Women and men's satisfaction with care related to induced abortion

Women's decision-making related to induced abortion - a cross sectional study during a period of Covid-19 pandemic, in Sweden

OBJECTIVES

To investigate women's decision-making on induced abortion.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A multi-centre cross-sectional survey among 623 abortion-seeking women in Sweden (2021). The perceived difficulty to decide on abortion was measured using a 7-point Likert scale, and analysed with univariate and multivariate analysis (odds ratios [OR], 95% confidence intervals [CI]).

RESULTS

About half (n = 322;52%) scored 1-4, suggesting the decision was perceived as easier compared to those (n = 292;48%) who scored 5-7. Reasons for the abortion were: poor economy (n = 166;27%), too early in the relationship (n = 154;25.1%), want to work first (n = 147;23.9%), want to study first (n = 132;21.5%), uncertain about the relationship (104;16.9%), and too young (n = 104;16.9%). Predictors for perceiving the decision as difficult: partner's hesitance (OR = 3.18, CI:1.76-5.73), being born outside the Nordic countries (OR = 2.23, CI:1.28-3.87), having discussed the decision with someone (OR = 2.42, CI:1.67-3.50), age ≥30 (OR = 2.22, CI:1.03-4.76), the Covid-19 pandemic (OR = 2.08, CI:1.20-3.59), and the desire to have children in the future (OR = 1.96, CI:1.18-3.28). After confirmed pregnancy, poor mental well-being was more common among those who scored 5-7 (n = 140;47.9%) compared to those who scored 1-4 (n = 122;37.9), p = .029.

CONCLUSION

Women's decision-making on abortion is complex; in times of crises, the decision procedure may be even more difficult. This valuable knowledge could be used to improve and promote satisfactory counselling beyond medical routines.

What constitutes a good healthcare experience for unintended pregnancy? A qualitative study among young people in California

Little is known about young people's experiences accessing healthcare for unintended pregnancy in the USA. To address this gap, we conducted in-depth interviews with 25 young people in California who had experienced at least one unintended pregnancy at or before 25 years of age. Participants were asked about their interactions with healthcare providers during the pregnancy, their thoughts on the determinants of their perceived quality of care, and the ways in which their healthcare experience could have been improved. Thematic analysis was used to organise information within and across interview transcripts. Two important determinants of participants' satisfaction with their healthcare experience were identified during analysis: (1) receiving comprehensive information about their pregnancy options and what to expect from each, and (2) having an empathetic, non-judgemental provider. Regarding abortion, participants described an unmet need for accurate information and frequent stigmatising experiences with dismissive and judgemental care providers. These findings highlight the importance of providing comprehensive, non-judgemental pregnancy options counselling to all pregnant people, regardless of age and desired pregnancy outcome; and reinforce the need for providers to consider ways in which their own bias may influence the quality of care they provide.

Men and sexual and reproductive healthcare in the Nordic countries: a scoping review

CONTEXT

Men generally seek healthcare less often than women and, other than traditional gender norms, less is known about the explanation. The aim was to identify knowledge gaps and factors influencing men regarding sexual and reproductive healthcare (SRHC) in the Nordic countries.

METHODS

We searched PubMed and SveMed+ for peer-reviewed articles published between January 2010 and May 2020. The analyses identified factors influencing men's experiences of and access to SRHC.

RESULTS

The majority of the 68 articles included focused on pregnancy, birth, infertility and sexually transmitted infections including HIV. During pregnancy and childbirth, men were treated as accompanying partners rather than individuals with their own needs. The knowledge and attitudes of healthcare providers were crucial for their ability to provide SRHC and for the experiences of men. Organisational obstacles, such as women-centred SRHC and no assigned healthcare profession for men's sexual and reproductive health issues, hindered men's access to SRHC. Lastly, the literature rarely discussed the impact of health policies on men's access to SRHC.

CONCLUSIONS

The literature lacked the perspectives of specific groups of men such as migrants, men who have sex with men and transmen, as well as the experiences of men in SRHC related to sexual function, contraceptive use and gender-based violence. These knowledge gaps, taken together with the lack of a clear entry point for men into SRHC, indicate the necessity of an improved health and medical education of healthcare providers, as well as of health system interventions.

[If you were to have another abortion, would you choose the same method? A study on 1032 patients' level of satisfaction]

INTRODUCTION

In 2016, the French National College of Gynaecologists and Obstetricians revised the recommandations on abortion care. Abortions can now be medical, regardless of the term, depending on the patients' preference. The aim was to assess the influence of the term and method on patients' satisfaction, in Haute-Normandie.

METHOD

This is a prospective multicentric study. A questionnaire was completed by patients the day of the hospitalization. The main efficacy parameter was the patient's satisfaction depending on term and method.

