Suicide gene-mediated modulation of graft-versus-host disease

Effects of bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells on hematopoietic recovery and acute graft-versus-host disease in murine allogeneic umbilical cord blood transplantation model

To investigate the effect of bone marrow mesenchymal stem cells (MSC) on hematopoietic recovery and acute graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) in a murine allogeneic umbilical cord blood transplantation (allo-UCBT) model. MSCs were obtained from C57/BL mouse bone marrow. The MSC phenotypes were identified by flow cytometry (FCM), and their ability to differentiate into osteoblasts and adipocytes was tested. Once murine allo-UCBT and aGVHD models were established, mice were divided into five groups: (1) total body irradiation (TBI) group, each mouse receiving 0.3 ml sterile saline infusion after TBI and used as control; (2) UCB group, receiving 2 × 10(6) umbilical cord blood mononuclear cells (UCB-MNC) after TBI; (3) UCB+MSC group, receiving 2 × 10(6) UCB-MNC and 2 × 10(7) MSC after TBI; (4) UCB+SC group, receiving 2 × 10(6) UCB-MNC and 2 × 10(6) spleen cells after TBI; and (5) UCB+SC+MSC group, receiving 2 × 10(6) UCB-MNC, 2 × 10(7) MSC and 2 × 10(6) spleen cells after TBI. To evaluate the engraftment of HSC, the white blood cells, red blood cells, and platelets counts were tested at different time points after transplantation, and the ratio of chimerism was identified by FCM. The acute GVHD clinical scores, recipient mice survival, and the histopathological analyses were used to evaluate the effect of MSC on acute GVHD. MSCs were successfully obtained in vitro and FCM analysis showed that these cells are highly positive for CD90.2, CD44, and negative for CD34, CD45, and they are capable to differentiate into osteoblasts and adipocytes after being induced. Compared to UCB group, the UCB+MSC mice had shorter duration of myelosuppression and higher percentage of donor-derived cells which was up to 22.87 ± 4.3 % and the white blood cell (WBC), red blood cell (RBC), and platelet counts started to increase by day 6 after transplantation. Moreover, the average survival time for UCB+MSC mice was 25.0 ± 10.55 days, while for the UCB group it was 15.5 ± 12.50 days. The UCB+SC mice showed fatigue, loss of appetite, weight loss, arched back, and hair ruffling on day 13 post transplantation. Approximately 50 % of mice showed skin ulcers, had diarrhea and other manifestations of acute GVHD, and all mice were died within 20 days. Histopathological analysis confirmed grade II-IV GVHD manifestation. In addition to transient weight loss, some UCB+SC+MSC mice developed arched back, hair ruffling, diarrhea and other manifestations of acute GVHD. The clinical scores in UCB+SC+MSC mice with acute GVHD (grade I-II or without GVHD) were lower than UCB+SC group (P < 0.05). Bone marrow MSCs can promote hematopoietic recovery and decrease the incidence of acute GVHD in murine allo-UCBT model.

Chimeric antigen receptor T Cells with dissociated signaling domains exhibit focused antitumor activity with reduced potential for toxicity in vivo

Adoptive immunotherapy using T lymphocytes genetically modified to express a chimeric antigen receptor (CAR-T) holds considerable promise for the treatment of cancer. However, CAR-based therapies may involve on-target toxicity against normal tissues expressing low amounts of the targeted tumor-associated antigen (TAA). To specify T cells for robust effector function that is selective for tumor but not normal tissue, we developed a trans-signaling CAR strategy, whereby T-cell activation signal 1 (CD3z) is physically dissociated from costimulatory signal 2 (CD28) in two CARs of differing antigen specificity: mesothelin and a-folate receptor (FRa). Human T cells were genetically modified to coexpress signal 1 (anti-Meso scFv-CD3z) and signal 2 (anti-FRa scFv-CD28) CARs in trans. Trans-signaling CAR-T cells showed weak cytokine secretion against target cells expressing only one TAA in vitro, similar to first-generation CAR-T cells bearing CD3z only, but showed enhanced cytokine secretion upon encountering natural or engineered tumor cells coexpressing both antigens, equivalent to that of second-generation CAR-T cells with dual signaling in cis. CAR-T cells with dual specificity also showed potent anticancer activity and persistence in vivo, which was superior to first-generation CAR-T cells and equivalent to second-generation CARs. Importantly, second-generation CAR-T cells exhibited potent activity against cells expressing mesothelin alone, recapitulating normal tissue, whereas trans-signaling CAR-T cells did not. Thus, a dual specificity, trans-signaling CAR approach can potentiate the therapeutic efficacy of CAR-T cells against cancer while minimizing parallel reactivity against normal tissues bearing single antigen.

