4: Final Report on the Safety Assessment of Toluene

Inhalation exposure to formaldehyde and toluene in the same occupational and consumer setting

Formaldehyde, a natural component of all mammalian cells, is metabolized to carbon dioxide. It is a colorless gas used as a preservative and a reactant in chemical processes in a wide variety of commercial and consumer products. Toluene is an organic solvent also used in a wide variety of commercial and consumer products. There is a growing concern that chemical exposure from consumer products including cosmetics adds to the overall toxic exposure bioburden. This study was designed to quantify the actual amount of formaldehyde and toluene exposure to professional nail technicians and their customers during the application of cosmetic nail products containing either formaldehyde or toluene. Formaldehyde concentrations were measured on workers and consumers using treated silica gel absorption tubes. Formaldehyde concentrations varied between 0.0012 and 0.0038 ppm. The results of this study clearly demonstrate that neither workers nor consumers are at any additional risk from exposure to formaldehyde or toluene in cosmetic nail products beyond daily exposure from commercial products in a work setting and in the home.

Teratogen update: toluene

Extrapolating from animal data, at the level at which well-controlled occupational exposure to toluene vapor is encountered, in utero exposure does not pose a significant fetal risk. However, following chronic and excessive industrial accidents or intentional abuse, toluene exposure several orders of magnitude greater exists, and at these levels in utero exposures in both animals and humans have been shown to produce significant delays in fetal growth. At these greater exposure levels, both dose and gestational timing relationships can be demonstrated in animal models. Of note, in both animals and humans, postnatal persistence of growth deficiency has been observed. A pattern of teratogenicity similar to that of the fetal alcohol syndrome is prevalent in all human studies of excessive in utero exposure to toluene. In humans, the effects of in utero toluene exposure among intentional abusers is confounded by such variables as general health and exposure to other teratogens. Chronic toluene abuse produces a renal tubular acidosis with maternal hypokalemia and profoundly lowered serum pH. Further evaluation of greater numbers of infants with respect to maternal renal tubular acidosis will be needed to fully assess the contribution of chronic acidosis. The contribution of maternal acidosis to fetal teratogenicity remains speculative. Coabuse of additional agents, in particular alcohol, may increase the teratogenic risks. The overlap of features following in utero toluene abuse with those of fetal alcohol syndrome suggests a possible common pathway of craniofacial teratogenesis. Lastly, genetic variations that result in deficiency of ALDH2, an enzyme involved in toluene metabolism, may increase the risks of toluene teratogenicity in at-risk individuals at lower levels of exposure. Prospective studies of toluene-exposed pregnancies would provide more information on the fetal effects at these levels.

Kinetic studies on toluene metabolism in ethanol- and phenobarbital-induced rat liver microsomes in vitro

In vitro metabolism of toluene was investigated at substrate concentrations of 0.03-6.25 mM in liver microsomes from control and ethanol- and phenobarbital (PB)-treated rats. Three metabolites, benzylalcohol (BA), o- and p-cresol, were measured by high-performance liquid chromatograph. BA was the main metabolite of toluene, whereas o- and p-cresol contributed only 1.1-1.5% and 1.7-2.8% of total metabolites, respectively, in microsomes from control rats. Ethanol treatment showed little effect on the percentages of three metabolites, but PB increased the percentages of o- and p-cresol to as high as 5.5% and 8.0%, respectively, following the increase in toluene concentration. There were two different isozymes with different Km involved in the side-chain hydroxylation of toluene in microsomes from control and ethanol-treated rats. One had a low Km value (0.13-0.17 mM) and could be greatly induced with ethanol treatment. The other was a high Km isozyme (0.60-0.87 mM). PB-induced isozyme showed a similar Km value to that of the high Km isozyme existing in microsomes from control and ethanol-treated rats. Two isozymes were involved in the formation of p-cresol in microsomes of control rats: the low-Km type had a similar value (0.15 mM) to the low isozyme of BA formation, but the high Km isozyme had a larger value (2.04 mM) than the high isozyme of BA. Only one enzyme responsible for o-cresol formation was detected in microsomes of control rats, and had a similar Km (2.11 mM) to that of the high Km isozyme of p-cresol.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)