RESULTS

A total of 1032 patients were included from November 2018 till August 2019: 733 medical abortions and 259 surgical abortions. For equivalent terms, medical abortion was associated with a lower satisfaction, OR: 1.9, CI 95 % [1.23; 2.99] P=0.004. For equivalent methods, a term higher than 9 weeks of gestation was also associated with a lower satisfaction OR: 1.56, CI 95 %: [1.09; 2.23], P=0.01. The satisfaction rate was up to 4 out of 5, regardless of the term or the method. For equivalent term and method, an imposed method due to the term was associated with a lower satisfaction OR:3.82, CI 95 % [2.15;6.90], P<0.001.

CONCLUSION

Term higher than 9 weeks of gestation, medical abortion and an imposed method are associated with a lower satisfaction.

Women's experiences with information before medication abortion at home, support during the process and follow-up procedures - A qualitative study

OBJECTIVE

To explore women's experiences of having a medication abortion at home in regard to their perceptions of the information provided before the abortion, support throughout the process and follow-up procedures.

STUDY DESIGN

A qualitative study based on interviews with 23 women between October 2019 and January 2020. Systematic text condensation was used for data analysis.

RESULTS

Three themes were identified from the analysis. The first theme covers how the women found the information given before the abortion to be inadequate and how this affected their feelings of safety. In the second theme, the participants described how they experienced lack of acknowledgement from health care professionals, and how this affected their feeling of support. The third theme covers how the women perceived access to health care professionals during the home abortion, and how this affected their feeling of well-being.

CONCLUSIONS

In general, the women stated that the information provided was inadequate, especially in regard to bleeding and pain. The women also found support during and after the abortion to be insufficient and would have preferred more help and information throughout the process. This suggests that health care professionals should improve their procedures for providing information, support and care.

Supporting Women at the Time of Abortion: A Mixed-Methods Study of Male Partner Experiences and Perspectives

CONTEXT

Although men are commonly viewed as unaware, uninvolved and even obstructive regarding their partner's abortion access, those who accompany women to an abortion appointment may be more supportive. A better understanding of men's motivations could inform clinic policies regarding their involvement.

METHODS

In 2015-2016, data were collected from male partners of women seeking an abortion at two clinics in a large Midwestern city. Twenty-nine interviews were conducted to explore how men wanted to be involved in the abortion and why they accompanied their partners. Thematic content analysis was used to examine these data, and emergent themes informed a survey, completed by 210 men, that focused on perceptions about and reasons for accompaniment. Descriptive statistics were calculated for the survey data.

RESULTS

Four in 10 interviewees were aged 25-34, as were half of survey respondents. Overall, most had at least some college education and were in long-term or committed relationships. Interviewees described providing primarily instrumental (e.g., transportation and financial) and emotional (e.g., companionship and reassurance) support during the abortion process. While 57% of survey respondents would not have chosen to terminate the pregnancy if the decision had been their own, all wanted to support their partners. Notably, 70% viewed the appointment as an opportunity to receive contraceptive counseling.

CONCLUSIONS

Positive narratives regarding men's support for the abortion decisions of their partners provide a counterpoint to commonly held negative narratives. Future research should explore how supportive men who accompany partners at the time of an abortion may improve women's abortion experiences.

Male Partners' Involvement in Abortion Care: A Mixed-Methods Systematic Review

CONTEXT

Although some women may desire the involvement of their partners when obtaining abortion care, male partners are not routinely included in the abortion process. A review of the literature on how male involvement relates to women's abortion experiences may help guide facilities that are considering incorporating male partners in abortion care.

METHODS

PubMed, PsycINFO (Ovid), the Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature, the Latin American and Caribbean Health Sciences Literature database, and the Cochrane Library were systematically searched without restrictions through September 23, 2015, to identify qualitative and quantitative primary studies investigating male partner accompaniment during the abortion process in noncoercive situations. Analysis focused on identifying different types of male involvement and their associations with women's abortion experiences.

RESULTS

Some 1,316 unique articles were reviewed; 15 were analyzed. These studies were conducted in six countries and published between 1985 and 2012, primarily with observational designs. Four types of male partner involvement emerged: presence in the medical facility, participation in preabortion counseling, presence in the room during the surgical abortion procedure or while the woman is experiencing the effects of abortifacient medications, and participation in postabortion care. Studies explored relationships between type of involvement and women's access to abortion care and their emotional and physical well-being. Most findings suggested that male involvement was positively associated with women's well-being and their assessment of the experience; no negative associations were found.

CONCLUSION

In noncoercive circumstances, women who include their male partners in the abortion process may find this involvement beneficial.