Enhancing the specificity of T-cell cultures for adoptive immunotherapy of cancer

Adoptive immunotherapy is a promising approach for the treatment of cancer; however, autoimmunity against normal tissue can be a serious complication of this therapy. We hypothesized that T-cell cultures responding maximally only when engaging two antigens would be more specific for tumor cells, and less active against normal cells, as long as the tumor expressed both antigens, while normal cells expressed only one of the antigens. A model system was developed consisting of cell lines expressing either folate binding protein or erbB-2, representing ‘normal’ tissue, and cells expressing both antigens representing tumor tissue. Human T-cell cultures were produced using two chimeric antigen receptor vectors (‘dual transduced’), or using a single chimeric antigen receptor vector (monospecific). Dual-transduced T cells responded less against ‘normal’ cells compared with tumor cells. This relatively simple procedure produced T-cell cultures that were as active against a tumor as the monospecific cultures used traditionally, but had lower activity against model normal cells.

Suicide gene therapy for graft-versus-host disease

In allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation, donor-derived T cells are key players for early immune reconstitution and efficient engraftment, as well as the graft-versus-leukemia and graft-versus-infection effects. However, a severe and quite common life-threatening complication is the development of graft-versus-host disease, during which the alloreactive donor T cells attack the host. Controlling graft-versus-host disease while preserving the benefits of graft-versus-leukemia still constitutes a challenge. A promising approach for the control of graft-versus-host disease is suicide gene therapy, which involves the ex vivo genetic modification of donor T cells with a suicide gene that allows for the selective elimination of the cells in vivo if graft-versus-host disease occurs. This article presents an overview of such approaches with special reference to lessons learned from previous clinical experiences, as well as a discussion of critical factors in suicide gene therapy.

Tumor ablation by gene-modified T cells in the absence of autoimmunity

Adoptive immunotherapy involving genetic modification of T cells with antigen-specific, chimeric, single-chain receptors is a promising approach for the treatment of cancer. To determine whether gene-modified T cells could induce antitumor effects without associated autoimmune pathology, we assessed the ability of T cells expressing an anti-Her-2 chimeric receptor to eradicate tumor in Her-2 transgenic mice that express human Her-2 as a self-antigen in brain and mammary tissues. In adoptive transfer studies, we demonstrated significant improvement in the survival of mice bearing Her-2(+) 24JK tumor following administration of anti-Her-2 T cells compared with control T cells. The incorporation of a lymphoablative step prior to adoptive transfer of anti-Her-2 T cells and administration of IL-2 were both found to further enhance survival. The reduction in tumor growth was also correlated with localization of transferred T cells at the tumor site. Furthermore, an antigen-specific recall response could be induced in long-term surviving mice following rechallenge with Her-2(+) tumor. Importantly, antitumor effects were not associated with any autoimmune pathology in normal tissue expressing Her-2 antigen. This study highlights the therapeutic potential of using gene-engineered T cells as a safe and effective treatment of cancer.

