for toxicological screening

Relative equivalence of CNS safety (FOB) assessment outcomes in male and female Wistar-Han and Sprague-Dawley rats

In 2006 the National Toxicology Program (NTP) of the FDA shifted to the preferred use of Wistar-Han rats from the more commonly used Sprague-Dawley (SD) strain - and industry followed. While European laboratories preferred the Wistar-Han line, there was a paucity of relevant historical control data in many US research institutions for the new "industry standard" rat strain. In 2010 the NTP reversed its decision and shifted back to SD rats because of reproductive issues with the Wistar strain. For post hoc comparative analyses, we report minimal practical differences in Functional Observational Battery (FOB) data from a large sample of male and female Wistar-Han and SD rats. In summarizing data from the preclinical safety evaluations of the CNS effects of new drugs using the FOB, it is crucial to understand the value of not only how the functional expression of drug effects in the rat are predictive of the human response, but also how and why they differ. What we can predict from the behavioral and physiological response of the designated test system to drug administration is the foundation of "generalizability" to the human's response. Here, we conclude that the use of either SD or WH rat strains in standard CNS safety studies provide equivalent supportive data for CNS safety assessment required for IND approval under the harmonized guidelines.

Genetically Defined Strains in Drug Development and Toxicity Testing

There is growing concern about the poor quality and lack of repeatability of many pre-clinical experiments involving laboratory animals. According to one estimate as much as $28 billion is wasted annually in the USA alone in such studies. A decade ago the FDA's "Critical path" white paper noted that "The traditional tools used to assess product safety-animal toxicology and outcomes from human studies-have changed little over many decades and have largely not benefited from recent gains in scientific knowledge. The inability to better assess and predict product safety leads to failures during clinical development and, occasionally, after marketing." Repeat-dose 28-days and 90-days toxicity tests in rodents have been widely used as part of a strategy to assess the safety of drugs and chemicals but their repeatability and power to detect adverse effects have not been formally evaluated.The guidelines (OECD TG 407 and 408) for these tests specify the dose levels and number of animals per dose but do not specify the strain of animals which should be used. In practice, almost all the tests are done using genetically undefined "albino" rats or mice in which the genetic variation, a major cause of inter-individual and strain variability, is unknown and uncontrolled. This chapter suggests that a better strategy would be to use small numbers of animals of several genetically defined strains of mice or rats instead of the undefined animals used at present. Inbred strains are more stable providing more repeatable data than outbred stocks. Importantly their greater phenotypic uniformity should lead to more powerful and repeatable tests. Any observed strain differences would indicate genetic variation in response to the test substance, providing key data. We suggest that the FDA and other regulators and funding organizations should support research to evaluate this alternative.

Identification and quantification of drug-albumin adducts in serum samples from a drug exposure study in mice

The formation of drug-protein adducts following the bioactivation of drugs to reactive metabolites has been linked to adverse drug reactions (ADRs) and is a major complication in drug discovery and development. Identification and quantification of drug-protein adducts in vivo may lead to a better understanding of drug toxicity, but is challenging due to their low abundance in the complex biological samples. Human serum albumin (HSA) is a well-known target of reactive drug metabolites due to the free cysteine on position 34 and is often the first target to be investigated in covalent drug binding studies. Presented here is an optimized strategy for targeted analysis of low-level drug-albumin adducts in serum. This strategy is based on selective extraction of albumin from serum through affinity chromatography, efficient sample treatment and clean-up using gel filtration chromatography followed by tryptic digestion and LC-MS analysis. Quantification of the level of albumin modification was performed through a comparison of non-modified and drug-modified protein based on the relative peak area of the tryptic peptide containing the free cysteine residue. The analysis strategy was applied to serum samples resulting from a drug exposure experiment in mice, which was designed to study the effects of different acetaminophen (APAP) treatments on drug toxicity. APAP is bioactivated to N-acetyl-p-benzoquinoneimine (NAPQI) in both humans and mice and is known to bind to cysteine 34 (cys34) of HSA. Analysis of the mouse serum samples revealed the presence of extremely low-level NAPQI-albumin adducts of approximately 0.2% of the total mouse serum albumin (MSA), regardless of the length of drug exposure. Due to the targeted nature of the strategy, the NAPQI-adduct formation on cys34 could be confirmed while adducts to the second free cysteine on position 579 of MSA were not detected.

