Intra-operative haemodynamic findings and their prognostic significance in femoropopliteal reversed saphenous vein graft bypass operations

Longitudinal impedance is independent of outflow resistance

BACKGROUND

Many investigators have measured outflow resistance (R) following peripheral bypass procedures, but correlations with graft patency have been weak. This is because the primary determinants of graft patency are the size and quality of the conduit, not its outflow bed. Efforts at separating conduit resistance from outflow resistance have been unsuccessful. Recently, the concept of longitudinal impedance ( integral Z(L)) has been suggested as a measure of conduit resistance independent of outflow resistance. The purpose of this in vitro experiment was to test the hypothesis that integral Z(L) is independent of R within physiologically relevant ranges.

METHODS

Rigid polyethylene tubing of known internal diameter and length (4.3 mm, 375 cm) was perfused with a glycerin/saline mixture mimicking the viscosity of blood (4.1 cp), utilizing a variable pulsatile pump and Windkessel, with outflow into multiply branched tubes of decreasing diameter simulating the hemodynamic conditions of arterial bypass. Flow and pressure were measured using ultrasonic transit time and catheter transduction, respectively, and waveforms digitized at 200 Hz. Flow was varied while maintaining "systemic" pressure and resistance. After Fourier transformation, integral Z(L) was calculated as deltaP/Q at each harmonic and integrated over 4 Hz.

RESULTS

integral Z(L) calculations were remarkably reproducible within the same day with a coefficient of variation (CV) = 4.0% (at 100 dyne. s/cm(5); n = 4) or over 4 successive days (CV = 4.3%). Furthermore, integral Z(L) was largely independent of R over the physiologic range tested, with integral Z(L) remaining relatively constant as R was increased sixfold.

CONCLUSION

integral Z(L) is a consistent and reproducible measure of conduit resistance independent of R over a wide physiologic range. It may be useful for measuring the adequacy of bypass graft conduits.

The hemodynamics of vein grafts: measurement and meaning

The long-term patency of infrainguinal vein grafts appears to depend primarily on the size and quality of the venous conduit. Therefore, those quantities which directly relate to the conduit's ability to act as a transporter of blood, namely internal diameter and longitudinal impedance (Z(L)), have predictive value for patency. Autologous grafts of good quality frequently remain patent even with compromised outflow. Therefore, those quantities that are outflow dependent, including deltaP, flow, velocity, shear stress, and resistance, carry less predictive value for long-term performance.

A new method of intraoperative hydraulic impedance measurement provides valuable prognostic information about infrainguinal graft patency

PURPOSE

Prognostic information about graft outcome, obtained by using a new method for intraoperative measurement of vascular impedance, was evaluated.

METHODS

Hydraulic impedance was measured in 136 infrainguinal bypass grafts that were entered into a multicenter trial. Seventy femoropopliteal and 66 femorocrural polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) grafts were used. The arterial impedance measurement involved a silicon bypass graft temporarily inserted between the proximal and distal anastomoses sites. A flowmeter probe and a pressure transducer were incorporated into the tube. The digitally stored waveforms were subjected to a fast Fourier transformation and both input (Z(x)) and characteristic (Z(0)) impedances, as well as phase relations, were computed and related to graft outcome after 3 years.

RESULTS

Significant prognostic information for both popliteal and crural grafts was provided by means of the phase angle of the first harmonic. Primary and secondary patency rates for popliteal bypasses were 45% +/- 1% and 65% +/- 2% for phase angles greater than -40 degrees (n = 57) and 37% +/- 1% and 40% +/- 1% for phase angles less than -40 degrees (n = 13, p(prim ) = not significant, p(sec) < 0.01). For crural grafts, the secondary patency rates were 49% +/- 1% and 61% +/- 2% for phase angles greater than -40 degrees (n = 53) and 15% +/- 1% and 0% for phase angles less than -40 degrees (n = 13, P <.01). All crural bypass grafts with phase angles less than -40 degrees occluded within 16 months. Steady flow resistance, as well as Z(x) and Z(0), failed to indicate a significant relation to graft prognosis.

CONCLUSION

This method provides reliable prognostic information regarding graft patency and opens hydraulic impedance measurement to clinical surgery. The phase lag between flow and pressure curves, as expressed by the phase angle of the first harmonic, provides significant prognostic information.