An improved bicistronic CD20/tCD34 vector for efficient purification and in vivo depletion of gene-modified T cells for adoptive immunotherapy

T-cell-based adoptive immunotherapy is widely used to treat graft rejection and relapse after stem cell transplantation (SCT). However, this approach is hampered by a high risk of life-threatening graft-versus-host-disease (GvHD). Clinical trials have demonstrated the value of suicide genes to modify T cells for the effective control of GvHD. Herewith, we show that the combination of a codon-optimized B-cell antigen (CD20op) with a selection marker based on a cytoplasmic truncated version of the human stem cell antigen CD34 (tCD34) allows the generation of highly enriched gene-modified T cells. We demonstrate coordinate co-expression of both transgenes and high expression of CD20op resulting in an increased susceptibility to Rituximab (RTX)-induced cell death. In addition, T cells partially retained their alloreactive potential and their CD4/CD8 ratio after transduction and expansion. Long-lasting transgene expression was sustained in vivo after adoptive transfer into Rag-1(-/-) mice. Moreover, gene-modified T cells were quickly and efficiently depleted from peripheral blood (PB) and secondary lymphoid organs of transplanted animals after RTX treatment. These results warrant further steps toward a clinical application of CD20op as a suicide gene for adoptive immunotherapy.

Adoptive transfer of gene-modified primary NK cells can specifically inhibit tumor progression in vivo

NK cells hold great potential for improving the immunotherapy of cancer. Nevertheless, tumor cells can effectively escape NK cell-mediated apoptosis through interaction of MHC molecules with NK cell inhibitory receptors. Thus, to harness NK cell effector function against tumors, we used Amaxa gene transfer technology to gene-modify primary mouse NK cells with a chimeric single-chain variable fragment (scFv) receptor specific for the human erbB2 tumor-associated Ag. The chimeric receptor was composed of the extracellular scFv anti-erbB2 Ab linked to the transmembrane and cytoplasmic CD28 and TCR-zeta signaling domains (scFv-CD28-zeta). In this study we demonstrated that mouse NK cells gene-modified with this chimera could specifically mediate enhanced killing of an erbB2(+) MHC class I(+) lymphoma in a perforin-dependent manner. Expression of the chimera did not interfere with NK cell-mediated cytotoxicity mediated by endogenous NK receptors. Furthermore, adoptive transfer of gene-modified NK cells significantly enhanced the survival of RAG mice bearing established i.p. RMA-erbB2(+) lymphoma. In summary, these data suggest that use of genetically modified NK cells could broaden the scope of cancer immunotherapy for patients.

Transient depletion of dividing T lymphocytes in mice induces the emergence of regulatory T cells and dominant tolerance to islet allografts

We previously showed that transient depletion of dividing T cells at the time of an allogeneic transplantation induces long-term tolerance to the allograft. Here we investigated the role of homeostatic perturbation and regulatory T cells (Treg) in such tolerance. Transient depletion of dividing T cells was induced at the time of an allogeneic pancreatic islets graft, by administration of ganciclovir for 14 days, into diabetic transgenic mice expressing a thymidine kinase (TK) conditional suicide gene in T cells. Allograft tolerance was obtained in 63% of treated mice. It was not due to global immunosuppression, permanent deletion or anergy of donor-alloantigens specific T cells but to a dominant tolerance process since lymphocytes from tolerant mice could transfer tolerance to naïve allografted recipients. The transient depletion of dividing T cells induces a 2- to 3-fold increase in the proportion of CD4(+)CD25(+)Foxp3(+) Treg, within 3 weeks that persisted only in allograft-bearing mice but not in nongrafted mice. Tolerance with similar increased proportion of Treg cells was also obtained after a cytostatic hydroxyurea treatment in normal mice. Thus, the transient depletion of dividing T cells represents a novel means of immuno-intervention based on disturbance of T-cell homeostasis and subsequent increase in Treg proportion.

The suicide gene therapy challenge: how to improve a successful gene therapy approach

The transfer of a suicide gene into donor lymphocytes to control alloreactivity in the context of allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (allo-HSCT) represents the widest clinical application of T-cell based gene transfer, as shown by more than 100 patients treated worldwide to date, several phase I-II studies completed, and a registrative phase III study, sponsored by a biotech firm, about to begin. In this mini-review, we will summarize the clinical results obtained to date, and attempt to identify the steps envisaged to optimize the suicide gene therapy approach.