Improving toxicity screening and drug development by using genetically defined strains

According to the US Food and Drugs Administration (Food and Drug Administration (2004) Challenge and opportunity on the critical path to new medical products.) "The inability to better assess and predict product safety leads to failures during clinical development and, occasionally, after marketing". This increases the cost of new drugs as clinical trials are even more expensive than pre-clinical testing.One relatively easy way of improving toxicity testing is to improve the design of animal experiments. A fundamental principle when designing an experiment is to control all variables except the one of interest: the treatment. Toxicologist and pharmacologists have widely ignored this principle by using genetically heterogeneous "outbred" rats and mice, increasing the chance of false-negative results. By using isogenic (inbred or F1 hybrid, see Note 1) rats and mice instead of outbred stocks the signal/noise ratio and the power of the experiments can be increased at little extra cost whilst using no more animals. Moreover, the power of the experiment can be further increased by using more than one strain, as this reduces the chance of selecting one which is resistant to the test chemical. This can also be done without increasing the total number of animals by using a factorial experimental design, e.g. if the ten outbred animals per treatment group in a 28-day toxicity test were replaced by two animals of each of five strains (still ten animals per treatment group) selected to be as genetically diverse as possible, this would increase the signal/noise ratio and power of the experiment. This would allow safety to be assessed using the most sensitive strain.Toxicologists should also consider making more use of the mouse instead of the rat. They are less costly to maintain, use less test substance, there are many inbred and genetically modified strains, and it is easier to identify gene loci controlling variation in response to xenobiotics in this species.We demonstrate here the advantage of using several inbred strains in two parallel studies of the haematological response to chloramphenicol at six dose levels with CD-1 outbred, or using four inbred strains of mice. Toxicity to the white blood cell lineage was easily detected using the inbred strains but not using the outbred stock, clearly showing the advantage of using the multi-inbred strain approach.

Evaluation of developmental neurotoxicity of organotins via drinking water in rats: Monomethyl tin

Organotins such as monomethyltin (MMT) are widely used as heat stabilizers in PVC and CPVC piping, which results in their presence in drinking water supplies. Concern for neurotoxicity produced by organotin exposure during development has been raised by published findings of a deficit on a runway learning task in rat pups perinatally exposed to MMT (Noland EA, Taylor DH, Bull RJ. Monomethyl and trimethyltin compounds induce learning deficiencies in young rats. Neurobehav Toxicol Teratol 1982;4:539-44). The objective of these studies was to replicate the earlier publication and further define the dose-response characteristics of MMT following perinatal exposure. In Experiment 1, female Sprague-Dawley rats were exposed via drinking water to MMT (0, 10, 50, 245 ppm) before mating and throughout gestation and lactation (until weaning at postnatal day [PND] 21). Behavioral assessments of the offspring included: a runway test (PND 11) in which the rat pups learned to negotiate a runway for dry suckling reward; motor activity habituation (PNDs 13, 17, and 21); learning in the Morris water maze (as adults). Other endpoints in the offspring included measures of apoptosis (DNA fragmentation) at PND 22 and as adults, as well as brain weights and neuropathological evaluation at PND 2, 12, 22, and as adults. There were no effects on any measure of growth, development, cognitive function, or apoptosis following MMT exposure. There was a trend towards decreased brain weight in the high dose group. In addition, there was vacuolation of the neuropil in a focal area of the cerebral cortex of the adult offspring in all MMT dose groups (1-3 rats per treatment group). In Experiment 2, pregnant rats were exposed from gestational day 6 until weaning to 500 ppm MMT in drinking water. The offspring behavioral assessments again included the runway task (PND 11), motor activity habituation (PND 17), and Morris water maze (as adults). In this second study, MMT-exposed females consumed significantly less water than the controls throughout both gestation and lactation, although neither dam nor pup weights were affected. As in Experiment 1, MMT-exposure did not alter pup runway performance, motor activity, or cognitive function. These results indicate that perinatal exposure to MMT, even at concentrations which decrease fluid intake, does not result in significant neurobehavioral or cognitive deficits. While mild neuropathological lesions were observed in the adult offspring, the biological significance of this restricted finding is unclear.