[Survey of 319 women satisfaction using abortion in centers of Pays de la Loire in France]

CONTEXT

Perinatal network the "Security birth" Pays de la Loire (RSN), in collaboration with the regional network "Sexual health" (RRSS) organized a satisfaction survey in 2014 among women who had an induced abortion in the centers in Pays de la Loire. The objective of the study is to evaluate the satisfaction of women who resort to abortion centers, study the factors and propose actions for improvement.

METHODS

A questionnaire, developed with professionals, was offered to women after the end of the abortion act. The scales of satisfaction were based on Likert scales to 4 degrees. They were collected for the period of contact centers, for the abortion itself, and overall. Data were collected on the civil status, the care pathway to get to the abortion center, features centers and professionals met, acts anesthesia and end of abortion, wait times and overall satisfaction of women. The women with rather poor satisfaction were compared with other women by univariate analysis with odds ratios (OR) and multivariate with adjusted odds ratios (ORa).

RESULTS

Of the 18 centers, 13 participated and 319 responses were analyzed. The abortions were performed on average 8±SA 2. Among the methods, 40.1 % were drug, and 59.9 % with anesthesia (14.0 % with general anesthesia [AG] and 45.9 % under local anesthesia [AL]). The first contacts on average to 5.7 SA were mostly general practitioners (38 %), then the abortion centers directly (22 %), and planning centers (16 %). The information was considered clear (94 %), the appropriate orientation (97 %), with respect to the application (98 %). The first meeting at the center was done 7 days after the call (6.7 SA), and met women overall. The abortion was performed 16 days after the first call center (8.0 SA) with satisfaction by field 78 % (waiting time) to 98 % (confidentiality, privacy…). The overall satisfaction rate was 89.0 % and 8.2 % were not satisfied. Factors related to the non-satisfaction in multivariate analysis were the least easy access to the center (ORa=0.31 [.11 to 0.86; p=0.02]), pain perceived≥4 (ORa=3 50 [1.32 to 9.28], p=0.02), the lack of explanation (ORa=0.23 [0.05 to 0.97]; p=0.04), and the accompanying inability (ORa=0.27 [0.10 to 0.70], p=0.007). Finally, 12.6 % of women reported for improvement with clear remarks.

DISCUSSION

This is the first regional survey on the satisfaction of women resorting to abortion. Delays from the first contact are satisfactory and show no organizational problem. The various dimensions of satisfaction showed a high satisfaction rate in the 13 participating centers. The least satisfactory factors are related to organizational problems (waiting circuits especially trips to the operating room and maternity) and problems related to the care itself (not enough explanations, reduced ability to reassure and support Savory absence, lack of choice of the method of anesthesia, pain experienced). Five areas for improvement have been proposed to the care-givers of the centers.

Support program for women suffering grief after termination of pregnancy: A pilot study

In this study, we preliminarily examined the effects of the Informational and Emotional Support Program for Women after Pregnancy Termination in 30 Thai women. A literature review and House's theory of social support informed the program content, which consisted of the following elements: (i) an evaluation of grief; (ii) an analysis of the problems and needs of each woman; (iii) informational and emotional support tailored to individual problems and needs; (iv) telephone support; and (v) an exit phone interview. The Grief Questionnaire for Women after Pregnancy Termination was used to measure changes in the grief levels of participants. The data were analyzed using descriptive statistics and the contingency coefficient. At the completion of the study, the participants' average grief score had decreased from the prior grief score and was in the moderate to low range. These preliminary findings indicate that the support program can be effective in real-life situations in Thailand to assist women who are grieving after the termination of pregnancy. Our findings highlight the need for nursing and emotional support to be provided to help Thai women after the TOP.

How women perceive abortion care: A study focusing on healthy women and those with mental and posttraumatic stress

Objectives To identify perceived deficiencies in the quality of abortion care among healthy women and those with mental stress. Methods This multi-centre cohort study included six obstetrics and gynaecology departments in Sweden. Posttraumatic stress (PTSD/PTSS) was assessed using the Screen Questionnaire-Posttraumatic Stress Disorder; anxiety and depressive symptoms, using the Hospital Anxiety Depression Scale; and abortion quality perceptions, using a modified version of the Quality from the Patient's Perspective questionnaire. Pain during medical abortion was assessed in a subsample using a visual analogue scale. Results Overall, 16% of the participants assessed the abortion care as being deficient, and 22% experienced intense pain during medical abortion. Women with PTSD/PTSS more often perceived the abortion care as deficient overall and differed from healthy women in reports of deficiencies in support, respectful treatment, opportunities for privacy and rest, and availability of support from a significant person during the procedure. There was a marginally significant difference between PTSD/PTSS and the comparison group for insufficient pain alleviation. Conclusions Women with PTSD/PTSS perceived abortion care to be deficient more often than did healthy women. These women do require extra support, relatively simple efforts to provide adequate pain alleviation, support and privacy during abortion may improve abortion care.