Adoptive transfer of gene-engineered CD4+ helper T cells induces potent primary and secondary tumor rejection

Because CD4+ T cells play a key role in aiding cellular immune responses, we wanted to assess whether increasing numbers of gene-engineered antigen-restricted CD4+ T cells could enhance an antitumor response mediated by similarly gene-engineered CD8+ T cells. In this study, we have used retroviral transduction to generate erbB2-reactive mouse T-cell populations composed of various proportions of CD4+ and CD8+ cells and then determined the antitumor reactivity of these mixtures. Gene-modified CD4+ and CD8+ T cells were shown to specifically secrete Tc1 (T cytotoxic-1) or Tc2 cytokines, proliferate, and lyse erbB2+ tumor targets following antigen ligation in vitro. In adoptive transfer experiments using severe combined immunodeficient (scid) mice, we demonstrated that injection of equivalent numbers of antigen-specific engineered CD8+ and CD4+ T cells led to significant improvement in survival of mice bearing established lung metastases compared with transfer of unfractionated (largely CD8+) engineered T cells. Transferred CD4+ T cells had to be antigen-specific (not just activated) and secrete interferon gamma (IFN-gamma) to potentiate the antitumor effect. Importantly, antitumor responses in these mice correlated with localization and persistence of gene-engineered T cells at the tumor site. Strikingly, mice that survived primary tumor challenge could reject a subsequent rechallenge. Overall, this study has highlighted the therapeutic potential of using combined transfer of antigen-specific gene-modified CD8+ and CD4+ T cells to significantly enhance T-cell adoptive transfer strategies for cancer therapy.

Occurrence of leukaemia following gene therapy of X-linked SCID

Recombinant viral vectors have allowed gene transfer to be developed as a promising approach to the treatment of genetic diseases. Recently, gene therapy of children with X-linked severe combined immune deficiency resulted in impressive levels of immune reconstitution--a triumph that was later overshadowed by the development of leukaemia in two patients. What were the causes of this cancer, and how can the therapeutic benefits of gene therapy be achieved while minimizing risk to the patient?

Targeting tumours with genetically enhanced T lymphocytes

The genetic modification of T lymphocytes is an important approach to investigating normal T-cell biology and to increasing antitumour immunity. A number of genetic strategies aim to increase the recognition of tumour antigens, enhance antitumour activities and prevent T-cell malfunction. T cells can also be engineered to increase safety, as well as to express markers that can be tracked by non-invasive imaging technologies. Genetically modified T cells are therefore proving to be of great value for basic immunology and experimental immunotherapy.

Graft-versus-leukemia effect after suicide-gene-mediated control of graft-versus-host disease

Clinical data indicate that after allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) for hematological malignancies, the graft-versus-leukemia (GVL) effect is in large part mediated by the graft-versus-host reaction (GVHR), which also often leads to graft-versus-host disease (GVHD). Controlling alloreactivity to prevent GVHD while retaining GVL poses a true dilemma for the successful treatment of such malignancies. We reasoned that suicide gene therapy, which kills dividing cells expressing the thymidine kinase (TK) "suicide" gene using time-controlled administration of ganciclovir (GCV), might solve this dilemma. We have previously shown that after infusion of allogeneic TK T cells along with HSCT to an irradiated recipient, an early and short GCV treatment efficiently prevents GVHD by selectively eliminating alloreactive T cells while sparing nonalloreactive T cells, which can then contribute to immune reconstitution. Nevertheless, it remained to be established that this therapeutic strategy retained the desired GVL effect. Hypothesizing that a contained GVHR would be essential, we evaluated the GVL effect using different protocols of GCV administration. We were able to show that when the GCV treatment is initiated at, or close to, the time of grafting, GVHD is controlled but GVL is lost. In contrast, when the onset of GCV administration is delayed until day 6, a potent GVL effect is retained while GVHD is still controlled. These data emphasize that, by a time-optimized scheduling of the administration of GCV, this TK/GCV strategy can be tuned to efficiently treat malignant hemopathies.