Acquisition, steady-state performance, and the effects of trimethyltin on the operant behavior and hippocampal GFAP of Long-Evans and Fischer 344 rats

Strain differences represent an overlooked variable that may play an important role in neurotoxic outcomes that can impact regulatory decision making. Here, we examined the strain-dependent effects of trimethyltin (TMT), a compound used as a positive control for behavioral and neurochemical assessments of neurotoxicity. Adult male Long-Evans (LE) and Fischer 344 (F344) rats (n=12 each) were trained to respond under a multiple, fixed-interval 3-min fixed-ratio 10-response (multi FI 3-min FR10) schedule of milk reinforcement. Acquisition was characterized by time-dependent changes in several behavioral endpoints in both strains, although rate of acquisition of the fixed-interval pattern of responding was slower in F344 rats. Steady-state (baseline) performance was characterized by slower overall rates of responding in F344 rats. There was little evidence of strain differences in many of the other baseline performance measures. Rats of each strain were then divided into two equal groups that received either 1 ml/kg saline or 8.0 mg/kg iv TMT approximately 18 h before the next test session. TMT produced transient changes in the performance of LE and F344 rats that lasted for several sessions. For many behavioral measures, F344 rats were more affected by TMT than were LE rats. TMT-induced reactive gliosis, as assessed by assaying glial fibrillary acidic protein (GFAP), was also greater in F344 rats than in LE rats. These results suggest F344 rats may be more susceptible to TMT-induced neurotoxicity than are LE rats.

Experimental approaches to the determination of genetic variability

Toxicology is concerned with the interaction between xenobiotics and biological molecules directly or indirectly coded in the DNA, and can be regarded as a branch of genetics. There is genetic variation in these interactions, which has important implications for risk assessment and because it can be used as a tool in studying toxic mechanisms. The genetics of susceptibility can be studied by forward or reverse genetics. Forward genetics involves working from an observed phenotype such as susceptibility to a particular xenobiotic and identifying the susceptibility genes. Often, this involves mapping and identifying quantitative trait loci, as most toxic responses have a polygenic mode of inheritance. The use of inbred strains is almost essential. Reverse genetics involves starting with a known genetic polymorphism and determining its effects on the response to xenobiotics. Studies of 'knockout' animals are a good example, although there are many naturally occurring polymorphisms that may affect toxic responses. In both cases, care has to be taken to ensure that the genetic background is carefully controlled in any comparison between animals thought to be carrying susceptible and resistant alleles.

Behavioral evaluation of the neurotoxicity produced by dichloroacetic acid in rats

Dichloroacetic acid (DCA) is commonly found in drinking water as a by-product of chlorination disinfection. It is a known neurotoxicant in rats, dogs, and humans. We have characterized DCA neurotoxicity in rats using a neurobehavioral screening battery under varying exposure durations (acute, subchronic, and chronic) and routes of administration (oral gavage and drinking water). Studies were conducted in both weanling and adult rats, and comparisons were made between Long-Evans and Fischer-344 rats. DCA produced neuromuscular toxicity comprised of limb weakness and deficits in gait and righting reflex; altered gait and decreased hindlimb grip strength were the earliest indicators of toxicity. Other effects included mild tremors, ocular abnormalities, and a unique chest-clasping response (seen in Fischer-344 rats only). Neurotoxicity was permanent (i.e., through 2 years) following a 6-month exposure to high dose levels, whereas the effects of intermediate dose levels with exposures of 3 months or less were slowly reversible. The severity, specificity, and recovery of neurological changes were route, duration, and strain dependent. Fischer-344 rats were more sensitive than Long-Evans rats, and weanling rats may be somewhat more sensitive than adults. Oral gavage produced significantly less toxicity compared to the same intake level received in drinking water. Neurotoxicity was progressive with continued exposure, and was observed at exposure levels as low as 16 mg/kg/day (lowest dose level tested) when administered via drinking water in subchronic studies. The data from these studies characterize the neurotoxicity produced by DCA, and show it to be more pronounced, persistent, and occurring at lower exposures than has been previously reported. Further research should take into account these marked route, age, and strain differences.