Validation of a new and specific intraoperative measurement of vein graft resistance

PURPOSE

Clinical studies have revealed that the most important predictor of successful bypass grafting is the origin and quality of the bypass conduit. Attempts at intraoperative evaluation of the hemodynamic properties of the conduit, including assessment of blood flow (Q), pressure gradients (delta P), and resistance (R), have not been useful. This is because each of these parameters measures the characteristics of the graft plus the outflow bed. To date, no specific measurement of the resistive properties of the conduit only is available. The purpose of this investigation was to evaluate longitudinal impedance (ZL) as a measure of conduit-specific resistance and to evaluate its potential in predicting the outcome of infrainguinal vascular reconstructions.

METHODS

ZL was measured during surgery in 73 infrainguinal autologous vein reconstructions performed in 68 patients in two separate institutions over a 21-month period. Vein graft ultrasonic transit time Q and delta P (from proximal to distal anastomosis) were measured at baseline and after maximal peripheral vasodilatation with an intraarterial injection of papaverine 30 mg. Waveforms were recorded for 10 seconds at 200 Hz using a digital acquisition system. R was calculated as proximal mean pressure divided by mean blood flow (Q). After Fourier transformation, ZL was calculated as delta P/Q at each harmonic and total ZL (integral of ZL) was defined as the integral of moduli from 0 to 4 Hz.

RESULTS

All hemodynamic variables were significantly affected by papaverine vasodilatation (delta P, 3.9 +/- 0.5 vs 6.3 +/- 0.8 mm Hg; Q, 78.2 +/- 7.0 vs 126 +/- 11 ml/min; R, 134 +/- 17 vs 72.7 +/- 6.2 x 10(3) dyne.sec.cm-5; p < 0.0001), except integral of ZL, which remained constant (31.1 +/- 2.8 vs 30.8 +/- 2.8 x 10(3) dyne.cm-5; p = NS). After follow-up of 1 week to 17 months (median, 5 months), the 1-year primary, primary-assisted, and secondary patency rates were 72% +/- 7%, 77% +/- 6%, and 81% +/- 6%, respectively. Using Cox analysis, primary patency was significantly associated with decreased integral of ZL (p = 0.0001), but not with baseline or papaverine-stimulated delta P, Q, delta P/Q, or R integral of ZL > 47 x 10(3) dyne.cm-5 predicted primary failure with 90% positive and negative predictive value.

CONCLUSIONS

Intraoperative measurement of integral of ZL in infrainguinal vein grafts is independent of outflow conditions (that is, does not change with papaverine), and hence describes the resistive properties of the conduit only. In addition, these preliminary data suggest that integral of ZL is predictive of short-term primary patency. integral of ZL is the first available hemodynamic measurement that is conduit-specific and may therefore be a better predictor of graft patency than currently available methods.

Measurement of vascular input impedance in infrainguinal vein grafts

The purpose of this investigation was to measure vascular input impedance in infrainguinal vein grafts and assess the importance of clinical and hemodynamic parameters in predicting graft patency. Fifty-seven patients undergoing infrainguinal vein bypass grafting for limb salvage (n = 40) or claudication (n = 17) were prospectively studied. At the time of revascularization, simultaneously acquired intraluminal pressure and blood flow waveforms were digitized at 200 Hz and subjected to Fourier transformation in near real-time. Input impedance was calculated at baseline (immediately after unclamping) and after stimulation with either papaverine or completion arteriography. Resistance (Rin) was calculated as mean pressure divided by mean blood flow (Q). Characteristic impedance (Z0) was calculated as the mean of harmonics 3-10. Intraoperative data acquisition required approximately 5 min, utilized the completion angiography cannula already in place, and was uncomplicated in all patients. Stimulation with either papaverine or arteriography resulted in increased Q (72 +/- 7 to 146 +/- 11 ml/min, p < 0.001), decreased Rin (126 +/- 13 to 52 +/- 4 x 10(3) dyne.s.cm-5, p < 0.001), and slightly decreased Z0 (18 +/- 2 to 15 +/- 1, p = 0.002). After a mean follow-up of 20 months, the 2-year primary patency, secondary patency, limb salvage, and survival rates were 61 +/- 8%, 74 +/- 7%, 76 +/- 6%, and 86 +/- 6%, respectively. Primary patency was not associated with any of the clinical variables studied including age, sex, smoking history, history of previous vascular surgery, hypertension, coronary artery disease, diabetes mellitus, creatinine, indication for revascularization (claudication versus limb salvage), anesthesia (general versus regional), or level of distal anastomosis (popliteal versus infrapopliteal). Furthermore, there was no association between primary patency and baseline Q, baseline Rin, or stimulated Z0. However, using univariate analysis, patency was positively associated with decreased stimulated Rin (p = 0.002), elevated stimulated Q (p = 0.006), and decreased baseline Z0 (p = 0.02). Multiple regression analysis identified stimulated Rin as the only independent predictor of primary patency (p = 0.002). Stimulated Rin > or = 50 x 10(3) dyne.s.cm-5 was 71% sensitive and 65% specific for graft failure. It is concluded that 1) vascular input impedance can be simply and reliably measured in the operating room, and 2) elevated stimulated Rin is an independent predictor of primary patency.