Effect of combined cytostatic cyclosporin A and cytolytic suicide gene therapy on the prevention of experimental graft-versus-host disease

The immunosuppressive drug cyclosporin A (CsA) represents the standard preventive treatment of graft-versus-host disease (GVHD), the main complication of allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT). However, its efficacy is only partial and many patients develop lethal GVHD despite CsA. A strategy of genetic immunosuppression based on conditional elimination of donor T cells expressing the Herpes simplex type 1 thymidine kinase (TK) suicide gene was recently developed. In this system, ganciclovir (GCV) selectively kills dividing but not quiescent TK T cells. Since CsA is known to have a cytostatic effect on T cells, it could negatively interfere with the division-dependent TK gene therapy. We thus tested whether administration of CsA would antagonize elimination of alloreactive donor TK T cells mediated by GCV in a murine model of GVHD. In vivo experiments revealed that, contrary to GCV, CsA only transiently controlled alloactivation-induced T cell proliferation, and likewise could not prevent lethal GVHD. When T cells resumed proliferation under CsA, they were however still sensitive to GCV. Survival, as well as immune reconstitution, was excellent in mice treated with GCV alone or in combination with CsA. These observations should help to design improved suicide gene therapy trials in the field of allogeneic HSCT.

Selective T-cell subset ablation demonstrates a role for T1 and T2 cells in ongoing acute graft-versus-host disease: a model system for the reversal of disease

Graft-versus-host disease (GVHD) is a major cause of morbidity and mortality of allogeneic stem cell transplantation. Strategies to control GVHD while maintaining graft versus leukemia (GVL) include herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase (HSV-tk) gene transduction of donor T cells followed by treatment with ganciclovir (GCV). Alternatively, GVHD and GVL may be mediated by distinct processes. In this regard, whether cytokine polarization occurs and to what degrees various subsets of cytokine-producing T cells mediate GVHD or GVL has been an active area of research using cytokine or cytokine antibody infusion or genetically deficient mice. This study takes a different approach that allows simultaneous investigation into both the mechanisms underlying GVHD reactions and the efficacy of HSV-tk suicide gene-based T-cell deletion. A source of donor T cells, splenocytes from mice transgenic for HSV-tk controlled by elements of either the interleukin-2 (IL-2) or IL-4 promoters (IL-2-tk and IL-4-tk, respectively) was used, thus allowing investigation into the roles of T1 and T2 cells in ongoing GVHD reactions. To assess treatment rather than prevention of GVHD, GCV was started at peak disease. Remarkably, treatment at this late time point rescued mice from the clinical effects of GVHD caused by T cells expressing either transgene. Thus, both T1 and T2 cells play an important role in clinical GVHD in a minor histocompatibility antigen-mismatched setting. In addition, because clinical disease was reversible even at its maximum, these observations provide controlled evidence that this strategy of treating ongoing GVHD could be effective clinically.

Suicide gene therapy of graft-versus-host disease: immune reconstitution with transplanted mature T cells

After allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT), mature transplanted T cells play a major role in restoration of the immune system. However, they can also induce a life-threatening complication: graft-versus-host disease (GVHD). Suicide gene therapy of GVHD aims to selectively eliminate alloreactive T cells mediating GVHD while sparing nonalloreactive T cells that should contribute to immune reconstitution. It was demonstrated previously that treatment with ganciclovir (GCV) can control GVHD in mice by killing donor T cells engineered to express the thymidine kinase (TK) suicide gene. TK allows phosphorylation of nontoxic GCV into triphosphate GCV, which is selectively toxic for dividing cells. Thus, in the TK-GCV system, the specificity of cell killing depends on the cycling status of TK T cells rather than allogeneic recognition. This is a potential drawback because in recipients of lymphopenic allogeneic HSCT, alloreactive and homeostatic signals drive the proliferation of donor T cells. It is shown here that the onset of alloreactive T-cell division occurs earlier than that of nonalloreactive T cells, thus establishing a time frame for GCV administration. A 7-day GCV treatment initiated at the time of HSCT allowed efficient prevention of GVHD, while sparing a pool of nondividing donor TK T cells. These cells later expanded and contributed to the replenishment of the recipient immune system with a diversified T-cell receptor repertoire. These results provide a rationale for designing the therapeutic scheme when using TK-GCV suicide gene therapy in allogeneic HSCT.