Individual susceptibility to toxicity

Individual variation in susceptibility to chemical toxicity may be due to differences in toxicokinetic patterns or effect modification. Well-documented interspecies genetic differences in susceptibility to chemicals had lead to studies of such variation also within species. Epidemiological evidence now suggests that common variations, particularly in the P-450 enzymes, may play a major role in determining individual susceptibility to chemically-induced disease. Physiologic factors are involved in the particular susceptibility of the fetus, the newborn, and the old. Constitutional susceptibility is also affected by acquired conditions, including chronic disease, such as diabetes mellitus. Perhaps the most complex area relates to the increase in vulnerability caused by previous or contemporary exposure to other factors, thus eliciting, e.g., synergistic effects. Although amply demonstrated by experimental studies, epidemiological or clinical confirmation is generally lacking. One hypothesis suggests that a chemical exposure may affect the reserve capacity of the body, though not resulting in any immediate adverse effect. Subsequently, the body becomes unable to compensate for an additional stress, and toxicity then develops. Epidemiological approaches are available and need to be expanded. Research in this area has potential ethical implications which should be dealt with in an open, informed forum.

Genetic quality control of laboratory animals used in aging studies

Laboratory rodents provide a useful model for aging processes in humans. Various genetic "types" of stock are available, including outbred stocks and inbred strains and their derivatives. Inbred strains, which can be regarded as clones of genetically identical individuals, provide a powerful research tool for studies in many disciplines, including gerontology. However, some form of genetic quality control is essential to ensure that the strains are authentic. Single gene polymorphisms, particularly those detected by electrophoresis and immunological methods, provide a powerful tool for such quality control, though these methods are expensive and require considerable expertise. Methods based on several loci studied simultaneously include skin grafting and polyvalent alloantisera. These methods are often quick and technically relatively easy, but are less flexible than the single locus methods. Methods based on DNA restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs) fall into both categories depending on whether a single locus or a multilocus probe, such as the fingerprinting probes, is used. These DNA-based methods have many advantages, and are likely to be the methods of choice in the future.

Genetic factors in neurotoxicology and neuropharmacology: a critical evaluation of the use of genetics as a research tool

Animals have evolved a detoxication system to enable them to survive in a hostile chemical environment in which foods contain many non-nutrient chemicals. Detoxication depends on enzymes which are often genetically polymorphic. As a result, inter-individual variation is common, and in humans several Mendelian loci have been identified. However, most variation in response is probably due to the action of several genes. Genetic variation in response to the neurotoxin MPTP and to chemically and physically-induced seizures is reviewed. In the former case, differences between pigmented and white mouse strains have been noted which are consistent with the hypothesis that humans are more sensitive than mice or rats because of the presence of melanin in human brains. However, variation in sensitivity probably also depends on other genes. In the case of audiogenic seizures, a single locus has been identified and mapped, but its relationship with seizures induced by other agents is not clear. Genetic variation in response to alcohol is also discussed. The failure of most toxicologists to consider genetic variation as a potentially confounding variable, and as a powerful research tool, is discussed critically in relation to non-repeatability of research on the neurotoxic effects of lead, and in relation to the genetic variation in MPTP, seizures, and alcohol response already noted. It seems clear that genetic methods provide a powerful research tool which is largely being ignored by toxicologists.