Computer-assisted modeling of blood-flow: theoretical evidence for the existence of optimal flow wave patterns

The purpose of this study was to model blood-flow waveforms in order to examine the relationship between various waveform shapes and input impedance spectra. Twenty distinct single cardiac cycle flow waveforms having the same mean flow and heart rate were created based on clinical and published observations. The "best" waveform was one with a steep flow upstroke, a high peak flow value, swift deceleration following peak flow, and flow reversal during diastole. Each flow waveform was paired with 20 computer-generated pressure waveforms to calculate input impedance spectra by discrete Fourier transformation. "Favorable" flow waveforms were associated consistently with a lower characteristic impedance (average of 4th-10th harmonics, Zav) irrespective of the shape or magnitude of the input pressure wave. Zav corresponds to the degree of compliance of the vascular bed and could be expected to be lower under favorable outflow conditions and in non-diseased vessels. In conclusion, this study provides theoretical evidence for the existence of optimal flow wave patterns and supports the notion of flow waveform assessment for diagnostic purposes.

Serial noninvasive studies do not herald postoperative failure of femoropopliteal or femorotibial bypass grafts

We performed a 5-year retrospective case-control study of 232 patients undergoing femoropopliteal (n = 188) or femorotibial (n = 44) bypass to determine if serial noninvasive studies herald postoperative graft failure. We correlated serial ankle/arm pressure indices (API) with graft patency. An interval drop in API of greater than or equal to 0.20 was considered hemodynamically significant, but interventional therapy was carried out only for clinically symptomatic graft failure and an API less than 0.20 above the preoperative value. The cumulative 5-year limb salvage rate was 82% and the patient survival was 63%. A significant drop in API did not correlate with cumulative 5-year graft patency. The 5-year cumulative primary graft patency rates were 60% and 62% in patients with stable and interval drops in API, respectively (Z = 0.15, p = N.S.) These results suggest that a significant drop in postoperative API does not predict patients with impending femoropopliteal or femorotibial graft failure. We believe that routine noninvasive surveillance and prophylactic intervention on detected asymptomatic lesions in leg bypass grafts may not be justified.

Operative assessment of femorodistal bypass grafts using a new Doppler flowmeter

Operative measurements using a newly developed Doppler flowmeter were made on 47 in situ femorodistal bypass grafts performed for critical ischaemia. Graft blood flow, peripheral resistance and impedance were measured before and after the injection of 15 mg papaverine down the graft. The proportion of retrograde blood flow at the distal anastomosis was also measured. The success of a graft at 1 month was defined by patency on duplex ultrasound scanning, a rise in the Doppler ankle pressures and an improvement in the clinical state of the limb. By these criteria the 1-month primary success rate was 35 out of 47 (74 per cent). Graft blood flow was of little value in predicting graft outcome but, combined with segmental pressures, accurately located six of eight technical problems which were successfully corrected. After papaverine, the peripheral resistance of all the successful grafts fell below one peripheral resistance unit (PRU). No single measurement was able to completely distinguish between success and failure, although discriminant analysis of all measurements was able to predict success with a sensitivity of 100 per cent and specificity of 97 per cent. A simpler combination of a peripheral resistance after papaverine less than 1 PRU and a retrograde blood flow less than 33 per cent predicted success, with a sensitivity of 97 per cent and specificity 83 per cent. These criteria have been validated on a further 26 grafts, achieving a sensitivity of 88 per cent and a specificity of 75 per cent. Simple operative measurements, using a newly developed Doppler flowmeter, enable the detection of technical problems and the accurate prediction of the early outcome of femorodistal grafting.