Genetic risks of antiviral nucleoside analogues--a survey

The available informations on the genotoxic effects in experimental systems of the antiherpesvirus nucleosides aciclovir, penciclovir, ganciclovir, brivudine and cidofovir as well as of the antiretrovirals zidovudine (AZT), lamivudine, zalcitabine (ddC), didanosine and stavudine are reviewed. Furthermore, data on carcinogenic activity of these drugs in laboratory rodents are compiled. Most nucleoside analogue antivirals induce chromosomal aberrations but are inactive in gene mutation assays. Carcinogenicity findings in mice and rats are variable but clearly positive for AZT and ddC. The possible mechanisms by which these agents may cause damage in the genetic information are still largely hypothetical, and experimental findings do not permit relevant extrapolations to the situation in man. There is no conclusive evidence that any of the drugs caused tumours in humans. The use of nucleoside analogues in antiviral therapy remains a pragmatic option that seems justified by risk/benefit assessment.

Retrovector encoding a green fluorescent protein-herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase fusion protein serves as a versatile suicide/reporter for cell and gene therapy applications

Expression vectors encoding herpes simplex virus thymidine kinase (HSVTK) have been extensively used in cell and gene therapy applications either as anticancer "suicide" or as "self-destruct" transgenes in adoptive immunotherapy applications. In both gene therapy applications, reliable detection of HSVTK transgene expression is required in genetically engineered cells. Direct fluorescent labeling of the HSVTK protein may be the remedy. We designed a retrovector encoding a chimeric GFP-HSVTK fusion protein that can serve as a bifunctional suicide and reporter transgene. The fusion gene was incorporated in a VSV G-pseudotyped retrovector (vGFPTKfus) and high-titer stable retroviral producer was generated ( approximately 3 x 10(6) retroparticles/ml). Tumor cell lines transduced at an MOI of 8 for 3 days led to >90% gene transfer efficiency. Southern blot analysis confirmed that unrearranged proviral genomes integrated in chromosomal DNA. Protein extract immunoblot with HSVTK antisera revealed the presence of a 70-kDa protein consistent with the predicted size of an HSVTK-GFP fusion protein. Fluorescence microscopy and FACS analysis revealed that GFPTKfus-mediated fluorescence was nuclear localized and was 30-fold greater than that observed in a bicistronic HSVTK-GFP vector. Growth of cell lines expressing vGFPTKfus was significantly suppressed in the presence of ganciclovir. The DA3 mouse mammary carcinoma cell line was transduced with vGFPTKfus and implanted in syngeneic BALB/c mice. Preestablished tumors completely regressed in seven of nine mice treated with ganciclovir. Normal human peripheral blood T lymphocytes were transduced with vGFPTKfus and nucleus-restricted green fluorescence was observed. Sorting of green fluorescent lymphocytes allowed for selection of engineered cells. In conclusion, we demonstrate the utility of vGFPTKfus as a suicide/reporter transgene in tumor cells in vitro and in vivo. Furthermore, its potential use as an analytical and therapeutic tool targeting human T lymphocytes is shown.

Transient control of a virus-induced immunopathology by genetic immunosuppression

The ability to control T cell reactivity using suicide genes opens new perspectives for the treatment of T cell-mediated diseases. The therapeutic effect is achieved by the selective killing of thymidine kinase gene-modified activated T cells by ganciclovir (GCV). This strategy has been shown to control T cell alloreactivity efficiently after bone marrow or solid organ transplantation. Here, we aimed to determine whether an immunopathological process induced by a viral infection could be controlled by GCV when T cells express a thymidine kinase transgene. When transgenic mice were infected with the lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus, administration of GCV resulted in an efficient, but only transient, control of the immunopathological immune response. Further analysis revealed the existence of a minute population of GCV-insensitive T cells. These cells expand in response to the virus despite the presence of GCV and cause immunopathology before viral elimination is finally obtained. Thus, when confronted with a replicative virus, the efficacy of this genetic immunosuppression strategy is highly dependent on the presence of even small numbers of GCV-insensitive cells. These results emphasize the need for sufficient preclinical investigations with regard to the pathology and the nature of the immune response if suicide gene transfer is envisioned for new therapeutic indications.