Rat strain and stock comparisons using a functional observational battery: baseline values and effects of amitraz

A functional observational battery (FOB) was utilized to assess the effects of 3-day exposure to the formamidine pesticide amitraz in outbred Sprague-Dawley-derived and inbred Fischer-344-derived (F344) rats (both from Charles River Laboratories) and in outbred Long-Evans rats obtained from two commercial suppliers (Charles River Breeding Laboratories and Blue Spruce Farms). Significant strain and stock differences were obtained in baseline values for one-third of the FOB measures. In most cases, F344 rats were different from the others. Characteristic signs of amitraz exposure consisting of increased excitability, hyper-reactivity, and physiological and autonomic changes were evident in all treated rats. These effects increased with repeated dosing, and many were still present 6 days after dosing. On individual measures, there were differences between the strains and stocks in terms of sensitivity and time course of amitraz effects. In general, Blue Spruce Long-Evans rats displayed more effects of amitraz and F344 rats recovered more quickly than others. Although Sprague-Dawley rats showed the least effect overall, they displayed the largest increases in the sensorimotor responses to stimuli. These data indicate that although some behavioral and physiological parameters showed strain and supplier differences, in both baseline values and the effects of amitraz, conclusions concerning its neurotoxic potential in a screening context would be similar.

Assessment of toxicity for major hazards: some concepts and problems

Approaches to the assessment of the toxic effects which may arise from chemical Major Hazards are examined. The definitions of hazard and risk and the types of toxicity data required for risk analysis are investigated with particular reference to the quality of the data and models available.

Strain-dependency of procarbazine-induced testicular toxicity

Three strains of rat were used to examine strain-dependency of procarbazine-induced testicular toxicity. CCFHB and CCFY1 outbred albino rats and inbred PVG piebald variegated rats were treated weekly with procarbazine (200 mg/kg/dose x 4). Fifty-six days later, the rats were killed and reproductive parameters evaluated. Strain-related differences in body, testis, prostate, seminal vesicle weights, testis sperm, intratesticular testosterone, and [125I]hCG binding to testicular LH receptors were observed. Although treatment with procarbazine affected testis function in all strains, significant interactions occurred between treatment and strain. LH receptor binding and stem-cell survival were more severely affected in the inbred strain than in outbred strains. Serum testosterone increased in the outbred strain but decreased in the inbred strain, generating an interaction that obscured possible main effects. Significant strain-related differences in within-group variances demonstrated that measurements were more variable in the outbred strains than in the inbred strain. Testes of the inbred strain appeared to be more sensitive to the effects of procarbazine than those of the outbred strains. These data illustrate two important toxicologic phenomena: differences in response variability and differences in target-organ sensitivity, both of which were explained by genetic variability.

The popliteal lymph node assay in mice to screen for the immune disregulating potential of chemicals--a preliminary study

Low mol. wt compounds were tested in the popliteal lymph node (PLN) assay to study whether PLN reactivity could be related to the ability of the compounds to induce autoimmune disorders in man. PLN reactions were measured 7 days after a single subcutaneous (s.c.) injection of dissolved compounds in amounts of 0.3-2.0 mg into one hind footpad of mice and assessed as the weight increase of the draining PLN relative to the PLN weight of the untreated contralateral paw. Hydralazine, chlorpromazine, diphenylhydantoin, carbamazepine, phenylbutazone and nitrofurantoin, all being drugs with a documented potential to induce systemic immunological disorders in man, caused marked PLN reactions. False negative PLN responses were observed following injection of procainamide and isoniazid. Among systemic drugs without known potential to induce autoimmune reactions in humans, quinacrine, denzimol and niridazole significantly increased PLN weights, while phenobarbital, levamisole and disulfiram had no effect. Chemicals with a well-known capacity to induce contact dermatitis in man like 2,4-dinitro-1-chlorobenzene, alpha-methylene-gamma-butyrolactone, p-phenylenediamine, 5-nitro-2-furaldehyde semicarbazone, 2-mercapto-benzothiazol and 1,3-dibutyl-2-thiourea caused marked PLN reactions, while the non-sensitizer 2,4-dichloro-1-nitrobenzene failed to do so. It is concluded that the PLN assay as applied in this study may give a rapid first indication of immunomodulating potential of low mol. wt compounds, but it does not discriminate as to the kind of immunomodulation.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)