Prolonged allograft survival through conditional and specific ablation of alloreactive T cells expressing a suicide gene

BACKGROUND

Control of antidonor activated T cells involved in allograft rejection while preserving immunocompetence is a challenging goal in transplantation. Engineered T cells expressing a viral thymidine kinase (TK) suicide gene metabolize the nontoxic prodrug ganciclovir (GCV) into a metabolite toxic only to dividing cells. We evaluated this suicide gene strategy for inducing transplantation tolerance in mice.

METHODS

Transgenic mice expressing TK in mature T cells were analyzed for (i) specific T-cell depletion under GCV treatment upon various stimulations; (ii) outcome of allogeneic nonvascularized skin or heart allografts under a short 14-day GCV treatment initiated at the time of transplantation; and (iii) the capacities of T cells from such allotransplanted mice to proliferate in mixed lymphocyte reactions and to induce graft-versus-host disease in irradiated recipients with the genetic background of the donor allograft.

RESULTS

Upon in vitro or in vivo GCV treatment, only activated dividing TK T cells but not B cells were efficiently depleted. Acute rejection of allogeneic grafts was prevented and a significant prolongation of graft survival was obtained, although associated with signs of chronic rejection. Prolonged skin graft survival correlated with decreased in vitro and in vivo T-cell reactivities against donor alloantigens, whereas overall immunocompetence was preserved.

CONCLUSIONS

Efficient and specific depletion of alloreactive TK T cells can be achieved by administrating GCV. These results open new perspectives for the control of allogeneic graft rejection using suicide gene therapy.

Immunological defects after suicide gene therapy of experimental graft-versus-host disease

Donor T cells are beneficial for engraftment, immune reconstitution, and antileukemic effects after allogeneic marrow transplantation, but they also cause graft-versus-host disease. Treatment with ganciclovir can control graft-versus-host disease if donor T cells are genetically engineered to express viral thymidine kinase. Clinical protocols with thymidine kinase-expressing T cells currently prescribe the curative use of ganciclovir for genetic immunosuppression only after clinical manifestations of graft-versus-host disease have appeared. The aim of this work was to compare early/preventive versus delayed/curative treatment of GVHD. Here, we found that ganciclovir administered early after experimental marrow transplantation was highly effective in preventing graft-versus-host disease caused by thymidine kinase-expressing T cells, and surviving recipient mice were able to mount a T cell-dependent B cell response. In contrast, curative ganciclovir administration later after transplantation was much less effective in treating graft-versus-host disease and surviving recipients had markedly impaired immune function. These findings should be considered in the development of future clinical trials using thymidine kinase-expressing T cells; to date, such trials have envisaged the use of GCV to treat only declared graft-versus-host disease. The use of thymidine kinase-expressing T cells for conditional elimination of activated T cells after allogeneic marrow transplantation offers a promising new approach for the control of graft-versus-host disease. The versatility of the thymidine kinase/ganciclovir system offers clinical options depending on whether thymidine kinase-expressing T cells are infused at the time of bone marrow transplantation or in a delayed manner, and depending on whether GCV is administered in an early/preventive or delayed/curative manner. The rationale underlying these options is more complex than it may appear and is likely to have a profound impact on the efficacy of such treatments. In the present work, we analyze the immunological impact when GCV is administered in an early/preventive or delayed/curative manner. Our results demonstrate that the delayed/curative strategy is clearly associated with severe immunological defects. To our knowledge, this is the first report of immunodeficiency subsequent to suicide gene therapy for GVHD.